See How Maj.Arya sat on chair...straight...while Lt.Gen.Shukla is casual... This is what Indian Army teach. Senior Junior... Work Ethics. Love and Respect 💓
@jasha9sandhuАй бұрын
" valour has its limits. Its need to be funded
@ghanvedsingh8946Ай бұрын
They are at different Loci
@sheetala2423Ай бұрын
@@ghanvedsingh8946no....they are not...look again.
@MrSprattersАй бұрын
I did comment on that to my wife....almost deferential...Sir...nice to see...
@rahulsinha623Ай бұрын
That's what army teach " decipline", the body posture of Major Gaurav Arya is just one should learn how to pay respect your senior.👍
@LetsExplore-om6nrАй бұрын
Service: Indian Army Unit: Regiment of Artillery Years of service: 1982 to 2022 What a man 🫡🇮🇳 Love from Arunachal Pradesh,, we need more podcast. Thank you. Jai Hind, Jai Bharat.
@soneysebastian829Ай бұрын
Finest brain that I have seen.....
@actualangel5133Ай бұрын
🫡🙏🙏
@lakhwindersinghlakhwinders2471Ай бұрын
Jai hind sir 🙏🏻
@GaneshGurung-p1wАй бұрын
Wrong
@GaneshGurung-p1wАй бұрын
Pl give details right
@manishdalviofficialАй бұрын
50 mins 33 seconds ke podcast mein itna seekha jitna shaayad duniya bhar ka newspaper 1 saal tak read karke bhi seekh nahi paate... and Major saab... Hats off... such intelligent questions... Bhai you are the best ❤❤❤
@Secret777-dАй бұрын
The way major arya sitting state front of gen shukla and say yes sir ( that is beauty of our indian army ) jai hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@ashishtode4484Ай бұрын
I must congratulate Major Gaurav sahab for getting such intellectuals for the show. It's an absolute privilege to get to hear Lt. Gen Shukla sir, his knowledge, his references, quotes foresight. Now understand why Gaurav bhai said let the intellectuals do the talking and we can try to absorb and imbibe what we can.
@alexanderotten9642Ай бұрын
Awsome podcast!!!Shalom from Israel
@thomasthomasphilp4393Ай бұрын
India sees its important that nations like Israel and Armenia must stand stronger against Islamism. Thus India is providing high tech weapons to Armenia. It was Israel who helped us to win Bangladesh war in 1971 and Kargil war against Pakistan.
@waffenhufАй бұрын
At a long run armenia is not indian ally , they'll oppose our actions in cyprus India and israel together run massive drug trafficking and cartels in cyprus to fund mossad and R&AW Its a well known fact even the dahara global the qatar spying case was also registered in cyprus And armenia alterted Italy about this company we can better ally georgia in the region , because a islamic iran is good for india but bad for israel so to maintain indo israel relations we need nations with no relation with iran@@thomasthomasphilp4393
@waffenhufАй бұрын
@@thomasthomasphilp4393how times you oppose islamic iran i condem them but its benifactor of india to counter USA in middle east and pakistan US had previoisly also sanctioned israel
@BITTERYETTRUEАй бұрын
What if Israeli support for India is severed?@@thomasthomasphilp4393
@shaankhaan1686Ай бұрын
India is an Ancient Civilization, nothing is new here even God, they have faced all these from I&lamic forces to Briti&h forces, From Chinese to Russians and What USA is playing all the Time is money and money...they build a sophesticated buissness all over world and when US hegemony is challenged they started betting at wrong horses now due to their buissness now their mates became the buissnessmen and now they don't want to fight....so today or tomorrow USA will back off and they have to fight their own war but there is a catch, in fear u can't do buissness and if ally will be in war u can either supply weapons or simply suck their money which u can't do now because allies of US will no longer paying US for security....then US will eventually fall , and between all the US society which looks glowing now will fade and once its done...either the world be at wor or the west will be enslaved and this is no long to come@@waffenhuf
@ankushzapАй бұрын
This is how our Defense Generals are. Happy minds with sharp wisdom!!
@alexsam73Ай бұрын
What a brilliant mind! I can listen to him for 10 hours straight, without blinking!
@jaivrat19 күн бұрын
Absolutely
@madhukarmurthi9064Ай бұрын
Thank god for Indian army, airforce, navy in this volatile world.
@sahilmehta2009Ай бұрын
We are sitting ducks with a 1.9% budget 😢
@DeepeshDivakaranmАй бұрын
This is the culture of Indian Army men. See how Major Gaurav Arya is respecting Lt General Raj Shukla although they both are retired officer. How he is responding to General by calling 'Sir'.
@rahulsinha623Ай бұрын
Look at body posture of Major Gaurav Arya that's one should learn.👍
@utubetruthtellerАй бұрын
this is called discipline
@Moulana69Ай бұрын
Love Major Gaurav Arya dedication, consistency and hardwork towards his KZbin channel ❤
@BlueStormySeasАй бұрын
He should have atleast 1 million subscribers!
@ummerayoub6168Ай бұрын
Shukla sir, salute... really genius and bird's eye on geopolitics......maza aa gya.
@rationalsanataniАй бұрын
Hope PMO is making notes from this conversation. Wonderful. Jai hind❤
@vaskaradhikary761Ай бұрын
Nomoskar Respected Sir Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla, Nomoskar Respected Sir Gaurav Arya.
@amitsureka9280Ай бұрын
Here's a redrafted version: "Outstanding interview! This is the first time I've ever commented on a KZbin podcast, but this one truly opened my eyes. Keep up the great work! I hope our DM takes notice of this conversation. Your guest was incredible."
@Priyavrat_BhardwajАй бұрын
Always great to hear Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla Sir on outer Geopolitics and Col. Ravi Shekhar Narayan Singh Sahab Ji on internal security threat. These two guys are great icons of modern times. Hope we'll have one podcast with Col. RSN Singh Sahab Ji soon.....
@FriendSanjayАй бұрын
Major Arya is a powerhouse of energy, effortlessly delivering podcasts that resonate deeply with the present and ignite our imaginations to foresee the future. On the other hand and without any doubt General Shukla is a boundless reservoir of wisdom in international relations. His ability to effortlessly unravel the intricate connections between the strategic aims of the USA, China, Israel, and Europe is nothing short of extraordinary. I've had the honor of knowing him since 1979, and he remains a living encyclopedia of current and strategic affairs. His only challenge is the limitation of having just 24 hours in a day. Hats off to Gaurav 🫡 and love you, Raj Sir ❤️
@kalyanbaron4614Ай бұрын
Major we need more podcasts from Gen.Raj Sukla. One hour podcast is not enough. Thank you for this amazing podcast.
@SuperSunny00007Ай бұрын
GAP will be a game changer . Miles to go Major. Keep pounding 🍷
@pritamadak820Ай бұрын
Finally a competent person hosting a podcast... Loved the intellectual conversation.. best wishes for many more to come ❤
@ronydias2257Ай бұрын
This discussion gave me chills
@ashwindaftary4561Ай бұрын
Lt.Gen.Raj Shukla is really brilliant... I hope the MOD and Finance Minister is listening to this podcast... Major Gaurav Arya, thank you .....
@BlueStormySeasАй бұрын
Came here to write that and you said it before I did, bro! Vande Mataram, Jai Bharat! 🙏🏻🇮🇳💕
@theeyesofindians4588Ай бұрын
Congratulations 🎉 sir FOR YOUR NEW GAP . JAIHIND 🇮🇳
@debkumarmukherjee756926 күн бұрын
Major, GENERAL SHUKLA'S TALK ON INDIAN ARMY, NATIONAL SECURITY, TECH INDUCTION , R&D HAD BEEN VERY VERY EDUCATIVE. I HOPE GOVT. IS LISTENING.
@seosea1569Ай бұрын
Jai Hind to Major Gaurav Arya Sir 🙏🚩🇮🇳💕🔱
@splashinventorАй бұрын
Woooww.. What an intellect Mr. Raj Shukla Sir is and he is an epitome of knowledge and intelligence. Its an honour, privilege and rare to watch and listen to him who is speaking raw facts, numbers, geo politics.. Worth watching.. I wish and hope to see that he becomes our country's defense advisor or defence minister. He has troves of knowledge even an IT person could not counter with and he is surely a geo-political think tank. I would like to see him establishing a lobby group which can shape our defence policies. One particular quote that shook me is "Valor has it limits".. Guys, focus on what they are discussing rather than how they behave and sit. Content is more important which is what we all need to grasp.
@neokineoАй бұрын
I am glad that you keenly heard the podcast. : I am absolutely also shocked with the array of revelation ,general saab opened up for all of us today. : AI certainly will have enormous applications coming out in few years with enormous surprises. : At a point general saab talked about drones giving reconscience to the artillary rocket batteries to Ukraine against Russia. And natively in the spectrum of star link (Elon Musk) internet. : Truly nervous technology.
@Agni_PuthraАй бұрын
Nice format Major Saab. Like this a lot.
@FullHD-ng2mgАй бұрын
General Shukla is one of the best defence analysts in India
@SanaatanSatyaHaiАй бұрын
This interview dispelled any doubts about the capability and strategy of our Indian Forces. The clarity of thought is remarkable-every minute deserves a rewatch. The explanations are simple yet profound, making it easy to grasp even complex ideas. As someone who enjoys geopolitics, this podcast is pure gold. Thank you, Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla, for every insightful moment.
@neokineoАй бұрын
Imagine, the span of sorting and studying the knowledge about AI , general saab would have did for long years. And the crux which he brought in a very tiny last 10 minutes about the abilities of AI in offence & defence. : Even major sir was subjected to clue less ness , that what to ask about it now.
@shreekaabbccАй бұрын
So true ….Salutes to both…Jai Hind
@neokineoАй бұрын
@@shreekaabbcc Jai Hind
@sunnyshukla9477Ай бұрын
The good Major's posture and demeanor are excellent. Ramrod straight back, nods and affirmations. Absolutely becoming of an officer in the presence of a Senior.
@HrithikSD436828 күн бұрын
Similar comments everywhere😬 Guys do comments about the podcast
@satya_vachan_mnАй бұрын
👏👏👏 Excellent Podcast. Usually I watch and like Major Arya's videos but don't comment. However, this one is such a good podcast that I felt the need to congratulate and thank Major Arya and Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla for covering a wide range of issues in less than one hour and with such good insights. Please do more such videos in future. Jai Hind 🙏
@suzie901Ай бұрын
One of the very rare smart 'Thinking General'.
@SSLAWHouseАй бұрын
I love the way how Gaurav Sir is giving respect to Shukla Sir. Dil Jeet Liya.
@bhayo8522Ай бұрын
Excellent discussion, Majorsahab! The more one hears Lt. Gen. Shukla, the more one wonders why is he not on board in the ongoing process of India's military modernization. He has such an abundance of insight and knowledge on critical technologies with which wars will be fought in the near future. At least, I have yet to come across as passionate and articulate general officer as Lt Gen. Shukla. I hope the MoD mandarins and the FM were watching this superb podcast.
@syedmahaboob2988Ай бұрын
Both are awesome. Their commitment very clear to save India. We have more genius and brave people in defense. Jai hind.
@sarthakgaind3276Ай бұрын
Congratulations sir for the podcast
@subhrajyotisahoo2853Ай бұрын
Congratulations Major Saab.
@techgaming4725Ай бұрын
NICE PODCAST. PLEASE INVITE AND DO A PODCAST WITH THE FOLLOWING----> -. COL RAJEEV BHARWAN -. NSG LUCKY BISHT .-COL KAUSHAL KASHYAP -.MAJ VIVEK JACOB -.COL SHIVENDRA KANWAR -. LT GEN SATISH DUA -.LT CDR BIJAY NAIR -.HON CAPT YOGENDRA YADAV. AND MANY MORE LIKE IF YOU AGREE.
@dkmohanty120Ай бұрын
Share kro pura india dekhena chahiye
@harrysingh560Ай бұрын
What a podcast, so informative and engaging. Loved it. Jai Hind 🫡
@angshumanbhattacharjee618127 күн бұрын
Listening to Lt Gen Raj Shukla is a rare privilege for us common people. It's an opportunity to gain invaluable knowledge and perspective. Thank you Major Gaurav sir for inviting Gen Shukla sir. Very rarely we come across such gems in Indian defence circles.
@aniketlimaye3432Ай бұрын
Congratulations Major Sir. A really good idea to have a podcast on the defense side of India. Excellent first guest as well. Jai Hind 🙏
@chaomaochowmeinАй бұрын
Salute to both sir 🫡
@rs-sn6hb29 күн бұрын
You're doing good work for people of Hindustan your knowledge guide us Major
@bikashrai568629 күн бұрын
Honestly i enjoyed and loved this conversation.... Im blown away with the knowledge of Lt.Gen Raj Shukla and enjoyed listening to him....I think you need to invite him agen and make a longer video... He seems to be so full of knowledge bout geopolitics and world affairs etc and also he speaks so clearly n wonderfully....Jai hind!!!
@satchaksАй бұрын
Undoubtedly the most awesome podcast/ video I've watched on The Chanakya Dialogues. Breadth & depth of learning was immense. I was compelled to replay the video over sections to get full import of the point Lieutenant General Raj Shukla was making. Well done Major Gaurav Arya👏🏻 Can we have another episode with this august & erudite gentleman soon, especially in the backdrop of the crisis in Bangladesh?
@skyman7420Ай бұрын
A true and useful Brain storming session vis a vis future Indian defence demands... enjoyed every second...need more such discussions... Thanks to both of you
@sundararajanramaswamy172Ай бұрын
Wishing your new venture a GREAT SUCCESS, Major
@cvsmoorthyАй бұрын
Amazing foresight amazing ideas. Salutes Lt. Gen Raj Shukla ji.
@kitoomehta8452Ай бұрын
What a beautiful podcast thx to both of you gentlemen.
@shrisundaram4622Ай бұрын
brilliant 1st GAP sir!good to see you now on Podcast mode! this is a huge hit if you start 1,2 pods per week!
@a2b1c1Ай бұрын
much needed podcast genre from gaurav ji . also add in-video timestamps . congratulations. jai maa bharathi ❤
@Chiragdave79Ай бұрын
Great conversation 👌 Amazing to see respect from MJ. Arya towards senior Lt. Gen
@invictusenigma9468Ай бұрын
Superb Thinking of General Saab A Scholar Warrior how lucidly he elaborates no warmongering no heated words superb understanding of geopolitics
@abhay.1238Ай бұрын
Thanks
@ananthakrishnan_subramanianАй бұрын
Wonderful Podcast... Superb research done, straight questions !! Love this ♥️
@gurdeepsingh1403Ай бұрын
Hats off Mejor, thanks a lot for explaining the critical issues in a very simple language.. Jai Hind sir
@dr.ANC0212Ай бұрын
Great Great Podcast LOVED THE thorough analysis on multiple topics Waiting for Dr. Abhijit Chavda on The CDP 🤩
@Dee_p_sa-kuАй бұрын
If China stops all boarder claims on India; and India China Russia join hands without being suspicious of each other, atleast this part of world may see long term peace. How and why needs answers by experts.
@user-cl5ix1hk6vАй бұрын
Read about Thucycides trap .. you will know why it is not possible in reality
@RadicalHindu156Ай бұрын
India should draw out a workable plan to pull china into its axis and pull it away from pakistan. And send missions to china to work on the plan also station them there until it’s achieved. Chink in the india’s defense armor is china. Russian help can be sought, they’ll be happy to help. There’s no civilizational war between India and china but there exists one between west and india and between India and the muslim civilization. India needs to curb growing muslim population india by any means. It’s by design.
@neokineoАй бұрын
India have Tibetans and there government in exile over here, a doubtful source of retaliation to china. : They won't make peace with us. Get it straight. + China know we have "Quarded " up with USA against them in seas.
@neokineoАй бұрын
@@user-cl5ix1hk6vI agree, just read about this theses right now as you said. What is seeming as seen now-a-days, if a dictorine comes into play, then wars seems inevitable, USA & China won't spend time on deployments anymore. Learning all about tense scenarios, I think china will hit GUAM...and things will blow up.
@prabhatsingh5129Ай бұрын
Excellent podcast 👍 Awesome questions, always a pleasure to hear such excellent personalities. Keep going sir.
@MadhuVMenon-nasskobar-maxxАй бұрын
That smirk, the upright posture, and the awe in Major Gaurav Arya's eyes say it all. The immense respect and thirst for knowledge he has for Lt. Gen. Shukla are truly admirable, and both Major Arya and we, the audience, have gained so much from this experience. There's nothing better than spending quality time with Major Arya's insightful and informative podcast. Congratulations, Sir, and best wishes for many more episodes to come! P.S. Apologies for the late response!
@korakatar7921Ай бұрын
I can listen to Gen saab all day . Fountain of knowledge. Such a pleasure
@crunchmonkeyАй бұрын
Absolute masterclass!
@nileshparab8135Ай бұрын
Please keep making such valuable podcasts.
@zootnetworkАй бұрын
Thoroughly enjoyed this intelligent conversation! Please bring him back again.. 🙏
@dontsupportrats4089Ай бұрын
"Peace is only achievable through overwhelming strength."
@vibhabhagat4613Ай бұрын
Very good podcast, waiting for more.
@Ankitrao77Ай бұрын
I must say what a conversation. Sir, please keep asking for some more time from Lt. Gen. Raj Shukla Sir every now and then in order to improve our defense understanding. Jay Hind 🫡
@sandeepkasar4176Ай бұрын
It's so joyful to listen to a beautiful mind. Absolutely bang on target.
@JHind110 күн бұрын
Loved this podcast Major sir. Lt. General Shukla sir is spot on. He is able to visualise the future. Now the defence is all about future not past/present. AI Warfare is the future. Thank you both.
@anantgautam2485Ай бұрын
Sir 55mins is very less with Raj Sir.We want a 2hour episode with him.He is a total tech genius(should be in the National Advisory committee too)
@DevendraKumarChakrapani26 күн бұрын
Lovely, LG shukla should be there in top command, .......really has no words for his understanding and bright thinking
@anishsuthar6466Ай бұрын
Best interview- I see world differently
@murlinswamy7361Ай бұрын
Exceptional is the word to describe Lt Gen Shukla’s knowledge, understanding and narration of his thoughts. Awesome Sir
Sir this was amazing👍🏻👌🏻 your such an inspiration sir 🙏🏻 whatever you do seems to be perfect 👌🏻 lots of love tou you sir .
@atulsinghpujara129Ай бұрын
thank you for starting these sort of podcasts sir now we can rely upon more insightful podcast about military stuffs
@amitsinghgusain4741Ай бұрын
Gen. Raj Shukla - Very effective communicator
@Putin_chachaАй бұрын
Best podcast I have ever heard. This shows how our indian army is capable. But lack of political leadership is harming the country. We have to go ahead as per sir raj Shukla thinkbase. Now time to speedup.
@saurabhsuryansh2673Ай бұрын
Thanks Shukla Sir for providing these kind of knowledge to Civilians like us
@skeptic4031Ай бұрын
What a phenomenal guest !! What a phenomenal first Podcast episode !! Bhai wah !! Mazaa aa gaya Major Sahab !! I predict you have a hit show on your hands !!! Well done boss !!!
@neokineoАй бұрын
Try to tally it to the content which is coming upon so called news channels across whole days and night. : I would literally buy a ticket for $50 to hear to this , if it comes that way even.
@izekrimwala4 күн бұрын
What a fantastic episode with a wonderful General Raj Shukla …. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
@bimijain5347Ай бұрын
Great Informative show.
@rajaninambiar6444Ай бұрын
Fantastic!!! Major Gaurav has such impeccable manners and style of his own and LT Raj Shukla seems so cool and comfortable . Really liked it 😊🫠🫠
@floracharles2709Ай бұрын
Congrats...Congrats...Congrats Sir!!! Very good insights.🫶😇 👋hello from Malaysia.😊
@rajneeshmathur6170Ай бұрын
Great stuff Major Arya .. My personal view . This is what abpeople at large might to hear rather than Pakistan rollercoster . Appreciate the podcast with respected Gen. Raj shukla.
@diliprajguru2208Ай бұрын
Thank you sir for bringing gen he is one of thinking gaints of India And really happy about his improved health
@digvijaya574424 күн бұрын
Gen Shukla is simply phenomenol. The podcast was simply amazing.
@sanjaimohan219927 күн бұрын
Salute to General. What a knowledge and clarity of thought.High level scholarly discussion.Defence expert par excellence.
@rohitmahanta9823Ай бұрын
Wonderful conversation 👍👍👍 Best of luck for next episode 🙏🙏
@MegaPankaj1993Ай бұрын
Kamaal ki GAP major sahb.. keep bringing out more for us. We all do support this great content. Absolutely loved it.
@rajkumarrana2313Ай бұрын
Wow wow wow 🎉🎉🎉🎉 super man of India......this sir should be inside cabinet or PMO with immediate effect. Well informed man Best
@E5330Ай бұрын
Such an informative podcast. Loved watching it in one go.
@SouravMoitra19Ай бұрын
I agree we are stuck in bureaucratic loop and decision is super slow, whereas our enemies are keeping us busy.
@Shaunak.2e30Ай бұрын
GAP🔥
@YoYo-qx9uo21 күн бұрын
Two of my fav military minds on a single screen,made my day
@iamghani29 күн бұрын
What is first thing that comes to your mind when you think about Indian army! -> Discipline Courage - valor - bravery and other things are nothing for a soldier when you don’t have discipline!
@mowiththeflow4446Ай бұрын
Amazing conversation! And what great depth in the conversation too! Great start to the podcasting journey Arya sir, good luck. My only one suggestion would be to focus on such quality speakers rather than focusing on churning out videos everyday. Jai Hind 🫡
@deepakdixit6073Ай бұрын
It was an amazing conversation. I truly applaud the foresight and insight of Gen Shukla. You may be the the most valorous fighters, and that is essential, but technology plays a huge role in wars and battles. Babar defeated Rana Sanga because he used cannons which were not used in India till then. Britishers were hugely aided by telegraph is 1857 which tremendously helped in logistics. We can give many more examples from around the world. Gen Shukla also talked about agility in innovation and manufacturing efficiency. If India or USA were to effectively contain China, they have to be more innovative and efficient in terms of cost, cycle times, and quality. I also agree with Gen Shukla about his assessment of the Trump doctrine of the US minding its own store first and about the needless expansion of NATO. I feel it was a brilliant conversation. May we get more of these conversations.
@arslangul6872Ай бұрын
The analyst is spot on. No chest thumping Pure facts. ❤