Ruining Minecraft Live's Crab [Minecraft 1.21]

[@tstdystopmotions]

I love that you’re probably going to do this for every single mob vote

[@szymonwojciechowski8513]

Me to

[@SStrawbery]

At this point I feel like it will be every mob vote

[@theplayer4664]

this answer has no purpose other than to take up space (this as in mine)

[@MrDoorknobREAL]

Pretty sure it’s every mob vote at this point

[@n0t_br33zy]

Why not

[@Seed]

The best part of the mob vote is we finally get a better upload schedule.

[@furytoo]

bro who the hell are you?? why are you everywhere?

[@madsyndromne]

Tick guy

[@KidBackup100]

BRO UPLOAD VIDS WHERE R U?

[@Orange-tophat]

THE OFFICAL SEED ACCOUNT???

[@sunday_vibes8956]

Rofl

[@ArmadiusC]

The idea behind getting crab claws is that crabs shed the old big claw because it gets infected or damaged during a fight. they break it off and a new one grows back. Its probably be like an egg laying mechanic of chickens where they drop it time to time.

[@blue-cloud-studios]

I would love to see a crab fight lol 🤣

[@Gabriel-lh7gy]

Or like the turtle shell, you have to breed and take care of them

[@darklion98]

Or you'll have to take a bunch of them intro the pit to make them CRAB FIGHT! YEEEEEEEEEAH! And then they'll drop the claws. Ok no, it's Mojang so they wont...

[@itscznben8728]

@@darklion98 has mojang ever elaborated on why they won’t do things like that?

[@LettuceGayming]

After a certain amount of attacks it sheds the claw

[@josephmontanaro2350]

fun fact, the sheering of claws is actualy something that happens irl, some crab species are harvested of claws then released to regrow them

[@squareguy5353]

I heard something about crabs missing 1 or 2 claws will die more often. Not sure though, feel free to correct.

[@mpollono]

@@squareguy5353I mean yeah they have less defense

[@keirduigy]

@@squareguy5353when crabs only have 1 claw removed they are still aggressive and will actively fight and lose against other animals. When both claws are removed they are forced to hide until both are grown back.

[@sunday_vibes8956]

Rofl

[@lasercraft32]

@@squareguy5353 To quote Patrick: "MAKES SENSE TO ME"

[@Lunarcreeper]

i just realized that according to their logic, they can't add crabs because according to mojang, if they're passive or neutral, it will encourage kids to touch them and get hurt, and if they're hostile, kids are going to actively kill crabs.

[@thebigyes8482]

Dolphins also break this rule, it’s a moronic rule. If you go up to a wild dolphin, there’s a very good chance you will be raped and killed.

[@kongthelegend6956]

Cows, pigs and sheeps

[@haq248]

They should make it that they hurt you if you hurt them

[@RealAlexShows]

2:48 crabs can drop their claws when stressed so maybe sneaking up on them or having a hostile mob sound nearby could make them drop a claw

[@sakura_yui_]

Crabs doesn't drop their claws when threatened by predators, they're showing defensive position with their claws. They will only drop it when they got injured on their claws

[@PurplePug0001]

You should call the potion "Potion of evolution" because it simply evolves everything it touches into what it rightfully will become.

[@orb6013]

Thats what carcinization means

[@sunday_vibes8956]

Rofl

[@gingergaming5686]

Yes but what will the crabs evolve to?

[@Luxintrus]

Should've made it so the crab death message changes the players name to Amelia Earhart 😊

[@Jay2480]

No way is that luxintrus from the hit smp content smp

[@handle42069]

when the person with an anchor as a weapon dies to a silly goober who has schizophrenia

[@cadettrev762]

Didn’t expect an Amelia Earhart being consumed by crabs joke in a Minecraft comment section, but here we are

[@sallykiamtia]

hi Lux :)

[@thebigyes8482]

@@cadettrev762Really? Like really? You don’t think this joke was at all predictable?

[@the_dexman]

my guess for how you get claws without killing the crab is that the crab naturally removes its own claw and grows a new one like they occasionally do in real life

[@Doctor-Of-Doom]

Like scutes!

[@kevingaming6494]

make them spawn with different claw sizes, increasing the damage and making crabs with bigger claws discriminate crabs with smaller claws.

[@antoniojoaquin2425]

Crab racism

[@aedenoleary]

Ah, yes... *S E G R E G A T I O N*

[@doctoryoyogaming5122]

Ah yes, crabism

[@dibershai6009]

In real life there are species of crabs which fight for females and the males with the biggest claws win these fights and get to mate with the females.

[@rinapeada5470]

​@@dibershai6009 and I thought humans are the first species to make love

[@joe-skeen]

After seeing this, anything that Mojang does with the crab (if voted) will inevitably be a disappointment in comparison.

[@northernalpine4350]

I fucking hate how thats accurate

[@user-ok3rr2uk4z]

If they added all three mobs every year without a vote but rather just instantly unannounced, there would be problems like... like... like... yeah no they could've so easily made this game better by just releasing all three mobs every year (which is generous to do considering they have a whole team on the job compared to this chad who will most likely add all of the mobs in 3 days)...

[@mikestaph]

We all need to expose how an extended reach will literally be useless, please, convince your friends to vote for the armadillo, we can't let them take our chance to use equipment on dogs

[@Kattenb]

It will be much better. This crab isnt realistic at all and he had no idea what to do so he just added random stuff.

[@gremloid]

​@@Kattenbdid you read the title of the video

[@Blaze_1379]

imagine if you could use the crab claw to make a grapple hook

[@Jay2480]

That would be awesome

[@Electroblade360]

GENIUS

[@Jellyjam14blas]

:0 oh ma yess

[@Vortical__]

Heh... Crabbling hook I'm sorry-

[@Jellyjam14blas]

@@Vortical__ The Grappling Claw could be made from a crab claw and either two chains or a lead.

[@Magicwaterz]

Regarding crab claws, they actually autotomize the claw if it felt threatened, or if the claw is a burden to them through either it is too damaged, or was trapped because of it.

[@Customfurball28]

I love how earlier today a person I know was like "they should add a potion of carcinization" and then you do in your video. Amazing coincidence, and good work on the mod, that was insanely fast!

[@zappingnerd5624]

nice mob mod

[@PIMKAMINA2]

i mean crabs sometimes shed their shells to get bigger, so maybe the player can just find discarded claws laying around crabs. maybe when you breed two crabs abd make a baby crab, the baby crab sheds its claw when it turns into an adult.

[@leszekryniec7054]

4:25 The powers of 2 are the coder's best friend, after all!

[@TheAnnyParker]

I imagine the crab will either drop it's claw when it grows up, ala scutes with turtles, or the extra reach will be an AOE type thing, like dolphin's grace

[@Knosek]

If it's the second one it's gonna be so useless lmao

[@duskadown6751]

I'm hoping it'll be a drop you hold in your off hand and can also be used to reach mobs or players in combat

[@xadielplasencia3674]

Its confirmed you'll get their claws as an item

[@sunday_vibes8956]

ROFL

[@th3epicr0ck]

Cant wait to see what mobs are in the mob vote other then the crab and to see what you will do with them

[@GI1Tch1]

others are seagull and jellyfish..if the leaker was right. maybe..idk

[@philipgelderblom6878]

I'm probably just voting for the crab

[@LoonaTheHellhound69]

Duck maybe

[@rdaug3110]

@@GI1Tch1 mojang themself leaked it, it is seagull and jellyfish i believe

[@GI1Tch1]

@@rdaug3110 they showed the videos accidentally i think

[@newphonewhodis9215]

I don't get why Mojang doesn't just add all those mobs, like seriously they're more than capable.

[@RemingtonTripp]

the stupid reason is cause they have to worry about the community's liking the mob so if one is hated then that sucks but if they make us vote its on us

[@starchysleet341]

it's marketing

[@orb6013]

The mob vote is for community engagement

[@Gabriel-lh7gy]

Option 1 those are extra mobs that wouldn't be added to the game otherwise (crossover mobs like the glowing squid or the allay) Option 2 we wouldn't be aware of the mobs and would complain about mob bloating (if the mob vote started earlier the stray, husk, and polar bear would have been a mob vote for sure) Either way it would have a negative impact on the game because these mobs are not designed to be all added at once

[@vaguedestruction]

It's because they want to include the community. It's good marketing to say "YOU can vote for the mob that gets added". It's just something to get the community hyped about.

[@Amiruny]

Crab should have a "Combat Mode" while on defense or attacking the crab claw will stay open and will close when pinched

[@bubbygaming2138]

HOW DO YOU MAKE THESE SO QUICK DO YOU HAVE LEAKS?!!? Anyways love the videos keep it up 😄

[@ruthless3r]

Magic

[@mnbvcxz9385]

It's because their mobs are so simple to add that modders can do it in less than a day and include more features.

[@ElectroTiger]

@@mnbvcxz9385 I don't think you understand just how long coding takes

[@Banana_Fusion]

​@@ElectroTigerI don't think you understand how little effort Microsoft/Mojang puts into their game

[@RichConnerGMN]

​@@mnbvcxz9385 6 months later and the point still flies right over your head every time, doesn't it

[@Ri_Guy16]

I remember when he did the allay, it looked so weird. I wonder how weird this will be in the future

[@dampierre99]

I love that this is my first time seeing the first option for the mob vote

[@michealnotmichael6595]

Not gonna lie, would love it if Eight makes a full-on tutorial series on how to mod but that would take like a year to finish lol

[@alexanderlori7651]

The crab randomly stealing items is a fun idea. They should make it so that killing the crab is not an option if you want the item back so you have to trade another item with it or something, maybe even obtaining their claw through that process

[@scout1696]

0:25 god i wonder what's gonna happen at the end Edit: Yep, knew it. Would've been funnier if it didn't happen.

[@LightZanima.]

If you drink a potion of Carcinization will you just become a crab yourself🦀🦀🦀

[@unixversal]

i think you should of made the crabs ruthlessly kill eachother if any song gets played in their vicinity

[@statelyelms]

I'm glad you eventually added the crab rave. Crabs dancing is just nice to see :)

[@TheEpicFlyer]

4:04 this was my favorite feature until he removed it-

[@helow8714]

jesus christ this dude is a faster coder than the combined effort of the entire team of mojang

[@mainframe1608]

Kingbdogs, one of the developers of Minecraft, made a great response for people like you who don’t know what it’s like to design a game. In his statement when people asked him why they can’t add all 3 mobs is because they’d have less in the core update because time is a limited resource. Also people forget that bedrock edition exists when they make this statement, theres a reason all of these “i made the update before mojang” videos take place on java edition. Bedrock is coded in c++ so they have to rewrite the code in that language and have to make sure that every platform of minecraft, even the mobile version, can run smoothly without any problems in the update. The developers work long shifts to make sure that the update comes out for a reason.

[@helow8714]

@@mainframe1608 i know that its really freaken hard to code a game. but this dude made an amazing looking mob within a day of it being announced. I just wish that mojang did more with its game. btw mobile sucks ass

[@hhff8534]

​​@@helow8714you want them to add the mob before the vote even happens?

[@drwhocoby]

Eight back again, making the mob vote more enjoyable

[@Multi-Waves_Music]

I really really really wish the crab claw would give us the ability to build underneath a block Because when you are floating in the sky it would be really nice to make steps down

[@BunnlyGames]

bro uploads every 2487 months and uploads faster than sonic can run when new mob vote mobs are introduced

[@Mike-mf3ed]

6:06 this is actually realistic as a lot of animals either evolved from or into crabs (like a lot a lot), or so I heard…

[@dtniland]

the fact that i will probably take 6 years for mojang to make a worse version of this is a bit sad

[@hrpang]

I was gonna save that Crabs do actually just drop their claws. They are capable of self amputation. But the grabby extendo arm thing is really hilarious.

[@Tusk_The_First]

Oh wow, so fast! Eight would never fail to destroy the next update lol

[@fulookin6701]

They won’t let you swear but are planning on letting you brutally rip of a crab’s claw to use to extend your reach 😎

[@DarkRaikon]

that's the thing that bug me about mojang... they are a company and their updates bearly add stuff in.... like the sniffer didn't let us make ancient blocks from it's flowers, just a few flowers you can make. it's not the crab+water biome remake it's just ONE mob

[@Mikailodon]

As a paleontology lover the potion of carcinization got me there

[@AndrewVega0131]

In irl crabs rip off their own claws when predators are attacking the crab. The animal attacking will eat the crabs claw as a distraction so maybe if you attack the crab I will have a chance to drop the claw.

[@Greedow01]

well done, just a little fact about nature that I learned 2 minutes ago, that when crabs are in danger, they cut off their claws but they grow back.

[@yungrafacruz]

Missed opportunity too make a crab name Hello I like money into a mr krabs 😢

[@strategystuff5080]

100% expecting the potion of carcinization to just give the mobs cancer.

[@matic768]

The reach distance improvement could be done through enchanting rather than crafting

[@guillermocervisalmeron2209]

Didn't expect that biology class at the end

[@barkstararchie]

As an evolution geek, the nod to Carcinisation was PERFECT

[@glubtier]

You get crab claws like that one gif of a crab angrily tearing off his claw and throwing it on the ground. I don't care if crab rave is overdone, i think every mon should have a dance animation. Zombies can do Thriller, Skeletons can do Spooky Scary Skeletons, cats can do catJAM, etc.

[@Jay2480]

The fact he probably did this in a single night

[@mistypikku]

and mojangcrasoft a AAA studio with hundreds of staff members take a whole year to add this shit

[@TSMSnation]

he started with a floating crab. then he suggested this dietetic building archetype design that cleverly builds upon the very vague original idea. I want this one. like not whatever mojang has planed, but THIS one.

[@lily_the_ladybug]

5:47 RIP Crab 2023-2023

[@pyjamaprince]

I hope the dance will be an actual feature

[@plighting_engineerd]

YEAH! I thought maybe you weren't doing it this year, I'm glad I was wrong. You've inspired me as well - I'm also taking a shot at coding these in each day. WAIT we both made basically the same joke with the claw!!! I made you have to swap it with an artificial metal claw. That's really funny.

[@Goat_Chhetri]

Love the eyes of the crabs it reminds me of OG minecraft noob

[@Frankly-ev9dq]

6:16 one must imagine crab happy

[@pinkduck4782]

the announcement came out 15 hours ago????

[@icejack3659]

The sword feature is what amazes me the most. 10/10

[@johnmck05]

Bro really spent the whole day making a Minecraft crab.

[@aminebutbetter]

2:26 he even has it saying that the user was slain by a crab!

[@de_fishy]

ngl your rendition of the crab looks really good

[@AshishXMC]

I love and missed this type of video. Sadly, it'll be gone again after the third mob has its video done, just like last time... :[

[@doozy5184]

This is actually great, you should make this a mod so that we can get the armadillo or penguin as well

[@JONITOKING]

Ah, the Minecraft mob vote! The only time of the year where we can approximate your upload schedule!

[@lasercraft32]

This is perfect. You didn't make it worse... you made it BETTER.

[@Kattenb]

No

[@lasercraft32]

@@Kattenb Can't take a joke I guess...

[@Kattenb]

@@lasercraft32 its just not better.

[@mlerxz]

Something that would make this mob a W is if you can use a shell remover to remove the shell making it weaker but then dying the turtle’s scute to re add a shell with ANY color!

[@ryanstopmotions9409]

Everyone says that it’s weird that the Crab claw it would be weird by shearing it off but that’s actually how they get crab claws in real life

[@Amadk179]

the idea of macking the crabs place blocks by themselfes despide being weird could have many implications

[@Draconic404]

If I remeber correctly crabs shed their shells so that's probably how you would get a claw

[@ABCD-ff9ft]

The description said all 3 names of the mobs in the mob vote before the videos even came out, how tf did you know

[@IronGearProductions]

"We need to folow Mojang's ethical code on real-life animals" Also Mojang: "If you set the sheep/cow/pig on fire before killing it, it'll drop cooked meat"

[@American_Lobster]

funfact: the species of this crab is called a “Fiddler Crab”, the giant claws only appear on males, they dont use it for eating for some reason. So they use the tiny claw to eat.

[@VanillqCustard]

You’re probably not gonna see this, but actually crabs pull off their arms, sometimes when they are threatened Or because it’s damaged so that’s possibly a way of getting it

[@Elytraz17]

What if you give him structure voids? it's a block that you can't see but can walk through Or.... Lava buckets

[@traerock7126]

Im very disappointed you did not turn yourself into a crab with the potion

[@kindalam_e]

i think crabs being able to pick up and use tools would be awesome actually kinda like an enderman but just for everything

[@thebananaspeedruns9275]

The only question I have about the crab, is just how much extra reach does the claw give?

[@Itzkamau]

It will give 1 to 1.5 blocks probably if it wins

[@plasma8321]

With crabs we can finally display every employee of the krusty krab

[@hillabwonS]

"another mob that has a 33% chance of existing!" - eight sided square

[@utubeiskaren7796]

I feel like the neutral crab should become hostile if you get within 1 block of it. That way it's still technically neutral.

[@Findingusernamesishard]

if the crab ends up winning we still dont know if we voted for the right mob until i see a crab rave

[@mahuba2553]

im pretty sure crabs cab regrow most of their limbs, incliduing their claw

[@XcaliburMortem]

The fact that he coded that into the game and make a video about it in less than a day is crazy

[@natothefla2178]

the crab rave part was awesome!

[@denisekyles4299]

I honestly hoped the last feature would be the ability to turn yourself into a crab but alas...

[@kirbyplushshow_]

6:17 bro can't get enough

[@NotTured]

The fact that he did it in like a day just shows how a 1 billion company could add all the mobs with ace Anyways great work 😃😁 Ill be waiting when the other mobs vote come out and ill see you too you earned a new subscriber :)

[@Kattenb]

He didnt even add it right

[@NotTured]

@@Kattenb yes there is no ai but minecraft could just ctrl + c that from other mobs with some changes and he may added some stuff that wasnt mentioned but it is more of a meme vid which is great

[@smietan2699]

Technically shearing the claw makes most sence. Many crabs to this to themselves to survive while escaping predators. Besides fiddler crabs that mojang based these crabs on, don't even use these giant claws for much more than attracting females. Crabs can regrow their claws too. However I really like your solution, it looked goofy af.

[@theprehistorichubert9448]

Wloud be cool if mojang made the crabs moult and drop a claw fragment once in a while which could be crafted into a usable crab claw

[@GalaxVerse]

Mojang's dumbest lamest move is making them Only spawn in mangrove swamps. that's lame because irl carbs can be found everywhere like in everywhere like lakes, rivers, sewers, Oceans, swamps etc adding them in swamps so that's the lamest move Mojang made.

[@Jellotines]

Well, crabs randomly rip off their claws, so you dont need to trade!

[@SentryX7]

Crabs Some time drop the Claws if threatened EDIT It is called Autotomy

[@BigGuy1]

Love how mojang says it takes a long time yet this Kan has already added all 3.

[@the_vine_queen]

why are we waiting months for Mojang to add this when this random guy with a square for a head can make a crab in a matter of days

[@diabIok]

This year I’m not spoiling myself about the mob vote, I want to discover each option through your videos

[@MilethReyes1045]

wait i just realazed that if you add all three mob vote mobs with 33% percent of winning it all adds up to 69% percent of the three mobs winning

[@That_OneGuy46]

Now make one for the armadillo. Make him an arms dealer.

[@Gucciblackberry]

I hate so much they want to put them in mangroves…. Like usually I’m not like that with Minecraft but that’s annoying cause why wouldn’t they put them on the beaches

[@Its_Maxie]

At the start when he was like "I hate crabrave" I knew, he's adding crabrave.

[@sultanbatumy]

I just wanted a new mob that have new ability, new animation & new foods and fruits, not just a crab, no new animation, just a normal crab like frog, can breath underwater & air, thats all