Do old FNF mods hold up in 2024? (Going back and reviewing old Friday night funkin' mods)

[@anyseasonlogic]

If you want to join my discord its discord.gg/a2RdzekTQ3 Its not much right now but it will be when i get the time

[@Kiri..]

fun fact kapi is literally just a cat not a furry don't know how he stands on 2 legs though

[@gabrielnavia-d3m]

0:25 true

[@GenayRuiz]

Fun fact during zavodila Ruv's microphone is not plugged in that's just his natural voice

[@TLEvilMel]

I’m still in shock at just how low all the charting scores were. Especially for the easier songs and the better mapped ones (Genocide+Tricky) and I truly believe that both versions of the recharted ballistic hold up to no more than a 6😭

[@sufferdude0537]

I really wish yall did nyaw for kapi, cause it's my favorite fnf song

[@slimjim4361]

"Tight bars little man" That alone shook the community for like a year

[@giganticmoon]

how?

[@Norrabal]

@@giganticmoon There wasn't a lot of voice acting or cinematics in mods, that was the first time it happened, and many people at the time were compelled by his narrative.

[@giganticmoon]

@@Norrabal OHH SNAP I FORGOT was just playing the mod yesterday.

[@epicnightmare5600]

And i think he was the only one who showed care for bf mid mod through dialogue​@@giganticmoon

[@GamerEbs1143]

Nice Pfp and True (I know where it's from.)

[@chriskoloski32]

According to FNF lore. Boyfriend and girlfriend are literally too stupid to realize how much danger they're in until the last possible moments.

[@vanished8732]

Explains alot.

[@chriskoloski32]

​@@vanished8732yeah. There's even stuff like Girlfriend us smart enough to do taxes, but she'll get her hand stuck in a peanut butter jar she will sit and wait for hours for help

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

​@@vanished8732 agreed

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I pretty much knew about it from the dev.

[@wingedbluj1674]

That combined with Boyfriend's inhuman confidence and Girlfriend's blind trust in him explains why canonically they're fearless... except thunder. They both hate thunder despite facing WAY worse.

[@RoachyTheRoached]

A fun fact that makes me like even more Zavodila. Ruv, the guy himself, it’s singing with the microphone disconnected, and still makes the whole church shake

[@SubToGWSPRO7372]

I remember a 3 year old song that was just insanity and if Ruv had his Mic on

[@Yes-im-thatguy]

What off!?

[@RoachyTheRoached]

@@Yes-im-thatguy the mic

[@SubToGWSPRO7372]

@@Yes-im-thatguy Ruv's from Mid fight Masses' mic is off, yet the place shakes, so if it were to be on... the place gon' collapse

[@PlushiePirate]

Too bad the songs have ass charting and try too hard to be difficult

[@JustaClassicOrangeFox]

To me, older FNF mods will always still matter. Even the ones I haven't played in the past. I literally played FNFever yesterday. It was so fun lol.

[@hyhyd6135]

Fever is a nice mod, especially Taki's songs

[@lexcentrique2554]

I can say that, but mostly because the recent FNF mods are really, really, REALLY uninspired. Like, "Hello, I am FNF mod of Sonic.exe, I am also FNF mod of Sonic.exe, surprisingly, I am also FNF mod of Sonic.exe, what a surprise! I am also FNF mod of Sonic.exe! Heeeeya! I am also FNF mod of Sonic.exe" And when it's not Sonic.exe, it's just other intellectual properties. It really feels like Friday Night Funkin lost its "Funk" and just became "Every other intellectual properties in the world starring a 7 foot tall midget with blue hair".

[@HypaTaiga]

I'll never forget listening to Taki's songs and bopping to them

[@hyhyd6135]

@@HypaTaiga Like how Taki's bopping on my-

[@THE_ADMIN-dl3qk]

@@lexcentrique2554 that is true

[@Much_Ado]

One of the the things i remember really liking about Smoke Em Out Struggle was that, in the midst of other popular mods like Tricky and Whitty, mods that sounded good but were ball-bustingly hard (for the time), SEOS showed that you don't need crazy fast hard songs to be a good mod, just some solid jams and compelling characters

[@aguyontheinternet8436]

but the songs still need to sound good lol

[@idkwhattoputhereImao]

@@aguyontheinternet8436 That's what he meant by "solid jams"

[@divineshrek3307]

I like to think he began the Renaissance of the fnf mods

[@G3arsandc0gs]

@@aguyontheinternet8436 The songs do indeed sound good tho.

[@bluecubeidk]

i honestly think its funny how a man just dies in front of boyfriend and hes just smiling the whole time

[@jamesnova745]

I gotta say, looking back at the old "15 attempt songs" like ballistic or tricky, and then looking at the mods of today. Man. We didn't know how good we had it back in the good old days. They look like child's play now. At least they aren't considered "easy" still. Also nostalgia hits like a truck.

[@ulc_UV_Swap_Sans]

I had vitinem flashbacks of ballistic back in the day when whitty was the only mod, looking nowdays, shit hit the roof so fast

[@ASaycoB]

skibid toilet story: SKIBIDI TOILET VS FRIAY NIGHT FUNKIN - skibidi toilet: brr skibidi dob do b dob yes yes - boyfiend friay night funin: beep bop! *shoots skibidi toilet* - skibdi toilet: *dies* - boyfriend: beep bop! - boyriend: *hits the griddy* 5 LIKES FOR PART 2

[@LegendhypergameGD]

@@ASaycoB *n o*

[@digimonlover1632]

I mean it was gonna happen eventually. Regardless it shouldn’t diminish how hard even the old mods are because gauging difficulty should be done by casual players. Not experienced ones due to them having much more of a bias.

[@ASaycoB]

@@LegendhypergameGD ok

[@D3r_N1ck]

The epileptic seizures are part of the Sunday experience

[@anyseasonlogic]

Yes but I had to turn them off for video purposes

[@sweetieswifey627]

Real and true

[@ItalianCountryball11]

@@anyseasonlogicpussy

[@FallenKing_BallinKing]

Lol

[@mirandaward6438]

Yep

[@jerpingherping]

I remember playing the Tricky mod for the first time almost three years ago and being flabbergasted by the cutscenes. It’s weird coming back to the game and seeing all of these huge mods wayyy larger than the original game. It is tiring seeing all of the creepypasta mods nowadays though.

[@YukiSnow75]

It’s not

[@therealman27]

agreed. although im not a fan of this game anymore, the amount of creepypasta mods i saw before i left was more than abundant.

[@JahwsomeJ]

have you tried looking for cool oc mods lol

[@aguyontheinternet8436]

the only big ones are Sonic Exe, Hypno's Lullaby, and Mario's Madness if I'm remembering correctly. Other than that all the biggest mods are OC's and crossovers. Like Graffitti Groovin, MFM, DDTO (and all the spinoff mods of it), Hotline 024, Radi, Void, Vs Imposter, Starlight Mayhem, Broken Night Dimension, Lav, Twinsomnia, Kou, Indie Cross, Phantomfears' Corruption, Hazy River, Matt, TGT, Whitty, Hex, Shaggy, Funkin Aside, and The Holiday Mod (full week 1 and 2) just to name a few Literally the number of crossover and OC mods *_eclipses_* the creepypasta mods by such a large margin.

[@dacrispmonke]

honestly, f**k pibby

[@Zpixi09]

God, even now, that entire “HAAAANNNKKK!” section in Expurgation is still one of the best moments in FnF

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I agree. It is so awesome

[@Beta_Extraz24]

Personally I think what makes these kind of fnf mods better than the ones we have today is that it had original characters like whitty and tabi, these were the simpler times that had a valence of identity, good music and art style to the individual mods. Nowadays it’s just boring and repetitive exe/creepypasta mods with sonic being used so many times. I’m sick of it Edit: hey cool 1k likes thanks guys

[@HitTheFloor16]

Did you know there's other current mods besides Sonic

[@Serial_Designation_V236]

I wouldn’t say that but I sadly have to agree

[@Beta_Extraz24]

@@HitTheFloor16 yeah I know but they just don’t hit the same as the oh mods in this video, those non sonic mods are just either about already existing characters or oc’s

[@HitTheFloor16]

@@Beta_Extraz24 there are good mods about pre-existing characters like a very recent one Vs. Fnaf 3 and the other ones made by Pouria

[@6_Michel_9]

people shit on sonic.exe mods so much that i feel like its on purpose and tend to ignore actual good mods out there that are not sonic exe mods

[@Aflay1]

I think a lot of these mods aged well. I'd still listen to em. And some classics even got an upgrade. I can listen to 2023 Foolhardy all freaking day. I jammed out to Foolhardy in 2021 after all. I saw the Regular Show meme on repeat.

[@anyseasonlogic]

We are definitely going to be looking at that

[@LyanBr]

Agreed man, these songs are BANGERS, I kinda miss the old times where ballistic was like the hardest song on fnf, but fnf now days still pretty, good with some upgraded mods and new mods.

[@z4chy1]

in garcello, his cigar at the bottom of the screen also changes colour

[@GrimmShane]

Fitting, since his ghost is made of its remaining smoke!

[@Welkinthewolf]

Went to an anime con after this game came out and there was a family who had a 7-10 year old cosplaying as “boyfriend” with a mic, red cap, and blue hair. They even has game’s music playing on a speaker. Best cosplay I saw that year. Snagged a pic before I left

[@portalworld9880]

While precious, I’m sure it was, my brotherly instincts kick in and makes me feel a bit worried. What with FNF meaning to be more mature in terms of content. Don’t get me wrong, I was a kid once and wanted to do stuff that was above my age rating, even if I didn’t realize it, but I just want kids to be safe is all.

[@71TheyCallMeMJ]

W person

[@_spooky_sandwitch_]

​@@portalworld9880I think they just don't realize the adult content. It took me a few months to realize that BF gets blue balled when you fail lol

[@portalworld9880]

@@_spooky_sandwitch_ Which, by quick glance at the game, I can understand that.

[@blockeontheleafeon]

Surprised Vs. Hex isn't on here since it's a Mod I and many others remember fondly from back in the day.

[@dismasyves]

Agree, Hex had some banger music

[@blockeontheleafeon]

@@dismasyves Glad I'm not the only one who thinks that.

[@lourencinho1228]

Zardy too

[@subnaticashark2093]

True it was like garcello before garcello

[@subnaticashark2093]

@@dismasyvesi think i liked ram one if the best

[@garhd]

at this point fnf is becoming very nostalgic, especially the mods. i was extremely invested in this game for years and have been in the community ever since its initial surge in popularity. i remember just finding out about fnf because of coryxkenshin and 8 bitryan, who were big motivators to check out the game’s mods. one of the first mods i remember playing was saltys sunday night, and im pretty sure this was before tankman, when the game only went up to senpai’s week. this game is very nostalgic to me, glad you’re reviewing all of these mods.

[@anyseasonlogic]

it is becoming a nostalgic for some me included, my friend told me about it and i played it when skid and pump got added so seeing it grow is amazing

[@fourlion_everywhere]

Same! Found out about this game from a KZbinr three years ago. I'm in this community since the first ever release of Whitty, I remember it being called bonus week practically everywhere back then (I even thought it was official at that time!). Nowadays Sonic mods are getting annoying, I hope that these ones will keep decreasing its nasty amounts (without dramas is likely!!!). Honestly, I miss those times, this era of modding and stuff coming along with this times irl. Not gonna lie, these three years felt like I just skipped those (especially last 2)!

[@雪者]

Now *THOSE* were good times indeed.

[@infernopython]

this is a throwback. i remember struggling with crappy chart and weird mod concepts, but thats what gave the game character. now we have full ass games built into the mods. im glad the game is still around, and hopefully the full ass game gets finished soon.

[@anyseasonlogic]

nah they took the mill and dipped

[@infernopython]

@@anyseasonlogic i mean they did buy some crack with the money, but they were doing livestreams showing their progress, and the modding community took their work and made a mod out of it because they were impatient, so they dont show us what they have made anymore. to prevent poeple from stealing it. cuz at the end of the day, whats the point in making something if someone else is just gonna take it and use it as their own.

[@_Ecliptic]

​@@infernopythonis the first bit true? I'm not caught up with fnf nowadays

[@infernopython]

@@_Ecliptic yeah, it was for the funis cuz they had extra money

[@pirilon78]

​@@anyseasonlogicbro was wrong

[@ricochet1351]

While the music may be the main attraction for these mods, The way that programmers continued to evolve the way that you played the game via mechanics was incredible. The typing mechanic in Monochrome stunned me, and it oy git better from there. Will you be talking about the use of mechanics is old & new mods?

[@anyseasonlogic]

most definitely just to complete V2 of hypno's me and my friend had to become experts in unknows to beat it

[@Rundalla]

I remember back when Tabi's mod came out, it got a lot of hype because I'm pretty sure Genocide was one of, if not the first, songs to actually push back against your progress when the opponent was singing. That being said, Genocide from that mod and YCR from Sonic .EXE were always my favorites of this era, mainly because they were among the few that leaned more into a rock/metal sound

[@lucaselchidoris4637]

Back when pushing back the player's progress had actual logic behind it. ( Tabi being a _boyfriend_ )

[@wingedbluj1674]

His arrows also flashed when he hits his notes just like BF's solidifying it even more.

[@Chinelolamb]

​@@lucaselchidoris4637how the hell have I never heard this theory omg :0

[@thatonesonicfanalsoenthusi4049]

It's crazy to think how some of these were from like 3 years ago or somethin, also these are pretty good compared to like newer mods that have ALOT of content in them, Hyped for part 2!

[@fourlion_everywhere]

The time flew by and oh boy, it did fast!

[@IIIGAH77]

Thank god this Brainrot of a game died

[@fourlion_everywhere]

@@IIIGAH77 mf haven't heard about the game's chart devblog yet

[@JDReC100]

@@IIIGAH77 about that.....

[@hoxiipoxii56]

​@@IIIGAH77 ...The Weekend has entered the chat

[@aguyontheinternet8436]

man what a throwback, all these mods are dear to my heart and- 28:52 wait what the fuck? Hypno's Lullaby isn't that old, it's only... _two years??_ wtf where did those two years go?

[@Deflamed_Sphere]

fr it felt way longer than it is only to be surprised a year pass by or smt nostalgic for something not that long ago.

[@matsurischlaagen1757]

Bidenomics do that to ya. 🎉😮❤😊😂😮🎉😮😂😅❤😊🎉😮🎉😮❤😊😂😮🎉😮❤

[@anshsgh6092]

@@matsurischlaagen1757what the fuck

[@Nightmare-jo3mz]

Watching and listening to old mod in 2024 At this time, Shaggy and Matt: are we a joke for you?!

[@anyseasonlogic]

dont worry it seems like part 2 is going to be hell for me

[@Nightmare-jo3mz]

@@anyseasonlogicwe like suffer 😈

[@hyhyd6135]

And Bob

[@chaoticMadnessgameing]

​@@anyseasonlogicsome of the mods in this video have been remained to be more polished

[@Joke.ExeTheJokingLookingDevil]

Xenophanes : *It's RERUNNING TIME!*

[@wallyevans3320]

I miss old fnf so much cause nowadays everything kind of feels the same. Practically every cool mechanic you could think of has been used already and the songs are starting to sound the same as each other meanwhile in old fnf everything was still being discovered and it was awesome seeing the new ideas people cooked up.

[@anyseasonlogic]

This is very true sadly

[@marcelodias5625]

Well, there is only so much you can do before it becomes doom

[@FoubreakV8]

Then there’s the creepypasta mods. Not saying they are the reason fnf is the way it is now… but I do still think they played a big part in it. Now I do admit mods like Mario’s Madness are cool and I do like… I will say I do wish we saw some more mods about original characters

[@Chillipeffer]

​@@FoubreakV8they still exist and are being buried

[@FoubreakV8]

And by being buried you mean ?@@Chillipeffer

[@ArguablyNormal]

I don't think the older fnf mods can be rated on charting because in that time the kade engine sucked and some mods refused to let you hit all of the funny notes mainly Whitty, Tricky, and MFM had this problem edit, I vaguely remember that Sunday also had this issue, but it's less apparent, only noticeable if you play the madness cover

[@anyseasonlogic]

true but knowing how old they are we rated them knowing how old it was

[@Gencinnamon245]

These mods are essentially the Founding Fathers of this game

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

True

[@-kayko-]

whitty is the father of the mods, it's the first one who got really popular

[@redviper57]

Not really hypnos lullaby that one isnt as old as the first 2 or 3 they showed. Personally think they should have used bob and hex and zardy tbh

[@iconica9516]

​@@-kayko- bside? lol

[@chunkymilk8188]

Look, I know ratings are subjective and it's all about opinions but I still cannot begin to fathom who let Gavin cook on the majority of these

[@gporter7475]

Most based Anyseasonlogic viewer 💪💪💪

[@VypxQ]

Gavin is just a hater

[@hoxiipoxii56]

I thought no one would say it😭

[@mothmanafterdark5924]

FR

[@StafkiGTN]

Bro hates fun

[@randoman9122]

What a trip down memory lane this was Also how you gonna review the Tricky Mod without Hellclown 😭

[@anyseasonlogic]

i know, sorry :( but i tried to keep each mod at least a 2 song max

[@hyhyd6135]

@@anyseasonlogic Hey, more songs to rank = more content = more subs

[@SamSamii2.0]

Because everyone was jamming on Madness on the original mods' release, and everyone was astonished at how good Expurgation was when the v2 came out, which made people forget about Improbable Outset and Hellclown.

[@hyhyd6135]

@@SamSamii2.0 I think Hellclown still holds up well, but yeah those two take the cake

[@SamSamii2.0]

@@hyhyd6135 I was talking about popularity, not about how good the songs are (because I actually find Improbable Outset to be the best song of the mod) I think the Hellclown hype was also kind of drowned down by the fake leaked version (which had these terrible BF voices and was extremely repetitive)

[@ShockRox]

23:00 Fun fact: the guy behind Vs Sky also made Vs Sunday. The second and third songs of Sky's week he used Sunday's chromatic by mistake!

[@ghost77vl]

May I ask how do you mistake the character vocals when literally making the song? Just curious, I never understood how it even happened and I've been confused ever since

[@lime0pop]

@@ghost77vl theyre really similar

[@BTC_XD]

for as short as fnf has been a thing (around 3-4 years) it still has some sort of nostalgia for old mods. the songs are pretty decent compared to modern mods but they still have that charm of being the OGs of fnf modding.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I agree.❤❤❤

[@CrazyRedINC]

The best thing about the old mods was that each one had it's essence by the BF voice, as there was no official chromatic scale or not knowing how to use it, because most of them used either utau, or soundfont (which samples were mostly done in utau) or pitched samples randomly, making each sample sound strange when pitched up or down a lot, example Mike Geno BF. Now everyone uses either the official chromatic, or creates their own, but it has no iconic, now they are all mostly sampled from Week 3 with OTT and Fruity Chorus, they are all really generic and unfunny. With so many options now on how to improve and make more original chorms... Very few people take advantage of that

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

True but knows Maybe someday people will take advantage of the options opportunity.

[@nuke9915]

saruky BF and old rozebud bf on top, foolhardy being as good as it is is mostly due to the epic voice

[@monarchy028]

I love the detail on kapi, all his notes are pink and blue matching his ddr pad.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Me too

[@tinycandleman]

Just gonna throw it out there, that's the Remastered Ballistic you played. The original chart was made while the creator was drunk, and it shows.

[@DrawciaGleam02]

Really? People liked the first version either way, so.....😊

[@goobyblench949]

​@@DrawciaGleam02 they had shit taste

[@dannyendo_legit]

Just saying those jacks are harder than what we got in Whitty mod now

[@titaniumgamer_10]

​@@goobyblench949 Skill issue

[@Shaders_]

I hate these kids that just say “skill issue”. It’s not so numb and barely any context. It’s just so annoying.

[@Grimbaloo]

I think the quality has gone up, but the originality has gone down. Which I am fine with, since I just want more songs for my playlist.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Agreed.

[@IssakPlayz]

I thought that this video was going to be a video essay or like a tear ranking system but this video was neet. I like how you showed gameplay with you and your friends commentating along. It was funy and great to watch. Keep up the great work

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Agreed

[@cosmictheorist6091]

I'm so sad that everytime people hear classical music like Beethoven they think of fnaf. It's also hilarious 😂 also I have played the first Kapi song in ddr I feel like the notes might have matched the game.

[@anyseasonlogic]

he's ginger he has a little more brain rot

[@redviper57]

Freddy fazbear

[@CheemsBurger1052]

I like this type of video style there's not 40 things going on in the background

[@anyseasonlogic]

Thank you! i try to have different type of videos to make everyone happy

[@HyperDashYT]

I remember so well these mods when they came out, they truly were a revolution everytime a new big Mod came out; now that we're in 2024 it really shows how big FNF got in the Modding Community. 90% of these Old Mods now are a bit outdated, also are quite slow and really easy when looking at them and also had BF sounding straight up like ASS. Rare were the big ol' mods that successfully stood the test of time.

[@anyseasonlogic]

Fnf community has truly thrived

[@hyhyd6135]

"Quite slow" *Tricky, Whitty and Tabi all having BPMs higher than 200*

[@fourlion_everywhere]

​@@hyhyd6135 *Bob which kills you with 999 bpm and a lag spike because of how many notes are on the screen*

[@hyhyd6135]

@@fourlion_everywhere Actually Run has a BPM of 200. The NPM (notes per minute) is closer to the number you said

[@maybelbtracer3519]

Knowing that some of these mods had updates with revamped songs/visuals, this video puts into perspective just how much they have improved. Monochrome (Perish Mix) is absolutely fire btw

[@anyseasonlogic]

ikr from art changes to engine changes makes v1 and v2 seem like completely different mods

[@TheB-Train]

Honestly, the mods of the early FNF community and it's uprising were peak. I can't say I really enjoyed any mods released in 2023 and beyond. Most of the newer stuff I enjoy are updates and cleanups of older mods. Really says a lot about the longivity and creativity aspects of them, and how mods have changed.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Agreed.

[@GoldenMineYT]

Underrated video, this has a lot of effort and was enjoyable to watch.

[@anyseasonlogic]

Aw thank you I really appreciate it

[@Frogowning]

Triplets born, the throne awaits A seer warns of a deadly fate Give up your children, separate Bide your time, lie in wait! Sonic Underground (Sonic) Sonic Underground (Sonic) They made a vow, their mother will be found. The children grow, learn what's right Leaders of the freedom fight They seek their mother, she knows they do Is it time? If she only knew Will the prophecy come true? Sonic Underground (Sonic) Sonic Underground Queen Aleena: I long for my children, but I have to wait To act too soon could seal their fate. They made a vow, their mother will be found Sonic Underground!

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Cool reference to the show. Honestly both surprised and unsurprised on why there has not been a mod based on sonic underground.

[@family-funkin949]

It kinda makes ne nervous seeing how it all used to be back then. My heart is fuzzing to the core 😢

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I agree.❤❤❤❤

[@zanertheslayer2407]

0:22 Hey look! It’s my Blue’s Clues mod scrolling by!

[@NeeraNarukami]

If I may suggest for part 2, try looking at some of the less popular old mods, like PomPom, Clip, Static, etc.

[@anyseasonlogic]

Definitely will try

[@fourlion_everywhere]

Also that one mask freak

[@NeeraNarukami]

@@fourlion_everywhere i'd prefer if he stayed in the past

[@ulc_UV_Swap_Sans]

​@@NeeraNarukami we*

[@captaincraftit696]

Obligatory mention of Zardy goes here:

[@FlittaLink]

So, something I feel like a lot of people need to remember in this community is that a lot of mods were directly inspired from one another and/or require background information of what the mod was originally based off to fully get the most enjoyment out of them. Mods like Hypno’s Lullaby, or even Sonic.exe’s target audience isn’t 100% meant for those blindly coming onto the scene. What makes these mods so amazing is the passion that went behind them, and it’s even more awesome when these things people are creating were things you yourself stumbled across and are now reliving those moments from before. That’s really the art of these fan-mods!

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

True

[@aguyontheinternet8436]

I love how for every mod, one of you three has a wildly different score than the other two, like Layne thinks Ballistic fucking _rocks_ or Gavin just hates Garcello and thinks the charting in MFM is not so bad actually.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Agreed ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@TrubbishTheTrash]

I find it so funny that (for what I’ve seen) people consider the Tabi mod the first mod to input the poison mechanic (I think that’s what it’s called) where when the enemy sing it drains bar, but that’s far from correct as the Jester mod (one of the earliest mods in Fnf history) had the poison mechanic and yet the mod is basically barely noticed

[@Chococodile]

Tbf, Boyfriend being so chill in the face of man-made horrors is canonically due to him being to stupid and cocky to realize he's in danger.

[@SCUnleashed]

hope you make a part 2 or sm, swear VS Shaggy is not talked about at all or at much when FNF was at its peak

[@anyseasonlogic]

I am planning on it but idk what mods to do so thanks for at least one!

[@SCUnleashed]

@@anyseasonlogic Vs Shaggy was underrated imo there was the original Vs Tord which im pretty sure was an early fnf era mod (think the song was called Norway?) there’s also the remixs for the original FNF weeks like the old B side and Neo mods. ill see if i can find any older mods to suggest later

[@anyseasonlogic]

@@SCUnleashed B side was one of the mods originally in the video but I may have forgot about it, oops

[@SCUnleashed]

@@anyseasonlogic the hex and agoti mods were pretty good ones

[@RahRizzle123]

Seeing Ruv sent me back lile 10 years. I cannot believe how long its been since these mods dropped Also with MFM I'm personally a Casanova fan

[@galactic-beastbo1109]

I know I got kicked in the face by 2020 because of ruv

[@shukohs]

so sand bc i deleted my files and i cant get the mod anymore 😭😭

[@UnrealSuperSonic04]

*brings up ballistic for nostalgia purposes* *uses the remastered version made shortly before the mod's initial removal*

[@Z3RO5286]

I miss when the greater good eye cult was still a thing in mods. It had so much potential. I feel whitmore being cancelled kinda killed more oc mods later down the line. I always loved the idea of mods being connected to each other.

[@Prod_by_proto]

I do the feel the scoring was a bit generous for everything up before mid fight masses given that better mods came out as time went on, but if they were being rated as separate categories or something, then sure, good taste in fnf mods. Also, the main thing about the songs in hypnos lullaby is the mechanics (at least for the songs in the mod that have them), and it would be really cool to see v2 of this mod featured in future, and perhaps even videos for newer mods? random tangent, a few online friends and I are working on a remaster bundle of some older mods that the director wasn't proud of, not sure how long it will take but I just thought I'd mention it. some the songs in it are gonna be fire

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Cool

[@madchick1972]

I have went away from my FNF phase cuz tbh FNF did fell off BIG TIME but Summer 2021 was when it was peak and I’m starting to go back to my FNF phase

[@AceTechn0]

**insert angry comment about “WHY DIDNT YOU TALK ABOUT (mod name)!!!111!!” here** Jokes aside, this is a pretty good video, and it’s nice seeing these mods again in a condensed format like this. Wishing you luck with the KZbin algorithm! 👍

[@anyseasonlogic]

Thank you! I always appreciate comments good or Bad

[@core_breaker]

man it hasn't even been that long and this vid made me super nostalgic... i miss the glory days of fnf. i'm not really interested in the game or its mods anymore but seeing all this old stuff was really nice

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I Agree

[@memememe7081]

I feel like fnf fans nowadays forget how impressive these were back when nowadays you could pretty much just mod in anything now easier and more efficiently. As for the music? While some songs obviously didn’t age as well since we have refined music tastes and all that, there’s some songs that are still in my top 10 personally (like expurgation for example.).

[@lygoozman125]

To me, Vs Tricky definitely pushed a mod in how it plays and what types of mechanics it can have. But Vs Sonc.exe definitely has had the greatest impact on fnf period.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Agreed

[@tristenx]

its crazy how even though the last time i heard these songs was over three years ago, i can still hum them almost perfectly - they were just that memorable

[@maddrumsticks]

Strangely nostalgic video for me. Fnf is what got me into the world of rhythm games. It's crazy to look at some of these mods and remember how I used to not be able to beat some of these songs.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

Same here

[@matdenfunnyman]

i honestly miss the simplicity of these old mods. mods now are 99% creepypasta shit, but these mods, while simple/outdated in some aspects, still have a charm to them that’s missing in recent mods imo.

[@kidincredgamez5819]

"I think this IS the first demon he fought!" >Casually forgets Girlfriend's family are literal demons, and then there's the lemon headed monster which may or may not be a demon...

[@ermlmao]

Have no clue why this was recommended to me, cause i haven't played this game in a couple years lol, but like nice video! Kinda cool to look back on silly stuff like this. The only fnf mod I have any clue about anymore is the Wii Sports one, and that's just cause I have a friend that still mods the game. He told me that a lot of the people that make the Wii Sports fnf fan mods have like super massive egos or something haha, which kinda sucks since I remember that one being my favorite.

[@GalaxyDerg78825]

It's really crazy how FNF has changed over the last 3 years, but still drama involving mods aside, being a source of children's entertainment for elsagate, I still think there are some pretty good mods I like personally, such as The Blueballs Incident, Mario's Madness, and Hotline 024 are examples of very good and properly made mods.

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I Agree

[@funny-man-2000]

The best part about Beethoven from kapi mod is that its litterally an exact replica of an actual ddr song because kapi uses a ddr pad

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I Agree

[@Churito144]

Man i miss when fnf was popular it was so fun playing all the difficult and unique mods like these

[@Nagoya_Chicken]

Man, I got hooked by this game because of Agoti, I didn't even realize its been 4 years since then, I'm still proud to be part of the community then😅

[@alextompkins4041]

the thing that set smoke em apart from other mods was that it wasnt focused on a super hard track, but rather telling a good story with a good one off character

[@kidincredgamez5819]

"It's a song definitely made just to be hard" No, that's vs Matt from Wii Sports.

[@sundu71]

nah bro the disrespect with monochrome 😭😭😭😭

[@anyseasonlogic]

i enjoy v2 better

[@waddleds665]

Little small fun fact: The comopser for Kapi, PaperKitty, was and i think is still also working for Sugary Spire OST (that one Pizza Tower cool ass fangame in the works i think)

[@Thwaktab]

This was a big trip down memory lane and I actually really enjoyed the video

[@plattell102]

Look at the bright side at least you didn't suffer through QTS termination mod

[@anyseasonlogic]

THE WHAT

[@plattell102]

@@anyseasonlogic qt and the termination song it's hella hard

[@plattell102]

@@anyseasonlogic good luck

[@DangenBruh]

not the brightside..,

[@GlaceonFan1997]

​@@DangenBruh💀

[@Robabank2034]

Underrated video I hope week 8 comes soon

[@ShadyDoesContent]

I was SO happy to see Monochrome here! :D It's one of my favorites of all time and sits proudly in my Spotify playlist.

[@NotSoGenesiz]

now although there are some REALLY good fnf mods that are more recent (vs hood: roundtable and vs allegro for example), mods definitely peaked in earlier years. luckily that just means whenever a really good mod comes out now, it become a whole lot more recognizable

[@nathanE578]

I wonder if we will see Starlight Mayhem, Annie, AGOTI and The Bob mod in part 2

[@anyseasonlogic]

maybe🤫

[@ultimatefart]

🧏‍♂️

[@croyisdeafFNF]

Starlight Mayhem (OG and Rebooted) is one of the best mods easily

[@rydotion]

and vs sketchy!

[@Dr.Silly-xl6tz]

This video has rekindled my love of fnf and all of its mods. I appreciate and respect that. Thank you.

[@RulerofReferences]

A little while back in 2023, Hypno's Lullaby got a rework, where Monochrome got extended, And Hypno got an additional song it its week (Lost Cause), along with a couple new songs such as Isotope (Glitchy Red), Amusia (Can't Sing), Death Toll, Dissension, Insomnia, Frostbite, Pasta Night, Bygone Purpose, Shinto/Shitno, Brimstone, and Purin.

[@KAlberich]

As someone who quit the FNF community in mid-2022, these bring back a lot of memories (tbh I’ve never even heard any new songs nor enjoyed their vibe as much as I did for older mods) I was a huge MFM fan and was thriving in the community until the original creator quit (I was actually crying just now because I find it to be so depressing that she’s just left the characters to be frozen forever and forgotten about) but yeah, thank you for making this video!

[@sparkthedragon]

i feel like old fnf holds up somehow better than a good amount of modern mods, mainly as there were less sonic and exe mods and more characters people hadnt modded into fnf at the time that were being modded into fnf, now its hard to find fun characters to mod into fnf that havent been done

[@AikeenMurray-qy8cc]

FNF vs hex was a good mod and spread popularity.

[@ineedzemedic5810]

It feels weird calling these mods "old" now. Obviously 3-4 years ago isnt too long ago. Remembering when these mods came out and became popular was a such a funny transition in my life. I personally think many of these mods still holds up years later. It feels weird getting nostalgic remembering these little mods when they came out.

[@JesBdoinItAgain]

For a game that showed up in the mids of the pandemic, it had a nice hit of nostalgia every time you come back to it. Some difficult mods like Kapi, Whitty, Tricky, Hotline 024, etc. No matter how hard they are, even if they kick your ass, they'd still give you a great time. Even mods that weren't made to be difficult had some great sounding jams like Garcello, Sunday, and Cassette girl. Couldn't say that to the hundreds of exe mods though. At first they were interesting, but then more showed up like ants craving for some sugar.

[@TheFiryDev]

Honestly I disagree with most of the comments, I really like how fnf is today, the songs are sometimes extremely good compared to what we had before, also I'm waiting for big mods to update like VMU, hotline 024 or indie cross (and also other mods)

[@anyseasonlogic]

i also love modern fnf like 024 or ourple guy

[@TheFiryDev]

@@anyseasonlogic Also there's a lot of OC mods, it's just that people ignore it or they just aren't good

[@boomgirlbucko]

Another really good one you could play is the Starving Artist V2 mod, the songs from the stalker are catchy af

[@DrSuperLuigiSeth1]

Indie Cross, Impostor and Mario’s Madness are incredible, but you should NEVER forget the classics. Also where’s my boy Hex?

[@LyanBr]

YEEEEEEEEEE HEX!!!!!

[@jaylee6083]

JusticeForHex

[@Aeni13]

I don't know how the mods of this are going nowadays, but man, I still find myself listen to music from older and famous mods. They were so great. Every mod brought so much creativity, and felt so unique. I don't know the difficulty scale, but besides some musics, they didn't sound impossible to non experienced rhythm players.

[@germanscience7246]

My favotire detail about mfm is ths At sarv's demon model is called "smokinhotbabe.png" in the mods files

[@Not_Kaitlyn]

Smoke Em Out Struggle is probably my favorite "old" mod. I love the songs, I love the simple story. And it made me cry. 10/10 would play again

[@legacyisanimesh]

I clearly remember VS Tabi (old) Genocide being insanely hard with the 4 note splash in the beginning

[@RamenNoodiles]

Older mods were something that felt like people made it out of love and enjoyment and appreciation for the original source material, newer mods are even better with good quality and even better production but there's something about newer mods that don't hit like in the early days of the community and I can never pinpoint what the science behind that is to be fair...

[@adolfogamboa7752]

Great video my man, hope that your channel grows bigger

[@yellowstarproductions6743]

I Agree

[@SansTheUnderman]

I remember the shit theories on triple trouble before the next version released like "Eggman.exe didn't let sonic take over in his song that's why the effect happens but it doesnt transition" or some shit lmao

[@thatwaterriver3824]

just realized in sunday marx is a reference to fucking karl marx in the bg

[@RydWolf]

One mod that's always stuck in the back of my mind is the Vs Mami mod. Something about the bells or chimes in the third song, plus the bonus songs are fun.

[@clash_king1025]

I forgot hypno’s lullaby was made during 2020-2021 That mod was my favorite even during v1 and v2 just blew my mind. I really stopped being interested in FNF mid-2022 and when I decided to check in and see the new mods my biggest gripe is how they handle gimmicks. They either just shove them in because why the hell not or they spam the living daylights out of them. This mod imo did gimmicks amazingly, because while they can be difficult, they made perfect sense for the characters and they embraced how the gimmick changed the playstyle. My favorite song still is probably the first. It’s a perfect adaptation of *the* hypno creepypasta and even before they deform hypno they still make him creepy with the stances, constant swinging, occasionally using some psychic move (maybe confusion? Idk) Sorry for the long comment, I just love that mod so much. They put so much effort into it and fully respected the original creepypastas. This vid in general was a fun nostalgia ride too. Besides Hypno, the Witty (with the charting change, thank god), tricky (even better with the new version) and Sonic.exe mods still hold up really well

[@thestickopia4619]

While I still like a fair amount of new mods, there definitely seems to be way less iconic mods. Plus something older mods did was have original characters just for the mod. That’s just nice to see I still like ones based on pre existing characters but I just like the little added effort of a new one

[@b0ks511]

I feel like y'all also should've rated the mods gimmicks, like tricky has so many cool gimmicks that make the mod so much better and hypno has the swinging pendulum and the typing thing which some of the viewers might not know of. I also want to say thank you for this video, it reminds me of the time when i used to play this game a lot and i can't say i was bad at it. I think i remember one bright summer day getting expurgation with like 40 misses and i was so excited to tell my friends about it. I haven't played fnf in a few years so this was a good reminder of the good times i had with it back in the day.

[@anyseasonlogic]

It was talked about but not enough of the mods had gimmicks to add the rating system like that plus i think having a simple rating system helps to keep everyone in the same page

[@b0ks511]

@@anyseasonlogic that makes sense

[@metalapplesus]

Despite the constant drama, I definitely want to give credit to Sonic.exe where it's due. That place being Triple Trouble. It really was the cornerstone foundation for having multiple opponents in one song, the mechanics harken back to the source material (the rings, the phantom notes from the second song only appearing once Knuckles appears, Eggman staying for longer than he was supposed to, etc), and the tune itself teases other sonic OSTs as it goes on. It's not JUST the drowning theme over and over, nor is it JUST a random splatter of notes for no reason, which a lot of covers, remixes, and other sonic.exe mods seem to overlook. Also, it was the first mod to celebrate a collection of several medias, it isn't just trying to copy off of another famous mod for clout, because it IS the mod being copied off of for clout.