Did Demi Lovato Really Hit A LIVE WHISTLE NOTE In Wildfire? (THE TRUTH!)

@carefullydeluxe on twitter

[@joelparkinson3562]

we love a hard working lovatic

[@lebomjaja]

I think she can whistle because when she laughs the whistle comes out sometimes, Mariah does too.

[@smartman6432]

Yeppp

[@fariassanez]

Yes, this year at the Super Bowl, whem she laughed, she made 2 Whistles

[@albilamooo]

Finally someone who has great proofs that demi hit a C#7

[@Key_1111]

*hit

[@albilamooo]

@@Key_1111 not me being so dumb and noticing now.

[@musicfan2487]

@@albilamooo 😭😭

[@Lovatix]

They*

[@albilamooo]

@@Lovatix i literally didn’t specify their gender.

[@kadirkaratas8081]

I don't know what I would do without your videos in my life

[@greymasterfreak9331]

Sonunda Türk buldum. Ben de bu kanalı uzun süredir takip ediyorum. Videolar çok yaratıcı ve Demi'nin potansiyelini gösteriyor.

[@walidmahdab8475]

Its feels so sower 😂😂

[@walidmahdab8475]

It'd be sour .. 😂😂😂 Ariana grande sweetener lyrics

[@Nanda-ku2yw]

Inducing vomiting damages the vocal cords and we know she had bulimia for many years. Imagine the notes she could reach if it weren't all the problems she had to face in her life. I want to know if it's possible she could recover from the vocal cord damage if she took some years of rest and vocal care

[@_.sxarlett.olsen._kk5321]

Okay so if she practice's enough Im sure she could recover or If she rests her vocals then mabey But i highly believe with enough practice or Rest i know from personal attempts that When i sang when i was younger i could only hit alto notes now I go tp atleast a Bb5 and im better at belting now that i gave my voice a rest And its louder So i defenatly believe she could recover Its just the fact she has alot of vocal strain from singing and the fact She had bulimia and that stuff bc i almost rarely vomit I think ive only vomited Mabey a total of 5-7 times in my whole life

[@Kristoff2005]

@@_.sxarlett.olsen._kk5321 teach me how to hit a Bb5 since I crack to head voice if I try, it usually cracks in G#5 and higher, my mixed voice is very dry after I sing too much, I use a louder falsetto (head voice) and start to go lower to know if it vibrates through my chest, it's my technique and it works like a female voice since my speaking voice started getting lower to C#2 and Bb3 which makes my vocal range G1 (vocal fry, not really sure about what note it is) C#2-Bb3 (chest) Eb3-G#5 (mixed) F5-B5 (head voice, really undeveloped) A4-Bb6 (falsetto!) No whistles🙂 Ikr it's a long comment but I just think you're better than meee and you could probably help me but it's ok if you don't give me any advice (this is literally the main point why did I type the other crap in this comment to waste your time)

[@mirage6222]

I saw your comment yesterday, I asked my dad who is a doctor, he told me that with taking care of of the throat enough, yes She is fine, i mean her chord notes are ok since years ago

[@josephinian4614]

@@_.sxarlett.olsen._kk5321 she never strain you tired tardears

[@addictedtovocals]

This comment aged well

[@laustboy]

It’s about damn time someone did this. I’ve always heard the whistle and tried to convince others it was indeed a whistle. Thanks Matthew

[@fabianreyes2152]

I heard it clearly. It was off but she did hit the whistle note. Thxs dude.

[@blogistuff4383]

Finally someone made a vid on this. I totally hear this whistle, it's not good but that doesn't mean she didn't hit it. Great vid Matt❤❤

[@XanderCorbettMusic]

blogistuff I heard the whistle foo

[@XanderCorbettMusic]

blogistuff too* I promise I’m NOT calling you a foo 😅😅😂

[@mandlandlozi4338]

U are a true lovatic

[@camdenepperson]

I FIBALLY GOT MY MACBOOK!!! NOW I CAN WATCH YOUR VIDEOS AND MAKE MY OWN!

[@SlayvatoLover]

I'm waiting for yours 😘 (Congrats for your MacBook!)

[@lovinglovato9941]

@@SlayvatoLover I just realized you changed your name

[@SlayvatoLover]

Loving Lovato Haha 💓

[@elmiratchagop3642]

Atleast she attempted.

[@MatiasVocals]

Fantastic video!! But i'm sure that my turner check the note as a C7, even the piano note sounds like a C7 but the most important thing here is that is a FACT that she did attempt the note!!

[@markowsky_01]

I also believe she has whistle note while singing Whitney's cover

[@abraaovasconcelos8544]

which cover?

[@dizzunicorn1329]

Marek Weryk whitney does not have a whistle regiser

[@abraaovasconcelos8544]

dizz unicorn i got it! he's talking about this video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oHSXp3eObaaGsJI she was singing along with the original song and she missed the lyrics, then she made an exclamation and it sounded like a whistle. that it :)

[@markowsky_01]

Ye exactly!

[@johnpalermo2422]

Demi would do ZERO justice to Whitney Houston song! 😂

[@GarageStudio7]

*Am I the only one who doesn't hear anything...* Believe me, I'm trying. Yes, maybe she hit it but please what's the point if it's barely audible... Edit: after the video I heard a faint brief whistle but TBH this is too much struggle. When Demi is *confident* enough to hit an audible whistle note live, she probably will.

[@JustinRodriguez123]

i agree

[@jazieebabiee95]

I hear absolutely. Nothing. Video confuses me

[@manni1148]

Thank you I hear nothing

[@saralovatomusic]

I can't hear it

[@tiarachavis8614]

Thank u demi lovato is not whistle registered I can hit a higher whistle note then that

[@brunohorstmann8078]

I was able to hear the whistle (a.k.a. squeaky sound) from the first time I saw the video of the obvious (SO OBVIOUS) live attempt, and still there are people who argue over the studio version. Like, dude, can people really not hear the difference between a voice and an instrument???? AT ALL?? One thing I do doubt is if she's ever attempting it live again. She rarely goes above the fifth octave, and even for artists that do it often we can't really say it's something easy, so I think she'll just focus on the usual mid and high belts (which btw I'm totally fine with). But anyway, I'm glad someone took the time to actually put together a whole 8 minute video evidence for this, and it was nice to hear the whistle repeatedly!

[@brunohorstmann8078]

@It's the summer of 2004 saaame

[@luxeey7297]

I KNEW IT THAT SHE HIT THAT NOTE!!!!

[@fariassanez]

Listen "proof" please

[@luxeey7297]

@@fariassanez The day it got "released" i heard it... I love it...

[@Lovatix]

@@luxeey7297 ICU

[@Alexmax9295]

I'm really not sure if she hit that flat whistle during that concert but it's simply stupid to think that she didn't do the whistle note in the studio version and to not recognize that she really attempted to do the whistle part in this live performance. Nice video btw :)

[@claudvnr]

This is a really well-made video!!!! I love it 💗 I believe it was her!

[@borathebrat]

A whistle note Doesnt matter because demi can do almost everythink as vocally. And she is perfect😍

[@brighterrocky1776]

Crying because I’m so happy she attempted this note. I honestly had no idea she did!!! Thanks for making my night! Even though it was very very faint I heard it. 😭💕

[@YgorCortes]

Damn I wish she would explore her whistle register more!

[@hutchrivers2912]

So much attitude and sass in this video. I'm here for it! Made me laugh!

[@roli-3642]

First! Also i really love your videos. Lovatic forever ❤️

[@talk6696]

People also need to understand attempting live whistles without training or long term experience is risky. Mariah (The Whistle Queen) took risks in her early days but she also worked on her register since she was a kid.

[@athenalee5524]

Nice explanation! There is also another video that did an EXCELLENT filter focusing on her vocals. You could _clearly_ hear the note.

[@renanrpm]

A lovatic praising Mariah? Congratulations! Rare. Very rare. It’s obvious that there is something there. The doubt about if it’s an instrument or her voice remains not 100% answered, but this video helped it a lot. If was she, great for her :D

[@bartolomemusic]

4:05 she also hit whistle note or it’s overtone? If so she made her way through E7

[@ArianaKaylaTorres]

You are soo good at editing these videos!! I love this channel!! 💕💕💕💕 #lovatic4life

[@Chris-xo1xl]

I love that your videos are the first things that show up when I open KZbin. Great content 💜

[@celstboch734]

Thanks, it's a very good video. We can tell you put lots of work in it. Love from Lovatics 🍒❤

[@squidward97]

YAAAS BETCH SOMEONE MADE A VID ON DIS 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽😀😀😀 what would I do without this channel....

[@Jose-kw5sz]

I didn’t need this video to open my eyes because I’ve always thought Demi attempted that note but you make me even more sure about what was I thinking❤️❤️

[@alex-np6cj]

I think this is the first video of any singer that tried to prove something and actually made sense. I love Demi, but I wouldn't call myself her fan because I listen to some of her songs and I don't want people to get offended by me calling myself a fan. Anyways, I really appreciate your work. Good job.

[@bartolomemusic]

4:28 i hear mariah whistling Eb6/D6 (I didn’t use filter)

[@saronsl8750]

i freaking love this video great job

[@leonardoduarte26]

I was there. It was the best concert vocally in years. And some people in the audience screamed when she tried do hit the whistle note.

[@rttnmlk123]

You can CLEARLY hear a metallic sound when she pulls away.

[@Mikaelson_Royal]

Whistling is a soprano's thing (or so I think). Demi is a soprano so why would she be UNABLE to whistle again?

[@omarash7810]

This is incredibly good. Like proving every point. Amazing job

[@davidemunoz9142]

I really love this video, and your channel, i know that i heard the whistle in other videos but i don't safe, thanks🖤

[@knaxor]

finally! Gosh, now everyone can shut their mouths about it. I really want her to try and give whistle tones more development, it’d be amazing to hear her try some runs like Jessie J has been doing on the side.

[@gayaf13]

*"I recommend you to see a doctor or something like that"* im dead.. i love you dude*

[@despairingleonardo]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hmKtZ6uJib15bZI 2:38 this was another performance of her where the whistle also appeared while she was belting. I believe it's pre-recorded. Back to the controversial video, I agree that she might attempt the note but the audible whistle was hard to distinguished live. kzbin.info/www/bejne/fICZlJJpbt53hKM 0:58 whistle also seemingly appeared while belting

[@phoemelacastro428]

This effort is amazing! 💓

[@blake3322]

You really convinced me!💕😉

[@manuster8146]

I really love your channel!!!

[@fanofthings9249]

I think when Demi pulls away from the microphone, it’s intentional. As we’ve seen, she doesn’t have much stage confidence especially when it comes to her very high and difficult notes. She most likely pulls away from the microphone on difficult and challenging notes, because she’s afraid to mess up and have it be projected loudly in the area.

[@anavieira4720]

This video is great and everybody that is saying she didn’t attempt should watch it Ps.: thanks for following me on Twitter ❤️ I love your videos Ps.: from which country are you?

[@blogistuff4383]

Ana Vieira he's from Brazil(just in case he doesn't answer)😊

[@lovatoslave]

thank you ♥ I'm from brazil, sao paulo more specifically

[@anavieira4720]

blogistuff thx ❤️

[@anavieira4720]

LovatoSlave 'Matthew S.' Well I’m from Portugal just like Gabriel (TEOhosiers)

[@andrejesus4530]

Ana Vieira Portugal aqui!!!

[@altheafalnican2268]

Wow I'm surprised that she can do a whistle WOW!! And I hope someday she can do it live without failing and I know she can do it!!!!😉💪

[@bellasara103]

It IS an instrument. When it comes to checking on a voice whistle versus an instrument whistle, the vibrations being heard are different. An instrument whistle is more smoothed, an ACTULY breathy whistle you can almost hear the breathing of that whistle, not only that but it gets higher as the person tries to hit that note correctly. The whistle we hear I Wild Fire, is an instrument. I am not 100% sure WHICH instrument it is however, I remember this one time over at a friends house she had this piano. It could play different sounds, and I mean it was like one of those 600$ wise ones. On one of those settings it had like a high pitch notes in it, which you could do little like chimes. As it gets higher it actually sounds like a high pitch whistle. Now, I am not sure what they used during the recording studio wise, but with how smooth that whistle is versus and actual whistle voice. It IS an instrument.

[@bellasara103]

Plus not only that, but if we take account on how deep a vocalists vocals are, Demi's are much deeper than what they seem. There are those little rare occasions where a person with that deep of a voice CAN pull off an actual high pitched whistle, but Demi's comes off to low and deep to me in order to pull off something THAT high pitched.

[@amberskyeee7]

C.L. Artsy Dreamer “Demi’s vocals are much lower than they seem” 😂😂😂 That’s where you lose ALL credibility because I’ve heard her LIVE on MULTIPLE occasions and so have MANY critics and her voice IS that light NATURALLY. Soooo MANY think it’s her backup singers or auto-tune and it’s not. Her voice is NOT that deep at all, ESPECIALLY not since her tonsils were removed back in 2014.

[@bellasara103]

@@amberskyeee7 Um... She has a deep vocal range. Yes a singer can HAVE a high pitch wise vocal rage, but after hearing her MYSELF as well, she in fact does have a deep vocal range, which is how she can hit so many low notes like in Confident, La La Land, This Is Me, and exc. It may sound as if she does have a high pitched voice, however she doesn't. Her 100% natural singing range is within a deep vocal range. Now, having deep vocals allows you being able to belt out your voice more, it makes a person hear the light pitch versus the actual voice within the studio.

[@bellasara103]

@@amberskyeee7 Just like with her song Sky Scraper though. She is partly forcing a head voice as well as using her chest voice in order to make it high pitched. Deep vocalists can sometimes have issues on hitting high notes unless you have been doing it more than 30+ years, or even longer. Sometimes they have to force a head voice which isn't the natural voice that is used. That's why we hear also in the song when it's the music video version, or even live, we hear a little struggle within her voice it self. She has to force that pitch out, instead of just naturally use the deep tone within her vocal cords.

[@augustmoments]

@@bellasara103 bruh that was clearly her. give up already

[@greymasterfreak9331]

OMG I love this video you are so creative and smart!

[@ammarnasir4212]

Thank u sm for doin this

[@EricJay98]

How could y’all not think this was her whistling? She literally laughs in whistle register

[@conor3311]

Wow you did REALLY hard work👏👏👍

[@diogoalexandree]

Almost impossible to find lovatics praising Mariah. Great video.

[@gabrielmarqui4458]

Great job in this video!👏👏👏👏

[@lianabankz8187]

Demi and her damn Holy vocals😭💗😍

[@lovinglovato9941]

I hope we get another whistle in D7❤❤

[@Sara-zk8ts]

So in the last video, I came from the Mulan soundtrack. This time, I came from the Winnie the Pooh soundtrack. I really like old Disney soundtracks, huh?

[@viktv7150]

If demi worked hard enough I feel like she could hit a whistle note

Btw I think it started as a flat C#7 and ended as a flat D7, she kinda did a super small glissando

[@MIXANDMTCH]

so then her full live range is C#3 - Bb5 - C6 (D6) - D7!!!!

[@moonfireproduction1521]

This video wow. I have no words, just simply amazing 👏🏻 👑

[@oneiastcabeiio4191]

When you repeatedly play it on a loop it’s a lot harder to hear.

[@RafLurv]

Even the studio version was short and brief meaning it doesnt comes naturally for her to hit that whistle part.

[@Ravenyall]

i can actually hear it very well. But if she can whistle, why doesnt she whistle 'lower' notes live in her concerts or use them more often? or even use her head voice? Bc whistling needs a good control of head voice.

[@lovatoslave]

that's the point, she doesn't have control over her whistles. her only whistle ever was this Eb7 and this C7/C#7 live and that's it. her head voice is improving from the past 6 years to now, let's hope she keeps improving.

[@alanah6858]

This was a good video!! And she killed that whistle note in studio! We love Demi❤️

[@kevkrisss]

OMG THE INTRO SOUNDS SO GOOD HOLY

[@blue8violet]

Ooo an actual informative video well done

[@MatiasVocals]

Btw in the Whitney cover at the soundcheck you can hear a F#6 with a run, do you think is her?

[@lovatoslave]

i think it's an overtone with the own track but could be a whistle since she's in the backstage and not doing anything that serious

[@elusive7244]

I think that we Cant hear the whistle cause she sings it thro her nose and when u do whistles thro the nose than its way weak. Mariah doesnt use her nose while whistling, thats why its more powerful. Ive also used the whistle register thro the nose and than i learned that i need to close the nose so i can hear it better and it did helped

[@roxh3558]

I love this kind of videos!! Great!!!

[@lunalovesnature]

Thank you soo frickin much, i've tried to hear it in videos and i couldn't, but here it's sooo obvious ❤

[@walidmahdab8475]

I do believe that she hit it .. Plz do more Ariana and demi vocal vedeod

[@sefakoru]

Love this video ❤️❤️

[@nialmagdl234]

5:50 I listened to this part quite a few times but I only heard it once. It could also be like that Laurel/Yanny situation. Maybe my ears just don’t pick those high notes up that well. And I’m one of those who maaaainly hears “Laurel.”

[@Faith-bx4ux]

I could actually hear the whistle in the first video you showed and it's impressive!

[@EmmaRobertsStan]

Here after she hit a centered C#7 live yesterday!

[@paloma-alfaro]

I don't want to be "that person" but Demi goes by they/them pronouns

[@EmmaRobertsStan]

@@paloma-alfaro oh ok sorry

[@paloma-alfaro]

@@EmmaRobertsStan it’s cool, it was an accident

[@paloma-alfaro]

@@EmmaRobertsStan but also a C#7???? Holy!!!!

[@charlottehattersley4260]

It dosents matter if she whisltled but she is still an amazing singer I love her and miss her so much she acts like my big sister xxx 😍😘😜

[@cats7414]

tbh I like the idea of her trying these notes for herself. Taking the mic away would give her more privacy and security to go for things. I wish nothing but the best for her :)

[@andresavila02]

Ur so smart, ty for this!!!

[@haroldstiwart2246]

wowww that is so detailed👏👏

[@tahabassem2613]

Wow you're literally my favorite person on earth

[@cf8205]

Thanks for doing a video on my comment!!!

[@qlimax95]

I will say that, and this is no hate. So please don't get mad or come for me. She has a great voice. She really does. But i wish she would work on her Mixed Voice :( it's Chest Dominant. For those of you who doesn't understand what that means. It's basically a lot of Chest Voice and less Head Voice when you're mixing. Which is not the greatest. Other than that. She's a solid singer. But, i hope all the drugs she consumed won't strip her voice away. And hope she will improve her technique :\ sometimes her belts sounds unsupported. (just sometimes) sometimes it's really well supported and great.

[@SlayvatoLover]

Btw good work but she also have a Bb7 live exclamation and she didn't have instruments or IDK so obviously demi has a whistle register, underdeveloped and poorly controlled but who knows. Maybe she'll be able to go in the 6th octave a day with those whistles...

[@yana8224]

This reminds me when she preformed sorry not sorry at billboards this year and her voice gave out then she made the face

[@jamesstewart5859]

Even if she pulled her mic, you can obviously hear his voice, because sound engineer uses audio compressor

[@LillyDoesGamingandVlogs]

Fact: I jut sang Mercy and Stitches by Shawn Mendes my highest notes were C#7 both times.

[@jamespoche2551]

Damn you are savage in this video Matthew

[@taeslvr_]

Your videos are greeeeat!!

[@strawberryjpeg6000]

I think she’s got the whistle, she just needs to keep practicing it with that song

[@olivervue1422]

if u listen closely u can hear her whistle at 3:02 to 3:03

[@tyreewall8144]

At Less Demi Lovato can sing🎙and she’s amazing🤩let me hear you try sing the whistle note humm😉

[@eiryves8554]

Wow, A flat C#7. So her live range is now C#3-Bb5(B5)-C#7(G7 Scream)

[@RainbowDave009]

She was off but even if she hit it, there's a thing called pitch correct too for in studio. So unless you are Mariah, Christina Aguilera and Ariana Grande or Kelly Clarkson or someone who really Can hit those tones with good ability to Hear them, we know Demi can but she rarely does it. Because unlike the other singers mentioned, demi isn't the kind of singer that has the connection to the register. But yes she has a head voice and whistle like everyone else does but some just don't use it like the other girls do. Demi is more of a belty singer than a whistle singer.

[@aydenanthony3011]

So glad they showed that Mariah Carey is the queen of whistle notes 😂

[@adamG2001]

Someone who knows what they’re talking about♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@grandpaeggos9392]

I think it was the background vocals from the song itself you just can barely hear it from all the other loud things going on

[@strawberryjpeg6000]

All I can say is some people’s whistles are different

[@juanbustamante1298]

Oml i love when she used her head voice for stone cold she should practice that it sounds so good OML dkrbekkfvdidhks