Exciting New Discoveries in Sirah Studies with Dr. Sadeq Ansari

[@asadullahsaaid3794]

*Timestamps:* 00:00 - Introduction 00:06 - Background of the Guest: Dr. Sadeq Ansari 02:32 - Exploring details of the Sirah beyond traditional sources 04:38 - Uncovering overlooked historical events in Islamic studies 07:04 - Details of the Prophet's compassion & care for animals 09:16 - New Insights from hadith about the Prophet's wife & companions 13:51 - Discourse on the Quran & Islamic view on pet dogs 14:12 - Respect for the imperfect nature of the Book of Revelation 16:18 - Importance of nuanced details in Prophet's life 18:01 - Revolutionary research project in Islamic studies 20:18 - Hadith books contain valuable information not found in regular books 22:07 - New insights on Umani's involvement in early Islamic events & her conversion 25:54 - Upcoming conference in Chicago about Sirah studies 26:24.- Revolutionizing Sirah studies through digitized Arabic volumes 27:54 - Secret gatherings of companions in Prophet's early life 30:56 - Advancements in Islamic scholarship in English-speaking world 31:55 - New discoveries in Islamic scholarship in the West 33:48 - Making Sirah Studies Accessible to Scholars 35:00 - Use of AI technology to create episodes/games of historical figures

[@Scott-s5j]

I’d like to offer a suggestion. While Brother Paul already asks his guests many insightful and thought-provoking questions, it could be even more valuable to arrange follow-up interviews where guests respond to a curated selection of questions and comments from the audience. The audience often brings brilliant insights and perspectives to the discussion that would enrich the conversation further.

[@Imran-wo7jm]

May Allah continue to bless you and your channel! ❣

[@azkhan5513]

Amiin❤

[@kb4432]

"And We have not sent you, [O Muḥammad], except as a mercy to the worlds." The Noble Quran 21:107

[@sedatpir1905]

Make note that God has never used the word religion or mentioned any religion as Judaism Christianity or islam. Religion is man made… Being “faithful” is then important notion. “All the prophets who were sent by God were sent here for one and the same purpose. Through them, God wanted to impart to man that knowledge of reality which would enable him to become an inhabitant of eternal paradise.” Prophets were not sent to divide the faithfull into man made religions

[@Iiiiiiiiiiiic123]

​@@sedatpir1905أن الدين عند الله الاسلام 😅

[@SawsanYasen-nu5vo]

@@kb4432 Pbuh

[@AnjumziaRana]

👏🌹🥀🤲​@@Iiiiiiiiiiiic123

[@beytullahcolak396]

Mashallah Dr Ansari! May Allah continue bless us with His Prophet Alaihi s-Salatu was Salaam!

[@MustafaTekin-y2x]

This is huge! Thank you everyone who involved in this project and also thank you Paul for making it public.

[@Shmoodyy]

May Allah swt bless, reward and put barakah in this man and his beautiful family, ameen.

[@Nusaybah459]

🤲 brother Paul may Allah reward you abundantly. May Allah give you success in this dunya and the Akhira. Ameen.

[@bodymind195]

May Allah swt grant long long hayat to this great researcher and servant.. whole Ummah is going to benefit

[@m.w.s.4145]

MashaAllah, JazakaAllahu khairan, Allah swt protect and bless you both and all of us. Very close to my heart and soul, I am also from Afghanistan.

[@fatemakhalis9467]

Thank you, Brother Paul, for all the insightful content you share on Blogging Theology. It’s been incredibly enriching, and I’m grateful for your efforts. I’d also like to extend my gratitude to Brother Dr Sadeq Ansari for his contributions. Additionally, Dr Yasir Qadhi’s intermediate-level Seerah series on the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is a remarkable resource. Spanning 104 episodes recorded over 4-5 years, it covers complex facets and subtle nuances of the Seerah in a deeply engaging way. I look forward to the new addition to the Seerah, as one cannot truly know how to love the Prophet without understanding his life, his pristine character, and the intricate, fascinating challenges he faced. It’s always a blessing to have scholars bring unique perspectives, allowing a broad audience to connect and deepen their understanding in meaningful ways.

[@FatimaBarkatulla]

Masha’Allah, Seerah helps contextualise the Qur’an and the Shari’ah. It’s essential to study and look into Seerah. I like the idea of looking for more angles for our times. However we have to be careful not to derive rulings directly from Seerah books since not all sources are authentic and correct for deriving rulings from.

[@HaAuIs-u4g]

Hadith is the mother of all Seerah

[@shahlaosman8043]

May Allah grant more strength , power and health for your that big project . 🤲🤲

[@takouachetamirgra1346]

this is amazing. indeed the beauty lies in the details. cant wait to check out this work. thank you brother and may allah bless you both

[@tamanadaqiq175]

Remarkable! A very impressive discussion. Looking forward to the follow-up

[@Sour01]

Amazing interview Mash’Allah and so impressed by Dr Sadiq Ansari. Would love to see him on again!

[@GurbanHaydarov]

Great to see brother Sadeq! Long time. Thank you brother Paul!

[@shahidjames4456]

May Allah bless you for your good works

[@yoyogi52]

اَللَّهُمَّ صَلِّ وَسَلِّمْ وَبَارِكْ عَلَى سَيِّدِنَا مُحَمَّدٍ وَعَلَى آلِهِ

[@nosman38]

MashaAllah may Allah bless you. Uniq information about the seerah. -Abul-Wafa al-Tahawe - Baytul-Medraas

[@xamihkhan]

What an amazing brother, Dr Sadeq Ansari. MashAllah

[@KhairulFahmiShafie]

Masha Allah can't wait for in-depth finding from our dear Doc.

[@nssiddique]

Amazing ... Masha Allah! Great work by Dr Sadeq Ansari.

[@Ar_tistt]

A very nice and benefitial conversation. Allah bless both of you.

[@zafarkhan5609]

Found the conversation very informative. Jazakallah khairan.

[@sammu]

Really happy you anticipated push back and asked for clarification on the irresponsible claim about the “pet dog”, it shows your prolific skill as an interviewer. Interesting talk nonetheless. I wish the brother had quoted sources.

[@siciidfaarax6478]

Found very informative. Jazaka Allah both of you.

[@tadichaguyo290]

I love you and this channel for the sake Of Allah.

[@RezaKhan2024]

From your description, it sounds like it was a guard dog. As companions were scared of it. People normally wouldn't be scared of a normal pet dog. Word scared means the dog would act aggressively upon any approach. That is the act of a guard dog. Assalam Alaikum.

[@Zofishanbintnoon]

JzakAllah Khair. Most needed ! Since it is about the Seerah , let's be mindful of the fact that RasoolAllah never had one and never approved of a dog as pet ... You are right that Quran allows us about keeping a dog for hunting or guarding purposes but not much ... RasoolAllah's personal likes and dislikes should be considered important in accounts of "seerah" Lady Memoona r.a spent comparitively shorter time with RasoolAllah s.a.w..

[@sALah1550]

Fair point and that probably means this research will have greater relevancy to seerah as a story and narrative over law. That being said there’s a lot of value in these reports that document the later years of the Prophet ﷺ and the years of the Rashidun khilafa

[@mustafam7431]

dogs were not living in houses

[@oddizzee]

Good point. However we cannot legislate based on Prophets (SAW) likes and dislikes unless there is a specific command from him that do not contradict the Quran. As Alllah says in the Quran. The Bani israil banned certain food claiming it was haraam but Allah says He did not forbid them that food. It was only something disliked by Prophet Yaqub (AS).

[@Zofishanbintnoon]

@@oddizzee alhamdulilah..the beauty of Quran is that it contains the accounts of divine correction of something contradictory that RasoolAllah did... He was right away corrected as the Quran and Seerah were to be exactly according to Islamic laws . Quran therefore discusses dogs of various types without mentioning RasoolAllah's choices ....I mean if RasoolAllah had a dog , most of us would be crazy about it .... But goodness he didn't have one !

[@samimidost6587]

May Allah swt bless your efforts

[@aminahbergliotrolsdorph7557]

جزاك الله خيرا.. My love 💓 for Seerah in many ways saved my Life .. الحمد الله

[@244lifekobe]

May Allah bless you brothers

[@Dr_Holiday]

Masha'Allah may Allah reward everyone who's putting their Deen before anything else

[@farzanabehshti6842]

May Allah Azzawajal bless Paul and make him very successful I read article in USA several years ago studies show that someone thing from dogs cause female issues such has ovarian issues also for infants some worm so small crawls to babies eyes and causes eye tissue degeneration. We always believe there are good reasons in Islam therefore opportunity to research and it will always come back Islam is true subhanAllah 🤲

[@PS5gamingNasir]

Thanks blogging theology may Allah bless you I always watch these valuable videos.

[@faouziyassine8262]

May Allah bless you

[@naeemulhoque1777]

Can you please Interview *"The Muslim Lantern"* someday? inshaAllah.

[@youssefjrad3319]

السلام عليك اخي بول و شكرا على كل المحاضرات التي تقوم بها

[@saliksayyar9793]

Irrespective of the truth of Torah, it is just showing respect to a book that the Jews respected. Respecting other people’s sacred texts. The dog was probably not in the house. Houses were tiny. The dog protected her on her journey. Guard dogs are ok

[@MoMo-yd9db]

Allahumma barik brothers ❤

[@dervaishkhanofficial]

He belongs to my country. Glad to know that 🇦🇫♥️

[@fatemarampurawala5677]

Sir i really think distictively achieve your humanship towards an eternal life to acknowledge moral of our islam to reaching upto a normal lay being of any natives.insha allah keep you healthy and live long.

[@sarkhangasimov9249]

Barekallahu fike. My former roommate ❤

[@jn6676]

Ustaazh Paul 👍

[@MamadiConta]

Great 👍

[@adielkamalie5252]

JazaakAllah

[@S40WBS]

Would have been good to have clarification regarding the strength and narration of the hadiths

[@ebrimajallow2704]

The whole concept of this project is something think about often..whenever i listen to sira i ask myself is there more are there more stories about the life of the holy Prophet s.a.w

[@Zofishanbintnoon]

Brothers .. practicing Seerah with complete pleasure is only possible in a country where he's respected and loved . About the west , submarines and aitikaaf openly are contradictory... May Allah Subhan bless us truth across the globe EAST WEST NORTH and South ..ameen ❤

[@anxoidenamikaze1551]

The prophet in mecca and the muslims were persecuted. So it is possible even in a non muslim counrty. In fact the life of the prophet is complete it is applicable everywhere and everytime

[@Zofishanbintnoon]

@@anxoidenamikaze1551 Meccan life is Not what prophet aimed at and was here on earth for !! All his efforts were to take the oppressed out of the Meccan situation and highlight the glories a Freeman's Islam brings ... Hope you understand my view.

[@Zofishanbintnoon]

But today I agree , nobody's having any freewill ... We are all in cages ... If we were free , Palestinians could never be burnt alive .... 😓

[@anxoidenamikaze1551]

@@Zofishanbintnoon His life is an exemple. Will you do like people of the book removing part of his life and not other part. For people who live similar events the life of the prophet is a role model and a schematic to bring islam in society

[@sarim9574]

I hope your bookshelf doesn't collapse Uncle Paul...it looks like its really weighing on it

[@doctorikon]

wonderful guest.

[@maruf2050]

Alhamdulillah

[@DIY2min]

Awesome

[@Gog3453]

This confirms the station of Ihsan as mentioned in the Hadith of Jabril

[@aqidahsunnahsahihah]

pls quote sources of all the hadiths and what are their status according to scholars (muhaddisin). We need an expert in jarrah wa ta'dil. Hi Paul, there are two experts in hadith that are worth an interview. Both from Malaysia; Mufti Dr Muhammad Asri Bin Zainal Abidin and Dr Rozaimi Ramlie.

[@BuRidah-777]

When speaking of hadiths it would be beneficial if sources are cited.

[@imammamunu9537]

An earlier Seera of the prophet called the Seera Maghazi was discovered after it was lost for centuries. It is earlier than ibn ishaaq. Perhaps BT may invite an expert to talk about it.

[@Kuleto]

That sounds great

[@fuzailahmad6604]

Dar-al-Arqam will be publishing a more complete version soon, Inshaa'Allah

[@ma5839]

Tarikh al Maghazi (History of the Prophet's (saws) Military Campaigns) is attributed to Ibn Waqid al Aslami, aka al Waqidi. Imam ash Shafii (rh) said of him: "there were 7 in al Madinah who used to fabricate authorities. Al Waqidi was one of them". Imam al Bukhari (rh) said of him: " he has been abandoned in hadith. He fabricated hadith". Imam Dhahabi (rh) said there is consensus al Waqidi is a liar who fabricates. While it may be interesting to read al Waqidi's works, the reality is there are fabrications and weak narrations which can mislead common folk who do not know they are fabrications.

[@MoMo-yd9db]

Sallallahu Alayhi Wasallam ♥️

[@ridwanfsyarif4072]

Wow, this is great! Imagine we can talk with "prophet's companion" through AI technology. I always curious about how wealthy is Abdurrahman ibn auf , i want to"talk" to him and ask all the detail of his strategy in economy (lots of moslem are in poor country, or have a difficulties in term of financial like debt, riba etc)

[@khairt1731]

This is why I love Shaykh Yasir Qadhi seerah so much. He uses Quran sources and authentic Hadiths from the sunni books with the old seerah books combined.

[@khairt1731]

21:00 Sh Yasir Qadhi mentions this in his Seerah.

[@mbuusieismael5333]

It's the best

[@ThedeadaccountAL]

be careful, Yasir Qadhi is a deviant

[@Vancouver2010BC]

Significant changes to the Torah occurred after the Prophet Muhammad (SAAW) was sent. This can be sensed from Quran 5:41-43, especially verse 43, which highlights alteration had taken place likely after that incident for at least one issue: "But how is it that they come to you for judgment while they have the Torah, in which is the judgment of Allah? Then they turn away, [even] after that; but those are not [in fact] believers" (Quran 5:43). One possible reason for these alterations, specifically at that time, is that the Jewish community expected the final prophet to be exclusively for them, as they were accustomed to having prophets sent specifically to their nation. This belief is supported by Quran 2:89, which speaks about their rejection of Prophet Muhammad: "And when there came to them a Book from Allah confirming that which was with them-although before they used to pray for victory against those who disbelieved-but [then] when there came to them that which they recognized, they disbelieved in it; so the curse of Allah will be upon the disbelievers" (Quran 2:89). Today's Torah doesn't have that. Nevertheless, even at that time, the Torah likely still contained verses that were original and divinely revealed. To illustrate this, imagine writing a document that includes verses from the Quran. Even though the majority of the document is your own writing, the verses from the Quran would still command respect, and you would not be permitted to treat the document carelessly. Similarly, while the Torah had been altered, it still contained portions that came directly from Allah, and therefore, deserved respect. In fact, Quran 6:108 instructs Muslims not to insult the deities of other religions, even if they worship idols: "And do not insult those they invoke other than Allah, lest they insult Allah in enmity without knowledge. Thus We have made pleasing to every community their deeds. Then to their Lord is their return, and He will inform them about what they used to do" (Quran 6:108). So, if we are instructed not to insult the false gods of other religions, how much more respect should we show for a book that at least contains some words from God? Now, regarding Dr. Sadeq Ansari quoting Tahawi: with all due respect, books like Tahawi's and similar works are comparable to writings in churches and synagogues. In Islam, we do not have a church or hierarchy of religious authority. The ultimate reference is the Quran and authentic Hadith, and if these are followed, one will not go astray. Relying on any individual’s interpretation, regardless of their status, can lead to deviation from the truth. The command is clear: follow the Quran and the Prophet (SAAW) alone, as stated in Quran 7:3: "Follow, [O mankind], what has been revealed to you from your Lord and do not follow other than Him any allies. Little do you remember" (Quran 7:3). In fact, Tahawi made several significant errors. For example, he classified wiping over shoes during wudu (ablution) as a matter of 'Aqeedah (creed), which is incorrect. He even included this in his book on creed. Furthermore, Tahawi advocated blind following of certain people, which is a dangerous approach. The only person we are to follow without question is the Prophet Muhammad (SAAW). Additionally, Tahawi made the flawed assumption that one must either follow the People of the Book or the Mushrikeen (idol worshipers), when in reality, there is no need to follow anyone but the Quran and the authentic Sunnah. Quran 15:9 reassures us that Allah has promised to preserve the Quran: "Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian" (Quran 15:9). To put it plainly, Tahawi's reasoning reflects limited intellectual capacity, and it's surprising that more people haven't recognized the flaws in his logic. His classification of wiping over shoes as part of creed is just one example of how misguided his thinking can be. Furthermore, when Dr. Ansari cited Tahawi as saying one must either follow the People of the Book or the Mushrikeen, this is even more troubling. The principle is simple: if something is found in the Quran or authentic Hadith, follow it. If not, you are free to act according to your discretion, even if a scholar issues a fatwa on the matter. If it wasn’t explicitly prescribed by Allah through His Messenger, it holds no binding authority. Moreover, Tahawi’s limited mentality suggests that on issues where Allah has left things open, he assumes one must blindly follow an established religious authority. But who’s to say that in matters left open by Allah, a Mushrik (polytheist) might not have a better idea? For example, managing a database or constructing a train system-these are worldly matters that don’t require religious ruling. In fact, the pre-Islamic Arabs had qualities such as pride, dignity, and resistance to oppression, which may have had positive aspects. On the other hand, some Christians might appear to surrender to abuse under the guise of humility, when in fact it could be weakness. Finally, Brother Paul, I hope you have checked your email. I sent you a couple of messages, including one yesterday. Please take a look when you have the time.

[@DWAGON1818]

Seerah and Sunnah should be joined.

[@AmeerLatif-o4v]

So the Hadith claiming the the wife of the prophet had a dog is apparently extremely weak and may have been fabricated; as one of the narrators in the chain is accused of stealing fabricated Hadith and then narrating them. Hence, what is the point of just mentioning random info as though we are adding something to the scholarly tradition without verifying it first? It is against the tradition of the scholars of Hadith. That is enough for me of this video.

[@Sheriff1977]

Brother Paul my only wish is why didn’t you become a Muslim earlier

[@mohammedowais6682]

Thank you for this - Though I can't see any narration that states Maymunah RA kept a dog, can someone enlighten me?

[@FawadBilgrami]

It looks like the project might benefit those who either lack trust in the scholars or knowledge. The interview was a good insight but fell short due to skipping the sources and/or stating he isn't an expert. I guess the project work is in its infancy but brother Paul be careful when you bring in a guest who cannot fully provide details as they say half truth is worse than a lie. It can create a fitnah. May Allah Bless you. Ameen.

[@walking64]

Also please try non Muslim resources for example monasteries temples and churches

[@Kirk-d7v]

Hi Paul an author named *Nurit Peled-Elhanan* should make a very interesting guest on you podcast. How about getting her point of views?

[@Tigerlilly5555]

With Prophet Muhammad PBUH placing Torah on the cushion, could it be that he was telling the Jews, the Torah is their Judge in this case, not him?

[@shafkat_ahmed_dipto]

AsSalamuWalaikum ❤

[@IsxaaqAcademy]

We need such deep and interdisciplinary works rather than subjective storytelling

[@3MIRINO]

اللهم صلي وسم على سيدنا محمد

[@Pierre-vn5rh]

Bonjour Paul William, il faudrait tenir compte des recherches dans les autres sources historiques afin d'apporter une couverture plus large (exogènes, des sources grecques, arméniennes, syriaques, non musulmanes).

[@mujtab304]

Here we are "When the Sun will rise from the West". The West is on the lead on Islamic studies. SWT assist and inspire you

[@hiddenfact5950]

Thank you, brilliant informatic discussion, indeed living in the west have more bigger opportunity to explore our hidden treasure of Islam in all dimension to understand how,when& what happened in first 500 of Muslim Hijara.

[@JohnnieWalkerGreen]

Since chatGPT has been mentioned several times, how would chatGPT contribute to Sirah's progress in the future? I am looking forward to the outcome of a new Sirah Book.

[@TK-wn3gh]

Hi, Where can i follow Dr. Sadeq and the team works?

[@AlemAlibasic]

❤

[@KhalidYassine-f6b]

Interesting facts indeed. Is it possible to give us the source of Maymouna's dog? The Only thing I know about that is the hadith in Muslim about the dog under Maymouna's bed that stopped an angel from entering the house... Is there anything else ? If so, where ? Thank you

[@kb4432]

That proves that this dog was not meant to come inside the house, so it was most likely a stray that used to visit or one normally kept outside. Dogs and images keep Angels away from houses

[@SKyser-i5k]

How can dogs keep angels away? What about angel of death? Makes no sense

[@KhalidYassine-f6b]

@@SKyser-i5k And also The gardian angels...

[@kb4432]

Belief in Angels is one of the articles of faith. We believe there are Angels of rememberence that were created who enter homes of people reciting Quran, and doing Allah's Dhikr in order to bear witness bear to it and affirm it to Allah SWT, even though Allah knows everything. Remember Allah, the most Merciful has said in surah Nur of the Quran that he is the origin of light(Nur) and that a similar light(nur) is lit in the houses of people who mention Allah quite often. We know that Allah created the Angels with a similar light(Nur) so they are therfore attracted to it. Wherever these angels enter, shaitans flee therefrom. We know that these angels don't go near people who are in a state of nijasah (impurity). Dogs saliva is also a form of nijasah. The smell of dogs is strong because of their saliva and people who keep them also carry this strong smell. We know that dogs are also dangerous because they have issues with anger management. It is known thatbchildren, elderly and adult owners of pet dogs have been injured or killed, when the dog turned on them. Lastly, as you have heard from people who keep them, dogs make better companions than Cats whereas Allah created men and women to be companions of each other. I could say alot more but i am short of time. Please read the hadith below. It is one of the most authentic hadith out there. May Allah bless you all and give you abundant goodness Abu Talhah reported: The Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog, nor an image in a likeness.” Abu Talhah said, “The Prophet means by likeness an image of living souls.” Source: Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3225, Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 2106 Grade: Muttafaqun Alayhi (authenticity agreed upon) according to Al-Bukhari and Muslim

[@ma5839]

​@SKyser-i5k All information about angels (malaikat) is "ghayb" that must be based in "naas" Divine texts (Quran a/o Sunnah). They are real beings with distinct features known only to Allah Who allows His prophets & messengers to attain certain information about them, and that information also provided in the Holy Quran. Thus, the authentic narration from the Prophet (saws) in which he said angels are averse to dogs. Allah AWJ empowered mankind to domesticate certain animals to benefit human societies and ease life. Domestication of dogs has been absolutely important to mankind, especially in early human history. But now, mankind no longer depends on dogs.

[@phantomtr1]

1. The Prophet's SAW respect towards another people's book, perhaps it is just that, a respectful gesture. Why does it have anything to do with what the book was? We are also told to respect the religions of others to a degree, and to protect their monks/priests and their temples/churches etc. 2. Who said the torah that they had 1440 years ago is the same or even similar to the one we have today?

[@nikjulianamusa8690]

Since ancient times, dogs has been used as guard dogs over life and property.. It cannot be denied that one cannot help but love any animal that show obedience and loyalty. One should look at the Hadith, where no wahyu was forthcoming to Rasullulah SAW when he was in his wife, A'isyah ra house and it turn out that it was because there was a dog in the house. It does not mean that we should be cruel to dogs or any animals to prove a point. We should understand that dogs were created for a specific purpose as protectors of life and property.

[@786humaira1]

I read Isaac Newton was a believer in the CREATOR OF HEAVENS AND EARTH . However he did not profess it as it would affect his professional standing .

[@arifmunshi6833]

A question for brother paul. In Matthew 22 On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ 23 And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you workers of lawlessness.’ If jesus was talking about 'workers of lawlessness' what law is he referring to??

[@uthman2281]

why is that relevant?

[@BAFREMAUXSOORMALLY]

When we are distracted by nonsense this is what happens to the best of us! What Torah, what "book", which language was it in when only priests had access to it in rolls???????

[@012345family]

Maymoona Radi Allah ho an hi was not just “a woman” she was the wife of the prophet peace be upon him

[@DrWoofOfficial]

ok?

[@mshafiq27]

The thief believes everyone else is a thief. The genocider believes everyone else is a genocider.

[@PadukaJelelo]

About the torah if I'm not mistaken. is not allowed for non Jew to touch it. As for the Prophet to give his seat , for me is an act of tolerance. Where I remember the Prophet signed the Hudaibiyah Treaty which to some sahabahs as not being a fair terms. Again an act of tolerance for the benefit of the Believers .

[@SedSid-v7b]

9:58 referring to the story of Bilaal RD as based on "Hadeeth". Hadeeth must be quoted as "Prophet pbh said" did the Prophet pbh mentioned this story about Bill RD? Please clarify.

[@QureShi-d4r]

Can u provide references for the things mentioned like hazrat mamoona crying over her pet dog

[@abdulkelani1150]

All books of hadith contain many chapters on sirah of the Prophet, peace be upon him, such as the Book of Maghazi in Bukhari. Ibn Ishaq's or Ibn Hisham's books on sirah are not the only books that contain history of the Prophet. In fact, many of their narration are not even authentic.

[@DrAzma]

Those narrations that were mentioned by Dr. Sadeq are not authentic, so there is a reason why they were not included in the classical books. For example at 9:30 the story of the dog المِسْمَارُ has no narration and it simply false ابن أبي أويس ضعيف جدا وابن معبد لم يسمع من ميمونة

[@parkerflop]

Scholars focused their efforts in authentication on narrations with legal implications. There would be greater laxity on other things.

[@methics5588]

No reference to the authenticity of the Hadith about Maymoona RA having a dog. Extreme Caution should be taken in the new things which are contrary to the authentically established matters.

[@Hanan-o1m]

Why we need more information about small details, we already have what we need in the Quran and Hadith.

[@najamulghanikhan]

All these details are known to Muslim scholars and are also documented in various seerah books. The tragedy is the obsession to stay within Bukhari only

[@RayOfHope8]

❤️❤️🌹🌹🤲🤲🍉🍉

[@naz7094]

Brother i also love syyadina omer series If we read a book most of the stuff vipe off by the time but uf you visualise can't go away

[@khalid6092]

It doesn't mean that the prophet's wife mamuna had a dog inside her house. Back in Pakistan I always had a dog but it was only an outdoor dog. Dogs were never allowed inside the house. You're mixing two subjects together. Dogs were always allowed in Islam but for outdoor purposes and hunting in other areas. Just go look at pet shelters in your city and you will see they are filled to the capacity, with abandoned dogs and cats. In the society that I live in, people are raising dogs and cats instead of having children. Allah, knows best.

[@faeiger9215]

This data shouldn’t be available to the public and laymen.

[@JohnSmith-zh2yn]

Why?

[@faeiger9215]

@@JohnSmith-zh2yn because they lack the prerequisite knowledge to be able to sift though it.

[@ThedeadaccountAL]

@@faeiger9215 wait are these hadiths already in other books

[@saidamohamud2300]

Are you sure that Maymuuna (umul muminiin) had pet dog????? I never heard it