»Die Zauberflöte« - René Pape singt »O Isis und Osiris« // Semperoper Dresden

[@elisabethmarkowa3119]

Wunderschön! Der beste Sarastro!!!

[@a.n.i.c.k.a]

The best performance ever. Finally a reasonable, not "" traditional"" tempo. Pape's vibrato is absolutely exquisite. He and Hans Peter König should give lessons all over opera houses. There are only very few singers who are able to control their vibrato - something quite normally required for instrument players. Almost every singer - including any "star" - has one kind of vibrato that just "happens" to them. Without control of how fast, wide or regular it is. Pape is a perfection ❤

[@misscameroon8062]

Just to help you enjoy more beautiful voices listen to Stefan Kocan a Slovak basso in this aria,should blow your mind

[@tomaszsadowski1515]

Thanks. Excellent.

[@Taehan_Kim_1]

Bravissimo

[@dianasmitsmans5997]

Sehr schön von Klang und Tempo nicht langweilig!

[@magdalenesulau8804]

Schöne Stimme, schöner Mann, komische Aktionen auf der Bühne

[@lukasmiller486]

Rene Pape is such a great baritone. So rich and powerful and commanding. I wish he had been the package deal with Renee Fleming for her performances of Thais instead of Thomas Hampson.

[@bradycall1889]

He's a high bass overbrightening

[@vad1m30]

@@bradycall1889he was right. That man sings like baritone. The last sound must have been F but there’s something different instead

[@bradycall1889]

@@vad1m30 I used to agree back in the old days. But I took a closer listen at his voice.

[@mikhailsungurov2472]

His voice is way too light for sarastro. Listen to martti talvela, mihaly szekely, kurt moll singing this aria their voices are much heavier and carry more weight to them.

[@FelixWue]

Suí

[@wrtölp3578]

Das Tempo ist zu schnell, man hört richtig, wie der Dirigent „denkt“, das ist viel zu intellektuell gespielt. Pape beeindruckend wie immer, auch bei ihm hört man, dass man ihm gesagt hat, wie er die Arie zu singen hat. Vor allem an der Stelle „die (Pause) ihr der Wandrer Schritte“, wesentlich schöner und geschmeidiger klingt Mozart mit elegantem Legato, das heißt eine Note fließt in die nächste, kein Schlagersänger würde so singen. Auch das Orchester bindet alles. Da kannst gleich eine Drehorgel spielen lassen, oder einen Dudelsack. Hat es Sarastro eilig? Ich denke nicht. Somit rechtfertigt sich ein angenehmes Adagio, welches kein Andante ist. Das hier ist andante von moto

[@zoltanrhedey1074]

Warum schnell?

[@gustavschade4285]

Keine Ahnung oder was ist los? Wir leben nicht mehr zu Mozarts Zeiten

[@drglaser74]

Finde ich zu schnell

[@apogaeum4313]

Ja, ich kenne es auch ge

[@apogaeum4313]

Ja, ich kenne es auch getragener.

[@gustavschade4285]

ist genau richtig das Tempo, man muss ein Adagio nicht zu ernst nehmen und daraus ein Schlaflied machen.

[@franssales]

No doubt he is a good singer, but he is not a bass profondo, and to sing Sarastro, it takes a low bass. Most of the aria it is too baritonal and the low ending forced, not calm and relaxed as it should be.

[@petroskalligas7186]

Pape ist keinen Bass, er ist einen Bariton. Deswegen ist er fuer diese Rolle nicht geeignet, denn er hat die tiefe Stimme, die fuer diese Rolle noetig ist, nicht. Besonders am Anfang hat er auch nicht genug Luft eingeatmet um die Phrasen aeussern zu koennen. Die Einatmung hat sich spaeter verbessert; es gibt aber viel besseren Sarastros als ihn [z. B. K. Moll, K. Boehme, M. Talvela, F. Crass, L. Lemcke]!

[@bradycall1889]

I don't necessarily agree that he is a baritone. I think he's just a true bass who needs to work on his technique. In this performance, his voice was probably just in a bad mood and that is why his low notes in this video are somewhat constricted and sound similar to fry.

[@petroskalligas7186]

@@bradycall1889 unfortunately, in my opinion, this is the standard of Rene Pappe; not a bad mood.

[@bradycall1889]

@@petroskalligas7186 Really? Yeah I guess sometimes his other performances can also be disappointing sometimes. I like him as a celebrity or as a public personality, but sometimes his singing voice isn't quite where it needs to be yet. Can you show me other examples of him frying his notes?

[@petroskalligas7186]

@@bradycall1889 unfortunately not "yet" he is almost 60. This a good performance of his, but still, he does not convey the confidence the role demands, especially in the beginning with the low notes being simply touched upon: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oYHGn36hf61meLM

[@petroskalligas7186]

There are much better basses in recorded history [Kurt Moll, Ludwig Weber, Laszlo Polgar, Franz Crass, Kurt Boehme].

[@mauriciofelipetejoarriagad3732]

Baritone!

[@tims.6286]

Thats never a Bariton, he graduated as Bass.

[@bradycall1889]

@@tims.6286 But he does overbrighten sometimes and othertimes overdarkens and doesn't have the best technique. I like his bass speaking voice a lot more than his singing voice.