Edward Comforts Winry after Confrontation with Scar | English Dubbed

Edward comforts Winry after she find out that scar had killed her parents. Winry tries to kill Scar
Disclaimer : I do not own this animé or the clip. The owner retains all the rights. It has been uploaded for entertainment purpose. So enjoy until it lasts
TAGS
Edward Vs Scar, Al vs Scar, Winry Vs Scar, Winry cries, Edward hugs winry, Edward x winry, Scenes from brotherhood, Scene from fmab, Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood, Fmab, Hughes death, Mustang vs Envy, Best fmab scene, Talking Chimera, Winry and Scar, Winry and scar English Dubbed, Dubbed, Fmab Dubbed, thomas sanders vines, thomas sanders, thomas, sanders, vine, vines, vine guy, storytime guy, comedy, vlog, anime, naruto, bleach, crunchyroll, yuri on ice, yuri, attack on titan, fander, fanders, foster dawg, thatsthat24, ultimate, storytime, ultimate storytime, cowboy bebop, Anime, scene, episode, anime summer, summer anime, anime 2019, best anime 2019, winry's death, fullmetal alchemist winry dies, anticipated anime 2019, upcoming anime, upcoming anime 2019, anime trailers, anime previews, anime episodes, best summer anime, new anime, Most popular, best,greatest, top 10, Best winry and Edward moments, Yuri on ice, Yuri on ice movie trailer

[@zorodpiece8693]

This scene in particular is one of my favorites. The English dubbed version makes it more powerful and meaningful. I particularly like the way Vic delivers his lines, and of course Caitlin Glass does a phenomenal job as Winry. Ed has a point, Winry's hands are meant for destruction they have a much better purpose. They're meant to give life.

[@simonaspalovis1204]

*aren't..but yes, you are right.

[@joegreen3802]

Gman it’s all on preference to how the actor delivers the performance. Don’t be a jerk

[@jodonthesith7172]

Are you that stupid? Let’s let go of the fact that you think that Japanese and English sound EXACTLY THE SAME. And talk about how they say things differently since it’s a different fucking language you fucking idiot. Maybe stop laughing your ass of and think before you comment you tard.

[@jodonthesith7172]

Gman Why so ignorant dumbass nigga?

[@jodonthesith7172]

@Gman YOu're calling me the ignorant one after you said japanese and english sound exactly the same? Dude now I just think that you're mental! :)

[@kerdunne3422]

Poor Winry she's one of the few characters who did nothing to earn her suffering, she's just a victim of circumstance

[@kokotaughs]

If you think about it so was Scar, but he actually let hatred consume him which is what Ed saved Winry from

[@biteme7857]

Scar has suffered too & is a victim of circumstances too. Scar has regrets about killing the people that were helping the ishvalan but the war must have caused some kind of PTSD or something to him to do that.

[@Reddragon-hn6ot]

@@biteme7857 He was victim indeed, and his motivation had some sense. He wanted revenge from both the state alchemists who killed all those innocent people and mainly from kimblee who killed his parents, but edward and winry didn't deserve his hatred as they didn't invloved in that massacre. They were victims as well. Edward joined the miliatry only to find answers about how to bring back their bodies and winry's parents were killed from scar himself. I think this was the moments when scar realised that their backstories are quite similar.

[@melb6557]

I thought they're going to make out after that. 🤭

[@excitedcat9517]

Idk her life didnt end up that bad, All things considered anyway

[@WiFiDown37811]

"It's your hands. they weren't meant to kill. they were meant to give life" be still my heart 🥺

[@sophiamura9484]

and THIS is when the edwin ship sailed

[@newmonarchy5829]

The ending song makes this scene so much more powerful, let it all out indeed.

[@Jaydeeyo54]

My thoughts exactly

[@Father_of_Death]

I can only imagine how traumatizing this was for Winry. Learning her parents were killed by a blood thirsty martyr and then feeling the same emotions he has only for her moral conscience to tell her that it's not the right choice. That's what makes Winry one of the strongest characters in FMA.

[@biteme7857]

Everyone here suffered. War inflicts pain, suffering and death on everyone. Even Scar has suffered too.

[@pikabiga]

This plus the outro broke me 😭😭😭 when Ed peels Winry’s fingers from the gun, counting each blessing she’s given, backed with the scenes earlier reiterating her parents’s passion for saving the Ishvalans... I need a MOMENT

[@StupidWeb]

I cry every time I hear Vic’s “it’s your hands… they weren’t meant to kill… they were meant to give life.” This whole series makes me cry more than any other I think. It’s absolutely superb

[@Father_of_Death]

He was crying during the recording session of this episode.

[@zacharyclark4092]

A lot of anime out there is stereotyped as over-exaggerating scenes of emotion, but one of the reasons FMA-B is my favorite out there is because it has moments like this where the emotions being expressed feel absolutely genuine and expected.

[@bardwayer]

This is such a defining moment for a show that has a strong anti-war message throughout. We are taught that revenge and meeting violence with violence is a natural instinct, but you see how believable it is for Winry to be unable to bring herself to do it based on the kind of person she is, and how much the world needs more people like her. And when you think about it her being unable to shoot set a chain of events that made Scar rethink his ways and ultimately work together with everyone else. I also appreciate that Arakawa didn't make it "yOu cAn'T sHoOt bEcAuSe yOu'Re wOmAn."

[@Sernival]

Thats basically why tho

[@AN-cr9cy]

I love this moment so much too. Ed is so comforting to Winry in this moment. She is practically beating herself up for not being able to pull the trigger, but Ed sees that as strength, not a weakness. It’s a gift to be able to give life and to show mercy to people who do not deserve it. Too many people act with retribution and hatred, but Winry acts with generosity and kindness.

[@Dell-ol6hb]

@@Sernival no it isn't?? Hawkeye and Armstrong both kill tons of people and they're women, it's because Winry is an automail mechanic she literally improves the quality of so many people's lives with her work, much like her parents being doctors before her. She is just like them, they went into an absolutely horrific war zone and did everything in their power to help others even when it cost them their lives.

[@Katniss0000]

Naruto fumble by not copying this your hand meant to save people. Could be a good character development and relationship development between Naruto and Sakura. But I guess the anime fillers already ruined sakura reputation.

[@heayawnkim7369]

Such a tender moment between Edward and Winry

[@ayradiaz5578]

FMAB is one of the very few animes that I prefer the Dub version.

[@DarkCrowI]

Ayra this was back when funimation still put effort into their dubs and all the actors didn’t just phone in their performances

[@Father_of_Death]

I agree. "Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood" is the peak of Funimation's 2000s dubs. "One Piece" is also good but FMAB has more heart and soul put into it.

[@ordelian7795]

@@DarkCrowI Also back when false accusations didn't ruin peoples careers. #JusticeForVic

[@millvo]

same

[@harshrana3012]

subbed was still not far behind man in my opinion, btw i prefer in either way

[@SaltExarch]

Whenever I hear "Let it out", I always think of either this scene or the scene where Ed breaks through the gate of truth and tells Al's body he'll be back for him. It's always one or the other, which just speaks to how memorable both scenes are.

[@DarthJoshReturns]

Winry: "I couldn't shoot him. He killed my parents, and I couldn't shoot him." Edward: "He also trashed my automail arm." Winry: *picks the gun back up* "That son of a bitch, I'll kill him!"

[@markomilo9580]

this scene. utter chills.

[@shaymundane1335]

It’s amazing what anime can do for someone. I watch this video when my PTSD gets bad and I ask myself why I’ve never returned vengeance to those who’ve traumatized me. I’m meant to give life, to give love and to prosper. I’m not meant for hate.

[@torondin]

Not just any anime can do this thoug. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, however, is not just any anime. Moments like this, and the sheer gravitas they manage to portray: this is probably why I have to consider this to possibly be my all time favorite anime.

[@elgatochurro]

Furry: I'm traumatized and have PTSD and fantasies of vengeance

[@jamiejones-pu9eu]

​@Angelus don't dismiss someone's experience. If just an animal gave them the hope let's all appreciate it

[@shaymundane1335]

@elgatochurro this is coming from a guy with sexualized anime children as his pfp. Weird.

[@leigh3659]

I felt tears starting to well up all throughout the scene, but it wasn’t until she hugged him and bawled her eyes out that they finally came streaming out 😭

[@FrizFroz]

What triggered it was "Let it all out... let it all out..." for me.

[@Fatema3006]

Me too

[@thedetective6500]

When you’re watching FMAB and you head the ending song come on early during the last scene it’s always a good sign that this scene will be great.

[@ByrneBaby]

Imagine being so tortured by your experiences/life that you genuinely question why you couldn't bring yourself to kill someone when given the perfect chance. Winry didn't deserve any of this.

[@LovelyLolo25]

LOVE this scene

[@Iam_Arabella.]

Heidy Gaytan me too 😭😭❤️💔

[@haydenberends3905]

Ditto

[@chrisabousamra2163]

Ed shows a wisdom beyond his years time and time again

[@Father_of_Death]

This scene is even more emotional when you learn Vic and Caitlin were crying in the booth.

[@venge_aog2822]

That transition was perfect...

[@haydenberends3905]

It kinda was

[@zoeroebuck5835]

Definitely one of my favorite emotional moments in Brotherhood. Best Anime Dub in my opinion 🥰👍🏻

[@slanetroyard92]

Ed's right. Winry isn't meant for killing. Like her parents she's meant to give life.

[@steffinrobinson7869]

This might be my favorite scene in the series. I don't cry watching movies or T.V., but I feel a huge well of emotion, and this scene makes me feel the most

[@tauhidershadKUFNAFLORAN]

It was at this moment that Winry definitively fell in love with Ed.

[@haydenberends3905]

Oh yeah. Definitely

[@yaomeii]

This anime is truly one of a kind.

[@erion1170]

One thing that this show does well is the transition to the closing song...

[@memoirsofepiphany]

Edward is the standard you can't tell me otherwise

[@zztwig1]

Always loved how he took the time to slowly open her fingers instead of just wrenching it out of her hand

[@princessangel602]

0:19 this scene made me cry so hard 😭 in the English I think the Japanese made me cry alot more 😭

[@katherinedonovan974]

Caitlin Glass's voice acting is enough to make you wanna give her a big hug. 😭😭😭😭👏👏👏👏

[@emanuelleguimaraes4185]

Wow, Edward said everything 👏🏼

[@cordifox]

Another reason The FMA/FMA-B are my favorite anime, I have cried many times watching both. Still do when i rewatch them. Just wish i could watch them both for the 1st time again.

[@AlooParantha_311]

This has to be *the best* Ed x Winry moment in all of FMA.

[@eireannmc9808]

Why can’t they make this much effort when dubbing other shows 😕

[@rocknroll5280]

Don't know maybe the budgets low mostly for em.

[@kokotaughs]

Commercialism and humanities urge for gratification. People will comform for a cheap dub as long as it's speedy over something well thought out and produced. It's instant gratification vs qualitative gratification.

[@TheAwesomeDarkNinja]

They do. But hearing the Japanese version first creates instant bias. There are plenty of phenomenal dubs out there.

[@manbehindtheslatra1813]

Eireann Mc this show had a huge budget

[@joeym3592]

They do. People just instantly hate them for some reason. The haikyuu dub, the sk8 dub, the kaguya dub, and many more are hilarious in their own ways and I personally enjoy them more than the sub.

[@andrew_yang12]

People say this anime is overrated? Get the F outta here. Best anime in my opinion

[@Father_of_Death]

I want Caitlin and Vic to reenact this scene at a convention.

[@emanuelleguimaraes4185]

Wow, Edward said everything 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 I'm impressed.

[@CristianGuerreroC]

who is chopping onions?

[@jordanvandevere5897]

This is one of the most powerful scenes in this story. FMAB rocks

[@slashthejackal8558]

GOD I miss Vic...

[@eleonoravostanis6976]

Slash the Jackalf you make it sound like he's dead, don't worry he will prevail #ISWV

[@cross-zevol4056]

@@eleonoravostanis6976 He must, and he will #IStandWithVic

[@starrynight669]

#IStandWithVic

[@alexpalmer7018]

This scene makes winry one of the strongest characters in the show. Everybody else perpetuates the cycle of violence but she doesnt. She is the one burdened with the responsibility to choose not to

[@iseewh3reurgettingat961]

Scar killing Winry's parents was better than mustang shooting them. It had more reason and emotion

[@ichikasawaizumi6705]

Dad: ashley, are you in love? Me: *looking for an emergency exit*

[@doomwinterxglitchgamer]

Samus: it's alright Winry, I lost my parents too, you're not alone

[@wengsbacay]

The ending scene with the ending music was soooooo gooooooooooddddd

[@nopenop1495]

I think this is when she started to fall in love with him.

[@rachelholloway9892]

Poor Winry Awww Ed is nice

[@EggplantEmperor]

This is how you write a strong independent women.

[@88kidflash]

This writing is superb, Edward speech was so profound

[@JCoopeR]

This scene fucking breaks me every time

[@Jaachi_Aaron-CJ041]

Thank You Elric for the bottom of my heart you never get the chance to defeat Scar once in a while? ☺️

[@juliansummers5983]

I think the song especially fits with this secne, because winry is really is hurt and she's letting it out.

[@dawnguy842]

When I first watched this show, everytime Winry cried, I felt like crying

[@sandwichmonster7067]

Beautiful scene

[@Freaky_Tarentino_Film_Student]

Vic and Caitlin were crying when they recorded this scene.

[@morgancooper5762]

This scene gives me chills

[@JohnGoetzGaming]

Modern Hollywood writers seeing this scene: "Why is a man telling a woman what she's good for and why does she need him to comfort her! This is so sexist REEEEEEE!!!"

[@wingzero7X]

This scene kills me every time

[@lenieldelatorre480]

the things our hands can do,give life and take life make or break things

[@stephenking5852]

Let It All Out…

[@LuigiMegaFanClub-l7h]

Scar is the worse friend ever.

[@ASOtheprO]

Let it all out Let it all out

[@Mandas999]

Imagine if the gun went off when it fell

[@ayaidan4840]

which episode bro?

[@jhager03]

Relatable

[@user-cu5jj8pn3e]

鋼の錬金術師 最後の錬成

[@user-cu5jj8pn3e]

鋼の錬金術師 復讐者スカー

[@Blackheart616-g7t]

Young Simba and Nala just fought Scar.

[@edwardelric2905]

No… absolutely not.

[@layanaljafry7864]

Episode number please??

[@hennessygarciahg]

Okay, when I first saw this I balled my eyes out. If it was audio described I would’ve been crying even more. I wish anime has video description so that blind people like me can watch it better. So, can someone please tell me what’s going on in this scene? Thanks.

[@edwardelric2905]

(Out of character. My username is Edward Elric) Hello! I’m visually impaired as well. I’ll try to explain this scene the best I can. Winry is kneeling down and sobbing because she couldn’t pull the trigger on her parents murderer. When Edward tells her let go of the gun, she puts her hand on the the left side of her face, and looks down at the ground and the gun in her hand. Edward looks at her melancholicly, loathing himself for making her cry again. Edward takes the still sobbing Winry’s right hand, the hand still holding the gun, and lifts each of her fingers off of it with his automail right arm. The gun falls out of Winry’s hands onto the ground. Edward looks down at Winry’s hands and the gun. He holds Winry’s right hand with both of his hands.

[@edwardelric2905]

I tried my best. 😅 I hope this helps you. 😇

[@hennessygarciahg]

@@edwardelric2905 hi, thank you so much.

[@hennessygarciahg]

@@edwardelric2905 OK now I’m crying even more thank you for explaining it to me

[@edwardelric2905]

@@hennessygarciahg You’re welcome. I know I already said this but I feel like I need to say it again. I tried really hard to explain this the best I can but, it is really hard to explain what is visually happening on the screen to a blind person as I’m almost completely blind myself. So I’m glad this helped you out.

[@Mosthero1]

How the hell is vic also the voice of Broly?!

[@adambump5297]

Talent that’s how.

[@diegomayz8503]

I wished Scar died in the series anyways. Yeah, its understandable that he wanted revenge against state alchemist, but the guy killed a bunch of innocent people too. He tried to kill two kids for goodness sake

[@matthorvath9951]

I think Scar's story is one of redemption. He knows the awful things he's done and in a weird way welcomes death. It is the same sort of arc we see for the state alchemists involved in the ishvalan war of extermination. They have all taken innocent lives and struggle with that stain on their souls.

[@FallenBird-rs8zn]

You clearly don't understand character writing

[@annamunoz6829]

I need the episode number plss

[@makiaftereight2099]

I think is episode 22!