Does MYM Chapter 5 work?

[@JJ-yo2yq]

I think the reason why Opaline's way of draining magic is so overly complicated is cause the writers are trying to drag the whole "her becoming powerful" out as long as they can so they can have that one big moment in the final chapter where she does gain all the power she wants before being defeated. Also yeah i hate how they set her up as this big bad that not even Twilight could defeat yet half the time is either treated like a joke or has a catch that just makes her seem less dangerous.

[@TheSimba86]

she's the most underwhelming villain ever, she finally found a way into town and she couldn't do anything except steal a cutiemark and go back to her castle.

[@forestgrump4723]

I like the feeling that she WAS really dangerous but this is what she became after Twilight nerfed her. It cost Twilight everything she had, but she did manage to mostly nullify the threat as best she could, but she lost her alicorn magic so, as a last ditch effort she left a message for some Pony in the future.

[@Doomzdeh]

@@forestgrump4723 If that’s the case, they need to establish it. As it is, we are no closer to understand what happened in the past or where Opaline came from.

[@magnusm4]

Obvious problem: Twilight in the show, fights Dragon Ball level of explosions and super speed fights and large scale attacks. Villain who challenged later Twilight now with full power: Laser tag in a single small room. Twilight fought a villain who stole EVERYONE'S MAGIC including Discord. Yet this primadonna who NEVER appeared prior or was ever mentioned. Somehow challenged her to the point that she, as mentioned by the wiki, did the same thing as the others did against Sombra and cast a shield to keep her out. And here her full power doesn't even scale a fraction to what was shown in the original series? Reading the wiki and fan videos helped me learn all this and I'm just so disgusted at how bad this is. I don't even watch the show, but watching the reviews and break downs of this one ironically makes me like the previous gen.

[@LunarEchlipse]

@@magnusm4 She also Fought Tirek with the magic of all 4 alicorn Princesses and the elements of harmony, Twilight without the elements gets bodied by basically every villain in the show. Hell, Starlight was matching twilight. The show itself shows that twilight isn't as powerful as a lot of people make her out to be.

[@lukaza1261]

Opaline: "you havent defeated me" Sunny: "We know" some time later Misty: "we still havent defeated Opaline" Sunny: "WHAAAAAAT?"

[@MoonlarkSpirits]

*wheeze*

[@johannesseyfried7933]

Sunny: "I thought we were just having casual Villain/Hero banter. You know, Opaline says "Nopony can defeat me now" and I say "I can, because I fight for my friends"......"

[@lartcheche78]

I think the cutie blossom bash is something that might have been founded by the CMC, like seriously it's like really something they would do.

[@XVuler]

It really does 🤔

[@Beyondthe5thPanel]

Absolutely! That was my theory

[@danspotter8618]

I miss my Somepony Applebloom ❤

[@amesstarline5482]

Maybe that's why it's celebrated in spite of the split Pony regions.

[@lartcheche78]

@@amesstarline5482 exactly !

[@dragonpokemonlover237]

I think Sunny’s cutie mark is about guiding ponies through their troubles, as stars are often used as guides when people are lost.

[@-pastellovessans6703]

That’s actually a really smart theory, though I doubt the development team of G5 really thought of that.

[@LunamoonOwO]

This actually makes sense

[@Birdsflight44]

​@@-pastellovessans6703 I mean, its kinda in her name: Starscout, aka divining the stars, aka looking at the imagery representative of the Elements of Harmony in their raw form, which determine the destiny of the Element Bearers, etc. Give em some credit here

[@-pastellovessans6703]

@@Birdsflight44 Although im sure that the idea was there on paper, it wasnt very well executed in my opinion. But maybe the series is better then the movie. Ive only watched the movie, so who knows. Dont take my word for it.

[@Mazyb0i_lol]

@@-pastellovessans6703 how can you say the team lacks development when you wont even make the effort to watch? Hasbro has also extremely underfunded the project and tried to force the team tom use Ai for writing and voices which they have heavily declined. it's a behind the scenes battle.

[@PocketDeerBoy]

I think generally the writing suffers from two main problems: they're scared of ever raising the stakes so much so that anyone is in any actual danger. While FIM has it's smaller scale stories, it's not uncommon for run of the mill episodes to be about defeating giant monsters or vindictive performers taking an entire town hostage. They can't seem to decide wether to make opaline a serious threat or a gag villain for this exact reason. They want the drama of a serious villain but aren't willing to commit lest a character actually gets hurt. Stuff like characters potentially losing jobs, missing opportunities to attain goals, characters being roped into situations they don't want to be in? Doesn't ever seem to happen. Another major issue is that magic just exists to solve conflict, something which rarely happens in FIM. Magic is introduced to heighten a character's interpersonal drama or otherwise cause a problem that has to be solved through friendship. Spike gets overly greedy and possessive about getting stuff for his birthday? Bam. dragon magic makes him into more and more of a giant beast. Him remembering a time where giving a gift made him feel connected to someone else solves the problem. This show rarely does this, magic seems to be more of a beacon that simply points out the answer to whatever conflict the characters face. I wouldn't even care so much about weird continuity if it was simply able to tell better stories.

[@forestgrump4723]

I feel like the cutie mark appears when you discover the kind of pony you want to be. So, hitch got his because he wants to be the kind of pony you can rely on. A leader. Sunny got hers because she wants to be the kind of pony that helps guide others through their problem. Like a guiding star. Pipp got hers because she wants to be a pony that shines in the spotlight. Like a pop star. Zipp got hers because she wants to be the kind of pony to blaze her own trail. Cutting through the darkness of uncertainty like lightning. And Izzy got hers because she wants to be the kind of pony who uses what she has to make others smile. The writers just worded it poorly, and seashell…. Is a kid who hasn’t really figured out how her cutie mark ties into who she wants to be. Hitch THOUGHT his cutie mark came because he was kind but in reality he saw his friends being cruel and thought “that’s not who I wanna be.”

[@aspixenc]

I quote you "I feel like the cutie mark appears when you discover the kind of pony you want to be." and then you say "and seashell…. Is a kid who hasn't really figured out how her cutie mark ties into who she wants to be." So by the logic of your theory Seashell should not have its cuitemark yet. I agree with you about the rest, apart from the fact that in each episode there is a new writer, so it seems that they don't even have good communication between them.

[@forestgrump4723]

@@aspixenc I was trying to find justification for Seashell… in reality I think they probably just didn’t put much thought into seashell cause she’s a secondary character

[@lartcheche78]

In episode 4, when the heir of Moonadancer (forgot her name) speak of the past, she mention a story about a bat called "DAWN" (Luster Dawn) and the others were behaving but one of them didn't get along (Opaline) so she asked to a spider (Discord maybe?) To craft a web to keep her away(the bubble that surround the castle of Opaline). does anyone realise that we may have just been told what actually happened after G4 ?!!!!

[@lartcheche78]

@Crybabycream well at first i thought so, but then i realised that elder flower refers to pony as bats, therefor calling twilight a spider would be like saying she's not a pony. So i don't know if its Discord, but i am almost entirely it's can't be Twilight, but i might be wrong

[@starburst22]

So does this mean Luster asked Twilight to make the crystals? If so they're both equally responsible for Equestria's downfall

[@annajensen4982]

Maybe

[@ostenfeld66]

Twilight said in Chapter 2 that she used her power to place magic in the crystals. I kinda thought about something being wrong with Luster

[@lartcheche78]

@@ostenfeld66 yeah she did but perhaps the events of Opaline happened after that, maybe Opaline was defeated by twilight, then for a time things were okay and then Opaline came back (somehow) but this time was Luster dawn that took measure against her, and then trapped her outside of equestria

[@sleepyrosie]

I think elderflower has more going on to her personally. After talking about moondancer, she acts like she’s talking TO moondancer. I’m wondering if she may be capable of actually communicating with her ancestors’ spirits? With moondancer being a longtime friend of twilight, I could very easily see this being how she has so much knowledge about g4 era. Then again, she also mentioned a “sparkly wedding,” which kind of seems like a reference to Cadance and shining armors wedding (especially with the shining armor cameo painting), AND she recognized a hat from the carousel boutique (unclear if it was from Rarity or made during the time Yona worked at the boutique), so she could just be like the Granny Smith of the generation who has lived for an inexplicably long time, even though she most certainly should’ve died by now. She could also be getting some sort of ancestral knowledge that’s screwing with her memory, so things like the boutique and the wedding could possibly be things told to her by her ancestors? Ooorrr… maybe I’m just giving this show way too much credit lmfao

[@HImitsuRose4869]

She’s definitely getting knowledge from her ancestors, and she was talking to Moondancer (after talking about Moondancer). Her stories HAVE to be real events in history if she’s able to connect to her ancestors, and other ponies of the past. Maybe she can talk to Twilight and the OG mane 6 about what happened.

[@aaazzz8324]

Doesn’t Izzy also talk to some ancestor at some point ? Maybe this is a unicorn thing to do ?

[@imjustagirlletmeliveomg]

Maybe because unicorns are kinda spiritual in this series for some reason

[@BG_NC]

This. She was absolutely tapping into her ancestor's memories rather than her own. I highly doubt it was only a few generations based on everything else that has been mentioned about the time span between G4 and G5.

[@amesstarline5482]

It's weird how simplified the cutie-marks, that they're way more generic and vague- instead of the vague destiny things. Pinkie learns to celebrate for others, Twilight learns to unite magics (of 5 friends, but also 5 main non-ponies), Sunset is about the duality of worlds and her personality. By this logic, Starscout's should mean her unifying the three main pony types, or learning how to stand up for herself. She's the embodiment of hope, not compromise. Maybe from her reading and creating her protest signs. Also, G5 repeatedly undermining G4 makes it hurt both shows. Like how Part 6 of JoJo can undermine the other parts. Chapter 5's plots felt, while promising, just a bit too redundant- too much "hey I'm too excited to listen to you". Too much "Misty is shy and no one respects her boundaries". Also thank you, pickles are bad.

[@TheSultan1470]

Sad comment

[@baeldaikokuten_yj6792]

Kinda agree with you except for one thing because i like it when gen 4 is shown in gen 5 😊

[@zuzoscorner]

I know right, it not talent anymore it just...ugh i hate it!! Hitch's mark story si sooo...dumb!!

[@shane5326]

The cutie-mark removal got me wondering how powerful Opaline really is, especially in her "Weaker" states. If Starlight was shown to be able to remove the cutie marks of five ponies at once, what's stopping Opaline from doing the same? Sure, Starlight spent years to study advanced spells but Opaline has and would be around longer than that.

[@Eclipse-mf6hc]

12:52 don’t forget that Moondancer is mentioned in PRESENT TENSE. Whether intentional or not, that seems to imply that she’s STILL ALIVE

[@ikmwrime29sorryaira60]

That just makes it worse-

[@melit.]

I was quite upset at how the cutie marks were handled. Not even just the bad writing around them but how rushed it all was. It was like rapid fire then “Okay let’s move on now!” I agree with you on how Cutie marks shouldn’t have been a thing because of there was no magic. So maybe this part of the story could be something like no one has any cutie marks and society has changed to the point where people just choose what they do. And when magic came back at the end of the movie Sunny would be the first pony in however to long to get a cutie mark based on her actions of uniting the pony races. And then the series could explore the other main 6 getting their cutie marks a long with other characters. Maybe the cutie mark is in contrast with their current career path and/or hobby. They could not like what their special talent/destiny is. And for other characters their cutie mark matches perfectly with their choices in life. A pony could have expectations on what their cutie mark is. Another could think they have to stop what they do now because their cutie male says it’s not what they’re supposed to do. So that would be like personal driving conflict for the individual characters. Based on whatever issue they have in tandem with their cutie mark based on misconceptions from cutie marks not being around for a long time. So interpersonal conflict with Opaline as an overarching conflict.

[@DrawciaGleam02]

Honestly, I think G4's lore around cutie marks caused a LOT of confusion about how they work.... Even by the end of G4, some fans felt cutie marks weren't explained enough. The destiny aspect is something that some people don't like because it implies a pony's path in life is set even before they are born. Which goes against the concept of free will kinda. Changing it from "destiny" to "an aspect of a pony's personality" may have been a better choice in the long run.

[@starburst22]

Cutie marks shouldn't exist without magic. For example they just disappear off Celesria and Luna when they gave Twilight their magic! I like this fix here

[@TS_Tiziano]

If Cutie Marks didn't have to exist without magic, why when Cozy Glow almost stole all the magic, did Cutie Marks still exist? Or when Starlight stole the cutie marks, the ponies still had Magic?

[@elinasakura]

That sounds so interesting, I am mad that they did not use that in Make Your Mark. It would have given more characters depth and explore who they are and how react to their cutie marks and what they represent. Seriously, why did they not do it?

[@HImitsuRose4869]

I almost want something bigger to happen with the cutie marks. Opaline steals their cutie marks and as they fight for them, they rediscover their destinies then their REAL cutie marks reveal themselves or something. Like the other ones were just temporary until the magic came back

[@jameswalton5733]

man, its like every crappy fanfic writer got together, got hired by hasbro, and were told "go nuts as long as it involves mlp"

[@ronaldpagar6513]

Wdym?

[@lolfreakwaca4328]

Nah trust me, something better would have come out of that! At the VERY LEAST it would be more fun than THIS!

[@kajamaja7148]

Fanfic writers ussualy follow the rules at least

[@AstralArbourSystem]

Honestly as a fanfic writer I plan to rewrite the entire thing when it's over

[@sweetdreams1028]

That’s just an insult to fans who’ve created far better stories involving G4 and its characters. Particularly things like Princess Trixie Sparkle, Daughter of Discord, ect.

[@lucyheartfilliadragneel]

So many issues G5 has wouldn't exist if they just laid g4 to rest and did their own thing entirely. but noooo. they have to try to have their cake and eat it too

[@xpompomplayzzx]

As soon as I saw the locket- that Sunny got from the breezies-, I immediately thought of the red heart locket that was gifted from Twilight to Starlight Glimmer and her group after she stopped the changelings.

[@elijahwalton2248]

Thanks for your thoughts. Make your mark chapter 5 had jerked my tears during Misty's reunion. Also Opaline has become a little joke at this point and her threat level has shrunk significantly. I am still waiting for a shrunk pony episode so I hope it happens

[@TheLegitAlpha]

It seems that she chose the worst possible time to make her grand entrance, which is why nobody took Opaline seriously. I find it amusing. She could’ve taken advantage of it, but the fact that she prioritized being recognized as a threat over actually being a threat definitely says a lot about Opaline’s priorities. How often thought of Opaline as a narcissist, and it actually shows.

[@TheRavenir]

I do think the show is improving with every chapter, but I wasn't ever as negative about it as you were, to be fair. Misty is my favorite character and this chapter focused mostly on her, so I can't really complain.

[@jcj268]

I kinda want Misty to hang out with Zipp and Pipp more

[@PumpkinSpiceCookie]

Me too :)) I think the show is actually REALLY good in chapter 5 and I really liked it :> as it a kid I was very invested in g4 and I liked it because it was my comfort show and it helped me turn my brain off :> so make your mark for me is a really good show :> it’s fine for other people not to like it . but for what I like about shows I enjoy it :)) sorry if that was so hard to read

[@kangarueroo]

That locket the breezies give Sunny is probably Megan's from the older generations of My Little Pony. Especally since they have older ponies names from those generations.

[@autumbreeze1129]

You're giving the show far too much credit to be thinking something THAT impressive

[@VcSaJen]

It's pretty much confirmed. G.M.Berrow (head writer of MYM) even posted G1 screencap with it on her twitter.

[@_patrycj_]

When I 1st watched it, I thought this was crystal heart. Sure, is smaller and color isn't right, but still

[@TheSultan1470]

​@@autumbreeze1129 Well you've got a pretty crappy attitude then

[@RoseCadenza]

The locket heavily reminded me of the ruby heart that Spike gave to Rarity.

[@hoppa_2184]

"Family Trees" was fun, but Misty's so called sacrifice, while a great idea, was cheap. There are literally only three pony settlements in all of Equestria from what we know, meaning Misty had to be a resident of Bridlewood, meaning in turn it would be VERY EASY to find him. So, she did never need the key in the first place. Though the key and the door were stupid in the first place. Who built the door? Why is it here? Seemingly just so for that character moment...

[@LightOffArchives]

I’m really glad you’re doing these videos, cause I’m sure not watching the show but I still wanna keep up just in case it ever become decent

[@yondaime500]

What do you think of Opaline not being able to go to Maretime Bay until now? At first I assumed she wouldn't go there because she wasn't strong enough to take on all the ponies and didn't want to reveal herself yet (or because she's lazy and wants Misty to do everything for her). Especially after chapter 4 showed that she is not trapped in the castle and can leave whenever she wants. But now she's saying she "found a path" there. MB is physically pretty close to her castle, since Misty runs there and back multiple times in a day at times. And she can see it with her magic, since the cloaking spell that "used to be" around Equestria is gone (according to both Misty and Twilight in chapter 2). But Opaline still couldn't get there. But her magic could. But her magic couldn't see inside the Brighthouse. But the mouse made from her magic could. Her powers are so confusing. A show for 6-year-olds shouldn't be this hard to follow.

[@Star_Strike]

The entire thing is dumb. Basically, the writers seem to have this idea in their heads that magic can do anything they want for the sake of padding the runtime. Most of the random limitations that are given to Opaline feel like they just exist to make her plans take more steps.

[@little.prince]

I’m still so mad that the movie was so good and the show dropped the ball on all parts.

[@tratanlightbreaker6029]

Honestly the series went down so much that I'm more hyped waiting for Strikers review of a chapter, than for an actual chapter.

[@BuizelCream]

This is my mood now tbh, and I'm 1 month late, and I came for his review than watching the chapter myself 😅

[@lazeybeanszzz2289]

Also the old mare in episode 4 recognizes the hat a mare had on saying that its vintage and is from the carousel Boutique.

[@samssams666]

"Great Great Great Great Auntie Moondancer" could still be a long time since to ponies that's much longer than humans, going back to the calculations of the apple family tree, and the fact that Twilight's magic was still present to protect the three pony races from Opaline, the ponies didn't stop aging at their normal rate. However one thing I'm worried about is if Sunny will continue to age like every pony else or like an Alicorn. Also Elder Flower said something about Dawn bats and I immediately thought if she was talking about Luster Dawn too and not just Twilight, because that would make a lot more sense.

[@VcSaJen]

I have no idea why people are so hung up on four "greats". Newspony mentioned thousands of moons, Argyle mentioned 10 generations, Opaline mentioned hundreds of moons, and it is explicitly mentioned as "ancient" Equestria, not "old". But nope, gotta count "greats", even though it's usually just means "many".

[@amberwilliams6999]

Makes sense 🤔 👌 👏 😊

[@forestgrump4723]

@@VcSaJenWell, I thought it was actually kinda cute and clever to think we’re 5 generations removed from ponies we knew… but then, there could have been ponies in moondancer’s family tree that were named after her too. So great great great great auntie moondancer coukd be like, an additional 5 generations removed from the moondancer we knew. I like the 5 generations for gen 5 though I thought that was cute and clever

[@hoppa_2184]

"Nightmare on Mane Street" felt like a jumbled mess. Ponies not being excited for Nightmare Night activities was ridiculous. It is a holiday, they would be excited to celebrate it with different activities. Only later we learned Hitch planned too many activities with over two dozens of them. Not really shown before, but even then ponies would be excited to try out several of those. Also, Hitch was being a bit shy announcing things as a sheriff, showing they really push him into being Fluttershy...again. The golden bumpkin disappeared and was never found. Hitch promised a prize, but he had none prepared. Nothing is ever addressed in this hot mess of an episode. Then there was the B plot about the Crystal Frighthouse. They mess it up seemingly, because they are too focused on their own things and Pipp wants to scare Misty who is not easily scared. Misty not easily being scared because she grew up with a villainess makes sense and would be enough plot for an episode. There was too much and too little time, so both plots ended up being shallow. It was infuriating though that the bats that didn't scare Misty before, did so at the end. It didn't work once, so it is not something that would easily work on her and more creativity would be appreciated. Heck, how about a lesson that it is fine to fail at scaring her, before scaring her or not scaring her in the end. Or how about hinting that she is not easily scared in the episode and go with the Hitch plot. That way there would be foreshadowing for the following Nightmare Night episode. Oh, also no one ever bothered to inform Hitch or anypony else about the one stolen cutie mark. This should be a clear give away that Opaline can get out now. Stupid too, seeing how she went after the dragons after stealing one measly cutie mark. Like, what was the point? Sunny and co. should know about her escapades, because of the stolen cutie mark. Opaline is stupid, she should have gone secretly to the dragons to begin with!

[@seangoh4337]

Elderflower did share a story about a bat named “Dawn”. (perhaps Luster Dawn? Idk) Then she said something along the lines like: one bat in Dawn’s group went bad or something so Dawn asked a spider (Twilight maybe) to trap the bad bat. Maybe this ‘bad bat’ was Opaline somehow; perhaps she met Luster’s friends and was in their friend group. This could explain how Opaline and her friends grew that Together tree. Hey, maybe what we know as Opaline’s castle could have originally been Luster’s friends group’s castle together (like Twilight’s crystal castle), where they grew the tree.

[@alliesoapway1076]

I love Zipp and her whole detective plotline, but I honestly feel like that should've gone to Sunny? I feel like Sunny should've been the one to look into threats and magic and the history of Equestria. Sunny was such an active protagonist in the movie but in the show it feels like she barely does anything, and when she does she wasn't the one to take initiative.

[@paolopol05]

If you look closely, the locket the breezie gave to sunny in mane smelody seemed to be the rainbow of light from G1. Also I think that the not divided Equestria elder Flower remembers might be one a few years before the tribes divided but some years after Twilight's reign, as she doesn't seem to have any Memories about Twilight Sparkle. She just knows one of her ancestors was Moondancer

[@AstralArbourSystem]

It's also quite possibly a different Moondancer, either named after an ancestor that being the original Moondancer, or the writers just forgot that name was in G4.

[@paolopol05]

@@AstralArbourSystem could be but since we know how much they like to mention G4 things I think she was actually referring yo our Moondancer

[@pandanforsberg]

Opaline is a joke at this point😅

[@Stellecottonstar]

*g5* is a joke at this point

[@jusussi]

​@@Stellecottonstarvery unfunny joke

[@Izzymoonbow71]

Severely 😮 this is not funny opaline is dumb

[@hunterbennett757]

​@@jusussiDoesn't a joke have to be funny to be considered a joke?

[@spacedoodles]

@@hunterbennett757yes

[@Xxwolfloverxx8473]

This is probably completely off topic on the video, but I just thought about what the mane 5 represents Sunny - Kindness Izzy - Creativity Hitch - Justice Pipp - Beauty Misty - change Zipp - discovery

[@PokemonkaDub]

Tirek was able to take magic from an EMBODIMENT OF CHAOS (sure, he was taken off guard because he was emotionally taken advantage off, but still!) THAT shown us that he was a real threat because the only thing we've seen overpowering Discord before were ELEMENTS OF HARMONY that he was capable of beating sometimes too! So... yeah, they just didn't even try in G5...

[@SunnyPopFeline]

This is painful, I think we know how it could be or were excited for a wow factor only to be let down, this almost feels like 10yearold child writing a story with no reason or lore and the parent who makes animation said “this is great! Let’s make it, who cares about G4 logic and world building, let’s throw it out the window and make this”. I think the cutie marks part broke me ;-; Love your work! Let’s hope the show gets….ehh.. better ish? Still saying, rewrite the script and I’m sure people be happy to make art or even animatic your work :0

[@scarletlynx6856]

I have so many theories about the weird things in the plot 1. The personality thing for cutie marks could be a misunderstanding of cutie marks passes down from generation to generation 2. Maybe Misty bringing friendship into the castle has cause the tree to be able to connect to the other with the name 5 being there in chapter 4 and Misty just being there texting her friends. 3 maybe there actually is something hidden in the bat story being a metaphor for something and they missed it because they didn’t do what Misty said to but then they talked about the together trees and that over all sound too clever

[@MrConredsX]

I think the show started to get better but also way too late. Chapters 1-3 were so slow most fans just tuned out, which made Hasbro not confident to make another season of Make Your Mark and only focus on short Tell Your Tale stories. This happens when you start the show with a bang like G4 with Nightmaremoon.

[@Star_Strike]

You are looking very bombordious today! Take that how you may :) There were actually a lot more points I wanted to make, but this video would have been hours long. I had to cut quite a bit, but most of the points were either very small problems, or very small positives, so I suppose it's not too big of a deal. Tis the problem with reviewing 6 episodes in 1 video ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@olianameraku]

Hi.

[@team_lila]

why not make a 2nd episode where you talk about those. id personaly be intrested (like i am in almost every single one of your videos)

[@thesmashbeyonder5127]

I really liked this chapter, honestly. It was so fun! I enjoyed it as much as I did the last chapter, and dare I say, I enjoyed it as much as I did some episodes of G4.

[@amberwilliams6999]

Me too I love both g4 and g5 just as much 😍 ❤️ 💖 💕 💓 💗

[@OmegaFox09]

The more I watch this series, the more convinced I am of being this an alternative universe. Like a bad ending lol As Patrick Star once said: “Let’s take bikini pictures bottom and push it somewhere else!” (In terms of pushing g4 lore and disregarding it)

[@buriedinbooks881]

Honestly I’m willing to give the Opaline arc a chance specifically because the world does genuinely seem very drained of the magic it once had (in g4) and having the main Alicorn villain also not be very powerful makes this angle more compelling. Cause either 1. The magic being less has nothing to do with opaline at all or 2. If opaline did do it she must have been forced to give up a lot of her own power as well. I’m just kind of really hoping they’re not going to go for what I’m afraid they are… 3. Twilight herself drained the world of magic ability to try and prevent a huge disaster (like the ones she solved in her youth) occurring whilst the ponies were in disharmony again. I bring this up as a possibility because the previous lore of twilight storing magic in the crystals could be evidence to suggest something like this..

[@christinek232]

G4 COME BACK PLEASE

[@liongod360]

If Twilight really lost to Opaline then the means they nerfed the HELL out of Twilight!

[@nataliafernanda8660]

Anyone else not liking how MYM is handling the songs? They appear first in the spootyfile and when they appear on the show they are incomplete. mane family and it all take time were honestly a disappointment, the lyrics were so beautiful that when the characters sang it would be something super important it all take times even achieved a little but being cut in half ruined it, mane family didn't have any significant impact. It seems like they first make songs and then think about some context, most of the songs seem like they could work as any song and not as music for the show.

[@SaiyanWarriorofEquestria]

I like to think Opaline was just a lackey of a more powerful and competent villain who actually defeated Twilight, but Twi took them with her. So Opaline just took all the credit.

[@Aestholus]

Ever wondered why Maretime Bay is a coastal town seemingly has no harbour or ships but a light tower?

[@BuizelCream]

The movie seem to imply Maretime Bay used to have ships and sailor services and stuff, and I kinda headcanon the seawall they built was defense against other pony races. I guess I have been wanting to see more adventures in the sea for the series due to their location.

[@SkydreamPony]

I genuinely love chapters 4 and 5. The earlier chapters felt a little simpler, whereas now we have developed Misty more, Opaline's actively making her move now rather than mwahahahaing a lot, and we're getting the heckin DRAGONS :D

[@dragonspirit6689]

special talents are your personality and luminescence, so technically, they didn’t throw out anything.

[@dianamnajarro5119]

Sometimes i think about how in just a short time we ourselves tend warp and misinterpreted meaning behind certain things and actions. It could be that they lost so much of their history that they had to reinvent certain concepts that they know exits but no longer know how they function. I like this idea cuz in a away, if they find something feom the past that they want to bring back, its possible they would completely butcher it because they dont have the full picture of it anymore and we would see how they got their new ideas on how their own world works

[@socksthevaporeonlol]

at 5:23 izzy is like "oh god plz not again"

[@DanknDerpyGamer]

Opaline hissing at the pony who got close to examine her (thinking she was wearing a costume) was hilarious! IMO the more people raise the issues with the stories, plot, world/lore inconsistencies, the more I ... well, I try to remain optimistic, that struggle gets amplified though. Seriously, if they want it to be a successor to G4, or take place in the same universe, they REALLY need to do some study sessions where they watch and study FiM - that way they can improve their chances of being able to do things that at least try to remain true to the established lore, OR steer changes in ways that would make SENSE relative to what has been established. What makes it more annoying IMO is the fanboying over G5 to the point where some will accuse others of just not wanting G4 to end or some other malarky when that describing a part of the fandom that exists doesn't mean you can just accuse anyone else of that shit (nor would it negate specific criticisms). Seriously, this shit ... I've seen more toxicity toward peope who liked G4 and those who are cautiously optimistic, or even constructively critical of G5 than the other way around, contrary to what some will try to say, and it ... doesn't help anything, at all. If anything, it just drives people AWAY from wanting G5, and subsequent generations, to improve / be the best they can be. This in fighting, whether it be between people who like G4 and G5, G4+5 and those who like 3.5 and eariler, or WHATEVER combinations, doesn't help anyone.

[@bethanysingsmrs849]

im sick of negativity too

[@meimeilei]

Opaline is a bat pony from that old pony's story after all haha

[@DanknDerpyGamer]

@@meimeileiThat's true!! 😂😂

[@dragonteearts]

Always look forward to your reviews when each chapter comes out!!

[@0MG4ASTR0]

i’m starting to think g5 is not cannon bc NOTHING MAKES SENSE

[@Sugarsoleil_uwu]

Doing something small being your cutie mark makes sense in g4 since it meant something bigger. Hell all pinkie pie did was throw a party, but it wasn’t just a little get together. The meaning of her mark was spreading happiness to those who needed it. These cutie marks…are so disappointing. Like it’s just a lame excuse of their mistake. “Shoot we put cutie marks on the characters but there’s no magic…uhhh we need to get a crappy explanation to make it look like we planned it from the start”

[@danielrhouck]

10:07 Trees grow from the top, not the bottom, and kids shows would usually want to get that sort of detail right so they can claim to be educational. I think a better fix might be to have it blocked from the ground by something other than moss so you actually could see it from the air 13:02: If you do some math on numbers in G4 that you are absolutely not supposed to do math to, you find that Granny Smith is hundreds of years old. If we don’t want to say that nopony dies of old age (which would solve the time problem but open up a problem of it being harder for so much history to be lost), then we should probably instead not take the exact number of “great”s literally. In a line right before that she said she had the memories of her ancestors, which might be just a her thing. Alternately, she went to a completely different changeling wedding well after S2 of FiM. 17:30 Opaline did, and claimed her prize of one (1) cutie mark.

[@SilverSpoonRiche]

Opaline is Starlight's spawn. I'm calling it now. I don't know what Stallion's soul she must have stolen to reproduce or if MAGIC was all she needed for an immaculate conception with Trixie or whatever but Opaline is def related to Starlight Glimmer.

[@echossaisse]

Opaline was confirmed to be around the same age as celestia and luna for some dumb reason 💀💀💀 so this theory wouldn't work

[@SilverSpoonRiche]

@@echossaisse true. But I don't trust the writers to remember their own continuity regarding Alicorn Land and snobs Tia and Lulu. So I'm calling it that Secrets of Starlight will reveal how Opaline is a daughter a clone or Starlight herself corrupted. 😂

[@SilverSpoonRiche]

Well, this didn't age gracefully. 🤔 I never would have thought Starlight Glimmer could be forgotten so easily. Maybe she pulled a Spider Man NO Way Home and made the universe forget her. 🤔

[@SilverSpoonRiche]

@@echossaisse it's been proven doubly wrong because g5 does not even remember Starlight Glimmer 😂

[@echossaisse]

BUT THEY STILL SOMEHOW MESSED UP THE CONTINUITY 100 TIMES HWAHT

[@shadamyandsonamylover]

My biggest problem with the show is just HOW LONG it’s taken to get to the point. Releasing in sporadic chapters with inconsistent episode amounts is literally only hurting the show. Also, so much nothing happens. I did feel like you had a too few many criticism (like the evolution from the cutesceniera to the cutie blossom bash - that would make sense to evolve over time and with everyone divided), but most of the criticisms were valid. This world building sucks.

[@aaazzz8324]

Honestly, the way they drag the main plot for so long by using weird, pulled out of nowhere and incoherent events and situations, is what is most annoying for me. I think I would even prefer them to have episode that dont focus on the main plot at all, and just be kind of slice of life episode. If the goal is to fill time and they dont know how to do it with the main plot, i would prefer slice of life filler episode that aren’t necessarily related to the main plot. At least we wouldn’t have so many frustrating incoherences

[@Im_JOEL1]

I left a French toast on my desk and is gone has anyone seen it?

[@Star_Strike]

Noooo... 🙂

[@team_lila]

at this rate of "magic happend" opalin is just going to disapear forever because MAGIC and no i dot mean magic Casted by a unicorn or alicorn

[@EgonDaLatz]

Never would've guessed that Chapter 5 could be better than Chapter 4, but here we are! It was worth watching for Misty; she really grew on me and her character arc is, dare I say it, more believable that Starlight's was in FiM. However, my biggest concern is that MYM picked up momentum at the very end. I mean, there are only three episodes and a special left to wrap up everything. I wonder if they can pull that off - most likely resulting in a rushed ending - or they'll push everything onto the much inferior Tell Your Tale that sports a format not suitable for more complex and mature storytelling. Guess we'll see in November.

[@thomasoates3003]

Elderflower has access to historic information preserved in Bridlewood so is likely quoting that. Furthermore, Elderflower is a bit batty, and so I'd take anything she says with a grain of salt. Given there is no concrete definition of a generation, that argument also doesn't work. Furthermore, we do have confirmation that much longer than you suggest has passed. CanterLogic is described in the film as having been around for 30 moons, moon being consistently used to mean year in G5, and Opaline refers to not having seen Dragonfire in thousands of moons, so thousands of years have passed. Edit: Opaline is running at a fraction of her full power.

[@starshine5594]

Is nobody gonna talk about the painting of Shining Armour that Alphabittle held up when he and Misty were talking about her previous love of art?😏

[@christiantwist3360]

15:06 well it’s good to know everyone still remembers that holiday

[@TheCountryCartoonist]

In my opinion, it’s not that this gen is bad it’s just.. the writers have uh- not the best ideas 😅 the chapters would make more sense if the writers had better ideas! But, who I want to talk about is.. Misty! Here’s why she’s the best (In my opinion) character in this series! She’s not only an interesting character.. but she’s also relatable to some of the viewers! (Like myself) for example, people who’s trying to be themselves, battling with childhood trauma, being manipulated by someone, or someone who’s trying to be a better person! Honestly, she’s the light of the whole series! She’s just an interesting character! And Alphabittle turning out to be Misty’s father was a big plot twist to me, and it was sweet on how they interacted! Thank you for reading lol

[@Lugiamasterbrony]

One of my friends theorized that Alphabittle was Misty’s dad. As for the old mare….I kinda think she probably wasn’t being completely honest or had some things mixed up. Then again I believe it was implied that Granny Smith was over 100 years old at least so ehhhhh.

[@HulluRichie]

I personally don't think Elder Flower was born when Equestria was united. The show implied that she could see the memories of her ancestors and/or outright hear her ancestors speaking to her, so she wasn't actually talking about her own experiences... at least that's what I think the show was telling us.

[@chelsealee9568]

I love this guy he’s so funny and he makes a lot of good points

[@Rowan_Branch]

((Sorry for my english, i want to write more than i know how to)) I think cutiemarks still work the old way (show purpose), but are now just interpreted differently There were also characters in generation 4 who had their cutiemark decoded differently over time. Twilight's little stars denoted her friends from the future. Starlight's cutiemark is in the same style as her future mentor's cutiemark. Sunset Shimmer became a phoenix as an adult (and so on) It's likely that Sunny's comet, Hitch's shield, and Zipp and Pipp's crowns marked their fate, not their best quality. And as children, they were interpreted in this way as the most obvious (except for Zipp and Pipp, since they knew from the beginning that they were destined to rule) So Misty didn't understand for a long time why she got the butterfly in the first place. Change isn't her talent, it's her destiny. She went from a bright and loud child to a frightened and quiet adult. Now her goal will be to change back and become open again I think it's also necessary to hit on the theme of the message in these episodes, because not only do they talk about the changes of kidnapping victims in a childish way, but they also make Hitch start to think about how he's going to experience separation from Sparky when he has to be brought home!!!!! I love that despite the show's childishness, they are trying to raise serious issues and draw parallels The introduction of exact timelines also seems wise to me. Twilight's decision was wrong, but I can believe its realistic if she remained under-experienced as a ruler. Since Opaline had a together tree, if Twilight died, it really couldn't be allowed to have magic in ponies or together trees in the world. Not only does this provide a logical answer to the "where are the other locations from g4" question (beyond the dome), but it also opens up a huge world for the characters to explore. Dragonlands is the first of the new locations Don't even try to tell me that in a conditional 60 years ponies couldn't forget friendship and create prejudices towards those they can't contact. I live in Russia, I know it's possible and in a much shorter period of time I on the contrary have questions for episode 5, because it had a very specific situation, the correctness of the message of which was indicated by small details that children are not able to understand. "Always tell your friend the truth" is a bad message, since you have to be able to separate truth from rudeness. Jazz didn't insult Pipp just because the flower was really stinky. But if we hadn't been shown the public reaction, told the name of the flower, and brought in the neutralizer at the end, it would have been an episode about how Jazz doesn't like the scent, so she tells Pipp that it stinks. And it's kinda rude.

[@christinaguzman9839]

The way he got mad in every single of make your mark is so funny 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣😂🤣🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂🤣😂😂😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣💥💫💥👑😂🤣💥💫

[@LaissezFairyWriter]

I haven’t seen anyone talk about the significance of that locket. It is a direct callback to the rainbow light locket from G1. Since this series “supposedly” follows G4, all three shows might be connected. The implications of this are interesting for sure.

[@random-productions1837]

in hindsight, hitch’s backstory could make more sense while typing in the whole kindness thing is if he got it from being fair and treating everyone equally in the course of upholding justice

[@icecrystal7965]

**Cough** Misunderstanding with Elder Flower She does not directly remember Equestria before it was divided, she has advanced ancestral memory Her Great Great Great Great Aunt was Moondancer (missed a great) So, it's been a **few** generations, as in geneology, that translates to the sister of her great great great great-grandmother Or 6 generations, about 150 years, if we're talking generations being 25 years... which they're ponies so who knows Considering barely anyone has a living ancestor older than great grandparents. Actually I don't know of any who do have a living great grandparent, but then, my family has slow generations and I don't get out much.. So adding 3 more greats to the already large great grandaunt is a decently big deal. And in Equestria, with the exception of the alicorns, the oldest living relatives of any given generation seems to be grandparent. Granny Smith being pretty much our best example. Also noting Granny Smith, pony lifespans seem to be longer than humans, though, considering she only made it to grandparent before dying, rather than great grandparent, it seems But no, Elder Flower is actually evidence of the opposite of what you thought it was So, you don't have to have that detail infuriate you anymore, with pony lifespans and stuff it pretty much guarantees a minimum of 150 years have passed between generations (since her name is Elder Flower, and unicorns seem to have a reverence for their old, and Elder Flower, and presumably her family are the oldest to hold the Elder title, they probably have longer generations, perhaps in the 35 year range, which would put us at 210 years, which isn't far from, say, the age of the United States), with no living witnesses of that era other than Opaline, Discord if the G5 comics are canon, and.. whoever else they may add, if anyone

[@sophypophy]

18:40 I WAS THINKING THE SAME THING 😂😂 Alphabitle (I can’t spell) is going to go nuts when he figures this out. And possibly try and take Misty away himself which I personally am DYING TO SEE 😂🙌🏽

[@Maczcheese]

Sunny’s cutie mark represents the spark of reason Hitch’s cutie mark represents protection, kindness is a way of protection

[@elpisgalaxy8934]

Whats next? Opaline is sunnys biological mother? That would be so weird.

[@yondaime500]

I mean, where else would Argyle have gotten all those artifacts he had? Maybe you're onto something.

[@NightCloudI]

Imagine if it's true. It isn't so far fetched though.

[@twilightsparkle2764]

Sunny is a clone of Opaline....who knows what else can screenwriters present.

[@thethirdnote]

13:20 the together trees are basically versions of the tree of harmony

[@Murdockchern]

When you said it also means pickles suck in and a ad appeared out of nowhere so it made it 10x’s better

[@bluewolfYT578]

13:29 I thought you were going to mention the changlins (idk how to spell it) she talked about

[@Crazylittlehobbit]

The age thing in MLP is always a hard issue, remember how old Granny Smith was, there when Ponyville was founded, and Per Twilight's Ponyville was hundreds of years old when she arrived there. So it could be hundreds of years since G4.

[@KopyErr]

the 'Cast: a fishing line' was stupidly funny for no good reason 😭😭

[@lucarionite6538]

They should consider hiring you as a script reviewer

[@hoppa_2184]

"Father of the Bridlewood" was alright, but I feel Alphabittle should have at least been right with one of the activities instead of all of them being wrong. She should have liked something from her childhood still. Not my biggest gripe with the episode though. That goes to the end of the episode, where Misty's dad decided, she can live with her friends and Misty also agrees along with her friends which doesn't make a lick of sense. They just found each other. They should spend more time together than a day, to truly reconnect. Misty can move in a few seasons down the line. This episode gave them no time to grow together as much as they needed to be. Also, what about him finding out she is a double agent for Opaline? How about some fatherly worry and conflict as he doesn't want her to endanger herself. Also also, what about Misty having to deal with her double agent life? Her being out constantly would draw attention from Opaline. All of this is handled extremely poorly. There is a lot of material for episodes right there. Heck, if they went with the Opaline as a caring mother idea, this could cause a conflict between two different parents as well! And where is Misty's mother? Her being not around anymore could be an interesting topic as well, in case her mother was still alive when she got lost. So much wasted potential!

[@Flycanjack]

12 seconds in and I'm already bombarded with dad jokes and puns 😭

[@sparxstreak02]

14:44 Another continuity error - the Breezies stated in Family Trees Part 2 that their night market opens randomly but Sunny & Zipp just arrive at a time the market happens to be open 😑

[@MrConredsX]

I also don't think Elderflower literally remembers Canterlot Wedding. I mean is it even possible to be alive when your Great great great great aunt Moondancer is also alive and young?

[@Butterflygirl659]

11:26 that sounds EXACTLY like that episode with Rarity and sweetie belle, and Opaline is just copying Starlight and Tirek in this chapter.

[@jusussi]

I thougt exactly about that XD

[@NightCloudI]

​@@jusussime too 😅

[@yondaime500]

That was a very entertaining review. I think Elder Flower mentions those events like the Canterlot Wedding as if they were her own memories, but they are actually memories passed to her by oral tradition. So this doesn't change much about the timeline of the show. It is "many moons" after the events of G4 and that's it. Regardless, it is still insulting that they imply that all of Equestria fell because of Opaline, and then write Opaline to be so stupid and incompetent. That's one of the big problems of G5 for me. But given that the mane 5 didn't even know they hadn't defeated her, I guess she has to be this way for them to have any chance against her. My new headcanon/coping mechanism is that she developed dementia over the years, and the ponies had their minds scrambled by Twilight's bubble spell somehow, and so everyone kind of operates at a lower level compared to G4.

[@Star_Strike]

Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed the review! I think you're right that it is possible the events of G4 were passed down through oral tradition, but that still doesn't solve the problem of Moondancer only being a few generations older than her.

[@RoyalAspects]

Personally I liked this chapter especially when misty reunited with her father and pipp and Izzy are psychos at times as usually. Just mindless stupid fun to forget the BS of life😂

[@MewDenise]

Yeah... I thought maybe the writers could save this but not anymore.

[@GaryLuKOTH]

Strangely, I like those credits at the beginning better than the show itself.

[@Skyler_Moose]

This show is starting to remind of dragons the nine realms

[@smarikaprinces7436]

This is completely off-topic, but I just wanna mention that in G4 testing testing 123 there is one time where twilight is saying something about the wonder bolts and her mouth stopped moving while she is talking

[@katmaresparkles9578]

The locket Sunny receives is the one given to Megan in G1 that contains the Rainbow of Light. Which means that it will be what truly defeats Opaline. So I am also wondering if the Rainbow of Darkness is in Opaline's possession somehow.

[@forestgrump4723]

Omfg! The rainbow of light is released and all these stupid horned and winged animals are revealed to be the lost generation of ponies since part of what the rainbow of darkness did was change ponies into other things! ….nah, they’re not clever enough for that.

[@Josivis]

10:01 maybe they were hinting to seeing the bigger picture, In the air she could've used her analytics and saw a pattern in the overgrowth

[@samssams666]

"About being unique" She's a fillie. So I'm going to assume that was just her representation about her cutie mark and that isn't actually what it stands for because she was probably grown up around people who boosted her ego.

[@jetragnarok2075]

I was literally saying "be for justice plz... be for justice plz..." and then "KINDNESS" Wha-. Since when being a sheriff is not more about justice rather than just kindness, besides he wasn't just kind, he was fair and just giving the pony a chance to play with them. Unbelievable how they missed another chance. But hope is still there...

[@haishalinkz3121]

6:49 Hitch supposed to know breezie language. Given the fact he's 'Fluttershy try hard copycat' Breezy appears on Legit MLP and only Fluttershy understand them

[@meimeilei]

Seashell: I am unique! Also Seashell: tries to be just like her idol Pipp!

[@TheSimba86]

I did enjoy chapter 5, Misty pretty much carries the show now for me. also Opaline is pretty much a joke, at this point I half expect the final battle between Opaline and Sunny to end with Opaline tripping on a rug and falling down a set of stairs

[@christinaguzman9839]

I love this channel 💫💥

[@pippxsunny]

Chapter 7 is about to begin on September 24 I can’t believe it!🎉

[@totallytylergames6888]

I think the reason cutie marks make no sense in g5 is because of magic being gone for so long that the cutie mark magic escaped from the crystals and for being locked away for so long it sort of changed its way of appearing since it was locked away and i think ever since martime bay day's crystal disaster, it might have messed with cutie mark magic even more, making it like wishing lantern!