에이트(8eight) _ 심장이 없어(Without a Heart) MV

에이트(8eight) _ 심장이 없어(Without a Heart) MV
2009.3.10

[@uwusunoo]

You know you're getting old when you see other comments saying "BTS brought me here" when you're just coming back to one of your favorite MVs which you've seen 6 years ago. xD I almost forgot abt this video, geez. I'm so thankful Bangtan is gonna cover this song. It's gonna be LIT. Can't wait to hear Taetae's voice.

[@ten7385]

Karen Jeon i'm 100 years old then hahaha

[@ten7385]

Karen Jeon i'm 100 years old then hahaha

[@jeoncenun1040]

SAME

[@MrKyubear]

same gurrll... (ㄒoㄒ)

[@yeppoheera]

same here. i forget this song when gag concert playing this song

[@ARMY-yz4oz]

but can we talk about how talented musically bang PD-nim his songs are always the best

[@maiomar1341]

ARMY 하스나 IKR he is just as talented as they are.they're so underrated ,it's such a waste that they disbanded 😔

[@ARMY-yz4oz]

Bts Is Gold yup

[@user-hm2xj5vq5c]

이노래와 뮤비내용이 안소희랑 왠지잘어울렸어

[@chelseabondzanga5922]

THEY'RE FROM BIGHIT TOO, PROMO-BIGHIT FAMILIA LET'S GET IT

[@sowonsera8523]

Chelsea Bondz big hit and source music It used to be one company

[@ikhwaatikasury5168]

Yes. They are from bighit^^

[@btssuejibae8130]

@@ikhwaatikasury5168 so this amazing song that bts covered that mad me cry was all along from a bighit artist too? Oh well

[@-insectbreedingteamibt3037]

초등학생시절때 좋아해서 매일같이 컴퓨터로듣던노래중하난데 5년지나서 처음으로 다시들어보니 정말 감동입니다. 사랑합니다,에이트

[@user-us7tx2xi2v]

슬프때 들으면 한없이 무너짐 즐거울때 들으면 너무좋은 곡

[@liaanne1047]

Bang Si Hyuk PDnim is such a talented producer and composer. I can't believe they will finally feature a special stage that celebrates the work of our beloved Big Hit Entertainment founder in this 31st GDA. Can't wait for VIXX, GOT7, IOI performing his hit songs and especially our Bangtan covering this song on stage. Ok, I'm gonna cry under a rock now.

[@susienk]

what are the Bang PDs songs Vixx ioi and others perform?

[@ikhwaatikasury5168]

Agree with you! Bang PDnim jjang!

[@noukie582]

Wow! Did GDA really dedicate a show just to show BangPD’s songs? Also this song is so great, I agree he is a great producer

[@NameePark]

Did everyone know this band was produced by Bighit ???? So cool because this was one of my favourite songs back in the day!

[@YourMumSey]

The male part reminds me of V's voice. OMG! Can't wait for their performance 😍😍

[@basmahamza6733]

Me too

[@myidgan7561]

That's Lee hyun

[@gremasvill4529]

Hello from 2020, I'm a BTS ARMY.. Here bcoz BigHit confirmed that you'll comeback on Feb. 9... Looking forward for your new music. Goodluck! 💜💜💜

[@chucharusy576]

Gre Mas Vill me too💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@nomyum7042]

Really? Didn't this group disband ages ago?

[@-DeaPutriAzhariHasibuan]

Human Being nopee. They become more sucessfull💜

[@user-pb4vk3fp6z]

이 노래 진짜 추억 돋는다 그리고 뮤비 내용이 예나 지금이나 참 슬프네 뱀파이어 소녀는 인간의 남자가 사고로 죽은지도 모르고 계속 기다리다가 빛에 의해 자신도 서서히 쓸쓸히 사라지는거

[@user-ot9xf4kl6b]

에이트 보고싶네요 이시절 이노래 대박이였는데..

[@wiwiknut9009]

10 years anniversary~ congratulations 💜

[@troijames]

I finally remembered this song. Been itching my mind for a long time now. I remember listening to this song a lot when it got released. How time flies indeed.

[@vivianzhou6032]

bangtan introduced us to another amazing song

[@user-di7kr4fd8z]

소희 🥺🥺~ 내가 보는 걸그룹 역대최고 매력녀 1등 ~

[@fernfernsone]

I cameback to this song after 5 years because BTS gonna perform it!! omgggg

[@doyoulikefishbread2397]

bangtan will perform this song omg 😱

[@ariamxiah623]

Came here because BTS will sing this song... i can already hear Jimin's high note there, and V's cool deep voice... BANGTAN can do a ballad with rap-sing part.. talk about real talent and flexibility in music... This song is almost like a "campfire song" Like young forever wherein you can imagine fans singing along with BTS, just like Dul Set

[@ariamxiah623]

bueno.TASTIC you're right! i was just trying to imagine how they will sing it based on how they give out lines in their previous song... but I also hope that Jin can have the girl's lines coz it's soft and kind of "weeping"... Anyway, like all ARMYs we're just too excited we always get ahead with our heads and posing theories ahaha Excited to see Yoongi.. hopefully he'll be there!

[@maghrebiamel874]

ariam xiah same here ^^ I'm so excited to watch their performance tomirrow with yoongi back again !!! aaaahhhh I missed him so much ^^

[@francysmaldonado8807]

me too lol came here just after know BTS is performing this tomorrow!!! OMG!

[@aakushah8993]

yassss

[@ngocanhthuvo9562]

2016 and still watching this. Ahn Sohee and 8eight ❤️

[@debbykemalayanti4478]

Already imagine about who's gonna sing in each part, cant wait for bts perform this in GDA 2017 😍

[@user-di5wx9ft1n]

BTSのカバーを通してこの曲に出会えたことに感謝します🙇‍♀️

[@francysmaldonado8807]

ARMYs this is like listening to Jungkook's rap and taehyung's deep Voice!!!!

[@huiminlee8049]

I think the song has really good lyrics so I'm posting it here. If I say that I'm in pain, I'm scared that I'll really be in pain If I say that I'm sad, I'm scared that I will shed my tears Why don't I just laugh, just laugh, just laugh... But people ask me why I'm crying... Everyday I cry, I smile, cry then smile again What's wrong with me, why do I do this repeatedly? Can't differentiate between bottles of alcohol and meals So far in my life, I never felt pain this excruciating Absentmindedly, I write your name over and over on a piece of paper In a day, the paper becomes black and I finally let the pen go I long for you, I hold on to my cellphone and let it go my eyes are filling up with tears again, this separation between us.. I'm without a heart, I don't have a heart So I wouldn't be feeling pain Everyday I talk to myself, and put myself under a spell But even so, I keep shedding my tears If I say that I'm in pain, I'm scared that I'll really be in pain If I say that I'm sad, I'm scared that I will shed my tears Why don't I just laugh, just laugh, just laugh... But people ask me why I'm crying, when I'm laughing like this... After you left, I think I became a fool I can't do, I can't do anything, so I die. I shove myself into a corner and live Without you there's nothing left to do A day is too long, way too long But what was I busy with, to make you feel so lonely, when you wanted to go shopping, going out with my friends was so easy, but why couldn't I do the same to you? I always regretted being so slow, I don't know if I'm really stupid, but I still can't let go of our bond. I'm without a heart, I don't have a heart Again today, I can see through your lies My heart is in so much pain, I'm begging for your help How can I smile in times like this? If I say that I'm in pain, I'm scared that I'll really be in pain If I say that I'm sad, I'm scared that I will shed my tears Why don't I just laugh, just laugh, just laugh... But people ask me why I'm crying, when I'm laughing like this... (let's smile) like couples in dramas (let's smile) like the title of your blog (let's smile) happy like in my past I'm without a heart, I can't be in pain I'm without a heart, I can't be in pain Let's just laugh, just laugh, just laugh Please, please let's stop crying now...

[@apaaja5960]

2024. And this song still on my playlist

[@michaelabongalon1982]

omg same!

[@stephaniecastro2]

Can't wait to see BTS perform this song! 😆

[@tathihuongkieu8025]

Stephanie Castro me too

[@bimmwu8754]

LolStephanie Castro

[@IdolGal]

i can roughly imagine who sings which parts XD

[@chewy52901]

didn`t get to hear suga`s part tho. i`m sad

[@stephaniecastro2]

Chua Lor yeah was his mic not working or??

[@sajanatamang1294]

Who is here after hearing that they are going to have a comeback after 6 long years? We can't wait to hear your soulful music. Good luck !

[@kimjhadejalotjot9648]

Sajana Tamang so exited to support every part of bighit fam 💜

[@mimi-do2fp]

I m here after that.... But in 2020 I m falling for this song

[@ishitasahi65]

What is the name of the song pls tell me

[@sajanatamang1294]

@@ishitasahi65 here is the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2ibnmeKhc2WnMk

[@verydeartomyheart]

👍

[@Meii8899]

thank you bts, i now know another great song💜💗💜💗

[@nurfaizahzahri]

Hi. It's 2019 by now

[@user-wv7bt4hd5e]

이 좋은 노래 다양한 세대가 누릴 수 있어 참 행복하네요. 모두 즐거운 일들 가득하시길.

[@user-jb3wv1ru3u]

I Miss u “So Hee” 2019

[@angelindieyoyoangel]

그동안 가수들 신보를 기대한적이없는데 에이트는 정말 기대된다 내 인생의 노래

[@minholly949]

THIS SONG IS ONE OF MY FAVOURITES OMG SUCH A PITY THAT 8EIGHT DISBANDED THEY'RE SUCH GEMS 😭😭😭😭😭 Can't wait to hear bangtan's rendition of it!! ❤❤

[@user-lg2to4rk3j]

13년만에 다시 들었는데 가사가 참... 이렇게 슬픈 가사였나라는 생각이든다. 그 당시에는 그냥 멜로디가 좋아서 들었고 가사는 멜로디에 붙어있으니까 따라 한건데 다시 듣는 지금은 가사 하나하나가 마음에 꽂힌다. 가사가 너무 슬프네

[@manniplaysgenshin]

Who else came here because of V, RM, Jin ???? 👇🏻

[@swarnasahukara4498]

Me!!!

[@evelynstevie]

Manal Fatima me!😂

[@shilpasaroj730]

Me

[@Hinata-ss5tr]

Me✌✌

[@jiniwon796]

Me

[@nickeinicoleeeee]

The fact that tae sounds like one of the original singers! WOOOOOWWWWW!!! I really love this song... The male singer in this one really sounds like him... Its like he's one of the singers.

[@user-ey9vl8hp7j]

12년만이지만 여전히 좋구나

[@saphireriley5827]

3 things caught me : - very good songs - imagining bangtan gonna sing this - sohee as model XD but i feel like they just gonna sang it until 2:19 since most of special stage never sang full of the song . . . pls bighit, let all member got parts ㅠㅜㅠㅠ

[@vanquocpham7439]

Saphire Riley what do you mean??? BTS will perform and of course each member has their own part

[@symckr]

but its an award show not year end shoe they have more airtime they can perform whole song

[@daegu-townsugaagust-d6963]

Saphire Riley it's joo hee

[@mybutterflies_7373]

Saw so hee as actress and listen to this song. OMG i miss this song so much. I really want bighit to do this kind of music again. I mean 2AM, 8eight, Homme 😭😭 lee hyun is the only one that is "active"

[@user-vq4wv7kc7n]

전이노래좋아해요노래가좋아요정말감동이예요흥분도하고그래요

[@danioliveiraefl]

Ahn SoHee so pretty

[@joaniewwh3502]

i'm here cos bighit posted that there'd be a comeback for this group. 💜 an army here at 2020. beautiful song and mv. bh be nailing visuals at 2011! 😍

[@AP-fi2di]

LeeHyun should release songs from time to time seriously his voice is wonderful and soothing

[@annz438326]

Waaahhhh..It's been ten years already..I loved this song back then..I was just starting my fangirl life by then..& I got to watch the mv again thanks to JiMinie..Now,I can't help but wish for e8ight to regroup & make a comeback..

[@ReachLoveYoungbae]

I miss their beautiful vocal & rapping. Who watching this in late 2015??

[@haileyyy04]

+Sunrise Hyunwoo so am i

[@ReachLoveYoungbae]

Haha nice to see u here

[@megalin9679]

another song to add to my playlist everyday.. in my opinion,sometimes its really rude when we comment "bangtan brought me here" but there is time when bangtan really introduce us to a nice song, really thankfull..

[@joy3203]

Jungkook 의 Noona there are really a lot of super nice songs in old era of kpop. i hope you get to discover them.

[@janeyyyjordan7641]

Such a beautiful song 💖😭. Happy 10th year anniversary! 🎉

[@Maricris1995]

I think taehyung loves this song so much. Ive been hearing him singing this song many times.

[@KJJholic]

Still love this song

[@whalienmy9909]

i came here to listen to min yoongi's rap part yet i fall in love with this song. this is gonna be jam from now on for sure.

[@sophie797]

Please, every fan of K-Pop know this song and it’s not thanks to BTS or another artist, thank you 8eight for all of your songs !

[@clarie_8654]

이 노래 좋아 했었는데 벌써 10주년이네요! 참 세월 빠르다~

[@soobrise]

WHO'S HERE AFTER BANGTANBOMB V RM JIMIN?😏

[@jessicam.r.6312]

Me ♡

[@Yashir_oTBHK]

I'm coming because of I'm coming because of RM V jin

[@joy3203]

I fell in love with the MV first because of Sohee. Wow I super miss this era of K-pop.

[@eljen18]

Thank God Black Snake sang this on gag concert it reminded me again of beautiful kpop songs.

[@ajun7105]

Same here.lol

[@user-gk2ki7oz9p]

아프다고말하면정말아플것같아서슬프다고말하면눈물이날것같아서그냥웃지그냥웃지그냥웃지그런데사람들이왜우냐고물어이렇게웃는데. 노래너무슬프고좋아요ㅠ♥

[@btsblackswan9274]

i'm so proud of BTS , they will sing a song from a group from their same company , I AM PROUD THE 8EIGHT ARE SUCH A BALAD GROUP TO SING FOR

[@whyrano453]

2010년대 초반까지 노래방에 맨날 나온 뮤비였는데 추억이다ㅜ ㅜㅠ

[@moonchildfairy2569]

lee hyun voice is beautiful

[@ohgeenius401]

my childhood memories right here..... still remember the buzz this got when they announce sohee would be in the mv

[@dosiphatra9567]

I have ever listened this song around 5 6 years ago. But Now I'm here again because of BTS. Thank to my 7 angels brought me to this song again💖💖💖💖💖💖💖

[@qmqprpdl]

어렸을때 뮤비에 나오는 여자가 누군지 몰랐는 커서 보니깐 원더걸스의 소희였었네...울컥 하게 만드는곡...

[@jeoncenun1040]

i really like this song when i was a child, my sister introduced me to kpop

[@shuureikou1822]

Who else came here because of Jimin's tweet on March 9, 2019?

[@noruuaya3391]

Me

[@desireeiaiza3958]

MEMEMEEM AHYSUSUUSS

[@mionysia]

Hi! 🖐️☺️

[@rere8516]

Absolutely me💜

[@Sunlitbab3]

Me

[@gfriendstan613]

For the new fans 8Eight the mixed group that debuted in 2007 by Source Music (GFriend company) and BigHit (BTS and TXT company) They won the first season of the television series, MBC’s Show Survival, whose format is similar to that of American Idol (USA). This mixed trio caught the attention of the jury and the public for its excellent interpretive ability. Driven by the incipient popularity he gained in the aforementioned television program, they made their first appearance in Music Core on August 25, 2007.

[@lysora1367]

Miss this kind of kpop Listen to this after watching super junior return 4

[@GaViioTiiTiisZ87]

HAPPY 10TH ANNIVERSARY 8eight!! Buy me dinner also💜🤗

[@nurhaninatrah6918]

the first line got me shivering i swear

[@alkenneth2614]

Happy 10th year anniversary for this song “without a heart”. 💜💜💜

[@lamnguyenhong6629]

A beautiful song with beautiful voice and my ultimate bias in Kpop - Ahn So Hee.

[@rain-pi4xw]

오래간만에 들어서 기분좋았는데 댓글상태왜이러냐.방탄에 별로 편견있는것도 아니고 오히려 외국에도 많이 알려진 그룹이라 좀 좋은쪽으로 보고있는데 원곡까지와서 방탄방탄거리니까 보기 ㅈㄴ 안좋다.이러니까 별 이유도아닌걸로 부정적이게보게됨.

[@AsapBeby]

in ra 상관 없는 가수를 부정적으로 보는 거 자체가 이상한데?

[@user-yj1xl7jp3k]

@@AsapBeby 상관 있는게 방탄소년단이 심장이 없어 커버했는데 방탄이 훨 낫다 이런 댓글이 많으니 안좋게 볼수밖에 없지요 원곡이 더 좋은건 팩트인데

[@24lucas45]

븅신꼰대새끼들아; 이렇게재조명되면 좋은거지 좋고안좋고를떠나서 외국인들이그걸어케알아ㅋㅋ존나한심하네진짜

[@user-ti5tt5mt7s]

이 댓글 개씹공감

[@user-ek9uw4ft5g]

24 Lucas 진짜 띄어쓰기 1도 안하고 맞춤법 좇같이 어기면 진짜 개한심하고 무능해보여요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-sq4xk2qu4f]

그냥 음악을 들을 땐 몰랐는데 내용을 들여다보니 너무 슬픈 내용이닷. 소희 보고 싶다. 지금 모하시낭? 방송에 나오시길

[@user-cb8hh5vd3e]

지금도 보고 있는분? 🙌 ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️ ⬇️

[@e_drag_studio]

저요!! 소희님이 너무 예쁘네요!!

[@oberdamujigae]

major nostalgia. I'm not a ballad person but this song has always hit me from my junior high days

[@user-sz1ud7dg8u]

와 10년전…미쳤다ㅜ시간

[@umarudoma4014]

The rapper seems Hanbin,the singer Taehyung and the girl has an unique voice for me,its beautiful

[@puppenstubemarquiz4305]

8eight, it's been a long time. this is the first korean song i used to like, i listen a lot when i was in 9th grade. now, I'am worker woman. oh, time so fast😄

[@user-jm3jv1qk1x]

사랑하는 사람이 사라진다는건 너무 슬퍼요 2년이 지났지만 간절한…

[@cesiagonzalez6409]

Happy 10 years anniversary! What a beautiful song

[@CokeGuo]

Suga's part 2:21-2:28 #SWAG😎 Hope JIMIN can sing the high notes 2:32-2:40 #amazingsong #thankyouBTS #loop

[@aliali-hd8vz]

Why didn't I hear this song before 😭😭😭😭 It's so good 😍😍😍 Bts did great preforming this😢😢

[@joy3203]

alia li probably because you were an infant when this came out

[@Zara-dp9sp]

I'm here cause BTS,,, BTS always know the great song,,,,,fighting BANGTAN !!

[@beathricebethsaida6559]

LOL. I should thank my ex boyfriend cause he introduced me to Kpop by recommended me to listen to 8Eight songs back then! And I didn't notice that 8Eight was under BigHit and also BTS sunbaenim. I feel old now listening to this song.

[@lamnguyenhong6629]

Watch this again because of BTS and my bias So Hee. I miss you a lot, So Hee ah, Wonder Girls ah,....

[@brunaniara3788]

BIGHIT Just work with high class talented people right?! I'm amazed.

[@fact.check.]

BRUNA NIARA its eight... 8 eight...

[@182nidasiddique7]

Who else is here after bh announces their comeback!!!! im so excited ...

[@wonderfulpolin]

i love this song and keep rewatching this because my queen Sohee!!! Omg this song is so so so so sad but at the same time the voice feel soothing in a way... Love them since way back until now!

[@gabrielamanzo7110]

I'm watching a drama called. " MISSING the other side". She is one of the lead actresses. It's on Netflix.

[@user-vj4xp4vw6c]

이 시절 뮤비 갬성 그립다.. 저 시절의 만두 소희도 그립넹❤

[@sryztmrzn5803]

Voice has so much pain on it 😭😭😭😭 just love this love

[@Fernfanning]

Sohee i miss you..

[@sophiavarghese2052]

THIS MASTERPIECE IS 10 YEARS OLD!

[@gabrielamanzo7110]

I heard this song for the 1st time when it came out. I cried to this song so many times. Till this day I still cry when ever I hear it. So much emotion. The vocals are exceptional. After all this years still one of my favorite songs from 8eight.

[@assia_kookie]

2020 welcome BACK 😭😭😭😭🥳🥳🥳🤧

[@indahdwirahmayanti7333]

After announcement 8eight will be comeback 👏👏

[@windaa6369]

I hope ARMY just support BTS and leave alone about who most get lines. i dont wanna see any fanwar of this fandom. fight bcs something like this again is shame. lets not be salty lets no complain. just talk about their hardwork for this special stage not focus line they get. bts never wanna you fight about this after all their hardwork.

[@user-gc9br5wx3n]

아프다고 말하면 정말 아플 것 같아서 슬프다고 말하면 눈물이 날 것 같아서 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그런데 사람들이 왜 우냐고 물어 매일을 울다가 웃다가 울다가 웃는걸 반복해 나 왜 이러는데 술이 술인지 밥인지도 모르는 채 살아 이 정도 아픔은 통과 의례인 듯 해 멍하니 종이에 나도 몰래 니 이름만 적어 하루 왠 종일 종이가 시커매지고서야 펜을 놔 너 그리워 또 핸드폰을 들었다 놔 눈물이 또 찾아와 너와의 이별이란 나는 심장이 없어 나는 심장이 없어 그래서 아픈 걸 느낄리 없어 매일 혼잣말을 해 내게 주문을 걸어 그래도 자꾸 눈물이 나는 걸 아프다고 말하면 정말 아플 것 같아서 슬프다고 말하면 눈물이 날 것 같아서 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그런데 사람들이 왜 우냐고 물어 이렇게 웃는데 니가 떠나고부터 난 바보가 된 것 같어 I can't do 아무것도 죽어라 방구석에 박혀 살어 너 없인 할 일도 없는데 하룬 길어 너무 길어 근데 뭐 그리 바뻐 널 외롭게 했어 니가 쇼핑 가자 그럴 때 친구와 술 한잔 마시는 건 그렇게 쉬운데 왜 너한텐 못했을까 언제나 제일 느린 게 후회랬는데 정말 바본지 끝까지 너와의 끈을 놓지 못해 나는 심장이 없어 나는 심장이 없어 오늘도 뻔한 거짓말을 해 가슴이 너무 아픈데 이렇게 보채는데 어떻게 웃을 수가 있겠어 아프다고 말하면 정말 아플 것 같아서 슬프다고 말하면 눈물이 날 것 같아서 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그냥 웃지 그런데 사람들이 왜 우냐고 물어 이렇게 웃는데 (웃자) TV속 연예인들처럼 (웃자) 너의 미니홈피 제목처럼 (웃자) 행복했던 내 어제처럼 나는 심장이 없어 아플 수가 난 없어 나는 심장이 없어 아플 수가 난 없어 그냥 웃자 그냥 웃자 그냥 웃자 제발 좀 눈물아 이제는 멈춰줘

[@mrerp11]

Remember kpop back then ? When kpop was more about the quality of music than that of views.

[@rappersdonthavehatersshutu4299]

do you know who is producer of this song?

[@Chihiro274]

man sohee is so pretty in this. i can see why korea is still crazy about her

[@Motokophorps]

이때뮤비보고눈물찔끔했지..그나저나이노래개좋다고에이트해체왜하냐고ㅜㅜ

[@carmen09]

The storyline is so sad and beautiful at the same time!! 😭❤