【點直播】 馬凱碩教授與香港青年學生對話 | 4月26日 | Prof.Kishore Mahbubani

傑出外交家、新加坡國立大學亞洲研究院傑出院士馬凱碩教授（Prof.Kishore Mahbubani）今日（26日）上午於耀中國際學校舉行演講會，與學生進行交流。
#馬凱碩 #演講會 #耀中國際學校
#點新聞 #dotdotnews
=======
點新聞網 ： www.dotdotnews.com
訂閱點新聞社交媒體平台
Facebook: bit.ly/3JOsF6s
Instagram: / dotdotnews
Weibo：weibo.com/7310744124
Bilibili：space.bilibili.com/501305963
歡迎下載 「點新聞」app
iPhone App ： apple.co/2MxsmE1
Android App ： bit.ly/36EmZtD

[@daning9764]

Thanks so much Kishore, for talking to students in Hong Kong, much needed and much appreciated!!

[@userngot]

It's encouraging to see Hong Kong students hearing words of wisdom.

[@GlobalDrifter1000]

From a CCP stooge.

[@joegoh1968]

All Taiwanese people needs to listen to Prof Kishore.

[@chengy.c3631]

希望香港學生聽到真實世界的情況，醒醒吧！

[@hanshaofa3758]

This speech should be a mandatory study material for high schools in HK.

[@JL-vl1po]

只是小部份香港學生參加, 希望這條片可以被廣泛推傳到全香港學生年青人,暸解現在世界形勢真實狀況，學習大局角度世界觀

[@chenghung507]

Housing issue was just one factor of 2019 street riot. Foreign interface was also one of the main causes. But I am glad that professor has addressed the social unrest as a riot. Thank you

[@eddyg4742]

Poor living quality for the vast majority, huge rich poor gap, lack of fair and reasonable opportunities, problems like these result in "weak immunity" if the society was to be described as a human body. With that condition, it allows the opponent(s) to spread "virus" easily. The infection then takes hold and spreads quickly across the society. Why the social problems ? I'd argue a major part of it is a result of the legacy issues / "land mines" left behind by the Brits. I'm glad the situation is now on a better track. Not yet on the right track because there are deep rooted issues that are difficult to fix, with too many beneficiaries of the old systems and establishments that have to be sorted. However, I have confidence in the wisdom and capabilities of CPC and the Hong Kong people. Many capable people and many patriotic people who work hard for the people and society. Wishing Hong Kong all the best. Have faith in the youths of Hong Kong.

[@leesnow-yh1mq]

@@eddyg4742 u r right. smart guy.

[@user-un3bd9pk7u]

Professor has been extremely careful about his words, not to excite his listeners. Couldn’t agree more foreign interference was the main cause of the riots. 👍👍

[@Hermit-Crab]

Hong Kong got screwed by the tycoons. The Chinese government thought that they could trust the tycoons and if they gave the tycoons all the freedom they needed, they would work for the best interests of Hong Kong. But no, that was not the case. The tycoons abused the trust and used the freedom to enrich themselves at the expense of the long term interest of the Hong Kong people. Who cares about whether the average young Hong Konger could afford to buy a property if the tycoons' wealth could increase by the billions?

[@douglaszhang7648]

Professor Kishore, I always respect you. I never miss any of your speeches. I learn from you.

[@autumnfar3114]

Professor Kishore, thank you very much for your interesting and informative speech.

[@wwow3953]

Very powerful speech every I heard before thank so much professor Mahbubani !!!🇫🇷👍👍

[@dorachan1332]

希望香港學生聽到真實世界的情況。

[@SKY-lu6xl]

没用的，已经被洗脑了是回不了头的，他们除了还有张中国人的脸，价值观和认知模式全部是西方的，他们已经不是精神文化层面的中华民族了。

[@koyiktang6494]

有点难

[@khpek1688]

P

[@user-lz1sn8mz3r]

难

[@oentoengjahja712]

Very humble, truly enlightening lectures, the speaker is calm but always answers directly to the core of the problem. I am always ready to listen to him for hours, time flies by unnoticed.

[@cosmoray9750]

" The Joint Communiqué of the United States of America and the People's Republic of China, also known as the Shanghai Communiqué, " The American is trying to renege on the Communiqué. Hence the selling of weapon and constant so called naval exercise in the Taiwan Strait.

[@echeng5271]

It's worth listening to Professor Mahbubani for his invaluable insights on geopolitical issues.

[@GlobalDrifter1000]

He is a CCP STOOGE.

[@user-lf1cv1wd5w]

台灣政府不敢邀請的人😂

[@chenyang9336]

不符合台湾价值

[@jesselivermore8298]

台灣政府是站在美國那邊的，並甘願充當美國用來絆倒中國的絆腳石

[@ct9245]

Even the N war started , its still limits in the northern hemisphere. Hence Australia , South America, are safer

[@leahlee8291]

因為民主自由可以自由拒絕反對聲音

[@newstar346]

因為忠言逆耳

[@sweelim5473]

As mentioned during the opening of his speech, Kishore pointed out the existence of structural issue where US would block China in all fronts from surpassing its leading position, yet he then said the current unimproved situation between US and China was due to air balloon incidence. Kishore has missed the fundamental point of US will never be sincere to collaborate with China in global governance but only interested in maintaining its hegemony position to rule the world by sabotaging China progression. Another well know fact that omitted by Kishore was the exploitation by the CIA to flame the Hong Kong unrest which came to an end after CIA had withdrawn its thousands of agents from HK (as indicated by the selling of large number of HK residential buildings owned by the US government) when the HK national security act was put in place which would allow the HK police to arrest these agents under the new act. Without the CIA funding the rioters, the riots had stopped.

[@donatwu3128]

You are right, Swee. The balloon incident was just a convenient but childish excuse for US to hide its shame for not having Blinken accepted for visiting China by Beijing. US will find some other excuse for its action had the balloon incident not happened anyway. I watched this video 4 hours after you did. I have hence given my view on it as well. You might not have read it because of the time lapse. Not sure if you have any comment on it or not.

[@sweelim5473]

@mytimezone Zone I am sure Kishore knows many more than he has presented. But he could avoid contradicting himself or creating a wrong impression to mislead.

[@sweelim5473]

@@donatwu3128 I shall look out for your comments - so far not yet shown on my screen☹️

[@sweelim5473]

@mytimezone Zone I am very sure that Kishore knows much more than he had presented. The issue is he could avoid contradicting himself on my point #1 and not to mislead the audience by omitting the critical CIA plot on the HK riot.

[@cinpeace353]

Being a diplomat, he have to a bit reserve to maximize his capability to reach a wider audience. If you watched some close to the West channels, not that many interview him anymore, including CNA which is a channel of his own country.

[@leahlee8291]

This video should be shown in all hk universities and high schools.

[@JIMMY-nz1ld]

All those rioters in Hong Kong need to wake up and working with their government to archive better future.

[@easternhouse]

Welcome to Hong Kong 🙏🏼👍🏼

[@kko-punch7059]

I wish I were there to tell Mr Mabubahni how much I appreciate him to speak for the world, not just for the Chinese n China. He really is an ambassador for peace ✌️!

[@user-un3bd9pk7u]

Prof Mahbubani has been very restrained & exceptionally subtle, when giving an analysis of the problems that HK faced in 2019 & of the geopolitics today. The reality is existential, challenging & much more worrying than the gentle words he delivered.

[@charsiuking4327]

What “cancellation”? Blinker did not “cancel” his trip. He was never invited. The balloon incident was a face-saving exercise

[@Hermit-Crab]

When Lee Kuan Yew passed away in 2015, numerous Chinese TV stations broadcast special programmes featuring him. I remembered one particular programme which featured a retired minister from the Chinese government. He talked about the influence that Lee Kuan Yew had on China and he cited a very specific example to prove his point. He said that Lee Kuan Yew once told the Chinese government that they must allow for private home ownership. The Chinese government asked why. Lee Kuan Yew said to them, "What kind of people would go to the streets to protest and to riot? Those who own their own homes or those who don't?" Immediately the Chinese government officials grasped the point and they proceeded to promote private home ownership.

[@margaretliu3409]

Ambassador, you are my favourite!!! ✌️✌️✌️👍👏👏👏💪💪💪😍😍😍💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝💝

[@yaohuihe]

可否配上中文字幕。讓更多人懂得這教授的智慧講話。谢谢！

[@wpgc2]

1:06:29 "we are on same boat but we continue to pretend that we are on different boats". Hope we will succeed in next 20 years to change that. Thanks Prof Mahbubani, YCIS and the two student MCs, good job! 👏

[@sheldon9527]

中美关系今年变得更糟不是因为气球，因为在川普时期中美之间一直有气球互相飘来飘去，而拜登政府这次选择了公开并借题发挥，为了掩盖他国内外问题糟糕的治理，借此向中国施压来帮助美国解决迫在眉睫的经济问题。如果有必要，美国可以找无数个理由施压中国。他们非常擅长凭空创造筹码。

[@Hermit-Crab]

兔子不是白色的吗？怎么变成了红色的？

[@chankwaikeung4447]

可否配上中文字幕。讓更多人懂得這教授的智慧講話。

[@user-ew9yu5gq7h]

❤有cc字幕(英語), 開啟字幕再開啟自動翻譯成中文字幕,簡體或繁體

[@JL-vl1po]

" To promote peace and understanding of the world" I like this statement

[@leolee5435]

Thanks!

[@caryyuen3100]

Prof. Thank you for your words of wisdom

[@Hello-sb6qe]

Sir, your speech has always been diplomatic, humble and at times very blunt to unwise or aggressive question

[@cestmoi4252]

I've always enjoyed every lecture and speech by Pro. Kishore Mahbubani. I'll definitely share this video with my kid. Greetings fm Taiwan.

[@SWandG]

Should have provided a glass for the guest, details are essential.

[@keehin]

Kishore's ability to seamlessly plug his books every 10 minutes is mind-boggling

[@tiewkiat]

He has spoken on this for so many times, and you guys still doesn't get it. So he just writes the book so that he doesn't have to say it over and over and over again. Even an elderly gentleman like him is sick of repeating these simple facts.

[@user-yw5wf6kz5t]

It was absolutely fine because speech on stage is limited by time, but a book can be read many times and digested properly.

[@xlzuo]

If you read the books, you might wish he mentioned them more often.

[@alexchan6860]

👍👍👍正👍👍👍

[@williamxiong9937]

一句话简明扼要的道出了香港深层次的原因。香港不能是李家的香港，应该是香港人的香港。不能安居，如何乐业。

[@andrewlim7751]

李嘉诚吸了多年的血，吸得香港人多开心，也是一种艺术。😂😂

[@good-morning650]

香港的超级地租，合法的葬送了香港的实体产业，香港的社会被吸血最后资源枯竭，李功不可没，对大陆也是一个警惕！

[@weipeng4425]

回归20多年， 不能安居还是李嘉诚的问题？ 还是李家超问题？

[@good-morning650]

@@weipeng4425 土地资源在谁手里？金融市场谁说了算？法律体系在谁的掌控下为谁服务？港币的自主权是谁放弃的？舆论在为谁服务？

[@good-morning650]

@@weipeng4425 主权没有收回来，任何问题形同虚设

[@rickli9258]

香港学生要了解世界，不要洋人说中国不好就觉得中国不好，也不要洋人说中国好就又觉得中国好，你们会晕掉的。要独立思考，中国有什么问题，香港有什么问题。有什么是好的，什么是要改进的。

[@ruifenghuang1029]

印度人也是洋人

[@atlus7498]

@@ruifenghuang1029 中国从来不称呼亚洲国家的人为洋人，洋人都是泛指漂洋过海来的欧美人。马凯硕是印度裔的新加坡人，不是印度人，他还是亚洲至上主义者。

[@ruifenghuang1029]

@@atlus7498 好吧，我的意思是不要亚洲人说中国好就觉得中国好，不要亚洲人说中国不好就觉得中国不好

[@hughzhen5754]

So critical thinking!

[@user-fy3rk9gi8k]

幸好有翻译，希望港人多看看，不要对大陆存在偏见。

[@user-gu4pk2tf5m]

打開YT翻譯就有字幕了

[@mengchittan23]

9:29

[@mmojave]

HK is too proud to learn from Singapore. Many HK politicians together with TVB went to Singapore before to "study" Singapore's public housing experience, but in the end nothing was done. While HK claimed to have the lowest corruption in the world, many HK politicians are in the pockets of HK property developers. To solve its housing problem, HK govt must take bold steps to reform and exercise eminent domain for public housing to work.

[@gcschoo]

We are happy to share our humble experiences

[@yanyang6050]

Cheer HK 🎊

[@kylelingjiang3252]

in short, democracy doesn't equals to good governance, example : US , India. And autocracies doesn't mean bad goverannce, example, China , SGP (not typical autocrascies but a little bit i think). In face, i think US's democracy humilated "democracy".

[@user-pc5ov7fv2v]

我同意你說的。中國社會主義確實帶來了人民生活品質上升。民主制度可以防止一黨獨大，從而危害人民。但美國的“民主”確實侮辱了民主這個詞

[@donhuang9855]

The USA actively promotes Democracy to the global community, but behaves Autocratically towards the International Community.

[@Truth433]

Great to see Hong Kong building their own Political elites

[@wfjn8138]

A balloon triggers fear and anger among the American people. Do the American people know how many military planes and warships come to China from afar every year, and how many cyber attacks there are? According to the level and standards of fear and anger among the American people, the Chinese people should have become "nationalists" for a long time. Originally, most Chinese people held goodwill or even favoritism towards the United States and the West, but in recent years, the actions of Western politicians have made the Chinese people realize that only goodwill and a smiling face are not enough to ensure their own safety! the precious stone lands its innocent possessor in jail!

[@lunarmaremare3990]

I would say that the whole world people is encouraging to have a new perception upon the changing of the phenomenon that China has changed and what role China, this is not only Hong Kong peoples have to adapt to change their perception with China. Alternatively, World Peoples are concerning. Mutual understanding through times of participation's rather than refusing to fix the fatal and conflicts.

[@nanhinting7447]

Many students forgot to ask one very fundamental question and that is as a student, was Prof a student activist in his University days. So from a student activist to a diplomat, that must be a 360° turn in his life.

[@ganboonmeng5370]

That is Lee Kuan Yew strength...he is able to get...good student activists..to work..for the country... with the argument,.." it is not about me or my party...if you want to work for your country..if you love your country...I give u the chance to proof yourself...People like Tommy koh...represented Singapore in the foreign service..and Singapore foreign service...in those..days..were recognised..as excellent...

[@leahlee8291]

360 degrees means coming back to the original spot. So no conflict.

[@usagi1603]

Any chinese subs for the chinese audiance to watch?

[@user-qf1em8wu9h]

可以看，翻译字幕设置成中文就可以了

[@usagi1603]

Thankyou for your tips

[@westw9915]

Captions 可以选择中文

[@wpgc2]

Echo the Thucydides Trap by professor Graham Allison 11 years ago. Hopefully whatever will happen in next 20 years, China is smart enough to avoid military conflict.

[@itpiao]

He's really cute when he put the Jacket on.😂😊

[@computer-ot8si]

Kishore Mahbubani 他最近都避免提中國, 說印度多很多啊

[@zoeliu1350]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@kshen7485]

希望香港学生能够真正理解马凯硕对2019年香港游行根源的客观和真实的分析，认真反省。

[@janepang99]

" The olderest rule of geopolitic - i.e. always double standard! "Lol.🤭@1:12:14😁💪

[@jameswu5380]

沒錯！ 國際地緣政治的競合與鬥爭中，含有大量人性的惡質成分。不適合佔多數的一般人。

[@outman1923]

就没有人想去把灯光调暗一点？如果我在现场，我也许会去做

[@cheekienau-young466]

And here come smart Chinese's governance at poverty alleviation is the key to bring the whole nation into unbeatable as well unrefusable prosperity! Bravo China!

[@kwokkeungpoon9971]

+ 中文字幕, 唔該🙏🙏

[@tonyhy5698]

装个视频字幕插件就可以

[@kwokkeungpoon9971]

@@tonyhy5698 多謝🙏🙏

[@jamieatelier]

🇸🇬

[@yikhungwong2453]

.馬凱碩教授真是一個非凡學者，對國際形声势看得清楚。👍👍👍佩服。

[@user-gl2wu2fs8h]

De-dollarisation weakens the US military hegemony because the power of US currency sustains its ability to ruthlessly use it to undermine the sovereignty of countries and organisations which are not subservient to the US' geopolitical goals. Given the US' warmongering mentality and deeds, de-dollarisation is good for Humanity. It facilitates promotion of peace, harmony, prosperity and happiness. This makes our Earth a better home for all.

[@steveking7932]

要求中文字幕

[@AnAverageChinese]

想让香港年轻人听到真实的世界情况很不容易。现场还是大陆学生提问的多，估计现场没几个香港的学生吧？

[@user-wu4xv4si5n]

沒有中文版嗎

[@westw9915]

Captions 可以选择中文字幕翻译

[@haoming]

大陆太需要这样的学者了.

[@weipeng4425]

金灿荣张维为陈平不香吗？

[@neoisnew]

Well said from 马凯硕。

[@LonganLee]

Does he say what's aligned with singapore or he speaks freely purely his personal views without fear or favor?😅

[@georwoogle]

[@kinyung112]

I agree the importance of good governance but I don't agree the riot was due to 50% of people in HK do not own a property. The people who departed in the last 2-3 years most owned a property. It is something else and it is not materialistic

[@leo7957]

香港的新闻媒体，社交平台全部掌握在美西方手里。你觉得天天听美西方讲故事，意识形态能不出问题？不要认为大多数人都能了解这个世界。

[@joezhou5542]

Because those departed hongkongese didn’t want to face the reality that Hong Kong belongs to all 1.4 billion Chinese people, not just 7 million hongkongese people.

[@andrewlim7751]

The actual FACT, he'll try not to say it in open, CIA organized colour revolution, their finger prints are all-over the place, he is well connected to know the details.

[@user-nq2sw6sg8q]

Are these Hong Kong students or international school students? They have an foreign English accent.

[@wpgc2]

just finished the entire clip, well worth the time. I googled YCIS and it's an international school.

[@user-nq2sw6sg8q]

@@wpgc2 It is better to speak to students that comes from families that are from the grassroot of Hong Kong society. Most of the international students comes from rich families. For eg, Kishore talked about the fundamental problem of the Hk riot is due to the anger of a lack of good housing policy by the govt. These students from audience don't feel the hurt as housing concern is not a problem as their parents could afford to live in big houses.

[@sang-suangam9772]

@@user-nq2sw6sg8q maybe if YCIS is grooming leaders for HK next generations ... these kids might be the ones, who might learn and work for a better future for HK, China, and World ... unfortunately, kids from grassroots, have other concerns, around basic sustenances, that they can't care about higher issues ... when good governance is in place, the grassroots will need worry lesser, about sustenances, and be able to maximise their potentials ... that was how singapore was able to groom later generations of grassroot kids... who became leaders ... i was also on the nutrition program, as a kid ... while i'm not a leader, i am contributing to my country ... in ways that i can ...

[@sang-suangam9772]

oh ... 中华傲诀， 很好的handle ^_^ 华英雄的 ^_^ ？

[@kshen7485]

Except 5 “C”, if you want to be a good leader, you have to have another “C”, a Chance or an opportunity, in which you can easily get there without any effort once you well prepared, as the sayings: “Times make heroes” and “All opportunities only GIC to those well prepared”. 除了马凯硕说的五个“C”外，要想成为优秀领导人还需要有成功的机会或机遇，在这种机遇下只要人们有充分的准备会不费吹灰之力即可获得。所以世上才有：”机会只眷顾那些准备好的人”以及“时势造英雄”……等等之说。

[@victorkmlee]

While I agree very much with Kishore's interpretation of events in the contest between China and the US, I think he is too generous with the US's intention. The US is very clear about its objective, total dominance and hegemony in all areas often at the expense of others. No country can be allowed to be a peer competitor. No country, foe or ally is allowed to progress or even be seen to catch up with the US. There is no room for 'win-win', compromise, mutually beneficial arrangement but a winner takes all mentality. America first, other countries lose. So it is not surprising America will use any tools at its disposal (fair or underhanded) to undermine other countries. Lately, the tactics have become more underhanded and provocative in tandem with China's unrelenting rise because she is becoming more desperate. China intitially hoped for a 'win win' situation but without sacrificing her own interest of progressing and doing well for her citizens. But this approach has failed. Unfortunately, forceful action or response seems to be only viable alternative. In order for other countries (global south) to rise, China must lead the way (even though these same countries will not agree with China on other issues) pierce and dismantle these barriers set in place by the US, West and their allies / vassals.

[@dunzhen]

Bunch of quality young people. And untarnished by mental colonization like so many in Asia.

[@joanliu9336]

一个人演讲的时候话筒为什么不摆到一起，话筒摆放方向本来是为两个人准备的。

[@ritawinson1101]

燈光照著老先生快受不了

[@arnoldtse6548]

As always, he is excellent in what he says. Yet, a rather careful speech, perhaps because he is speaking in HK. As an example, China exemplifies in domestic governance. At least, one that worths mentioning when Professor emphasizes so much of improving the life of bottom 10% of the population. Instead, he switches to the example of Singapore. That is cunning, perhaps for good reasons. He gives good analysis but in the world of power struggles, we need more than analysis and reasonings.

[@echeng5271]

That is your view, not professor's view. How do you know what is in his mind?

[@MMLL369]

Perhaps you'd consider watching all of his other speeches, quite relentless on governments.

[@arnoldtse6548]

@@MMLL369 I watch many of his speeches, many quite relentless. That is why I say this one sounds a bit restrained. He is more a scholar than politician and for that reason, he acts with bravery when attacking the West. I have a great respect for him, and this speech does not distract me from that conclusion. It only shows diplomatic he was when speaking in HK. Btw, I live here.

[@andrewlim7751]

He knew very well HK is for top 1% by the 1% of the 1%. 😂😂

[@fannyalbi9040]

he has always been cautious about the words he is using. he is from “fine” country singapore, he knows the “fine” words. same in his books

[@legpol]

Why Professor Mahbubani used American national language? Why his country Singapore chose the American nation language as its national language? Or, why all the world is speaking the American national language?

[@TaoDeLiFa]

Mistake 1, Singapore's national language is Malay not English Mistake 2, Singapore's working language is British English, not American English. Please also note that every ethnic Chinese in Singapore study Simplified Chinese on top of British English.

[@legpol]

@@TaoDeLiFa : But the British language is called English, and was made internationally popular by America. Every countries was benefitted by using the same English and calling it English. Was Singapore greatly benefitted by learning the English? Was all the world benefitted by using the English language?

[@ct9245]

@@legpol because after WW2 , the winner states pushes English as common language (普通话）for the world and technologies . All major regional / world meetings using English as their common language : APEC , RECP, TPCPP, ASEAN +10, QUAD, UN, etc

[@legpol]

@@ct9245 : Then you meant that if the winners did not push, the world would not have used the American English. The world might have used the Chinese 普通話. But at that time, China did not push her Pu Tong Hua. Instead, China invited the Russia language into China. This invitation clearly meant there was no push. It was all voluntary. China apparently could have stayed with the Russian language for good. Why China did not?

[@aaga721]

@@legpol ?????

[@stevechang9189]

新加坡太小了

[@kkleung3872]

Professor Kishore , having heard so many words from various platform on the rival between US and China, I want to know what would India play the role in the coming ten years on such confrontation between these two super power. Hope we can have your views about that.

[@dkj6946]

Search on KZbin, he did explained this on other topics

[@user-nc9pm4gg7j]

那个气球并不是真正的原因

[@taozhang3135]

一个睿智的学者

[@bangthingneng9433]

There are so many dialogue such this all over the world from time to times. Uncountable i shall say. . There are also lots of wonderful relevant amazing good questions been asked during the QA session. However, the world is getting worst as far as humanity is concerned. Be it geopolitical, global governance & good governance. What is actually went wrong ?.

[@ruifenghuang1029]

In your view "the world is getting worse in...", until Russia Ukraine war, there was no major war for hundred years

[@leahlee8291]

Because the no. One wants to stop the no. Two from catching up.

[@minminshen2477]

六亿农民的收入少于一千块，是不是低层的10%? 有受照顾吗？中国的CEO的收入与这些农民的收入我看是150000倍

[@kysluo3953]

没有受照顾吗？你没看过中国的近代史吗？之前人均收去是什么样的呢？300块都不够行不行！

[@virtutemodestia3477]

Lol another whiner from Taiwan

[@user-ij2dy4dn4m]

大陆的人其实特别羡慕香港的学生，既能来大陆发展，又能出去发展。你们机会真的太多了，而内陆却有太多的限制。

[@xlzuo]

唯一的限制来自于你的自我设限。因为既没有制度性的限制，也没有人为的限制，你既可以去港澳，也可以出国，也可以留在内地发展。

[@user-ij2dy4dn4m]

@@xlzuo 你学历、年龄是怎样的？读的书多吗？阅历是怎样的？你真的天真的认为是自我设限的原因吗？

[@jackjagf3345]

显然是自我受限啊，你有足够的能力获得公费资助甚至自己拉赞助，哪里不能去了，我去过十几个国家了没觉得被限制啥了

[@user-ij2dy4dn4m]

@@jackjagf3345 那你的家庭环境、背景是可以的。

[@phlim4500]

大陆太多限制？我不清楚中国大陆的情况，或许你说的是真的吧。可是即使是这样，新马一带还是很多中国来的工作者，很多都是白领的，金融，法律，物流，工程都有，已经到了本地人也感受竞争的程度了。所以我完全没感受到你说的中国大陆学生出海发展受限的问题。

[@hwangfongmain7326]

Amphisbaena😅

[@fsteh787]

Intelligent pill is the best medicine to cure you after your stupid shot…

[@computer-ot8si]

不用翻譯了, 他一向都是这样說來賺養老金的, 他一向都認為是中国好大, 中国人好勁, 領導人全都好英明 (直到某天突然說他叛国即拉, 哈), 其他国家就算心不喜欢中国, 也要和中国做生意, 所以世界不能沒有中国, 而中国自己又咁勁, 越做越大就成為世界第一, 將來就算中国乱踏人权, 乱拉人, 都奈他不何, 只能接受中国做一哥 又說美国太理想主義, 金權政治, 而中国就实实在在做实事 (其实是口號治国, 哈)

[@andrewlim7751]

他说的是事实。

[@computer-ot8si]

@@andrewlim7751 啊, 你看到我打的字都奇怪啊

[@andrewlim7751]

@@computer-ot8si 是不该看到鬼的。唉！

[@computer-ot8si]

@@andrewlim7751 原來頻道主沒閒理这个留言, 哈

[@andrewlim7751]

@@computer-ot8si 你觉得自己很有趣，很重要，很有道理？😂😂

[@limlim4251]

大家醒呀！海外许多地方很久以前小学生就学习中华简体中文了，没有必要继续将文字复杂化！文字觉醒呀! 让世界及子子孙孙容易学中文, 全面跟上国际大成员的中华文字发展趋势的简体中文. 海外很久以前小学生就学习简体中文了! ！ 不要脱离中华文字发展趋势呀! 全面采用容易学的简体中文，让世界及子子孙孙容易学！ 加油！ 复杂旧体的繁体留给专家。为何还要旧体复杂的繁体呢？ 中华很久以前就有符合时代容易学的简体中文·。简体中文也是这个时代趋势。

[@andyxperia1068]

He disappointed me with this speach... He started to lied and kisses US ass...

[@kens7853]

😂😂😂 are you watching the same speech like the rest of us? 😂😂😂 or your understanding is questionable, prof kishore is never known for kissing america's ass. maybe you should on the sub title. 😂

[@cinpeace353]

It is hard. He wants to be able to reach US audience. Without some kisses, he can't reach out to US audience and work as a bridge between China and US.

[@fsteh787]

Read more, explore more

[@pengkong6350]

也許你誤會了，他没有偏某方，他對現况和過去的對比講述，及A對B和C的双標帶出，講者系要持平，答案是聽者自己領會。

[@espionage84]

Not sure how he is kissing US behind. Sounds very balanced to me

[@andyxperia1068]

This is b.s.

[@ganboonmeng5370]

You are bs😂

[@walterwu164]

Do we want the world order to be dictated by a Marxist ideological CCP or led by a democratic ideological US? That's the question today. Say what you want but what's happening in the battle of the 2 superpowers is a battle of 2 polarising ideology. Dictatorship vs Freedom. Given the ability, I believe a good majority of the native Hong Kong people would prefer to leave Hong Kong/China.

[@食铁兽]

为啥要选择？每个国家都需要根据自身情况调整，中国不是在推销自己的制服。只是向世界其他国家证明，道路千万条，要走适合自己的路。当你说出独裁和民主自由的时候，就已经自己下了错误的定义。谁能说清真正的民主自由是什么，只是根据自身需求定义吧了。

[@ruifenghuang1029]

Congratulations you are parroting whatever US MSM is spewing

[@MMLL369]

Ideologies are merely words, not actual doings furthermore, your Marxist / democratic contexts are not "questions" today, but rather problems todays. None of which you mentioned are actually following through what they say.

[@newstar346]

That's why so many Americans are dying everyday under the "democratic" guns

[@leahlee8291]

When you insist that the world should be dictated by the democratic ideology, even when it is proven to be a failure in good governance, you haven shown a mentality of dictatorship.

[@yixuanlang2695]

Man of wisdom!

[@yongdeng1813]

I dont know why his book is titled 中国的选择 in chinese….i dont think thats the correct title for his book.

[@tee-wooi]

没有中文字幕不能看。

[@peacefulmind6254]

Does anyone ask, why US not willing to cooperate with China to make the world better instead? China is willing to do that… it’s all depends on US.

[@user-ox7te3vk5k]