EVERGLOW (에버글로우) - Bon Bon Chocolat (FANS SINGING SINCE STAGE AUDIO CUT OUT)

[@Darcactusofficial]

The Forevers cheering tho. It must be giving Everglow the energy to perform well. One day I'll be in that crowd, one day.

[@chuue]

SM, YG, Pledis, and Cube Entertainment one day! The cheapest tickets there were actually $45 !!

[@ireneseyebrowsforlife3840]

bbyongs really??

[@ireneseyebrowsforlife3840]

bbyongs if l would’ve known l would’ve been there haha

[@ai.kimgaram]

$45 only? omg imma go to that concert cause i already saved a lot like $1000 for a vip ticket

[@emailrandy]

Yeah, u need to learn the lyrics cos they dont song live ever. Be prepare to sing for them.

[@lilhonni]

I like how when the korean parts came 4:15 the international fans were like “something something ennnaaaeee bon bon chocolat” 😂😂 but that was so cute

[@arigato3279]

😂😂😂

[@yangmaeumi7189]

yooo if i was there(sadly i wasn’t) i would do that too “something something” lol

[@luciaperez1832]

Ya 😅😂

[@vaffangool9196]

@@yangmaeumi7189 *I was there* and it felt like I was one of the few people that _didn't_ know the Korean lyrics. I'm glad this video is here to make me a little less embarrassed for shouting out made-up words.

[@yangmaeumi7189]

Vaff angool your so lucky you got to go!and you don’t have to be embarrassed that your didn’t know the korean lyrics..there are a lot of people that don’t know the korean parts of the songs(i’m definitely one of those people)...so don’t be embarrassed,at least you supported everglow and helped out with the “audio problem” 💜💕💚

[@mynx9178]

4:23 Lmao E:U face when Forever started the "nanana"

[@eminebolkan]

4:23 - 4:24 I can hear her laugh Lmao Like 'HahAHaH'

[@sudhashathiyamoorthy6695]

Cutieeee pie

[@loveheart935]

It’s a little embarrassing not gonna lie, but they handled it well and I’m glad Forevers still enjoyed the performance. Even if they don’t sing it live I do think they should at least have the mics on even if it’s set to really low just in case incidents like this happen in the future.

[@istantherightkings944]

They of course felt Embarassed, i would too honestly. I feel bad for them, imagine how humiliated they feel.

[@uwotm8]

i stan the right Kings worse things have happened and I'm sure they didn't lose any sleep over it. True pros expect the unexpected.

[@theeepidural6144]

i stan the right Kings tbh the fans know they can sing live and the girls know it too well at least a couple of them can sing live. Especially Mia and Sihyeon it’s good they have a break and let the back track do it’s thing

[@hyper3710]

THEY WERE SINGING IT LIVE BUT THEIR MICS WENT OUT AS WELL

[@uwotm8]

Quentron Ozmero. They weren't, watch from 0:55 and Sihyeon stops singing halfway through her line but the singing continues.

[@sparriax3379]

I remember someone commented in the M/V about a misheard lyric: “everyday, everyday, you go to Walmart everyday” and I can’t unhear it anymore

[@marzipan24]

Where?

[@barneyrene4187]

WTF I CANT STOP HEARING THAT ANYMORE KSKSKSKS

[@rayart3507]

Literally the first time I was listening to bon bon Chocolat I just heard "Everyday everyday you go Walmart everyday" 😂

[@rayart3507]

Literally the first time I was listening to bon bon Chocolat I just heard "Everyday everyday you go Walmart everyday" 😂

[@adabelortiz3981]

JAJAJAJAJAJAJA

[@chuue]

Hello, I was there! I just wanted to say they did sing in many songs. Even if the playback is overpowered, in a clip of mine when forevers start chanting you can hear Mia singing along. Although harder to hear in this video.

[@gemini3652]

Thank for saying this! I'm glad they were I don't want people to use this to hate on them again....

[@SHOSH2609]

bbyongs SAY IT LOUDER FOR HATERS IN THE BACK 😂

[@sophtheloaf4393]

@bbyongs who is your pfp??

[@chuue]

soph the sponge Solji from EXID! Me&You era.

[@ondapopmusic]

The uploader must pin this comment to let the haters know that they actually sing

[@urbantokyo4313]

YASSSSSSSS FOREVERS give them the LOVE they DESERVE 👏🏻😆

[@choi.san2006]

I'm the 666th like

[@galaxy_kitten95]

Seems like the girls received a little more love in Atlanta than Dallas. From videos I’ve seen, everyone in Dallas seemed dead to me. Like, you’re at a concert, aren’t you? But, here. Even with the audio issues, the fans supported the girls all the way through. I actually felt the energy! Forevers in the ATL, you guys did a fantastic job! 💜

[@kimhoang4484]

Gotta agree with you somewhat. I was at the Dallas concert and me and the girl next to me was screaming our lungs out yelling singing along etc, but lots of people were just recording the whole show. Like com on guys leave your phones down 😑😑

[@volvamp9752]

I was at the Dallas show too. There were a few people there who just sat in corners but I lost my voice.

[@kimhoang4484]

@@volvamp9752 haha yeah I definitely lost my voice after and my throat hurts so bad my co-workers wanted to quarantine me in case Corona virus but no guys just Everglow haha

[@chuue]

Thanks! We definitely had a lot of energy.

[@uncchristine99]

ATL was lit! The venue was small but we showed our love!

[@a23g23u23std]

it was quite obvious they weren't singing live... it was literally the original song playing 😂 i couldnt even hear their live vocals.... :[ but forevers and everglow seemed to be having a lot of.fun

[@istantherightkings944]

They were indeed lip syncing. Yue hua didn't even bother AT LEAST making it seem like they sung live, they just played the Studio ver.

[@a23g23u23std]

@@istantherightkings944 it's really sad.. i'd be somewhat disappointed if i paid money to go see them on tour, just to hear the literal original song playing. i agree, yuehua should have at least used prerecords or something

[@Christina-uo3xn]

@@istantherightkings944 I don't think it's Yuehua's fault. Maybe they just don't feel ready to sing live. Compared to other groups their vocals are still a little bit weak. They're doing very great for rookies, I think they just need a bit time😁

[@istantherightkings944]

@@Christina-uo3xn as much i love everglow, i' not spending so much money To just Come and see them lip sync to an audio That Is Obviously The original.

[@SHOSH2609]

a23g23u23std SINGING LIVE OR NOT.....ITS NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS.....GO FOCUS ON YOUR FAVS INSTEAD OF DRAGGING EVERGLOW....LETERALLY EVERY KPOP IDOL SOLO OR GROUP LIP SYNC SO ..NOTHING NEW....😒

[@katherinejuarezvalencia3287]

All those people who were "disappointed" because everglow didn´t sing live don´t have an idea of how the world works and believe that they are the ones who decide when to sing or not, IT IS THEIR COMPANY. You also don't have an idea of what it is to sing and dance live, most idols do lip sync in their presentations and it isn´t a bad thing, they focus more on their choreography and the quality of the dance, stop demanding things that arent in their hands.

[@pinkpink-kb6dl]

We can still be disappointed while not blaming the girls. I dont blame the girls at all.

[@jchsheishfjsk5052]

Louder for the people at the back

[@0lala020]

*quality of dance and performance. But you are 100% right. There's a reason why one of the most known clips from a boy group I like (SECHSKIES) is of the leader (Eun Jiwon) ripping off his headset in the middle of lip syncing his verse.

[@0lala020]

@@scarlett6977 If the company tells you to lip sync then you lip sync. Especially if your contract is on the stricter and tight side. To some people having a company that may sometimes have you lip sync isn't a big enough deal breaker to try to leave before the contract expiration date AND risk paying a heavy fine while being indebted to the company. Also I must point out that Mamamoo is a vocal based group and not a performance based group so they definitely should be singing. But a group like Black pink, who's a performing based group-if they had a different company would end up lip syncing. I have seen events of performing/dance based K-pop group lip sync to their songs when they were not given any mics.

[@0lala020]

@@scarlett6977 Idols are not singers first then performers. If they were singers first than they would be vocalists/singers. But they're idols. Being an idol is more than just singing, dancing and/or rapping. There are idols out there who literally got into their companies from their ACTING skills, MCing skills, Modeling skills, Songwriting skills, composing skills or simply because of their personality and energy. Idols aren't just limited to one thing (singing) and that's the beauty of Korean idols. I know another idol country is similar with it not just being about singing. In a country like Japan the purpose of their idols is to connect to the audience. Singing, dancing and rapping talent is second to connecting with the audience and giving a good performance. Their system is based on the connections idols have with their fans. They make a profit off of that sort of relationship. (K-pop kind of has this too but it's not as emphasized as J-pop) I don't know about VietPop, MandoPop, Cantopop, Thaipop or Qpop idol system well enough but I wouldn't be surprised if the focus is also NOT on singing, dancing and rapping talent. Also, thinking of idols JUST as singers completely ignores rap based groups like BTS (literally formed around the leader RM who is a rapper), Seo Taiji & The boys or idol rap soloists like E'Dawn, HyunA, Zico, etc. It also completely ignores dance based groups like Miss A and After School. (Yea I can't think of more modern examples sorry listening to more indie music/just listening to older people at this point.) I've been listening to idol music for well over a decade now. It used to be worse than this if my memory was correct it was common for companies to just have idols lip sync a lot. If you're coming into idol K-pop expecting everyone to be these fantastic singers with all the groups having a focus on singing than I'm sorry but I think you have the wrong genre. You may need to listen to Korean indie pop music, Korean R&B, Korean Trot, Korean indie or something.

[@kyujinz]

The girl that screamed ONDAAAA at 1:59 is my spirit animal

[@lifeofkiki3953]

It’s actually kinda sad & disappointing that they didn’t sing live

[@haeri6588]

Yeah, although it is a decision from their company.

[@linhttm58]

Ikr ? Especially it's their own tour ! They surely *can* sing live but the company didn't let them for some reasons

[@IrishGirlBragh]

@@linhttm58 Wait the company doesn't let them sing... what th point in that?

[@lunarqi]

LifeOfKiki at least they could focus more on their dancing

[@antant25]

In Korean music culture live singing is very uncommon tog o with choreography unless you/your group is known. For vcals

[@ondapopmusic]

4:01 How much power does your fandom have FOR•EVER: Yes

[@amani4025]

4:22 Autoton : ....... Forevers : Imm end this man's whole career !

[@MiamiCali706]

Thank you Atlanta for cheering them on when the music cut off. That was amazing.

[@notyourdaddy2148]

love that Onda, Sihyeon, and Yiren didn't stop at all and kept dancing and smiling after the audio cut out :)

[@StarK1d23]

That’s always cool to see fans sing when the audio cuts out mid song. Atlanta showing EVERGLOW love!!!

[@elenamalie8563]

Its weird seeing them perform bon bon chocolat in good outfits lmao They killed it!

[@thereverbed4119]

😹😹😹😭💀💀💀

[@sarahcheng1238]

You guys did a great job👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@thuhatran6690]

Power of fanchant

[@jaybeeprosser9013]

The fact that they still obliged the fans that kept singing and they still danced a little bit was awesome. ♥️

[@flowershower3525]

Forevers from Atlanta you guys did a great job ❤

[@sourlily4230]

Sad how the microphones were just for show :( I love how the fans continued the song though and even mimicked the instrumental parts LOL

[@MoMosMoment2345]

I don't actually see anything wrong in lip syncing but we can see clearly here that the mics were not working properly so even if they were singing we wouldn't hear cos the mics were not working........... And moreover ,Forevers are not complaining about their lip syncing.....

[@its_arisely]

TXT is a crown I'll run away with if it’s a stage show or something then I think lip syncing if fine but at their own concert? Absolutely not. There’s no reason for them not to sing live

[@alocasean]

Arisely well whatever that reason is, only the company knows

[@its_arisely]

-A ok? But there’s still no reason

[@Rhal928]

You don't need good mics if you're lipsinging so i don't think it was the mics problem lol

[@doiepop]

@@its_arisely I mean I agree, but most of the song is autotuned and it's the company's choice if they sing live or not.

[@kileylara3682]

E:U face when they started singing the nanananas was so cute🥺

[@timetotimm]

much respect to the crowd in atlanta and props to EVERGLOW to continue dancing even after the audio cut out.

[@Hana-vh1om]

4:30 the crowd singing brought a smile to my face. The crowd be lit doe

[@minimochi2206]

*Yeah... That blows that they aren't singing live but maybe there's reason for it. I agree that their mics should always be on regardless in case of incidents like these, so they can communicate with their people and/or the fans.* *At least the fans tried helping them sing towards the end and showed them all their love and support...Even if they didn't know all the Korean words. Lol at least they tried!! Now those are true fans!!!*

[@shookie6926]

People say it’s was the company choice. The fans tho! True fans right there

[@ElGatodelasWeeeklyKpop]

Jajaja que hermoso momento!! 😍💗🐈

[@doraemon1443]

I just came here after watching in your channel...😇

[@taasnimzaman5622]

@@doraemon1443 me too

[@Zipzapzooo]

Wassup

[@Emy-tq1wl]

The company should've let them sing live tho, I hope in their future tours, they'll be singing live and that I could be in the crowd cheering for them!!!!

[@MMDAnimator2004]

This just shows forever are real ones. They help everglow even when stage audio cuts out

[@baemonlover7820]

Why so many people obessed with everglow sing live or not. It is Everglows' concert. They have to dance powerfully every songs. Why you guys act like only Everglow lipsync in kpop industry? The background vocal is so loud so we can't hear the actual voice. Everglow is talented and loved by many people. Stop hating.

[@emailrandy]

Now most talented kpop group sing lives plus dancing, even during local performances in Korea. To protect their voices? what a joke. Its a US tour. R they saving their vocals so they can perform live when touring in Mars?

[@chifuyuberet]

@@emailrandy Dude, stop commenting the same thing on all these comments. You're really pressed over what thousands of K-Pop groups have done and still are doing. I didn't know lipsyncing was such a God awful thing that you have to go out of your way and insult these girls. Please provide all videos of all K-Pop groups from 1989 to 2020, and show me whether or not they all sing live and dance at the same time for EVERY performance, specifically tours. Thank you. Get a life.

[@tasnimirdina5499]

@@emailrandy stfu

[@TalonNeverDie]

This clip is pure gold... Everybody should see this Everglow comeback

[@amani4025]

4:16 Eunji "Mia" was singing with Forevers 😭💙

[@Kimnojam]

lol Yiren and Mia 1:10

[@ariaf7666]

Which one is yiren

[@Kimnojam]

@@ariaf7666 2nd from right side wearing sleeveless shirt

[@ariaf7666]

Thanks i know 4 of 6 members

[@ragingphoinix9144]

So they couldn't actually sing live? I mean...that would have actually been epic.

[@ragingphoinix9144]

@@Lala-ij1df And they have. They did it on countdown.

[@hazelnuts]

They can sing live but it is theire company's decision on how they should perform live.

[@user-nd5lg2rj2j]

i mean this is an incredibly demanding song

[@Hikarahime]

stupidhead Agree, I don’t doubt their ability to sing live. I would rather they put everything into dance for this song though. Most of the song is auto tuned and it’s basically a dance song.

[@yohanchu]

Its actually dumb to think that they would sing. Its a concert like u think they sing all of those songs live

[@amani4025]

4:23 EU's face 😂😂😂

[@denislambert6728]

Thank you for sharing this amazing fancam of our young queens

[@runlove4780]

they should be more responsible with those teams, that's impossible.

[@mediverge]

4:24 E:US FACE OMG ITS SO CUTEE SHE WAS SHOOK FOREVERS DID THE NANANANAN

[@Laychims]

I must say. Everglow handled that VERY well.

[@jamisonmoss8609]

I’m glad I got to go and see them perform live!!. It was my first K-Pop Concert and I wanted their concert to be my first because Everglow debuted around the time I was really getting into K-Pop. So happy to be a Forever!! This moment was really embarrassing for them but I am so glad that everyone in Atlanta including myself started to sing so they would keep dancing. Unfortunately the audio went out multiple times that night but it was still an amazing Event. I ended up buying a Hoodie ay the Concert and even met them in person. It truly was a night to remember. Everglow is by far my favorite group and I will continue to support them in any way that I can and I hope that I can see them at another concert in the future

[@lisadinahson2002]

I remember when I said they haven’t been singing live so far in their tours and I got attacked. It’s nothing embarrassing about it they’re still rookies and probably they were told to.

[@RoseAllDayyy]

Yes Atlanta Forevers for giving them all the love! 💕🙌🏻

[@pickles4801]

all of y’all saying “oh they don’t sing live,,, awkward....” like ALL of y’alls faves haven’t used a back up track before 😳

[@jcflores2696]

pickles ༄ no one denying that lmao. It just sucks that people have to pay so much money to not even hear their idols sing live. I understand lip syncing on music shows since those are purely for promotions but concerts are different. In ALL of the kpop concerts ive been to (even itzy who are also rookies like everglow) , they were all singing live. At the end of the day, no one is blaming the girls bc all the decisions are decided by the company. It just sucks for the people who spent their hard earned money

[@pickles4801]

JC Flores i’m referring to the comments that ARE bashing the girls directly and not realizing the company makes that decision. there’s ppl that aren’t upset bc it’s a concert and wanted to hear them live they’re just bashing them and saying they have bad vocals and are inferior to other groups 😌

[@KLeeFMVs]

Thing is, this wasn't just a "backing track", it was literally the original song. Their mics weren't even on.... at all. Not saying it's ok to bash them, but let's just call a spade a spade.

[@pickles4801]

@@KLeeFMVs thats what i mean to call it lol I know they're lip-synching

[@KLeeFMVs]

@@pickles4801 Never said you didn't 😊

[@ShadenELF]

I'm so proud😭

[@julesfoury9240]

* music stops * Everglow : oh shit here we go again Forever : let's continue * start singing * Everglow : okay let's continue * being professional and dancing like nothing happened * love them, they're so cool they continued to dance with fans singing, so lovely ❤! Forever being better song player than the music 😂

[@stepyourkittyup1646]

Oh my god it's like Mean Girls! This is so awesome, they must not know about US fans lmaoooooo

[@Apricitysings]

I'll be watching this everydayyyuy itssssssd sooo goodddd

[@phillip3945]

Just look how happy the girls are!! Smiling ear to ear. They definitely felt the love from the fans. Great job Atlanta!! #everglow

[@brunosilva5187]

i don´t see why people are surprised in seeing they werent sing live, almost all kpop groups linpsying in their tours and shows to protect their voices

[@intoarielverse]

No, most sing live over a backing track

[@ttechaiit]

@@gracefire9067 stfu

[@emailrandy]

Yeah, in the 80s. Now most talented kpop group sing lives plus dancing, even during local performances in Korea. To protect their voices? what a joke. Its a US tour. R they saving their vocals so they can perform live when touring in Mars?

[@oKimchiio]

@@emailrandy they did sing live tho for most of their other songs especially on music shows yall need to relax lmfaoooo why is lip-sying so bothersome for yall literlally NO ONE in the audience complained so shut it

[@gabrielfrquenz]

@@emailrandy You just don't know what singing is like, do you? It's not like a damn guitar where you can just replace your strings, you can't replace vocal chords, your instrument it's your body, if you don't take care of it you're hurting yourself, it's not a fucking joke, what the hell you're talking about? It's your health what's in risk. Can you understand how delicate it is? Also you don't know what was the reason behind it, singing and dancing it's not easy and I bet you can't do it. You think they are damn androids? They're humans like you, like me, like everybody here. Try to get their lives, you won't stand a week.

[@luzshopee12]

Everglow beautiful!!!!!!!!!

[@jennferley8854]

you gotta be honest. Their audience carried their performance and Everglow didn't really know how to handle it

[@praveenw.4393]

Jenn Ferley they are inexperienced . Hope this will give them some idea when they experience this kind of scenario again

[@Esth.1]

They're probably not trained for such a thing to happen, poor girls, they prepare for the show to go as great as possible T_T

[@monicadjuricich1717]

you can see on their faces that they love performing and they love their fan base, it just makes me smile so much

[@aisha6849]

0:27 NOW LOOK AT HOW E:U ATE THAT

[@Hikarahime]

Aisha ༄ She is my favorite dancer in Everglow for a reason 🔥

[@cherrijoong1765]

They looked so happy and appreciative of Forevers singing along. It was so cute!

[@shadiya-kq6cg]

I'm happy to be in this fandom their so supportive

[@amanatabdallah1688]

EVERGLOW FOREVER LETS GOOOO

[@yangmaeumi7189]

this is so cute!!! i would go and do that too but i wasn’t there(sadly)!Everglow is literally my favorite group and it makes me really happy that this happened because they deserve this kind of love! 💗 also this might just be my favorite moment in kpop

[@asmajanjua8169]

I love the way the fans were singing ❤❤

[@ataentertainment6332]

The stage crew really said. It’s karaoke night 😭🤣

[@justme-hs8ro]

U CAN SEE HOW HAPPY THE GIRLS R

[@litandrea1018]

Forever por siempre 😂😂 me siento orgullosa de mi fandom💜💜

[@dargelis6308]

X2 ellas son unas de las mejores merecen más Apollo

[@Jxnis_Janix]

@@dargelis6308 Es verdad

[@zacharikurbah6358]

They're singing along, I love it

[@julesfoury9240]

Fans love a lot everglow

[@Luna-pp4ch]

Forevers you did an amazing job

[@CN-qk8is]

エバグロって海外だとこんな小さい会場で公演してたんだ... 会場の人たちも外国駒なのにちゃんと歌詞覚えてるのさすが！

[@nobodyknows017]

4:00 is when it starts if anyone wanted to know

[@superbnary]

4:00 *THE MOST ICONIC THING THAT COULD HAPPENS IN MUSIC INDUSTRY*

[@draculena]

that’s so cute 🥺 despite the unfortunate situation, i hope everglow knows how much their fans love them

[@baykatz9116]

These girls are troopers! It’s not easy to come back after technical difficulties.

[@VivaLaVida_Loca]

This is iconic moment 😍

[@jisuskitty]

all of the screaming every second is a mood 😂

[@iMColdBlood]

I just want that opening dance break whenever EVERGLOW perform🔥

[@temitopeeleyinmi6154]

They handle it amazing if it was me I would be laughing in embarrassment and wouldnt even want to dance

[@arii.moon_]

4:22 Verdaderamente, ame esa parte 😔❤️

[@ondapopmusic]

I wish i was there singing with them as well

[@analyelena925]

My Queens are amazing .... US love everglow

[@vanillayunx.]

the intro was lokey so dope and its amazing how forevers tole care of that

[@faviourquiola5626]

That girl like...MIAAAA!!! Hahahaha she is all of us

[@HandmadeSolace]

That's a pro for ya 👍 (that's gotta be scary for a bunch of girls on stage in front of a crowd. They pulled through pretty well tho. It always helps to have support from the fans)

[@chchwey]

Everglow rock! I want to pick all the fans out there! you guys did a good job~

[@cosmious3807]

it was amazing how happy the audience and everglow was:( they’re so cute

[@CreepyYetBeautiful]

this is so precious

[@xingtrey1073]

The fans did a great job

[@sempornamari]

Whatever happen love Everglow !!!

[@arachinidpinky]

That was so amazing...

[@djrommybalibalita5747]

Amazing crowd ! Such an awesome stage that day!!!

[@heytay3400]

SO BEAUTIFUL

[@sofi32907]

Awww this is adorable

[@Emmanuel.14.12]

Great job forevers 💖

[@bayx3549]

Mia legit was irritated after the audio got cut for the second time!

[@Sofii.103]

no puedo dejar de ver este videoooooooo

[@amani4025]

That's so cute 😭💙💙💙💙

[@notmarissa4673]

I like how when onda sings everyone sings

[@pato-8450]

Quedaron shokeadas es que los fans siguieron muy bien la canción y ellas con la coreo

[@DJCASHMONEYK]

LMFAO YOU CAN HEAR ME AT 1:10 continuing with 잠들었던 im actually dead

[@user-cp3ls4ud5o]

I love them so much

[@missswag6109]

Que hermosas , ese es mi fandom . Forever de corazón

[@sofirios7773]

Their reaction to the nanana is gold