【ENG】#周深 是懂嗑CP的 来音综当恋爱观察员也是没谁了！看到#李天责 和#王OK 的反应像在演当电灯泡的我！ #舞台2023 【订阅甜妹】

甜妹爱舞台！欢迎订阅一起嗑综艺~
和甜妹一起冲在吃瓜第一线~
#닝닝 #舞台2023 #周深 #王嘉尔 #Ella #黄绮珊 #jaypark #孟美岐 #朴宰范 #宁艺卓 #닝닝 #奥斯卡 #庆怜 #安崎 #徐子末 #甜妹嗑糖中心

[@jasonhu2927]

王OK真大器 一次就是100分送天責 這女孩玩真的!!!

[@tengteng7975]

她给了100 我还以为守护的分应该都差不太多，不然怎么算守护，但后面陆续都30以下徘徊😅 虽然1分也是分但真的很考验人性🤨

[@wulfhart2]

news flash: The Next 2023 is not a singing contest or a survival variety show. it is actually a Drama series with Wang OK and Li Tianze as the lead.

[@CallmeShadowyn]

This is what we all came to watch, amrite? They just need to create series at this point.

[@陳靜玲-f9q]

Ella真的EQ高阻止黄媽講出伤害兩位歌手影響成績，好歌是要傳唱的，到底是什麼心態，夲來歌唱來唱去会没有的，太情緒化了。

[@lojamie6262]

建議黃媽純粹分享這首歌跟她獨特的情感連結就好 用不著要別人也要好好保護 每個人都是獨立的個體 有自己的情感認知 都值得尊重~ 黃媽版本的確很好聽 但我覺得她並不適合作為一個評審 心智不夠成熟

[@Isaac_HK]

我個人理解黄媽不希望歌曲的感情成為博取比賽分數的工具而已，而且比賽場合的焦點很多時候都著重於演出者的唱功和舞台表現，所以她才想保護歌曲

[@toodriptohandle]

我覺得黃媽是成熟的，因為她自己知道，所以她才會先求救於Ella，而不是直接說。她知道自己說法的技巧，這裡有一個緩衝，其實表示她有思慮過。與其說心智不夠成熟，不如說是她還不夠當評審的經驗，選手也要經驗評委當然也是。而且黃媽一直都很願意聽歌手說，她這裡聽完OK後有道歉，第一集她也很直接為了評論服裝的事跟耿星睿道歉。不成熟的人是不會真心道歉的。

[@toong6598]

人到了一定年紀心態上都會有所轉變，對於某件事會有獨特的固執，你去老人院參觀就明白了

[@sueanaphotography]

年轻人其实未必不理解这首歌, 不要轻率论断, 年轻人面对现实的挣扎是非常大的, 比年长的人更强烈。一首歌没有任何人不可以共鸣啊？喜欢这对儿CP磕！

[@品全-i6y]

怎麼說，其實黃媽的意思就是這首歌是拿來治癒的，而且覺得需要到那個點，才會拿來唱一下，因為這首歌對黃媽來說是神聖的，才會有這種情緒，後面周深也有說這種感受，其實就是對那首歌有敬畏之心，才這樣，所以不用這樣說黃媽🙃

[@ericw3020]

这是对于黄妈的神圣，这首歌既然能够拿来用作为黄妈你就要大方的让孩子们想要如何去用这首歌来表达他们的故事。 你如果接受不了别人使用这首歌无论是什么动机，那么你就收起来别让他们用。 这样别人也不需要接受你的负面情绪，你也不需要委屈的觉得别人践踏了你的神圣了。 身为音乐人，一首歌你要这么使劲的去保护不敢轻易触碰。那么请问不能碰的音乐，算是什么音乐？ 有人喜欢这首歌，是这首歌赋予了所有人感到才受到喜爱，这不是作为音乐人所追求的么？ 着像了呀黄妈！

[@鍾佳均-x8g]

王OK好可愛啊啊啊啊啊啊~💖💖💖💖

[@anabelnove134]

Ahhh too cute!!! The way she brings out the child in him. And how he chased her… acting weak and asking her to come to the doctor together.

[@kathykong8608]

太喜欢李天责声音

[@lateefahsanni3884]

I just love their vocals so much. So distinct and so unique to them. Wang Ok and Tianze’s stages always touch my soul. Very talented singer Wang Ok & Musician Li Tianze

[@jingzhang9825]

李天泽 王OK: 富二代和混血儿美女 感情第一 比赛第二

[@kathykong8608]

我喜欢李天责和王OK

[@bobbymoss6160]

Hahhaha love 王OK and 李天责 chemistry, really like their rendition of the song.

[@lala-rj5di]

两个都很可以啊。和Ella 说的，还真让我发现有这首歌。黄妈不应该伤心的。我不觉得有把原创的味道抹去。我觉得各自都有不一样的味道。都可喜欢。我比较喜欢没rap的李天责。

[@user-hsinching]

其實這首 向雲端 本身就有饒舌 只不過OK把饒舌的編曲改了一下 我覺得他們倆都唱得很好，OK我聽到後面突然感覺有點像佛經😂😂不知道為什麼 天責唱得也很有感覺

[@krazylla819]

部分歌手確實會迷失在流量裡，最後迷失了心，黃媽應該意指唱歌應該發自心，而不是因為流量才去唱，向雲端是一首以治癒作為創作理念的歌曲，她希望這首歌能夠帶給聽者沒有目的的溫柔（？）

[@johntitor1354]

這首歌很安慰。。 聽了無數次也哭了無數次。。但我還是走不出陰霾，我換了抑鬱症我真的走不出來。。。對不起我辜負了所有人。。。

[@borar_ose13]

沒看這之前我還在真以為他們是情侶來參賽😂

[@Joeylim-y3h]

他们不是情侣吗？

[@Jessica-gc2ji]

傳唱這首歌才是真正的保護這首歌..🙄

[@anna09840984]

黃媽這樣的反應我覺得不太好，歌就是給大家唱的，妳管人家目的呢？ 好險Ella趕快擋

[@kathykong8608]

王OK 也唱到很好听

[@danielheng501]

Both of them came up their own version of this love song base on both of their uniqueness that are in curent time, you can see them sing harmoniously during their personal practises. How can she just want her song to remain sang in original state as old like her?. Her time and now is different 50 years different, she should be proud that her song still alive till now and even the audiences knows to sing this song that had carried on for decades. I dont agree that people would just change her song, throw it and forget about it. How can she pre judge the singers saying they does not treat the song with dignity!?. Mixing her personal with her professional as judge. Claiming she didn't get to copyright her songs seems like a threat and her selfish nature.

[@shanlin4270]

我個人不太理解黃媽的情緒化表現😵‍💫，我認為一首好歌可以治癒所有人 若想保護這首歌就應該繼續傳唱並傳承下去這份感動😊

[@sueanaphotography]

唉！这脑回路也是难follow

[@alexsim1624]

嗯，这就是独有和共享的区别。 有些情感和经历，某些人是想独有，而非共享的，这被看作，我和你之间的区别。这往往是人最柔软最脆弱的心中一块。 做歌手，是赚钱的职业，但倾情而作的歌曲，并不都是为了赚钱的，也有想永远放在心底，珍藏起来的。

[@jt5566]

from first stage already seen that they are interested in each other...

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

same their chemistry r cute 🥰❤

[@diwu4113]

磕了磕了😂

[@virginiatan9548]

两个都好棒，但李天责比较打动我

[@cynthiazh5207]

虽然觉得两个人唱的都不怎么痒，但没看懂黄妈的点在哪里？每个人对一首歌的理解各有不同， 为什么一定要求符合自己的观点才能唱这首歌。不管出于什么目的， 人家花钱买了版权就可以唱啊。真对这首歌有特殊感情， 不希望别人随便唱，就自己买下版权， 确定申请的人自己满意才授权唱好了。

[@athomenotavailable]

荒井老师真的是无处不在

[@marcoc2706]

“向云端”这歌流量很高么？在这之前从没听过。

[@怡珍陳-f8n]

喜歡黃媽，真！！不只是真，還心胸寬闊！！ 整個過程除了感受到她的情感豐富，還感覺到她對小輩的愛護與溫暖❤❤

[@jinglinwang3266]

黄妈是有信仰的人🙏

[@許豐洋]

個人感受，黃媽很摯樸真誠

[@Shawn311-e3m]

实话，李唱的好好听，好感人。也是第一次听。也比较喜欢李的版本。

[@a29723172]

黃媽歌裡 聽到的是豁然開朗的篤定 已在方外 Ok的是 在迷惘中已看見出口 天則的是仍在迷惘之中😂 不過黃媽的情緒化有點讓人反感

[@louistan577]

我是刚认识了 王OK 才认识《向云端》这首歌，有谁和我一样吗？

[@wanjing9448]

好爱王ok的 听了想哭🥺

[@emmaku2388]

黃媽过于情绪化, 而且太主观了, 真的不适合当推荐人 评判人

[@wilfredtankhoonpheow2605]

Totally agree with you

[@kathykong8608]

我也觉得

[@serenechong5356]

对，我也觉得，幸好Ella阻止的快,这会影响学员。

[@sueanaphotography]

唉！

[@danielheng501]

Next time do not get judges that are too wide century old gap difference to be judge in millennium time.

[@layzhangismyhero4395]

wang ok and tianzhe jayooh i love them together ❤

[@雙下巴成天喊減肥的可]

我要嗑瘋惹❤

[@athomenotavailable]

恋宗！

[@tkyh4839]

黄绮珊真的不太适合做评委、太情绪化😢

[@sinpeiung4961]

還有另一對維澤和佩玲，覺得也有CP感，😄

[@aohoaam]

They are more of friends and colleagues if I might say. Like Veegee and Caelan, they are very close to each other, but I'd never feel like they would be lovers (at least not now)

[@xxxkkk4228]

我只看了片段，嗑到徐子未和李佩玲大vocal cp，沒想到主流是另一對啊😭

[@aohoaam]

@@xxxkkk4228 🤣🤣🤣

[@xxxkkk4228]

@@aohoaam Agree. How about Caelan and Lyly😳? I also ship Xu Zi Wei and Lee Pei Ling haha 🥰

[@aohoaam]

​@@xxxkkk4228 ​ =))) I think they are all good friends so people can catch some moments to ship them. From what the show has showed us so far, I feel that they are just very supportive to each other but not more. I personally do not ship any cp from a show =))) (until this show+ I dont watch too many show) Abt OK and Tianze (Duke Lee): I am their music-fan first, then only when I noticed how other people's reactions are so strange toward them then I did a bit of research. At the end of the day, if they're not real cp, the joy that I have when I follow them is worthy for me to support this cp ^^ And I am telling you that I am still fluttered everytime I watch their livestream. Like I shouldn't be their, let that cp alone together =)))))) (exactly what Zhou Shen felt haha)

[@GraceLiu-n1d]

Ella情商太高了，Hold住全场。说白了两个参赛选手唱的太好远远超过了黄妈的原唱，黄妈受不了了，但好在最后还是能支持选手

[@샤오밍-s1d]

❤❤❤❤Zhou shen good boy

[@Zoe-vt8po]

ok唱的有味道

[@jingzhang9825]

黄妈是好歌手 但清规戒律太多 不适合做指导老师

[@凌阳-h4g]

一般翻唱是不会去了解那个作品的诞生原因或者作曲编曲或是原唱所表达的意思嘛，难道不是去用自己对歌词以及故事的融合来唱吗？以上为本人的观点，只是表达自己的想法，没别的意思哈。

[@workinprogress9613]

I watched that whole thing because I wanted to see what happened with OK, and now I wish I understood the language.

[@socheatanim2759]

❤❤❤❤

[@abysstu]

被人理解一直都是一件奢侈的事..

[@graceshu-minchang5732]

不ok了，搞戀綜😂真的是玩人心

[@weeeeeeeeeeeeeen]

2:02 cc抽筋了？怎么看着这么舒服呢 hhhhhhhh

[@GraceLiu-n1d]

天责比王OK和黄妈对这首歌的演绎都好很多，歌词改的hen h

[@where311]

其實我不太懂黃媽的觀點😅😅😅

[@dayafk3981]

老娘作品 不是給你們蹭流量

[@timyee1008]

​@@dayafk3981简单粗暴😂

[@haobangdada]

歌词怎么对不上唱的

[@maryychasenn]

name song pleasee 😭😭😭

[@GraceLiu-n1d]

听到后背唱的好、本来应该当面肯定鼓励才对结果在舞台了不顾实录和观众当面发飙，不能控制情绪哪里像个55岁的成功歌手，这样的人配请来当评委吗？

[@aohoaam]

I definitely missed some points but anyone could explain me why Wang OK and Tianze (Duke Lee) were teamed together for the 1st public round please? =))) And why I bought the VIP member for youtube channel but still haven't seen many videos that are shared on weibo/bilibili...?

[@bobbymoss6160]

I was wondering about that as well. They should how the other contestants team up for the 1st stage, but not these two. However, if you look at the song credits for 王OK and 李天责, they are in each other's song, since the initial individual performance. So my guess is they got to know each other in the dorm rooms before the 1st performance and decided to connect and the relationship just blossomed from there.

[@aohoaam]

@@bobbymoss6160 Actually from the latest videos, they explained that all contestants already gathered before the recording day. And Tianze helped OK with the guitar part for her internal test. And since that, they started talking and realized that they share several similarities in term of music and life.

[@aohoaam]

@@bobbymoss6160 I love the fact that we can always see their names on each other's performances whether they perform together or not. That's how they support each other, and we could see the special bond between them, not all the other contestants could do like that.

[@jssjess276]

比到最后男的会爱上ok吗？

[@haobangdada]

爱了 不敢讲

[@dousaaa1110]

近期已經官宣囉😊

[@jackeric75234422]

黃媽這樣的反應真的很作……

[@melissashuenshuen6082]

天呀，有病吧。瞬间下头，华晨宇那个自杀的歌不就一直传唱，反而治愈了很多的人。哇这个评审别人评论真性情我迷茫了都

[@lawchen9529]

那個姓黃的到底在說什麼鬼😂

[@Tientt604]

王ok 不ok

[@GraceLiu-n1d]

黄妈连创作者都不是有什么权利不让参赛者演唱？太小眼了太不能摆正自己的位置了吧，还觉得自己是乐坛老大吗？学学李健好吗？王菲唱红了他的歌曲对吗？人家什么也没有说吧

[@sandradewisutanto6337]

好喜欢他们两个～ 希望可以在一起