Disney World COOKIE CHALLENGE -- Gideon's Bakehouse

Gideon's Bakehouse in Disney Springs is known for having the BEST cookies in all of Disney World, but which cookie is truly the BEST of the BEST? We ate EVERY cookie on the menu to see which one deserves the #1 spot!
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Did you enjoy this video? If so, please Like, Favorite, and/or Share the video with others! We'd love to hear your comments.
Don't miss a video - Subscribe to our KZbin Channel: / allearsnet
Sign up for our newsletter AND get a FREE checklist to help you pack for your next Disney trip: allearstoday.c...
♥ TWITTER / allearsnet
♥ PINTEREST / allearsnet
♥ FACEBOOK / allears.net
♥ INSTAGRAM / allearsnet
For complete planning and vacation information on Walt Disney World, Disneyland and Disney Cruise Line visit us at: allears.net

[@jocelynschifano6757]

Love the new people I am seeing in the videos but would love to have them introduced and maybe do a new round of challenge games with the new people!

[@LaLunaLady]

YaY! for new scavenger hunts!

[@disneylover751]

Brilliant idea. I feel like we get to know them better during challenges.

[@notyournormalg1]

You guys have all really come into your own. Quincy especially is really blossoming as the anchor for this group. We Stan.

[@disneylover751]

Agreed!

[@mrjiggawatt]

I was afraid for AllEars when Molly left, but it’s still great! Good job!

[@ginacampbell2486]

Love, love, love this video and trio! Great sense of humor laughed out loud with "save the cookies". I look forward to more videos with the three of you. Great team chemistry!

[@arthemiseb9209]

Sammy!!! So excited to see Sage. He was amazing during our Halcyon voyage.

[@SharpeAshleigh]

Literally just realised why I recognised him!!

[@lillianfredriksson1890]

Ooohhh. That’s where I have seen him. What a great addition.

[@grumpibell]

Yessssss

[@brianpatry6362]

OH SNAP! I thought I recognized him from a Disney vlog! Turns out it was vlog entry on AllEars from when they stayed at the Halcyon. lol

[@heather_ncsu2037]

We were debating this. Glad we weren’t the only ones.

[@lifewithlindsay7327]

Ok loving Sage! I hope we see him more often!!!

[@MusicalOne09]

Just wanted to say Sage has such great energy! Quincy, Emma and him seem to have a really nice rapport. Hope y'all can continue to do videos together!

[@Hierro330]

SAVE THE COOKIES!! That's so awesome I love it. I need to try Gideon and please make this as a series! I love to see more challenges of other food, desserts, etc. around Disney to see what is the best of the best

[@walkingwithmellow5955]

Fantastic video! Love the new addition of Sage! Please do a cake challenge next! Thanks again!

[@MelissaH1977]

I have never been more jealous of your job.

[@britbroersma]

Sage!!! So glad to see you here!!

[@melissafigueroa5454]

This video was awesome! I enjoyed it a little to much lol thanks!

[@AmberDoubleU]

This would be a fun challenge. You can never have too many cookies! 😋

[@codiewoodhouse1988]

Quincy is the Randy Jackson of cookie judging 🤣🤣🤣 love it

[@lavetaloca7790]

"that's a no from me dawg," Quincy; doesn't miss a beat

[@grumpibell]

My name is Gloria and Im a Sage Starkey stan!!! I’m glad to see him as a part of the team

[@burnruber13]

So Sage is Sammy from the Galactic Starcruiser right?

[@emalymick]

Petition for an Erin McKenna vegan treats review by Breedlove!

[@disneylover751]

What a great idea! I’ll second that. I love anything with Breedlove.

[@CathyS_Bx]

They should actually offer a "Time of the Month Cookie" because . . . cravings!

[@kuhteen]

Great video, loved the energy! Seriously considering going to WDW just to experience Gideon's.

[@dannygrau2983]

The best part is its all calorie free. 😂

[@disneylover751]

Hi Sage, Emma and Quincy! I will be looking for you all next month when I’m in WDW! Thanks for the delicious review. I hope to try this place. I’m a big time cake fan too. I’d love to see a cake review from Gideon’s.

[@mjfury9183]

haha same! I'll be at the springs in Oct as one of my last days at disney.

[@dannygrau2983]

I love gideons!! My favorite flavors are chocolate chip , peanut butter crunch , then the triple chocolate chip , and finally the cookies n cream cookie, all delicious 😋.

[@irishgirl4977]

Love the PB Cold Brew - delicious! The pistachio toffee cooking is soooo good.

[@MrFluffFluffandNeo]

It’s funny cause we tried pistachio and cookies and cream the only time we ever tried Gideons and I absolutely loved both. Pro (not really) tip: bring some back to your hotel/resort and yes, even though they’re melty, they’re perfectly wrapped so you can make it all the way back to put them in the fridge and save them for park days to eat on the go for a light (but rich too) breakfast. Definitely still tasty cold.

[@captiv8marketing]

NO WAY #TeamPistachioToffee I have dreams about the deliciousness of the Pistachio Toffee Chocolate Chip Cookie from Gideon's We got all of these but the specials back in April and are now stuck in Minnesota with no Gideon's! Though the line may reach us here soon ;-)

[@lindasadler6338]

Hello to Sage!! I think this the first time we’ve seen him. Fun video!!

[@courtbourne]

He was Sammy on the Halcyon Galactic Starcruiser

[@candycemonroe7345]

@@courtbourne WOW

[@MagicalBeckyMe]

I am dying to try the Pistachio Toffee cookie. I want to try all the cookies!!

[@jeffaltier5582]

I be darned if I will spend over an hour in line for a cookie. Don't care how gourmet it is.

[@lisad5372]

Triple chocolate with the peanut butter frosting is the best!!! It took us three days to eat it! haha Very rich! This was a fun video! Like these three together!

[@janeogle650]

oooh could you do cake challenge??

[@chloesumner1317]

Loved the reviews and also love Emma's multitude of Hercules ears and coordinating outfits!!!

[@paigemccoy8526]

Gideon’s peanut butter cookie is my absolute favorite. If you like pb cookies, you’ll love it. 10/10 for me. The coffee cake cookie is 9.5/10.

[@frankcooney1693]

Hopefully them mentioning the cakes while waiting in line was foreshadowing a CAKE CHALLENGE video.

[@nocotheatrix6457]

Sage, so sad you didn't like the peanut butter one. I really wanted that to be tasty!!! I would choose the double chocolate! Yum!

[@rachelhill9407]

Me and my daughter geeking out in the background when we walked by 🤦‍♀️

[@MagicalBeckyMe]

Oh sad. Lol the cookie I am most curious about at the very bottom.

[@LaLunaLady]

I liked the new guy, Sage. I thought he brings some fun energy to the group and I'm becoming very fond of Emma as well. And of course, Quincy always rocks! 🤠

[@lillianfredriksson1890]

Loved this. I would like to see more content like this where you try one type of food at different places and do comparisons.

[@mariferbernal6655]

My favorites were the pistaccio, the peanut butter and the traditional one.

[@enriqueeduardovillegas4037]

Pls do the same with the cakes

[@stephanierobinson4896]

My favorite is the coffee cake cookie! But, I haven’t had a chance to try the banana bread chocolate chip. Hopefully, next trip!

[@samanthajay7944]

Sage… why do I recognise you? Whose video have you appeared in because it’s driving me mad that I can’t work it out 😂 are you a friend of Tim tracker/Adam woo/mr morrow?

[@beeferannenewbold6796]

If you watched any Galatic Star cruiser videos, he may look Identical to Sammy

[@tmsala59]

Everything Looked Delicious! 💖

[@angieg8208]

Sammy!!!! / Sage!!!!!

[@funnymanatee]

Bring an umbrella for shade while waiting in line! 🌂

[@ks328]

This spoke to me. I am a big fan of the original. Excited to try banana bread and cookies and cream the next time I visit.

[@KW-kj8vk]

I really like the energy Sage brought to the video! Also love Emma’s shirt!

[@kimberleyjones1956]

Loved this!!

[@kimp1044]

Love Emma’s Minnie ears ❤️

[@dannygrau2983]

Dont judge !!! Oh snap😂.

[@ALivingFlame]

I rate this video 10 Spooky Books out of 10! 📚👻

[@Gwencassidy]

Did they have any vegan cookies

[@gemtachataj6119]

Sage looks like that guy from starwars galactic starcuiser

[@daves9355]

You need to actually eat the cookies to determine if they are good or not vs scraping the side of them with a tiny baby squirrel size bite 😂

[@jenniferlawrence1372]

I LOVE orange coffee almost as much as peanut butter coffee.

[@MrShmoove69]

Is that the guy in this video who was the mechanic on the Star Wars hotel?

[@indigoblu624]

I love the banana bread cookie taste but I was not a fan of the walnuts.

[@jeffreyandacht4569]

I've eaten 8 by myself

[@justinmccarthy3464]

Quincy, you were my favorite creator... But Emma has stolen my heart. Glad she is part of the team.

[@colleenwins]

Sage!!! So excited to see him on here!

[@crystalrichards7504]

how do you join the vritual que for Gideon's? I believe I rememebr a previous video mentioning there was a virtual que but it is quick to fill up.

[@percythemighty]

You have to go to the store entrance. They only do them sometimes, on particularly busy days. You can’t join from elsewhere, you have to physically go to the store. Or you can go to their original store in Orlando and not wait in line at all.

[@kkarolsilva22]

Suggestion for the videos: activate the subtitle function in Portuguese (BR) 🙂

[@MicheleKlinger]

Now I just want cookies from a place I can’t get to lol

[@dionbrodeur1077]

Question for Sage.... Are you also not a fan of the underbaked cookie? As a pastry chef, I never really understood the reason people go crazy over under-baked cookies. I get that there is a gooey factor, but there is a better depth of flavor from the caramelization of the sugar and and satisfying snap of a crispy exterior and slightly softer center. If I can fold the cookie or dent my cookie clear to the bottom, I find it my stomach gets upset from the uncooked portion.

[@dionbrodeur1077]

I too found the cookies too be underwhelming and mainly BECAUSE of the texture and the excessive amount of toppings. The flavors profiles were good, but my stomach did not agree with the taste buds.

[@melissabell1444]

I’ve had most of these cookies before, I think they were scored a tad too low.

[@pennidud4932]

I adore Quincy! I like the energy that Sage brings. I'm working my way towards Emma. She has a different vibe.

[@KarenLopez0924]

I agree. I haven't been a big fan of Emma's but I am really liking Sage.

[@LisaWells34]

Did you like the Key Lime truffle? 💚

[@stacyscooby8488]

They are yummy 😋

[@AdamSTL-UNC]

MMMMMM😉

[@lovestodive1879]

Gonna go with a big nope for me dogg. I've heard that they are almost like they aren't totally cooked, there is way too much choc. chips on those so just no. I don't like cookie dough though so there is that.

[@MissMyMusicAddiction]

I have never had that experience with Gideons. I'm disappointed, because I might actually like the cookies even more if they were undercooked.

[@WalterRiggs]

There is no line worth buying a salted cookie. Any cookie in WDW is better than salt cookies from Gideons. IMO

[@Tommy-B.]

Artificial banana, cherry, strawberry, and grape are all better than the real thing.

[@yanshen5154]

First!

[@livella123]

Hi @sagestarkeytv 😊