Chinese Textbook- Which do I recommend?

[@cicimandarinchinese9133]

I like how the exercises you showed don't seem to rely on English too much.

[@fatalshot0093]

The simplified version is $61. Interestingly the traditional version is half that price.

[@whoizrez]

I can imagine. unless ur gonna be based in Taiwan it’s a waste of time (and useless for Hong Kong since it’s still teaching mandarin)

[@ElementaryChinese]

Could be that you're looking at an older edition of the traditional character version.

[@fatalshot0093]

@@ElementaryChinese No, it was 4th edition. It was around $29 for a while. But I checked again, it disappeared assuming that the seller sold out.

[@assurgentg4113]

Don’t know if you’d reply. But I just could not find an answer. So I want to know the difference between 3rd edition and 4th edition of Integrated Chinese.

[@AlfariziChannel]

Best video explaintion

[@ElementaryChinese]

It was a loooong one. I tried to be more thorough.

[@shrwnt]

Based on your reviews, I will probably get bored faster with Living Language Chinese. I'm self-studying and I just finished lesson 5 of Integrated Chinese. The questions so far I've been able to figure out (or at least that's what I believe. lol) probably because they are still on the "easier" side. Although I'm guessing that in the later lessons will be much harder to figure out by myself.

[@ElementaryChinese]

Friend, you gotta get a language exchange partner or tutor. Biggest reason is so you can begin having conversations from the get go. : ) What inspired you to start studying Mandarin?

[@shrwnt]

@@ElementaryChinese Thanks. I'll follow your advice. I'm part Chinese but I don't speak Mandarin. lol.

[@lukefroberto]

Where can I buy Integrated Chinese 4th Edition in China? I can only find the 3rd Edition on Taobao 🤔

[@coolmatterstome]

Should I get IC textbook 3 or 4 and why? I was skimming through textbook 3 and the scope & sequence in it looks very similar to an previous edition (2?) of IC that I successfully finished. I'm wondering if it's a good idea to jump directly to textbook 4? I'm not the best at writing from scratch but I can 'recognize' read many of the characters. Would I be missing much? Does Text 4 pack a powerful punch or is 3 better?

[@ElementaryChinese]

SO much has changed from the 3rd edition even. All of the partner activities are new, which in my opinion is the best part. I'd only get 3 if you've already finished 2.

[@coolmatterstome]

@@ElementaryChinese How do your rate Textbook 4 compared to Textbook 3 in the colorful latest edition? Is it a repeat of the same characters and themes or does it introduce a healthy amount of new material making it a worthy buy?

[@laborer_in_the_harvest]

who was your professor at UW?

[@sakthit656]

Sir I eagerly want to learn mandarin chinese please provide best books for study also read and write(work book) best 5 books

[@GeorginaEsiTakyiAnnan]

Hi we can do a collab

[@Destiny-tv8ox]

3rd

[@CodyMSmith-oo5qd]

First comment