Eat It Or Yeet It But Everything Is Green

This one is for Shayne who actively avoids green food on Eat It Or Yeet It.
SUBSCRIBE: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshPit
WEAR OUR JOKES: smosh.com
WHO YOU SEE
Courtney Miller // / co_mill
Shayne Topp // / shaynetopp
Noah Grossman // / noahgrossman214
Amanda Lehan-Canto // / filmingamanda
Tommy Bowe // / tomeybones
Angela Giarratana // / angelagiovanagiarratana
Garrett Palm // / gpalm79
WHO YOU DON’T SEE (usually)
Director: Kimmy Jimenez
Editor: Andre Gardere
Director of Programming, Smosh Pit: Kiana Parker
Associate Producer, Smosh Pit: Kimmy Jimenez
Assistant Director: Heidi Ha
Art Director: Cassie Vance
Assistant Art Director: Erin Kuschner
Art Coordinator: Alex Aguilar
Audio Mixer: Major Latimer
Camera Operators/Gaffers: Eric Wann, Macy Armstrong
Director of Photography: Darren Kho
Production Assistant: Joshua Dozier
Prop Assistant: Oliver Wehlander
Set Dresser: Squid Spelman
Social Media: Tommy Bowe, Mallory Myers
Director, Design: Brittany Hobbs
DIT/AE: Matt Duran
Post Production Manager: Luke Baker
Production, EVP: Zoe Moacanin
Production Manager: Amanda Barnes
Production Coordinator: Heidi Ha
Production Assistant: Marcus Munguia
Senior Manager, Channel & Strategy: Lizzy Jones
Talent Coordinator: Selina Garcia
Office PA: Ovsana Tsaturian
NEW SMOSH VIDEOS:
Watch Competitive Storytelling | Board AF: It's Kind Of A Fun Story: • Competitive Storytelli...
Watch Reddit's Biggest Regrets | Reading Reddit Stories: • Reddit's Biggest Regre...
OTHER SMOSHES:
Smosh: smo.sh/Sub2Smosh
Smosh Games: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshGames
El Smosh (Spanish Dub): smo.sh/Sub2ElSmosh
SmoshCast: smo.sh/Sub2SmoshCast
FOLLOW US:
TikTok: smo.sh/TikTok
Snapchat: smo.sh/OnSnapchat
Instagram: / smosh
Facebook: / smosh
Twitter: / smosh

[@DarkWatcherDS]

Shayne is a menace to society LMAO. He injures Amanda, gaslights Angela and steals the bell from her. THEN TRICKS THE WHOLE TABLE INTO EATING THE GARBAGE COOKIES?! This man is a danger to us all

[@Galiant2010]

He's gone inShayne

[@livingwithpetsandplants9539]

Lol 😂

[@KatalinaKristina]

They need to call HR lol

[@Kradch1]

Psychology + acting be like 👀

[@Lordpooz09]

Eat it or Yeet it is literally Shayne's villain origin story

[@criticallol3039]

I believe if you took the DNA of Shayne and Angela and mixed them together, you'd probably create the loudest human in existence.

[@lphphd5298]

That's just a child

[@Periodnetta]

So if they had a child

[@elfieharper]

they'd also be green after all that dye

[@criticallol3039]

​@@PeriodnettaNo, no. Just a fully formed adult human embodiment of a sonic boom walking out of a cloning tube, like in that one Doctor Who episode.

[@harrywebb2602]

I believe it would possibly create a mogaie and then a gremlin

[@halfbee7886]

Shayne’s degree allows him to turn into a psychopath he needs to be for this game. It’s perfect.

[@connorwhite7120]

Honestly I think it's more that he's a good actor lol

[@williamjasper2734]

Shane doing his best Cuba Gooding Jr impression: I WENT TO ARIZONA STATE!! I’M A SUNDEVIL MAN! 😂

[@sarahwatson3192]

Shayne and Amanda went full sibling for the bell. Amanda was the younger sibling “THERES A HOLE IN MY HAND.” And Shayne the older one with the “that was half Damien speed.”

[@pmp5527]

Damien is the even older brother who's in college and the siblings think he's really cool and Shayne's old enough to have played with him when he was younger

[@stevenolivares5643]

@@pmp5527omg that’s perfect lol

[@simpayshenaides]

You guys do siblings and friendship on the cast makes me cringe all the time LOL

[@retro_mxxn3334]

@@simpayshenaidesthat’s sad, for you of course

[@abbystevely7018]

The fact that Shayne didn't wear his limes shirt for this episode feels like a bigger betrayal than stabbing Amanda's hand

[@RyuujinLetum]

With Mr Gruber calling him Limes

[@imgabiireyes]

right?

[@gopherbarney8707]

No guys that's Ian's shirt, Ian wore it that day but Shayne made sure to steal one of Ian's Bummers with "looks like a baby duck in a dawn commercial" and "brought to you by BP"

[@TechnologicallyTechnical]

I mean, I think 'stabbing' is selling it short, he basically ripped Amanda's hand in two.

[@Miladybug]

It’s the Kimmy betrayal all over again

[@flipotssss]

Noah's best jokes always fly under the radar: "You got perforated! Two more and you get a free sandwich" 😂

[@ChaosGames21]

I know! I was dying laughing when he said that! 😂

[@ellieanderson5745]

OR OR "The same way he hurt you with no regret"

[@Foxy-ve1oh]

i know i was laughing so hard at that but i dont think they noticed that joke,they were probably to focused on amanda to hear it

[@KatalinaKristina]

True 😆😆

[@umbrellawitch504]

im dying bc of that joke hes a genius

[@PrettyBigDyl93]

As usual, the caption writer is the real hero. 16:53 (Angela giggling and panicking like a squirrel) is too accurate.

[@spiralheart42]

Also 20:12 (Angela screaming like a feral Guinea pig) 😂

[@miranda27895]

@@spiralheart4221:36 Angela feral screaming 😂

[@furno2373]

Damn cc guy went after her. 😂

[@user-dl6gm4ee6x]

That is so funny😂😂

[@user-dl6gm4ee6x]

Angela went insane at the end

[@jordanfiebig6404]

"Is this coconut? EWWWW!!" - Tommy after eating a wasabi cookie, unfazed Truly a man after my own heart

[@maveryriley]

Shayne was absolutely unhinged today. He successfully managed to trick the entire table into eating wasabi cookies.

[@Freda2346]

This has to be one of my favorite eat it or yeet it moments

[@mudstt]

Definitely top 5 Eat it or Yeet it moments

[@gehtdinichtsan309]

his degree in psychology finally pays off! :p

[@f.faucon6681]

Don't forget that Courtney had to remain silent about the content and managed to trick them too with her countdown. Amazing duo.

[@christopherbartko6042]

Iiiiieee LOOOVVED IT.... The look on his FACE! 🤣

[@VivaLaVlogger]

But can we talk about how buff Tommy looks in this video?? OKAY ARMS

[@edithmilian]

I was just about to comment! He looks soo good!

[@Fanthomas1742]

Yeah I noticed it at the end of the love is blind video. Impressive

[@fredrainey3038]

Y'all I was about to say! he looks yoked

[@phillskinner8671]

Came to say wtf? has Tbo been on teh juice?

[@ThePoisonLotus]

Like, respectfully? Bark. Woof, even.

[@Lady_Ginnie]

Amanda repeating "wheatgrass" in a more and more annoyed tone while everyone around her debates what tasted so weird about Noah's dish was hilarious, lol.

[@damienw95]

Angela saying "Yeet bucket's on the right, Angela's on the left" killed me 😂

[@abbybaudhuin7859]

and then Courtney saying yeet buckets on the left killed me more lmao

[@IceArceus_]

Shayne was on another level this episode 😂 So unhinged lmao

[@P0rk_Sinigang]

Yeah, and then everyone else would also feed the energy. This got weird, lol

[@AliFareedMC]

He turned Angela into a cat 😂😂😂

[@kaweenis]

amanda too LMAO

[@sinnaro13]

So good!

[@YTFlove4ever]

He came to sacrifice everyone else to the eiyi gods

[@alchemist3661]

Shayne played the biggest mindfuck ever, TWICE. First with Angela, then with LITERALLY EVERYONE

[@caitlinbecker9889]

The subtitles being " Angela giggling and panicking like a squirrel" took me out 😂 Followed by "Angela screaming like a feral guinea pig"

[@arodallecwildflower4538]

You've inspired me to turn on subtitles

[@COMsquared]

exactly what i came to the comments to say XD

[@kandle513]

Everything about the wasabi cookies, from Shayne's trick to Angela to snorting it to Tommy screaming about the coconut water was the epitome of chaotic Smosh I loved it 🤣

[@chisk_392]

FINNALY SOMEONE MENTIONED TOMMY’S DISGUST

[@horsetronaut]

Courtney's horror to Shane's reveal sent me

[@kandle513]

@@horsetronaut omg yes I just came back to watch it again and you're so right

[@artsyaeollaaria5821]

I love how Shane is laughing off hurting Amanda. You KNOW Damien would be shitting his pants with guilt.

[@izzayy_]

@@refreeyokay bud.

[@gilly_axolotl]

​@@refreeydo you know that what you said comes across quite rudely, just like in general

[@RetrospectsToo]

That’s how you know they have become good friends.

[@Munchticles]

But Shayne only went at half Damien speed.

[@rhiannonmackenzie2527]

Shayne was pretty quiet for a few minutes afterwards, I think he was feeling the guilt, but tried to shrug it off to enjoy the episode.

[@sterigma555]

Thank god Shanye uses his powers for comedy and not evil.

[@ImNotElijah]

Idk today he utilized some sinister activity 😭😂

[@trinitybernhardt9944]

That was evil lol

[@rhettmitchell]

This one was pretty evil actually

[@TechnologicallyTechnical]

@@rhettmitchell yes, but it was funny evil

[@mrkbri]

Shayne has evolved from reading people’s minds to straight up controlling them 😭

[@GilbertTheWeird]

Like Plankton with that remote in Spongebob's brain.

[@ellieanderson5745]

DYING at shayne laughing for well over 30 seconds over his duck joke

[@bosserman444]

When was this?

[@succhiami]

​@@bosserman4445:09

[@mctom613]

@@bosserman4445:08

[@anastasiahall2711]

Shayne being a mastermind and everyone flipping out while Tommy just enters his mind palace 😂

[@T.Florenz]

Amanda has inescapable mom energy except for that powerfully perfected younger sibling fake pain scream. 💀

[@Stephie0125]

The thing about Amanda is she's so damned competitive that she turns into a child the instant that competitiveness is challenged. I get the short bangs in those moments.

[@jellllybean30]

@@Stephie0125 lol what

[@hardrockjo_3978]

17:05 Amanda, to shayne: how did you eat that with no issues? Noah: the same way he hurt you with no regret HOLY SHIT 😂

[@killianistired]

Tommy meditating with the cookie nodding while chaos went on around him is the emotional detachment I wanna carry into the new year. Icon ✨️

[@JdOsLive]

Shayne really uses his psychology degree only to just to mess with the other cast members' decision-making in hitting the bell lol.

[@trinitybernhardt9944]

Well worth the years of schooling 😄

[@talia_al_gabagool]

Like the chimpanzee bit lol

[@acediaavaritias1860]

What does his psychology degree have to do with this? He simply faked his reaction, you don't need a degree to do that. If anything, it's his acting. Y'all swear he's doing something super complex.

[@GreenPoint1992]

@@acediaavaritias1860 i know right?

[@Olivia-xf4gy]

I'm honestly so terrified and impressed by Shane's ability to lie and psych people out as well as take wasabi

[@nix_go_boom3124]

That psychology degree

[@daanachmad4032]

He is a lot smarter than he presents himself to be.

[@Tylerlefttheband]

He's experct in mental bretrayal

[@Cecona]

This is the same man that tricked everyone into thinking he was terrified of apes knowing they could never legally bring one on set

[@shadow_master7303]

Used both his acting and psychology skills

[@LivingMyLife22]

Amanda repeatedly yelling ‘wheatgrass’ killed me 😂😂

[@MsACP2012]

She was so fed up that they wouldn't listen lmao😂

[@matthewgigs3456]

16:56 I love how Angela rejected the beach, put it in front of Noah, grabbed his right out of his hand in a matter of seconds.

[@christophergirardi8145]

Damn, Shayne came in clutch this episode, his Grave Mouth and Psychology Degree is truly a dangerous combination.

[@lonestar2078]

does his Grave Mouth have any effect on spice? figured it was specifically only sour stuff

[@nevermindmeijustinjectedaw9988]

ask your grandparents what they can still taste. old people naturally develop grave mouth

[@akx13]

Shayne had such strong older brother vibes in this video. Like after he smashed Amanda's hand he might as well have said "you're fine you big baby stop crying" and then tricking your younger siblings into doing something they shouldn't? Straight out of the older sibling handbook😂

[@boomgirlbucko]

Ironic since he's a youngest sibling

[@Lucarioguild7]

I mean Amanda was definitely milking it a bit much lol

[@WAHedgeWitch]

I feel like Arasha would be perfectly to strategically place on set with a drink that looks gross & says oh it’s actually good….then when it shows up on Eat it or Yeet it…it’s actually bad 😂💀

[@renolta1365]

I love Shayne’s pure spite and just unrivaled anger while everyone is drinking the “ultimate green juice”

[@jisatsurai]

i cannot express how funny it is when noah eats something vile, spits, and then immediately jumps into a wildly specific yet insanely accurate example of what that food just tasted like with the passion of a mad man.

[@Music-vr7sz]

Noah is great

[@DEFSeattle]

Hosting a show called "put it in my mouth" does that to you

[@Scrofar]

We dont' need smell-o-vision ever, we just need Noah

[@Drecane]

I don't know if it was intentional, but Courtney getting them all to do a countdown with the cookies so someone didn't take a bite early and react was perfect.

[@nehamaw]

Omg yes! I didn't notice that 😂 so smart.

[@orangeants]

I bet it was intentional, she has the card with the ingredients in her hand lmao

[@taliesinbreen]

She knew. Good on her for reacting quickly enough to stop anyone doing it solo.

[@koriankimchi]

Shayne's little hands in his lap moment at 15:43 cracks me up cause he was just like, "...and now we wait"

[@ollysombrero8427]

Shayne created a monster by pitching this game😂 and on top of it now that he's been in almost all of them and is fed up with it, he's just physically and mentally taking it out on everybody😂 The mind games are fun but I think he genuinely hurt Amanda. APOLOGIZE SHAYNE!

[@azzindril813]

Shayne tricking everyone else to eat the cookies was yet another great example of him using his psychology degree xD

[@menta1]

He is a certified psychological weapon

[@844pm2]

That’s acting

[@daniellespatz9490]

Tommy started coming for Shayne’s gig, being buff, and now Shayne’s in his villain era 😂

[@LateLastNight]

Tommy is looking jacked this episode!

[@gallopera]

he's so hot it's distracting

[@kodyterry6184]

Shayne was literally psychotic this episode, I think he needs his emotional support Damien from now on

[@dakotaguin32]

I’m a little mad no one understands why the green eggs and ham wasn’t messed with. Cuz in the story they turned out to be good

[@iluvboothill]

Shayne was OUT OF HIS MIND this episode and I'm here for it

[@a-cygnus]

Amanda: How did you eat that with no issues? Noah: The same way he hurt you with no regret. This killed me. 😂

[@nehamaw]

That moment was just to funny.

[@Oliapfel]

Shayne tricking the whole table into eating the spicy cookies was incredible. brought the whole damn ship down with him. i salute you dude.

[@jakethequakeghareeb244]

23:11 they forgot to blur the yark

[@Binaural_Walks]

Tommy's "Is this coconut EW" at 17:10 was the most relatable thing I've ever heard in my life

[@vinnybdr7025]

15:46 - the betrayal in Amanda's tone, and Shayne's child voice saying "and I got you!" has to be the biggest contrast in emotional experience I have seen in an EIOYI

[@mar__k]

Yeah Shayne wanted to get Amanda back from that green drink 😆

[@MiraMidnighttt]

Shayne is always playing an undercover agent of chaos in this game, and I absolutely love it 😆

[@jessesandholm7704]

"That's what they clean off those ducks in Dawn commericals-" LIKE SHAYNE IS CRACKING FUNNIES LEFT N RIGHT THIS EPISODE

[@megggiezombie]

The fact that they did this episode while Noah's hair is green makes me very happy

[@UninspiredArtemis]

Shayne walked onto set and chose violence, both literally and psychologically 😂😂😂

[@gamechimp869]

shane psychologically broke angela. we just watched her have a manic episode.

[@ArunRaj-zz2xy]

20:10 turn on subtitles and enjoy the burn

[@llAlukall]

Angela: 'Remember, yeet bucket's on the right, Angela's on the left.' - Courtney: 'Bucket is on the left!'

[@barbarian-furu]

but it was on the right tho

[@llAlukall]

@@barbarian-furu Yes. That's what's funny.

[@barbarian-furu]

@@llAlukallindeed

[@mage1439]

Noah's "I did it wrong!" killed me. And then it got wilder. "There's a hole in my hand, you psycho!" But Shayne using his psychology for evil was the best.

[@PoofyFancyPants]

The big bite ended up being amazing too. Angela nearly had an aneurism before eating it and then jumped on Noah's cheese theory only to express resigned after the reveal "It's a bunch of fish shit" Entire episode was off the rails after the inhaled the wheatgrass.

[@christyanne7471]

"How did you eat that without any reaction??" "I'm crazy" 😂😂 Shayne 'Grave Mouth' Topp

[@rosey4exclaim]

Whoever did the captions on this video deserves a raise! "Angela screaming like a feral guinea pig." "Garrett laughing maniacally." 😂😂😂

[@HenryNguyen-li4xb]

Noah's "I did it wrong." Then Shayne's "That's what they're cleaning off of ducks in Dawn commercial" is SO HILARIOUS. 🤣🤣🤣

[@brickwalla]

Respectfully, Tommy looks absolutely stunning. He has always been cute, but lately he’s truly unbelievable

[@zaraheart]

He’s lost some weight, that’s probably why? 🤷🏽‍♀️ lol

[@hotduelist]

He's looking kinda ripped lately. I love it

[@polkapyr]

i love his little bangs

[@miniclip0703]

9:30 Giving this joke the appreciation that Noah DESERVES

[@Zoro-IX]

11:18 that slow zoom on Angela’s reaction 😂 comedy gold. Good job editor

[@en9719]

Ever since "let's do this" shayne has been in an ongoing psychological warfare with everyone

[@vjabonador1067]

Putting that Psychology degree to good use.😆

[@Mack10011]

i'd argue it's been since that one show with no name where he fully convinced courtney and olivia that the care bears were originally murderous monsters

[@teamweavertv]

Angela and Olivia have both fallen for Shayne’s “you should take it” trick lol 😂

[@844pm2]

fr you would think they been around him long enough to know the way he operates

[@screemingslay5415]

As well as Kimmy

[@kbwolfe9491]

@@screemingslay5415 Man I miss Kimmy

[@fortynights1513]

@@kbwolfe9491Funny that you mention Kimmy. At about 3:44, I swear I heard her laugh.

[@snwmat]

@@fortynights1513 shes the director its in the description

[@IyaniO]

The fact that she threw away the fork makes me love her more

[@jessicabuckham3421]

The kitchen process for the green juice was edited so cinematically and dramatically lmao hats off to Andre

[@lakeJesus]

Y'all should do a Blind Eat it or Yeet it. Where they have to be blindfolded while the wheel spins and the one it lands on has to keep on their blindfold and not know what the food looks like.

[@QuikVidGuy]

how do they eat it? all finger foods?

[@tveerose]

that is sick and twisted- i love it

[@taleeesha]

​@@QuikVidGuyperhaps, or maybe Courtney can feed them

[@NicolaiAAA]

Or even keep the format the same - they have to choose whether or not to try the thing on the table, but they're still blindfolded the entire time so they can't see it.

[@SoraKHLuver]

This is actually such a good idea!

[@goldenluver33]

Angela's fried catfood reaction for sure solidified her as a permanent EIOYI contestant. Unfortunate for her. Extremely fortunate for us.

[@0.0_AC_0.0]

I don't know how many people use captions but I love the "Angela giggling and panicking like a squirrel" after they all ate the cookies. It made my day a little better :) hehe there was another one that said "Angela screaming like a feral guinea pig" I love her energy so much it hurts omg

[@alfredoo-sauce]

this is one of my favorite eioyi videos lol. angela freaks out with the big bite, shayne tricks everyone TWICE, and Amanda just dabs at 24:00??? lmaooo everyone is so funny this episode

[@brendenevans1186]

Tommy’s green eggs and ham bite is the all time most eloquent bite on this show

[@mar__k]

At 2:16 you can even see the inner and defeated pain on Garrett's face when Tommy already knew. You just can't get Tommy, Garrett! 😂

[@licia_bobishka]

@@mar__kI think that’s more because Tommy’s insulting his burnt eggs 😂

[@psd103]

I think you mean elegant. Eloquent doesn’t really make sense here.

[@mar__k]

@@licia_bobishka This is actually a reference to an on-going joke that Garrett just can't get to Tommy. Happened before in EIOYI. Sort of like whenever is Tommy's turn Garrett just starts shaking nervously and biting his fingernails.

[@henrahmagix]

Tomey the Adult: "Split one with me." - Noah the Child: "What about me?" - Tomey the Exasperated Adult: "There's multiple cookies!"

[@rtooth27]

Angela is legit a cartoon character. She seems like the person that instantly lifts everyone in the room as soon as she walks in.

[@nathanmccormick583]

CC literally says "Angela feral screaming" when she has to yeet her dish. Shayne did her so wrong lmao

[@KJ-od5od]

Damien when he accidentally taps someone's hand: oh my goodness, are you okay!? I'm so sorry! I'm so sorry, please take this dish, do you need anything else? Shayne hitting Amanda's hand so hard it leaves marks: 🤣🤣🤣

[@Fanthomas1742]

To be fair he did warn them not to go for it 😅

[@brothermangaming]

you can tell he felt bad lol, went quiet for a while (until he didn't)

[@AntoinesCorner]

Jackie in Herd Mentality: "Why'd no one say green eggs and ham" Jackie: *leaves Smosh* Smosh Producers: "We should do a green eat it or yeet it episode." 😂😂The audacity.

[@Shutupcracker]

did she leave?

[@harizzium]

Wait she left? When?

[@v.connected]

I was gonna say! This is how I find out?!

[@DinomotoMennovi]

​@@harizziumyeah, she left for another opportunity elsewhere. Left on good terms, no drama.

[@MrBadBoy2105]

@@DinomotoMennovi and you never know she could be back

[@C4PT41NSL1NKY]

Tommy just being so collected about everything when the entire world is burning down around him is an energy I want.

[@mikeisfine]

Shayne went full bond villain this round with the mind games. And once again Angela is an absolute treasure lol

[@nickysmits2557]

I love how when Damien hurt someone on EIOYI he was like ''omg I'm so sorry, are you ok? I'm so sorry'' and when Shayne hurts someone he's just cry-laughing

[@sarahhayes9314]

I can’t get over amandas WHeAtGrASs and Shayne’s facial expressions at 7:53 😂😂. Amanda and Shayne in this video are going crazy and i love it

[@Cashley22]

I went back to that because of your comment and just noticed Shayne mouthing "wheatgrass" both times Amanda says it 😂

[@molliegarcia8243]

Tommy's full face in the table 🤣🤣21:40

[@faeri_]

“That’s what they’re cleaning off of ducks in Dawn commercials.” Shayne is *unhinged.*

[@syndixel9857]

Amanda progressively getting louder with wheatgrass was peak Eat It or Yeet It

[@sydneysullins]

Shayne maliciously holding his hand on Amanda’s while she continually screams “OW.” is such a comedic highlight that not one is talking about 😭😭

[@polkapyr]

meanwhile hes grunting the entire time and shes ripping his hand off of hers lmfao

[@sarahanderson6696]

That "the same way he hurt you with no regret" comment from Noah flew so far under the radar and it was unappreciated.

[@michaelwestendorf9104]

16:12 😂😂 Shane the ultimate villain lol

[@Charlie-nr6vd]

Amanda in this episode is everything. "WHEAT GRASS!"

[@alanaperry7936]

She was stresst😂

[@disneyking4458]

"YOU'RE A PSYCHO!!" 😂

[@Emperor_Fun]

Shane has learned how to lie on a more intentional basis, unreal potential for even more comedy.

[@impedimxnta]

hahaha I’m pretty sure he said in the smosh mouth episode with arasha that he wanted to try and start lying more because of her!

[@Scrofar]

using his psychology degree for the greater worse

[@sarveshgovinder2775]

This episode is his psychology degree in full effect 😂

[@Maurenriques]

I absolutely NEED to watch the Smosh Mouth podcast after this you KNOW it was top tier after the Stabbing and Cookie Incident™

[@tonjibyrd]

Shayne tricking everyone to suffer through the cookie situation with him is a genius level of manipulation

[@raychipsd]

angela’s “this is disqualification behavior!” reaction to shayne was so funny

[@nehamaw]

😂 😂 😂 Shaynnnnneeee. Tricking them all into having the cookie was hilarious and evil and I'm here for it! 15:30

[@arcticfox3878]

I appreciate the accuracy of the subtitles at 16:52 *Angela giggling and panicking like a squirrel*

[@juicyboi121]

This video almost feels like a "best of" compilation all on its own. Amanda yelling WHEATGRASS, Shayne's mind-gaming, Angela's incredible freakout... it's all so beautiful Q.Q

[@Masqueraide]

I love when the cast plays more mind games on each other than Garrett does

[@IzzieOwens]

I just got a KZbin survey about your comment 💀

[@RyleesDiaries]

I love the way Courtney helped Shayne trick them cause she was reading the card before lmfaoo

[@Bun-505]

I love the way Noah describes the taste of things with such specific accuracy

[@trueblue96CFC]

Angela and Amanda have been the best additions to the cast since Damian

[@Mack10011]

yet you can't spell his name right /j (this is just shayne =/= shane all over again)

[@maurice1987]

And Chanse!

[@frankelguy]

It’s so weird watching literally any video with Shayne and Courtney in it now

[@emilyd4230]

20:23 Eat it or Yark it

[@meganhertslet5380]

We need a podcast where we just get an in depth analysis of Garrett’s mind 😂😊

[@pk.18]

get garrett on smosh mouth!!

[@phinexman]

"Coffee, I will make shayne taste sour food again. Wheel of Mythicallity." The three storms of ideas i see with Garrett

[@meganhertslet5380]

@@pk.18 exactly!!

[@cathyoldrich]

I feel like his mind would just be like an NBC sitcom about a coffee shop and a main character who enjoys giving costumers food poisoning

[@MrSte553]

No we don't