Money and Scuba: Diving Economics From Three Perspectives

[@SeminoleScuba]

Great video James. "It is ok to make money in this industry!" Thank you... people seem to think we should work for free because we do what we love!

[@nosmosisprod]

It was a turning point in my diving when I discovered Diver’s Ready and then started training with you. It opened my eyes to good training (and I willingly opened my wallet) and learned a valuable lesson: You get what you pay for. Since then, I have invested in myself with other top tier instruction (also not cheap) and guess what, my confidence and skills as a diver have been remarkably impacted. Looking forward to Advanced Wreck, bud!

[@jassenjackman3284]

It’s been 2 years since I went pro and I’m still working on instructor certifications to teach the things I want to teach. I will say, the money I spent for a week with you bought me one of the best weeks of diving and learning I’ve done.

[@HarveyWall-r2j]

Hey James, love the show, great content. I watch from the UK and this was a great article. Since I assume your audience is global, it would be worth mentioning the club structure we have in the UK ie. BSAC. It's a great way of introducing younger and less financially able people to the sport of diving with training paths to high levels of recreational diving qualifications and beyond!

[@sidemountsarge]

BSAC is voluntary, somewhat different to the professional/for profit side of things.

[@diveguernsey6521]

@@sidemountsarge There are some great clubs, but some truly terrible ones too. I've seen some that train purely to help cover other costs in the club and for the "instructors" to sell off their old junk equipment. I put instructors as a quote because I've seen people that couldn't cut it on the local dive boats join the club and become instructors very soon after.

[@dre64]

James, you made my day!!! @3:45 "this individual used much more colorful language than that..." loooooooool.... I cannot stop laughing 🤣🤣🤣I love this British humour.

[@adampilot8275]

So happy that Jamsie quotes the full price INCLUDING the xtras in one lump sum. FAIR. Pity others can't do so.

[@adampilot8275]

With all the well presented technical knowledge passed onto others Jamsie always gives a humane perspective. Class bloke.

[@jamesaurich501]

Thank you James. I have been an instructor for 25 years and said the same things for a long time. Keep up the good work. Stay happy and healthy. SAFe Diving

[@jamesbenners9114]

Excellent explanation James!!! I wish I had known you back when I was becoming an open water scuba diver. Now a Master Diver, I’ve seen a lot of what you’re describing here. Sad state of our diving community. Please keep cranking out these informative expos’e of how things really are and hopefully as more of us wake up to what’s really happening, our hobby/careers in diving will change for the better. Thank you for your service to the diving community!

[@bloodymarvelous4790]

I think it's logical for the student to presume that a diving course is a diving course. So if that student sees one offered for $400 and one for $300, the question is not "Why is left out in the $300 course that's in the $400 course?", it's "Why are you charging $100 more than the other guy for the same thing?" It's up to the instructor charging more to explain why his course is so much more expensive. I agree with your explanations, but it's not something you can assume an upcoming diver to know. Your course description should explain the price of your course if it's substantially higher than competing courses.

[@diveguernsey6521]

Many students also think that the instructor works for the agency,.

[@ignacioa6401]

James, this is a great video! Thank you for your passion for the sport and the scuba community. Your video 100% resonates with my experiences.

[@albertendler2038]

Diving instruction should never be a place to skimp on cost. I did my research and found the instructor with the best reputation from the local dive community and waited for an opening in his class.

[@Ducky27645]

As a skydiver, I can fully respect this video. Btw, sharing parachutes is a thing. Lol… FAR more expensive than scuba which is why I don’t jump anymore unless it’s off a boat and wearing scuba equipment.

[@mgancarzjr]

$2k plus just to get licensed. Then you gotta jump regularly just to stay current. Never a drop zone in your back yard, either.

[@Ducky27645]

@@mgancarzjr amen brother! I remember the good ol’ days when jumping out of a twin otter was the norm at $20 and up to 14K. Every DZ I’ve spoken to lately only rocks a C182 and the price has gone up and the jump altitude down! Bring on the ocean and dive gear!

[@mgancarzjr]

@@Ducky27645 one of my most treasured memories is hanging half outside of a Twin Otter wondering where I'm supposed to hold onto.

[@diveguernsey6521]

I've just started cycling again. Ideally i'd have a DH bike 7k, XC bike 5k, Hardtail, 2k Emtb 6k, Gravel bike 5k and road bike 5k. So that's 30k and another 10k to fit out my workshop to store and maintain the bikes.

[@Ducky27645]

@@diveguernsey6521 Sounds like you’re splurging on top of the line gear and can afford to cut some costs there. My old XC Specialized was about $2k and that was a very capable bike. And if this has become a dick measuring competition, don’t get me started on aviation. Lol… That’s the ultimate expensive hobby!

[@karolinabaltrusaityte2546]

Thank you, James, for great video! Everything you said so true as an instructor myself, I can't believe how much dive shops are willing to compromise on quality and safety just to get a price down. It's absolute madness. This sport is expensive, and for a reason, it should not be at the expense of an instructor wages or people's safety.

[@patrickcarnathan5862]

As a new instructor I am learning the ropes with a Dive shop. I am adding more then the minimum to my teachings, (IE: DSMB deployment at depth, Gear, Better weighting, good boyoncy etc.) discussing saftey etc. Since I have a full time carrer in another industry I am happy (at this time) to learn from other instructors. After I beleive I have the experience to be a good instructor then I will venture out, build my brand and become more of a "Private" instructor teaching saftey, skills etc so I do not see divers running on reefs in Cozumel. (Yes, taking fins off, video and actully running in boots on the reef) Thanks James for all the great content.

[@alexanderfoster3628]

I wish I'd had an instructor like you. I had an instructor for my OW who didn't even want to do the minimum let alone extra, when it came to verifying skills in OW after the doing the pool dives he told us he couldn't be bothered and we only ended up doing half. Someone died at the centre 8 months later and multiple HSE violations were found. I paid an instructor at a different dive centre to go through everything with me again and it made such a world of difference.

[@timgosling6189]

A refreshing attitude. The results of the 'race to the bottom' are to be seen everywhere and you can almost feel the holes in the swiss cheese jostling to line up.

[@0nBe1ay]

I love this video! Accurate and honest.

[@DiversReady]

Top Dog forever!

[@fredesch5133]

As a recently certified OW diver, I looked at all 3 of my local dive shops before picking one for training. The cost differential didn't factor into which I chose. I chose the one that I felt most comfortable with and happened to be closest to my house. Their policy of if someone signs up for a course on a certain date, you get the course regardless of whether anyone else signs up also impressed me. I signed up and I guess because the course started the week after (Daytona's) Bike week, I was the only student and got private lessons. Diving is expensive but addicting.

[@micheleporter6199]

I absolutely love that you charge more money for better quality dive training. I got PADI certified last year and I was absolutely terrified, but my husband had gotten certified the previous year, loved it so much and really wanted it to be something we could do together -- I ended up having to pay extra for an additional night one-on-one in the pool with the instructor before going to take my tests. Just having that ONE night helped me so much. I wouldn't have passed otherwise.

[@safelander7811]

Your section on instructor economics blew my mind, as someone who fell victim to the utter circus of rotating new-instructor-to-dropout, this resonates with me so much, and is something I suspected was happening all along for a few years after. As someone passionate about sharing knowledge of things I care about I always figured I would become an instructor, but as so many find out, couldn't sustain the lifestyle. It's a real shame that the mainstream way of building a career in this industry is unsustainable for the vast majority. There are ways around this, such as mentorship schemes like the one you mentioned which sound fantastic, hats off to you! However it seems that this is the minority of cases... Great video as always, thank you for speaking up about a topic that is rarely discussed in the open.

[@markgrohman3014]

James,As Instructor I myself train beyond the standards.I choose this and my return student for more training reflects this.I know Instructors that have put students in dive chambers and just push out numbers .I would never become one if these Instructors and I agree you want to receive quality Instructor time there is a cost involved.Keep up the good work Thanks Mark.

[@angie12039]

I am an instructor for 3 years now. And I am totally with you. Creating safe and experienced divers. I am lucky in the center I work, that many divers come back to learn more and do a career from Open Water to Divemaster or even Instructor. So we have an eye on them and teach them every time, they are with us to become better.

[@grene1955]

Right on point! I am retired from a global company with technical products. We NEVER sold on price! We sold on quality and support. I used to tell the distributors I was training, that if they went into a pitch meeting with nothing but price, they've already lost. Not that price is unimportant, but if that's all you have to beat the competition, you are in big trouble. I want to have customers who buy because they know they are getting top tier products, and I will do everything in my power to help them be successful.

[@CritterHunter]

"diving is expensive"... Coming from someone opening my own shop, thats an understatement. Also i see big upsides to being a sdi facility and flexible teaching tactics.

[@diveguernsey6521]

I'm not sure it really is anymore. I see lots of people spend far more on say an ebike to ride to the pub a few times a year. Much of the equipment prices have not risen with inflation in the 25 years i've been in the industry. Reg 3-400, bcd 2-300, Cyinder 180, computer 300, mask 50, Fins 75. These are not much different from early 2000's prices. Just think how much people spend on a mobile phone these days.

[@diveguernsey6521]

Also worth checking out SSI for Rec. Depending on where you are. In the UK they are great to deal with.

[@gigiandthesea]

Thank you, thank you, thank you! As an instructor I ask prospective students, who are looking for the cheapest price, if they want to be qualified or just certified. I do not want to certify students; I want them to be qualified. Therefore, I am not the cheapest nor the quickest instructor in regards to any training.

[@phrankster909]

When I did my open water last year I had a look at what I was spending and how much I got. When you look at the pool sessions, open water dives and the cost of equipment you borrow I reached the conclusion it was exceptional value for money. I'm not convinced anyone is making much from diving (outside of maybe Mares or Suunto), they're doing it for the love of the sport. I feel it's important that we keep supporting the industry and getting more people into diving as it's for our benefit too. It's expensive compared to running or tennis. But then, no one dies from tennis because they didn't get their racquet serviced.

[@diveguernsey6521]

The big companies are struggling too, just look at Apeks / Aqualung. It's rare to see such a fall from grace. One big exception is Shearwater, I think because they maintain pricing to keep everyone happy. You mention Suunto, at one point in the early 2000's they had a huge market share, perhaps 90%. They thought they were invincible and cut dealer margins to near 0 and put out a bad product. These days, i bet they are lucky to have 25% share and that's decreasing all the time as Garmin take over the watch market.

[@josepablomir]

I totally agree. It's true; these "cheap-and-fast McDive" centers and instructors (I didn't invent this term, but I love it!) drive prices down. But it's in us to offer the services we believe customers deserve and need. Going above and beyond is not just a market differentiator for our offer but also a necessity due to the nature of our sport.

[@christianbanholzer5612]

You speak out of my heart and I'm only an ambitious diver (no plans at all to go professional) Quality of the training and trust in the trainer is so important! And so as you said very well...nothing is for free, why would it be? 😅

[@bluefish4999]

I got lucky when I got certified, my instructor I met through my neighbor had dived since the 70s, he came to my pool with all the gear and let me make payments, he also sold me most of my 1st time gear(had to deal with a oversized BCD for 150 dives but it was brand new), I went through OW and Advanced pretty quick, I was also living in Lauderdale by the Sea and had shore diving and we did lots of deep wrecks, I got to dive with my instructor well after my courses were done and all the experienced divers around me, I still dive with him sometimes all these years later. It was way cheaper back then for courses and equipment, I'm a Dive Master but have never worked in the industry, that may change before I get too old to do it.

[@Ice_Diver_Ed]

Ok. I’ve been a diver 25+ years, a dive master 22+ years, and a Master Diver 20+ years. I’ve got well over 500 dives with single tank, double tank’s, quad tank’s, and rebreathers. And this is simply the best answer I’ve ever heard.

[@PelagicExile]

Not thinking too hard about it (or looking it up), I would guess your kit cost around 3000 +/- 250 USD if bought new right now. 800-1100 regs 600-800 bcd 180 fins 120 mask 250 light 120 dSMB/reel 400 wetsuit 150 booties 150 wetnotes/whatever is in that pouch Edit....forgot the Perdix....add 1000 so around 4000 USD Second edit after the video....I was not expecting to be that close on the aggregate cost

[@cyklopPL]

You sound very reasonable. Hope more people will approach it in such way

[@solvenprepper6906]

My dive shop offered a small discount for being around the first of March which is the off season. My dive buddy and I work together and did our research plus homework and had our instructor to comment on what we found. We really put our hearts into learning the safest approach to diving. It was the divers ready video on " Nitrox is for everybody " that prompted us to pay the extra for the course. Since our certification, we have noticed some bad habits from other divers. Having a QUALITY dive instructor for a safety net was well worth the money as my instructor was far from a minimalist. The point is, If I'm paying quality money for an instructor then I will go the extra mile to do my part to pick his brain.

[@stevewarren6608]

Really insightful talk, James.

[@TheSilentWonder]

That's why I joined a BSAC club (British Sub Aqua Club) . I got quoted one price which included everything from the course to the club membership and equipment use. They're not interested in student turnover and quick profit (it's a non-profit club anyway) but rather experience and community and diver safety. Unless there's a specific skill or course I want, I will never train through a commercial agency!

[@t-ime]

in my country, a lot of them are pushing sales. when i started diving, the most asked question was what i do for a living, because there were many people curious where/how i have the money to dive, and trying to see how much they can upsell.

[@nickargent23]

"Race to the bottom" just reminds me of Koh Tao.

[@saschaganser9671]

Such a good video! People underestimate what a hard job the diving industry is and how difficult it is to make a living from it. Many instructors stop after a few years and change career. Good coaches cost money.

[@farbeyonddriven8173]

Feel fortunate that even though i'm in central PA we have a well entrenched "loaded with experience" dive shop not too far away.

[@DavidRakeck]

Loved the video, flight training is similar. Most flight instructors only work for about 1-2 years, and by the time they become great instructors they leave to go to the airlines. Its a perpetual cycle that would be difficult to change.

[@billhazel4476]

Great video as always James and I learned more about my passionate sport.

[@salpaturzo3126]

$3,200 - $3,500. As a recreational diver I purchased my equipment one piece at a time, because of expense, and it would add up to be about the same.

[@baginthewind4501]

I don't think scuba has to be as expensive as most people make it. I bought my initial set of gear for

[@kurttidd8922]

As a recent graduate of James’ Advanced Nitrox/Deco Procedures course, I can assure anyone contemplating signing up for any of his courses that with James you get WAY more than you are paying for. Yes, it costs money, but it is without question the best value-for-training program I have received (and I have professional dive certifications from three of the largest certification agencies). If you want to engage one-on-one with a knowledgable, experienced, and genuinely FUN professional, save up your money and get on James’ schedule. I am a FAR better diver and dive professional for having spent the time with James.

[@akumabito2008]

A very important topic, that gets far too little attention! Thanks for sharing your insights.

[@Juror63]

THANK YOU!!! For explaining what was a SERIOUS head scratcher for me! Now the turnover makes since. It's a shame though. 🥴

[@whaleshark2625]

$3,200 would be my guess for your OC Rec setup (can't see if your Perdix is there but I'm guessing yes). Also can't see if you've got an AI transmitter on the first stage. Edit after watching - guessing I was low on the regs, wetsuit and BPW.

[@Will-ol9lp]

I understand that we are going through tough times. None saying that my wife and I agree with you James. People will always make a way for what they want. Here’s to the email guy. Maybe he should have said if I gave you 2/3 down can we work out a payment plan. Some people will never learn. Keep the great content coming. Someday I would like to dive with you Dive safe y’all Will 12:11

[@coreybaldwin5593]

Always great videos👌👌

[@DiveandLearn]

This is one of my favorites this year!

[@Raybrienza]

James, Great topic. I have been a pro since 1984 (SSI) and 1992 (TDI/SDI). For the most part, I have been a part time Instructor in Colorado USA. I did manage a dive shop for 3 years (the owner was using me as bait to sell it from under me - another long story). As I was listening to your video - I was thinking that I have seen around 125 - 150 instructors and many of them stayed teaching on average 6 years. The current shop that I am at we have around 35 instructors we have a group of about 15 instructors with 20+years and 20 instructor at the below 5 -7 years. The fees I have to pay (dues, insurance, Dan membership, other certifications (equipment service, PCI, .... ) is about $2000/year. For me an average set of gear runs about $4000 - 5000. no tec gear. I am in the process of rebuilding my tech gear I expect to pay around 10,000 + (not rebreather) not including getting my certs back - going slow.

[@DiversReady]

Thanks for sharing Ray! That all sounds about right! Impressed that you got to work with and retain such an experienced crew. Are the 20+ year-Instructors full time teaching/have no other source of income?

[@Raybrienza]

@@DiversReady James ... The 20+ year instructors most are not full time, kind of, They are retired from other careers (Firefighters, legal, Medical, and others ) Im technically part-time as I am a Realtor (or I pretend to do that full-time) , I do spend 30+ hrs at the DS most weeks). We do run 18+ trips a year to destinations around the globe. (British Columbia to Egypt to Asia and the Caribbean) all from Colorado USA. (Interesting fact, Colorado has the highest number of divers per capita in the country - There are more snow skiers per capita in Florida then there are here) (Very little diving done in Colorado, I do Dive here)

[@Guru_Swami]

I would happily pay a fair amount for an instructor that I click with and is actually invested in my training being meaningful and adjusts the training to my personal needs and skill level. Throw in some good nuggets of knowledge and make the training fun and all inclusive, as in just be up front with what is and is not included and not only will I leave a good tip, I’ll sing your praises and send more people your way!

[@SCT15H_07]

I've often wondered if dive gear is priced high due to the percentage rate of people willing to take it up and stick with it resulting in the brands needing to make their money off a smaller number of people. But if gear was cheaper would the amount of people taking diving up increase 🤔. I imagine there is a high profit margin on dive gear compared to cost of manufacture

[@Juror63]

NEXT "mouthpiece Monday" topic!! You've got us wondering Mr. James!

[@bloodymarvelous4790]

To be fair, James does invest in quality. It may not be top of the line, but it's stuff that's reliable and hard wearing. That's something you do pay for. You can put together a dive setup that's half that price, but it's stuff that either won't grow with you, or won't last. You can get a single tank tropical regulator set for $300~$350, or you can get an $800 set that can do tropical and cold water diving, single tank, twins, and sidemount configurations. Likewise, you can get a BCD for $300 that will serve for the occasional recreational dive, or you can get a BPW for $900 which can stand year round heavy use. You get what you pay for. If occasional warm water diving is what you're looking for, you don't need to get anywhere near $4000 in gear. You can get a full setup for about $1500. If you go the used route, you can even go much cheaper (but beware who you're buying from).

[@christophercarder1828]

My LDS owner has a saying, the profit margin is always better when he sells his gear the second time

[@wineweasel]

I think what deters people is PADI charging so much for an online course which should basically be free as they don't even provide a Text book want people to get verified make the online bit free and charge semble rates for the rest of the course

[@WindwardToEden]

I really need to get into scuba…wish I had the money. Hopefully one day!

[@rickdeckard7926]

I skydive (wingsuit), Paraglide, mountain climb, scuba dive, whitewater kayak, and ski (snow & water), also play tennis. You are correct, tennis is cheaper even with 5 rackets and private club membership.

[@jeffreymassetti2602]

Our 3 most senior instructors have a combined teaching experience of about 100 years, I guess that's good. Our team probably averages 8-10 years but we are in need of younger folks of which some are in training. Funny the oldest instructors seem to do the most training.

[@UpTheClock]

Very similar to the photography industry...many people are way under charging their packages and wondering why they are struggling financially and also burning out.

[@praveenbk21]

Yeah , As a instructor I totally agree with you. Nowadays students are realizing the quality of teaching and instructor value.They don't mind to pay little more premium to get premium service.

[@ramytk1]

James made a video a while back about picking an instructor. I was blessed and found an incredible dive shop where I live in North Texas. Most things I do through them (including my DM program). However, for Tech Diving I am doing all that through James. Will it cost me more, absolutely. Is it worth it for the one on one instruction? Hell yes. Each person has to decide what’s right for them in an instructor/ mentor. Watch that video. Great tip in there. James, if you can is there a way to link that video in the description of this one? Might be helpful for some. See you in two weeks man! And keep the weather good this time! 🤣

[@seanharrison8284]

James, good video with a lot of valuable content. Sorry I’m six months late to watch this, life gets busy. Most of the economics are pretty accurate and certainly you have made a solid point that people need to know their worth and charge for it. You also make a valid, and well proven, point cost equates to quality…most of the time. At the end of the day, it is each individual’s decision - what kind of customer do you want and what kind of customer do you want to be. That decision does have a ripple effect on the rest of the industry. A marketing slogan I stole from Shoei (helmet manufacture) “if you have a $99 head, buy a $99 helmet”. I would like to know where you got your “agency” data? You grouped 200+ agencies into one set of initial and annual dollar figures, that’s the bit that is not accurate. At least from my perspective. Keep putting out the great videos, I enjoy watching them!

[@danosyanturio5998]

It's also interesting how the prices differs between different countries. I just made my OWD in the Philippines for around 300€ I was the only student and it was a very good instructor (a Korean) And it wasn't the cheapest course in this region. I'm wondering how they payed the equipment

[@cosak691985]

Great video and well said.

[@cblaster171]

Of course you have the viewpoint that is in your best interests. Many do.

[@jmurphy644]

Great observations all around

[@ABCDiver]

This was my mindset as a brand new OW student: dive shop X charges $300 for the entire OW course, dive shop Y charges $400. I knew nothing about scuba and my only information was the price and the card that I would get at the end; so the "product" in my mind was that card, and if it's the same in either case, then I should go with the cheaper shop. Obviously it was ignorance (and some stupidity) on my part. I still would've preferred if the $400 dive shop explained to me about the safety aspect, the skills involved, importance of a good instructor etc., I probably would've gone with them instead.

[@CuradoIago]

Thanks, highly enlightening content

[@gmancolo]

It's all relative. SCUBA seems more expensive than rock climbing, kayaking, skiing, etc., but less expensive than flying, boating, etc. I've talked to many highly educated and skilled SCUBA divers and they routinely say that choosing an instructor is much more important than specific agency affiliation (though many seem to prefer SDI/TDI). I got into SCUBA for fun and to see cool stuff and locales. It does seem like a lot of new instructors are being churned out, with a fair amount of turnover, and generally it seems like a fairly low-paying job similar to other recreational jobs.

[@wanderingfinds2268]

YES! I went out of my way to find a good center with a strict instructor for both my OW and AOW and i feel much more confident/safe in the water. Ive seen so many other centers passing people who dont show the required skills and become "someone elses problem"

[@JohnS-er7jh]

I totally agree with your perspective, when people complain about cost, my attitude is, just go do something else. If you cannot afford scuba diving, try snorkeling. I REALLY enjoy snorkeling. I find it so relaxing and fun, once I get going I don't want to stop. As far as 'discount' intrucstion schools, that is why for things that relate to public safety you need laws and regulatory governing bodies to regulate the market providers, so they have to set a minimum standard (including pricing, to discourage discount services).

[@MorganDaly]

Great video!

[@geemac44]

Hi James, I totally agree your comments and concerns regarding the quality of OW instruction in today’s cut throat market. I’ve only been diving since 2004 and when I reflect upon the training methodology used to gain certification, I find it to have been over-priced and lacking in instructor quality and quantity of knowledge gained for OW certification. I’ll step up to be corrected if my thoughts on restructuring OW certification are ridiculous and fanciful. OW Certification should 1. include repetition, repetition and repetition by teaching the basics of diving ie equipment preparation - gear on gear off in and out of a pool or shallow water, basic safety skills to regain your dislodged regulator and/or mask and/or fin after breaking a strap, what is buoyancy and trim. How to prepare and obtain perfect buoyancy and trim. Teaching the in water basics repetitively, in conjunction with pre and/or after dive session classroom sessions to gain an understanding of Boyles Law, Archimedes Theory, the law of thirds, safety stops, etc to understand the practical application of knowledge through repetition 2. Have a minimum of 10 mixed OW dives ie shore dives, boat dives and jump water entry from a jetty or similar elevated platform at depths to say 20m max with 3 mins/5m safety stops (2-3 days) 3. Nitrox or EAN theoretical and practical training in the benefits of mixed gas diving with a minimum 15 dives (3-5 days) to 30m with the 3 min/5m safety stops, and 4. Diver Rescue & Navigation including classroom theory (CPR & 1st Responder training) and repetitive in-water practical scenarios including navigation and SMB deployment which could be red/orange for emergency and green/yellow for diver safety stop and boat rendezvous. Either or can be agreed with the boat skipper, DM and divers in the pre dive meeting and checklist. A minimum of 10-15 variable depth and location depths should apply along with CPR and First Aid Certification for a (revised) full OW accreditation. Having this certification has enabled me to help one injured diver, nothing of concern, just a puncture wound below the knee with bleeding and pain, but an effective minor rescue that has given me greater awareness, confidence and a calm reactive mindset during every dive. My dive buddies are happy knowing there’s at least one Rescue diver in our dive group. I can feel the naysayer prepping their negative responses already, but I ask this question, “Would you prefer to help an injured or distressed diver back to safety or just hover in hope that someone else steps up?” I can personally assure you that a thank you and a smile from an injured diver is priceless. Having full OW- Rescue & Navigation Accreditation is worth the investment and time in gaining the underwater and classroom experience that gives an OW Diver confidence towards the practical application of knowledge. After all, a 5-dive OW certificate might be a quick buck for a dive operator but how confident do you and/or your dive buddy feel at your next shore or boat dive, after the reality of rushed training and a handful of dives make you feel…Overwhelmed combined with self-doubt are two factors that spring to mind. Been there, and felt like that and with hindsight, I would have welcomed and no doubt enjoyed an extended OW training program as proposed. Looking forward to spending more bottom time with everyone again soon. Enjoy!🤿😀

[@nomadicstrength]

Never have I clicked on one of your videos so fast

[@barryinkpen6026]

Well said on all accounts! When I hear folks say "scuba is expensive!"; I ask, "how much is a motorcycle, an ATV, a snowmobile, a SeaDoo etc?"

[@bloodymarvelous4790]

But that makes no sense. Last time I checked my scuba gear wasn't engine powered.

[@barryinkpen6026]

@@bloodymarvelous4790 Hahahaha!!

[@johnmontgomery2735]

Great video James

[@ianyapxw]

How would you go about choosing a good instructor/school? I don't like in Florida but I'm keen to know more, not just for OW but for AOW, tech, etc...

[@johnwilliamsscuba6487]

When you have been around diving as long as I have, you see business models change. I don't like the way the industry is structured.

[@Mindysadventures]

I agree you get what you pay for. Thank you for not being average or below. We need higher standards

[@Captainwill55]

Got cerftified when i was about 15 yrs old , and had a blast , very wonderful experience private lesson , came out super confident but you are right , nowadays its crazy , seems like you cant get a proper school , the good one all shut down because of covid or they got crushed by the cheap ass competition that offers rediculously short and fast amd cheap quality-less training ! Its just about pumping students and it makes me cringe about our beautiful sport 😞

[@JPINFV]

I think the catch 22 for the basic training series (OW ->Rescue) is that it's hard to tell quality from norm from trash as someone entering the sport and it's hard to tell how much quality from norm really matters. If an open water course costs $300 more than the standard, for example, how can someone new tell that it's worth $300 more? Furthermore, is the higher quality worth the cost? This is like cattle boat dive companies. I can dive with one of the Miami cattle boat companies for $158 (2 tank, shallow water, with BCD and reg rental with group guide). I can drive down to Key Largo and the McDonalds of diving (the one you had a bad drift dive experience with), get the same deal for $129, except have more options on locations since they have more boats. Is Miami cattle car worth $30 more than Key Largo cattle company? Now once people start getting more towards the tec side from the basic open water side, quality becomes a much higher consideration in my mind.

[@doreenhuwe9815]

Totally like your approach re training and pricing. Not to push the prices down !!! TOP !!! Anyhow - Why does all the customers want to pay less and get cheap prices, but receive high quality? this is not in a balanced relation. But its a big problem in this industry. dive equipment costs a lot of money, and instructors and guides, required such a high quality eduction which costs a lot of money too, but dive centers does not want to pay much salary, and as instructor one has to have all the equipment themself, which is fair enough, but no fair salaries are paid in the diving industry, although as an instructor one has to take full responsibility, has to have a good dive insurance, and take care of human lives to the highest extend and provide safety, but its not reflected in the salary nor the diving fees. This industry needs to be cleaned up in relation to pricing !!! for the service we all provide as Instructor. I mean even to become better qualified as an instructor it does cost a lot of money. It's not easy to live a normal decent life on diving industry jobs.

[@RNAvirus]

Passed my advanced open water a couple days ago, while in Jamaica. I'll stick to my nursing career, maybe instruct in retirement. But the slave year you must do as an assistant, to the, instructor is not something I'd do.

[@MikeR_DiveR]

James - we are entering an alien environment on life support equipment every time we dive. It’s not elitist. It’s just your life. Here’s to training confident, comfortable, qualified divers!

[@j.r.shartzer]

My guess on the price of your equipment setup was a little over double what it really was. Scuba always seemed cost prohibitive to me but this video is actually encouraging, I can reasonably save up $5,000. I'm trying to figure out the logistics of being able to train. I live on an island in the US pacific north west with many popular diving spots all around me, but the only real instructor here doesn’t have a great reputation, so, although I live 10 minutes from great diving locations, I'm not getting in properly untrained and that'll probably require time off work (which is impossible) and blah. Some day.

[@wineweasel]

I think you should do a follow up.on this video I'm off to Turkey and was planning on a recreational dive the resort I'm going to has 3 dive centers according to Google but it prob has many more in the UK I pay around £30 a dive at local dive center more if it more than 15 miles offshore now I have contacted the 3 dive centers and the cost vary wildly even though they are all offering the same thing £160 £120 and £50 for 2 dives thinking they prob price high knowing you'll likely knock them down I tried negotiating a better price got them down to £120 £100 and £50 considering I pay £30 for a dive in UK I would expect turkey to be around £60 or slightly cheaper for two dives as the wages are less in Turkey

[@dominiquegingras7334]

You are not wrong, but one thing you haven’t thought trough, is that the certifying agencies prefer the recurring fees over the newer instructors. The logic behind it is there is barely any cost to keep them as opposed to certifying new instructors. The logic behind recurring fees, is to get money for not much work. When you certify new instructors, the whole company structure is used. There is a IE that needs to travel, stay in hotels, eat, and entertain. It also involves the complete corporate infrastructure and other employees. Something a recurring fee does not use much. so the reality is, the recurring fee has a much higher net value or profit.

[@diveguernsey6521]

I've made diving a proper career in a local dive center with minimal tourism and therefore local divers.. I learnt to dive at 12, before you could at that age. We acquired the dive center when I was 14 as a family business and completed me OW at 15. Started working full-time at 16, DM as soon as I was 18 and OWSI that same year. Technician and Adv Nitrox instructor in my early 20's. I took over the running of the center in my early 30's and became a Tmx instructor before taking over ownership in my mid 30's. I've just turned 40 and i'm 9 months post heart attack and unable to work or do much else. Basically I've given my life to this industry 7 days a week, literally 365 days a year. For my trouble, i earnt about 1/2 minimum wage for working 2x - 3x the hours. In an effort to survive, i've been selling stock on ebay. Just today i've had one guy claim that the new liftbag i sold him has a 2" cut in the top and another that offered 25% of the listed price and then sent me an abusive message when I declined it! The price is already good as i'm selling at a discount to move the stock working on pre-covid prices, which have seen a roughly 20% increase. The industry needs to change, or there likely won't be much of one.

[@psychotimo]

I mean, I do agree with dive training needing to be high quality, but economics is also a thing. and sure lowering the price will most often lower what's included it, full agree as well. But for most peeps: if 2 shops offer the same service (on paper) for a different price, it's common sense to go for the cheaper one. unless you justify why your price is higher, it might just be like a fashion thing like "we're {insert generic fashion brand} so you'll have to pay us 1K extra just for the prestige we bring". which is something a lot of people don't care about. so yeah, you shouldn't need to, but having a good explanation that justifies why your training is more expensive is a big thing. If you show 2 identical looking items and just tell peeps that one is 100bucks more expensive, and they can't see why, then obvi they're going for the cheaper one. sure, some people would pay extra cause 'the pope spit on it' or 'elvis looked at it', but a lot of peeps won't. So as far as we know, the more expensive dive shop is charging extra cause it's built around a toilet where jacques cousteau once had a massive sh*t, but that doesn't make the training any better.

[@wildsurfer12]

Can’t decide what’s more expensive, scuba diving or tennis!

[@nomadicplanet1158]

You should talk about how a lot of dive shops will not rent tanks and weights to properly certified divers without them paying for the dm to lead you. Dive shops over regulate padi & ssi certification to scam the divers out of money they don't want to spend & just want to do their own thing without the pricy dm to lead them

[@DamonBates]

You talk about volume turnover of instructors but not volume or economics of students. That would be interesting; your way vs. group instruction...which, dare I say, is the way most of us learned. I've DM'd for a well established (30 years) shop in the Boston area for 5 years ...and Im the new guy. Most of our instructors are 10 and 20 year vets. We certify a LOT of divers but there is no way we could do that by turning over instructors all the time. That would create chaos. Im not aware of any other shop in the area that does that either.

[@sacuW9ep]

If you think SCUBA is expensive, try getting a pilot’s license.

[@JPINFV]

@S. M. I think that's underselling it. Instructor time is 1:1. There isn't 5 student pilots building time in the same plane at the same time with 1 instructor. Aviation fuel is more expensive. Insurance is more expensive. Maintenance on the plane is more expensive and undiluted (an hour of engine time is an hour of engine time, regardless of if it's a boat or plane... but that boat is going to spread out the hour across more people). The training time is also longer.

[@Mistdragon_offical]

Yea

[@jacobkessinger2619]

Facts. I have a tens of thousands of dollars peace of plastic in my wallet

[@SimonAmazingClarke]

Cost verses safety, I am going to go into an environment that can kill me, easily. How good of an instructor would I like to have?

[@safelander7811]

I would love it if this video could be shown to all those agency representatives out there (course directors and such) who proudly tout how many instructors they've certified in the last year blah blah blah as if they're doing the scuba industry a favour.... What a world we live in.

[@robertfunabashi]

Curious to know your thoughts on where the casual or part time dive instructor fits in. Many of us happily teach on the side of a more lucrative day job for little or no payment simply because we love the sport and are passionate about providing quality instruction. Indeed, many of the best instructors and DMs I have encountered have been volunteers. However, working for free undoubtedly has the potential to facilitate a race to the bottom from more career oriented colleagues. Curious to know whether you think these practices help or hinder the quality of instruction in the industry overall.

[@diveguernsey6521]

Dpes it happen in any other industry? If the money was proportional to other industry in the area then it could flow through and everyone would be happy. The DC is happy with free labour of course now because it has to, but it;s really difficult to work with volunteers because it's harder to rely on them. I'm not saying they are unreliable per-se, but it's certainly more difficult to offer a professional service/

[@abibstopherwilliam]

I've been an instructor for just over a year. The best job I've had so far didn't involve teaching at all-it was guiding snorkelling tours but they wanted dive instructors for their experience and comfort in the water. The pay was good and the hours and conditions weren't total bullshit. I'm currently working for a fast food-style training centre where the OW course lasts 2 days and costs under US$200. We are actively discouraged from taking over 90 minutes to conduct the confined water session and I have colleagues who 'finish' their sessions in 30-40 mins; nowhere near long enough to teach people skills with mastery. I try to add better value and then get complaints from my colleagues for taking too long and earfuls from my managers for wasting time. The conditions are alright and the pay is ok (it's a first-world country with employment laws) but I know that I am not training people to the standard that I can train with sufficient time and attention. The whole business model is built around sucking people in with a cheap price and then selling them a package to get up to instructor or Divemaster without any care as to whether they're good divers or would make good dive professionals. My main fear is, however, that if I leave this job and go somewhere where more time is taken and attention paid, the salary and working conditions are likely to be way worse. The dive instructor 'lifestyle' is appealing but at the same time in those places where it exists, it is almost impossible to save for the future-a house, a car, a family etc. So you're left choosing between those jobs that pay alright but are usually crap and those jobs that muight be more fun but don't pay. We'd keep more people in the industry if dive shop owners and managers didn't treat staff like crap...

[@diveguernsey6521]

Courses can be literally pyramid selling. "Just a bit more and you can be"

[@peterjulianphotos4659]

Hey James, definitely not an instructor BUT, earned my C-Card back when dinosaurs roamed the planet. Firstly nothing has changed since aforementioned dinosaur experience - it's still a race to the bottom, and to place it in context my C-Card was validated in 1987 and it cost me $299 to complete the Open Water course (of a now defunct agency) and today in 2023 find LDS's who offer courses at $450 and less (like that''s half the inflation rate). Admittedly my dive course comprised of 10 dives of which 6 had to be open water greater that 10 metres and my 'school time' was about 30 hours over about 10 weeks, so I still dive with my FAUI C-Card which draws laughs from Instructor Candidates - but I can still run rings around them when it comes to understanding Boyle's, Charles's and Guy Lussac's laws. I've never been bent (touch wood), I've never run out of air, I've never exceeded my no deco limits (without a computer) and while my gas consumption isn't as sharp as it used to be, I still think I'm safer than 50% of divers. One day I'd love to drop by, do some awesome dives and then relax with a quiet ale, pale ale or lager. Keep up the good and honest work.

[@westonraynak4331]

Hello, I’m interested in becoming a dive instructor and I’ve been trying to figure out the best way to do this-it looks like you have things figured out pretty good. I got my PADI Openwater and everything you discuss here rings true, any advice for someone just graduating and wanting to make this a career?

[@knightclan4]

this is the way

[@stevetazphoto]

I’m $5000 in debt as a recreational diver and I still need a $2000 dry suit before I can continue. Haven’t dived since I decided to prioritize my finances and pay off the debt it’s been 6 months…

[@miksveltmanis4427]

For the guess at 3:00 - Anywhere between $2000 - 3000

[@dalerichardson8842]

I've never understood this race to the bottom James. Any sane person should want the best training possible and I would always prefer to pay for that level of training where you feel safe and happy and you get the most out of what you are learning. Learning with a good quality experienced instructor is actually better value pound for pound. Why would you scrimp on your training and put your life at risk !