ENTRENCHED VS CENTAURA (REVIEW)

[@whimsicalidiot5564]

The dev of centuara has said that there will be no player control for the vehicles because he wants for the entire game to be focused on being a foot soldier. He plans to add engineers in the future but they will only be able to build sandbags and wires because according to him "digging trenches and building them in such a short time is super unrealistic"

[@mrbloby8806]

Yea if I remember he said that engineers don’t start digging trenches in a middle of a firefight

[@VitalikZ-yz5qw]

Yay, another reason to never play centuara

[@mrbloby8806]

@@VitalikZ-yz5qw if I was very invested in building stuff in a warzone I would just play trenches at that point

[@STAR_8831]

L​@@VitalikZ-yz5qw

[@RandomFurry07]

I mean yeah The Centauran Wars last for decades, can't wait for Aquilla

[@Chrono0dr-qn7vu]

The artillery spam in centaura is pretty realistic honestly if you take into account that in ww1 I believe that in the battle of Somme or something, there was 3 million shells fired in the course of a day. Entrenched could use a little tweaking on a lot of maps but is most pretty good, I don’t like when people tunnel though.

[@taderdinedillon2509]

There were also artillery operations in the latter half of the war which had 5 million shells fired in just 5 hours

[@bubbubthealmighty9240]

Yeah the artillery in its current amount is alright, i just think its too accurate for ww1 artillery considering everytime i've died to it its been a direct hit. Also they need to fix the issue with it spawn camping a side for a couple minutes

[@Manuel_Dubs]

The artillery was the weapon with most kills in the ww1

[@RTSfan-ee5lt]

@@bubbubthealmighty9240Assuming you are talking about Capri valley, the Artillery was rebuffed to not spawn you in trenches, or at least not as much.

[@a12475]

60% of men in the western front died because of artillery shells, maybe centaura needs more artillery

[@gmdtanker6211]

The fun thing about centuara is that the artillery happens in phases. Every few minute intervals, the artillery will start to target a portion of the map. It helps provide support if you are battling on the defensive, and it helps keep the match in check whenever one side seems to be hard pushing an objective. One cool think about the artillery is that it provides a distinct atmosphere. From your trench, seeing the artillery smoke and clouds of blood from across the battlefield really beings home the reality of war.

[@Tema2kyboi]

In some maps only 1 side gets artillery that provides support Like zeppelin and Ship But people just keep walking to death, players don't understand

[@Tema2kyboi]

In some maps only 1 side gets artillery that provides support Like zeppelin and Ship But people just keep walking to death, players don't understand

[@michazaba9871]

​​@@Tema2kyboiWhile the zeppelin belongs to Corvus, and the ship to Cetus, they target both teams. Devs explained that the ship shooting at Cetans is a result of miscommunication (lore-wise).

[@Tema2kyboi]

@@michazaba9871 Yep, its obvious you have to run back and wait, but players decide to keep moving to death

[@Kodaiva]

@@Tema2kyboi those fire wherever the combat is happening regardless of whos there

[@helmit_kid9755]

Old entrenched used to be more ww1 styled or at least cinematic. especially before the building update when it was sitting in a trench as artillery is raining down around you as your getting charged with officer whistles going off and grenades exploding everywhere

[@sigmundwayneramos5471]

It was the time when the alpha and britain update they were good

[@dunnomynameso746]

You are so correct, and I remember hiding in the bushes.

[@RoyalProd23]

They're both really great games. Entrenched is meant to be more arcade like while centaura is supposed to be like a story and sort of realistic. Both are great. They both have great graphics and gameplay that can be fun and enjoyable for everyone. If youre feeling like grinding or just having a little fun then entrenched is for you but if youre more of a person who likes lore and realism with also amazing action i recommended centaura but both games can be for everyone.

[@monkegame6972]

So story Vs gameplay

[@orangeshyguygaming3875]

My biggest gripe with Centuara is that I feel like the reason people praise it so much is because of the realism, even though the gameplay can feel very unforgiving in comparison to Entrenched. I think that when you die in entrenched it is much easier to tell what killed you so you could learn from that mistake and preform better next time you play, whilst a majority of the time in Centuara, you can’t tell what killed you making it more frustrating to play. Overall, the realism is what Carries Centuara in my opinion.

[@Lorenzo20124]

Btw there’s something in the bottom left hand corner that’s shows how you got killed and also pay attention who killed you cuz you can’t escape artillery

[@user-micronesia]

Dying in Centaura and having no idea what killed you adds to the realism, you're not always gonna know what's coming at you, which is thrilling really for most players You describe Centaura like it's supposed to be arcade type shooter game, when it's themed as realistic (And also what the other guy said, just look at the kill feed)

[@Cutepanda1943]

@@user-micronesia Vehicles and artillery in centaura have aimbot. They should not be able to instantly kill you in in a random shell crater. WW1 artillery was pretty inaccurate.

[@Bowie-og4jz]

⁠@@Cutepanda1943did you fight in world war 1

[@Cutepanda1943]

@@Bowie-og4jz Did you.

[@noob12455]

I like the artillery spam, because it is realistic. Personally, both games are awesome and deserve love, if you're looking for a more action packed fast based game entrenched is for you. But if you like strategy, realism and longer games Centaura is for you.

[@object_333]

Also for lore

[@Kaleb-i9r6x]

Fr

[@vampsekai]

i like the artillery spam, but the problem is the artillery knows how to aim. you barely see centaura artillery miss, i think it should be random instead of aiming for players. same with armored cars, they should aim but be far slower and more innaccurate, but it should make up for it with having a large gun that acts as artillery

[@Aiwwmss]

They should make artillery way less accurate for realism.

[@aCloaker_isapproachingatyourlo]

The thing is when there were arty spams and the enemy had like 3 capture points supposed to us 2 in Capri Valley I keep telling my teammates that a creeping barrage was coming and we charged after the party and yet they never listen but it sure is fun as always

[@Eric0225]

Centaura imo is more of an action shooter point-and-click game, the lore is actually really cool, but gameplay-wise it is pretty fast paced and is just "shoot at a bunch of heads and die a million times until you capture the point", there isn't really a lot of communication between your teammates, it is a phenomenal game and it is pretty spectacular as well. I like charging with a bunch of strangers straight to my death. So it's pretty fun to play. Entrenched requires a little more strategy but is still somewhat the same, the reason you need a little more strategy is because if you're playing builder you want to strategically place fortifications. And as a normal footsoldier you can also dig trenches so you can build you and your teammates some cover. I will say that honestly Entrenched plays waay less smooth than Centaura and i'm not a big fan of the gunplay and the bullet speed. Nevertheless i could still play Centaura for much longer because it is pretty simple and straightforward and the lore keeps you in the game.

[@user-micronesia]

Yep, in terms of strategy and war sense, Centaura doesn't have alot of that but it's hell of a good job to show how grueling war was when you sacrificed hundreds of men just to move a mile forward

[@marcorocchi6758]

Centaura may be realistic and more immersive, but sniping people with pistols from 500 studs and using the repetierpistole or the doppelpistole is hella fun in Entrenched (Entrenched devs, please add Italy, cmon you added Austria Hungary you gotta add Italy)

[@marcorocchi6758]

@Alf_Ymoh Thank god I've been asking it even before the Engineer update

[@paratrooper5030]

​@Alf_YmohI S O N Z O

[@ColumbanOfficer]

Centaura focuses on intensity, violence, and accuracies, while entrenched is an arcade war game with immersive things. (Not hating to entrenched.)

[@cartmanplaysgaems]

add belgium nation!!!111!!!1

[@Iburneddownanorphanage]

They added italy recently lol

[@L3af_boi]

there have been a lot of updates that have released/are planned to release to fix a lot of the issues with centaura. The motars were recently nerfed, and a sapper class will be added, it won't be able to dig, but only make like sandbag walls or stuff. The armoured cars and tanks will stay NCP bc 1: cracked players can abuse the cars to completely change the course of the match, and vice verca. 2: the devs wants the game to mostly focus on being a soldier. Also artillery is a big part of battles irl, with it covering friendlys, and rooting out enemeis. Other than those things, you did a pretty good job of highlighting the pros and cons of each game.

[@gotouchgrass853]

Honestly, The armoured cars should stay ai because if they are players then they will move to positions like 10 cm close to the enemy spawn

[@sailorsown]

I was thinking the turret would be player controlled not the driving itself

[@Aguythatlovescentaura]

@@sailorsownidk that means you can snipe people with the turrent, so its still kinda overpowered

[@Sisbrolife8183]

@@sailorsownif you control the turret you can just snipe a person across the map no problem because you dont have a range limit. or even pin them down. in centaura, suppressing fire is the way of winning

[@Tema2kyboi]

​@@Sisbrolife8183LMG would be best thing

[@paxarite]

@@Aguythatlovescentaura make it low accuracy

[@Java_mapping1]

As an Entrenched player i really like Centauras flamethrower

[@Cutepanda1943]

The centura flamethrower is terribly implemented due to it being super strong while being 100 points making it an annoying but not that economical weapon.

[@ipapachubbs8609]

​@@Cutepanda1943It heavily depends on the map, plus its a huge risk to a team, if an enemy shoots the tank its joever for anyone around you.

[@Tank_lover]

​@Cutepanda1943 mf is mad cuz the flamethrower is doing it's job?☠️🙏😭

[@luulasmene7786]

One thing I dont really like about Entrenched is how you can spam any class you want, if the enemy team has 5-6 flamers or decides to have 10 assault, the game is over for you (same for officers, in this case it makes no sense to have more than 2 officers in). And I don't see that on Centaura because they have a cap on how many people can play with certain classes at the same time, which results in a much more balanced gameplay, at least for me

[@cartmanplaysgaems]

Yeah, that's a really big problem, mainly with op classes like assault(or map compatible classes, like flammer)

[@Kasierriech]

It has balencers

[@luulasmene7786]

Six months later than the first comment and I can safely say the Entrenched's biggest problem is how dumb most of the players can be, the game indicates the objective in almost every way, and still ppl refuse to follow the objective, lose and then complain abt it in chat💀

[@cartmanplaysgaems]

@@luulasmene7786 yeah, I hate recons and engies on offense, terrible.

[@luulasmene7786]

@@cartmanplaysgaems fr fr, also ppl playing support tryna be Rambo (they don't know what the word support means)

[@InostropianFan-sz9kg]

3:45 its just the reality like in ww1

[@ryujibackyeah4189]

"Fun" Fact : you can use the flamethrower to kill the Armored car (and you will hear a voiceline of the driver screaming and burning alive)

[@Kasierriech]

Yep

[@八雲藍-y2j]

The artillery in centuara makes sense. In ww1 there was tons of artillery shells being thrown. And the devs want it to make it a Ww1 experience

[@ambraaaam]

Something being realistic does not make it a good feature in a Game necesarily

[@ComradeZephyr]

@@ambraaaam But if the aim of the game is to be semi realistic, then realistic features such as crap tones of artillery does improve the game,

[@ambraaaam]

@@ComradeZephyr the point of the video is that you're more rather to die by an arty shell than an actual player, was that realistic? Yea, but it's not fun, when You play a Game You want to loose because You didn't Perform well, not because You didn't have a chance from the start

[@Kodaiva]

@@ambraaaam yes, that is how artillery works

[@ambraaaam]

@@Kodaiva please read what i wrote again

[@Egg-ehg]

An important thing to add is the lag: I generally find Entrenched to have better frames, and it is also more mobile-friendly in my opnion.

[@Aguythatlovescentaura]

Honestly centaura is fun on mobile. Especially since you do have a couple tools to help you fight pc players, such as auto shoot.

[@YurieSnowie]

I like both but I like Centaura, I love unforgiving games in general, games that makes you insignificant, the amount of artillery and mortar shells that are being fired is PTSD inducing and I love it

[@darkachegemony]

I prefer entrenched over centaura because you can build in there and you can also choose your class much easily. Compared to centaura, where if you want to be a medic or officer theres a chance it will have too many players playing that class. Which you either would pick the default class or youre gonna have to wait for someone to die in that class that you want to play

[@Dasmemelord]

Me personally, yes I do think the arty in Centaura can be annoying, I personally don’t have much of a problem with it. I like both games it’s just that I prefer Centaura because it feels more immersive in the war theme compared to Entrnched

[@user-micronesia]

Annoying yes, but realistic also yes

[@maurology]

@@user-micronesiaIt’s just inherently bad game design

[@Dino95423]

in my opinion, you cant really compare them, their gameplay is different as in entrench you can build a trench to help your team, in centaur, you cant really help your team in a significant way.

[@leewilson4362]

One is centered on being a good game first and foremost,the other is focused on saying war is bad and its atmosphere first,it’s why comparing them is difficult.

[@LandonGasao]

@@leewilson4362 exactly. Entrenched is bascialy an arccade shooter yet with some spice of immersiveness and realisim.

[@cartmanplaysgaems]

I have to disagree on the team being good or not part, having a bad team can impact your performance heavily on entrenched, not much in combat (unless the other team has a similar skill cap to yours) but on capturing points yes, just today i had a full match without a single point captured because none of the teams could advance (mine because of skill, but the enemy couldn't because i was carrying, absolutely carrying).

[@maurology]

Yeah, this critic has no idea what he’s talking about

[@RandomFurry07]

Yeah no they aint adding non-AI vehicles, theyre support vehicles, its focused on infantry, so giving player control to vehicles may lead to consequences I do think they do need to nerf the turn speed, since 360 degree turrets from the 20th century are quite slow,

[@thatoneperson134]

Meanwhile they also plan to adding a literal desert train battle

[@paratrooper5030]

​@@thatoneperson134do u mean arida desert in grusan campaign?

[@sealoftoaster1969]

Centaura's artillery actually have their attack patterns according to the map. If you can see the pattern, you can survives litterally any barrages.

[@remixgameyt1172]

There are patterns already. If it's coming from your side, it's gonna start at your trench and keep moving to the enemy trench and vice versa.

[@Cutepanda1943]

3:14. They were spawning so close because they spawned before you took the objective. After they were killed no more spawn shields appeared because their new spawn point was a lot further back.

[@CHEEZKITTY2636]

Both games have horrors, but I feel like centura shows the more realistic perspectives of PTSD but when I’m playing in trenched, I see my comrades get shot right in front of my face and it can freak me out but centura freaks me out more so it wins

[@CuriousLightOfficials]

Artilery in centaura gets annoying because we don't know how to use it. Probably we shouldn't go when artilery coming and stay in trench, and charge when it ends, or use artilery for defense. The most realistic detail in centaura (i think) its when officer uses whistle near large group of soldiers it starts making battle cry noise, it feel like real ww1 because ww1 was based on trenchs and attacking or defense. Entrenched is not that realistic like centaura, i mean even guns VFX or artilery shells. For maps, yes sure in entrencheed they are bigger , but the graphics looks plastic, in centaura the graphics looks very good, i mean smoke, blood, even the buildings or tanks, you can burn it/destroy it. For centaura bots is it realistic that they have so good aiming, because soldiers in real wars are so experienced. In nutshell: both games is good but i also think centaura is more dark and scary.

[@shadowknight_2505]

And also the game specificly says: ''COVER IS YOUR BEST FRIEND'' So you better frucking utilise it against the armored car or maybe go around it, It's suppost to give the enemy team a buff by giving them something to hide behind and something for them to not get flanked from that cover

[@Rablax]

mechanics definitely Entrenched but Centaura definitely war

[@vesnabernjak-ord8674]

Armoured cars are meant to be deadly. And no, they don’t have aimbot. If your zippy enough you can easily dodge the armoured car bullets.

[@Cutepanda1943]

Armored cars should not act like tanks though. They should struggle to move through no man’s land and be weak to grenades and rifles because of their weak armor. Also it makes no sense why they are mainly used heavily trenched based maps where their maneuverability is less useful.

[@CultReport]

I get lost so much in blackton that it feels gigantic

[@goothehightech12]

The developer has said entrenched is loosely based off of WWI. I think both are great but I do prefer entrenched more. I do LOVE centaura but, entrenched has that arcadey feeling, and the maps for me are pretty good, Centaura is based off of lore, and I also amazingly love lore. Both are great in their own ways, if you mix them together and make a game out of it, it'll be better than it's parents. They both are amazing. I play on mobile so entrenched is better for me, and my RAM is only 4GB, so it's less laggy, it has autofire, but, for both games you need skill to play, in entrenched i can't just autofire 10 people, I have to strategically so I don't die. Same thing in centaura except no autofire.

[@MariaElenaMedrano-p8p]

Entrenched is also Mobile player- friendly because in Mobile version you can contour the controls to your own likings and because of that you can play it just as good as consoles and PC although PC players have some advantage like less lag, faster reaction time and not having to worry about battery percentage. Centaura on the Other hand doesn't have any feature or settings to rearrange the controls, like when you play it on mobile you have to stop moving to shoot and crouch. That's why I only play the assault class because they have an automatic weapon and that gives me a tad bit of chance to actually kill someone and contribute to the team. Plus in Entrenched, shooting skill alone will not win you the battle, you can have a God tier aim and still get mowed down by the two MGs built by the skilled enemy engineers so team coordination, building fortifications and structures also contribute to the outcome of a match.

[@Graf_Zaluper]

I like Centaura because it shows what happens in war, if in entrenched you just shoot on a sunny day, then in Centaura you find yourself in real hell on the gridlock map, the battle can go on for hours, I once got into a battle that lasted 2 hours and 13,000 died in it, I think that there is no point in giving players the opportunity to control armored vehicles, because there will always be an idiot who will get stuck somewhere and will not be able to leave and will simply do nothing, he can get stuck in a trench, in a tree, or he will, on the contrary, interfere with his allies.

[@traceytraced]

Entrenched looks like the Western Front in Ww1 and Centaura looks like Eastern Front Ww2 but with Ww1 technology

[@Partizani192]

uhh, maybe sun didn't stop existing when ww1 happened? Just an idea tho

[@user-micronesia]

​@@Partizani192there is a sun, just that in war the amount of clothes ad smoke everywhere covers the sky, it was that dark

[@Partizani192]

@@user-micronesia mostly the early war Entrenched maps are sunny because the war wasn't that crazy yet. After that it's mostly night or winter maps

[@user-micronesia]

@@Partizani192 cool

[@yahyaboujnah-q1e]

ur aim it's so good good video i agree to you ideas about entrenched i will now try centaura it's does look fast paced like cod i often like this gameplay good video .

[@dakmoibruh800]

As a player who played both games (I played entrenched more but I played centaura to give my own opinion). Entrenched does not aim to be realistic, it only based on ww1, unlike centaura which aims to be realistic to show the horrors of war. If you ask me, I would say entrenched is like call of duty but take places in the first world war, centaura will be battlefield 1 but it has its own lore (yes I know it took inspiration from battlefield 1 but I cant find any good example), so it is reasonable for centaura to let the vehicles controlled by ai. If they let players control the vehicle, then I bet that most of them are too stupid to control. This is happening in entrenched as the most of engineers main are too dumb to know when to attack or how to defend the point (worst is they stay behind the defend zone and build heavy bunkers which couldnt be use if the enemies pushed the team back). I welcome any corrections

[@Taco_truckman]

The amount of skill this man has, with guns in game is insane. I thought i was good at entrenched until i see this guy getting 20 kills in 1 minute 3:12

[@Imgonefromytnow]

Centaura is also called the PTSD simulator and is considered one of the most realistic depictions of war on and not on roblox. The only thing that can compare is no hud battlefield 1.

[@maurology]

Centaura is not realistic at all. It’s the most fast paced arcadey game on the platform. The gameplay is literally the same poorly designed maps where you click on heads and hold W at an objective for 45 minutes with an average lifespan of 30 seconds, Sure it’s brutal but it’s not realistic to war at all. And I’m willing to bet without the “ptsd” mechanics or lore this game would not be as popular since it’s just another barebones shooter without it

[@BomberGoBoom]

​​@@maurology Man i been looking at a few comments and i kept seeing you reply with full of Hatred comment toward Centaura by calling it a Slop or Barebones Shooter listen this is people Opinions alright just respect their opinions also if you really don't like the game then leave and play the game you enjoy very much, is way better then just spreading hate

[@maurology]

@@BomberGoBoom I know that now, I have changed and stopped spreading hate, those were comments from some time agp

[@BomberGoBoom]

@@maurology Alright, That good 👍

[@Tank_lover]

FFS STOP CALLING IT A PTSD GAME YOU CANNOT GET PTSD FROM A WW1 FPS GAME

[@Whiterobot12]

idk if it's just me, but for weapon handling, i got to give it to entrenched. centaura feels so.... cumbersome

[@CountryBallHistorian]

The bullet sprays in entrenched are very realistic it sometimes make me change my aim ti watch tge bullet velocity unlike in centaura where tge bullets go in a straight line

[@maurology]

Centaura weapon handling is just boring , it’s a barebones shooter that is only popular because it’s “ptsd mechanics” and lore, which are just excuses the devs use to cover up for inherently bad game design

[@whatabowtflushyandmpg]

entrenched and centaura are maded by the same Creator

[@DewiGrove]

I agree with a few points you have about Centaura, but the first few things that you said about entrenched i think is either inaccurate or wrong, but your point about the Ai armored cars and the artillery in Centaura I 100% agree with.

[@glockpit2674]

centaura for the artillery im ok with it because its wat make the game feel more chaotic and feel like a real war and for the amoured car in centaura i agree with u plyrs should be able to control it rather then AI

[@hahahahha264]

the owner said that the cars wouldn't be controlable😔

[@GeneralKatkat]

I don’t disagree with classic, 8 year old children will not contribute to the battle when they’re in armoured vehicles

[@youlocalshitposter7232]

They said that all vehicles will be ai for the following: player behavior can vary, vehicles are meant to support your team, but some just use it to farm kills and do their own thing, and he wants to keep as many players as infantry due to that being the focus of the game

[@hahahahha264]

it would be annoying just like when people shoot and reveal your location in dead ahead@@GeneralKatkat

[@八雲藍-y2j]

The devs want you to experience what the average foot soldier was going through in ww1. So the vehicles are gonna be ai controlled

[@DeusVult1013]

Centaura with entrenched weapons and lore will be the perfect ww1 game, but i also like centaura lore aswell

[@ImANeptunian]

Really, both games are for different types of players and they are all great. If you like a simple and fun war experience, you’d probably like entrenched. If you wanna FEEL the horrors of war and how it was actually like, centaura is for you. Yet like said in the video, entrenched does have bigger maps, it also has less lightning and graphics. But centaura is entirely based to be as real as possible. Basically every death involves a scream but most of the time an arty (Artillery) death can be just the clench of flesh bursting into a million tiny pieces as they all fall on your commander and comrades.

[@Imperial0630]

The problem of armored cars it's the fact of you can't enter on it and kill the pilot, making it op And the problem of entrenched is the cooldown of meele that you need to attack 3 or 2 times for one hit

[@paratrooper5030]

flametrooper pov:

[@Alexander-ns2su]

My one gripe for centaura is dealing with cracked players like you who see 3rd person view behind walls and trenches while I play 1st person view

[@professional_larper16]

I know I'm a bit late, but I want to weigh in my opinion on this. The reason you don't make as big of an impact in centuara compared to trenches is that in centuara, you are insignificant, just another number that's going to be killed off eventually. Every time you spawn in centuara, that's a new person. Every time you die, that's just another number added to the kill count. Also, as a mortar player mouse go brrrr on A point

[@lectroeel6290]

You described it perfectly. Centaura is immersive and realistic, however it sacrifices enjoyability. It's a game at the end of the day, and games are meant to be fun, which is why I like entrenched better. Entrenched can be tense and realistic sometimes with you getting sniped for peeking out of your trench for a single second, however it also feels more like a game

[@professional_larper16]

@@lectroeel6290 Mhm, I perfectly understand your view on this, and respect your opinion. Ive never played entrenched, so I wouldn't know. Ive only played CENTAURA and Shell shock. I personally enjoy CENTAURA despite the issues, due to the fact that its still a fun FPS and requires teamwork to get objectives.

[@maurology]

I really do feel like the “horrors of war” part of the game is just an excuse the devs use to cover up bad game design and its working. Dying to artillery every other respawn isn’t fun. “OHHH BUT IT SHOWS THE TRUE HORRORS OF WAR AND BRUTALITY OF ARTILLERY” No. Dying every 30 seconds holding W at an objective not even communicating with your team isn’t fun either. It’s just inherently bad game design. I bet that without the “ptsd” mechanics or lore Centarua would not be as popular as it is today because it’s just another barebones shooter.

[@WaterConsumer87]

A classic case of a critic not understanding the game they are reviewing. Is it the games fault for being realistic and not an arcade shooter? Go play phantom forces or something if you want that type of gameplay.

[@maurology]

This is so true, Centaura is just any other shooter with no substance or interesting things to set it apart yet the only reason it is popular is the lore and “ptsd” mechanics.

[@WaterConsumer87]

@@maurology PTSD plays a much more minor role in the game. The main thing that differentiates the game is external stimuli. When you join a game of Centaura, you aren’t fighting just other players, you are fighting their respective armies. Artillery and Naval support fire, Armored vehicles, Pillboxes, and even aircraft play a role in the battle. These things often interact with the control-capture system to make the game feel more like an actual war, and it makes the player feel smaller and weaker, instead of empowering them like most games try to do.

[@Cutepanda1943]

@@WaterConsumer87 The other stuff feels more like rng death then actually tactical help,

[@WaterConsumer87]

@@Cutepanda1943 It isn’t RNG, you just have to learn to deal with them. Artillery has distinctive tracers and sound effects, which means you can evade them if you move smart, and that comment just doesn’t make any sense when it comes to armored vehicles or any of the other things.

[@syntheticbombs]

it took me 4:25 seconds of watch time to finally turn up the volume and figure out it's not an AI voiceover

[@Finalwarsgodzilla-1954]

Entrenched=fun Centaura=realistic My opinion

[@maurology]

Other way around. Centaura is the most unrealistic fast paced arcadey slop

[@Cervus-zz1ox]

​@@maurologyfr

[@thej8656]

Entrenched is more strategic meanwhile centaura is pure horror

[@Ipolitelyaskyoutodie]

Entrenched is just the beauty of warfare turned into chaos, just everyone gangsta until the frenchies pull a Vietnam

[@potatomine6678]

i like the artillery spam cause it is realistic asf for the times when trench warfare was THE THING. although my pvp in entrenched is better than that of in centaura

[@maurology]

I really do feel like the “realistic horrors of war” aspect of Centaura is just a term used by the devs in order cover up bad game design and its working. Dying to artillery spam every other respawn isn’t fun it’s just bad game design.

[@Cutepanda1943]

Artilllery wasn’t accurate in WW1 though and struggled against trenches.

[@potatomine6678]

@@maurology that's true tho

[@potatomine6678]

@Cutepanda1943 i know

[@AlbertBundt]

Tbh people always hate cent aura arty but it adds a certain atmosphere to the gake

[@AarninDoesStuff]

CENTAURA is more like WW1. And yeah, obviously it's not gonna BE WW1, the game is just based off of it, but I'm talking about how you WILL NOT step 5 feet out of the trenches before getting blasted by guns or artillery or mines.

[@timjaszko5200]

Bro is struggling hard to find a reason why CENTRAURA isn't a book level of atmosphere

[@marescalo]

The only thing I don't like about entrenched is the first person. Like it legit kinda sucks, and I only use it when I'm in a more confined space. Yesterday I think I was playing as Germany against Russia, and I entered this big ass tunnel that was close to the enemy point. I was using first person, and I got surprised by this guy that was camping by the right. I shot him one time as I got scared, and I hit him for 100 in the head instantly killing that mf 💀 and after another russian player began shooting me from the end of that tunnel, but I somehow made it out alive

[@talibanprobomber]

entrenched and centaura the best ww1 games against each other what a masterpiece

[@vietnamarmapedia8624]

Don t forget also that Centaura has it s own lore including religion and has more gore like when people are burned alive they scream their lungs out and fire is smth to be feared in Centaura, in Entrenched is not that big deal

[@sam0l0v]

In my opinion, Entrenched was created specifically for phones, not everything is as loaded there as in Centaura. But Centaura was created for computers, it has good graphics, everything is ok. You may not agree with my opinion, but that's what I think.

[@4ffuhsj]

One story from playing Sentara I was playing I can’t remember the name of map I fired my rifle for no reason and I just ooft someone

[@blakstone17]

mortar will get a little nerf that will decrease his accury at longer range in the next big update also there will be a anti-tank class to take care of armored car and tanks in the futures new maps

[@coconutcarl28]

omg jackson

[@duskint]

personally i prefer smaller maps because it makes it feel more cramped and fast-paced

[@Udhek]

*Centaura* Is More Focused On PvP But Also In History. *Shell-Shock* Focus More On Surviving And Try To Recreate The Scenarios Of The Soldiers And A Little Of PvP. *Whizz-Bang* Is Also In Recreating But Also More PvP. *Entrenched* Is P2W With Your Average 25+ Health Gamepass And More PvP Than Ever.

[@furiouskillerdal4550]

I'm the mortar man getting quad kills by just denying the enemy a specifc area of cover lmao

[@enclave7125]

Entrenched is more arcade and organized war style and focus on being somewhat realistic and fun Centaura is lot more immersive and chaotic gameplay focusing on story telling and brutality

[@maurology]

Heeeck no centaura is the most arcadey slop fest holding W at an objective barbones shooter yet. The term “chaotic” and “horrors of war” is just a term the devs use to cover up just plain bad game design.

[@EjazIbrahim]

Centaura: EVERYONE CHARGE GO GO GO GIVE EMHELL!!!!!!! Entrenched: hey guys lets build a big tunnel to their obj

[@Cutepanda1943]

Small brain vs big brain.

[@Tema2kyboi]

@@Cutepanda1943 Nevermind, you are just crybaby + you are an ignorantly dumb

[@Kamzers]

Why are we putting them againts each other???

[@Cetus_countryball]

I say that both games are good because the graphics are awesome ❤

[@もふもふ2235]

bullets in centaura are hitscan which make landing shots a bit easier

[@shadowknight_2505]

Why do you sound like a depressed Anakin skywalker? Have some more emotion when reading the script.

[@shadowknight_2505]

Im not saying that you should have the youtuber stereotype voice thats on the other end of the spectrum you need to be in the middle

[@shadowknight_2505]

the spectrum goes from Gman ASMR to average russian badger video or mr beast voice video

[@sailorsown]

It’s a ai voice XD

[@shadowknight_2505]

@@sailorsown It was so monotone it went from obviously AI to right back to depressed random guy that sounds like anakin

[@Arandombank]

With entrenched, it pretty kind of a strategy game not really ww1 experience because it has no feel 😐. You know the light is bright, artillery is not even a threat slow paced, chilling. With centaura just try to survive, artillery is just a fcking asteroid, car and tank so cool fog of war, scream, officer whistle sometimes is just fire man or loss hearing, it really just a cinematic gameplay and fun. Players dont really communicate they just like: “FOR FATHERLAND!” Or talk about smt really weird

[@Am_and_ar]

Corrections: 1.The artillery is slow because the main factor of the officer class it needs to be close to nearby teamates so it can get a faster,deadlier and longer artillery. 2.some entrenched maps HAS night maps Ok thats all of it i can say.

[@Partizani192]

light is bright because sun still existed in ww1 genius

[@maurology]

You guys only glaze centaura because of the “ptsd horrors of war mechanics with realistic lore” and without those this game would just be another dead barebones shooter (which it is but people still play it). The ptsd realism mechanics are just things the devs use to cover up inherently bad game design.

[@ohwow512]

Funnily enough, Entrenched's graphics is probably more TECHNICALLY realistic than centaura. Now, i think we can all agree that centaura's graphics is better, but the thing is it utilizes a bluish color grade that dramatizes and amplifies the brightness of blood and bullets. You can actually see this cinematography technique used in the 2022 movie All Quiet on the Wesern Front, where they used a similar color grade for their battlefield scenes. Moreover, like All Quiet, centaura reduces the brightness of the sun in the game to further enhance the prominence of note-worthy visual objects (bullets, blood, etc). In contrast, Entrenched doesn't use a special color grade and keeps the lightning in the game pretty much the same, if not slightly brighter than the standard roblox game (i assume it's to aid the gameplay. Wouldn't make for a really fun game if you didn't see anything). The exceptions are the 2 maps verdun and the newly added nighttime map that i absolutely despite and will not remember its name, which are darker and has a desaturated look to its environment, a filming technique often seen in many war movies (e.g Saving Private Ryan). Conclusion? While yes, Entrenched's lightning effects and color grade are technically the more realistic of the two, centaura's lightning and color grade are the more dramatic and visually appealing (and VISUALLY more realistic, too).

[@Mr_Fugnug]

Centauras maps are agony

[@RandomFurry07]

Just like real life

[@maurology]

@@RandomFurry07You fell for the bad game design coverups by the devs. The Centaura maps are just horribly designed there’s no dispute.

[@RandomFurry07]

@@maurology I'm very sure you're over exaggerating to a degree this time Yes the maps are not good, but it doesn't mean they can't be enjoyable

[@dragone3]

i would like if you could be transported in the vehicles or be a gunner. also, the ai cars need some tweaking and a debuff with certain weapons. i shouldnt be able to be shot by the car while torching it.

[@swedeboi1]

entrenched is based on WW1 and centaura looks like WW2 and ww1 is mostly trench warfare so making trenches fast is needed

[@sprintfoxy1240]

The thing i hate the most about Centaura is the artillery more specificly how its done, its fun until you get spawncamped by it or hide but it goes through the building, Gridlock is the best exemple HOW THE FUCK DOES THE ARTI HIT ME INSIDE THE TRENCH ?! Trenches main purpose are protection against bullet and shells and its super effective, so why every two sec do i die inside my trench.

[@OperatorFritz]

The reason why they hit you inside of the trench is because they are wide, not small like actual trenches.

[@sprintfoxy1240]

@@OperatorFritz it still sucks

[@OperatorFritz]

@@sprintfoxy1240 So the trenches should be slim and small?

[@sprintfoxy1240]

​@@OperatorFritz i mean yeah, i think it would add even more to how soldiers felt inside them.

[@ProkiddUX]

You sound so AI and human at the same time, it scares me 😭

[@I_love_my_cat_cole]

My honest opinion Community Entrenched Graphics Centuria Realism Centuria Maps Entrenched Replay-ability Entrenched Cosmetics Entrenched Less paw2win Centuria More sandbox elements Entrenched Entrenched got 5 Centuria got 3

[@marcorocchi6758]

Entrenched isn't pay to win, I've never seen the shield, dummy or the other bundles bring a real advantage in the match

[@I_love_my_cat_cole]

@Alf_Ymoh have you heard of the shield it has saved my ass SOOO MANY TIMES ehen im rushing an enemy trench and theres an LMG that shield made me survive getting sniped either get to cover or use the shield

[@maurology]

Take realism away from centaura right now, graphics and realism are VERY different things people don’t understand

[@I_love_my_cat_cole]

@@maurology Wizzbang 💀

[@marlon806]

Only reason why i prefer entrenched over centaura is because entrenched is more mobile compatible then centaura

[@victory9161]

i feel like entrenched is more about gameplay and centaura is more about realism and atmosphere

[@maurology]

Centaura is NOT realistic bro

[@victory9161]

@@maurology yea i know but more realistic than entrenched i guess

[@Pajarodeideasmoralmentedudosas]

A Real Serious Competition Shell Shock vs Centaura

[@Partizani192]

is this your serious competition or are you just joking? Entrenched slams both

[@ДенисМолдован-л1ч]

Shellshock has really bad gameplay

[@lueisred6901]

Shell shock is so mediocre

[@abnormality3345]

is your voice okay???

[@sailorsown]

It’s a ai lol

[@object_333]

@@sailorsownno way 💀

[@ramendope2894]

@@sailorsownMy dumbass thought you have sore throat or something💀

[@dfprod.]

@@sailorsownlame honestly, just use your own voice. i don’t think you want people to recognize you based on some shitty ai voice

[@MeboGRJ]

i love both games but I now prefer Centaura bc of the story

[@Pablo_the_monkey4]

Roblox gave trencht a malatary and it gave centara horror damn 10/10 ptsd for centera

[@lilyjasia]

CENTAURA is not an average war game it’s a horror game

[@mozambique9113]

Centaura moves too fast for me. It reminded me of CoD

[@EpicBeefStudios]

Let me decide in realism war style Entrenched ww1 beta wins easily. EWB is more realism with the characters guns, scripts and movements.

[@shadowknight_2505]

In my opinion they should nerf artillery but nerf armored cars slightly

[@Factsandmemes69]

Respect

[@kingtutt5149]

bro cant think of reasons why they dot let the amored cars be playered controlled

[@nomus1172]

Spawn campers . A decently good player would use tanks and armored cars to spawn camp . And considering only two classes in the game can actually damage vehicles that would get pretty annoying

[@kingtutt5149]

@@nomus1172 and you are right it appears that maurlogy doesnt know what hes talkin about

[@ozloll]

There’s really no best one and worst one. There both great and fun in their own ways.

[@SandManOnTop]

Centaura is too dark for me like literally the screen is so dark I can’t see shit so I enjoy entrenched more

[@Tank_lover]

...do you play with sunglasses on my guy?

[@SandManOnTop]

@ no it’s like the amount of like fog and yes it’s super dark

[@Tank_lover]

@@SandManOnTop ...what fog?? I've never had any issues with fog *or* darkness, Maybe it's cuz I play on Playstation but still *turn your damn brightness up my boy*

[@SandManOnTop]

@ that’s not the problem I always keep my brightness low because it saves battery and every game I play I don’t have a problem with the brightness I just don’t like the general brightness of the game

[@Tank_lover]

@@SandManOnTop get glasses then lil bro

[@JackGotPixeld_175]

I like entrenched's mechanics better but I like Certuras graphics better

[@tawintianchomnad4478]

Now we got horizon blue 1919

[@Cervus-zz1ox]

It sucks

[@Tank_lover]

​@Cervus-zz1ox true

[@tawintianchomnad4478]

How?

[@hansscar-h4417]

Centaura is bad, for me, for now, its lagging af on my phone

[@JerseyShore2]

Entrenched is better than Bf1. Centaura stinks

[@MaazAhmed-ru7zp]

Guess u just can't handle the realism of war and how hard it actually is...

[@Tank_lover]

Lmao I bet bro doesn't know the "Shoot and move to the side" tactic

[@dayangsalzanajohari6890]

For me centaura is very hard to control in me(probably i had skill isue control it)meanwhile Entrenched is more easy and less laggy to so i more prefer for Entrenched but for grafic ofc centaura win

[@Imapanzer]

they are differnt, and they both are good :)

[@josefDALL]

i think its hard to rank two games when wether you like one over the other is heavily opinion based

[@snaillpro3004]

I wish i could play centaura, but its not allowed on my ps4, so i just play entrenched instead

[@guishenStreetB]

Entrenched gun play is literally better wdym

[@maurology]

For real, this guy who made the video had no idea what he’s talking about