Eat It Or Yeet It: Ice Cream Party!

[@TheRealSullyG]

9:52 was possibly the biggest betrayal in "Eat It or Yeet It" history

[@kawong3975]

*Top 10 anime betrayal*

[@jackacebedo2318]

Oh shit I love your stuff man!

[@ApsaraMenaka]

followed by stopping keith by saying "its not your time, its mine"

[@bigchumbo6489]

hey you're that guy that gets on yiay all the time

[@Mewoblast]

What’s up checkmark

[@runawayfaeIX]

Damien's face when Shayne's joke hits him... That was a precious moment.

[@hopelesshopebot8602]

omg i know rightttttttt

[@Camcam331]

I didn't understand at first, because the caption said from a "bowl", but the caption was wrong 🐂

[@runawayfaeIX]

@@Camcam331 🤭😂 definitely not right!

[@drc9374]

The Best moment for sure

[@hanter765]

7:18 here’s a time stamp so everyone can keep repeating it

[@lawrencefosterjenkins8216]

shayne giving us "it's not your time...it's mine" energy on his turn

[@ZoieXmarie]

😂 what episode was that??

[@lawrencefosterjenkins8216]

@@ZoieXmarie It would've had to be the one with Brittany Broski, my favorite EIoYI episode of all time

[@mungethekpopstan]

the way he made keith pause too lmao

[@roselynestelle6081]

Evrrytime he says something like that is when you KNOW he's going for it!

[@roselynestelle6081]

2:12 the look on her face 😂

[@LightingtheDraghog]

Watching Shane each “Eat It or Yeet It” is liking watching a character go through a villain arc

[@clownation2130]

Shayne's 'it's milk, but from a bull' is so underrated lmao

[@macran4]

i love damien's reaction there

[@Wavestuff6]

7:19 the subs said bowl so I missed it at first lol. Damien’s face when he’s caught off guard like that is hilarious, like in the video where Courtney makes them put on fake nails

[@clownation2130]

@@Wavestuff6 IKR?! I kept replaying it for his reaction, it's so genuinely funny 😂

[@clownation2130]

@@macran4 Amen.

[@enexius67]

Same energy as “burger, but cold” lmao

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

"It's milk but from a bull" Another banger... *Another banger by Shayne from iCarly* Was honestly expecting it to be "Ice Cream, But Melted"

[@memorless]

"I scream! ... butt melted"

[@SailHatinSoap]

Ice cream but warm

[@Gcool243]

Shane’s eat it or Yeet it tactics have quite literally never failed lol

[@pvic6959]

how dare he do that to kimmy smh lol

[@LabradorIndependent]

Slightly new viewer here, I'm not quite sure what he did?

[@alainasemler1505]

@@LabradorIndependent he’s done it twice, where he distracts the other person from hitting the bell bc he wants the dish

[@LabradorIndependent]

@@alainasemler1505 Oooh I see, cheers.

[@loyael]

@@LabradorIndependent Welcome to Smosh :)

[@zetascorp3880]

I'm really liking seeing Spencer show up more, I think he's always added a quirky nuance to the crew. Fun times!

[@LukaTim]

He was like the Olivia replacement for this episode

[@Babyteef]

he gives me youngest sibling energy and i love it

[@thelastone7123]

Because thats what the show needs.. Another straight white man

[@roryren.2240]

Spencer already looks like he needs an adult and there is absolutely no one qualified around him

[@pennywisethedancingclown2702]

Mom the other kids are eating weird shit, pick me up.

[@johngennaria7081]

@@pennywisethedancingclown2702 i may or may not have had a hand in that mom

[@EdmanXERO]

I know what Spencer needs... "... another straight white man".

[@Phantom-vo8jy]

1k likes your welcome

[@roryren.2240]

@@Phantom-vo8jy sick thanks man 🙏🏻

[@raymundoii]

Shayne is on a roll this episode! 7:17 - Milk from a Bull 9:53 - Betrayal 14:35 - Starbucks Roast

[@brylegopela5601]

The look on Spencer's face is priceless he looks like a kid that's about to cry 🤣

[@Amateur.Nail.Art.1]

Courtney to Shayne: “You are now safe from the game.” Me: “But you are not safe from Kimmy.”

[@jahnabanana]

I would have fought Shayne for that berry one, that looks BOMB.

[@astralknightmage1342]

Would you actually have fought shayne? HAVE YOU SEEN HIS PLUS ONES

[@bbdoll1518]

Salt and Straw (the place it’s from) is so good!! I had a blue cheese pear one and it was incredible (sounds weird I know but trust me)

[@GravityFallsGuy15]

Um, actually, you’ve made a grammatical error. Those were two complete thoughts separated by a comma (a comma splice). In the future, try to be more careful. Put a period instead of a comma, and capitalize the first letter of the next word.

[@polkadotties3669]

Did you say... berries???

[@gemmacleary3245]

@@polkadotties3669 berries and cream?!?!?!?!?

[@MerindaNOTMiranda]

I just need a loop of Shayne's "Milk but from a Bull" and Damien's reaction. That was too good.

[@jourdynmiller9930]

I keep repeating it now that I watched the whole video 😂

[@DoubleAsPlace]

There should be a Eat it or Yeet it: choose your fate edition. The item is revealed and after someone dings the bell they can choose to keep there dish or swap it for one no one has seen yet. The big bite could be all of the unchosen items blended together.

[@isaiasmartinez1288]

That actually sounds sick! I like it.

[@alauna3465]

they better see this, i would so watch it.

[@unblorbosyourshows9635]

Eat it or Yeet it: Monty Hall edition

[@JohnDoesDrones]

They already did this somewhat with the Christmas Episode. The first person went and picked a “gift” and saw the food in it. The next person could either steal it or go for a different option that had not yet been seen. The person who went first got final dibs on what they wanted. The option to blend it all together though has not been done.

[@theonlyrose7970]

That sounds brutal. Love it!!

[@Galiant2010]

For Kimmy's sake I was REALLY hoping that hers was like that "dirt" and gummyworm thing where it's just pulverized Oreos lol.

[@alchemist824]

Every time I hear dirt from them it sounds like "durt"

[@DisgruntledHippo]

Garrett for this episode; "Mashed Potatoes, but cold..."

[@thicc-mothman]

btw mashed potatoes are used in advertising and movies as prop ice cream since they don't melt under hot studio lights

[@pvic6959]

i _WISH_ lol

[@johngennaria7081]

@@thicc-mothman that is confirmed. To mimic flavors they put food coloring to mimic the product with some edible paint to mimic of there is chunks of things like strawberry

[@rachelfrancis1990]

I thought spencers was “ice cream but melted” lol

[@Sos4tan]

That's what they ate in every Baskin Robbins

[@CordyBrush]

"In memory of what's his fa...he was kinda like Shane" I lost it xD

[@kitkatelife8014]

Was I the only one that thought Damien was going to eat a whole giant spoonful of wasabi?

[@hadinasrallah8928]

Same

[@Batman25JM]

I was so sure it was wasabi. I was shocked when it wasn’t.

[@sarahgrace13s]

Omg same!

[@WubbyPunch]

I was sure it wasn’t when I saw the spoonful. Nobody can eat that much wasabi at once. Even if you like it. It’s just not something a sane person does.

[@SilverCookie412]

I thought it was going be either wasabi or very bitter matcha

[@samjamison2371]

5:46 Damien’s talking about how good his dish is and Shayne’s face on the left…it screams murder 😂

[@selish2904]

sometimes when i look at spencer, and then remember when ian said he doesn’t physically abuse any of the editors but spencer, im starting to believe it 🌞

[@unblorbosyourshows9635]

i think that's just the dead inside editor vibe

[@dressbitch]

2:17 that zoom to Saige's face and the abrupt cut is sitcom material

[@rushs11]

7:18 that reaction Damien gives after hearing Shane is incredible

[@sandrafunacc1]

The dedication of Shayne to the psychology behind this is amazing.

[@maxmustsleep]

Shane's "It's milk - but from a bull" killed me 7:17 I almost missed it lol

[@squilly4148]

Of course Damien I'd the only one that heard him 😂

[@hotliacult2986]

i just got that, jesus christ

[@AscendedXSaiyan]

I couldn't stop laughing at that 🤣🤣

[@maxmustsleep]

@@squilly4148 nah kimmy is giggling pretty hard as well :D

[@c_lay]

I wish Shane would’ve followed up with salty when Courtney was going thru the different tastes🤣

[@mikecardenas3032]

Watching that move from Shayne on Kimmy was like watching a pro athlete make a sick play and the announcer being like " what a play by the savy veteran!!!"

[@drpibisback7680]

I was thinking wrestling announcer: "BY GOD! THAT WOMAN HAD A FAMILY!"

[@AntonMinhasDahlqvist]

the face Damien makes when he realizes what Shayne meant… 💀 7:18

[@samuelmikler]

exactly xD

[@patiobeer]

The amount of chaos Shayne injected into this video was incredible

[@abiraazhar2]

Damien dying at Courtney's "stick around, lil folks" was so funny lmaoo 15:30

[@psicoparkita]

After that sushi game where Shayne won while being a straight up villain. And that time he tricked Keith, no 1 should be surprised by his villainous move today

[@adityabiswas7684]

Which sushi one?

[@jasss6020]

I'm laughing so hard on Courtney's unamused expression at Shayne's joke at 14:47 😂

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

She just has heard more than humanely enough of those kinda shit coming out from Shayne's mouth i guess lol

[@RiveroftheWither]

Damien's face when Shayne said "bulls milk", I'm dead 🤣

[@nataliewing4337]

Oh dang, I thought he said "bowl's milk." Makes a lot more sense now lol

[@HelloIAmAnExist]

10:00 psychology degree coming in clutch, the mind games are 200 iq

[@Alexander050101]

This version of evil Shayne is his “Chris Evans in Knives out” arc

[@tjrauchie3081]

I didn’t think many people could match Shayne’s comedy and Comedic timing, however Spencer is a goddamn comedic master

[@inthehouser1]

12:30 I don't think Garrett has ever said "Have the yeet bucket ready." Wow that really says something.

[@ivorellarackley4401]

11:09 Kimmys "lock the doors!" Gives me such "call an ambulance...BUT NOT FOR ME" vibes and I'm cackling

[@christianwise637]

Dark Kimmy has been unlocked yet again

[@alchemist824]

Kimmy's going to beat him up and everyone else is gonna help

[@vexinglex4996]

12:45 You know it isn't even an aesthetically pleasing food if Damien is giving it THAT look.

[@olivergalleguez]

8:27 poor Spencer he was traumatized by that ice cream lol

[@12JoHook]

Yo, I love old Smosh, but in my humble opinion, current Smosh is as strong as ever. I love the old crew, I love the peeps that stayed and I love the new additions. Keep it up y’all 🤙🏽💗💜💙

[@SolidOcelot]

Glad to see Spencer on this, I love when he's on stuff

[@kingkana18]

Damn, people should learn to be like Kimmy. Even after being betrayed, she's still so nice to Shayne

[@adityabiswas7684]

No one has seen shayne since this video ended.............

[@goddessbyiris]

We now know what happened to his leg

[@shelbydont]

We don’t deserve Kimmy 😌✨

[@bippolhdt4730]

More like people should stop being like Shayne

[@SupremeLeaderKimJong-un]

Saige: It's someone's thing, but you're judging them for it Also Saige literally minutes before: *It's because it's vegan that it's all wrong*

[@vampiregirl523]

She did at least say "all wrong textured" not that the thing is wrong

[@rebeccasands1452]

It's not really a judgement of vegans just that vegan versions of non-vegan foods are often not great.

[@alchemist824]

@@rebeccasands1452 yeah, it's either falling apart or has a lot of sodium or something else

[@Deathbird_Mitch]

Even Vegans will tell you that Vegan versions of "regular" foods are odd.

[@yashaly09]

5:39 shayne 😭💀 the way he just stares

[@ArielsWaffles]

7:25 makes me think of the girl who tried Wassabi for the first time and she goes "help" 🥺 😂😂

[@blueskies3060]

No matter the video, Spenser takes every video to another level of funny.

[@brendan0195]

No one: Shayne: NO DON’T TOUCH THAT NO...*ding*

[@fatmambodje2944]

What the hell

[@01halle]

@@fatmambodje2944 I thought the same, such a nonsensical use of this meme

[@Morster]

I love when they include people who haven’t been on the show very often: the juxtaposition of the newbies’ horror before it starts, and the experienced people’s numbness is hilarious 🤣 *Edit* : Just noticed they got rid of the wheel 👀

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

That wheel thingy was only a temporary thing used to prevent THE virus from spreading, now that they've been vaccinated i guess there's no reason for them to use it anymore

[@aryahnalegrand9089]

Sorry for the insanely long comment: I’ve had to drop out of school and go to the hospital everyday for medical treatment for about a month now and I’ve hated it. It’s been the hardest thing I’ve ever done and, on most days, I just don’t even feel like pushing through. The only thing I look forward to every day is watching the Smosh videos. So thank you so much for doing all that you do and for making these videos. It makes it so much easier for me to push through my treatment.

[@EdilbertFernando]

Shayne just threw his little sister Kimmy, whos always cheering for him, under the bus. Dark dark turn my friend XD

[@Managuan]

I love how Milkbean saddistically torment Saige before she take her bite. XD

[@taylorchristine769]

Okay the murder eyes from Kimmy to Shayne and Damian at the end, kills me 🤣. Also proof that she is the true April ludgate

[@deathbychocolate7170]

So glad the bell is back least everyone eats something now

[@anicoleww]

I love Kimmy, she seems like she’d be such a great friend to have. And loved the hair, girl! My hair is a good bit longer and curly but idk how to do French or Dutch braids 😩

[@ztron8093]

Y’all should do an episode of Eat it or Yeet it “in character” like you did among us in character or other vids “in character” i want to see the chosen eat or yeet!

[@TheMocutMiester]

Underated idea

[@Madiba888]

Watching Spencer suffer was way funnier than I expected Please, have him on this show more times 😂

[@firmanchristiansianturi4794]

We need a special episode for Damien where he just make/suggests all the "gross" stuff that he likes, or he's the only contestant and the rest of the cast make/suggests foods to see if he likes it or not. Edit: Oh, and we need a cooking show with Damien in general.

[@patrickhenderson7547]

I had to rewatch Damian 5 times to see the delay, and absolute awe of Shane’s joke. I was crying and dying laughing 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@brandonirvingolivafierros8463]

1:54 Spencer´s face like "DID U JUST TRIED TO STAB ME IN THE BACK!?"

[@justbovel]

Damien's facial expressions and Saige's lines is the perfect commentary!

[@CJXalax]

The whole-body shimmy that Shayne does makes me laugh so damn hard. That and the quick cameo of the "Shayne Bottom" voice 😭

[@mystic844]

12:15 Shane, “You turned me into this” as he is looking towards Garrett

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

He legit went from taking a disgusting food for himself to save Olivia to straight up playing a reverse psychology to steal the good food from Kimmy, i guess the quote is true, "you either die a hero, or live long enough to see yourself become the villain" lmao

[@mystic844]

True

[@here2watch08]

Kimmy is so adorable and I love her 90's style.

[@PJeffOwen]

Damien was for sure gonna say "I'm a martyr" at 4:35 but pulled out last second, then just panicked and repeated himself. Well saved after the initial panic though bless him.

[@jamesmcdonald2055]

13:26 What do we- do we hit them? JFC I love Spencer, this genuinely made me laugh out loud.

[@skinnybuddha8988]

I'm really happy Smosh is finally adulting up a little bit. I say that because they finally let some more sexualized jokes fly, little bit more adult humor, and just little stuff like not blurring out a middle finger. Thank you! Please keep it up

[@thunderkingabsolutepower8039]

Waiting for mythical chef Josh to replace Garret as the cook for an episode of eat it or yeet it. I bet it would be funny and also delicious.

[@georgelloydgonzalez]

Josh has been a guest

[@thunderkingabsolutepower8039]

@@georgelloydgonzalez oh I know I meant as the cook for all the food for an episode

[@christianbergman6596]

Thats sound really fun and Garret must eat:D

[@thunderkingabsolutepower8039]

@@christianbergman6596 I’m just waiting for that to happen but knowing how much Garret has stepped up his cooking game I bet facing a professional chef will be fun and to see Garret as a contestant will be the icing on top.

[@deckarddwizardd1909]

6:17 the three people left are Blossom, Bubbles and Buttercup 🤣

[@Vijay007-]

5:29 I love how Courtney gives Damien a disapproving look with how he eats his ice cream

[@Justnotjlo]

Im on like 10 years of watching smosh and it just keeps getting better bro

[@oxymoronman]

Kimmy is literally the cutest human being in existence.

[@Mittens_McG]

This is truth

[@greysalt3792]

Fax.

[@Dez09]

Idk saige is up there too in my opinion

[@WubbyPunch]

@@Dez09 cuteness comes from character too. Sage is pretty too, but kimmy is the queen of cute.

[@Dez09]

@@WubbyPunch just my opinion but yeah can't argue with that lol

[@StormBoy95]

Shayne being on this show every time and being able to predict how the bites would happen and getting a good bite and making Kimmy was so funny!

[@TakavaNirhii]

7:18 Damien's reaction is everything

[@dreamerofrealityb5207]

7:20 Damien’s reaction to Shayne’s “it’s milk but from a bull” still makes me choke on my spit to this day 😂

[@antonioa7906]

14:11 should’ve call it “iced” coffee

[@psicoparkita]

Aww poor adorable, sweet Kimmy! Her face when Courtney asked her how she was feeling bummed me out

[@paydenstdenis7880]

Spencer will forever be my favourite ever since I seen him on clevver

[@beornshmidt9181]

The amount of sheer pride Shayne has as he eats his Goat Cheese/Marionberry/Habanero ice cream is contagious. I really want some of that. Might try to make it myself.

[@scopex6335]

Shayne has been tortured in this show so many times , we need an episode just him eating his fav food in a "Shayne cam" and watches other members play the game 👌👌

[@love55ickbeat5]

He has not been tortured! He's got burger but cold and malic acid that he literally can't react to! Lol and he's had some good tasting stuff too so his percentage of eating good stuff is in his favor

[@scopex6335]

@@love55ickbeat5 I mean that he has been involve too much , not always torture specifically , give him a break ya know

[@love55ickbeat5]

@@scopex6335 They can't He brings in the views 😅

[@scopex6335]

@@love55ickbeat5 so i said a chill " shayne cam" like garett cam

[@ariqsyafwan4987]

They've did that twice already, actually, the first time was during the "Garrett revenge" episode, where Garrett and Shayne literally swap position, and the second time was when they had to determine what will be put in their bowl of ramen based on their answers on various trivia questions

[@vannapearl1188]

It would be such a wholesome video if one time they end up all being good. Like no bad ones and everyone's just having a good time having nice treats together.

[@loganstock8023]

I was really hoping the toothpaste one would be an homage to "buger but cold" and it would be "ice cream but warm"

[@SOFAKINGdesigns]

just here to appreciate saige and all her glory. her outfits are always amazing

[@adakubis5658]

I love Courtney's little laugh when Damien said that it was fruity💅

[@davidvagnell6317]

I love how they always have an extra spoon ready for Damien!

[@cheyennemarie7075]

Shayne’s one episode away from pointing and yelling, “BEHIND YOU!” Then ringing as they look away😂😂

[@FenrirMont]

Saige un Eat it or Yeet it?? OMG YEEEEEES ❤️💕🙌🏼

[@cenistired]

"It's milk, but from a bull." im gonna pee ohmygod

[@shannona8525]

Saige giving Courtney the kissy fave after Damien said "very fruity" is being severely underrated 😂

[@lulusunbeam]

5:40

[@lulusunbeam]

@Tiffanie 00 5:40 I scrolled for so long to find this comment

[@unusanous2237]

Spencer's first EIOYI, congrats

[@smoshpit]

his first... maybe his last

[@rebeccah3091]

I love Kimmy so much, she is so cute and her and Jackie probably are 2 of my favorite smosh members.

[@callmeaurelius]

"It's like milk, but from a bull."

[@teinili]

Kimmys face is so incredibly expressive it's amazing :D

[@PearloftheParticular]

Next episode: Eat it or Yeet it but everyone is in character. For example: Shane: Chosen Noah: John Morgan Courtney: Barb Ross Keith: Bobby from the Block Damien: Snape Spencer: Johnny Bullseye Olivia: Jones I think that would be GOLDEN

[@tommyzoid4691]

Barb Ross has been one of my favorite original characters in forever... I hope we get more art classes from her

[@Nekrozz4]

Courtney: "It's summer, it's hot..." The autumm rain behind my windows: No, it's not.

[@joshuahumphries7743]

Same

[@bryh555]

Dang where I live we’re still getting to over 100 degrees a day

[@Galiant2010]

Same, coolest day we've had in months here as MN fall starts to take over. High in the mid 60s and rain.

[@joshuahumphries7743]

I mean it’s gonna get hot soon cause Louisiana lol very humid

[@deckarddwizardd1909]

Shayne: This one's usually bad Also Shayne: **dings the bell**

[@LinnHeidiPoosz]

Im so happy we get to see more of spencer!

[@microsoftman5]

10:03 top 10 anime betrayals 😫

[@NUGGet-3562]

Unidenti Fiable Chunks had me ROLLING

[@mohdshahril7922]

10:31 another moment that its good

[@ellie_ibarra111]

I’m legit grounded and got my phone taken away, so now I’m watching this on my school iPad. I NEVER MISS A VIDEO! Update: I just got my phone back and now I’m rewatching