I Killed Every NPC in Baldur's Gate 3 (w/ Director's Commentary)

[@samuelfreeman-db7hz]

Dumpy in the first two Acts: So I missed someone so I redid that act Dumpy in the third Act: So I killed someone and then got a little eepy

[@MaximilianBrandt]

Should have called the new elf fireheart. Shortened "fart"

[@mysryuza]

Besties with Shadowheart. Shart and Fart 😂

[@Dootium]

How about a saving everyone spinoff? There are a LOT of named NPCs who die if you don't go out of your way to save them.

[@CharismaAt-1]

That sounds cool ash

[@trazyntheinfinite9895]

Those poor souls in that underwater dungeon.,...

[@huskiefan8950]

.......then a LOT of people are gonna be dying, once I finally get my copy 😂

[@Ginger92312]

I second this!!

[@luierdaneenpamper3877]

@@trazyntheinfinite9895 can u also save the people who are in cazador's dungeon?

[@Sleepy2399]

POV: average Chaotic Evil player in a normal campaign

[@Rateltong]

"It's what my character would do"

[@Slideerr]

Everything that lives (and undeath/everything else) is a walking level up 😂

[@TStizzle19]

Lmfao literally me when my gf went "what do you mean you killed all of the tieflings?!" And I said "I've embraced the dark side, the tadpole is my friend" ​@@Rateltong

[@MayHugger]

⁠@@SlideerrOne of the problems with using exp over milestone in D&D is that it encourages and rewards murderhobos. It sucks looking at a character sheet and knowing that if I was just willing to be a monster and butchered a ton of innocents, I could’ve levelled up, and thus just be blatantly stronger.

[@greytrainingrounds9344]

Bro people just don’t know how to play a good chaotic evil player. Gotta tie your story into the party and the mission. Kinda railroad yourself into not murdering your party.

[@legomann9092]

How am I only just now Realizing Haarlep is an anagram for Raphael

[@LegionWing01]

Holy S that some nice text conjecture you got

[@OvenHut]

i noticed it the first time i met him, and my friend i was playing with who has 600+ hours and multiple complete saves JUST realized when i pointed it out haha

[@ChibiRere]

I have over 1500 hours logged!! HOW DID I MISS THIS?! 🤯😱

[@mobgabriel1767]

bhaal's words at the end of the dark urge's questline are like having sans judge you but in reverse

[@MagicPumpkin33]

Fun fact! If you keep the Gith egg in Lae'zels inventory till the very end, she becomes a mother to a the child ^^ (and hopefully raises him better)

[@karlwittenburg5868]

If you are romancing her as well then you’ll be raising it together, which is nice

[@senittoaoflightning4404]

Yeah, Xan, he's cool.

[@themudpit621]

that IS a fun fact!

[@winnn998]

By the way, after you witness gortash's inauguration, all the npcs in that room will be killed by the steel watch and the guards so you didn't have to worry about them running

[@hossdelgado626]

That's funny, so he struggled for nothing

[@winnn998]

@@hossdelgado626 yup. good effort on his part though

[@eli3290]

ultimate murderhobo playthrough

[@EdwinCaldwellBills]

POV the (mostly) innocent NPCs: dumpheles! I missed you. dumpheles: I have become death destroyer of worlds

[@Athen-cz1zs]

Pro tip I use in every honor mode: go to shadowhearts spell book and equip 'command' you can use 'command: drop' on Zhalk with about a %50 success rate. You can then easily take and equip the everburn blade, and Zhalk will only do 6 damage per attack with his fists.

[@booboobear8214]

Omg keep it up dude, super great videos!

[@dumpykong]

dude 3rd comment! you freakin' rock!

[@luwakdoesart1244]

Really glad there's little paper sounds to announce the notes, it lets me know when to look over to read them since i like doing a lot of things at once but don't like missing them :]]

[@seraftt]

11:30 so she's Quil? I was looking for her in Baldur's Gate because of a letter, found on a beheaded person in one of the cells near the murder tribunal, the letter was sweet they were saying they pre-ordered Quil's music or sum like that and they wish to see her soon, i really thought that there was no npc called Quil because i couldn't find her on the location mentioned on the letter (the blushing mermaid) I'm amazed at how much time Larion spent on having this world feel real because of little things like this

[@ShayJ1337]

Npc is non playable characters and you play as your companions so i dont even think you had to kill them for the challenge

[@dumpykong]

Yeah but it wouldn’t feel complete if I left them alive

[@salamantics]

You’re only truly playing as your origin regardless, Gale, astarion, shadowheart, and laezel are NPCS unless they are the player.

[@benross9174]

@@salamanticsnah they are by definition playable

[@pupernickel]

​@@dumpykongwyll is still alive in hells

[@neonkbfalcon]

A new durge endings allows you to kill everyone in faerūn

[@Serelor]

Hate to break it to you, but it's actually *very easy* to have Mirkon (the tiefling child near the harpies) die. It's so stupid easy that my only explanation for why you didn't experience it may be due to positioning/difficulty. Mirkon normally dies so easily that you have to actually *try to* prevent his death, which makes this run even weirder than normal

[@prokhor_zakharov]

I accidentally killed him just by walking down to the beach, observing the scene, and deciding "eh, I'd rather come back and deal with this after a long rest." Oops.

[@themudpit621]

yeah, I was pretty sure I remembered him dying and me reloading, because every playthrough now I work on keeping him safe.

[@gorgit]

Just deleted an honor mode run where he got killed today... Another 5 hrs down the drain

[@averagepufferfish5612]

If you raid the grove then you can get Minthara to try to attack you at the after party in which you can kill another 20 goblins.

[@SherifNeamatalla]

@28:34 You actually left a single person alive in the Hag's cave. There is a guy turned to stone, you can use basilisk oil on him, he'd live if you do this after you kill the hag, or die of sickness if you do it before killing the hag.

[@thatguy00271]

excited to watch the entire video! the commentary is amazing!

[@TessaVer]

you can actually kill oliver by putting him in a silence bubble and destroying his shield. He thus wont be able to talk to you and you can kill him. This mainly breaks the quest

[@mobgabriel1767]

"its just so silly its so fun its so serious all at the same time its like the game was handcrafted for me" you really should try to play DND dude you pretty much described the game XD

[@Mo_Mudabber]

This is better than the board game

[@Finn-wc8nq]

@@Mo_Mudabberboard game 💀

[@TheSniped117]

​@@Mo_Mudabber Board game? 🤣

[@MayHugger]

⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@Mo_MudabberWhat board game? 😂

[@CalamitasBrimstoneWitch]

@@Mo_Mudabber Lmao 'board game'

[@devinodriscoll]

With patch 7’s new Evil Durge ending, it looks like you got another run to do.

[@jcdenton2187]

11:20 The owlbear mate is part of Honor Mode actually

[@gikzmee7282]

Despite being the most vile run, it was so beautiful and touching. you dealt with so many of the victims with so much love

[@prokhor_zakharov]

It's a pity you didn't get the new "in Bhaal's name" epilogue; it would have been absolutely perfect for this run.

[@g-alicenine]

So that first kid, you can sorta kill him by just not going there at all until after grove is raided. You'll find him dead after that.

[@bricekrispees]

i like hearing your voice over the fun pictures that move

[@creedolala6918]

I appreciate the 3-hour edit that turned into three seconds of footage though. Your videos are top notch, the edits and annotations add a lot.

[@mr.c4937]

This is probably the sixth time I've watched these videos, And I'm still not getting enough of them. Keep up the great videos, as always

[@ryandornan8698]

this was extremely entertaining. Well done!

[@KeirKee]

did you know that if you drop the nhetherstones at the steel foundry before it is blown up you get a totally unique encounter with some kobolds.

[@StarzRantz]

i have watched this whole thing through one sitting this has been so sick you gained a subscriber

[@colorgreen8728]

The cutscene where you push the duergar into the water off the boat always makes me laugh lol

[@Phantomgamer85]

“What are you doing on gechs raft”

[@kaosstars]

I just rewatched the separate videos a few days ago but I love this series, so I'm happy to re-watch it again. Awesome content man, keep it up!

[@cheyennesilver6344]

“The emperor kicks into Gear!” 😂 Subscribed

[@brizzle4674]

had to stop during act 2 tho because I saw too many things I didn’t came across in my first play through so I guess I’ll wait for patch 7, play the dark urge and then watch the rest of this 🎉 But hey great video keep it up man!

[@nikkinvin]

1:33:40 That last tomato for Wyll killed me 😂 Did I really just watched a 3 hr video from a dude who killed every npc in Baldurs Gate? Apparently I did and I regret nothing

[@Finn-wc8nq]

1:50:19 adding onto the sticky note if you play as a selunite cleric and talk about Selune after she meets her parents she’ll tell you to give her some time on worshipping a new god 100% so while she is a selunite and admits it she’s not completely on board yet

[@nasldevelopment]

you should do a playthrough where you only use non lethal attacks and make sure nobody dies at all.

[@Iamsilly895]

I’ve been waiting for a video of all the videos stitched together and this is great!

[@goreobsessed2308]

Time to enjoy this ride once again... one day ill actually do the harpy scene ive played through 4 times and somehow every time i never find the harpies trying to kill kid

[@Fishnuke14]

I’m pretty sure how you find it is go to the druids grove entrance and take a little path south east to the beach

[@goreobsessed2308]

@@Fishnuke14 that's crazy if it's by the Grove itself I've been through and around it so much man I can miss the most obvious stuff

[@qhu3878]

​@@goreobsessed2308 enter the area with the idol (not via the lift), to the left theres a stone arch. through it turn left and you find the harpy encounter, turn right and you can find alfira

[@charlesbryson7443]

As soon as you go down the stairs where the statue is, turn left.

[@clownintraining5944]

Also cast sanctuary on the kid and silence on yourswlf if you dont have high wisdom Makes the fight WAY more bearable.

[@Finn-wc8nq]

If you go to the harpy beach see the kid on shore but not interact, then rest and come back they’ll be dead in the nest

[@RandyH524]

i carried that kid all the way through act three and then dumped his body then reanimated him as a ghoul. he sacrificed perfectly. gave me the advantage was the move that turned the tides.

[@salamantics]

You can also send one party member (a rogue or a spellcaster with invisibility) and stealth away once combat starts. When the kid makes it to the harpies they’ll auto attack and kill them in 1-2 turns. Other than the snake in the grove you have very little other opportunities to cause the disconnection of children. That’s why Kagha was right

[@skynet0912]

I like doing things like this too, but my new way of playing is much more... unpredictable... Basicly, it's just a normal playthrough, but every dialogue choice is decided with dice rolls! My main rules are that i can NEVER reroll a failed roll, i can't use stealth or explosives at all to cheese encounters, and if my character decided to end a conversation or refuse to help, i MUST honor that, and never speak to them again unless their circumstancs change, like if a quest about them updates or they move location.

[@lilscuba9808]

I have never felt so hollow like I did when Lae'zel had to go. I'm glad that I'm not the one that had to do this, but man was it a good watch. Thank you for the video, Dumpy.

[@fishtank13]

happy that this finally came out! awesome work on the video!

[@gideonventura1745]

With yurgir you can actually convince him to kill his underlings and himself for you

[@blueview5212]

I dont think you can kill children in video games but non human children is a blured line i geuss

[@crystallake6159]

I love this video and idea. Even if it's simple to think "I'm gonna kill every one of you", it's not simple to have determination to do this so good job dude! If you want to continue this series of "I've killed every NPC" then I have good game for it and made by the same studio. Divinity Original Sin 2, check it out, great game overall

[@sircelery7376]

1:06:00 if you fail the checks on the statues it summons a couple of guys for you to kill. I think you missed those

[@Phantomgamer85]

I don’t think there unique npc I think there just justiciars nice find tho

[@DiabloGoldSecrets]

You could speed run this by just getting gale to explode 😅

[@The_bluebean]

Dumpy: sees extremely prominent character in every single promotional material in first playthrough. "he attacked me so im gonna kill him instead of talking to him for 5 seconds"

[@tekniekgamer6599]

SPOILERS FOR ACT 3 KINDA In act 3 specifically when you go to blow up the Steel Warden Factory if you drop one of the Netherstones you can encounter kobolds on the left side of the building trying to take it as far as I know these are the only other time you encounter them

[@leotheliongames]

Time stamp 2:12:20 he made a note about it :)

[@hypeflexington7081]

How the heck did you figure that out??! I wouldn't have even thought of dropping one somewhere. Who figures these things out haha

[@Squee-g8f]

@@hypeflexington7081lol usually other content creators trying to figure out how to softlock the game. If you drop them in the iron throne too, the weird water guys that ambush on the south bank of the lower city will have them. If you’ve killed them, the trader will have them. If the trader is dead, they’re in a fish… lmao. They really made contingencies for everything. However, if you drop the kethric one in the jungle the djinn sends you to, I think that actually soft locks you permanently.

[@karlwittenburg5868]

@@hypeflexington7081yeah there’s a bunch of checks and failsafes to ensure that essential items never end up inaccessible. If you leave a nether stone in the Iron Throne, the a suhuagin will have it when they ambush the docks. If you’ve already done that fight, then a merchant will find it washed up and you can buy it from him. If you instead kill the merchant before that, then a fish carcass washes up on the beach having eaten the stone

[@aaron6112]

Technically you shouldn't get rolan to stay the kids die if he isnt there to save them

[@taelion]

For 70 hours in the first week and a deep love for the game I feel like you said "I had never seen before" once too often lol

[@Ramperdos]

This was a banger trilogy.

[@WolfgangRP]

So glad you did this regionlocked. Great run! :)

[@jamesduke5848]

you think wyl is the kindest and most well-meaning soul? have you met halsin? lol

[@FluxOperation]

I can’t imagine the time and dedication that went into to this. Congrats and I love it!!

[@mrbgarles6724]

Whenever I come to one of your videos I’m astounded that you don’t have more subs. This quality and dedication deserves 10x the attention you get. Keep up the amazing videos!

[@TheBritishHunter830]

Hey Dumpy, awesome video. Been waiting for this for awhile ever since I watched the original Act 1. I just have one question. Could you maybe NOT kill everyone in Skyrim next time? That could be a fun anti-challenge.

[@Hitori_YT]

I became so invested I tried it myself, actually very fun to be able to see all these things I was too scared to look at!

[@colinmcdonald23]

gonna pronounce it like Tayve from now on

[@НиколайБрагин-б6й]

Great work! Thank you, I've watched it all from the beginning.

[@nicii179]

when you said every npc i didnt consider scratch and the owlbear cub as npc’s, which is on me but damn dude

[@nicii179]

AND KARLACH?!

[@Teatur_]

“Like a weed whacker through a baby’s soft spot” is an absolutely WILD analogy.

[@majina5749]

Keep up the good work man!👍🏻

[@yourfriendlach]

This revelas so many things I didn't know about the game, I thought the empower being THE Baldur was just a fan theory. This is the first time even hearing about Ansur.

[@FoxGamer-hb3ot]

fun fact, if you drop a nether stone in the steel watch foundry and then blow it up a pack of kobolts will appear

[@Aaylias]

You should've made the director's commentary the rat from horrible histories

[@no-to3si]

I have JUST found a very weird failsave in act 3, involving the netherstones. If you go to the steel watch factory and drop the netherstones, the Emperor will tell you to pick whem up. If you ignore him and blow the plase up, three cobolds will spawn. (not telling youto replay the game, its just a fun fact)

[@igamerflavor]

you can kill the goblin children by throwing them of the cliff and only one goblin tries to fight you because of it

[@alitazext2826]

Pieth, Great Video!

[@themadowl9224]

Man I expected just another challenge video from this, but I enjoyed it way more. Your humor is great, I love that you explain the plot (even though I have about 300 hours in the game) and still try to have some roleplay and overall this just felt much more like watching a person try a silly - maybe a bad word for this but you know - way to play the game instead of an overplanned genius challenge edited down to 20 minutes. It reminded me a little of how LPs used to be, except, of course, you would have had to release one 15 minute episode a week in a numbered playlist for that. Anyway the actual point is just that I enjoyed this way more than I expected and got really invested. It's also been some time since I last thought "hey this youtuber seems like a nice person" instead of just "yeah this guy sure knows how to make content"

[@AlpnzAMV]

I am happy this video exists sir.

[@firpishable]

As far as killing children goes, when saving Halsin you have to expressly kill two goblin children or they alert the whole goblin camp.

[@noatiendoboludos]

5:10 "didnt realize he was a main companion" His face is on the god damn loading screen, HOW do you not recognize him

[@jacquicollins8826]

You could have killed the Shadow Druids if you confronted Kagha about them.

[@rudyreinoldobarbiannetobar7783]

There is an ending where leazels became a an ascent knight to her queen, and it’s technically death. So you should kept her till the end

[@Jbird__8]

I’ll never stop loving these videos

[@travisgriffith2307]

you missed killing three enemies in the shar monument after you give the alter blood steal the ritual dagger and they appear intelligence, charisma, wisdom justiciars

[@SherifNeamatalla]

In my dark urge run, I stole the robe from Wyll to give it to gale, then sacrificed him in the Underdark after convincing him Karlach was a devil and letting him live long enough to know that wasn't the case.

[@chadxox3]

Remember when you first did and holy shit the final version is awesome!

[@pupernickel]

1:36:00 "i didnt know this immortal woman cant die" SHE TOLD YOU SHES IMMORTAL also everyone told you, that the spear is to kill her.

[@alittlebitastra]

AN AD OCCURED AS YOU KILLED SCRATCH :(

[@laurenwhale]

there are also soooo many NPCs at the Water Queen’s House to the south of the Steel Watch Foundry (aka the place you get the quest to get the Wavemother’s Robe) - then to the southwest of the Water Queen’s House is a passageway into the Water Queen’s Cellar the has a bunch of NPCs you can agro

[@Pystoria]

Hearing about your first playthrough again was crazy

[@jbear3478]

I’m doing a solo evil run. I can’t wait

[@stuminnis4050]

You missed the three dark justiciars in the Shar shrine under the town square in act 2. If you fail any of the blood tests, they appear. You passed the tests, so they didn’t appear.

[@laurenpaus7608]

in my first play through i polymorphed marcus and im pretty proud of that move. honestly i need to use that more

[@sparkslegends7482]

Skyrim had Dump Fallout 4 had Dumpette Elden Ring had Dumpster Oblivion had Dumpathan Now Baldur’s Gates 3 has Dumpeles It’s a big murderhobo family, a pantheon of killers, Doomdays, sentient beings bent on slaughter.

[@Onebadterran]

And so now there are lots of extra characters in Honor Mode...Still, impressive all the same!

[@BlueEyedMomof378]

The harpies can kill that kid. I've had it happen in one playthrough. I reloaded. I can't fathom how you were able to kill the goodest boi and my little chicken though. My heart hurts watching this.

[@LeoTheDarkAngel]

Currently rewatching this a I'm doing my own "kill them all"-run. Still fun to watch, even though I already know the video^^

[@sparkslegends7482]

A group of Goblins are called either a Gob or a Tribe.

[@diamondedge83]

A group of Goblins are called a Malignity.

[@sparkslegends7482]

@@diamondedge83 , I like yours better. The definition for malignity describes goblins perfectly.

[@deelikes2683]

You can kill the guy being operated on in The House of Healing if you attack Malus rather than talking him into being a patient

[@travisgriffith2307]

mizara was in the room right next to the pods you purged and you get a infernal rapier for saving her and passing a check

[@ssaberwolf]

I'd definitely call a group of goblins a murder of goblins.

[@creedolala6918]

idk If this means one more batch of people you missed, but on my first playthrough I saved Oscar and got the Poltergeist shown in the video. On my second when I killed him, lady Jannath's house is full of people at an art showing, including some unique npcs. I think there might be more people doing it that way.

[@erinletts2839]

No one ever talks about the goblin who hits kethric w/ the axe in kethric's opening scene. That goblin is scary strong, i know the scene is suppose to impress upon us how badass kethric is... but i'm always amazed no one mentions that little gal.