Everything Wrong With Who Framed Roger Rabbit

[@CinemaSins]

Hey guys! This video is a re-upload because the original version of this episode was no longer viewable. We'll be posting these re-uploads every Saturday as well as every Thursday during our September vacation. There are still NEW sins videos every Tuesday, and new ones every Thursday after our September vacation.

[@1caaru5]

You know NOTHING

[@GGIOBLACK]

Noice

[@IamaPERSON]

The only reason they're not viewable is because Netflix decided to copyright that stuff.

[@sebastieno.1614]

I'm putting *56 sins* on this random invoncincnence.

[@smellyratboy]

Enjoy your holiday also 22 views 87 likes illuminati confirmed OMG

[@mamodokod]

Who framed roger rabbit holds a huge place in my heart. It's a cinematic masterpiece.

[@benning138]

97% on rotten tomatoes.

[@ahlethescout8404]

No one should disagree with you

[@a.g.ltopic7990]

It’s on Disney plus I also agree with you a lot it’s a nice movie I just never understood the plot haha

[@thewizardofcroagz394]

@Luna Lockheart you went to far, 1 sin ;-b

[@michellea221]

Ikt legandary

[@adiahaalexander9359]

5:26 "Movie tries to make me feel bad about the murder of a shoe" Me: Movie succeeds

[@TheGoldenDunsparce]

I used to have to skip that scene because it upset me so badly lol

[@ojmj1984]

I always found that scene heartbreaking.

[@SonicFan147]

That is a pretty horrific scene honestly... especially to kids watching, hearing it whimpering for help and such.

[@angelanimelover18]

Yes it used to be make cry I had to look away or put it on mute :/ lol

[@JJiMedia]

That was probably the most horrific cartoon scenes I saw as a kid. I still remember the expression of the shoe as it tried to escape and plea for mercy and all the muffled calls for help as it was lowered to the Dip. For me that was equivalent of someone just simply taking a pet and straight up murdering it in acid.

[@micahphilson]

You say it may not have aged well, but the level of work that went into this movie is almost unmatched, and he removed no sins for it! Seriously, to get this level of quality and detail from having to rework each individual frame of the movie several times is so above and beyond the call of duty that nobody today even thinks of options that would add that level of character.

[@alexatkin]

Exactly what I was thinking. I think they should struggle to better this even now, the only real difference is they would use modern tricks with lighting the animation, but even THAT they can't get right most of the time in CG Animation/real-life crossover movies TODAY. Too many shortcuts to save money.

[@nxtm4n]

I think it may have been done before they started removing sins at the end, but I'm not sure.

[@graciegj63]

@@alexatkin Too bad they never used Jittlovs ideas. All because he was a non union filmmaker. He did do short films for Disney in the 70's. He did the shadow demons in the movie Ghost. All by himself. The only thing he didn't do was the music.

[@StillJustDreaming]

"I'm not bad, I'm just drawn that way" 7:16 - Great line, regardless of what you think of the rest of the movie, I'd say that this line is still great today.

[@Alysa-Aiday]

Replace "drawn" with "raised", and you got me saying that damn line!!

[@recommendedforyou2936]

What is it supposed to mean

[@StillJustDreaming]

@@recommendedforyou2936 That it wasn't her fault that she acts the way that she does - the animators drew her a certain way so she acts that way. And yes, as someone else already mentioned, I suspect it was a take off on "raised that way"

[@recommendedforyou2936]

@@StillJustDreaming oh ok thanks I gotta see the whole movie

[@konstantinopoulos33]

It’s from the book, in a bit of a darker context

[@therosey144]

5:27- The scene where he puts the shoe in 'Dip', messed me up as a kid...

[@CharlestonChica]

It's like putting a puppy in acid.

[@FreeSpiritPaulette]

CharlestonChica holy $h¡t

[@denny2322]

This whole movie messed up my head as a kid

[@deuceman1335]

this movie probably made all creeps

[@nerdprjncessshortsandstrea7843]

Yes, me too. I actually had to stop watching. And it was good that I did, because the villain melting at the end would have given me nightmares.

[@MazeDaGr8]

I'm mad he didn't at least remove a sin for Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny being in the same scene. Which is one of the greatest moments in cartoon history.

[@Paulafan5]

No sins removed at all? I mean, it's an epic cross over with Mickey, Donald, Bugs and Daffy... And nothing of this scale had been done before (combining animation with live action on this scale).

[@RobertJRoman]

In concept it was great. In execution I thought that Mickey seemed too much like just a sidekick to Bugs. The truth is, the two characters don't really work as a team. I always imagined a better crossover scene. Bugs was a notorious crossdresser, right? (If only to fool Elmer.) Imagine him borrowing a dress from Minnie, and Mickey getting real freaked out about it...

[@mercyjinn]

@@RobertJRoman I remember how strict the rules were for getting Mickey and Bugs together. They had to have the exact same amount of screen time, importance and lines. I guess it was just easier to put them together at the same time.😊

[@RobertJRoman]

@@mercyjinn Yes, but that was primarily a Warner requirement because the movie was a Disney-owned production. Warner would not have objected to Bugs getting MORE screen time. And Disney likely could have been talked into a more memorable scene if it improved the entertainment value of the film.

[@mercyjinn]

@@RobertJRoman Good point but I think that these two iconic characters would overshadow Roger and Valiant. They're so loved that people would desire to see more of their interaction, but they are not important here, hence such a tiny scene.

[@BraxtonKovary]

Trying to include logic to the opening kitchen scene is down right hilarious.

[@FromJamestime]

DarkTyyp Music exactly!

[@ctpaja]

Everything that has happened in that scene is ''scripted'' by the in-movie director. It's a set, of course nothing is going to happen to Roger and the baby. Waste of sins.

[@KnakuanaRka]

DarkTyyp Music Then again, the toon characters are interacting with real objects, which being real, shouldn’t be acting “toony”.

[@automaticBRO]

REVIEW---THE MAN FROM U.N.C.L.E.

[@mads_in_zero]

K1naku5ana3R1ka Doesn't Rodger (when escaping from handcuffs) imply toons can break logic on even real world items "as long as it's funny"?

[@me2olive]

The "couldn't she just draw him again" sin is the toon equivalent of saying couldn't you just have another child to replace one that was murdered. Creating a new life doesn't somehow resurrect someone who died!

[@Ladyartemicia]

the book it was based off of I think had something to do with redrawing characters but they were really bad duplicate creations and couldn't survive long after the original was killed. I actually think thats a huge twist in the much darker book version lol

[@Dirtbag-Hyena]

@@Ladyartemicia Theres a BOOK!?!? 😲 The more you know🤔 That seems like one weird read.

[@HuntingViolets]

Who Censored Roger Rabbit?

[@JJiMedia]

@@Ladyartemicia If that's true, then what explains the "weird version" of Jessica Rabbit in Toon Town? Nah, I think they just overlooked that - and I'm overthinking it.

[@MamaMOB]

Except there's a big difference. No two human beings are alike. You can make billions of the exact same drawing.

[@youngsirzo]

5:00 "Goofy brought up on spy charges" 'Who Framed Roger Rabbit?' accidentally inspires Cars 2

[@Quartermaster323]

It was an Easter egg: Walt Disney was once suspected of being a nazi sympathizer

[@davidbethke5463]

​@@Quartermaster323, this film was so overloaded with Easter Eggs, I'm amazed they managed to squeeze a plot in there at all!😅

[@alicewilloughby4318]

2:10 - I'm not sure Who Framed Roger Rabbit really is for kids. My impression was that it's at adults and meant to parody the cartoons from our childhoods, which we might be feeling nostalgic for.

[@rockycuro7737]

No, the movie's for kids

[@snkybrki]

It's PG.

[@psicopato2460]

I don't think it should be for kids either, I mean, a guy is shot down in this movie, what's in "for kids" on that?

[@ThePlushProductionsTPP]

Well PG movies back then weren't all "kid friendly"

[@theblizzard8735]

I think it'd probably work as PG-13

[@monochromeintechnicolor5036]

The 'Booby Trap' pun should have removed a sin.

[@giggityking6505]

12:34 *Additional sin* ROAD ROLLA DA

[@lollipop96537]

XD 😂 Ikr

[@melodi2036]

@Teddy James in all of movie history ?

[@itzepikgaming7164]

666 likes your dead meat

[@thescreenslaver8520]

As Th3Birdman would say: Jermey sins something he likes cliche *DING*

[@mads_in_zero]

If Toon Town exists, then that means some areas just work on toon physics, thus is makes perfect sense to assume a set could be constructed out of toon materials, allowing for cartoon physics to be filmed by a real crew. Also, as Rodger later points out, toons can pretty much react to physics however they want "as long as its funny".

[@SCP_Wandsman13_13]

The problem for this guy is that he's sinning a cartoon for not being realistic.

[@mads_in_zero]

@@SCP_Wandsman13_13 You make a good point and two years later I'm not sure why I bothered.

[@SCP_Wandsman13_13]

@@mads_in_zero I was insulting Cinemasins.

[@thelazygamer2195]

@@SCP_Wandsman13_13 this comment has given me all of the headaches.

[@SteaksAndBourbon]

What heartless monster didn't feel bad about that shoe?

[@jp3813]

The filmmakers said that they made it into a shoe to avoid traumatizing children. They failed!

[@spindalis79]

The voice of that shoe is Yeardley Smith (Lisa Simpson).

[@tempolynnrealofficial]

spindalis79 I thought it was Bart Simpson?

[@brandonbedard916]

@@tempolynnrealofficial nancy cartwrit is bart

[@mackthewriter]

How the hell did Disney allow such, oh wait my bad its DISNEY! Bambi, Dumbo

[@Matthew-Anthony]

5:07 "A coarse corpse course, of course." That was a clever togue twister and he managed to pronounce it perfectly.

[@wendydabee]

Oh, yeah, Christopher Lloyd did such an amazing job as Judge Doom, the whole ending (but especially the steam roller) just freaked me out as a kid and still does to this day. So good, so creepy. :)

[@LadyOnikara]

Me too! Judge Doom scared me so much as a kid it was YEARS before I could watch this movie again.

[@scaleythedino49]

Agree he did a fantastic job :D

[@littlecolumbia22]

The part where his flattened body gets up and re-inflates is disturbing.

[@tonyacosta4574]

This was the first time seeing Christopher lloyd being a villain which was crazy for me seeing since he was always so friendly

[@OurFoundingLiars]

The only thing wrong with this movie, is that it’s labeled fiction. The now demolished toon town was real, and the government is covering it up. Keep asking questions.

[@NCMonefaith]

I was born there. I miss my home.

[@munjee2]

Why do you end every comment keep asking question it's very stale and unoriginal at this point

[@OurFoundingLiars]

Munjee Syed - it’s a condition, and that’s pretty rude of you to bring it up. Keep asking questions

[@RebSike]

they fucking killed Top-Cat right in front of me... THEY MADE ME WATCH AND NO ONE WILL LISTEN!!! just fucking blew him away. I remember toon town. I will always remember. We'll see who is crazy when Camelot falls.

[@amybrown1823]

Stay woke.

[@jonathanw1019]

I was 9 when I saw this in the theater and knew damn well who the hell Betty Boop was. Side fact: The voice actress who plays Boop came out of retirement to do the role. She also had a spot in Christmas Vacation as the great aunt who wraps her cat and starts singing the Star Spangled Banner at the end when the shitter blows up. Also, patty cake IS sex between humans and cartoons.

[@BarryHart-xo1oy]

Yes,l also knew who Betty Boop was when this movie came out.

[@davidwesley2525]

​@@BarryHart-xo1oyBetty Boop is My Favorite Cameo. 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@bonniehowell4259]

Who Framed Roger Rabbit was so ahead of its time.

[@dolphchu8482]

Yes it completely was because they made a movie called Looney Tunes back in Action which came out in 2003 which makes this movie look like a masterpiece

[@Paulafan5]

Groundbreaking film and he sinned the groundbreaking elements. Having a cross-over of characters like that wouldn't happen today. Daffy and Donald in the same film? Never again... and he sinned that scene.

[@LilChuunosuke]

Makes sense when you realize it was the highest budget film of its time.

[@ngoyette94]

Paulafan5 he didn’t sin daffy and Donald being in the same thing, he sinned the fact that a piano battle was the best thing they could think to do with a daffy and Donald cross over

[@Justin-Hill-1987]

Dolphchu Without Who Framed Rodger Rabbit, we would not have other movies that blend live action and animation, such as Rock-A-Doodle, Space Jam, Looney Tunes: Back in Action, or the SpongeBob SquarePants movies.

[@skittlecar1]

6:44 They bumped the lamp. That had to animate the shadow going across Roger. Amazing.

[@LukeyD88]

Seeing Doom get run over by the steam roller, scarred me for life.

[@maskedmutant6055]

"None of the knives hit Roger" Because someone yelled *"USE THE PLOT, ROGER!"* ....or "cartoon" logic...

[@cinemagraphic6324]

*"THAT'S not how the Force works!"*

[@BlackCover95]

Or because it’s literally staged and the producers don’t want to harm their actor.

[@userdetails1]

or unless they use the trick magicians use. no knives were actually thrown at roger they actually pop out of the other side of the wall to make it look as if they had been thrown at the wall

[@DhantExMachina]

If Monika says that i'll just agree

[@brodiero-solar302]

Monika subscribed.

[@CuracaoCow]

NO sins off for Jessica Rabbit??? Really??? She was responsible for the sexual awakening of half the world

[@ZimmFor3]

heroselene wdym?

[@genxrants]

And probably the start of cartoon fetishes.

[@Positivethinking2]

And scene totally includes lap dance

[@jakepullman4914]

He actually adds sins. The idea that a cartoon can be sexy offends him, which in context, is pretty racist.

[@Dirtbag-Hyena]

@Light and Dark So whos sexier?? Jessica or Holli Would from Cool World?? I know my choice & it has nothing to do with a rodent😋😁

[@MeAndI338]

Talking about classics, I really want to see Everything Wrong With Monty Python and the Holy Grail

[@PeanutTechno]

If he's going to sin the classics, he may as well sin Shakespeare... Everything Wrong with the 1999 film adaptation of A Midsummer Night's Dream

[@graciegj63]

@@PeanutTechno Yea, there's definitely things wrong with that movie.

[@PeanutTechno]

@Grace J I would know since I had to watch it 2 times for my theatre and acting classes recently.... Also if he does do Midsummer Night's Dream I want to see how long it takes until he gets frustrated about them speaking in ye olde butchered english (If he starts speaking in angrish or goes on a massive rant about it, I wouldn't blame him, they do that for the whole movie)

[@DJonScott]

Benny said "careful with that gun" because he was concerned about real people like Eddie getting shot. Also "drawn that way" has a double-meaning. Even if Jessica isn't literally drawn badly, she can still be drawn toward badness. "Not bad, just drawn that way." Get it?

[@lifewiththatonepreppy]

I took it as people made her out to be bad. They make it seem like she's a bad person, but she's not. She drawn out to be bad.

[@DJonScott]

@@lifewiththatonepreppy OK so it had a triple-meaning.

[@Alysa-Aiday]

@@DJonScott: Yikes. I hate people who have double standards. But *Triple* standards?!? I need a permanent nap

[@EngineerRiff]

Thanks, I would’ve never figured that out on my own

[@CommanderViviax]

I never got the Betty Boop thing. At the time and now, Betty Boop was and is still used. She was colourised. Even if it was just for items etc, and not on film. Surely she'd be colourised by then.

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

I think it's more that audiences still associate Betty Boop with the black-and-white era, similar to how we still associate the characters from _Toy Story_ with primitive 90s CGI despite the pristine photorealism of the third and fourth films - they're just iconic to a certain era.

[@davidwesley2525]

@@ARCtheCartoonMaster Betty Boop was in only one color cartoon Poor Cinderella filmed in the two strip cinecolor process during the Fleischer era. Every other Betty Boop cartoon is in Black & White.

[@BlondeCurlsBlueEyes]

@@ARCtheCartoonMaster In addition to this, her scene may have been intended as a nod towards the many real performers of the silent era who struggled to make the transition to "talkies", something that the film Singin' in the Rain explores in more detail. Also, wasn't Betty a redhead when she was colourised? They may have wanted to avoid having her compete with Jessica; Joanna Cassidy, who played Dolores, dyed her own natural red hair to brunette for the same reason.

[@davidwesley2525]

​@@BlondeCurlsBlueEyesBetty Boop's Hair was made Red to Show the Limited Color of Cinecolor. Walt Disney had Exclusive Rights to the 3 Strip Technicolor Process. Max Fleischer could only use the 2 Strip Cinecolor Process. To Show the Limited Color Betty's Hair was made Red. Betty Boop Dyed Her Hair RED for the Role of Poor Cinderella. 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 Betty's Natural Hair is Black. 😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁

[@mcrande]

Instead of being "That's racist" should it have been "That's toonist"?

[@Set2Seth]

*DING*

[@mcrande]

@@LucyAdroit 😀

[@kriszk]

That's racist is way funnier!

[@Emisop]

Saying "That's racist" is a joke now in this channel.

[@waters129]

Yeah but that wouldn't be as funny. They always say 'that's racist' even when it's sexist or whatever. That's the point.

[@Chaos89P]

I think that "acid" you mentioned is actually a concoction of paint thinners. Turpentine, acetone, and benzene. The "Dip" is freaking paint thinner!

[@thequietkid4887]

Wow, you’re right. But it shouldn’t work on humans, so why does Doom wear gloves when dipping the shoe? It could only mean he is a toon! Seriously, the shoe would be a smarter villain.

[@javierburgos7]

@@thequietkid4887 or maybe he just didn't want his arm to get filthy but dipping it in that goo thing...

[@itsdawheelchair2307]

Epic Mickey 3 confirmed!

[@martinpenwald94]

@@thequietkid4887 while the fact that he wears gloves should obviously be intended as a hint that he's a cartoon, I still think that the dip would cause at least a rash or some other kind of damage to the human skin, too.

[@XaxaTheRapper]

what a keen observation. hell yeah. that's got my brain moving about the functionality of this universe. what couldn't you do?

[@johnhammersmith7828]

Sin on you: you saying that bread needs to be refrigerated, you sad, sad, man.

[@alexg1778]

Yeah, refrigeration is not good for bread. Freezing then thawing is ok but you shouldn't refrigerate it.

[@eliasmoffat5510]

@@alexg1778 living on the coast, I absolutely need to refrigerate my bread if I ever want to finish it, especially in the summer. It goes moldy in a matter of days

[@kenhollis6197]

@@eliasmoffat5510 Living on an island, I can attest to that.

[@eliasmoffat5510]

@@nilgor70 in fact, I do refrigerate bread. I'm aware technically it makes it stale faster, but it still prevents mold and I don't notice a large enough difference to warrant stopping

[@LuznoLindo]

Still, who stores completely uncovered, in a stack, on top of a fridge?

[@gilgamess]

I've dug Cinema Sins for a lot of movies, however, there were a couple of weird ones here, such as why Benny the cab would be so worked up about the Brooklyn Dodgers, aka "Bums". As my Dad told me, the Dodgers moving out of NY was a BIG deal at the time. It made national news. The oven doesn't "shoot people out of it", Roger runs out of it. The director doesn't mention stars for the first time, he is merely referring to the script, which Roger keeps lousing up. We're just seeing take 24. You also complain that "Roger has no lines" in his cartoon to have messed them up. He has a LOT of lines. In the bits that you don't show, Roger rambles on about his family while the baby crawls around. Normally, you set up a nice smart-aleck world, but these and some other "sins" aren't sensible.

[@benning138]

Amen bro, just padding the sin count!

[@larrote6467]

I don't think the smart aleck talk has been present for a long time; from my perspective, the longer cinemasins has gone on the less research/pondering they do on the films, often being selective and contradictory. Small example: complaining that much about Doom going away, when he was clearly covering his eye and going to cover to fix his "tooness"; you don't need to think much about that to deduce it, the film is very explicit about it, you just need to have watched the film at least once. What I think they do now is just write down the first funny thing they think and run with it. I still watch some of the videos to catch funny observations, but most of them now are just dumb/half-assed observations.

[@randomnessltd]

@@larrote6467 CinemaSins has really degraded itself. Now it's just an annoying add-on to that which leaves us all off. You can't apply real-world logic to a cartoon world because it wouldn't be a cartoon.

[@FreeSpiritPaulette]

Morty Smith yuh

[@raritania7581]

The movie is set in 47 and the Dodgers moved in 56 though.

[@niftykoala]

-1 SIN. TUMBLEWEEDS. Roger Rabbit takes place in 1947. This is 2 years after WW2. LA/Hollywoodland is still surrounded by a lot of desert. As a matter of fact the Pacific Red Line in the movie, would actually take people to housing areas that are desert areas where many G.I.s lived after returning from the war. Guess what shrubbery died most often in those areas, and would be both blown and dragged in by trains and trolly.

[@aw8079]

The Big Lebowski has a tumbleweed in LA 1991, Sept. 11.

[@firerunner35624]

I was gonna say the same thing about 40's era Los Angeles. Except, that quite a bit of it was surrounded by orange groves.

[@bettyschneider5268]

niftykoala ...... 🐨 you must know your history? I don't know about 1947 because I was born in 1956 I guess I could have read about it! But I am from Maryland East Coast! 🇺🇸... Lol 😆 ...🐨🐨🐨🐨

[@kb470]

When Doom murders the shoe, without it ever committing, or being convicted of a crime, let alone one with capital punishment

[@kassard1]

Gameriffic that shoe continues to break my heart all these years later 😩

[@travissmith2848]

Yeah..... a judge is allowed to continue on who it is common knowledge he bought the election and executes toons on the spot for the crime of annoying him. Don't try to logic it too hard or you will be calling for judicial oversight committee member's heads.

[@dragonwings36]

It still upsets me so many years after seeing that poor shoe being murdered. Plus, its buddy is now all alone. :( That makes it much worse.

[@jaebee1121]

I'm with you, but my brother pointed out that the shoe was rubbing up against someone who obviously wasn't in to it, and we don't really know that much about shoe anatomy... Who knows what shoes get away with because they're so innocent looking with their puppy-dog eyes.

[@bonniehowell4259]

@@dragonwings36 That scene almost made this film a deal breaker for me as a kid.. I was so upset over that poor shoe.

[@DanielCollins85]

How I miss when you'd say "This scene does not contain a lap dance." - I even bought the shirt!

[@pisscvre69]

Should have happened when Jessica Rabbit shows up x,D

[@jaimereynolds258]

I used to watch this movie so much as a kid, that the VHS got worn out lol 🙂

[@benning138]

Same!

[@millerkarageanes1562]

It’s now on Disney plus

[@SomeSegafan]

Same

[@ShawnBettasso-rn9kk]

Me too I which it alots of time and I which it all the time and I seen it when I was little and it's my favorite movie from my childhood and it's a good movie but not funny about this movie and it's still a good movie but not funny about this movie and who agree with me about what I say

[@junimoony]

3:42 According to Cool World, yes but they will turn into a human after. They also say you shouldn't.

[@petersarubbi]

"Noids do not have sex with doodles!" - Frank Harris 😁

[@GGIOBLACK]

Jessica rabbit was my first love. Then Lola bunny. Now bowsette.... I have a problem.

[@Bad-nightmarefoxy_1987.]

I like Jessica rabbit and bowsette so u have a problem with that

[@TheNukaColaMan10]

Despacito 2 yes, you do

[@minnesotanice1094]

I remember thinking Lola was annoying as shit.

[@nosfonader8792]

Lola Bunny for me

[@AdamFord152]

Wait, have you noticed that Bowser has red eyes, but when he puts on that crown, his eyes turn BLUE!?!? CONSPIRACY! THE GOVERNMENT IS HIDING IT ALL!!!

[@peyn]

12:36 TERRIFIED me as a kid and was the reason i never wanted to watch this movie

[@MassLox]

Im glad it wasn't just me.

[@graciegj63]

I've already seen worse by the time I saw this movie. Anyone ever watch Watership Down?

[@aureliamartinez3493]

😯

[@GrigorKaza]

Can’t relate

[@daerdevvyl4314]

Grace J It was a great book, but the same guy wrote a weird and kind of boring book about dogs called “The Plague Dogs.”

[@WinklerVideo]

An hour and 45 minute movie has 145 sins! Would you look at that

[@mercyjinn]

I remember thinking that animation cell of Bugs and Mickey would be priceless but it turns out they painted each character on their own cells.

[@LuznoLindo]

Wow. Honestly, it makes sense from a technical standpoint. The guys at Disney painted Mickey's, while the guys at Warner painted Bugs's, and they brought them both to Williams when they were done.

[@mrmusickhimself]

This was the first movie I ever saw in a theater, in 1998 at the age of 4. I had the Roger Rabbit tent, Viewmaster gift set (complete with 3D red-eyed Doom wielding a buzzsaw in your face), the cryptic NES game -- all of it. It's one of those rare movies that get better with age, and becomes a completely different film upon rewatch for adults who once viewed it with more innocent eyes. Every aspect miraculously worked, including the score, hearing the "Valiant and Valiant" piece never fails to bring a tear to my eye. Plus Bob Hoskins remains a hero to short, stout guys like me, and deserved an Oscar nod for his performance considering he would later suffer hallucinations due to it.

[@dropkickmurphy4114]

Slight typo: Roger Rabbit was released in 1988, not 1998. :-)

[@kbitchkal8765]

Nothing IT'S ICONIC ❤

[@kbitchkal8765]

Oh 😂

[@kurag5198]

Having a few mistakes doesn’t mean it’s anything less than a masterpiece

[@ShaudaySmith]

Yeah, still can't watch that shoe scene. even in the safe distance of CinemaSins. That shit is too much for my heart to this day.

[@universe1225]

It was funny!

[@WakoDoodle]

Weird thing is, there are betty boop cartoons in colour. Very few but still they exist; so why is she in black and white? Is it a personality thing? An emotional thing? Is she like that because she feels old or worthless? If that's the case why aren't many cartoons like this? What about those that ran on low frames of animation back in the early days when animation is born? Are they handicapped because of it? Toon many questions!

[@Paulafan5]

Also, some Betty Boop shorts had "wardrobe malfunctions" the animators secretly put in. And there was one in Roger Rabbit that had to be taken out (when Doom spills Dip onto the road and the cartoon taxi crashes, there was a Sharon Stone moment with Jessica).

[@niftykoala]

They got the original voice actress, Mae Questel, for Betty Boop. Robert zemeckis wanted to portray her and many others in the most purest ,1974, form of how the characters were portrayed/known in the majority of their animations at that time.

[@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah]

@@niftykoala Did you mean the 1930’s bro? 1974 is pretty damn late for Betty Boop 💀💀

[@dianacarbonate]

I was 4.5 when my family went to see this in the theater and I was TRAUMATIZED. I think becoming a huge fan of the Back to the Future series is the only thing that stopped the Christopher Lloyd nightmares. Jesus. Still always kinda loved it tho!

[@juliam1090]

Same same same!

[@mccalderbros5647]

Alternative title: man who doesn’t understand cartoon logic tries to apply real life logic to a movie using cartoon logic

[@instantstupor]

Yeah, that's the issue. You can apply logic, but you have to apply the logic of the world of the movie. Cartoons co-exist with real life there, so both toon and Earth physics are valid. That whole section of the video fell *real* flat.

[@mccalderbros5647]

IanTH exactly

[@kenhollis6197]

Y'all are taking it far too seriously...

[@BullGator-kd6ge]

The same can be said for this entire video.

[@FreeSpiritPaulette]

This is a joke video it’s not meant to be taken seriously

[@jimmyguy428]

That's not an awl Rodger is cleaning his ears with, but a file. One sin removed for improper tool name!

[@AaronTheBlackDragon]

I haven´t seen this movie in ages. I should give it a look again and see if it still holds up the way I remember.

[@cjwrench07]

AaronTheBlackDragon It totally doesn’t. It one of those movies that you love as a kid, re-watch later, and see all the junk. Especially after you’ve watched this channel quite a bit, and start calling out sins in your head.

[@lordyamcha9742]

Doctor Cthulhu it totally fucking does.

[@Wilss]

It's still great.

[@aries9269]

I still find it amazing. I may be biased from nostalgia.

[@Adelaide_Transit]

The death scene of doctor doom is the reason why I see therapy.

[@TamamaCandyLover]

This is literally my favorite movie of all time and I found this hilarious. The animation was way ahead of it's time.

[@hoikatz]

I just watched this movie for the first time today, and as an artist, HOLY FUCK! The animation budget must’ve been high as HELL

[@mats7492]

amazing what you could get away with in an 80s kids movie

[@DefgirRZawa]

@ I know it's been 4 years, but... Watership down? Also a lot of anime got censored because it was "for kids".

I was surprised that my comment still existed because my account got terminated 2 and 3/4 years ago.@@DefgirRZawa

[@ejl423]

I'm still pissed off at you for saying it hasn't aged well when it has indeed aged remarkably.

[@bluebay1031]

I think he might've meant most people who didn't watch it in their childhood wouldn't go out of their way to watch it today. It's still relevant, but not exactly ageless

[@Parkent]

The movie takes place in the 30's and has aged remarkably well. The book it is based on is set in the 1980's... and hasn't...

[@Udontkno7]

Ikr? I'm 16, it's one of my favorites.

[@krazylucrezia]

I think he's referring to the subliminal adult jokes that are often sprinkled in kids' movies that they probably wouldn't get away with today.

[@Paulafan5]

There are CG films from 5 years ago that have aged horribly. This is classic, traditional animation combined with live action and it's pretty seemless. Also, why no sins removed? He removes a bunch of sins for Get Out for its direction, but the direction of this film is epic considering it was one of the first films to incorporate so much animated elements in a live action film.

[@air-headedaviator1805]

I know we say this often but, no sin off for major titles from competing businesses showing up in the same movie????

[@mxrceline__solo]

I watched this movie at about 6-7 years old, and it's still my favorite movie. Edit- Kids movie?! Hahahahaha. +3 sins.

[@juliam1090]

My dad took me and my brother to see this as kids thinking it was a kids movie. I was slightly traumatized but weird enough to enjoy it anyway.

[@mynameisnotthathardtospell8199]

My parents let me watch this when I was *really* young and it scarred me

[@PeterStollVideo]

I don't get how people think this didn't age well. It completely holds up to films released today in 2022. Many movies have tried to accomplish what this film achieved, and never came close.

[@kirkdarling4120]

A year even later than your comment...it still looks good.

[@dabunnyman9133]

Won't fault ya for expecting logic from cartoon characters. But I will disagree about folks not knowing who Betty Boop was when this film came out. She'd had a big revival in the 70s and was a popular licensed character at the time.

[@Anon24052]

da Bunnyman that still was 10 years before.

[@heatherreagan8078]

Ditto. Saw her in reruns all the time.

[@YouKnowImOnMyPeriodYah]

I wasn’t born until the 2000’s and even **I** knew who she was. I can’t remember if it was Great America or Disney but there was plenty of Betty Boop merch

[@mranimazing2190]

0:14 This is basically sinning the entire movie though, and yes, cartoon physics apply in the real world, if a cartoon is in anyway involved.

[@Paulafan5]

Did he constantly sin Wonder Woman for its physics?

[@ChainsGoldMask]

This movie is flawless....you’re ruining my childhood

[@bluebay1031]

It's not that serious

[@pleblord4339]

It's a childhood special and those are sacred

[@loganpatriquin9443]

If ChainsGoldMask's childhood was Who Framed Rodger Rabbit, I doubt they had a childhood. *ding*

[@bluebay1031]

@@pleblord4339 No they aren't.

[@retsaweman]

How can he ruin something that is already over? Or are you still a child, huh?

[@mickael9184]

what the HELL... my dad let me watch this movie all the time when i was like 6... i never realized all of these adult references.... It makes it like 10x better

[@lemerdeposteur]

I just clicked on this to say that there is NOTHING wrong with Who Framed Roger Rabbit. It’s a masterpiece of filmmaking.

[@remylebeau2785]

Thank you..lol

[@rydo728]

I think that in these kinds of movies, trying to find logic shouldn’t be a sin

[@zytrux1627]

How dare you to not delete a sin for the donald and daffy piano battle. That crossover is incredible

[@notsusan]

it's basically one of the greatest movie moments of all time just for existing.

[@GGIOBLACK]

Can we please get a tv sins of the flash. That show has a LOT of sins.

[@raphagafloresol7069]

Despacito 2 damn silent bob 😧

[@TenaciousJoe24]

This is so sad

[@Paulafan5]

It has a lot of cool elements, and then moments you see a mile away. "Don't stand so close to an open vortex, Jay... Too late". Or the fact Barry gets people killed. Plastique, Ronnie, Detective Thawne die because of him.

[@ratuse]

A FEW of your sins kinda missed the point.

[@heatherreagan8078]

I was born in the mid-80's but I knew who Betty Boop was. She was in re-runs for a long time. It was the Harvey reference I didn't get. Not until over 10 years ago when my dad rented Harvey from Blockbuster.

[@blagus3743]

Jeremy is a boomer.

[@SouthernGothicYT]

I feel like Cool World took the concept of this movie and just said "more sex"

[@Violet-Storm]

and more acid trip

[@blondbraid7986]

And way less coherent story

[@HerrDeutschBlood]

It had Ralph Bakshi involved. What were you expecting?

[@graciegj63]

Anything with Bakshi involved, you're going to get insane visuals and just straight up big lipped alligator moments all over the place. His lord of rings and wizards animations scared the you know what outta me as a child. Parents had no idea that not all cartoons were for children.

[@maxman1602]

Some Random Guy To be fair, the script he sold to the studio was thrown in the trash as soon as he left the office and a new script, only vaguely resembling his ideas, was written, with even Kim Basinger getting involved in the rewrites at one point.

[@speedingatheist]

This movie was never a movie for children. 10 sins for CinemaSins. No appeal possible.

[@asherdevin]

But it's a children's movie, and rated as a children's movie? And I watched it as a child, as did most of the comment section it appears.

[@MagnificantSasquatch]

I watched Friday the 13th films as a kid. Your argument is launched into space.

[@mitrooper]

It was the 1980's, if it was released today in 2018 in it's original form, people would go bonkers on social media and the film would be taken out of theaters.

[@speedingatheist]

+mitrooper Yep, because retarded feminists denounce the existence of women like Jessica Rabbit. Internalized misogyny and shit... ;)

[@bonniehowell4259]

It was marketed as a film for kids. Rodger Rabbit was all over MGM studios when this film was popular.

[@peterfrank3365]

As a Tom & Jerry fan, I'm still bummed that they were cut from this film.

[@zaccaryvega]

At least Droopy made the cut. I would have loved to see Screwy Squirrel, George and Junior, The Wolf and Red, or some other MGM cartoon characters in this film. But we just have to make do with what we have.

[@melaniehoyle5483]

Tom and Jerry were from silent cartoon days so they might not have been added because they would've been expected to talk, however I did see at the end when all the toons rushed into the room to celebrate Spike was there.

[@greenekj6]

The Goofy cartoon Eddie and Roger watch didn't even exist in 1947.

[@bloodood406]

The filmmakers were aware of this, but they used it anyways because they thought it was the closest to Goofy's classic comedy.

[@17moonbeams]

Mary Poppins Penguins shouldn't be in 1947 since Mary Poppins came out in 1964. But then Mary Poppins is set in 1910. 🎵

[@catchifyoucan232]

THIS is a good sin to bring up as opposed to the crappy SIns littered throughout this video.

[@jcharmaine1]

Whats the name of the cartoon?

[@greenekj6]

@@jcharmaine1 Goofy's Gymnastics

[@fulcrum7493]

"it has NOT aged well" lies

[@ignaciocue]

Too right, you are.

[@scaleythedino49]

Yeah

[@lugi5215]

the video or the movie?

[@thebadfella5296]

@@lugi5215 cinemasins said that the movie didn't age well. cinemasins is wrong.

[@Rangerays]

Oh Jessica rabbit, my first crush

[@davidwesley2525]

My Biggest crush is BETTY BOOP.🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

[@parallax2107]

CinemaSins Guy doesn't know an awl from a file.....*DING* :-P

[@jorisweyen7934]

Should get a sin off for the amazing work put into making the toons interact with all those live objects.

[@evstar14]

2:29 OMG i literally did forget to take my tablet IRL, thanks Cinema Sins

[@FreeSpiritPaulette]

I understand that these videos are jokes and are not meant to be taken seriously, but a large number of these “sins” aren’t even sins, and it was missing more of the smart alecky comedy aspect.

[@chriswinkler284]

I agree. Normally, I really dig Cinema Sins, but this one was just BS from start to finish :P

[@shelbylarson2112]

Are we just going to ignore that Cinema sins refrigerates his bread? 1:02

[@dashdbz1]

Came looking for this comment. Who refrigerates bread lol

[@Abyzz_Knight]

1:00 Said unstored, unrefrigerated so this video isn't some confirmation that they refrigerate bread, they could just store it also storing bread in the fridge not something that is weird or uncommon.

[@polkadotpink5175]

@@dashdbz1 my family...

[@MrJoshcc600]

It goes moldy faster in the fridge

[@pibb2474]

Josh Cc600 That is a falsehood. Mold requires a warm environment to flourish. Refrigerating your bread actually keeps mold-free for longer. The downsize, as some may view, is harder bread, but I feel the trade-off is worth it.

[@ThatCoalSoul]

3:57 Scene contains a lapdance! SCENE CONTAINS A LAPDANCE!!!!!!

[@GiantParfait]

Yes. This was my favorite movie growing up. Jessica was one of my childhood crushes. The combination of 2d and real world was amazing for its time. 😍

[@metriod64]

8:45 Bob was really animated for that part

[@macbruno357]

" A coarse corpse course, of course." Greatness!

[@bonniehowell4259]

I cried when that shoe got murdered when I first saw this.

[@lachlandoig763]

This video would be a lot shorter if there weren't all the sins about cartoon physics. Umbrella sin if you must but don't just sin every instance of it. Also PG actually meant Parental Guidance, that meant something back then rather than just being slightly more intense G. It's equivalent to M/PG13.

[@travissmith2848]

Point of fact, PG-13 was introduced just four years previous in response to Temple of Doom. So it took a guy's beating heart being magiced out of his body and bursting into flame as the guy was lowered into lava combined with a murderous cult with brain wash juice and effectively child slavery to make people say "Yeah, it may not be R but we need something stronger than PG." And the nightmare fuel that was The Black Cauldron was PG as was the '86 animated Transformers movie where Prime was shot and killed on screen. Even when intended for kids 80's PG could contain some serious scar you for life material.

[@eliascrooker7773]

Lachlan Doig Don't tell him how to run his channel. Travis Smith The Black Cauldron is NOT nightmare fuel.

[@travissmith2848]

Elias Crooker You sure about that? The movie is famous for the controversy over just how dark and graphic it was.

[@eliascrooker7773]

Travis Smith You are mistaken.

[@olleselin]

R

[@Spleknik]

I'm not sure this was technically for kids was it? I think it was just a normal noir style film but with the added pleasure of cartoons. also I love all of these videos. Great job!!

[@breederspinner3018]

I think it's based off a book.

[@silhouettoofaman2935]

Not to mention PG meant something completely different back then. It wasn't like it is now, basically a G movie with a little more violence. Back then, PG literally meant "parental guidance."

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

@@silhouettoofaman2935 Man, if only they said it at the start of TV shows like they do in Australia. Then everyone would get it.

[@stiiffyrabbit]

'"I'm not bad - I'm just drawn that way!" No sins off - no justice.

[@shelbylynnbx]

the betty boop comment, about her being not colorized but later on mickey was, was something i always wondered about. but still it makes sense at the same time

[@howlouttonight]

7:04 But Roger explained that "You mean you coulda done that at any time?!" "Not at any time. Only when it was funny"

[@PHNX-bv5qs]

I thought you would've at least take a few sins off for the amazing visual effects. Sure they're WAY outdated by today's standards, but I think it's still pretty good even today.

[@alexatkin]

Honestly, a lot of modern effects are still flawed. They still can't seem to get the lighting right half the time despite tons of technology devoted to it. This stands up WAY better than a lot of attempts since to mix animation (especially CG) with live-action.

[@xuselium]

OMG! I Love this movie, anybody else agree?

[@warreng675]

Yeah i thought he would of, took a couple of sins off

[@aliyahr2701]

Me too

[@MzCherryDove]

One of the things I LERV about CS, is that they cheerfully skewer movies they themselves LOVE...

[@xaviergriffith3417]

Buddy i love yhis movie

[@jairusespana1356]

Lol this guy is spoiler boo

[@TUM_Toons]

Title: Everything Wrong With Who Framed Roger Rabbit Me: Simple... NOTHING!

[@GuadalupePicasso]

Refrigerated bread dries out more quickly.

[@ARCtheCartoonMaster]

Wait... people actually refrigerate bread?

[@pix3l_brat]

One of my favorite movies as a kid! Jessica Rabbit 😍

[@Joe-ou8pn]

She my wife

[@kb470]

@DrågōñŠolo 23 wow, someone has some issues with strangers on the on the internet. You should talk with someone. Ya know. A professional

[@eduardojara6955]

If she breaths she's a thot

[@emelingrace4186]

Ikr???

[@bitsandbirbs4174]

Sinning this movie is a sin in itself

[@ichigokurosaki1081]

"Jeremy will continue to skip over infinity war cliche" Ding!

[@stephengayda5202]

3:23 Betty Boop left out of the Colorization... That's Colorist, erm, BlacknWhitist?

[@m.syauqiabdurahman2798]

Actually The Filmmaker Make A Good Choice To Keep Betty Boop In BAndW rather than in color .

[@zeusathena26]

I was an 80's kid, & loved Betty Boop. Her cartoons were on Saturday mornings, in Texas! Lol

[@DEMIxGODxSHADOW]

You made this just to piss us all off lol

[@dontmindme2066]

Everything wrong with Sixteen Candles? Maybe? Possibly? Please?

[@sleepysmartboy6287]

3:10 Leave Betty alone! She was my childhood and deserves better lol

[@Trainboi1983]

When did you get born P.S.ignore the grammar mistakes,I am having non leathal stronke

[@Aoife_Clancy]

I LOVED AND STILL LOVE THIS MOVIE! Jessica Rabbit is a legend!

[@CasualRacerRed]

Everything Wrong with Who Framed Rodger Rabbit Me: *Them's fighting words*