Discovering Reichsfuhrer Smith Plans｜Man in the High Castle｜Season 4

Connect with me: / tudor.chrs Movieclip from:Season 4 Episode 10 - The Man In The High Castle
Everyone of you requested to post the scene where Helen discovered Reich plans after invading the West and in order to create a proper MovieClip I combined Reichfuhrer speech in front of America with the moment of launching the order of attack against BCR.
Watch the Recall of Luftwaffe clip: • Luftwaffe cancels the ...
The Man in the High Castle is an Amazon Prime original series that portrays a post-war, dystopian world where the Allies lost World War II. Watch season 4 here:www.amazon.com...
I do not own nor take credit for the clips uploaded here. All credit goes to the creators/owners. I do not take or plan of making profit for any of the videos posted here. I upload the videos for entertainment purposes only. I do not own nor take credit for the clips uploaded here. All credit goes to the creators/owners. I do not take or plan of making profit for any of the videos posted here. I upload the videos for entertainment purposes only.

[@krisninoorpatrianti8262]

"Remember Michael? from the office" "This him now ,a *ŐBERGRUPPENFUHRER* "

[@sean_connors]

Nein. John Smith ist Reichsmarschall, Amerika End of season 4 anyway. In S3 he was promoted to Oberst-Gruppenfuhrer, and was Obergruppenfurher when we first met him in Season 1.

[@sean_connors]

Krisni Noor Patrianti - dropping 40 feet at 80 mph no less!

[@BadH0mbre]

Sean Connors Nein. Reichsführer, Amerika.

[@sean_connors]

Daniel Jaramillo - Ja! Danke!

[@uspatriot6415]

Rip English

[@promethium752]

John Smith is like Walter White. At the beginning, he made it for his family. At the end, he made it because he loved it.

[@LINKINPARKSPAMPT5]

And I thought he would resign after season 3 ending

[@NicholasSteMarie]

My god that is an amazing comparison

[@miguelleite3510]

i don´t think he love it he just didn´t know how to be diferent he lived so much time with the monsters that he became one of them and didn´t know how to escape or to react diferent

[@elim4181]

@@miguelleite3510 I think that’s what a lot of people forget with John. Helen confirms earlier in the season that it wasn’t enough to pretend to be in the reich. They had to embrace nazism to stay safe. And after about 15 years of being a high ranking nazi general, it’s understandable that he became a nazi himself.

[@Arxfatal1]

No, he clearly says in the end that he never knew how to stop this spiral. He does what is expected of him, up to the point where he needs to cross the line to stay alive. Even in the end, one could guess that he is invading west America because I imagine that's what the people expect of him, or he would face a coup. That's why the ending of the series doesn't make sense in my opinion, the fuhrer of America cannot just call off the attack without having the entire army, the politics and all the nazis of America condemning him for showing signs of weakness....

[@M.G.2000]

Wouldn't have it been nice if Smith walked in while his wife was turning the pages and said "How do you like It?" like Jack Torrance in The Shining?

[@tiringsarcasm]

prinz martin oh my god

[@RK-ep8qy]

Nahh

[@srezno-ivan2006]

Here’s Johnny! 😈

[@nathanseper8738]

That would've been bone-chillingly creepy.

[@randomrazr]

why did he want to commit genocide?

[@Nidal_Aldari]

I don't understand how the path of the train isn't under surveillance...how could 5 random rebels attack him with ease... it's the Reichmarshal !!! The ending of season 4 is rushed.

[@rhysgermon9728]

Reichfuuher

[@Gillan1220]

Because secrecy was security. A train line is difficult to secure and it would put too much attention if you station too much troops there.

[@rhysgermon9728]

Actually ur right cause then the whole die newbenwelt would have been found out about

[@mikecornell5018]

I agree. The historical Nazis were pretty good at infiltrating resistance movements by blackmailing people they captured. They would say, "Work for us and your family won't be sent to a concentration camp." They were also pretty fanatical about security. That's how Hitler was able to stay alive until the end. I'm sure the alternate history Nazis would have the same qualities.

[@failhail9338]

Yeah unfortunately Amazon cut Man In The High Castle short. They had plans to go up to 6 seasons, but in the midst of Season 3 Amazon told the show writers that the show would only be given 1 more season and they'll have to wrap it up. Ducks because it could have been a lot better if the writers weren't forced to condense everything into 1 last season, which made it sucky.

[@ZacSaleski]

Just when you think John was starting to turn the corner...

[@Wisconsam2117]

Imaging the "Other World" where he actually does that, its a much better outcome.

[@TheBassraider]

they clearly cut show in middle.... ending was just horrible they should make atleast 2 more seasons to give it proper eding... this season should end with Smith/Gortzman coup and next 2 season about independent USA and alternative universe... would like to see Smith turning out from his Nazi side or escaping to other dimension

[@zzskyninjazz1821]

Witch-king of Angmar shame it was cancelled

[@ZacSaleski]

Witch-king of Angmar i guess they wanted to end it because it was a shorter story they didn’t want to drag it on. But I agree the ending felt rushed and very quick

[@balabanasireti]

@@Wisconsam2117 No.

[@tudorchristian2618]

The way you edited all sequences is very successful.For someone who didn't watched the show this clip is like a little story.

[@ChristiansEdits]

Thanks for the appreciation.

[@thehightable5995]

Smith addressing the nation like presidents used to do, while sitting in front of swastika flags is one of the darkest distortions of a real life act that this show has ever manage to put. And the only good scene on this mediocre finale.

[@kammler6774]

You mean the most awesome depiction of America's future.

[@robertwright4906]

Kammler this was by far my favorite season minus the last 10 minutes

[@kammler6774]

@@robertwright4906 I mean you can expect a show in today's era to be cucked on this issue, but man in the high castle is the closest you can come to being uncucked.

[@robertwright4906]

RDV V my mistake I meant the people coming through the portal. I loved John smiths ending. I completely agree.

[@robertwright4906]

Kammler I really liked the show I thought it was perfect. It wasn’t about contemporary politics and wasn’t infiltrated by fanatics. It was decently pragmatic and believable. Honestly I thought the show rivaled GOT when there was political drama. Nazi power plays were fascinating to watch. It was really quite similar to Roman politics

[@jcarlovitch]

Lots of people confused why she is upset now but didn't care about past atrocities. I believe it was because she accepted Nazi doctrine and choose to live in denial until Nazi doctrine caused the euthanasia of her son. After that point in the show she started to question said doctrine and started to see those numbers in the book as real people instead of merely numbers on a page.

[@PRubin-rh4sr]

Nah, she was upset because previously, they could justify their actions as "We did it to survive, to not be killed by the other Nazis." Now that they have full control and Smith kept on doing it, it was understandable she would be upset. But they should have driven this thing more to the audience. Helen just looked like an annoying wife here.

[@jcarlovitch]

@@PRubin-rh4sr you didn’t have to kill millions of your own countrymen to survive. Her husband took an lead part in the American holocaust, which oversaw the murder of every American Jew, African Americans, Latinos and Asians in the occupied eastern United States. Not to mention mentally ill, handicapped and those who opposed the regime

[@taliaeategg2027]

@@PRubin-rh4sr like if he retired?

[@aricboettcher]

Outside of the hospital scene in EP 1, I don't recall any of the non-Nazi characters having knowledge of Concentration Camps. Germany hid their existence in WW2 so it could be possible that Helen was learning about them for the first time

[@jcarlovitch]

@@aricboettcher Doubtful. her husband took in active part in the American holocaust, she surely noticed that there were no more Jews or minorities in the Nazi occupied America and in season 1 Heydrich bragged about killing millions in front of Smith's whole family.

[@ittybittytittycommittee6652]

Smith is evolving into Schmidt

[@camerongreene3357]

Johann Schmidt

[@spikey1389]

Lmao

[@gottod6895]

Actually I read somewhere in the internet that many American families with German family names due to ancestry have changed their last names to sound more English and American and that because of the prejudice they faced along the events of WWI. many Schmidt have become Smiths

[@777Revlon]

😆😂🤣

[@endloesung_der_braunen_frage]

A true German IT seems, since National Socialism is basically inherent to their genetics.

[@thehightable5995]

I wonder how the Nazis kept a census of how many minorities people live across the JPS and the Neutral Zone, those data looked quite precise. Speaking of precise, those numbers of how many people fit on those death trains are truly disturbing.

[@Mark50x]

@The Director of SHIELD looks like he learned nothing from his trip to the alternate America.

[@justtheaverageone3840]

I think the japanese gave the nazis the demographic statistics of their occuaption zone, and from the neutral zone I guess spys and other intelligence date was gathered. IRL the nazis had quite accurate numbers of russian jews etc. even for non occupied territories, because they already planned how to exterminate them at the wannseekonferenz 1942. Freaking disturbing if you think about it

[@chaomingli6428]

The Nazis signed an agreeemnt with the Japanese to ensure oil supply to Japan. Probably in exchange Japan provided the numbers.

[@Alte.Kameraden]

@@justtheaverageone3840 I don't see how that is possible IRL. The Soviet Union kept piss poor records on populations. During Stalin's famines figures flat out made up to mask the number of people dying in Ukraine, Belarus and Russia. There is no way the Nazis could of gotten an accurate estimate of Jewish Populations in Soviet occupied Belarus, Ukraine, let alone Russia. German Intelligence on the USSR was also piss poor in it's own right prior to the invasion of the USSR. So it's implausible they could have, if not impossible they could have accurate records.

[@justtheaverageone3840]

@@Alte.Kameraden I don't know how good they we're in population statistics but then again we're talking about an alternate nazi controlled universe so who know where they got their data from; I'm sure the gestapo or whatever intelligence service they have in the alternate 60ies has their methods :P

[@claudiapicariello5813]

0:55 he gives me chills. I hoped for his redemption till the very end. To me he was never a villain. He was of course, but there's always been conflict between the man he was and the man he would've been.

[@jarrodyuki7081]

well................

[@ransomdekafenya2584]

Nah I actually feel that. I was rooting for him until the very end. In a similar fashion, you can't help but root for Danny Vinyard, and even Derrick at times. But you'll always find people scared of the N word that see these people as simple characters with evil motives 100% of the time. You must forgive them. Because they are fucking retarded.

[@uberlags7022]

people can't have a redemption arc when they're dead

[@williamdonovan7867]

Strange how words on paper can be more disturbing than an image of violence

[@nathanseper8738]

It highlights the disturbing nature of Nazism: it made mass murder into a business.

[@Gangst3r4ever]

@@nathanseper8738 oh stfu. Capitalism is the same. Just less straightforward

[@nathanseper8738]

@@Gangst3r4ever I think capitalism is more "amoral". Businesspeople do what is best for their wallets.

[@chaosXP3RT]

I think it's because it's reducing human beings to just words and numbers on a page

[@samuelwithers2221]

It's so disturbing because of how meticulously planned it is. This isnt just a random act of violence or self defense or a war; it's the planning of mass genocide down to the size of the cattle cars needed to transport people to their deaths. And seeing that amount of detail and forethought put into something so horrible really shows how monstrous people can be, and its absolutely terrifying

[@Tobias_R]

I love the direction of this scene. The score, the shot choices. It all conveys such a sense of terror and evil.

[@strictly_sports32]

Episode 10 never happened. The true finale was Season 4, Episode 9.

[@townsendx7705]

Mike Hobbs Correct. Heil Smith!!!

[@sebping7205]

@@townsendx7705 I absolutely agree

[@Rizelibirkullanıcı53]

you couldn't be right more my friend

[@eternal5930]

It ended when the BCR had victory and they defended against the Nazi invasion.

[@bensonfang1868]

@@eternal5930 Not possible, the BCR only has popular support from a minority of the population. As late as 2000, California was almost 80 percent white. The other states of the pacific coast are less diverse. It's very unrealistic to assume that this massive majority would rather live under a black communist state than an white american one, especially right after their Japanese overlords withdrew. Most white americans in the 1960s would sooner accept Smith's autonomous american reich than the BCR. We already saw this when there were pamphlets that smith sent that the reich would liberate them.

[@joshmccollen700]

Smith's arc had led us to believe he was capable of redemption. But after decades of subservience to the NAZI's, their ideology was all he knew. Truly a tragic character.

[@danieldravot341]

The plural of Nazi (not all caps) is Nazis, without the apostrophe.

[@bladefeather2293]

Yeah

[@jtgd]

The only way he could have redeemed himself is to not be in power. Germany denazified due to allied occupation and a ruined country. The war came to Germany after 6 years of waging it against others, and all the abhorrent crimes against humanity that weren’t known to many were blatant. Eisenhower made the effort not just to show Germans the camps, but filmed and documented all that was left that couldn’t be destroyed. The Nazis may have gotten away with knowledge of the crimes, had they not documented many of it

[@anshumanchaurasia4956]

No bro, he knew what he was doing, and he regretted itn every day, that's why we're shown how he gets nightmares about the Jew friend he betrayed in initial era of Nazi Reich. What we saw at the end was simply LAZY WRITING. Once the top Nazi leadership was eliminated, he was answerable to no one, he had full autonomy. Nobody would've questioned him if he soften up on the Nazi side, and didn't go with the whole genocide plan.

[@maxflares8888]

@@danieldravot341 grammar Nazi in the chat?

[@richardl9014]

You either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain.

[@sash91216]

that is why he decided to die a hero

[@mikehogan5824]

Cool saying but plenty of examples of those who never fell from grace

[@marioserpico2223]

"...To be able to look through that door and glimpse all the people you could have been, and that out of all of them, this is the one you became." - John Smith

[@LordTalax]

It was a stupid saying in Batman and a dumb one here.

[@slippsdungeon5814]

Smith's story was the best. They should have made the show just about them and the Japanese.

[@Machiavelli_01]

Ты имеешь ввиду выставить сопротивление террористами?

[@dermetzgermeiser]

There’s a reason his character is named “John Smith.” He is the archetype of the man who survives above all else. This series is just so chilling and well done thinking about watching it again

[@easyben21]

I think. Earlier in the season John smith got to experience what life was like had he won the war, he got to see his son and his family and we as the viewer also got to see him as a different person under those circumstances. He mentioned to julia one of the things that surprised him about the war was that he was good at following orders, he was good at leading men. He felt had he stayed there it could have corrupted him/changed him. John Smith started out joining the nazi party at the end of WW2 to make sure his family was safe and that he did what he could to survive. he even made the moral choice not to help a friend because it would of harmed him and the look of horror on his face when he see's his friend again shows us that he realized he had changed. After that, I think due to all the years of living in that headspace as an officer and as a nazi changed him, it wasn't easy to change back to the way he had been because he had spent so long being that top officer. While I agree I felt they could have done it better justice, the reason he shot himself though proves he regretted what he had become and that he failed to stop himself.

[@azazaz4627]

Ya Helen even told him he needed to stop, and he said "I don't know how.."

[@hannesschwan6284]

you are obviously a native english speaker, can I ask you why you chose “would of” instead of “would have”? doesn’t make any sense to me, but occasionally I stumble upon it

[@TheFunnyDictator]

​@@hannesschwan6284Yes, exactly!

[@DoubtkeyApartments]

@@hannesschwan6284It’s a spelling error that comes from the pronunciation of “would’ve”. Mistake aside, they mean the same thing

[@DoubtkeyApartments]

@@TheFunnyDictatorI think you wanted an answer too?

[@M1tjakaramazov]

The title is misleading. These were not Smith's plans; they were directives passed down from Berlin to complete the process in America after the Japanese were ejected. Smith admits himself later on he doesn't know how to stop it.

[@ReaverLordTonus]

To me it made no sense for Smith to go full Nazi, the show seemed to imply once he obtained power and autonomy, he would work to transform America into a free nation again, basically redeem himself for his original betrayal.

[@theragingben5393]

US discriminated minorities before the end of WWII and nazi rule made situation worse, so, maybe, Smith doesn't see these people as americans.

[@whopper170]

We can’t be sure, But given that the John Smith of the other world was a good man, his best friend was a Jew, and would’ve stood up for blacks in the diner (per Thomas), I disagree.

[@ArgonYouTube]

James Cho Ah but that’s he alternate self, the Nazi one is an opposite from his alternate.

[@GabeNsApostle]

In the previous episode, Edgar Hoover played a clip wherein Helen reminded John that he had the same doubts and disbeliefs about Reich policy as she does. He confirmed this but asserted that he kept them to himself. When there was no one that could threaten John Smith anymore - as per the pure autonomy of the American Reich - it was completely out-of-character for him to execute Nazi policies.

[@seangannon6005]

Did it? I know the show implies he doesn't truly agree with nazism however his actions are always unilaterally in support of it. He never did anything that undermined the Reich until his coup at the end.

[@MarquezRobinson]

John Smith can utterly feel that his time is near and the pressure is on him heavy near the end of this scene....

[@Arakko-i7h]

S4.E09... This should’ve been the ending and there should’ve been a season 5 to end the show properly. Smith is such a good character that i began to side with him and hated the resistance. Wyatt is ok but Juliana is so boring. it’s Rome all over again. I’m pretty sure a lot of American presidents wanted to do that to Hoover. This scene was so good and then the next episode just derailed everything... I think, we can all agree, that this episode should be the real final episode. They divided the empire; The end of this season was such a shame. A real disappointment for an otherwise very good season. It really felt rushed towards the end. And here’s the thing... Smith was kinda the show's main character. Season 1 he was the antagonist. Season 2 and 3 he had become an antihero and by season 4 Juliana's arc had been so far relegated to the side, that Smith and Helen were constantly centre stage with the Japanese plot being the next most interesting. The show went out of its way to make clear that John was never a die-hard Nazi. Every deed and decision he’d ever made he’d done for his family. The tragedy of his character was supposed to be that he could only go upwards onto ever more shaky ground, or come crashing down with his wife and kids' fates in the balance. To all of a sudden take a 180 with his character feels so cheap and forced to me. Why is he going full steam ahead with plans for Holocaust.3.0 when he and his family are safe? Because he “didn’t know how” to stop it? Really!? But his mate, Bill, could turn the planes around with a single order and publicly throw away his badge? Not to mention that’s terribly unrealistic for a nation where significant portion of the population are extremely indoctrinated and at least half the top military staff in the American Reich are still die-hard Nazis. This needed another fucking season. We should’ve had John lose his sanity over Thomas and kidnap him. It would’ve made for great storytelling. If the writers wanted to drum up the “Absolute power corrupts absolutely” trope, they could’ve... but not in half a bloody episode! Way to butcher 4 seasons worth of character development in 30 fucking minutes. :(

[@piggy8761]

Shoulda had a second declaration of independence and unified america without going full nazi Terrible choice they made

[@Arakko-i7h]

@@piggy8761 truth

[@Ayhunt7]

Juliana is so boring.

[@Gillan1220]

We all hoped John Smith would be redeemed. Guess we were all wrong.

[@9965paul]

John Smith did nothing wrong.

[@presentatormeneerjajaja1829]

@@9965paul ratting his friends out? Atleast the General wasnt a nazi and cancelled the attack on the BCR

[@Fredfredbug4]

DevilTrigger degenerate

[@katherinetan4587]

@DevilAshes "a good nazi" -- you're sick

[@LordMichaelRahl]

It was obvious he was too far gone.

[@xxsilent12x]

I like how this series don't give a daum about redemption where like the bad guy eventually turns good again or the good guys win cliche like most Hollywood movies

[@itsederrengifo]

Considering it was a series about Nazis, pointing who is the evil one is not easy. Everybody only had motivations to do what they did, but also many of them used those motivations as an excuse to release their inner demons. Smith at that point of the story accumulated a lot of demons that his other self in the other universe didn't have, even Kido who seemed to be honorable was in charge of repression and torture, he also had his demons. I think the message of the series is that everything that surround us is too damn fragile, only takes a crazy man with a crazy idea to create a world like that one.

[@TheNerdForAllSeasons]

The good guys did win, dumbass. The Japanese left and Whitcroft representing the American Nazis pretty clearly is going to try and restore the Republic. Smith basically said it during the Denver episode. "Why don't we just go all the way?" "Bide your time, Bill." The reason people were hoping for a redemption arc is that, properly done, it would have been earned. Everything Smith thought he was doing to protect his family, ended up destroying it. The eugenics laws killed his son, the state brainwashed one daughter, the other hates him, and his wife tried to have him killed. It would have been a fantastic story.

[@TheNerdForAllSeasons]

@gamingvideos Partners: Matt and diemio Michael Nazi America had nukes. Several hundred, according to dialogue. Nuclear countries don't attack each other.

[@eeeccc3562]

Unfortunately, it had a cliche ending.

[@grandrum4889]

Never underestimate the dark power. John Smith went from good to surviving to leader to the evil lord/ Dark lord.

[@hengzhou4566]

You call it "dark power" only because it failed. Why aren't you living in a dark power too?

[@mustard8759]

The semites are using dark power but are they called bad people

[@08alende]

It's one of the scenes where the writers intention was to discredit Smith so that nobody would feel sympaty towards him when he dies. Lets be real, Smith wouldn't even concern about concentration camps etc. He has much greater plans (Space travel etc).

[@ervinm.5065]

I swear, by the third season on I couldn't care any less about Giuliana Crane, the entire serie was held on the back of Smith and Kido

[@Ayhunt7]

Juliana is so boring.

[@user-bd7lw6pz8d]

how I like about this show is the colour tone that each season it goes darker and darker and muted compared to the alternative universe that its brighter and more hopeful

[@TheFunnyDictator]

Wdym? Reference? Please reply to me!

[@ChristiansEdits]

Pure evil and diabolical John Smith for 3 minutes straight I swear. Everyone of you requested to post the scene where Helen discovered Reich plans after invading the West and in order to create a proper MovieClip I combined Reichfuhrer speech in front of America with the moment of launching the order of attack against the Western States.

[@ChristiansEdits]

@@nikitaa3784there you have it kzbin.info/www/bejne/hoqoh2mBe92tnNU

[@Qkdkdq]

John best character in the show, easy.

[@clementnade972]

He spent so much time blending in with monsters he has forgotten how to stop acting like one.

[@colingibson1998]

I don't know why she is horrified about john setting up the camps since she helped him before with it

[@Lightningkuriboh]

Colin Gibson it’s cuz this time he is doing it out of a place of strength, in the show they clearly explore they did what they did bc they thought they had no choice

[@colingibson1998]

@@Lightningkuriboh yeah I guess your right but i wonder why they would be royal to the Reich after they killed there son

[@jesusramirezromo2037]

@William Wykoff But the american reich was independant from the German rich bay that point

[@gerardoorilia9321]

In my opinion, this could have been the real ending, and it would have been wonderful.

[@sameralas6906]

The map shows a suggested concentration camp in Alberta. Alberta is part of Canada heh !

[@ChristiansEdits]

Hah not even the Canadians are safe those days lol

[@imperiumgrim4717]

LOL that sucks

[@DLordSadow]

He controlled Canada as well as the Reichsfurher of North America.

[@Winterlandschaft]

A canada what speaks austrian german would be nice. ;) Then it´s a feeling like Tyrol v2 with the winterlandscape and german speaking people. ;)

[@jb76489]

Samer Al the Canadians put Japanese into camps same as Americans did

[@jeremiahpalaspas244]

There is so much potential for 1-2 more seasons... but, here we are.

[@timf2279]

Covid and woke.

[@helmetguy6495]

I still wish we could've seen the reformation of the US at the end of the series.

[@rhysgermon9728]

Yeh that’s what I thought was gonna happen

[@azazaz4627]

We did but didn't. Whitcroft tore off his Iron cross and called off the attack on the Western States. IE basically implying, since he was now in control of the country as it was basically a military dictatorship run by the Army/American-SS (And even the American-SS seems to be indoctrinated to be loyal to the AMERICAN high command, and not the one in Europe), that some form of the United States will be coming back.

[@zumagallerte4669]

Oh, it would be beautiful. Fat people in Wal Mart on mart carts, opioid crises, gang wars, rioting and looting PoC, pedophile hollyoood, rap music, drag queen story hour, homeless people in streets full of shit and needles and healing from the Nazi occupation.

[@jonothandoeser]

I always wondered if Smith's "absolute autonomy" really mean that, had he renounced the Nazi worldview, that the Reich would have stood idly by and calmly accepted this. It seems more likely that if Smith had transformed North America into a pluralistic, western, democracy, that it would have been the one shining rebuke to disprove the practices and philosophy of the Reich.

[@TheNerdForAllSeasons]

@@jonothandoeser Whitcroft stated they had access to several hundred nuclear missiles in America. That's a pretty serious deterrent.

[@pershing5286]

Oh good, there's only going to be one Concentration Camp in Canada. ........And its right next to my hometown, dam.

[@ryancoulter4797]

Pershing was that circle ⭕️ on Calgary? I thought they’d stick one somewhere in Saskatchewan

[@imperiumgrim4717]

LOL

[@starman1144]

@zikkimeister or a Slav, or white Jew. Not all whites are safe. Saskatchewan has a large Ukrainian minority.

[@Sleipn1r]

It is interesting why his wife of Smith cries when she sees the secret plans of concentration camps - she still needs to remember quite well the pre-war laws of segregation in the USA in the early 1940s. =/ The series was initially curious, but in the middle it began to degrade.

[@daru5002]

Segregation is one thing - collecting all the minorities in a few camps and exterminating them is another matter. Also Helen most likely was from New York, and many Northerners did not support the laws of segregation.

[@bluesnail5042]

Jim Crow laws were only truly prevalent in the South of the USA. Giving blacks second-class citizenship in the USA is one thing, mass extermination of minorities is a different thing entirely.

[@benjamingrist6539]

Nikolay Pavlenko the idea that segregation wasn’t prevalent in the North a very common misconception. For just one example, Dietrich Bonhoeffer (the German pastor who famously took part in a plot to kill Hitler) spent a few years in New York City. While there, he was kicked out of a restaurant for daring to bring his black friend with him. It was then that Bonhoeffer began to think, “If it can happen here in America, then it can happen in my native Germany.” A few years later, the Nazis came to power. There were also plenty of race riots that took place in the North well into the 1970s. One famous photo from that era shows a white Bostonian using an American flagpole as a spear against black protesters. The North was just as racist as the South, they just took great pains to keep quiet about it or hide it afterwards.

[@joehill4094]

@@daru5002 look up the forced sterilizations of minorities in the United States.

[@thedoctorairsoft6813]

Why the hell would anyone compare segregation and mass genocide? For fucks sake its like comparing the interment camps with Death camps, Its apples and oranges mate. Telling a black guy he can't drink out of that fountain is a lot less worse then throwing him in a gas chamber and killing him along with hundreds in the same exact room.

[@metroranger7295]

This came way out of left field for John, like I get it he is men't to be the big bad but after spending so much time with the man over four seasons and watching Him put his life on the line for his family this feels like the witters only remembered at the last moment "oh shit he is a Nazi and he hasn't really done any A-typical Nazi stuff... I know lets just make he do the Constriction camp thing that will make the Fans hate him" the Fans "WTF" like honestly having John have to confront his Jewish friend in the other universe and come to the realization of what he did right after the end of the war and how much it did break him and for them to just say "oh ye he is the Big bad guy" just feels rushed and out of place, this show up to the last episodes was brilliant but they really did drop the ball at the end.

[@memeagain1762]

As a 50% German 50% American I think I'd be safe

[@catholicracialist776]

No, because you don't have 100% germanic D-N-A and Nordic face structure They would not spare you

[@CantThinkOfADamnUsername]

1:33 my mom opening my childhood “drawing coloring book”

[@pyromagic7113]

I think this scene was to show the true horror but sophistication that went into the death camps, this scene is all fictional but this shit really happened and not that long ago.

[@Balnazzardi]

Except this plan would have been more akin to "Generalplan Ost" in scale....the plan that would have wiped out Soviets/Slavs from western side of Ural mountains had Nazi Germany managed to defeat Red Army. But ye what adds to horror in this scene is knowing that this systematic mass murder did took place and they had plans to do it in much larger scale than they already managed to do....

[@tobim5574]

No it didnt.

[@williamdonovan7867]

Pyro Magic how very true

[@georgbergsten6050]

Tobi The Viking First denier I found here

[@tobim5574]

@@georgbergsten6050 Ok BERGSTEN lmao oy vey

[@Ali-tm1kr]

ONE NATION UNDER SMITH!!!

[@rebel0032]

A season 5 was needed, finale episode ruined it, for what was an overall great show

[@timf2279]

I agree it was too rushed/compressed at the end

[@jal123me]

This scene made me physically ill while watching, I couldn't help but think... the producers based these documents off of real plans that were drawn up during the war.

[@FixedFace]

what real plans?

[@jal123me]

@@FixedFace the ones the party drew up during ww2.

[@BravoSixGoingDark]

*''Soon, we will be one nation again.''* 😟

[@WarbonnetProductions]

The music really makes it even more eerie.

[@perrocapitalista6230]

You know which music is please?

[@kd6836]

The National Socialist German Workers' Party doesn’t allow for any change or grace, not even from the one in charge. The ideology is very powerful.

[@Dead-bl7to]

Engineers note: the chambers must have wooden doors.

[@redshuttleredacted6422]

M y f e l l o w A m e r i c a n s... Geez I wonder where I have heard that before.

[@ortho-g9826]

It was a GREAT series, no doubt. But, it was in many ways thoroughly unbelievable.

[@TheFunnyDictator]

Why so?

[@Havok135]

Its alternate history, of course its unbelievable.

[@Ugapiku]

TBH I wanted to see a bad ending where Smith does his plan...

[@Ugapiku]

@@CaptainStandiford lmao ok

[@sid2112]

@@CaptainStandiford Imagine a world free from the tyranny of the left where anyone can live the life they earn without authoritarians forcing them to give up half so they can spend it on bullshit. Imagine a world where government didn't need taxation to function, because the functions are limited.

[@Calypso993]

In the end he became the very same man he critiziced in Berlin before killing him.

[@grady2104]

Thanks for sharing! Could you maybe upload the last scene of Episode 1 were John takes the kids with him

[@ChristiansEdits]

Thanks for watching the vid.And about the scene you asked there are no big repercussions afterwards...so it's pretty uninteresting.

[@grady2104]

@@ChristiansEdits hmm i just liked this scene :P the music and the setting was very good

[@theduke7539]

Horribly inefficient. They use basically replicas of European frieght cars, when the US already had a vast amount of established cattle cars and freight cars of our own design in use. Plus, rail lines in the west are much more spread out than in the east, so unless they plan to use trucks, theyll need to lay out a lot more rail lines.

[@davidmurray9193]

The Americans were practicing eugenics (not on the concentrations camp scale but in stopping people of a mental state from reprocreating) way before the Nazis who then based a lot of their aryan ideas from that practice...in reality

[@_Devil]

MITHC truly is the darkest ending for the US

[@samuelborgeson3897]

Its a shame this story didn't get to play out more. Would have liked to see a real win from at least one side.

[@jeanpierre5941]

If you are wondering, this is inspired by something that the Nazis actually planned called the Generalplan OST or GPO.

[@eternal5930]

1:46 When I saw this page it was... Disturbing.

[@davidgriffiths7696]

Pity about San Francisco. It was quite a pleasant spot for a stroll.

[@johnm7491]

I never understood this change in Smith, throughout the series he never showed any signs of support or favor for cleansings, at least i'm aware of. And it's not even as if he was obligated to do so, North America had complete autonomy from the Reich, no one was forcing him to do it?

[@mrgomelonsolaris]

This reminds very much of how the Soviet Union was in reality. You can't escape the dogma of the system, because else you are suspected of being a traitor to the values and the next guy with ambition will accuse you of heresy and take your place.

[@Flashblade]

I was expecting this finale to be riveting as fuck. Instead I got 2019 Lakers.

[@patwiggins6969]

He sold his soul a long time ago. Don't know why he's having reservations now. He knows he's damned.

[@cliffcox7643]

Assault on San Francisco...... nice. Maybe we can make the place more affordable again.

[@AgentPepsi1]

John Smith!!! :-D

[@imperiumgrim4717]

@Random Autonomous Drone Pilot Hail Caesar for the Empire of Rome

[@AimlessTrek]

The last episode had 2 seasons worth of development stuffed into 60 minutes

[@TheFunnyDictator]

Why so? Please reply to me!

[@HavanaSyndrome69]

Why are there so many jews in these places compared to everyone else on the west coast? Is it because when the Reich took the east they all fled to the west?

[@emilioo.7972]

Sounds logical

[@timf2279]

They rounded up the population on the East coast. The rest fled to the neutral zone or Pacific states.

[@gabriellouisemanalansan2507]

0:53 that's the admiral that also shows in season 2 idk its the admiral in where martin huessman finishes the war room planning

[@thnktank1]

The best parts of this show for me was the nazi oligarchs' wrestle for power.

[@Tiisiphone]

Absolutely. Game of Thrones, SS style.

[@2snowgirl520]

Agree

[@Raduldo]

A damn good looking plan.

[@stax1996ify]

I mean , they ruined the whole series whit last scene , i just saw the rates on imbd for last episode it's 5.6 i think . They could at least make another series , 5 season could be reeeeeaaaallly good

[@ChristiansEdits]

It's not like Amazon was running out of money...I have no idea why they canceled the show so early...however we should be glad we recived S3&S4...they wanted to stop after S2 in 2016

[@Rowrin]

@@ChristiansEdits They ended the show because they said in an interview it was becoming too depressing. There was an interview after season 3 where they said something along the lines of "wanting to make a fictional show, but that after the 2016 election their story was becoming more reality than fiction" or w/e, thus were planing on wrapping it up with season 4. Basically they wanted to end it because orange man bad.

[@LegionnaireScout]

Most shows end in this non-sence way these days .. GoT being another example ...

[@flint9889]

@@Rowrin That is the most stupidest reason to cancel a show. How can you compare to a fictional show about Nazis to real life right now. Bunch of freakin babies.

[@Gauntlet1212]

@@Rowrin Cancelled because of TDS. Makes sense if you look at the dominant mindset in hollywood.

[@PRubin-rh4sr]

Produce: "Alright, could you draw us a blueprint for a working gas chamber?"

[@MinorityRespecter88]

John Smith was clearly the hero of the story

[@SteveVi0lence]

I love how the bad guy looks like that bad guy from a bug's life

[@generalripper7528]

Transport infrastructure is unrealistic. US Railways have much larger train cars compared to German ones, thus they could fit more "cargo" in there. Just an observation for authenticities sake.

[@baronbrummbar8691]

germany normified many things during WWII ---- so it would make sence that they put german train norms on the us aswell

[@generalripper7528]

@@baronbrummbar8691 True, but overall it wouldn't make much sense, since the atlantic divides Germany from the US and the larger train cars make more sense for North America.

[@baronbrummbar8691]

@@generalripper7528 that didn´t/wouldn´t matter to ns germany ---- the normified thing witch made 0 sence to normifie ----- for example they put ALL of europe in the same time zone - P.R. China does the same and it has terrible effects

[@ReveredDead]

Remember when Himmler told Smith "I saw myself in you John". He was right.

[@nycot107]

Rufus Sewell is awesome.

[@A_massive_wog]

This was the laziest part of Season 4's writing. Smith didn't believe in the ideology. So when he becomes the leader of the American Reich he would not have simply followed the old Nazi doctrine.

[@itsederrengifo]

Not even Himmler believed in their own ideology, for many of them it was just a game of power. I think that from the Nazis, the only one with an idea to pursue was Heussman. Smith was pragmatic, and not necessarily a good person (he sold his own friend), so following Nazi ideas to kill "enemies of the state" makes sense for him, his power was directly related to make the American Nazi elite happy, and at the same time get rid of a resistance that was gaining more power, a resistance led by black people, something that the white eastern population (already aligned with Nazi ideas) would never allow to reach power or rights. I would say his profile is similar to Stalin.

[@robertmcdonald8342]

It's almost as if Smith not helping his friend was the result of a triage

[@harrisonqu8359]

Lol, would be epic if president Xi announces the same way John Smith did before taking Taiwan.

[@asdfghjkl92213]

Harrison Qu it would totally happen lol

[@catgs7577]

what is strange is that everyone is talking about john's plans for phase v while we can clearly see an ss bringing his plans sent directly from berlin s4e10 around 04:50 . These are the different phases organized by Himmler, a meeting where John was not invited ... so or despite all the previous episodes John turned between Sunday and Monday into a Nazi worse than himmler and Hitler reunited or he certainly has total autonomy management but Berlin is waiting for results ... so the big question is what will do with Berlin, which wanted to raze all the cities on the west coast now that he is dead. unless by some miracle the Reich disappeared with him ...

[@Matthew-qx3dh]

The guy who called off the attack on San Francisco was a true American John Smith went mad

[@bumblebee__]

Saved? More like.. *Under New Management.*

[@rewjik7998]

i love how she is all shocked, despite the fact that that the USA had concectration camps of its own before and after WW2.

[@jrqf8689]

Rewjik not to that scale or that cruelty before

[@orlandof6496]

You really cant compare the ones the US set up to the literal DEATHCAMPS.

[@rewjik7998]

@@orlandof6496 Yes you can.

[@orlandof6496]

@@rewjik7998 When did the US systemically execute millions of innocent civilians in death camps and simultaneously use them as slave labour?

[@kkhagerty6315]

PatrioticPatriot1776 F technically the Indian wars

[@markh9755]

Bruh he should change his name to Johanne Schmidt now

[@1-o529]

The ending is so rushed its sad to see an amzing show with such bad ending

[@Someone111ify]

Yeah, the director didn't show us why the fuck the army to protect the project Nebenwelt had lost so easily.

[@timf2279]

Screw Amazon.

[@joannabayles971]

I found it very slow to begin with, I was impatient. But then things clicked and by the time it ended there were scenes that were surprising. All in all I think the idea was good, parallel worlds, what ifs and would it change things...so, good.

[@PaulA-ns9te]

this was actually in Stephen Miller's desk.

[@jackson7962]

Based lmfao

[@tobifisher5622]

I wish

[@Bmpaul02]

Emprahs Finest that didn’t stop the Judische ghetto polizei

[@PaulA-ns9te]

@@emprahsfinest7092 that was a really good "I have a black friend" response

[@PaulA-ns9te]

@@emprahsfinest7092 because you're a racist pig

[@JohnXina54]

They screwed us over with this season ending so much

[@Ayhunt7]

Juliana is so boring.

[@filipstudeny]

And at just that whole character development went to garbage

[@Ealdorman_of_Mercia]

The show started off strong, the time travel aspect was brilliant and very interesting, it got me hooked, I was expecting so much more of the show.. The way they ended it after Smith became president is utterly ridiculous.. I felt like I wasted all my time watching the show..

[@Ayhunt7]

Juliana is so boring.

[@lvpo8866]

Heil Smith!!!

[@endloesung_der_braunen_frage]

You agree with this?

[@lvpo8866]

@@endloesung_der_braunen_frage Yes.

[@endloesung_der_braunen_frage]

@@lvpo8866 So you support genocide, correct?

[@jackohlander8355]

Nastasija Milanovic Is your name Slavic in origin? You may need to touch up on what the Nazis believed about, and did to the Slavic people of Europe if so.

[@helpiamstuckonthismanshead3385]

@@jackohlander8355 ya she does need to catch up on her history i bet she might not be slavic and just another fat amrican

[@mushroomhead5914]

I wish it could be true, but it is only a fantasy... Maybe one day..

[@malcolmlaprairie5115]

A deep ending but it ruins 4 seasons of development for smith - I suppose it's making a point there but still

[@PadecMaybeReal]

If only the show ended at 1:00

[@80sOutrunFan]

S4 bad af. we need 2-3 seasons to give this story a good ending.

[@alfredearl]

What a rushed ending, would've been better if Smith didn't die like that or didn't die at all, but this show has been "cancelled", such a shame, I actually liked this.

[@Giant_Dutchman]

Why were the armbands so dark in this scene?

[@danielgriffith3923]

Wessel 18 probably in mourning for himmler

[@DLordSadow]

I think it was a lighting issue.