Trauma in the Middle East: The terror of Hamas and Israel's war in Gaza | DW Documentary

How was the attack on the Israeli state prepared? How was it even possible? To mark the first anniversary of the Hamas attack, the documentary film analyzes the failures of intelligence services, politics and the army.
Could the catastrophe have been prevented? What motivated Hamas to carry out the attack? And what was Israel’s response - with which consequences?
In the making of this film, directors Duki Dror and Jens Strohschnieder revisit scenes where the 7 October attack took place and speak to survivors, journalists and security experts.
For some Israelis, the gruesome events of that day are reminiscent of bloody pogroms and the Holocaust. For the Palestinians, the ensuing Israeli war in Gaza is triggering memories of the Nakba. The film poses the question of whether these traumas can explain the incomprehensible atrocities and the lack of empathy on both sides. Leading traumatologists worldwide try to explain the incomprehensible. Can there be any hope at all? "Hurt People Hurt People: October 7 and its Aftermath” looks at both sides of this spiral of violence - and tries to paint the big picture, which is often lost in the incessant stream of breaking news bulletins.
#documentary #dwdocumentary
______
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
⮞ DW Documentary (English): / dwdocumentary
⮞ DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
⮞ DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
⮞ DW Doku (German): / dwdoku
⮞ DW Documentary हिन्दी (Hindi): / dwdochindi
For more visit: www.dw.com/en/t...
Follow DW Documentary on Instagram: / dwdocumentary
Follow DW Documental on Facebook: / dwdocumental
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G

[@amhamoges5547]

This is not about land dispute ,the core of this problem is Religion &Religion only.If we can't talk about the main problem there will be no solution .

[@vdjKryptosRock]

Religion has nothing to do with it. Nowhere else is this ever said about settler colonial violence.

[@WoJackHorseman24]

It’s entirely about land rights and statehood. European refugees arrived and seized the majority of their land. They are colonizers

[@05350]

Certain religion can never coexist with others, no matter which country it goes to, it always ends up into violence.

[@rajworship]

​@@vdjKryptosRockit's about religion..why muslim are fighting in Kashmir.??.why muslim are fighting in philippines??why were they fighting in Myanmar?? what is common in all the fight..what are they fighting in burkano faso or in mali or was in Chechnya or in Nigeria... people can see through you people lie and treachery

[@nikko-kun643]

​@@vdjKryptosRockthere are some part that religion fuels this problem at some point. Its the truth.

[@JoshLevente]

The psychopath Sinwar, with the help of Iran orchestrated a medieval war against an innocent population in kibbutz and the festival, with no regard for consequences or human life, and the Palestinian people celebrated in the streets of Canada. They turn around and cry foul when the trauma of Israeli society led the Netanyahu government to no choice but war. The Palestinians problem is not Israel, it has always been Hamas. The only way forward for the region is through coexistence, peace, shared ideas, and positive attitude to mental health.

[@kojoboateng6755]

You mean apartheid co-existence where Palestinians are soo restricted, can't move around freely. Is that how you'd like to live your life?

[@tuforu4]

Arabs. Spent. Oil money on weapons.

[@05350]

Aren’t Palestinians living in a place administered by Palestinians? Obviously, they are the losers as they failed to manage anything besides building the tunnels and attacking the neighbours.

[@yasuke1280]

@@kojoboateng6755🥱

[@somerandomfella]

After watching the whole video, it's almost as if the Israeli government knew about and allowed the attack to claim provocation.

[@Brandonhayhew]

War is true horror beyond comprehension

[@tomidilluminator]

October 7 shouldn’t have happened. Why does Hamas and their group always have to go the terrorist way

[@olgadeweger3805]

Thats what you get when Israel always goes the occupy way.

[@FastAy-t8n]

Best comment ever ,I believe every one voice should be heard ,poverty is always the result of war

[@WoJackHorseman24]

Nelson Mandela was labeled a terrorist at one time

[@05350]

Because they believe in devil.

[@007april60]

1st official terrorist attack was by Zionists, on British Headquarters for Mandatory Palestine in 1946. 1948. Israeli govt. Admitted Israel had struck 1st on another attack. The right of return was initially formulated on 27 June 1948 by United Nations mediator Folke Bernadotte. Proponents of the right of return hold that it is a human right, whose applicability both generally and specifically to the Palestinians is protected. No Hamas around. Mass Graves 1967. Ordered to Dig own, Xd without trial, Dr. Aryeh Yitzhaki is just one of many who documented this. Soldiers were threatened with execution if they questioned or didn't comply. Einstein wrote "If we wait until the Great Powers and the United Nations fulfill their commitments to us then our Palestinian brothers will be under the ground before this is accomplished" etc. He believed the Israeli were “akin to the Nazi and Fascist parties.” Hummm. Rachel Corrie. The UN, Dr. without Borders, Unicef, other Jews, and IOF speaking out. Even lies of Oct 7th were exposed. June 1967 USS Liberty attack by Israeli jets and torpedo boats. They knew! 2010 flotilla raid in int. waters, IDF confiscated passenger's evidence, it was aid for Gaza. This documentary said Israel was under a voluntary ghetto. Yet they control everything. It's illegal to graze, to gather rainwater. Throwing rocks is a jail sentence even without proof no matter the age. Military trial. October 7th is the casus belli needed for a bigger plan. A plan not kept secret, just fuelled. The right to defend goes both ways.

[@bowlampar]

Both sides fill with unforgiveable hatred toward the other with encouragement from 'power of the day' and outsiders. Violence had been going on for at least 75 years with no ending in sight in foreseeable future。

[@CoreyIsTheName]

Ever heard of the crusades? People have been fighting over the same rocks and sand for millenia. For nothing.

[@Hopeadehopelehope911]

She said she lost 70 of her family members. But how many of them are terrorists? make it clear madam.

[@Life-mq5ou]

Gaslighting

[@spitefulbob9254]

All of them because they and the other side are ‘tribes’.

[@TommyTumma]

Zero

[@NemoElohemi]

@@TommyTumma😂

[@hilawiehawaz5633]

Chronic victim mentality, while victimizing millions and millions, generation after generation. What a miserable state of mind

[@Worldaffairslover]

Who are you referring to

[@yasuke1280]

Islam In a nutshell

[@juliajs1752]

@@Worldaffairslover Israel might have been the victims of the October attack, but the crimes and atrocities committed by them over the last half century should not be ignored.

[@MP_mp20]

Eye for an eye will make the whole world blind 😢😢 Thank you DW, for unbiased Doc

[@singhjasbeer5216]

Bottomline is Hamas is entirely responsible for all the sufferings faced by Palestinians and now Lebanon.

[@rusticbox9908]

Utter BS! Israel was formed in 1948 and Israel expanded into Palestinian lands multiple times before Hamas was formed in 1987! Hamas was from from the suffering of the Palestinians!

[@NemoElohemi]

⁠@@rusticbox9908b.s. they would live good lives and with well paid jobs if they only stopped teaching children hatred in kindergartens. Check how Muslims live under their own governments in Egypt, Morocco, Algeria… then talk. This documentary is so disappointing. So called ‘historic Palestinian lands’ were British mandate before and before that ottoman empire that Erdogan wants back. Palestine has never existed as a country. Yasser Arafat invented it with his Russian masters. Palestine is Latin for Roman province 2000 years ago. What do Arabs have to do with Romans? All lies and propaganda.

[@singhjasbeer5216]

@@rusticbox9908 Oh yeah, do remember the celebrations done by entire Muslim world for heinous act by Hamas. Celebrations for murdering Infants, babies, children and women?? No 7th October then no Gaza war no retaliation by Hezbollah in solidarity with Hamas hence no attack on Lebanon either. It is a chain that has been started by Hamas, accept it or not.

[@singhjasbeer5216]

@@rusticbox9908 Oh yeah, do remember the celebrations done by entire Muslim world for unacceptable act by Hamas. Celebrations for overpowering Infants, babies, children and women?? No 7th October then no Gaza war no retaliation by Hezbollah in solidarity with Hamas hence no attack on Lebanon either. It is a chain that has been started by Hamas, accept it or not.

[@ilyeslefi2048]

your mom too !

[@fisalmoon]

As an Arab from Saudi Arabia, I support Israel for commonsensical reasons. The Palestinians are NOT Arabs, read the history and who can be correctly called Arab.

[@WoJackHorseman24]

So Jordanians are Arab, and Egyptians are Arab, but the people living on the small strip of land connecting them are not considered Arab?

[@hazimmizyed]

You're just an israeli spy. You can say you're Madonna if you wanted to

[@tuforu4]

​. Yrs ago I worked in. Iraq. . I learnt. Arabs. No like the. Palestinians..

[@ebweint]

At a certain point a Moroccan has more in common with a Spaniard than with an Iraqi. A Moroccan and an Iraqi could not even understand each other. The farther you go from the Arabian peninsula, then Arabic is just a script, not a common spoken language. France and America both use the same script, not the same language. Even America and Australia do not have a shared sense of nationhood. Perhaps the Pan-Arabist dream has always been a bit fanciful. I would see t-shirts in Ramallah with Nasser ruling everything from Morocco to Yemen to Iraq. Did even Nasser really think this was a possibility? You are seeing a repeat with Islam, there are too many flavors and types for a resurrection of a caliphate. The Ottomans never conquered Persia and throughout it's lifespan numerous independent political entities emerged that were either crushed or negotiated back into the Ottoman state. There was a lengthy period when the Saud Clan had an independent country in the 18th century. The idea of the Ummah is a spiritual idea, it's politically irrelevant. It's as irrelevant politically as Christendom.

[@athinanethi7844]

Thank you for this nuanced documentary … we lose nothing from mourning innocent lives … our identity should be expanded and we should fight for a better future 🫶🏽

[@sanjuktasinhaofficial]

It's a never ending saga of destruction, death, trauma, pain and despair and the whole world can do nothing but remaining a helpless spectator

[@legostud]

The world could do more, but it won’t do anything out of fear of being seen as antisemitic.

[@sanjuktasinhaofficial]

Very true indeed

[@miriamzajfman4305]

Excellent documentary !

[@mothaybabonnam5632]

Anything about the trauma of civilians attending a music festival and getting murdered ?

[@andrewdeen1]

you mean those people who held that rave outside a concentration camp??

[@starcapture3040]

What were they doing dancing in a war zone next to a concentration camp?

[@05350]

@@andrewdeen1camp managed by Hamas?

[@ManishKumar-tx7mc]

You can clearly see double standard of German based (DW documentary). For example they are running a program about BSF has killed a boy from bangladesh and taken interview of Bangladesh home guard interview . BUT they didn't try to engage BSF officer in their program ,they didn't take what are BSF's saying in this matter. But when comes to western country suddenly their stance changes. I fully support Israel right to defence and fight against terrorism .

[@JimLifeWorthLiving-u2i]

Thank you DW for the documentary. I have been watching your programs for several years and I always return knowing to get information with great narration and production work. Cheers. Happy Oktoberfest. - former highschool German language student. took it because of Rammstein :P

[@IsraelControlsOurSocialMed-p2x]

Isn't this a German based news group? 80 years of embarrassing yourself is too much. Get off your knees.

[@lornestein7248]

• In 1937, the Peel Commission proposed the partition of Palestine and the creation of an Arab state. • In 1939, the British White Paper proposed the creation of a unitary Arab state. • In 1947, the UN would have created an even larger Arab state as part of its partition plan. • The 1979 Egypt-Israel peace negotiations offered the Palestinians autonomy, which would almost certainly have led to full independence. • The Oslo agreements of the 1990s laid out a path for Palestinian independence, but the process was derailed by terrorism. • In 2000, Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered to create a Palestinian state in all of Gaza and 97 percent of the West Bank. • In 2008, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert offered to withdraw from almost the entire West Bank and partition Jerusalem on a demographic basis. • In addition 1948 to 1967, Israel did not control the West Bank. The Palestinians could have demanded an independent state from the Jordanians. On the contrary whilst Jordan was in control Arafat said there was no longer a claim as it was no longer part of Palestine. Once it was back in Israeli hands it miraculously became disputed land again!

[@minhazularefin5490]

It seems 1200 is more important than 40000 human beings to DW . And they called them unbiased media.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Dottor_J]

including over 10000 children. And the 40k count is only talking about humans killed with weapons. The IDF bombed water infrastructures and hospitals, the real death count is much higher

[@seungdaelee8299]

these documents are why I check DW channel every hour.

[@rocobruno]

Apart from the highly complicated origins of the conflict, I found that video quite objective after all. In this region, it seems only hate or fear of the other side is cultivated which is a sad state of situation. Will this conflict resolve to peace in my lifetime, sadly, I doubt it...

[@Ronifromearth]

Thanks DW 😊 👍

[@DWDocumentary]

Thank you for watching. :)

[@pratikdas1875]

Peace for all

[@banerjeesiddharth05]

Mind blowing documentary 👌 🙌 👏 🙏

[@ronaldanane5451]

The definition of trauma is deep and manifests daily in our lives

[@livewillalive3744]

Solution is both sides dissolve their countries name and keep ISPAL OR PALRAEL for Israel and Palestine and unite as one nation, Many countries consist of multi -ethnic,multi - religious countries like India,why can’t palestine and Israel, I wish both come together and live as one nation then their will be peace otherwise till world end of the world war cycle will be continued and it will be never ending.May peace prevail between Israel and Palestine.

[@TechnicallyBeige]

People with those "double standards" comments clearly didn't get past the 15 minute mark of the documentary. This is an exceptional reminder of the humanity of all parties involved; that people are not their governments, that people do not choose this or want this, and that all anybody wants anywhere is to live safely. That there are no TRUE winners in a war; everybody loses, because ALL survivors are traumatized. People are getting dragged into things they'd really rather do without, and some random trolls sit online and declare this "biased" just because it's not focusing solely on the thing they want to hear. War is ugly for everybody. Both sides deserve to be heard. If your idea of justice consists of an entitlement to neglect any perspective other than your own, go check your own standards, if you have any at all.

[@judyclarkson5887]

WAR u said.. When the settlers have been doing nasty things to the native people of West Bank. They even blockade their mosque that they can't practice their religions ritus there... Idk why some ppl still dare to say that this is a war unless those ppl haven't educated themselves enough on this topic. It's a classic ongoing occupation and some militias groups decided to fill that vacuum to fight against that ongoing occupation. Simple as that

[@kojoboateng6755]

The idea that you can move yourself to a land already occupied and evict the original occupiers by force is wrong.

[@nolongerinbetween3913]

Exactly. War is ugly for everybody - for Nazis as well, for oppressors, for occupiers, for colonizers etc Right? It's easy to see how ugly was the war for one side having a music festival and partying just hundreds meters away from the people they imprisoned...

[@Worldaffairslover]

How about the settlers? There are hundreds and thousands of them. Representing a sizable portion of Israel. Nearly 10%

[@davidbeare730]

It is untrue that Israel and Hamas etc. are boath acting irrationaly because they are traumatized. HAMAS declared war by invading Israel and then ensured massive civilian casualties in Gaza by using Gazan civilians as human shields. Examining history will never change these recent well recorded events.

[@ronenlevy7433]

Whenever you here the term "Both Sides" stop listening!!

[@legostud]

“Volunteer Getto”? Who volunteers to live in a Getto? This guy at 14:20 sounds very much like a German Leader during WWII.

[@RobertMartinezPhoto]

It seems like Gaza is a modern concentration camp / ghetto. Kind of bizarre and crazy like if it is reversed. Versus WW2 camps... somewhat. Sad And no I am not a scholar or take sides. And it is indeed complex. Just saying its like it is reversed now. And sad.

[@michal3506]

Sinwar, you re next on the list

[@muhammad_ainur_fitri]

The conflict between Israel and the Palestine is unsolvable and finally a nuclear bomb was used and was in the middle east, because in a conflict between Israelis and Arabs and Muslims, rationality dissolves and fears take over. - Lee Kuan Yew

[@graceazar4637]

Most of this documentary is BS . the palestinians live in lala land , they could stayed but they want all ! And they have a limit with Egypt, why they muslim brothers dont help them !Hamas is their enemies

[@tuforu4]

NO. FACTORYS OR DEVELOPMENT SAME AS SYRIA.

[@karasumaru2805]

@@tuforu4 No hospitals or universities or cancer wards or NICU facilities either. What a bunch of savages. It's almost like Israel blocked all their trade, bombed their civilian infrastructure to make life as miserable as possible to get them to give up and leave so they can have the land.

[@JacqueKC]

And now we are getting second hand trauma! I remember a time when others were the terrorizing team and the world knew! This madness has to stop and the lies that come with it!

[@JAM661]

Gaza has been treated like a open air prison for decades. The lose of Palestinian lands while Israel offers those land to Jews who live all over the world to come to Israel to live there and take over that land does not sit well for the Palestinian people or for the Neighbors around Israel. For decades the government of Israel has been denying the basic human rights to the people of Palestinian and when responding always doing so with increased violence. Basically people will only allowed to be beaten down so long before they have fight back. But Israel's arrogance through the years and through their belief that they're stronger than their enemies have led them to know peaceful Solutions and only responding always with increased military powers. What has happen does not surprise me one bit. The sad thing is 90% of those who will be harmed by this has no personal responsibilty for this and those who been making horrible choice will continue to make them. You have children throwing rocks a 100 ft away from a Israeli soldier who is in riot gear and those rocks would cause no injury. However instead of soldier ignoring the problem or even just throwing the Rocks back at the kids they're literally shooting at the kids like target practice with military Long Range High caliber rifles. Yep that looks good to do that to a bunch of 10 years old. Isreal is here from there inactions and refusal to understand there polices of power are not policies of ensuring peace, only control. Gaza is like the Warsaw ghetto and the people have about that much freedom when it come to be able to leave. They cannot leave that strip of land ( a whole 25 miles unless Israel gives them permission) The bubble has burst. Meanwhile how do you think the people of Gaza have felt all these years. But when you do tatics that kill innocent people or purposely limit things like food and opportunities the Palastein face it does not sit well and people will fight back. I don't know why America supports Israel anyway because they certainly have not done anything to help us, that's for sure. They just keep drawing us into wars that are really none of our business.

[@WalkwithRoberto]

I hope you don’t mind if I offer a few clarifications based on historical context and well-documented facts: Firstly, the comparison between Gaza and the Warsaw Ghetto is not accurate. The Warsaw Ghetto was a horrific situation during the Holocaust, where Jews were systematically starved, abused, and ultimately sent to extermination camps. While Gaza certainly faces hardships, it's important to recognize the different historical contexts. Gaza is governed internally by Hamas, a group that has been responsible for starting conflicts over and over, massacring its own internal dissidents, launching thousands of rockets at Israel, and using civilian areas for military purposes, which complicates the situation significantly. Israel's restrictions on Gaza, including the blockade, are largely a security measure aimed at preventing weapons from entering the region. It's worth noting that both EGYPT and Israel control Gaza’s borders, with EGYPT enforcing its own restrictions on the Gaza-Egypt border. Regarding the land issue, Israel was established in 1948 following a United Nations resolution, and the Jewish connection to the land dates back THOUSANDS of years and It’s important to mention that Israel has offered land for peace on several occasions, such as the Camp David Accords in 2000, but negotiations have often broken down, due to the Palestinian side. As for Israel’s response to violence, it’s vital to acknowledge that ANY COUNTRY facing security threats, including frequent rocket attacks targeting civilian populations and terror attacks, would seek to protect its citizens. The claim that Israeli soldiers target children is false and not supported by any credible international investigation. Israel’s military response, like that of any state, is subject to international law and scrutiny. It's also critical to remember that Israel’s military is defending against groups like Hamas, which openly calls for Israel’s destruction, the annihilation of Jews and is always using civilians as human shields, which they readily exploit through social media. Gaza has seen years where goods and humanitarian aid have flowed freely, but they always end when their leaders decide to increase violence and launch terrorist attacks, which naturally results in Israel tightening its restrictions for the safety of civilians. Gaza has historically prioritized conflict over development, investing in weapons rather than infrastructure for their people, which contributes to the dire situation. Best regards

[@DanielFöhr-z5b]

- not an open air prison, there is a border with Egypt. - Israel has trade with Gaza (at least before their heinous acts) and also provides 13% of their drinking water. The classic argument “they are just fighting back at Israel” is laughable. Raping woman, children and young peaceful people at a music festival has exactly nothing to do with fighting back. And they are excited about it, brag about it calling their parents. People in the west including you from probably Germany or Switzerland need to get rid of their conceived notion that Palestinians just want to live in peace. They are indoctrinated since childhood to believe in a death cult (Islam) - where you get straight to paradise when you **** a Jew. Unfortunately people like you are too far gone and fell for the victimhood propaganda of the Palestinians and the Muslim world. They are purposefully building military installations under civilian areas, fight in civ clothing etc- all in the effort to have more Palestinians killed to arise even more pity. It is sad. Hopefully you’ll never have to find out how wrong you are with your peace loving ideals about Gaza and Muslims. Go ahead to Gaza , Iran , Pakistan and declare you are gay or dare to say anything against Allah - you ll not leave alive. Ah well, I forgot Muslims have a history of killing cartoonist in the west, too. Pure coincidence of course and not representative of the teachings of Islam (please read the damn book and inform yourself a bit. Compare it to the Bible or other scriptures)

[@fisalmoon]

keep lying 🤥

[@spacemonkeyII]

Fisalmoon. If he's lying then point out where and refute what he said or go back to Chaturbate where you're an expert.

[@tuforu4]

Ayotollah khomeni in 1979. Said it. .

[@repenttoreflect8933]

The title of this documentary is so biased. A reporter and journalist has to be impartial. Just shameful.

[@ekno2506]

Heartbreaking. Especially when I see those kids. They should have never experienced all this.

[@SupCortez]

Comparable to the brutal wars fought by indigenous people of America vs the Spanish

[@evelynreyes8231]

Great documentary, very informative; it almost seems like both sides have been hurt so much that they are blinded and without a clear objective about a reason to keep fighting. They just keep doing it, generation after generation.

[@NemoElohemi]

It’s a documentary full of lies. But you need to know history to understand that.

[@isajamil4027]

This is the most hypocritical title to ever be given to a video

[@IsraelControlsOurSocialMed-p2x]

Imagine oppressing people for 80 years then turning around and acting like the victim.

[@SamSam-jr5qu]

Let Israel live in peace

[@maxpro6379]

Muslims should learn how to live peacefully with others

[@spacemonkeyII]

Stop it Sam Sam you IDF bot. People aren't playing your game anymore.

[@spacemonkeyII]

Max. They're in their own countries not bothering anyone else. What's USA doing in the M.E?

[@spacemonkeyII]

Serious question Max. They're in their own countries minding their own business. USA though is in the Middle East. What is USA doing in the Middle East?

[@legostud]

The horrific acts of October 7th could have been prevented if the 2 years of peaceful protests by the Palestinians hadn’t been ignored by the world. Why is a 2 state solution so hard for the world to recognize and support.

[@Why_Dude_Why]

what makes you think hamas, hezbollah and iran have ANY interest in a 2 state solution. THEY DON"T!!!

[@hashimabdullahi34]

@@Why_Dude_Why are you serious with this your ignorant statement? Is literally even in the Hamas charter that they will recognize Israel and make peace with it if Israel agrees to a 2 state solution within the 1967 borders,Israel is the stronger side here and they have never offered Palestinians a full autonomous state.

[@Why_Dude_Why]

@@hashimabdullahi34 No. In the 1988 Hamas charter they wrote, " Israel will continue to exist until it is destroyed by ISLAM. " It was revised in 2017. From Wikipedia: In May 2017 Palestinian political and military organization Hamas unveiled A Document of General Principles and Policies (وثيقة المبادئ والسياسات العامة لحركة حماس), also referred to as the new or revised Hamas charter.[1] It accepted the idea of a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders, i.e. comprising the West Bank and Gaza strip only,[2] on the condition that also the Palestinian refugees were allowed to return to their homes,[3] if it is clear this is the consensus of the Palestinians[4] ("a formula of national consensus"[5]); but at the same time this document strove for the "complete liberation of Palestine, from the river to the sea",[5] and did not explicitly recognize Israel As you can see, the Hamas charter calls for 1) THE COMPLETE LIBERATION OF "PALESTINE" FROM THE RIVR TO THE SEA 2) Does NOT recognize Israel as a legitimate state. THIS IS NOT A PRESCRIPTION FOR PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST. TO SAY OTHERWISE IS TAQQIYAH=MUSLIM LIES=TO TALK OF PEACE WITH A SMILE ON YOUR FACE AND A KNIFE BEHIND YOUR BACK

[@KT-pe6zh]

This documentary leaves out the fact that the so-called "peaceful protest" you are referring to was very much violent. During the great March of Return, Palestinians in Gaza sent over to Israel incendiary kites and balloons, creating fires that would ultimately damage infrastructure and the environment.

[@Beeoriginal33]

"In August 1831, led by Nat Turner, the rebels, made up of enslaved African Americans, killed between 55 and 65 white people, making it the deadliest slave revolt for the latter racial group in U.S. history". " In December 2021, the Virginia Department of Cultural Resources dedicated the "Blackhead Signpost Road" historic marker the intersection of Virginia State Route 35 and Meherrin Road. Nat Turner's Rebellion is celebrated as part of Black August". * SOURCE WIKIPEDIA So, Nat Turner, a very intelligent slave, one day organized a revolt , which led to the massacre of 65 white people, among them women and children. Even at that time , an editor of a newspaper said basically "if u treat people as black slaves were treated , a revolt like that was to be expected" . As u see, since 2021 that revolt is part of "Black Month". Just saying..

[@mrincognito8355]

Lol comparing real victims vs self made victims...1948 UN partitioned two states, Hamas rejected the plan wanted whole land. Evacuating entire region creating refugees. Start multiple wars lost all the time. Even most of its allies do want to continue it's war as it can see HAMAS has only one solution from the beginning and Its not going to happen based on their capabilities. Now talk about shoving all your failures of decision making on to your enemy while you make further escalations. Talk about double standards

[@mrincognito8355]

@@Beeoriginal33 I do not support Israel in this aggression whatsoever just for context both sides should take responsibility..only one side should not perpetuate victim hood ..Comparing slavehood to this manmade crises is ridiculous

[@mrincognito8355]

@@Beeoriginal33 What solution do you see as logical for both states?(Two states solution rejected multiple times by HAMAS) Why does only Israel should be responsible for this Humanitarian disaster situation of Palestinians but not HAMAS.

[@WoJackHorseman24]

@@mrincognito8355 Hamas did not exist in 1948. There should be a single state named Palestine, with Jerusalem as its capital. The European refugees who arrived in Palestine after World War II could have coexisted without claiming territory and behaving like traditional colonizers

[@mahfuzulislam26]

Double standards and biased report.

[@RottenChain]

would you care to provide arguments for that statement, I am interested.

[@yasuke1280]

Fuqch izlame 😊

[@orsataf9278]

Islam is bad

[@MP_mp20]

Where their is Islam their is problem

[@RottenChain]

@@MP_mp20 and I suppose Ultra Zionism is not bad?

[@qamachi69]

Thanks kindly DW for deleting my comment. Truly this channel is so Honest and Awesome ❤

[@DWDocumentary]

If your comment doesn't appear, it may have been held by KZbin or deleted because it violated our community standards and guidelines. Comments that are copied and pasted numerous times often fall under KZbin spam. We kindly ask viewers to read and respect our netiquette policy. This can be found linked in all our video descriptions and on our website: p.dw.com/p/MF1G.

[@erolgenlik4922]

This should be on Turkish version too....

[@HassanHadow]

I'm feeling physically sick

[@paulwary]

Should israel have been founded the way it was? Probably not. Are the israelis going to move out? No. Do the Israelis have a right to protect themselves? Yes. Do their actions in Gaza count as genocide? Probably. Is either side going to relent? Absolutely not.

[@trinisun]

The Jewish life seems to have more value than the Palestinian life, according to the West.

[@a1physicsacademy45]

Double standards of western media

[@theladiesman.8537]

Well western media tends to be kontrolled by the youknowwhos.

[@IsraelControlsOurSocialMed-p2x]

Who 0wns western media.

[@RottenChain]

would you care to provide arguments for that statement, I am interested.

[@KevinBruun]

stop manipulating the world we are not all totally dumbs lol

[@candicemacfarlane1527]

Talk about being one sided....

[@sumitnirban8151]

Moral of the story is hyenas will remain hyenas and Lion remains KING of jungle.

[@tony20c9e]

The only ones who are whining are those who celebrated October 7.

[@itispossible9272]

Is this document one sided perhaps?

[@SahilShaikh-k6s]

DW saying Israel knew about but didn't take it seriously 🤔

[@santoshpatil-eo9ol]

What did lord Krishna preached to world after Kurukshetra is that no one wins war, one who wins war is that one who wins heart, one who has humanity , one who follow dharma, if you preserve dharma definitely dharma will preserve you................. after all no one has permanent place on earth....................... god has given brilliant mind to every human being but the same mind don't know what's coming in future, no one know how we are going to die and where we are going to die but always dream how we want live this life............... in my opinion if you want good relationship with someone bow your head for good deeds, be kind to others, forget past live in present......... happiness comes when we share things not destroying peace......... if you don't have character to love someone its alright but shouldn't have character of betraying someone..................... i 🙏 to lord shiva once again peace and prosperity prevail in both countries ....

[@jonathanganani903]

Looks like Good Documentary.

[@danivlogs3100]

Lmao Israel propaganda awww poor Israel video ok. Nice try

[@orengamble2362]

Unsubscribing. Not watching. Headline sounds like an assertion that Israel is the victim rather than the perpetrator of this violence.

[@GrillWasabi]

Middle Eastern world have such beautiful people and food. I am a US citizen and I disagree with the war! Let it be peace. ❤🙏

[@symoonstar23]

Now people's should learn care&loving & do not look down on others people's

[@sandman303]

What you call when you get what you ask for...? ~Palestine!

[@whilebeingjezebel]

Is the narrator an AI voice? Also the translator.

[@bisiyahaya350]

I am trying to understand how this would ever ever end. Everything in life has a cause and effect but what happens if people responsible for the cause don't want to accept responsibility but only talk about the effect of they started 🤦🏾‍♂️. And the cycle would never stop one attack, revenge follows, another revenge attack another revenge and it goes on and on and on....until when? Only God knows I suppose

[@EveryGoalsInFootballMatch]

7/10 is bad Mistake

[@SeánCaomhánach]

Ridiculous reporting, Unsubscribing!

[@afteryou55]

Great piece DW!

[@ruffY143]

Chess is older than islam....😂😂😂 chess was founded in 6th century in India...while Isla in 7th century 😂😂😂

[@eddyr1041]

There is a good story about the suffering of nakba... But ps: There is also a statement that most big majority country of 1948 agrres with the erection of the state of israel. World voted... For palestinian the should be palestinian atate too. Except... The arabs.. Why... as majority in area region they were confident they can win by ethnic cleansing jews in new state of israel...the voting world...votes in only lips service but voted...hence they attack like sands is their amount... Miracles happen... arab lost.. These also stated in video

[@Terminator550]

The propaganda is strong

[@taylor12633]

eye for an eye. endless decades of war.

[@abhinavauzir8011]

Great documentary .Atleast you are not biased .Please try to cover Manipur ,India .Since last there is a war like situation.👍👍👍

[@samanthaw4955]

And what of “Israeli Terror” DW? Genocide is a war crime atrocity no matter how you try to downplay it. Justice for those oppressed by an apartheid regime.

[@whilebeingjezebel]

33:58:05. She could be talking about holocaust victims, or palestinians, couldn't she? #thinkaboutit

[@Decision333]

Imagine Germany (The original abuser) funding and supporting the new abusers (Israel). Abuse causes abuse. Trauma causes trauma.

[@Worldaffairslover]

Claiming that Israel has equality is as laughable as the notion that all men are created equal

[@ebweint]

Can you think of a political entity ever in human history when the ideal and the reality were completely synchronized?

[@34547]

What about the terror of Israel for decades?

[@amirkestin8413]

😂😅

[@egynyilas]

@@amirkestin8413 when the goyim have enough of you again then the Muslims are going to laugh

[@orsataf9278]

Islam usual victim hood

[@AbomahmodElbacha]

We are all human beings regardless religions so we need to find ways for sustainable peace for all nations. PEACE AND SECURE WORLD IS VITALLY IMPORTANT NEED FOR ALL THE GLOBE 🌎.

[@KareemMontoya]

Act of terorist act of satan

[@Ronifromearth]

18:08 they are doing yoga ?! 😊

[@TheTritan408]

Victims card denied

[@theladiesman.8537]

Always the victim, zero self reflection on their own behaviour. Is ra hell is the aggressor here.

[@IsraelControlsOurSocialMed-p2x]

The whole world is watching. Everyone is watching except politicians and media. Gee I wonder why that is?

[@ahsantariq1720]

For the audience: The 2 "sides" referred to in this documentary include the occupier (Israel) and the occupied (Gaza). You can figure out the rest yourself. Bonus: The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has declared the occupation of Gaza as ILLEGAL.

[@maxpro6379]

Stop stop blah blah blah

[@williamgenis9596]

20 MIN Y YA LO SAQUE...SESGADO POCO OBJETIVO E HIPOCRITA....

[@wolfy789]

DW ignoring the fact that Gaza shares a border with Egypt.

[@avrahamavraham5977]

❤❤❤❤❤🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🫶🏻💕

[@Musavwastanley]

Stop seeking sympathy from the world your sons,husbands,and dads started thise and not the jews as you state it.

[@ParasSharma-hn9sp]

German web series on Middle East.

[@orsataf9278]

Without lies Islam dies

[@ManuelAlfonso-pl7fc]

el que esta quieto se deja quieto

[@cheylou1]

Why won’t the arabs take their own people home to intricate.?

[@PhaseTw0]

Yeah yeah the poor palestinians...zero self reflection.

[@IsraelControlsOurSocialMed-p2x]

@@rolffriis5149 its a big word, I don't think he can spell it.

[@CoreyIsTheName]

Tell me you didn't watch this without telling me you didn't watch this.

[@demiller74]

Klein Einsatzgruppen… that was October 7th.

[@marc-andregagne3764]

i love them both palestinian and jewish but they are both mad ;)

[@عبداللهالسيدالبحباح]

just to remind u all of the destroyed buildings u see in gaza not israel

[@rajworship]

just to remind you that hamas started it on 07/10/23.. HAMAS..started it .stop claiming victimhood. people can see through you people lie and hypocrisy

[@عبداللهالسيدالبحباح]

@@rajworship bro how we were living in peas then suddenly u come to me and say this my land and kiking me out of my house in 1948 and so on ...and when i come and try to return my land ...to free the 9000 prisoners that u took u say to me ur the bad guy? U can go in tili and see how they treat us how they kill us and when we respond u say u started this ... actualy i started defending my self sir

[@beautifulworld-b9q]

Unsubscribed

[@MohammedHatamzadeh]

مردم میترسندعربی یادبگیرندیاحرف بزنندتامجبورنشوند۔۔۔۔تروریست معرفی شوند۔۔۔۔۔۔زبان عربی زباتروریست معرفی شده

[@ไม่ดี-บ3ฟ]

Fake

[@spacemonkeyII]

Hello Americans. What is your military doing in the Middle East? Protecting your freedoms? How did your freedoms get into the Middle East?

[@Lyall304]

Hello why are you fighting the only Jewish nation in the world? How many Muslim countries are there? You justify going against Gods promises to the prophet Moses how?

[@spacemonkeyII]

Modern Isra hell is a creation of Satan. Are you are Satan worshiper? Answer the question: what is USA doing in other people's countries?