It was brought to my attention that there was a member missing in my original thumbnail. I did not do that on purpose. I was up until 4am this morning editing and obviously counted wrong so as Soon as I was aware I changed it. I apologize. 🤍
@walidmouahid10 ай бұрын
i think it's soojin that quit the group , but she just debuted lat month as a soloist
@whalesaph10 ай бұрын
@@walidmouahid She was forced to leave, but yes.
@walidmouahid10 ай бұрын
@@whalesaphyeah ik , i just realized what i wrote ...thanks
@byulharang330210 ай бұрын
periodtt girl. no need to apoligise😻
@jamesvalkyrie746910 ай бұрын
It’s fine.
@anuarzh464610 ай бұрын
"I wish it was longer" - every (G)I-DLE fan after HWAA ending.
@Jneedstostopobssessing10 ай бұрын
Honestly, that probably goes for most of their songs 😅
@Wolfyeh-gp2hh10 ай бұрын
ITS TOO GOOD
@de68a10 ай бұрын
I love when songs give a unfulfilled ending - especially this one. The desire and yearning for more fits so well to the key, tempo , lyrics and melody of the composition. Echoes of melancholy and sorrow. One of the finest ever written kpop songs.
@bahngchanz10 ай бұрын
Frfr
@TheF4kE10 ай бұрын
I said the same after Senorita
@Fan_Storm10 ай бұрын
Hwaa is basically an amazing poem written by Soyeon that's turned into a music video like 🤌🤌🤌
@Jneedstostopobssessing10 ай бұрын
I'll always remember Shuhua's reaction to Yuqi's lyrics for the Chinese version and saying how poetic they were also
@pinkinmybloodd10 ай бұрын
senorita is one of the funniest line distribution lmao the way yuqi went from last to first because of all her fufufus 😭
@jesu_cc10 ай бұрын
she really foofooed her way to the top
@justyouraveragewendyenjoyer10 ай бұрын
she ate and left no yoofoofoos
@jamesvalkyrie746910 ай бұрын
Fufufu
@inter.stellar10 ай бұрын
Yufuufuu on Top >> Maknae on Top
@elliejelliy10 ай бұрын
@@inter.stellar isn’t shuhua the maknae?
@jamesvalkyrie746910 ай бұрын
Uh oh is such a bop that even Caitlin's camera lost focus on the first half of it. 😂
@sameerakhan745510 ай бұрын
Caitlin has been FEEDING us lately. First Red Velvet and now G-IDLE, back to back and 1:12 hr and 40 mins kong respectively?? Thank you so much Caitlin. We all really appreciate you and thoroughly enjoy your reactions. Take all the breaks you need, I'm sure it gets pretty hectic (as seen from your community posts) and thank you for the reaction❤
@moonlightbae_10 ай бұрын
soyeon is a BEASTTT👑❤️🔥
@mariapiccioni597410 ай бұрын
Wow I had no idea you had never heard these iconic songs! I really appreciated you reacting to Villain Dies as well :) G-idle's huge success today wouldn't have been possible without their continuous experimentation, and it gave us SO many good songs and mvs. If I had to describe this group in a few words it would definitely be "the self-produced concept queens of kpop" And side note your simping for Soojin was VERY relatable 😫
@cruLife-morningSTAR10 ай бұрын
Their album is always top tier. But you can see how much they've improved since "I burn". "I burn" is just one of the best albums out there, with Hwaa as title track and the bsides are literal fire! You should definitely check it out, even without recorded reaction especially Moon and Dahlia. After I burn, they released "I Never Die", "I Love", and, "I feel" which is a game changer for them. Definitely step up from their production but "I burn" is justa piece of art.
@Robalexe10 ай бұрын
I Trust is incredible too. They've always put out bangers, their first album has Maze and Dollar after all.
@ningpop_10 ай бұрын
Soyeon & Idle make really meaningful songs. The most meaningful ones you're watching is Hann and Hwaa.
@yo.leoo__10 ай бұрын
Hwaa and Hann are the best off them And the fact that hwaa was the last mv off soojin is just sad😢
@ArdenAdams212510 ай бұрын
I was just listening to Soojin’s music; what a coincidence!
@steffengoelitz10 ай бұрын
I think, I'm in the minority, but Senorita is still my favorite (G)I-DLE title track. Thumbs up for the reaction. 👍
@jocelynrodriguez474910 ай бұрын
I also adore Senorita and feel it is underrated
@__Sunny___101010 ай бұрын
HWAA is a masterpiece
@salsabilanajwaa10 ай бұрын
IKRRRR CAITLIN ABT VILLAIN DIES!!!!!!!! i think everyone should LOUDER abt this one song, deserves better. NEVER DIE!!!!
@Yunboba10 ай бұрын
These songs are too good!! I'm glad u're exploring there discography more!!
@griseldablanco540810 ай бұрын
Fun fact: HWAA was rejected several times by CUBE, as they believed it would be a failure. It was ultimately a huge success, and in my opinion, is Gidle's best title track.
@sidekicks140310 ай бұрын
i burn is a masterpiece
@griseldablanco540810 ай бұрын
@@sidekicks1403 Facts 👌
@kenmakozume71306 ай бұрын
Yes! Until Nxde, Hwaa was the most successful comeback of theirs with 9 wins🫶🏻
@chris_tyt10 ай бұрын
Thanks Caitlin for reacting to these masterpieces! And yeah, Hann and Hwaa are both in a trilogy with Hann (Alone in Winter) in between. Hwaa is so artistic! One of top I-DLE songs.
@MYjynnie10 ай бұрын
this is what i wanted when people react to (g)i-dle's music i also want them to focus on the lyrics most especially some of the lyrics are made by soyeon, minnie, and yuqi so i hope they also acknowledged how meaning their songs are. That's why pausing during the mv is fine with me. Thanks for reacting to Red Velvet as well, and now the double take with mii girlies 💜
@kenmakozume71306 ай бұрын
Not some, ALL of them! 🫶🏻
@saravengeance10 ай бұрын
OMG IM SOOO HAPPY TO SEE ALL OF THESE REACTIONS 😭😭💗
@hannshu9 ай бұрын
imo idle just grow up and evolve non-stop, including in terms of sound. however, i also think that their previous sound really suited soojin a lot, it was more light and airy i think, and now they come off very strong. again after everything that happened and just natural growth. anyways, i enjoy everything they're doing and i love all the songs be it before or post tomboy. i've never loved a k-pop group more than i do with (g)i-dle. their songs and personalities resonate with me so well
@luizmagalhaesc10 ай бұрын
Villain Dies is totally about soojin for being expelled from the group in the middle of a bullying controversy
@analuciamedeiros482810 ай бұрын
btw: idle debuted in a time when kpop groups had such defined concepts, but they're own concept was exploring different concepts while having concepts for the girls themselves. for example: soojin was sexy, minnie was chic, soyeon was sexy... so they kept their own concepts within different styles of music and MVs❤️
@mariafumiki872010 ай бұрын
I SCREAMED WHEN I SAW THE TITLE OF THE VIDEO. My favourite group and my favourite reaction KZbinr omagahhhhd
@darkstar287410 ай бұрын
I can’t vouch enough for the channel who creates the line distribution/lyric videos you use for B-sides, Random-K is the only one I trust to get translations and member’s parts right without guessing for the sake of getting it out quickly, they take their time with them and the output is worth it.
@gcuacamole10 ай бұрын
NOT early 💔 but girl I just wanna say as a Neverland I was FED with this video. Thank you so much for giving us the best reactions, they are so genuine (relatable also) and crack me up every time. 💗 Keep up with the awesome work, but also while having some time for yourself :))
@Miyshujinminnsoyqi10 ай бұрын
Out of all the kpop group mvs i have seen,G idle has the most catchiest Mvs ever.literally all their songs are a masterpiece ❤
@neververforever285710 ай бұрын
If the Villain Dies is definitely related to Soojin's departure from the group 💯 I think that Soojin was portrayed to be the villain by the media and the public even though there was no evidence of the accusers' claims, but she will never die, because she's back 😁😁😁 Like when (G)I-DLE proved everyone that they will never die when they came back with Tomboy 🔥
@Angelmoon36510 ай бұрын
You absolutely need to watch villain dies live, it is insane!❤
@Jiyongbutterfly958910 ай бұрын
Probably I'm the only one who loves G-IDLE 's music Pre-Tomboy era more.Bcz Lion ,Hwaaa,Hann are just pure masterpieces.
@Cindy-ie4yx10 ай бұрын
You’re intro with the tv is the same as rotten mangos 😩 I really thought I was watching a podcast I was so confused
@caitlinbensonn10 ай бұрын
It’s a free green screen on KZbin lol lots of people can use it lol
@mollyeagan26510 ай бұрын
i love your videos so much caitlin!! they always make my day so thank you so much for everything you do!
@pinkseonghwa10 ай бұрын
Hwaa, Oh My God and Lion is for real idle’s holy trinity of songs
@owangatang200010 ай бұрын
my ults ❤❤❤ loved your reaction caitlin! their music is very different from a lot of other groups, and they’ve gone in many different directions, but it’s all guided by our wonderful leader Soyeon 👸 thanks for checking them out! 💕
@BananahRae10 ай бұрын
I’ve always interpreted the “you foo” as actually being “you fool” which fits the song pretty well. It’s one of my favorite songs of theirs.
@candypunch524710 ай бұрын
Caitlin!!! I follow you cause i like your expression & vibes when react video! I am not native English speaker, I'm from southeast Asia, when i watched your video, i learn new words (hehehe). Keep going, honey! I really Adore youuu ♥️
@ngozisia359410 ай бұрын
My favourite kpop reactor reacting to one of my favourite kpop groups. Let's goooooo!!
@Tristana.Keauna10 ай бұрын
I don't know how I've missed this series - but really, really loving it!!
@stayaw4ke10 ай бұрын
HWAA to me is literal art, the red dresses, Minnie’s note 😵💫 also since you liked villain dies (I was gagged) you haveeee to listen to the album, it’s cohesive and is a real no skip. also I know you like guitars sooo 😊
@GeoJoe_1310 ай бұрын
The first song you reacted to was actually their first comeback. Like how on earth is that their first comeback, it's so good in my opinion I love it so much. Also for the trilogy it's in you already listened to 1 of the other songs which is Hwaa. The trilogy goes Hann(Alone), Hann(Alone in winter) and Hwaa
@JohnnieGrooves10 ай бұрын
Villain Dies is one of my all time favorite songs of GIdle. So much so that i even made a short bass cover of it. Villain dies, DARK (X-file) from their later album and even Soyeon's "Psycho" from heir solo album, are all great dark songs. They should have made full on MVs for these songs. DARK (X-file) MV was just a teaser, that left me begging for more... The group can nail the dark concept like none's business. Just look at the live performances of Villain Dies, Psycho and Put it Straight (Nightmare ver.) from Queendom. I love the creativity and authenticity of these girls, even though their latest releases are not my cup of tea, I still believe in their talent!
@pearsfears10 ай бұрын
Omg yes!!!! this video is all i wanted
@sidekicks140310 ай бұрын
hwaa's short ending echoes the theme of the song, they will burn the brightest even tho it means the fire wont last long
@Judithly10 ай бұрын
Love your reaction, like always!
@BLOOOOZ10 ай бұрын
About what happens in Señorita's MV, it reminds me of Russian Roulette by Red Velvet
@geosamarymarquez867110 ай бұрын
Soon in which is the ex member of gidle recently re debuted as a soloist however she barely does any promotions due to the controversie apparently many k netozens are still hating on her when it was proven she was innocent
@siu07897 ай бұрын
Hwaa is a literal masterpiece
@felixlight782810 ай бұрын
IM SO EXCITED FOR THIS ONE
@0_mo.on_010 ай бұрын
Hope you reaction to soojin solo debut ❤
@urfavtyongf10 ай бұрын
this was needed
@nabii046510 ай бұрын
esto era justo lo que yo necesitaba ver omfg
@ivegonepink10 ай бұрын
MORE IDLE IM DEADDDDD
@AyalaBlack10 ай бұрын
Where are those people requesting reaction coming from? Are they bot??? Anyway I hope you are well and your break do you some good. Hope school is going fine too. Hwaa was my first Gidle song and I still loves her so much. Villain Dies is fighting with Lion as my favorite bside. I heard her the 1st time at one of the year end shows and I was like "YES ABSOLUTELY". Never heard Uh Oh before but I actually enjoyed it a lot Thank you for this you've worked hard and we appreciate it a lot 🫶🏽
@edilee590910 ай бұрын
These are my favorite Gidle songs!
@SolangeRivera-i8k10 ай бұрын
YEEES GRACIAS POR TU REACCION
@pooferfloofer10 ай бұрын
Edit: I am NOT talking about the amazing slaying fantastic caitlinbensonn here I am talking to Soojin directly because Hann english lyrics and uh idk bro idk how to do that link thing with the time mark so there you have it that's funny soojin that's funny that you said you won't comeback anymore and it's funny that the subtitles didn't put a space between come and back because GUESS WHAT SOOJIN YOU JUST HAD YOUR COMEBACK.... as a SOLOIIIST
@caitlinbensonn10 ай бұрын
I didn’t say she wouldn’t comeback anymore just that she’s not longer apart of this group which is the truth. That’s all I stated.
@ninon._.1110 ай бұрын
Hi, now i advise you to watch their live performance, they are so impressive !!! Ps : i really love your videos, your reactions are so funny !!
@Pookasoul10 ай бұрын
I think the accidents and Near death experiences in Senorita meant that their love is dangerous... like.. they mean trouble, ya know...
@guilhermeantonucci940310 ай бұрын
Great video as always but I'd like to point out that the audio is really low in comparison to your other videos.
@caitlinbensonn10 ай бұрын
Yes I’ve already mentioned before that I had audio issues when recording this series. I’m not sure what happened but there was an issue so I just had to work around it the best I could. Hope it isn’t too much of a problem. I still think you can hear me and the song enough regardless.
@guilhermeantonucci940310 ай бұрын
Not a problem, watched anyway like always! Keep up the good work :)@@caitlinbensonn
@m363k410 ай бұрын
ONG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG I CANT BELIEVE ITS ACTUALLY TRUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE GIDLE IS IN THE HOUSE AGAINNNNNNNN OMGGGGGGGGGGG IM SOOOO HAPPYYYYYYYYYY🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@jisumin60810 ай бұрын
People really been sleeping on idle 😢
@sweets997810 ай бұрын
I fully bought kaja beauty stuff because of gidle. Idc if it’s capitalism. The blush was awesome and the little heart lip thing was cute
@Itz.J4DE7 ай бұрын
You should listen to Moon!
@jared-vz7kf10 ай бұрын
you should listen to the hwaa album!! imo is their best album
@kimchijuneyaa10 ай бұрын
i suggest you to try checking out gidle's I NEVER DIE album coz it's very gooodd!! Hope u can check it out some other time, no pressure tho! Thank you for this reaction and ily ❤
@Ketchame10 ай бұрын
Pls reaction to Agassy soojin solo debut
@Khun_Sitt12310 ай бұрын
One of your girls reaction pls
@216pink10 ай бұрын
I miss Soojin my bias so so much so you reacting to these classics is making my heart so happy!! You’re the best! ❤
@r.ks.t240410 ай бұрын
Yes I miss you Soojin🌹 By the way, Soojin is comeback ❤️❤️
@shineinstars10 ай бұрын
same !! i miss her in idle but im glad she was able to redebut
@sirpauinthai120522 күн бұрын
@@shineinstars Is she going to come back with gidle?
@Pookiewhore10 ай бұрын
That whistle in hann is actually Minnie's whistle omg
@jamescurfman32843 ай бұрын
Yup. She's a pro. Their Killing Voice video proves it. :)
@arttqi10 ай бұрын
gidle has one crazy discography honestly
@shineinstars10 ай бұрын
fr and every song is a banger
@chris_tyt10 ай бұрын
Villain Dies, of “I NEVER DIE”, you can’t help but think it refers to Soojin’s forced departure. They had a live performance of this song at MMA Awards 2022, in which they literally said “I’m no longer a prisoner.”
@samuelpurezaribeiro856510 ай бұрын
Soyeon's rap in villain dies was incredible
@kanelives60910 ай бұрын
Ikr, and people say she cannot rap in english?? Girl killed it, it's one of her best
@hyeongpinkz10 ай бұрын
she secretly dragged seo shin ae's ass and i love her for that
@Indorap_YT10 ай бұрын
@@hyeongpinkzPERIOD
@GleeChan10 ай бұрын
You pretty much hit the nail on the head. For me there are two (G)I-DLEs: Pre and Post TOMBOY. I don't think Soyeon had an issue with talking about big issues in her songs before, but after the stuff that happened to Soojin and the group's livelihood seemingly up in the air, I think the gloves were off. TOMBOY came back swinging, all subtlety gone. Part of it was "this is our last chance, let's do everything we've wanted to do because what do we have to lose" sort of deal, but the other part was they put more of their pure emotions into I NEVER DIE. After that, (G)I-DLE's been more personal and in your face about the things they want to talk about. Again, I want to preference that they were still talking about heavy issues before, but it was vailed in metaphor. The best thing about (G)I-DLE, is that they never were trend riders and always did things their way. So TOMBOY wasn't completely out of no where. It fits their character. But yes, there was a shift and one that arguably was for the better. They were always high mid-tier before TOMBOY, almost just there to being a top group, but now I think everyone can agree they're in the top five. (Lastly, if you want to see Soyeon go hard, check out "Is That Bad Bitch Number" )
@ridhwaan898310 ай бұрын
GURLL!!! My jaw dropped as soon I saw the title 😭😭😭 Thank you queen for this reaction 😭🩵
@mandsgaymer413310 ай бұрын
Great video as always!
@Wolfyeh-gp2hh10 ай бұрын
28:54 ok so some neverland info🤓: hwa means fire and anger so they’re trying to melt down the ice/loneliness (or in other words “HAN” in korean) and bring back the spring/hope/hapiness through their flames. Hwaa also means flower (different Chinese hanja) so the hanja for hwaa switches from the fire version to flower version in the last chorus as they break out of the abyss/HAN.☺️ that’s how HAN and HWAA are connected. And there’s another song called “Han alone in winter” in the “I burn” album and it’s supposed to be a trilogy🥹!
@amiragrimeh284510 ай бұрын
Thank you so much I was searching for an explanation all over the comment section 🙏
@Wolfyeh-gp2hh10 ай бұрын
@@amiragrimeh2845 I GOTCHU
@dekonfly10 ай бұрын
Also to add. Hann alone is denial. Hann alone in winter acceptance of their state. Hwaa finally releasing the anger and moving on with your life after past lover.
@thongz170210 ай бұрын
It’s time to crown G-Idle as the Concept Queens if it’s not done yet.
@DuriaMuria10 ай бұрын
Soyeon the leader writte and producer all videos from debut, imagine the power of this gg, Queens of the absolutly k-pop
@tamarlevy594910 ай бұрын
this video just reminds me how much soojin shined as a group member. i wish her all the best in her solo activities
@kairopractor10 ай бұрын
HANN, Senorita and HWAA are legit in my top-4 along with Oh My God. I like their new path in music too. But these 4, it's my jam.
@Naty16-0610 ай бұрын
OMG Cait thank you sm for reacting to them again! the way i love this girls !!! i am a proud Neverland after all their being through they never die 🤧❤
@astro0716010 ай бұрын
I CLICKED THE MOMENT I SAW THIS NOTIF.
@I-DLEneververSVTcaratULTkpoppy10 ай бұрын
OMGG thank u so much for thisss! As a person who loves Cailtin's reactions + as a neverland I WON todayy! YAY! Thank u so much and love uu
@LilRedWitch10 ай бұрын
Caitlin posts? I click. What a wonderful way to spend a cool autumn morning than to snuggle down and watch a queen react to queens. Appreciate your videos as always! 🫶🏻
@hivisonnogueira84810 ай бұрын
loved the video
@SylviaLee_10 ай бұрын
Thank you Caitlin❤ just to remind you that we love you so much❤ This series is sooooooo good and I really enjoy it🫶
@gahiz659210 ай бұрын
THANK YOU SOOOO MUCH CAITLIN WE'VE BEEN FED ROYALLLY!! APPRECIATE YOU ALWAYS
@jiturakii10 ай бұрын
OMG IM SO EXCITED FOR MORE GIDLE!!!!
@sannihakkarainen10 ай бұрын
Yesssss, what a perfect collection of songs! Uh-oh is basically about Soyeon and the way people didn't believe in her success at first and it's just her big F U to those who initially didn't believe in her and then turned around and tried to act friendly when she got famous and successful. You can always count on Soyeon to be real in her songs!
@Wolfyeh-gp2hh10 ай бұрын
25:36 idle never felt like a super feminine type of group tbh I feel like that’s why they’re so versatile. Also remember “it’s neither man nor woman, just me idle😉”
@gaiapiazza532910 ай бұрын
Oh wow I love G-Idle so much, I hope you enjoyed Soojin's solo comeback! I miss her in the group, but they still very good and incredible...
@kanelives60910 ай бұрын
The way i clicked RIGHT AWAY, also thank you for reacting to Villain Dies, their bsides are just so good. I hope you react to the whole I Never Die album one day!
@Jennieni540210 ай бұрын
sojin solo debut now😢
@Vogelkinder10 ай бұрын
"Hwaa" remains the song that I think I love the most from their discography. It's so beautiful and emotive and makes me cry nearly everytime I hear it. Also, Yes, Hann, Hann (Alone in Winter) and Hwaa area trilogy of songs depicting the failure of a relationship, the regrest engendered by the break-up, and the recovery of herself in "Hwaa".
@dinihfiy140110 ай бұрын
girl i had thw same expression for villain dies cause it's my first time hearing it too like gawd damn 😭😭
@tillywilson603810 ай бұрын
Hwaa still gives me chills whenever I hear and see it, such a beautiful song and video. Always makes me a bit emotional when I think of it being soojins last release with the girls but I’m glad they’ll always have that time together❤ Also bestie is back and as charismatic as ever😊
@Pookiewhore10 ай бұрын
Everyone shut up my boo is back
@HanQ2810 ай бұрын
I love how Caitlin repeatedly falls in love with Yuqi without even knowing her name, in both First Look and Double Take of gidle lol