Dexter Vs. Jigsaw: Who is the "Better" Killer? | Horror Villain Fright Fights

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

If you enjoy this video is GREATLY appreciate if you were able to "do the usual KZbin things" But most of all PLEASE SURE THIS! I doubt it'll happen but let's get this thing viral! 🤞

[@danfors1333]

Yes Jigsaw has low bar when he chooses people for death traps. He would probably put your head in the reverse bear trap just for generally yelling too loud in your videos and disturbing his auto-generated playlist of ASMR content.

[@Wesley8Bit]

Dexter would eventually fall victim to Jigsaw because even if Dexter caught and killed Jigsaw it wouldn’t matter because Jigsaw would have a plan in place if he were to die, he always does.

[@MrSecyrb13]

What about Dexter being trained in various martial arts and having certain perception to danger vs a normie that loves jigsaw

[@losgann]

Different iterations of characters would also be fun to compare, such as Anthony Hopkins' Hannibal vs Mads Mikkelsen's Hannibal or a Jigsaw apprentice battle royale. I reckon Dexter would survive a trap and end up as a Jigsaw apprentice/disciple if these characters shared a city and then go off the rails again after John's death.

[@accidentalmadness1708]

Hoffman easily wins

[@losgann]

I think technically Gordon won the previous round but maybe we'll see if Hoffman can overcome his epic bad luck and make a comeback in the future.

[@accidentalmadness1708]

@@losgann I think Gordon only won because Hoffman didn’t know he was a secret apprentice (assuming I remember correctly). If they both know about the other being a threat then the borderline terminator like Hoffman might be able to pull off a win either with a trap or his hands.

[@TheUnapologeticGeek]

How did I not see this video coming? You were born for this, mate!

[@felight5700]

I think if they were hunting each other, Jigsaw would win, considering he's a freaking demigod. Plus he has all his lackeys, Dexter is by himself.

[@MrSecyrb13]

More like cult leader

[@7.62-ATA]

Didn't dexter take on gangs and sicarios?

[@AluminumDestroyer1941]

He’s not a fucking Demi god retard, nobody is a Demi god

[@valdish9620]

Who would win? A murderer vs cancer patient

[@RenegadeSpider2]

idk about that last one, I'd say during season 2 the whole maimi was talking about the BHB. the public feared first then respected him. and wanted him to keep doing what he does. he was very known in season 2. just not him personally

[@LaughnCry27]

Love both these characters and their franchises' This is awesome!

[@greengamerguy623]

My money would be on Dexter any day Dexter is a beast he took down a spec ops officer James Doakes with ease.

[@mgalla213]

Didn’t Lila kill Doakes?

[@RenegadeSpider2]

@@mgalla213 yes, but Dexter subdued doakes. while he got shot in the leg mind you.

[@travisjones640]

What trap would he set for Jigsaw? Maybe make him tell Debra the truth earlier or he rats him out or helps a potential victim kill him?

[@TenebraeXVII]

Down the line from this video's production, Saw X shows that Jigsaw absolutely could afford the treatment (which was actually a scam but he didn't know at the time) he was trying to get coverage for out of pocket, but it wasn't about the money, it was about his belief that he was entitled to coverage for an unapproved medical procedure that in hindsight was super ineligible for an insurance payout because medical insurance does not pay for fraudulent treatments.

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

What did I say about that in the video? (I don't remember it's been a couple years lol)

[@TenebraeXVII]

@@LetsCrashThisParade I believe it was a question of if Jigsaw's resources could pay for traps if he apparently couldn't pay for treatment. I'd recommend looking at KittenArcader's recent "Foot the Bill" series which is almost caught up to Saw X and estimates roughly what Team Jigsaw would have to be paying out of pocket to fund John's shenanigans (and covers some other movies as well like Now You See Me, Scream, Home Alone, and The Collector. John has had a long and very successful career as a celebrated and recognized architect and civil engineer and has invested in a fair bit of property and other assets so he definitely did have the money on hand, it was just the principle of the thing (he paid his premiums, therefore be believed that he was entitled to coverage for whatever when even now unapproved experimental treatments are not often covered because of the associated risk.) In context, Saw X kind of makes Easton denying coverage for that experimental (scam) treatment probably the most responsible decision he ever made in an official capacity.

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

@TenebraeXVII love Foot the Bill haha, great reference!

[@travisjones640]

I don’t wanna know whose better, I wanna see them go after each other in a crossover

[@mc98smusicmoviereviews93]

Dexter isn’t really a “horror show” per se, but I’ve always wanted to see him match against John Kramer.

[@younghan3573]

Jigsaw is more effective! He kills after his own death!!!

[@MrRepoman197]

I think this would be a very interesting fight. I don't know if Dexter would be intrigued or stunned by Jigsaws methods. If they were deserving victims like if they killed someone I think Dexter would be fascinated. I can picture Jigsaw saying to Dexter "KILLING IS DISTASTEFUL". I wonder if Dexter would become another one of Jigsaws apprentices.

[@darthmeticulous6901]

13:27 That’s funny, cause’ the other thing I’ve heard people say is he looks like a Sith Lord.

[@younghan3573]

Wow! Forgot about Nick Cage movie "Next"

[@alltopicsreviewer7674]

If Jigsaw 🧩 captures Dex to play his madness game and finds out his the BHB and is addicted to collecting🩸blood!Jigsaw will force Dexter to Drink a litres of criminals blood🩸which Dexter would need to saw 🪚off a victims body part in the game in 2 mins!!! just to unlock a countdown mechanism death trap strapped to Dexters body!! But if Dexter is hunting jigsaw 🧩and knows everything about him!nah!! My Bet is Jigsaw 🧩 in a matter of seconds be on Dexters ritual kill table!Saw🪚🆙 and sent bottom of the ocean 🌊!!

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

Hahaha great theories I enjoyed that. I reckon in the open world Dexter definitely takes the advantage but yeah on Jigsaws turf in one of his... Kill buildings for like of a better term lol I think I'm betting on Jigsaw...? But I'm not a hundred percent sure haha

[@alltopicsreviewer7674]

@@LetsCrashThisParade True! depending on Which comfort zone they meet up to challenge! Can you also do a DEXTER VS. MICK TAYLOR challenge!!!Please!!😃😃😃

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

@@alltopicsreviewer7674 hahaha ooooh what a good idea, I'll keep old Wolf Creek Boi in mind for something for sure

[@alltopicsreviewer7674]

@@LetsCrashThisParade Also maybe DEXTER VS. ELITE HUNTING CLUB from HOSTEL the rich psychotics!! Dam I would like to see Dexter terminate every single one of those torture Monsters!!!

[@andrewkelly1337]

Jigsaw might not be able to get out of Dexters kill room but Hoffman or Amanda or Dr. Gordon could theoretically rescue him

[@chadgrewal4829]

Can you please do Hannibal Lecter Vs John Kramer??

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

I'll definitely consider it mate! I reckon thisll be the first of a series

[@IMOReviews]

The more thought I applied to this argument, the more difficult the answer became 🤔😂 it’s actually a very good matchup! Both love doing their research on their victims, and both have a complicated morality towards killing 🤔 it’s like, who would be able to trick who better? 🤷‍♂️😂 great video bud 🙌 (edit) yes, championship boxing matches go for 12 rounds 🥊😂

[@detonationpyrotechnics4156]

Dexter is by far a more effective killer. It's not even close

[@RykerJones28]

The one that kinda irritates me more than is probably rational is the dude who faked being a Jigsaw victim. Hes total trash but his wife? She definately did not deserve it. She didn't know he was a fraud and just did what any supportive wife would do.

[@LetsCrashThisParade]

Check out my video "Saw Characters that Deserved Better" if you're interested because I cover it there lol

[@AngryEyess]

A tie!!! How could they Tiieee!!! Clearly the winner is the one who should've won and I bet there fanbase on that

[@eueu4854]

Dexter from the movies is less brutal. In the books he uses vivisection and probably more.

[@detestor420]

Such an odd comparison

[@krazikofiman]

If they came face to face with no prior knowledge of who he is, who would deduct from the initial meeting that the other is a killer? If once convinced the other has to die, who would set up the more effective trap? If they became good friends would they band together and protect each other? If as good friends would that be enough to prevent killing each other? Glad it's all fiction!

[@MrSecyrb13]

Wouldn't dexter figure out about jigsaw due to investigation and watch him or his peons

[@lpnp9477]

It's spelled "penis"

[@greengamerguy623]

all of the warehouses are abandoned its America and its shitty rundown cities and industrial areas, I don't think he owns any of them that wouldn't be realistic and would get him caught as soon as the police look at who owns all of these places.

[@BeckywiseTheDancingClown]

Quality content 👏👏👏👏 Jigsaw is definitely more intelligent than Dexter. He's proficient in game theory. He can anticipate how somebody will respond or act in his games

[@kooltactic8269]

Jigsaw and it’s not even close.

[@ZenYogi55]

Chewch…commit