DO THE CATWALK - Girls’ Generation (少女時代) | Line Distribution

[@taeyeonkim2112]

I forgot to note, the echo "Do the do the catwalk" at the last chorus is kinda controversial, some ppl hear Tiffany, some hear Yuri or Sunny, it's hard to tell who that is so I decided to consider it as bg vocals. No one sang it on stage anyway. Personally I hear Yuri but I'm not sure.

[@nighthunter3372]

Do you mind doing a Vocal analysis

[@taeyeonkim2112]

@@nighthunter3372 I can't cause that's not my strength sadly, sometimes I do some lead vocals analysis cause it's easy to filter it but the vocals in background are smt else, so much harder and I can't do much with those vocals.

[@PrayashLand]

Me thinking it was Hyo 😂

[@RescueDogFam]

@taeyeonkim2112 I hear Yuri, but I understand why people think it's Sunny. I'm glad you listed as background vocal tho. I think it really isn't anyone's official "line"

[@attwboy]

i hear yuri too

[@hashimotosan4571]

The "do the do the catwalk" adlib at the end of this song is Yuri's. She actually sang it on stage. You can see that if you search "Japan 3rd tour SNSD - Ryan TV", and there will appear another short version of Japan 3rd tour, lasting just more than 1 hour. You see that video at 34:39, then Yuri will show up at the big screen mouthing along the adlib.

[@nighthunter3372]

She's most likely singing her lines after the adlibs.

[@Jon-wd3rm]

@@nighthunter3372 Nope. She opened her mouth already with "do the do the". I had to watch it many times to confirm.

[@jake_thefox4675]

yeah but snsd members are always mouthing to lines that they dont sing 😭😭

[@mantegashargel]

Love Hyo’s lines in this song

[@DDP121]

omg Yuri, i never thought she sing a lot in this song 🥺

[@SeoJuhyun91]

[LINE DISTRIBUTION] Girls Generation at [TAEYEON KIM] (NEW VERSION) OT9 UNTIL : DO THE CATWALK 👡 TAEYEON_2917.4 JESSICA_2510.8 TIFFANY_1899.4 SEOHYUN_1693.6 SUNNY_1443.0 YURI_961.4 SOOYOUNG_925.1 YOONA_836.0 HYO_748.1 MY FAV ALBUM SO FAR 👑 // 💗

[@igotaboy_]

what “i got a boy” was for yuri, “love & peace” was for sooyoung, she had such good lines in this album

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Love and peace is even better for Soo than what IGAB was for Yuri tbh, Soo is another lead vocal in this album, Yuri was not quite a lead vocalist in IGAB

[@hees_mine]

@@Oliver-uz1fs atleast yuri had 100s because the igab album was mostly TTS + taefany's duo

[@ongbakbuang]

I wonder who did the cat-calling parts especially after before Jessica's first line and Yoona's last line.

[@justingamba399]

sunny at the bottom AGAIN. oh, this album was definitely not hers 😭

[@Xanekz]

I love this longgg

[@nighthunter3372]

Definitely The best treatment in this album Yuri gotten excluding Lips chorus.

[@TheBB1994]

I love how Yuri was either staying at the bottom 3 or occasionally (more like randomly) went to the top 5 as if nothing happened.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Isn't this her only top spot aside from Gossip girls? she's mostly last IIRC

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@Oliver-uz1fsI think their saying Yuri position during the song.

[@nighthunter3372]

​​​@@Oliver-uz1fsI think she's definitely 7th in album position. There's no way she's beating Soo. Her only chance was if Lips chorus was Counted. Everyday Love Soo has more and I Think Lingua Franca. Karma butterfly is around the same. Forgot about Blue Jeans Yuri has a slight lead in Blue Jeans.

[@tashakle9900]

Love&Peace (at the moment) Taeyeon - 256 Tiffany - 247.3 Jessica - 185.8 Seohyun - 183.4 Sunny - 150.2 Sooyoung - 132.2 Yuri - 120.3 Yoona - 108.3 Hyoyeon - 101

[@Jon-wd3rm]

Before you guys say anything about how Jessica's role as the group's main vocalist was trivialized on this album, let me just say that I don't think it even mattered to her. If it matted to her, she would have mentioned it on her books, but she didn't. I guess it's safe to assume that she was probably exhausted during the period of time when they were recording this album since she was extremely busy. It was painfully more noticeable during the Love and Peace Tour, where she always looked too tired and bored to perform. I'm saying this as someone who has been her stan since 2009.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

@@Jon-wd3rm I still feel a bit let down lol, like, would've been nice if they used Sunny more to make up the lack of Jessica's "bright" vocals but in contrast Tiffany was the second main vocal (or even the main one tbh)

[@taeyeonkim2112]

@@Oliver-uz1fs some songs do make me feel lack of Jessica bright tone like LIPS, or motorcycle but the rest sound fine to me. I love Tiffany's voice in this song.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

@@taeyeonkim2112 don't get me wrong Tifanny did an amazing job in the studio, she definitely slayed her lines but the fact that Jess was mostly given English lines and that Sunny was a vocalist this album kinda annoys me

[@taeyeonkim2112]

@@Oliver-uz1fs haha I didn't defend anyone, just say my point, cause I always felt some of the songs in this album lack of the bright tone and you just said what I felt so can't hold the urge to cmt about it

[@nathi.talita]

I love ❤❤❤❤

[@brunoguardia8539]

ohh i love this song, this album is soooo good

[@Edu_uwu]

One of the best songs in the album for me, along with Lips and Karma Butterfly

[@guntherstewart8941]

Do the catwalk The production of this song really fits the title of the song so easy breezy beautiful covergirl lol. It’s very repetitive but that makes it really easy to learn the lyrics. The use of a catcall was interesting Main vocalist Taeyeon, Jessica & Tiffany Lead vocalist Sooyoung Vocalist Yuri & Seohyun Sub vocalist Sunny, Hyoyeon & Yoona If the pre chorus was done in full the second time around Yuri would be in the lead vocalist category. The “are you to walk” and seo and tae’s verses got a little more weight so did tiff and tae’s chorus part. “Daduda Dadua” was one part even though it was repeated twice because it’s not words and pretty casually delivered.

[@nighthunter3372]

Once we find out who the Do the catwalk adlib is Yuri or Sunny maybe moved up. Cause it's either one of them. Its not Tiff as her tone doesn't sound like that.

[@3BenjNZr]

Hyoyeon being last yet still gets 3 perfectly decent sized lines is so good like despite the diffs in vocal/dance line being random (giving sunny one of taeyeons lines woulda helped) this is a v good dist

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

This and Karma butterfly could've been the best distributions from the album given Sunny some more lol

[@RescueDogFam]

Do the Catwalk Opening: Sica, Tae Verse 1: Seo, Soo, Tif, Yur, Seo Chorus 1: Sun, Soo, Tif, Hyo, Sica, Sun Verse 2: Tae, Tif Chorus 2: Yoo, Hyo, Tae, Sica, Yur, Seo Bridge: Soo Chorus 3: Sun, Soo, Tif, Hyo, Sica, yur Outro: Yoo There's a main vocal line in this song "Daduda.." Tae, Seo, Sun, Yur 1st & 3rd chorus are the same, 2nd Chorus is different. Sica and Hyo sing in every Chorus, but not the same lines. There are no repeating Chorus lines here. Tae- 3 lines, 5 adlibs, main high note, MVL Jes- 4 lines, 1 adlib Tif- 4 lines, 3 adlibs, high note Sun- 3 lines, MVL Seo- 3 lines, MVL Yur- 4 lines, MVL Soo- 4 lines Hyo- 3 lines Yoo- 2 lines Fun fact: Yoona only sings in English in this song. Should've given Yoo Tiff's first line, it's all English. Yoona's English is cute. Main Tae- 10 points Tif- 8 points Lead Jes- 5 points Yur- 5 points Vocalist Soo- 4 points Sun- 4 points Seo- 4 points Hyo- 3 points Subvocalist Yoo- 2 points

[@nighthunter3372]

Omg I Guess right that TaeSunSeoYul Dadada is an MVL despite it random gibberish.

[@nighthunter3372]

I would consider Tae Tiff Chorus part though as a MVL like a Taengsic situation and The are you ready to walk doesn't feel like singing more like talking where as Dadada has melodies

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

TaeTi chorus is definitely the MVL here over the speeches and the duda duda duda Even YulSic chorus part are more of a MVL imo

[@nighthunter3372]

I wonder will there be a song where there is 3 MVL or 4 MVL

[@RescueDogFam]

@@nighthunter3372 I have not found one yet. And before this album, I wouldn't have even considered 2 MVL in the same song. This album breaks some rules for sure.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Happy for Yuri but man, I can't sugarcoat it any longer, Jessica was a lead vocal in the album, her lines here are equal to the dancers, she has flyers and that's it :/ Sunny was also a vocalist in is album, like, why

[@RescueDogFam]

Jessica is 1st in overall line distribution 5 times on this album (Flyers, Blue Jeans, Karma Butterfly, Everyday Love, and Galaxy Supernova)... Tiff has 2 or 3 #1's (I think), Yoona is first in Gossip Girls, and Tae has 4 or 5 number 1s.

[@RescueDogFam]

Sica ends up a main Vocalist I believe on this album. As long as I didn't make any other mistakes. I don't mind when you guys point out something I forgot to count. but so far, Sica is a main or Lead on just about every song.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

@@RescueDogFam her lines in blue jeans and galaxy super nova are mostly talking

[@yesok1432]

I think Sun ranked as a vocalist in the Boys and the first mini album as well.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

@@yesok1432 not the boys

[@nighthunter3372]

Main Vocal line for me is TaeSunSeoYul dadada😂😂😂😂 Theres so many lines capable of MVL here. The do the catwalk part and Dadada. Would consider Tiff and Tae chorus line.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

Tae has it too in the intro lol But is likely the TaeTi chorus and probably the YulSic one since it's belting

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@Oliver-uz1fstrue but imo it's The dada cause it's just random lyrics. Yeah but I think it's Taeny's chorus part.

[@RescueDogFam]

I struggled on MVL for this song. But, I gave this song 2 MVLs

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@RescueDogFamI also consider it hard as there are many high parts.

[@Jon-wd3rm]

Alright, guys. This has been a debate since 2013, but who do you guys think is singing the "Do the do the catwalk" ad-lib during Yuri's post-chorus? Some say it's Tiffany, and some say it's Yuri. I personally believe it's Yuri (Tiffany wouldn't pronounce "catwalk" like that).

[@nighthunter3372]

I thought it was Soo or Sun the whole time.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

​@@nighthunter3372I think is Sunny

[@nighthunter3372]

But listening more I hear Yuri more. Tiff's tone doesn't sound like that. It's mostly towards Yuri and Soo. Maybe Sunny.

[@nighthunter3372]

​@@Oliver-uz1fsI hear Sunny at first but now I hear Yuri. It's most likely Sunny cause most of the dance line won't record adlibs.

[@Oliver-uz1fs]

@@nighthunter3372 comparing it to Sunny's pronunciation in the chorus is definitely hers imo

[@sawottalgi]

im still really confused on who those adlibs are :P yk, the "do the do the catwalk" ones in between yuri's dadadi duda's, it could be yuri hers, it is definitely not tiffany because tiffany's accent is obviously NOT like that at all...i see people in the comments here saying its sunny, tbh yeah i kinda hear it? but im still really confused...

[@taeyeonkim2112]

I hear Yuri lol

[@sawottalgi]

@@taeyeonkim2112same but sometimes i hear sunny though it sounds more like yuri haha

[@nighthunter3372]

Another Yuri dominated song.