Doctor Who S6E7 'A Good Man Goes to War' REACTION

[@TheFallofTheEleventh]

Deepa: “Mel….Mels” Luke: 👁👄👁

[@hmsljj]

"Melody .. I'm not sure how I feel about that. Mel, or Mels" (Luke deadpan gaze)

[@joestacey6185]

The look on Luke's face when Deepa says "Mels"...

[@kyleboffa793]

yeah

[@obiwankenobi687]

I really like the scene where the Doctors talking to Lorna. He pretends to know who she is so she doesn’t have to die feeling pointless for fighting this entire war just to meet him again.

[@lukeyread]

SO sad 🥺🥺

[@mattgarrett2583]

The Doctor mostly tells everyone to run.. so just being like, "Hey, didn't we run?" you got like a 90% chance of being right.

[@obiwankenobi687]

@@mattgarrett2583 he still pretended to know who she was though, it was nice of him

[@BlueStar4040]

I always thought he actually knew what he did in the forest and he remembered that there was probably a random kid there somewhere. But they never really talked so ofc he doesnt know exactly who she is

[@obiwankenobi687]

@@BlueStar4040 I think it was written more for the fact that he didn’t know who she was at all. It fits thematically with the whole episodes idea of ordinary people fighting for or against the Doctor and how he influences people’s lives so much without stopping to realise it

[@hothotheat3000]

The baby turning to yogurt made me scream the first time I saw it. Karen plays the hell out of that moment with her horrified screams for Rory.

[@FahadAyaz]

Yoghurt baby! 😂 😂

[@dizzzysoup]

"i like her already" "she's gonna die" doctor who in a nutshell xD

[@lukeyread]

Deepa knows how it works now 😂😂

[@InspirationxStrikes]

It's time!!! That intro with Rory is my absolute favorite intro in all Who! "Would you like me to repeat the question?" Rory is an absolute precious father, I just love his reaction to baby Melody. And the reveal!!!! Deepa's face just was priceless when she realized what it meant. I also have such a soft spot for the River Song theme, it's such a beautiful piece.

[@FacePimpd]

That quiet “whatthefuck” is EXACTLY the right reaction! Series 6 kills it with the cliffhangers.

[@cyberdalek615]

And people say Chibnall is currently killing the show. No, he's not. Series 6 is proof that it's actually Moffat.

[@jumbojaba1235]

@@cyberdalek615 moffat was a good writer, season 6 wasn't his best but he has made some brilliant episodes and seasons for doctor who, chibnal has not

[@cyberdalek615]

@@jumbojaba1235 I can’t believe you misread what I said. Either that, or you took it way too seriously...

[@Jim_The_Fish]

@@cyberdalek615 I get it’s a joke now because you’ve said so, but it’s not clear in normal context.

[@justashjd]

OH MY GOD IT'S TIME!!! EVERYBODY STAY CALM!!!

[@waratah6236]

STAY *BLEEP* CALM!!!!!

[@the_judge_8262]

But how, how can we stay calm !!!! 😜

[@JERBYTUBE]

Doc Ten when he meets River: "I point and laugh at archaeologists" Doc Eleven at 9:47 : **Points at future archaeologist** 😂

[@PandezPanda]

OMG I never caught that before

[@cyberdalek615]

I actually put that as a fun fact as part of the Series 6 version of my 'One Character from Each Episode' posts on Whovians Amino. Yes, this confirms who I am there, for those there too...

[@MavenCree]

Yes, Captain Jack was originally supposed to be part of this rescue crew, but John Barrowman had a scheduling conflict with the first season of Arrow. Torchwood was done by this point.

[@lukeyread]

Ahhh, I knew it was for something, just didn’t know which. Thanks for the clarification 😊

[@Hanmacx]

@@lukeyread yeah Captain Jack was going to be beheaded and later turning into the face of Boe

[@MavenCree]

One of the best TV reveals of all time. We were expecting a reveal that she was his girlfriend or wife or sommat... Nope! She's the baby. We were floored. And then we had to wait for two months (?) for the next episode.

[@ConnieBoo20]

OK I need to calm down but this is a monumental episode and I can't wait to see the shock on Deepa's face Edit: 3:28 had my cry laughing for like 5 straight minutes

[@wendyheatherwood]

Somehow "Would you like me to repeat the question?" ended up being the most bad ass line in the history of Dr Who.

[@Torrmtrooper]

My top vote for most badass doctor who line is "I'm river song, check your records again" As she proceeds to make a Dalek beg for mercy

[@kitsukailegendary]

if u watched the episode the Doctor's Wife, when the Tardis was human and she said to Rory "That the only water in the forest is a River" a little teaser if u were paying attention.

[@caitlin329]

They actually included that and 'Pay attention- it's not really her' in The Brilliant Book with a list of other fake 'hints' before this series. So you could work out as you went along which were real and which weren't (some of the fake ones sounded fun, too).

[@robinnes2662]

Genuinely amazing that Deepa managed to get this far without spoilers - more than a lot of reactors can get!

[@Bauernpart]

"the only water in the forest is the river." I love it how they already tell us this in the episode where the tardis was in that woman, she tell the doctor those exact words and now, it does makes sense. This is so brilliant.

[@averagecartoonfan6348]

holy shit "oh it's your cot, haven't seen that in a long long time" the last time she saw it was when she was there as a baby

[@azizuladnan2957]

I know it's unrelated, but speaking of river and doctor, meeting at wrong direction, it makes me looking forward on Steven Moffat's HBO series adaptation Time Traveller's Wife! Ahhh, can't wait!! :D

[@davidhunt7454]

Woah no way. That’s a great little combo. Great book trash movie let’s go for telly :)

[@Not_Rachel]

When Deepa said Mels I lost it 😂

[@KaddelEdits]

One of the biggest mindblowing scenes :D

[@cyberdalek615]

Oh yeah, finding out the cot belonged to the Doctor? That was quite a shock 😰 Jk...I know that's not the scene you're referring to.

[@davidaskew217]

Like you Luke, I have been waiting for this since you both started - A Good Man Goes To War is my favourite, and your reactions certainly didn't disappoint!! Thank you so much!! Can't wait for Let's Kill Hitler (a very underrated episode in my opinion!) 😁👍

[@blueashke]

Deepa's reaction was everything I'd been excited to see. LOVE IT!

[@whobp8]

Hmm, if Deepa's seeing Madame Kovarian in her dreams it's just possible that Deepa is actually a Flesh Avatar. What a twist that would be! I absolutely love this reaction. I'm so pleased that you've been able to get back together and resume your journey through Doctor Who. Every time I watch one of your reactions I can't stop smiling. Great stuff!

[@the_judge_8262]

Someone get a doctor, Deepa's broken! Luke, well done as usual for keeping it all in and but revealing a thing👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@djcowell91]

Aww, no reaction to one of my favorite lines? "Good men don't need rules. Today is not the day to find out why I need so many." (But so many good reactions, thanks!!)

[@jeckjeck3119]

General and his army: ''We are not fools!'' 11 seconds later:

[@sailoraurora]

the reaction to this episode of River's real identity ... never get old or bored to watch!

[@k.r.jrandomchannel8022]

I would have loved vastia and Jenny had their own series

[@miadavies1575]

This is my all time favourite episode!! Love your reactions!!

[@seravalencia8441]

I clicked on this cause it’s one of my favorite episodes of dr who but I had to subscribe when Luke said “I waited ten years for this, in Azkaban!”

[@lukeyread]

Haha! Welcome to the channel 😊

[@Alfie-cu4np]

I love this episode, it’s a culmination of all previous six episodes and this is one of my favourite episodes written by Moffat, as he creates really intimidating characters, particularly the Headless Monks as they are brilliant in this episode, and the twist in this episode is so brilliant and perfectly executed as Moffat builds up to the twist perfectly and I really enjoy the side characters as well, especially as they are all unique and brilliantly written. Overall this is a quite a fun yet tense episode and I wouldn’t have it any other way.

[@joevanno4323]

The only water in the forest is the river....the tardis tried to tell them when she took human form in that episode.

[@shannon_1012]

Been waiting for this forever I'm so happy I can finally watch it 🥰

[@Lia-zw1ls7tz7o]

9:46 "I'm a time traveler, i point and laugh at an archeologist"...one incarnation later, points and laughs at an archeologist 😂 13:39 OMG, I didn't notice he's done it twice now!

[@Legendary3Dgamer]

finally he's doing dr who again

[@CrankyGrandma]

This episode kinda showed how the doctor could have been in the time war.

[@e21dan]

And then I know: River is essential "Wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey" being

[@Hanmacx]

Remember when he said: "he point and laugh at archeologists"?

[@Jack-gf3ig]

3:27

[@coladict]

OMG I just noticed ANOTHER spoiler behind Luke! edit: it's for season 8, in case any of you are looking and can't see it.

[@gwinnellheald8592]

14:50 you guys singing genuinely made me cackle bdhdjdk

[@jakerlegend1266]

Ooohhh aaahhh Ooohhh.. (laughs) Please can you sing that every week Me: 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@divinemadness7119]

I LOVE your reaction! I think my favourite bit is 14:50 …la,la,la 😂🤣 classic!!

[@ItsMeHarry]

I know they planned to bring Captain Jack back for this episode but Miracle Day was being filmed at the same time in America, so the scheduling meant they couldn't. Imagine that surprise if he did turn up after not seeing him since (also seeing River and Jack in the same episode)? ...editing this because I realise I'm a dumbass and got a bit eager saying this even though you literally said the same fact lmfao I'm a dumbass

[@dizzzysoup]

YES BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE !!!! :D

[@creator1094]

When you were like 5.5, I was like "you're me."

[@Legendary3Dgamer]

5:58 the doctor isn’t a living breathing man Heez Ai TIme LoRD OOooooH 👽👽👽

[@PandezPanda]

*FLAILS* it's here... ITS HERE! :)

[@derJOgelle]

YAASSS WE'VE ARRIVED AT THIS EPISODE!

[@JERBYTUBE]

YESSSSSS. WAIT NO. Lemme get my popcorn

[@Hanmacx]

That smile at 3:29 🤣

[@GeorgeAlexander3110]

'.....what the fuck...' ICONIC!!!

[@ryanratchford2530]

Captain Runaway

[@hmsljj]

AAAAH! "The" reaction has arrived!

[@tomski120]

How many times did Lukey look down the camera lol Love your reactions, you are both bonkers 🤪

[@curtinparloe]

Looking forward to the "Luke gets an eyepatch" reaction... Are you going to show Deepa Two Days Later?

[@dean67impala96]

I missed this sooooo much!!!!!!!YES

[@NG-we4nx]

River coming back from her BIRTHDAY celebrations at the start of the ep🙌😭

[@ojwh1933]

I think it's more likely Amy was taken somewhere between 'The Impossible Astronaut' and 'Day of the Moon' (as opposed to pre-Series 6), considering she thought she was pregnant in the former, then there was a time jump as they split up, and then she started experiencing visions in the latter. I'm not a fan of this episode for a few reasons, but I'm glad you both enjoy it.

[@rickysfilmreviews3825]

I can't wait for Luke's voice to break!

[@ajandrianjafymusic]

I’ve been waiting for this one

[@jessetorres8738]

Happy Digimon Day everyone.

[@lukeyread]

Today’s August 1st!!! 😂

[@davidmichaelson1092]

This and the next episode are the best.

[@RAP7ORv]

3:27 that look xD

[@Jamestopboy]

The Doctor hasn’t just kissed the daughter. The implication is that the Doctor has… ahem’d… with the daughter too. Multiple times. Or… will have, anyway. Deepa usually laughs at death. You know it’s serious… when Deepa doesn’t laugh at a baby that becomes a pile of splooge.

[@careforajellybaby21]

By far one of my favorite episodes. I love Madam Vastra and Jenny

[@lukeyread]

Me too 🥺🥺

[@dustinheese]

So great!

[@darkhumour741]

"I just wanna FLICK that stupid eyepatch off her" The actress lately turned out to be a transphobe irl so I'll join you Deeoa 👏

[@phillipsuttles1926]

i love you guys

[@bananasaregood8655]

Please do a reaction video to classic doctor who honest trailer!!!

[@pretentiousn3rd]

Finally......WE'RE HERE

[@michaelspence2902]

Minisode after this please

[@SGlitz]

Minisode Alert

[@mikelarsen5836]

Reactor complains bomb was too loud and hurt his poor ears? What a wuss! Like to use the Tardis to transport him to the trenches in World War One! He'd last 10 seconds! 😂😂😂

[@xUwatMC]

I thought I really liked Madame Vastra and Jenny until someone pointed out to me that their dynamic is fucked up when you think about it, the only way Steven Moffat can include representation of a lesbian couple is if one of them has to assume the role of the man and the other the role of the woman, it's just pretty disgusting. It's quite a common trope but it's just another moffatism that I am so fond of discovering...

[@FortoFight]

I'm not a huge fan of this twist tbh, it feels a bit like Moffat just invented it out of nowhere and you have to use a little contrivance to make it fit with the character we originally were introduced to.

[@piggyintheshadows]

Apparently it was planned nearly from the start. He told Alex Kingston who River Song was way in advance so she had an idea of how to act in her scenes with Amy since she's supposed to know the whole time it's her mother.

[@booradley8895]

Great episode followed by an awful one