Doctor Zhivago (1/10) Movie CLIP - Peaceful Protest (1965) HD

[@TJPoppy]

Timeless movie, if you haven’t seen this you missing out, they don’t make masterpieces like this anymore.

[@TruhliAhmo]

what a great movie.. yes!

[@ANProductionsOfficialChannel]

What a great way to show the horror here... by not showing it. Seeing Zhivago's reactions with the sounds is more than enough for us to paint pictures in our minds. Beautiful film.

[@rollingthunder9071]

AN Productions In my humble opinion it's one of the best films ever made; its acting, directing, photography, script, music and everything and everybody else that/who contributed to its making.

[@erictaylor5462]

In the original Alien movie, I think the Xenomorph is seen for a total of 34 seconds, and never longer than a few seconds at once. And you never ever see it clearly. The less you show, the more you leave to the imagination, and the imagination is way better than any kind of special effect you might dream up in 1965, 1979, or 2021.

[@SC1089]

No choice. In the mid-1960s, not only were special effects not good enough to graphically show it, but doing so in the time period would have made it extremely poor taste, and the censors would have gone crazy

[@twohawk1203]

It reminds me today, of Ottawa police on horseback.

[@exchequerguy4037]

Much like Hitchcock, who knew that it's what the audience doesn't see that heightens the sense of horror.

[@erictaylor5462]

I love how they depict the violence in this scene, simply showing it though the expression on Zhivago's face. Through his horror we imagine how terrible it must be.

[@Operafreak9]

Lean chose Shariff for the role because he wanted everything filtered through his perception. Shariff had to act with his eyes. The thing that stands out to me in this movie is the faces. I do not ever see a false emotion. In particular Rita Tushingham brings me to tears with just the blink of her eyelids, as if she thought carefully when she would blink, and the faces of Tonya's parents just amazing.

[@celesasheldon6931]

I don't have to pretend about living though horror.

[@jacktorrance9688]

It's done because CGI didn't exist in 1965.

[@erictaylor5462]

@@jacktorrance9688 You don't need CGI to create such scenes. Check out the Forbidden Planet,

[@josiahlomas2111]

Whats.more horrible...100 years of communist nuclear threat or a king

[@DelightLovesMovies]

I love a great film like that, it made me cry a few times..So beautiful and tragic, one of the all time greatest films.

[@cheeseandonions9558]

Amazing scene that captures the essence what happened countless times in human history

[@davidhawley3337]

It's still happening.

[@chop3625]

One of the most powerful scenes in film making history.

[@agenttheater5]

Quote from the IMDB page of 'Nicholas and Alexandra' from 1971: (after learning of the 'Bloody Sunday' massacre) Tsar Nicholas II: Why wasn't I told they were marching? Count Witte: Would you have met them? Tsar Nicholas II: How could I? Count Witte: Would you have given them a Duma? Tsar Nicholas II: Of course not! Count Witte: Elections? Schools? Tsar Nicholas II: No... Count Witte: THEN WHY BOTHER TO INFORM YOU? YOU WOULDN'T HAVE DONE ANYTHING.

[@numbers-stations]

If this was January 9 1905, then its very wrong adaptation of events here. No Red flags were present at that day, bolsheviks and mensheviks ignored it, instead they carried Orthodox icons, also it did not happen in the night. Nicholas and Alexandra showed more precise than this. Havent, seen this movie, maybe its not even Bloody Sunday showed there.

[@gideonharris1493]

@@numbers-stations the only Bloody Sunday I've ever heard of is from Northern Ireland in 1972.

[@numbers-stations]

@@gideonharris1493 Well that's certainly not the only one

[@gideonharris1493]

@@numbers-stations Ok. Cheers. Now I know.

[@oilersridersbluejays]

I don’t think it was meant to be Bloody Sunday 1905. It was possibly a later event as protests began to grow in Tsarist Russia.

[@billlombard9911]

One of the top movies ever made , this is a MUST see

[@Demille40]

Zhivago could only see the beauty in the world.

[@Wolfen443]

That scene is terrifying, is repeated over and over in history, eventually those who oppose a regime resort to violence or forces as brutal as the regime.

[@andrewstravels2096]

That in itself is the message of the movie. It’s lose lose for everyone involved.

[@patrickwalsh279]

I think you're right for the most part, but there is the astonishing exception of Gandhi (and it yielded another superb and, in the true sense of the word, epic film.)

[@アリアーヌ]

美しくて、時に残酷で。人間の様々な感情について深く考えさせる。素晴らしい映画です。オマー・シャリフの大きな潤んだ瞳が素敵。

[@drdeadbeat1604]

日本に住んでいる外国人としてこのコメントを見つけて嬉しいです👍

[@boin60]

최고의 명화. Dr. Zhivago.

[@JesusHernandez-dd9lo]

!!! Doctor !!! Peaceful protest

[@aliceneris9926]

É o meu filme favorito, já assisti muitas vezes, e quero continuar assistindo , sempre.

[@DS-wk1kn]

Does Omar Sharif have the world's largest pupils?

[@YouClickk]

May I ask, what school in what country did he used to teach?

[@worrywart1311]

@@YouClickk Not Lilliputia, that's for sure.

[@YouClickk]

@@worrywart1311 OMG, I mistook pupils for students

[@manoharmeka999]

@@YouClickk what for?

[@garrysmith6734]

The worlds largest pupils that have not been enlarged through cgi you mean?

[@EshBBX]

I'll never get over how solemn and sad the band already sounds while playing.. alone in the snow. Only to get cut down like that.

[@tomislavdumancic9034]

My third best David Lean movie.not as good as Lawrence or Kwai,but still damn good. And this scene is a dramatic masterpiece.

[@WilliamDoyle-rb6lt]

Omar Sharrif was great in 2 of my top ten movies. Dr Zhivago and my no 1 Lawrence of Arabia.

[@tucker.84]

Is it just me or the person in the thumbnail looks like Shostakovich?? I find that pretty interesting because not only does the band leader look a lot like him, Shostakovich was also a well-known Russian composer.

[@MrRrusiii]

Probably Julius Martov?

[@rebeccap6878]

Wow, you're right! I actually have Shostakovich playing in the background as I type this, haha.

[@Gooberpatrol66]

The character's name is Strelnikov

[@matthewlaurence3121]

He is a British actor named Tom Courtney. I think he was cast and deliberately made to look like Shostakovich, who after all was a man used to living in fear.

[@mariajurado1100]

Maravilhoso esse filme, assisti quando jovem 2 vezes, assim como

[@adil_a8873]

عده مرات شاهدت الفلم جميل الاخراج الموسيقى الأداء لكنه محزن موريس جار عمر الشريف رود شتايكر

[@saulponce946]

This scene is very sad.

[@freddy8479]

What authorities is the crowd confronting? MOUNTED POLICE? COSSACKS? or BOTH?

[@daniellocker6921]

Increible escena con el rostro de angustia y tristeza y impotencia se vio esa masacre es sus ojos 😢😢 pelicula extraordinaria que tengo en mi coleccion que todo cinefilo debe tener y aprender lo que yo llamo BUEN CINE ❤❤❤❤

[@HenryMcGuinnessGuitar]

Is this scene based on actual events? Someone said the Antipov/Strelinikov character was loosely based on Trotsky

[@troyschulz2318]

I believe so, some people have claimed Antipov's based on Dzerzhinsky but they don't really have a lot in common. I don't know if this scene is based on any one specific incident, but clashes between Cossacks or pro-Imperialist authorities and Reds were very, very common.

[@forickgrimaldus8301]

Also there were a lot of cases where the Russian Army did this, an infamous one was Father Gapon who was shot at in the Tzar's place.

[@valentinbalbinot5054]

It must certainly be. Similar events have happened in History, for instance the events of "Peterloo" in Manchester (1819), peaceful protesters asking for a change in parliamentary representation, over 80K people properly gathered and observing the rules were charged by the mounted yeomanry with sabres. Everywhere around the world those horrendous massacres happened...

[@k.arlanebel6732]

Trotsky was a top Bolshevik, even though he was assinated by Stalin. His story is nothing like Strenikov's. Strelniknov (Pasha Antipov) is not a Bolshevik and is in fact against the Bolsheviks even when working with them. He is an independent revolutionary. He is a fictional character who is created to portray someone who believes in the revolution passionately, but is eventually inwardly broken by how inhuman the revolutionary atmosphere becomes. Pasternak actually felt great sympathy for the tragic character of Stelnikov. Read the novel. It is another confirmation that the Russians are the greatest of all novelists.

[@exchequerguy4037]

It's loosely based on the Bloody Sunday massacre of 1905, though chronologically several years later.

[@allison88888888]

poor instruments 😢📯

[@HenryMcGuinnessGuitar]

I can't give that a thumbs up, but I confess I did laugh

[@allison88888888]

u meanie 😊

[@gideonharris1493]

No instruments were harmed in the making of this film. However I can't speak for the horses legs.

[@eadecamp]

Nobody should ever bring little kids to a demonstration no matter what the cause. Many of them are too young to understand what's going on, and they're just some adult's pawn.

[@exchequerguy4037]

Or human shield.

[@ritazanin1429]

Speak for yourself & your privileged kids

[@antonyware9887]

Obviously naively believed that the forces of reaction weren’t as brutal as they obviously were.

[@alecsardo2635]

Exactly

[@eadecamp]

@@ritazanin1429 I don't have any kids, if that's what you mean.

[@poilochien]

quand omar sharif avait demandé à david lean comment il devait jouer la scène, le réalisateur lui avait répondu qu'il devait essayer de faire comme s'il avait un orgasme ...

[@burtonrivera5253]

The irony is that Mr. Laura s husband to be starts out idealistic and becomes a tyrant. Rod Steiger first ravishes Laura, yet it is he who ultimately saves her....

[@peterweicker77]

Poor, peaceful Zhivago. So distraught. So passive. So helpless. Mass murderers are MEAN!

[@McAlbert]

Someone knows the tune played by the band?

[@jashvantlalfallawala235]

डॉ. झीवागो, ईस फिल्म के बारे में, मेने सभी समीक्षा हिन्दी मे पढी। इन सभी समीक्षा से प्रभावित हुं। लेकिन मुझे फिल्म के ईन कुछ अंस से, पहले से ही यह फिल्म देखने की आज 57 साल के बाद भी पुरी नही होती! 1965/66 मे ईस फिल्म के बारे मे, मेने बहोतसा साहित्य पढा था। आजके मोबाइल यूग में पुरी फिल्म नहीं देख सका। 1966मे शायद भारत-रशिया के राजकीय संबधो के कारण हो सकते थे??? शायद आज भी!!! क्या यह फिल्म दोबारा 70 mm के परदे पर हिन्दी डब्बीग मे रिलीज नहीं हो सकती!!!! फिल्म के बारे में तो बहोत कुछ लिखा गया या लिखा जाये गा, तम्मना मेरी यही है, फिल्म मे कैसी होनी चाहिए यह डॉ. झीवागो हिन्दी डब्बीग मैं फीरसे बदे परदे पर रिलीज हो। क्या कोई हिम्मतवाला.....

[@Mike_Spilligan]

Is this the future for Kier Strelnikov's Britain?

[@cheeseandonions9558]

Omg I was looking for the scene and I thought was like in the mid-movie... Never trust your memory...

[@Mdebacle]

You may have been thinking of the railroad station scene, a great scene.

[@cheeseandonions9558]

@@Mdebacle Did it also involve the Cossack riders massacre? I might have conflated them into one...

[@Mdebacle]

@@cheeseandonions9558 All I remember is Zhivago drafted by the partisans, then they had a cavalry charge against the White Russians across the ice.

[@Tripp1993]

A little behind the scenes note: Because of logistics and international problems at the time, this film was mostly filmed in Spain. It was where lots of biblical epics, some Orson Welles works like "Chimes at Midnight," and most of the scenes from the Dollars Trilogy as well as "Once Upon a Time in the West," were filmed. But it was still with the fascist leader, Franco, at the time. It was a way during the Cold War to give the West a further advantage. But when this scene was filmed, many people awoke. They were filming it at some point around 3:00 AM. They have overheard the tune and began to panic, thinking that he was overthrown... but they were told that they were making a film. So it was a false alarm.

[@1966johnnywayne]

You might also consider a warning to readers...Long, run-on Sentence Ahead.

[@Tripp1993]

Oh, sorry about that.

[@catrachocolo]

Made up story. While the entire scene was indeed done in Spain, it was filmed on a set in a studio. No people living there.

[@crikitaftw]

Franco's system and fascism are not the same.

[@davidgrover5996]

Franco’s system was closer to the theoretical ideal of Fascism than what Hitler or Mussolini achieved @@crikitaftw. But Franco was a Statesman first and foremost not a fanatic.

[@ST-hr4xv]

Could anyone please explain to me the context behind this scene? Would be much appreciated. Thanks

[@Beowulf1ca]

Whenever I hear the song "Violet hill" by Coldplay I think of this scene.

[@summer20105707]

This is what the Ottawa police did today. I pray for a revolution. God save Canada.

[@joanfirestone3469]

My husband never saw the movie, but I was telling him about this scene yesterday and said the movie predicted the Ottawa terror, trampling people with horses and beating them. Had to dig up this clip, identical all these years later.

[@summer20105707]

@@joanfirestone3469 the Ottawa Terror. From now on this is the name for this disgraceful crime.

[@summer20105707]

@@richardg1426 I see your point. But we have a leader with a God complex. Tsar Trudeau the 2nd. "Sarcasm" He brought in the emergencies Act formerly war measures act to crush a protest. People like him should not have power. He demonstrated that he will abuse it.

[@eadecamp]

​@@richardg1426 The only people who lived better were the government elites and their families.

[@gideonharris1493]

Can somebody please explain the wording on the signs? Thank you.

[@СергейСергей-э6э2н]

"Warshawanka" song, polish and Russian revolution song

[@gideonharris1493]

@@СергейСергей-э6э2н But what are the words on the banners?

[@СергейСергей-э6э2н]

@@gideonharris1493 "freedom and Brotherhood "

[@gideonharris1493]

@@СергейСергей-э6э2н Thank you!👍

[@СергейСергей-э6э2н]

@@gideonharris1493 find the film on KZbin "The Horseman Called Death", it is on the Mosfilm account, there are English subtitles there the film is based on the memoirs of Boris Savinkov, a significant figure in the social revolutionary movement

[@IronWarhorsesFun]

i love this movie because it refuses to take a side politically leaving it up to US the viewer, it simply gives us the vision of these events through the eyes of a bystander. Many of these events are clearly horrible but its still left up to us to decide what to think. this Nuance has been not only LOST but VERY DELIBERATELY destroyed by Modern Holywood.

[@poilochien]

j'ai lu le livre quand j'avais 20 ans et à part le fait qu'il est moins bon que le film, je me suis toujours demandé pourquoi le régime soviétique avait refusé de publier ce livre ... trop d'idéologie tue l'idéologie .

[@winningwinning8081]

Canada next , soon

[@JohnyZman]

About to happen again!

[@petersmith4202]

The bastards got paid back

[@JesusHernandez-dd9lo]

Ariana Grande hours and miles of peaceful protesting yesterday that got little to no coverage. all throughout beverly hills and west hollywood we chanted, people beeped and cheered along. we were passionate, we were loud, we were loving. cover this too please.

[@vanillaexplosion99]

Keep it up and you will find out how powerful the American war machine is.

[@drdeadbeat1604]

Not quite the same

[@ivanetedias9981]

Não vejo um corte desse filme em idioma português brasileiro

[@ericshackleton9454]

Failure of autocracies worldwide

[@ariella4444]

I absolutely hate mustache. I really can’t stand it on anyone, but I think the only man in the world who looks great with mustache is Omar Sherif

[@monichat]

Thanks for the REVOLUTION and LENIN

[@dcmaccabees5558]

Canadian Trucker protest, 2/19/22 (Colorized)

[@musicandfilms9956]

I come to this film ignorant of the story and context. Why did the demonstrators flee instantly upon seeing the cavalry advance? Was their determination for their cause completely dependent on the authorities' acquiescence? And what parent would abandon their small daughter as at 2:33?

[@isaacio8924]

Cavalry throughout history has always been used as a shock tactic in combat and war to break the lines of an enemies formation. The protestors mistake in this scene was actually fleeing in of itself. You see when a formation is charged by cavalry, the best thing you can do is stay in formation and packed together, as horses are intelligent animals and will not risk their safety charging down massive clumped together entities. The demonstrators fled because the most primitive defense mechanism our bodies have is fight or flight. In a dangerous situation, if you cannot beat an enemy, you run away. The demonstrators new very well what the charge (which started as a gallop) was going to turn into, and what the result would be-so they ran away. The parent I doubt abandoned their child so much as the child lost the parent in the general confusion.

[@genekelly8467]

@@isaacio8924 In "Ghandi"-the marchers laid down on the street-the horses would not trample them.

[@valentinbalbinot5054]

Cavalry has always been a symbol of power, authority and fear. A man mounted on horse is physically and symbolically "higher" than the rest of the people. Through history, cavalry has always been used to intimidate, break formation, pursue stragglers etc. It's always been symbolically and physically a strength of nature, already during middle ages and renaissance, a formation of heavily armoured knight had the kinetic power of a canon ball. A man tames a the horse, and elevates himself above the pedestrians. Through history horses were often more expensive than every other possession and only aristocrats could afford such a thing. Knights were aristocrats, and being so they were involved in politics and the right to go to war. The Hussars here were as every order in the army, a strong corps with its own culture and traditions. They could afford a horse and were elite troops and represented the order in place. The order of the rich and the monarchy. That's why this scene is also very powerful since it's literally the army of the rich vs the poor pedestrian miners. Also this scene is so strong because you've literally have an army of (peaceful) miners (they walk orderly in platoons like infantry on the field, with music instruments to motivate the troops) vs the more "noble" soldiers of "righteousness" aka the rich = mounting horses, which proves further what I've been discussing earlier. Being in the army was a real pride in the family back then, especially in the aristocracy. Then of course you had different ranks and some soldiers were more valued and prised than others (cavalry over infantry). I can't really remember but being in the army back then was the first son's duty, then cadet was to be lawyer, and the benjamin was to be a doctor (needs to be verified but I recall in this order) Society was very codified especially for the bourgeois. Sorry if I went a bit off topic but these things are all linked in a way or another. For the bourgeois, disorder has always been a threat (and the bolcheviks were for them the physical representation of disorder, disorder in society, in their vision of the world, in their establishment, in how the rich want to shape society).

[@musicandfilms9956]

@@valentinbalbinot5054 Thanks for that informative reply.

[@subkontrabasklarinet]

Is there a mistake on the banner? Shouldn't it read "bratstvo" instead of "bratsvo"?

[@ПАХАН.ЯУ]

subkontrabasklarinet Some of the Russian spelling has since changed over the years including some dropping or adding of letters

[@eoghannp8619]

Yes, this is a known ‘blooper’ in the film. Although the spelling of Russian was changed after the Revolution, the spelling of the word братство (bratstvo = brotherhood, fraternity) was not affected by this change.

[@DellaStreet123]

As great as this scene is, it is full of bloopers. "Bratstvo" was misspelt, several words on the banners use contemporary, post-Czarist spelling and I'm pretty darn sure no lay band in Czarist Russia would have had a sousaphone at that time. It did exist, but it was used in North-American marching bands. The Russians would have used a helicon (similar construction but with a slimmer bell that pointed downward) or a regular tuba.

[@KevinInPhoenix]

No written constitution or bill of rights means that the government can do whatever it wants.

[@அவானிஉயர்ந்தது]

Hard to decide whether the Tsarist Russia or Soviet was more brutal.

[@maragglez]

Ese no es el inicio. Falta la mitad.

[@barnesmultimedia2725]

The regime of Nicholas II was evil.

[@McAlbert]

Capitalism is evil

[@erickollman4441]

Maybe so, but what followed was far more evil. The Bolsheviks committed some of the worst atrocities in history.

[@sammyvh11]

All Russian regimes have been evil for the entire history of Russia. I know my family witnessed genocide in Latvia 1890s

[@poilochien]

il était très mauvais ...

[@CarlGerhardt1]

Compared to what Stalin did?!!

[@romanchomenko2912]

Ah there you who do not understand Boris Pasternak came from Ukraine and always had a conversation The Ukrainian front in the film yes his ancestors from Odessa.

[@garrisongosling2634]

Was this Bloody Sunday?

[@Beowulf1ca]

I thought Bloody Sunday was in Ireland

[@pyromaniac4240]

There have been numerous "Bloody Sundays" in history, and there have been ones in both Derry, Ireland. in 1972, and in Russia, in 1905.

[@thomasjanak8000]

The Bloody Sunday you’re talking about involved the palace guard lining up in formation and opening fire upon the Bolsheviks during one of their protests. Many were killed I believe

[@oilersridersbluejays]

Not the exact place and time, but probably in the same year (1905) I believe.

[@gideonharris1493]

Well there's a 1 in 7 chance...

[@silviaruhsen4666]

Seems, earth moves too slow

[@TheGrenadier97]

I come to see the cavalry, bah.

[@silviaruhsen4666]

Against any Zar

[@scotgat]

A government's (any government's) answer when people ask for bread and freedom, in whatever year. I fear America is headed for a time when the police and military will not hesitate to fire on its own women and children even for the most minor of protests. And it isn't as if it hasn't happened before: WWI veterans in the 1930's; Kent State, etc.

[@hannejeppesen2887]

Well, we are getting close.

[@Operafreak9]

De Santis passing laws to do that in Florida. Trumpism.

[@takashitamagawa5881]

It's a hard scene to watch now, thinking about what has happened to protesters and dissenters in Vladimir Putin's Russia. One thinks of Alexei Navalny.

[@hannejeppesen2887]

Perhaps the President need to watch this scene, and those who call for more aggressive actions towards the protesters. Protesters not looters, they are not the same.

[@Bfdidc]

It wouldn't make any difference to him. It doesn't affect him directly, one way or another.

[@vanillaexplosion99]

Most of the protesters are Marxists and need to be dealt with harshly. The US is not Russia 1917, the American warrior class is conservative, big, strong and heavily armed.

[@scottanthony4511]

@@vanillaexplosion99 Marxists? You are full of it.

[@donwalsh9426]

Ottawa, 2022.

[@Mastermind111111]

I feel sorry for the Cossacks

[@kazanefendu]

why? They betrayed the will of their own creed and ancestors by becoming dogs of a nation that has no care for their creed or ancestral will.

[@magallsys]

Similar to what is happening in Myanmar nowadays.

[@silviaruhsen4666]

Sovet don't need any leader

[@petersmith4202]

And what just happened with the British coronation no protesters allowed

[@eadecamp]

Were there protesters? Sorry for my naivete, but I didn't hear anything about that.

[@TirsoErnestoCastilloDeLemos]

Los cosacos del Zar.

[@newatit665]

Hey, this is just like the RCMP crushing the Canadian Truckers.

[@yjy5448]

Here is what is needed with the violent protests in the States

[@nhmooytis7058]

Yeah ‘peaceful protest’, heard that BS before...and recently...

[@CormanoWild]

Did you watch the same movie I did lmao

[@Cander509]

What else are you supposed to do with Bolsheviks?

[@eaglesfan226]

Ya know, the #Resistance could use a song like this

[@melofacertainage]

Yes, the #resistance theme should be the same theme from the Benny Hill Show, I think that’s very fitting for the #resist cause!!!

[@Zakk_does_Voices]

Based

[@dimapoc5853]

Clearly those cossack didn't kill enough of them

[@silviaruhsen4666]

I am a 'dreamee'

[@evansmith3589]

Madrid becomes Moscow!

[@CormanoWild]

America 2020

[@silviaruhsen4666]

❤

[@primusinterpares99]

.

[@JesusHernandez-dd9lo]

$$$ Peaceful protest We're following the money leader $$$

[@88mmFlaK]

One of the proper ways of dealing with communist mobs

[@hannejeppesen2887]

If the Tsar and the government had been more responsive, the might not have turned to the communist, but stuck with the more reasonable and peaceful Kerensky. Many people were hungry, there was a huge divide between the rich and the peasant. Not like in the US where most people have a chance to up in life.

[@An_Cummanach]

Let them take over the country? Lmao OK.

[@andro7862]

Killing citizens protesting for rights = good?