DISCONTINUED PALETTES THAT I WISH WOULD COME BACK! & Ranking my Top 5

[@Rforsch1]

I think Oden’s eye is going to bring back last year’s holiday palettes🤞🏻

[@Kimbyroseh]

My favorite discontinued palettes are by far, the too faced chocolate bar palette and the too faced sweet peach palette. They’re still some of my most used palettes and they are OLD.

[@gita_]

One of the best palettes I own and I didn't see in the list here, is Kalaidos with Angelica - "Club Nebula". Great one ❤️! I love every Oden's Eye collab I have and I manage to order their Christmas palettes last year. I hope they bring them back for the Holidays 🤞🤞🤞

[@rachelapalmieri]

I missed out on Club Nebula!!! 😢

[@kelseyc.9587]

I depotted my BH Naughty pallette into singles. They're such amazing quality but I never used them because of the bulky packaging and Christmas theme. Once I made them into singles I didnt associate them with Christmas anymore and I use them all the time 😄

[@rachelapalmieri]

That is amazing!!!

[@lissettecamacho2063]

Love my BH Naughty!!! Great palette !!! So happy I was able to purchase it!! 🤗 🎉

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

I feel the fear and I resent the fear. I refuse to jump on anything, anymore because of FOMO. I promise that I will not rush to purchase a reissue because I missed out the first time. Will I ever de-stash any of these? Never. They are my Precious.

[@danicee]

Speaking of discontinued, I wrote Colourpop yesterday to ask them about the palette for the Haunted Mansion collection and they said they don’t believe it will be restocked. It was on the website for less than 2 weeks and resellers are selling it for $80+ 😓

[@rachelapalmieri]

Awww noooo 😩

[@daniellezadora7637]

People are crazy reselling stuff 100x what it's worth 😂 ppl we're selling the Mario ethereal eyes on mercari for like 300$+ and some had hit multiple pans in them!! NFW

[@tianiortiz8529]

Fall magic and the ABH Jackie Aina are definitely Yum as well. Like everyone else I hope Odens eye just brings those Christmas palettes back out this year. I typically pick their stuff up on Black Friday because the deals are amazing but I wouldn’t wait again I would definitely grab at least the warm toned one. BRING THEM BACK😢

[@lauriediaz5075]

I agree and I have the bh Xmas palette it will always be my favorite from the brand 😊❤

[@rachelapalmieri]

It’s so gooooood!!!

[@alexandreaturcot8921]

First, Unearthly cosmetics is my favorite indie brand ♥️ Second, it used to be Bh cosmetics until Makeup Revolution took them over 😢 I need to break out that HUGE Christmas palette asap! Last but certainly not least, I get so excited for your videos especially eyeshadow content. Your video/memes are hilarious, "I love Chipotle," 😂😂😂🤣🤣 P.S. I hate when brands do limited edition and then they don't have enough for more than a day or two. Or they say limited edition and then all of a sudden it comes back every year, for a short time period? Like what the what? I am looking at you Natasha Denona Gold palette, lol.

[@rachelapalmieri]

Thank you so much!! 🧡

[@AnaCabral2014]

Loved the video❤ the good thing about is , since the pallets are discontinued we will save money not wanting to buy everything 😂

[@rachelapalmieri]

🤣😂 haha truuue

[@christahodges]

Okay, I own all but three of the palettes you mentioned. The BH holiday (which i totally have fomo over), Theresa is dead, and OE Judy (because I bought the OE Annette palette instead)

[@rachelapalmieri]

Nice 😊

[@loriann3744]

Cruel just cruel lol teasing!!! Loved the video!! ❤

[@rachelapalmieri]

Lol!!!! Thank you 😊

[@heybuddy2009]

"Guess what it's my video"😂

[@rachelapalmieri]

🤪🤪

[@susanlynn5159]

Just bought the Theresa is Lethal palette sometime last month when it was offered for the last time. I also have the first one, Lethal is Dead and the palettes work great together.

[@rachelapalmieri]

Amazing!

[@shimmersandsilver]

The pretty “space trash” shade in the Theresa Is Lethal palette is really similar to “Ski Bum” in Nomad Whistler! “Limoncello” was a home run; I adore the packaging. Loved this video idea, Rachel… Thank you!

[@rachelapalmieri]

💜💜💜

[@tianiortiz8529]

Love the sultry palette. I picked it up when they brought it back the last time. I was able to pick up the set they had with the drawers and liner, mascara and mini primer from Ulta for like $32. I didn’t even appreciate it as much back then definitely loving it more now that I’m in a neutral phase.

[@rachelapalmieri]

It’s a gorgeous neutral palette for sure 😍

[@armand9199]

The indigo column of the primal palette haunts my dreams... it is SOOOO hard to find a Dupes for those shades. I really hope blen bunny repurposes the shades from primal into some small palettes or brings back the indigos somewhere else.

[@rachelapalmieri]

That would be amazing!!

[@tianiortiz8529]

Yes the BH naughty palette is a good year round palette.

[@rachelapalmieri]

It really is!

[@tianiortiz8529]

I regret most of my CP purchase but Limoncello is so yum! Every time you bring it up I’m like YES GIRL! LOVE IT!

[@rachelapalmieri]

YESSS! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@addiewoodcroft]

Good Sport from Colourpop comes to mind. I had to recreate it from Sydney Grace shadows. I am so thrilled that I picked up the Oden's Eye Christmas palettes and the Hela palette...The BH Naughty palette is spectacular! Thanks for reminding me to get that one out!

[@rachelapalmieri]

Oooh Good Sport! I never picked that one up but I know it’s a favorite for a lot of people! Thanks for sharing 🥰

[@LorraineParis1]

I still have the Sultry Palette. I love the Odens eye Christmas and eve ones. So glad I have them. A work of Art in every way! I’m October baby and shared that day with my Mom!! Happy October birthday Girl!!💜🌈💜

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yayyy!!! Happy birthday to you too! 💜

[@morganwentworth2041]

My favorite discontinued palette is Warms My Blood. That's MY perfect warm neutral palette

[@rachelapalmieri]

Ooooh!! I missed out on that one 😢 it is gorgeous.

[@morganwentworth2041]

@@rachelapalmieri I picked it up for $90 on Mercari and it was worth every penny 😅

[@tammyherrera7262]

I have the Sultry, naughty & Aina palettes. 😍 I wish I would’ve gotten the Chipotle, CP Good Sport and Nebula palettes🙁

[@amysmithssportsandmakeup1397]

I had the Oden's eye Christmas palettes in my cart and passed and wish I hadn't so if they bring it back I'll be all over that like flies on s*&t. I also missed out on the the Tarte Aspen Ovard palette- wish I had bought that when everyone was trashing it. I really like the Colourpop Plush like me palette for its blend of warm, cool, and grungey but work appropriate. Congrats on the sponsorship- you work so hard and enjoy it. I think I'm finally gonna pull the trigger on the Leather and Lace palette from Unearthly. There's so many palettes that people don't want I see sitting on shelves cough cough Morphe JH, JC. Love ya girl. I just turned 50 last week so it's Libra season!

[@rachelapalmieri]

Plush Like Me is sooo good!!! Thank you so much for your kind words 💜💜

[@lisaluft520]

I agree about the ELF bite size. I don't understand the hype. But I love my Chipotle palettes. It's what I'm wearing today.😊

[@rachelapalmieri]

Oh no way! That is too cool! 😃

[@reneklein6049]

Congratulations on the sponsorship. I've heard only good things about Ana Luisa jewelry. Love The Sultry palette. Great neutrals. Theresa is funny beyond words. Wow. The BH Naughty palette is very pretty. One of my favorite ABH palettes, which I think is discontinued, is the Norvina. Fabulous colors and formula. I've yet to try an Oden's eyeshadow. I really need to grab one. The Fall Magic is gorgeous. I can see why it's your #1. Thanks Rachel. ❤️ 🩷 💗

[@rachelapalmieri]

Thank you Rene! Theresa is so funny and SO nice. I met her in person about a month ago. So incredibly friendly. Thanks so much for your thoughts & watching my videos 🥰

[@susanlynn5159]

I still have my Sultry and it is SO Good that I don’t feel I need the Glam palette from Natasha. I prefer the Carli Bybel x ABH and I think that she and Jackie were done wrong with the way ABH released the palettes. I can’t remember exactly but I believe they had a third release around the same time - maybe a huge Norvina? Just Wrong. That BH Christmas Naughty palette was a huge surprise! I bought it after seeing Heather Austin’s seven looks video and I was just Wowed, and the formula is tops! The good ole days when BH was on top of the world 😢 Yeah, I hate pressed glitter too, so I avoid them like they’re contagious.

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yes! The Carli Bybel one is great too!!

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

I’m currently waiting for my Blends and Sugar & Grunge palettes to arrive. I keep checking my tracking every day. I can’t wait to get mine. 😊

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yay!!!!!! I hope you love them 😃

[@MelBscents]

Omg yes, I have the 1 and 2nd palettes in your ranking and like you said they are just so so good! Like you the odens eye red dragon palette was the first palette I ever bought from odens eye and I was blown away!! And the fall magic palette is just perfection!!💚🙌🏼🍁

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yessss!! 😍😍😍

[@katiechatseyeshadow4394]

Great ranking, wish the wold palette with Annette by oe would come back. Only one of the three I haven’t been able to get second hand x

[@rachelapalmieri]

Oooh I skipped on that one too and I know so many people love it!

[@bansheemuse4794]

I want these eyeshadow palettes to come back! ABH Mario collab Adept House of el Adept Kodanne I love the colorstories of the Oden's eye but do not like the formula, and the unearthly eyeshadow palettes I would buy. I do not like the new fall magic and wish I would have bought the older one,

[@KagamineRinVocaloid]

I'm glad I have almost every Oden's Eye palettes. It's my favourite brand by far. I'm just missing their jewlery collection but I'll try to get them soon.

[@rachelapalmieri]

Their products are incredible!!!

[@Kimbyroseh]

Oh! That red dragon palette, odens eye x judy…. And the one they collared with Annette, the wolf? Palette? I can’t even remember the name of it but I really regret not getting those two palettes!

[@daisycate]

Great video! I missed out on Nomad Cosmetics ‘America’s National Parks’ palette. I did get their now discontinued ‘Haunted Europe’ palette, but I am happy for others that it is coming back next year. 🎉

[@rachelapalmieri]

I missed out on Americas Parks too!! 😭

[@leaj3799]

America’s Parks was my first Nomad purchase and a nostalgia buy for me since my family traveled in the summers to numerous parks when I was a kid. It’s a really good summer into fall palette. I held off for a while on the Haunted Europe because I was on the fence since I prefer warm to cool tones. I finally bought it when it went on sale last year prior to discontinuation and I really love it. I’m very glad Nomad will be giving others the chance again to discover how good it is. That said I’m on a low buy for various reasons, budget and overwhelming number of palettes among them, so I’m not allowing FOMO to influence me as it did in the past. I have a list of what really might fill a hole in my collection and waiting on sales and my budget before buying. That said, if Oden’s Eye re-releases the Christmas Eve palette, it goes to the top of the list and I’m not a blue girl either.

[@daisycate]

What a terrific theme. @@rachelapalmieri

[@daniellezadora7637]

I was able to snag an original fall magic pallet from mercari! I absolutely love it! I also ordered the new version along with sorcerous smoke during the first pre-order and I can't wait for those! I think they'll make perfect companion pallets at least that's what I'm telling myself to justify the splurge! 😂😂😂❤

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yes!!! They are going to be SO beautiful together!!

[@debbieotoole1072]

I'm so glad i picked up the Oden's eye Christmas eve palette it's gorgeous. I was going to say i regret not getting CT fire rose palette but it's today just dropped again on CT website 🙌

[@rachelapalmieri]

I saw that!!! Yayy 🙂

[@Mike.GoldenTouch28]

Be a stacker! Fun 🤩

[@rachelapalmieri]

😍

[@MakeupwithMariela1]

I missed out on the odens eye holiday palettes and got mine off Mercari paid more than I should have but happy to have them lol hopefully the don’t bring them back but guess I can be happy for others that didn’t get them and didn’t pay and arm and leg and waited haha

[@rachelapalmieri]

They’re truly so beautiful 😍

[@kerriwright4593]

I wish I had gotten the giant wolves oden's eye x Annette palette

[@rachelapalmieri]

A lot of people feel the same way!!

[@christahodges]

Good morning, sunshine 🌞 😊

[@rachelapalmieri]

Good morning! 🥰🥰🥰

[@KBellaBeauty1]

The classic ABH!

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yessss 👏🏻

[@nancy9961]

Still regret skipping on the Christmas palettes by Odens Eye 😑

[@mistichristensen7088]

Super fun video! 🌻💛

[@rachelapalmieri]

Thank you 🤗 ❤️

[@faizanfareh4753]

This is a fun video idea!

[@rachelapalmieri]

Thank you! ❤️

[@kerriwright4593]

I do wish I had the sultry palette but I already have a bunch of abh palettes I don't use lol

[@megdvs21]

Love this list 😍🤩😀

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yay! Thank you! ❤️

[@hes01231]

I was SO upset about the OG Fall Magic restock.. I was at work so I didn’t see the notification and it sold out super fast. The outer packaging is just as stunning and magical as the shades inside! I think I like the color story of the Sorcerous Smoke more than the new Fall Magic. I’m hoping they’ll stick around. I can’t spend $70 on every palette I am drawn to. I think Glaminatrix has got me more than any other brand when it comes to FOMO and buying when they’re like “get it before it is gone forever!”.. that Nocturnal palette would have haunted me until the end of days 😂 🤞🏼✨ sending the vibes out for the restocks people want the most and also a huge dollop of vibes for brands to do significantly less LE releases✨

[@rachelapalmieri]

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@daniellezadora7637]

I agree! Another brand that's terrible with fomo is cosmic brushes! Everything sells out ridiculously fast! I don't have time to cyber stalk brands! 🤣

[@hes01231]

@@daniellezadora7637 Same lol no time for that! I will say at least Cosmic Brushes doesn't do limited edition releases!

[@dubsbeautydiary]

Odens Eye x Judy is the one that got away for me. I think about it ALL THE TIME! The color story isn’t my vibe which is why I didn’t pick it up. But all the regrets. Lol

[@rachelapalmieri]

It’s so beauuuutiful!!

[@leahmiranda8359]

Hi Rachel! ❤ The bh Naughty palette was for holiday 2020. The Lit List was bh Holiday 2021. Bh had ceased to exist by holiday 2022. I have both of them. They are beautiful. Can I have your ‘aging’ eyes instead of mine??😂😂😂

[@rachelapalmieri]

2020?! Omg how time flies! 😱 and yes of course, you can borrow them anytime you’d like! 😂🤣

[@leahmiranda8359]

@@rachelapalmieri 😂😂😂

[@kerriwright4593]

I came from Angie's channel ❤

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yayy!! Hello!! 👋🏻👋🏻

[@kathleenkaffeine8696]

congrats on the sponsorship!

[@rachelapalmieri]

Thank you!! 🥰

[@midnightskyler6028]

I dont know much about palette brands because im like semi beginner in makeup and getting to know the brands. But omg its so overwhelming but exciting at the same time because i want so many palettes now ahaha. I want a collection. Im gonna start saving up and buy a bunch one day hehe 😂

[@kathleenmoortel5449]

I was new to makeup too in 2021 and I have amassed quite a collection (small by youtube standards but not every day standards). One tip I can give you is find out what eyeshadow colors you like and what tones look good on you. I have some cool toned palettes I almost never use because I did not know that I look much better in warm tones. Also if you’re up for it subscription beauty boxes are a fun way to try out different color stories. I recently subscribed to Ipsy by Boxycharm and they run some great sales which could be dangerous for your wallet 😅 but hopefully provide you with some quality products.

[@rachelapalmieri]

Yayyy! There really is so much to choose from, but so many great brands out there now. Have fun exploring 😁

[@celestecelestial90]

This sounds bad but the limoncello palette color story makes me a little queasy to look at. 😂 Maybe it’s something from a past life. I’m weird. 😂

[@heybuddy2009]

Hi queen!!!❤❤❤

[@rachelapalmieri]

Heyyyy!! 👋🏻👋🏻

[@LH-ci1bn]

I missed out on the Hummingbird palette and im so annoyed with myself.

[@rachelapalmieri]

😢

[@lauriediaz5075]

I SO REGRET NOT GETTING THE ODENS EYE XMAS EVE PALETTE. I GOT ONE BUT NOT THE OTHER, I ALSO REGRET NOT GETTING THE ANNETTE X ODENS EYE PALETTE

[@rachelapalmieri]

😢