Dimash Autumn Strong & Koji Tamaki - Ikanaide original ( REACTION )

[@yokoyokotyan]

前者は歌の上手さで聴衆を魅了しようとしてて後者は感情を迸らせる手段として歌唱技術を使ってる 前者は歌うまいな〜、と感心はするけど心に直接訴えかけてくるのは圧倒的に後者だな

[@zuhrah1867]

Бог захотел через Димаша открыть для многих Кодзи только через исполнение Димашем этой песни я захотела найти оригинал так и познакомилась с прекрасным исполнением Томаки Кодзи

[@СанатТокушев-б4с]

я сам казах , но версию Кодзи Тамаки раньше услышал чем версию Димаша , так как я слушаю много японской музыки , не надо приплетать сюда Бога , как по мне Кодзи Тамаки на много лучше поет эту песню большей эмоций вызывает , а Димаш берет эту песню техникой и не более

[@和わ]

Dimashさん この歌を そんな元気モリモリに😅💧

[@熊忠-n1x]

マシマシのモリモリ。そもそも日本人の感性にはこういうのは合わない。どんなに技術的に素晴らしくとも。

[@toshi09147]

メタルとかやればいいのにね

[@c8259]

私は貴方のコメントリアクションを観てとても共感できてうれしいです💗 玉置浩二の歌、作る曲、詩、すべてが最高です。ありがとう🥳

[@chenesere]

Dimash is a very good craft man whereas Koji is THE artist. They belong to different categories.

[@kazz789k9]

Dimash is good, but Koji is in another level with so much emotion! You cannot stop crying listening to him singing.

[@aran-uq8ik]

Koji is nothing compared to the one and only Dimash

[@kazz789k9]

@@aran-uq8ik He is technically great, but sorry I do not feel anything when he is singing, like listening to a robot or a computer singing.

[@adrianboutsias2437]

@@aran-uq8ik have you ever listened to Koji properly before? Especially when he was younger? You're comparing a guy in his 20s to a 60 year old man in this clip!

[@aran-uq8ik]

@@adrianboutsias2437 Yes I have, many times. And all of him is great. But Dimash is Dimash and he is on another level.

[@kazz789k9]

@@aran-uq8ik Go have a look at other reactions comparing the two. They always cry when Koji sings, not Dimash. That is the fact.

[@lagerhop9184]

One is for show-- other is REAL!

[@ongenmania4004]

Dimashの歌が色を重ねていく油彩画ならば、玉置浩二の歌はまるで水墨画。 Dimashの歌には、心から感心し、玉置浩二の歌には、心の底から感動する。

[@mario-cr5ch]

上手い表現に感心します👏👏👏

[@c8259]

すばらしいですね。同感です👍

[@Mr-er6ui]

Dimashさんのオペラ歌手を彷彿とさせる歌の上手さに感動しましました。素晴らしい！ でも…心に響いたのは後者の玉置さんでした。不覚にも泣きそうになってしまいました。

[@mikigoti4042]

Dimash is amazing singer.voice❤.but Koji sing very emotional.so deep.😪

[@vincentwee632]

The original singer is and will always be the best. Tamaki Koji is one of a kind. He is widely regarded as the greatest singer songwriter in Japan and East Asia.

[@aran-uq8ik]

Dimash is widely regarded as the best singer in the world.

[@vincentwee632]

@@aran-uq8ik totally not true. He is too new to be considered that. And he is not talented enough to be a world class songwriter. At least not now. He has a wide vocal range. Many singers out there in the world also have that wider vocal range like him. Period.

[@aran-uq8ik]

@@vincentwee632 Ok now you are getting funny. 1. Give me one singer who has a vocal range like him 2. What makes him unique is much more than only his vocal range. His different ways to sing, different genres, his emotions, and many other things.

[@adrianboutsias2437]

@@aran-uq8ik he might be technically excellent, but you can't shake off the feeling that he's doing it all for show. Koji has never given that off in his entire career spanning almost 50 years - plus you really should listen to Koji in the 1990s when he was in his peak, you might be pleasantly surprised

[@aran-uq8ik]

@@adrianboutsias2437 Ok its quite obvious that you havent listen to Dimash properly. 1. If you only think its the technique what makes Dimash unique, you my have a problem with your ears. 2. I dont need to listen to Koji again, I did it many times. And my words are still the same.

[@firstmissin333]

玉置浩二が切ない歌を歌うと魂がもってかれるから　とても危険だ

[@よこりん-h1r]

私は日本人です。TAMAKIは日本の歌番組で 「IKANAIDE 行かないで」を作った当初は上手く歌えなかったとコメントしていました。この歌を歌い切るには年月が必要なんだと思います。 ディマシュも十分に素晴らしい歌いかたですが年月と共にさらに素晴らしく変化していくのではないでしょうか。楽しみですね！

[@everclearr]

Wow that's the most insightful comment I've read on YT in regard to this song so far! I mean, that just makes so much sense!! ♥︎

[@ikkytedytv1415]

I adore Dimash, but this time must admit Koji sing it better with all emotions, he feels every word n note, coz he wrote the song himself

[@jiaunmew878]

Dimash and Mr. Tamaki did an awesome job. But MISIA’s version totally blown me away. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpOsgqiparyYg68

[@ikkytedytv1415]

@@jiaunmew878 amazing! Just know Woman can sing this too, thank u

[@jiaunmew878]

@@ikkytedytv1415 you’re welcome. MISIA always have unique ways to express her songs rather in artistic or emotionally.

[@soniamarrero7369]

Dimash is telling the story and touches your soul.Koji is living the story and breaks your heart!!.😪

[@Qoo62]

Wow! What a great expression!

[@トーマス芳田]

You have finally discovered Koji Tamaki, a Japanese treasure.

[@peterlim5217]

Koji win hands down. It’s not about theatrics. It’s about the soul.😉

[@jmssun]

Dimash sang it greatly, but sang like a patriotic party anthem.. strong on the facade, but totally lack in emotion Koji is… The Light, intertwined with all shades of color

[@angieminipin3536]

歌の上手い奴なんて世界に幾らでもいるだろうが、中々オリジナルには敵わないんだよな。

[@bukkatyan]

You’re reaction is the best.❤❤❤

[@takamasa1552]

Dimashと玉置浩二。全然反応が違うのが面白い。 玉置さんの方は、Dimashを聴いた後ってのもあるかも知れないが反応が早く表れるよなぁ。 まぁ、理解出来るけどね。 Dimashは、相変わらずスゲーなぁ、玉置さんは、オリジナルの凄味が染み出てて貫禄がある。 伝わるモノが違い過ぎて比較は難しいな。

[@gisanyomo5958]

dimash is very technical!!!! but koji is soulful

[@СветланаСуворова-щ7в]

Тамаки - великолепен.🇷🇺💕

[@shah3545]

Both are great singers. Dimash with this Chinese version which is more to loneliness and Koji Tamaki with pain in the song. Applause.

[@matheumendez6258]

Dimash is from another planet, but the original version is better.

[@everclearr]

Hahaha I 🤍 Dimash but I kinda agree

[@MrBlueGull]

"Ikanaide" has two meanings in Japan, "please don't go" and "please don't die." I am sure that It means the latter in this song, because it says "I am glad that I can touch you being still warm." It also says "Your spirit will become memory someday somewhere." I think it's very sad song. Dimash is an amazing singer who can control his voice perfectly, but I think Koji Tamaki sings this song from the bottom of his heart. I love both singers!

[@fumin8]

@MrBlueGull In this case "Ikanaide 行かないで" means "please don't go" or "please don't leave". There is another letter "逝かないで" for "please don't die" with the same pronunciation. This was the theme song of Japanese TV drama ''さよなら李香蘭 Sayonara Ri Kōran '' for about 4 hours in 1989. 李香蘭 Lǐ Xiānglán (in Chinese), Ri Kōran (in Japanese pronunciation) was the former name till the end of the World War Ⅱ of the very famous Japanese singer and actress, 山口淑子 Yoshiko Yamaguchi (Shirley Yamaguchi in USA). She was born in China 1920 to Japanese parents and died in Tokyo 2014. There was quite a sad story for her between her beloved two home countries, Japan and China. This song's words are very simple but express Ri Kōran's emotions full of sadness and pain toward leaving from her beloved China, Chinese people and Ri Kōran herself in 1946.

[@fumin8]

Yoshiko Yamaguchi - Wikipedia en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoshiko_Yamaguchi

[@davidbriseno7719]

They are both great, but Koji has the heart of one who saw that time and knows what went on after the war. I can also relate to this song. For 39 years I've carried my Autumn Strong in my wallet. I see her every time I open my wallet, and it's beginning to fade, every time I try to discard it, I can't. I have searched and tried to have others find her just so that I can say how sorry I am to have let her slip through my heart. Whenever I feel there is no chance of finding her. I play this song, if only to hold my thoughts of her in my heart and memories of our time we spent together.

[@user-ic7fo8ic9p]

You can feel the depth of pain just from listening to Koji's voice without even the need to understand the lyrics. He is really in a league of his own. He released this song in 1989 when he was 31 years old.

[@webmarch06]

I never knew that Mr. Tamaki was so famous in countries other than Japan.

[@KakiztoX]

I'm Chilean, I love his music

[@webmarch06]

amazing.

[@jimmyaddy8357]

I am from Malaysia. I am crying while listening to both songs be it from Dimash or Koji Tamaki. The tears running towards my cheek

[@junfuture1564]

玉置浩二の歌の説明はエモーションしかない。 もう1人は上手い。

[@dittyunplugs3942]

i prefer soul pouring to precise crafting as entertainment. good to have both options to suit a variety of tastes.

[@海道狂也]

端的にいえば歌と共に生きた年月の差。ワインと同じで、時間は不思議な作用をする。ディマシュが年月を経てどれだけ成熟するか分からないが、現時点で 玉置浩二に遠く及ばない。 彼は歌うと言う事がどういう事か既に理解している。つまり真髄を理解していると言う事です。

[@zezacatela2951]

Search for the video Ikanaide - Koji Tamaki from 20 years ago...

[@michaelbradley7529]

Dimash recently did the original Japanese version of this song, and perhaps that would have been a better comparison. Autumn Strong is really a different song that shares the same melody as Ikanaide (the Chinese lyrics are completely different).

[@everclearr]

Agreed

[@ameliamartin3641]

I like Dimash voice... He is the younger version of Koji. Beautiful voice and very emotional song. I love them both.

[@ongenmania4004]

If Dimash's song is an oil painting with overlapping colors, Koji Tamaki's song is like an ink painting. I am deeply impressed by Dimash's song, and deeply impressed by Koji Tamaki's song.

[@gjrloiouyfchicfhhudrgky3470]

Comparing it to painting, Dimash is pure realism at very high level. Koji Tamaki is surrealism and abstract at very high level. Putting in emotion requires way more complex skills. If you ever knew anything about classical music, and how they value expression, you'll understand.

[@davidsanabria7714]

Never heard of this guy. Been following Dimash since 2017. Never Listen to any other music outside my country. (USA) except Spanish. Washum Dimash saying introduce me to other singers all around the world and how great they are. For a 27 year old young man there was no other singer that I heard in my lifetime ,and I am 60 years old that could sing like him. He makes cover song his own. It’s a shame the skill he have so many people put him down. All his music is emotional. When he gets to be 70 years old he would probably say even better. Don’t put him down because of the talent he have that nobody else has.

[@ingrid2562]

The song was dedicated to real person, you should know a story of writing this beautiful song

[@mynlm]

Koji's album version. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i4fJoYtraM5jas0

[@カレンデュラチャンネル]

ikanaide→Don't die😢

[@LeeMaitland]

I personally believe that Dimash is the best singer on the planet, by far, his capability is unmatched and he learned this song in a really short amount of time. But the way Koji expresses this song, the pain behind the words is something that only comes with painful experience. DImash blows your mind, Koji breaks your heart. Both are transcendent.

[@maniaulakh5696]

Dimash has great technique but it's missing the soul. It's like seeing a really good looking burger but the ingredients are off... Koji burger not only looks good but tastes amazing..... sorry I'm hungry...

[@miupapa1448]

大声で歌う歌では無い。 前者は何がいいのか分からない。

[@РооПол-ц1б]

OMG Dimahs Fantastic Wow Bravoo

[@nero6308]

People are so strange sometimes. It turns out that if a singer has good technique and excellent skills, then his emotionality suffers?) No, no and no. These two aspects are by no means mutually exclusive. Dimash perfectly conveys emotions, but at the same time demonstrates good technique.

[@unehermite4215]

La gente no es extraña, es envidiosa 😉

[@maniaulakh5696]

Respectfully disagree. Hundreds of people are saying the samething, so there might be something there that you might be missing. (And that's ok, I miss things all the time as well). I encourage you to take a deeper look. There is a nuance idea present, that is hard to articulate but easily felt. Dimash is singing from 10000 hours of rehearsal, and you can clearly see the fruits of his labor. But my God Koji!...he not only reaches an unattainable level of mastery, but also talks directly to your soul. This is a lifetime of experience on full display. Just incredible! Koji is on another level fffoooorrr sure.

[@ҒалымжанҚашқынбеков]

👍👏👏👏👌☝❤🔥💓

[@phoenix321on]

Actually, I didn't really understand your message. I hope you meant well. It is quite silly to compare them. There are two absolutely amazing singers with different life experience. One is old and wise, another is just a boy who is starting his career. (2017!). I have a great respect for Dimash for choosing this particular song. The choice of music he sings speaks out for itself. As for today, Dimash is probably the only singer I can listen to for hours and hours. Respect other great singers as well, but still...

[@タオ坊]

比べてどうする？

[@0-Oz-0]

どうもしなくない？

[@nancycarrionquevedo7732]

Dimash, Dimash, Dimash!!!!!,eres el mejor cantante del mundo sin duda

[@lagerhop9184]

Zhou Shen - also - maybe ,,,, no , Is better than Dimash Memories Time to say good bye Monsters This is me Big fish Unravel Delabengba More!!! Beats Dimash- artificial, Zhou- real

[@h.y.h9554]

Dimash Dimash Dimash I wonder after 10 years what Dimash's voice will be after the experience and life breaks. Dimash you are a legend ♥️♥️ love u Dimash

[@AsianJazzify]

Dimash is just TRYING TOO HARD....., Nothing Compares To ORIGINAL SINGER KOJI TAMAKI😍

[@夜間飛行はとのやす]

不必要な技術とやり過ぎは虚飾。言葉数と音数を削ぎ落として作られたシンプルだけど思いを凝縮した歌には不似合い。そこに違和感を感じてしまいました。 聴きたいのは心を掴まれ揺さぶられる歌なんです…。

[@jiaunmew878]

Yes, Dimash did but his was sang in Mandarin. Mr. Tamaki really sang the soul out. But the one really blown me away is MISIA’s version. kzbin.info/www/bejne/hpOsgqiparyYg68 Her version she haven’t sing yet I’m already crying with the opening of the song.

[@sergiomunozcastillo7284]

Woow Dimash is the best. Beautiful beautiful!!!!!

[@Фатима-в6ф2в]

Dimash!💕💖

[@aslanpecanin2238]

Ofcurse koji has a lot more emotion he is much older and go more through Life than dimash but if you wont speak tehnicly he is not even close to dimash im speaking this as Singer

[@hornsup1228]

Yes, Dimash is a great singer but not an artist. To me Dimash is like singing machine, showing off his technic and that's it.

[@gjrloiouyfchicfhhudrgky3470]

Expressing emotion actually requires different skill. And, Koji already had more skill for that at Dimash's age. You clearly know nothing.

[@janhendriktromp7723]

Dimash very sad song heart breake

[@tolinicoara881]

Koji Tamaki only... But the version of Dimash have to be to...

[@aelong5840]

Dimash destroyed the song,pls don't sing again.