Don Giovanni - Commendatore scene (Furtwängler)

[@funkycatglasses01]

Furtwangler of course is phenomenal🤩. But the singers though🤯. Thank you for posting!

[@FabioPBarbieri]

Cesare Siepi was a superb actor in a wholly operatic mode - standing still or measuring the stage, but always in the service of the character. He has got Don Giovanni exactly right - the way he is continuously nerving himself up, forcing himself to do something he knows is insane, just because "a torto di viltate tacciato mai saro'" - he does not want to be called a coward. And that is how the Statue ensnares him. This is the best Don, as a piece of acting, I have seen so far.

[@johnspradling7906]

Terrifying scene and acting. Furtwaengler draws superhuman power from the music and the scene. Dated visually, but very well sung, and the effect cannot be argued. Superb.

[@wolterzz3267]

This is how every Commendatore scene should sound. Slowly building up to the big climax.

[@murrayaronson3753]

The first Don Giovanni I ever saw in March 1966 at the old Metropolitan Opera House was with Cesare Siepi. Alfredo Kraus was Don Ottavio. Pilar Lorengar, Justino Diaz, Fernando Corena, and Theodor Uppman were also in the cast. I was too young to realize how outstanding a performance this was. Sometimes youth is wasted on the young.

[@jjrj8568]

Poetic comment; sometimes I think "growing up/getting older" is about fully grasping the things I discovered (but didn't fully understand/appreciate) during my youth, classical music/opera included

[@allenjones3130]

I'd have to take a guess that Corena sang Leporello, Uppman played Masetto, and Diaz portrayed the Commendatore. "Don Giovanni" is one of those operas that beg to be performed by an all-star cast.

[@marcmo2004]

The slow tempo makes it more powerfull and this enhances the magnificient voices of Siepi and Deszo. Despite the two same tone of voice (bass), this is a great performance led by Furthwangler.

[@ecisme10]

Siepi did a great job as Giovanni. It was slowed a bit from how I normally hear it but it works. I think his acting was great because it wasn't too subtle or static and wasn't super over the top. Glad I found this.

[@BorisGodunov]

It IS slow, but that's because Furtwangler wrings every note out of it. It's magnificent.

[@VallinSFAS]

Wagnerian. I think Mozart was trying to lead to this. Definitely in his swan song Requiem.

[@natashkk]

Incredible!! What good conduction of the orchestra!! And the singers are sublime!! 5 stars!!

[@woncho99]

My favorite Bass of all times, Cesare Siepi passed away on July 5, 2010. Rest in Peace, Maestro Siepi. You were the greatest.

[@alejandrosotomartin9720]

outstanding sound, incredible orchestra, how lucky we are to hear this

[@BaldricOutremer]

In my opinion, the slow tempo is absolutely perfect for the scene. The one moment when it could be a bit faster is when the Commendatore is urging Don Giovanni to repent. Siepi is an incredible singer, a good actor and likely the best Don Giovanni I've ever heard.

[@saracaselanizilio4627]

Totally agree! Siepi is the best don Giovanni ever

[@2gtomkins]

There's nothing wrong with Siepi's singing, but whoever is responsible for that bit of stage business where he tries to stab the statue (at 4:26) should be shot at dawn.

[@AlBarathur]

No other version I have seen so far is so dramatic as this one. Thank you for uploading it was refreshing.

[@Johnny1206]

Siepi and Furtwängler!!! This is absolutely a perfect match, never to be equaled.

[@godzilloid]

His voice is great, and he acts out the arrogance of the character perfect.

[@davidshengelia4798]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZ3JXp-rZd6ZeLc

[@aladarmiklosdr.szentkiraly7548]

Perfect ! Furtwangler s tempo...the orchestra.........simply the best

[@talvela100]

Registrazione storica di enorme valore. Siepi è immenso!

[@donboia]

I just love this version of the Don Giovanni's Commendatore scene. Both singers are awesome, and the timing followed by the director is just perfect to create the feeling of... "fear/affraid/suspense" to the public. Just perfect. Bravo!

[@adityapurohit8232]

A gem of a performance. All three characters are performed with great authority, Furtwangler's sublime conducting adds to the tension of the scenes. Thanks for loading.

[@voraciousreader3341]

“Sublime conducting,” with a tempo twice as slow as was conducted then or now?? I don’t know if it’s the conductor’s tempo or if the film has been slowed down, but it’s horrible, whichever way is the truth.

[@fernandsanchis9881]

Très impressionnant! Sublimes voix, mise en scène effrayante, musique extraordinaire! Un grand moment, à la hauteur du mythe!

[@tiago3m]

Wow! Most perfect interpretation I've ever heard. Sublime, perfect, creepy! Slow and deep, perfect driving!

[@sas147741]

I'm almost in tears, this is so beautiful....

[@shakaama]

god giovanni's siepi's voice is ridiculously good. he's like a fog horn across the water, just warning you not to come near. it's as clear as a bell and as strong as the sun on the sahara dessert.

[@davidshengelia4798]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZ3JXp-rZd6ZeLc

[@Lordofdeath127]

greatest music ever written....

[@matthewlaurence3121]

It frustrates me that I cannot find such shows of operas in Germany to-day. The performances can be terrific, but this business of putting the performers in modern clothes in 21st century set-surroundings and adding a little gretuitous nudity now and again detract from the majesty of the material.

[@lizardking02793]

I agree with the modern clothes in the 21st century, but as to the nudity, I think it depends on the opera. For instance, I saw a version of Tannhauser where the woman playing Venus undressed completely in the scene where she tries to appease him, before banishing him. In that instance I think it fit for the scene.

[@thomasborgsmidt304]

lizardking02793 The problem with nudity in opera is that most sopranos are a bit to the plumb side - if not downright fat!

[@lizardking02793]

So what, the music is great still. and not most are fat. i've seen many thin sopranos and some of the the world's best sopranos are thin. Anna Netrebko, Renee Flemming waltraud meier, Natalie Dessay, and Angela Gheorghiu

[@thomasborgsmidt304]

Hmm.... Your comments have had me thinking: The problem is that it is difficult to detach the music from time. I'm not here talking about fashion which is sort of cyclic thing allowing pottery to be dated with a precision of 30-40 years. Fashion makes Lauritz Melchiors stage dress up with winged helmets and the works seem downright ludicrus. No - I'm talking about detaching Händels music from its time. You can play it on the periods instruments, but most of them were terrible by todays standard. Crumhorns f.i. cannot be kept tuned, say little and are generally a lot of trouble for meagre results - so much in fact, that by todays standard it is not possible to earn a living as a musician. A lot of the music is composed to get around the limitations of the instruments - the harpsicord and chembalo make trills because that was the only way to keep a tone ringing. It is problematic to substitute an electric guitar for a lute. Few want to reintroduce castration to provide the cast for a Händel opera - quite apart from the wastage: 1000 castrated to produce one acceptable performer. We are all products of our time and nostalgia isn't what it used to be: Any historian knowing anything of a period would want to go back in time to the renaissance and its disease and poverty ridden hell-hole.

[@thomasborgsmidt304]

lizardking02793 Were thin: That is the operative word. The fact is that most women get a bit on the heavy side with age. As to the quality of sopranos then we could point to Maria Callas that bantered and lost voice. The fashion with thin women and models is more marketing related. Models are thin, because that makes the costoumer recongnise the dress on the rack. But my real issue is that I consider nudety on singers an insult to the singers: Just look how Cecilia Bartoli suffers because she hasn't a great dress to show off in stage productions.

[@dumspirospero-s1l]

voilà comment deux artistes extraordinaires chantaient il y a soixante trois ans j'ai monté le son pour apprécier ce duo de rêve chapeau !

[@idaspe]

What a DonGiovanni!!! Great voice, so deep...!!!

[@sinafatemi-s5q]

Tears coming from my eyes for this great performance. Gives me chills.

[@JmmrtnzYT]

What a wonderful version! It's epic!!!

[@arturogrady9064]

The best Don Giovanni

[@kid926]

Cesare Siepi In don giovanni davvero insuperabile una voce che fa tremare i muri

[@shaguree]

The most powerful scene from Don Giovanni!!!

[@kuglagerfeld]

the best commendatore scene ever!

[@A3MinuteEgg]

Vladimir Gligoric ikr!!

[@OperaSamia]

The BEST from the 20th Century! Can't wait to see what follows!!!

[@user-ph4tm8ps2e]

Merci pour cette version.

[@HellasItalia4]

Cesare Siepi (1923-2010) Il mondo ha perso uno dei piu grandi cantanti di sempre. Grazie Cesare

[@faye872]

The demands of this opera on singers and orchestra are just so great. Technically and emotionally. It is really terrifying.

[@agadigby]

absolutely timeless!

[@GGbreizh]

Furtwängler in colour, impressive. The great man unfortunately died short after this performance.

[@fakepapertiger528]

Hopefully not by statue

[@paulostroff99]

@woncho99 -R.I.P.Cesare Siepi.One of the all time greats. We shall always remember you.

[@hymnodyhands]

This is really slow by today's standards ... but as a composer I like how I can distinguish every note in every instrument, and thus HOW Mozart created this rich tapestry of drama... an expected treat on top of the splendid acting and singing!

[@EmilyGloeggler7984]

There is no splendid vocal acting here.

[@Jeff-lf4hy]

​@@EmilyGloeggler7984what Are you talking about idiot. This is legendary. One of the best don Giovannis EVER

[@andrewvincenti2664]

@@EmilyGloeggler7984as if you sing better😂😂😂

[@mirjamdevries9376]

Per me la più emozionante tra le scene finali del Commendatore: Don Giovanni che cerca di colpire uno spirito con il suo pugnale! Due grandi e stupefacenti bassi profondi a confronto.🔥👍

[@ElisabettaVS]

Wonderful music, only my dog goes crazy listening to this xD She barks whenever the statue sings xD

[@A3MinuteEgg]

ElisabettaVS lol

[@shalva92]

ყველაზე მაგარი ოპერაა ოპერათა შორის! Best opera of all time! Лучшая опера всех времён!

[@luisrincon7819]

Georgian

[@FabioPBarbieri]

And notice how often his hands go up to his neck - it is as if he is feeling the noose tightening there.

[@ksh430]

the best don giovanni

[@davidshengelia4798]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZ3JXp-rZd6ZeLc

[@alexandredarrasse5068]

Sublime...je pleure à chaque fois comme un fou...

[@FranciscoFerrerGaliana1930]

Simplemente impresionante.

[@ub12581]

Questa versione dell'Opera è FANTASTICA e io ho la fortuna di averlo in dvd! Cesare Siepi è il migliore Don Giovanni di tutti i tempi, seguito solo da T. Allen

[@qwerty6383]

Pls upload with better quality :3

[@shadboltbill]

Three basses onstage at once! Heaven!

[@ceci1993chap]

è la migliore opera mai concepita e scritta

[@sawahtb]

I never got a chance to see this Opera in a theater, but now I can check out many versions and singers. I really love seeing the different ways it's interpreted. I've seen only a few Operas in my life but Mozart's are the best.

[@daepi199]

06:03 Siepi's scream is real super fucking sexy and his "oime" sounds really cold.

[@MaChiHofmann]

Furtwängler ist einfach unglaublich wie er die Sänger und Instrumentalisten animiert zum Äußersten in Ausdruck und Darstellung zu gehen.

[@morecassoulet]

What a gem.

[@paga123]

Fantastic and very different from the today version.s The best quality of this version : it is disturbing ! yann

[@kuangsu]

una statua di bronzo o pietra che sia NON PUO' avere una voce umana , trovo il vibrato della statua del Commendatore una soluzione geniale , A DIR POCO !!!!!!!!!!! ... un CESARE SIEPI degno figlio di APOLLO ... passeranno i secoli prima di avere un DON GIOVANNI DI QUESTA LEVATURA ,,,,, GRANDISSIMO FURTWANGLER ..... GRAZIE !!!!!!! ...

[@francescaemc2]

Respond to this video... Thank you for posting this, from the bottom of my heart. Grazie mille!!!!!!

[@Gorboduc]

Anyone who complains that this is too slow really doesn't deserve to listen to it.

[@TS57ovr4]

@Goethefemme It's not that basses were not popular; they were were quite common in leading roles, actually. It was the baritone part that was not often significant role and was not written as "baritone", but actually as just another bass. Baritones did not come into popularity until the late Classical/ Early Romantic periods.

[@davidkahil5158]

Furtwangler always did the best stuff

[@natasolen]

Semplicemente geniale!! Se adesso cantassero cosi!!

[@clivepapayanis3121]

Despite "slow" tempi, not always consistently "perfect" singing there is no better document of this opera in its entirety than this performance. Dare you to find one.

[@bebetonguga]

Me pone la piel de gallina... Realmente es genial!!!

[@elijah24567]

Excellent.

[@harmonieautog]

Ernsters' voice was never the same after he was released from Bergen-Belsen concentration camp. Truly a pity....the vibrato was very limited prior to his imprisonment there.

[@langengro]

At 1:55, when they painfully extend the grave "Altre cure più gravi di queste", Don Giovannis bodily movement appears to freeze with the music.

[@wotan20]

I like it this way, something almost like a Wagnerian drama. Reminds me the Flying Dutchman in its dark, sweeping emotions.

[@Selkaen]

Sorry, I wrote it as I saw it written. Thank you for correcting.

[@ReachRoadSedg]

Quite magnificent. Life can be lived, but death cannot be denied Thank you.

[@ombra004]

Mi sconvolge ogni volta!!!

[@florencioigual]

What a pity this old recording didn't benefit from today's technology. Such a powerful rendition

[@veristaconvicto9881]

Splendido!

[@brunopreisjunior8489]

comece com trios,quartetos, sinfonias.depois a opera. opera e o topo. o topo da evoluçao musical.

[@kuddelfranz20001]

Phänomenal Danke

[@AdrianMutu87]

by far the best

[@ettoremonamour]

Bravissimi!

[@Antipaavi]

This strikes me! The musical interpretation is good and the singers act exceptionally well. The tempo is indeed slow, but it creates a very doomsday-like atmosphere. I wish I could only find it on VHS or DVD. Selkaen, do you know if this is acquistable somewhere? Where did you get it from?

[@edmundcampion9888]

I very much agree. The slow temp helps us to realize how terrifying this scene is.

[@paulostroff99]

Stunning performance.TY. selkaen

[@albertoserrarsm5658]

Brividi

[@BaritoneDeLaTorre]

Yes, Don Giuanni is for baritone, but Cesare Siepi was bass.

[@blakecarterpiano]

This version captures the feeling of hell pretty well.

[@pietroarvizzigno4417]

Superbo

[@sweetaliena]

I was thinking the same thing! The closest embodiment of this version is the Kurt Moll version.

[@debradorfman7940]

Moll also sings the low D at the end.

[@penkoviq]

absolutely correct!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@francescaemc2]

@woncho99 Maestro Siepi was a baritone. You are correct about the greatest part:)

[@rosy3385]

Sublime même si c'est ancien !!!

[@theprivateer83]

Furtwängler IS GOD

[@raynardi7243]

da brivido

[@robertanico]

Agghiacciante, bellissimo.

[@paga123]

Hi It is my favorite opera piece and I am a real fan of Furtwängler , in Beethoven specifically. Here I am a bit mitigate : I like the conception (slow and momumental) but the realization seems not really efficient : perhaps a gap between the singer (Siepi) and the director (Furtwängler), like a gap between the fire and the ice? I don' t know. This version seems very disturbing and this is nevertheless a quality here ! Greetings

[@Selkaen]

I still wish there were a video of the 1956 performance, I like Gottlob Frick as the Commendatore. Ah, well...

[@stefanarngrimsson5727]

Fortunately we do have the 1956 performance on cd, with Frick dropping down to the low D at the end of his last phrase.

[@miguelmouta]

Dont you think that it steals both the rythm, and the message , Selkaen ? I mean , about changing Mozarts usual communication with symbolic objects and musical elements . Thank you for sharing this beautiful vídeo.

[@ousejamais1vezousejamais1vez]

Nice tempo!👍

[@Selkaen]

Hai ragionissimo. Ora sentiamo tanto la mancanza di Siepi nelle produzioni più recenti! I Don Giovanni di oggi poi sono troppo chiari per il mio gusto, preferivo bassi in questo ruolo piuttosto che baritoni.

[@Selkaen]

I kinda agree after all, I like a faster tempo.

[@francescaemc2]

@kuangsu Se non c'e' Furtwangler son sono felice! Ecco! L'ho detto. Credo che Mozart sarebbe d'accordo. Non ha scritto questa musica per un direttore all'acqua di rose! Grazie infinite.

[@miguelmouta]

Good version. Also , the first one I see , dressings and scenario are historically correct. But I dont remember that Lorenzo da Ponte did put the murder trial ,on libretto ( 04:26).

[@Selkaen]

Obviously it's been added by the stage director. In other versions there isn't.

[@jakethewoz]

That is absolutely false! I sincerely hope you misunderstood what your instructor told you. Why would Mozart write so many roles for basses and baritones if they were 'laughable'? That is ridiculous.

[@JmmrtnzYT]

Este Don Giovanni a cenar teco más lento, más trágico, con un comendador pétreo y con una tremenda actuación no sé si será superado alguna vez... pa q hablar de la calidad del reparto de la versión!