EVERY Register Note From Whitney & Mariah Analyzed By Opera Singer

Want a GUARANTEED react? Check out / lesagesinging
Lessons - lesage.simplyb...
Discord - for singing help and singing talk - / discord
Wish the video wasn't cut up like this? Adsense is the only way this channel can currently exist. If you're interested in supporting the channel, and having access to entirely unedited reaction videos, you can do so by clicking the "JOIN" button next to the subscribe button.

[@LesageSinging]

Who do you think is the better of the 2? I tried to be as extensive as possible. It may be the case that I didn't find all of Mariah's notes. That very fact is telling because her range is so absurd. I personally do not have a winner or a favorite. I find both singers use very interesting techniques.

[@user-bs9ct7li8n]

Whitney might be more rounded but Mariah has the range... My opinion is they both win

[@progresseniola1606]

They are both good. Both mostly their tones does it for me and I like Mariah musical choices very much

[@Undubbedriah]

Can you do a video about either Lisa Fischer or Vivian Reed? I just discovered them recently and OMG their vocals are unbelievable

[@Mommyyriah]

Well Whitney wins consistency for me But i prefer mariahs prime

[@tylermills4812]

Honestly comes down to preference. I prefer Mariah's strengths and her voice to Whitney's. That being said, I wouldn't bat an eye if anyone placed Whitney over her.

[@user-bs9ct7li8n]

Mariah has hit an F#2 one time it was haunting

[@whitneyhouston1122]

And a F2😊

[@witchesgirlautumn1894]

THAT LOW???!

[@LesageSinging]

May I ask where this is? I'm doing another video specifically covering their interesting approaches to low notes. I'd love to get it right!

[@whitneyhouston1122]

@@LesageSinging Ofccc!!! It’s in the My all 2014 video where she hit the F#2 in the black dress as well. I’m pretty sure you could find it in a vocal range video, lemme see if I can find it in a video and I’ll send it to u!

[@emildepadua7817]

​@@whitneyhouston1122F#2 but that's mostly air but funny she hits an F2 in Bliss without much air

[@sandhyanagarajan]

Both of them are absolutely incredible. Mariah has the range and agility while Whitney has a more developed head voice. I think they both win!

[@LesageSinging]

I am 100% with you here. We are so lucky to have these singers recorded.

[@PedroHenrique-zr6je]

It's funny how lambs act like Whitney wasn't one of the greatest examples when it comes to agility lol

[@Matt-su5fy]

reducing Whitney to her head voice is insane. Her head voice was more developed because her entire voice was more developed. Her placement alone should put her above of this comparison. Notice how her pitch is accurate 99% of the time.

[@shadowcArey]

@@Matt-su5fy Her pitch is not really that accurate. People are just less judgy about Whitney when it comes to voice because her style is more raw.

[@shadowcArey]

@@PedroHenrique-zr6je Whitney has incredible agility, but Mariah is just better/more prominent at it.

[@juanma5315]

Whitney and Mariah legends

[@jenpot25]

Winners in their own rights...

[@LesageSinging]

absolutely

[@chengreyes1876]

React to Michael Bolton and Mariah Carey duet We're not making love Anymore Live 1990, first appearance ever of Mariah on stage :>

[@zusman84]

Yess! Great choice.

[@ariauwo]

Omg yessss

[@Eddy6159]

The F5 Mariah did in I’ll be there was purposefully though? That’s exactly how she does it on the studio version.

[@Bigdrip840]

Whitney's crown jewel was her belt. People think it's her high note but that was not it! Whitney has many live videos nit sure why the maker didn't included!

[@LesageSinging]

There are a lot more videos that I'll have to check out it seems. :D

[@whateverLolitawantsLolitagets]

I simply love the voices of both ladies! Thanks for the video.

[@colombiacrack88]

Mariah for me but both are legends

[@LesageSinging]

Yeah its more just for fun. The both of them are treasures.

[@EarCandyPisces]

At 23:30, while she did move intentionally, it wasn't a mic technique. She was feeling the song out, and was "feeling" the mood. It went with the "vibe", and so the kind of posture she did came out naturally.

[@anthonystone8338]

Mariah for me. Ungodly vocals

[@SC_327x]

They’re both really really good, but Whitney was insane.

[@Suijiro99]

I see no reason why we cannot celebrate them both as the same time. Simply the greatest singers ❤️

[@ahmdzki341]

Mariah thinks sustaining notes is boring, not sustaining the f5s in the 'I'll be there' performance was a stylistic choice she didn't sustain the notes on the record either.

[@helloworld17778]

because her voice isnt meant for sustaining high notes LMAO she sure doesn't find sustaining B4s C5s boring 🫣

[@ahmdzki341]

@@helloworld17778 lt's not like she has never sustained belts anyway, she does it sparingly and i tend to agree with her.. long notes are boring.. 'mine again' is a good example of a Mariah song with lots of sustained high belts.

[@daydream10.18]

​@@helloworld17778 she could if she wanted to. But nodules make it pretty taxing on her voice so phrasing is much more ideal. Also, could we please stop acting like what she's doing is an easy thing? Literally phrasing high belts is MUCH HARDER than sustaining them. Having awful technique while phrasing high belts is like stabbing your vocal cords.

[@helloworld17778]

@@daydream10.18 we already know it's the nodules that stop her from going all out. i just find it hilarious that lambs always bring the "mariah finds sustaining notes boring" bs when obviously she doesn't find sustaining mid belts boring and WILL sustain them for a long time for absolutely no reason. she's just as showy as any other divas (as she should. show us all you have). stop pretending like oh every choice she makes is intentional and artistic. sometimes it's simply because her vocal condition does NOT allow her to sing how she wants to. sustaining and phrasing are different skills. most singers find one easy and struggle with the other. whitney is also the type of singer who can phrase high notes very well but can't sustain them for a long time because her voice is just not built for it.

[@daydream10.18]

@@helloworld17778 I mean, it is true to some extent because she has rarely done them in her prime. She only relies on mid belts nowadays because her upper isn't accessible as it used to so she does what she can do at the moment to entertain the fans.

[@TaylorLeRon95]

You need your do a reaction or analysis on En Vogue!

[@LesageSinging]

I haven't heard of that. I will add it to the list of things to check out though. Is that a group or a specific performance?

[@TaylorLeRon95]

@@LesageSinging they are a female singing group from the 90s! They have the best harmonies of any girl group in that era.

[@victorberbert]

They are great in their own ways. I think each one have diferent strenghts.

[@parkmarr4650]

Can we just appreciate the fact that we are all fortunate enough that we are born in this generation to hear these amazing vocalists. I mean, why with a versus?

[@maxmusterman7672]

Whitney plays in her own league

[@nobodycares775]

You should also react Celine Dion range

[@Rico-x2g]

Mariah is the queen of Music!

[@marianunez2442]

2:36 F#2

[@LesageSinging]

ty for pointing this out. I am going over their lows very specifically for another video. This helps.

[@benjaminwashington2087]

Not a F#2

[@marianunez2442]

@@benjaminwashington2087 What is it then?

[@3van3lm]

The way you went speechless during whitney😭😭😭

[@lehlohonolotsotetsi3191]

That's because Whitney is fantastic, but the truth is he has been speechless with Mariah as well he's just reacted to her more before most of these clips by Mariah he has reacted to. Both singers are incredible.

[@diorrboyyyy]

Ofc just like everybody is WORLDWIDE. other singers cant relate

[@EArmandE]

Whitney gave you chills so, I think she’s your fav of the two. 😊 mine too. 😂

[@LesageSinging]

I mean, I've had chills from Mariah as well. I simply haven't listened to Whitney that often. They are both amazing singers.

[@EArmandE]

@@LesageSinging you’ve got great taste, cutie. I recommend listening to some live performances of Coko (of SWV).

[@progresseniola1606]

Does anyone know the name of those performances where Whitney hit those F6s and G6s

[@whitneyhouston1122]

My name is not Susan live in 1990 of 1991 from the Im your baby tonight tour! She’s like in a pinkish blazer curly hair.

[@superninja6481]

@@whitneyhouston1122 the way u know every whitney and mariah performance even the obscure ones 🙌

[@whitneyhouston1122]

@@superninja6481 Tyyyyy! They’re both my favorite singers so I do as much research as I can and mimic everything they do since I was a kid!

[@superninja6481]

@@whitneyhouston1122 omg me too! and it's so nice seeing u everywhere haha 🥰

[@LesageSinging]

wow that's next level. I appreciate the dedication. That'll help me look into her more as well.

[@eriveltocosta4499]

Pls react to Cynthia erivo singing Alfie as tribute to dione wwarwick you'll be completely stunned

[@LesageSinging]

I love her. I'll write it down.

[@tectonicshiftfitness2586]

Does anyone know what song or performance that Whitney hit the E5 and Eb5?

[@danielabelenda4896]

He I believe live London 1985 I think

[@tectonicshiftfitness2586]

@@danielabelenda4896 thanks

[@jymmirachael4316]

Is Judy Garland a contralto? Cause you never hear her go above a B4/C5 for any real reason at all.

[@AbelinoBozarth-os5nf]

Mariah all day!

[@THEE.apples]

They snubbed Whitney in the hv section

[@daydream10.18]

Bruh, we all know she's incredible at HV. There's nothing left to prove.

[@THEE.apples]

@@daydream10.18 yea but those were just straight up bad clips

[@EarCandyPisces]

You mean head voice? Naw, he showed her best qualities, and it was EXCELLENT!

[@user-te6bi9xs6l]

E2 is mariahs lowest recorded

[@jamdawgutube]

Whitney is so versatile

[@diorrboyyyy]

over 30 genres😚

[@stefeuphoria6086]

Whitney all day everyday.

[@gillianomotoso328]

You made them look like same person. Lol

[@wbillswbills9276]

❤❤❤

[@amordimaampao6576]

I loved them both. But damn I choose Whitney Houston. She's the golden standard❤

[@gnelj7298]

That’s how I feel too

[@terrionyoung8778]

Can you react to Toni Braxton

[@bagashatta4715]

Are u really opera singer?

[@LesageSinging]

yep.

[@user-bs9ct7li8n]

Celine Dion has great lows as well

[@Undubbedriah]

Her lower register is the best out of the 3 singer imo

[@LesageSinging]

I have yet to listen to Celine's live recordings.

[@LesageSinging]

That would make sense given the very little I've heard from her recordings. That's definitely on the to do list.

[@petteremmartz]

U should react to demi lovato range

[@ceegarcia3399]

Neither compare to The Voice Barbra Streisand!

[@THEE.apples]

The Voice is Miss Whitney

[@jamdawgutube]

Whitney is the voice

[@diorrboyyyy]

Whitney > Barbra > Mariah. Whitney and Barbras use of dynamics is just unmatched

[@whateverLolitawantsLolitagets]

I love Barbra's voice, too. However, Barbra and Whitney are not to be compared. Whitney is The Voice, period.

[@issamoodissavibe]

all 3 mariah barbra whitney have been called the voice by many people lol its funny how nippians think that title belongs to whitney only when the other 2 were actually called like that by critics and nippy only by her fans 😹