Explained: The Border Dispute Between India and Nepal | The Quint

[@broadcastingsagar]

In Nepal even a common person can provide heaps of the strong proof that Kalapani and Limpiyadhura belong to Nepal, Whereas the Indian side, even the government doesn't have a single solid proof. That's why they are trying to skip the diplomatic talk.

[@tivo3720]

Solid proof ?!!! Solid proof is that India deployed its army in that territory during war with China. And it's Nepal who is resently published a new map showing that kalapani is in Nepal. India has not published a new map. Nepal did .

[@tivo3720]

@user-qy1xg5fk3f boo ... Who doesn't even know anything about northeast India. Comes here to lecture us . I'm from northeast India 🇮🇳. U Pakistani and Bangladeshis ... Just go away from our land

[@aAverageFan]

These areas have been under British & then Indian control since the 1860s so Nepal can't claim them after more than one and a half century.

[@aAverageFan]

​@Indi An Fasod COPE harder

[@Pavan4054]

@IndiAnFasod Keep dreaming

[@addaccount2166]

India in 1962: Hey Nepal! we are fighting a war with China and since your military presence in Kalapani and nearby bordering area is minimal, can we station around there for the period of war to monitor Chinese movement? Nepal: Sure, we have the best of relations and if it helps in your defense, why not? India: Thank you. we are establishing 18 military camps in Nepali land bordering China. Nepal in 1969: Hey bro! the war is already finished but your camps are still around, could you withdraw your forces? India: Okay! (removes 17 posts, but remains in Kalapani and controls Lipulekh area because it is strategically too significant to monitor China) Nepal: Kalapani? India: (to then King) Don't forget you are economically too dependent on us, also we can seize you from power by using the revolutionary forces. You remain quiet, you aren't using that area anyway. Nepal after democracy in 90's: Hey bro! now we are a democracy and we now have access to historical evidences and facts, could you withdraw the army and settle the issue as the land is on the east side of river Kali? India (Under Gujral and Bajpayee): Okay lets solve this and all other border issues with help from experts. (Experts reach on agreement in 98% border area except Susta and Kalapani area, recommend it be settled on high political level, remains an outstanding issue) India in 2015: Hey China, wanna trade from Lipulekh and make Mansarovar quickly accessible? China: Okay! Nepal: But it's our territory and we have been claiming it all along? (sends diplomatic protest to New Delhi and Beijing). Hey bro (to India) let's solve the issue first among us before any agreement with third party. India: Ok then, No official visit for your PM Koirala (first time a Nepali PM does not make an official visit to India) and a blockade! India in Novemeber 2019: New Political map released (8th edition) with Kali river marked well inside it's territory when it should be a border. Nepal: Yo bro! You say East of Kali is Nepal but it is well inside your territory on the map? India: Oops! (9th edition is quickly released with river's name erased) Nepal: Let's solve it with foreign secretary level talks, there is pressure from general public after the blockade. This way the relation is only getting worse. India: We don't care, you are too dependent on us. ( Inaugurates the road during Covid-19 pandemic, despite the construction not being completed and with presence of high level Military and Defense personnels) Nepal: Come on! at least sit down and talk before doing things unilaterally! Indian Army chief: China has made Nepal speak. Indian Media: Nepal ki ye aukat ki wo India ko aankh dikhaye, Inhe fir blockade karna chahiye! Nepal: Ok then we'll issue our own map with disputed territory (Will benefit the increasingly unpopular Oli govt as well as address public outrage due to India's consistent big brotherly attitude) Indian Media: China, China, China, China!

[@sadmimashahrin6769]

India is losing all it's border friends and china is swiftly taking the place. India is living in a dream. She has to wake up and see that everyone is going against her and need to fix her attitude.

[@lyanz566]

Very true

[@bibekgadal4356]

true ❤

[@truthspeaker5628]

Well composed dialogue including facts..........Kindly check the comments made by me too on this issue.........

[@TAnbalagan.9051]

If it is true then as an indian, india🇮🇳 should return kalapani to nepal🇳🇵.

[@aryansitaula2240]

Nope, the Indian troops were given permission by King Mahendra of Nepal to deploy in Kalapani. Don't manipulate other people with wrong facts!

[@gklnth187]

He clearly states the problem starts after Nepal becomes democratic..

[@sv19570]

Aryan Sitaula Very very small poor country Nepal 😄😄😄😄😄😄

[@samipbhetwal8427]

santha look at global hunger index

[@dionakgamer7769]

Santha Viswambharan that doesn’t justify taking the land of Nepal

[@subhraghimire2486]

Not like your country ruled by british!

[@kabindrapokharel4791]

An Indian citizen getting killed in the southern border of Nepal doesn't have any connection to the Limpiyadhura-Kalapani-Lipulekh border issue.

[@nowwhat6716]

Indian like some spice in every thing for entertainment thats why godi media is so successful 🤷‍♂️

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

Don't know how can any prime minister can give such a crucial area to any country 😩. May be he don't know the importance of that area. May be because at that time china was not neighbour of India, it was Tibet. When china captured Tibet it become threat to India even till now. But historically area is used by India since after sugauli treaty to trade with Tibet and pilgrimage to mt. Kalash before and after independence of India. River is looking starting point from kalapani not limpiyadhura in map. It will be biggest blunder in the history of India if that area gone out of hand to other countries ,the whole national security will be in stake. Kalapani region, galwan valley, dokhlam and Siliguri corridor are 4 most strategic crucial posts to secure India from china .

[@pattricksmith861]

yes I dont trust any news from Indian media. Its funny and sad that people still follow and trust these news.

[@lavr7196]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 Hemang Shrivastava firstly I don't understand wether you are talking about indian pm or Nepali pm because no Nepali pm ever has handed these are to india. And indian pm cannot give it tosomeone when it does not belong to his country in the first place. It might have been used for trade with Tibet, lot of country trade through others border but that does not mean it belongs to the traders, coming to mt Kailash pilgrimage, not a single Nepali citizen is against it because we accept all religion in Nepal and have majority hindu population. coming to the starting point of river in the 1815 states that the Nepali border starts from origin of Mahakali river, if you type source of Mahakali in Google maps it show India utterkhand, as you said starting point of the river so there you go the ACTUAL ORIGIN of river and Nepali border. Lastly 4 strategically crucial post for india against china, but Nepal is a different country than china and India. It is a peaceful country therefore if india has threat from china make a deal or treaty or a defence pact with Nepal. India's encroachment on Nepal cannot be justified with any of you reasonings.

[@fsr3621]

Pattrick Smith Hehe because you are from Nepal😂 you only support those takes your sides.... Blaming Godi media bla bla.... etc... won’t change anything...

[@sauravjaiswal3562]

Indian man shot dead in Bihar state is a whole different story and no way related to border dispute. And yes, the disputed land should be resolved through a diplomatic talk. India and Nepal are friendly neighbours and need to find a way out. Peace.

[@shamserchand6916]

I thought it was worthy channel but here you go and speak the same words like godi media , and there might be differences in us over covid situation but not on border issues with india and plz do little hard work and you will find more this is not the only one issue there's more then 70 issues of border encroachments from india

[@nowwhat6716]

Why r u bringing Indian death as if this incident is related to border dispute 🤷‍♂️mention the whole incident or don't mention it at all✌

[@sunilsphotography4981]

Couldn’t understand the term disputed territory and Indian territory. Is disputed territory means it’s INDIAN territory? Please stops these Propagandas. Please research first before posting something like this. As per the treaty, Sugauli treaty was border treaty between Nepal and East India where both agreed and signed. After that there’s is No any agreements or treaty defining the border which makes INDIA ( East India / India ) guilty to change border and engulfing Nepalese territory. Next about the border issues heating up. Please go through google map and see the road that was built. The previous engulfing was even insufficient so INDIA has again built some portions of road on the Eastern side of Kali river. So what do you call it? HYPOCRISY? kzbin.info/www/bejne/sGqWqYqji7mIZsk

[@nowwhat6716]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 another indian with his foolish logic 🤷‍♂️

[@prajjwoltimilsina6999]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 Have you read the treaty mohodaya? i think you should study it first.

[@lavr7196]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 here you are correct there is no mention of where the origin of river Mahakali is. But it is stated that Nepal's border on east start for the origin of Mahakali river which geologically starts at Pithoragarh, Uttarakhand 262501 therefore there is that violation according to 1815 treaty of Sughauli. Furthermore treaty of Sughauli cancels, per according to 1950 indo- nepal friendship and peace treaty in which article 8 states Article 8 So far as matters dealt with herein are concerned, this Treaty cancels all previous Treaties, agreements, and engagements entered into on behalf of India between the British Government and the Government of Nepal. Including 1815 treaty of Sughauli sing by Nepal and British east india on behalf of India. So please return all land including Sirmur, Dehradun, Garhwal, Kumaon, Sikkim and all territories receded by British east india company on behalf of India during the signing of 1815 treaty of Sughauli.

[@DarkPhychic]

History and Politics: Current regions of Madhesh handed over to Nepal by the East India Company through the treaty of 1816 (to support Nepal financially) and the treaty of 1860 (as a gift to Nepal for its help to British in suppressing the Sepoy Mutiny in India)

[@ChandishSipai]

@@DarkPhychic they didn't gave it to support Nepal "financially". It was a treaty dude. That means Nepal also gave one third of its territory to Support the company "financially". Moreover, the British Government were supported with cash kind and men in both the great wars

[@lavr7196]

Why is it that you explained the 1815 treaty of Sughauli, but not 1950 indo-nepal peace and friendship treaty where it states in Article 8 So far as matters dealt with herein are concerned, this Treaty cancels all previous Treaties, agreements, and engagements entered into on behalf of India between the British Government and the Government of Nepal. Which means all 1,05,000 km2 of land handed over to east india company according to 1815 treaty of Sughauli must be returned to Nepal. And to all of you indians saying it's history, what's the point of bringing this topic up now How many years did you wait before claiming back goa from portugal, how long did you wait before changing back old cities names after british left. Food for thought If anyone wants to comment saying Nepal and india are brothers and we can solve this peacefully go look up 1950 indo-nepal peace treaty educate yourself and people around you and ask government of india resolve this quickly and peacefully. Deepest condolences to the family of soldier's who lost their lives in ladakh. But how is that indian media defines india-china border dispute as attack on national sovereignty, while india itself does not honour the treaty already singed and holds onto Nepali land and uses same rehtoric to explain two completely opposite situation.

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

Don't know how can any prime minister can give such a crucial area to any country 😩. May be he don't know the importance of that area. May be because at that time china was not neighbour of India, it was Tibet. When china captured Tibet it become threat to India even till now. But historically area is used by India since after sugauli treaty to trade with Tibet and pilgrimage to mt. Kalash before and after independence of India. River is looking starting point from kalapani not limpiyadhura in map. It will be biggest blunder in the history of India if that area gone out of hand to other countries ,the whole national security will be in stake. Kalapani region, galwan valley, dokhlam and Siliguri corridor are 4 most strategic crucial posts to secure India from china .

[@lavr7196]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 historically area might have been used by India to fend off China after annexation of Tibet but it doesn't change that fact that the land belongs to Nepal. And national security threat also is not good enough excuse to say china annexed Tibet therefore India claims Nepali land to prevent threat from China.

[@TonyWangel]

Hemang Shrivastava that area belongs to Nepal. Nothing to do with the Indians

[@truthspeaker5628]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 Hey asshole! get your information correct. India didn't use Kalapani regions since sugauli treaty but after India was defeated horribly in the war by China in 1962. Indian Prime Minister Pandit Jahawar Lal Neheru had asked for permission with the Monarchy of Nepal to keep its soldiers in the Kalapani regions of Nepal to keep an eyes on Chinese Movements only for a temporary period of time but not to include Nepalese territories in Indian map. Indian soldiers came to the region after granting the permission from the Government of Nepal in 1965 AD. and not in 1816. If China is such a dangerous country for you all then why are you all making trades with such a dangerous country?? Paisa chalta hai, lekin dosti nahin?? dosti chalta hai lekin biswas nahin..........ridiculous. Fuck with Indian security. The is the era of rockets and nuclear power. if China thinks of attacking India then it could come through any points of India or abolish India with a Nuclear or Atomic weapon.

[@Pavan4054]

@@TonyWangel All the areas mentioned above are in Indian territory..Nepal have nothing to do here.stop enchroching into Indian territories

[@sarojshr]

Artificial manipulation of historic facts ??? Are you kidding me? Read the Sugauli treaty thoroughly. Unsubscribed

[@lavr7196]

Thats how the politics and the world operate my brother therefore we must educate ourself on the facts. I would ask you to also look through 1950 indo-nepal friendship and peace treaty. Specifically Article 8 where it clearly states all treaty before this shall cancel wether it was signed by British india on behalf of India or by India. Therefore Nepal has every right to take back Kumon, Gardwal, Sikkim and all other terittory receded by British indian at the time of Sughauli treaty.

[@avikumarirm]

Article 8 of india nepal treaty of friendship and peace cleary over rides the sugauli treaty.

[@sarojshr]

@@avikumarirm if India wants to invoke that treaty, we will be getting Greater Nepal by giving few lands from crurrent Nepal back to India.

[@avikumarirm]

@@sarojshr do you even know the meaning of a treaty?? India has always respected each and every treaty it has signed. If nepal wants to revoke the treaty then nepal will collapse.

[@avikumarirm]

And by collapse i do not mean that india will attack it but nepal heavily depends on india. That treaty is the basis on which nepal gets free access to indian ports and commerce. Without which a landlocked country like nepal cannot sustain.

[@AnkitRoy-jn7rq]

Every country is diverting covid issues to border disputes... Typical politics. 😂😂 Poor citizens will never understand this.

[@aadi2456]

Why no Media is reporting this? 'Maharashtra govt signed MoUs collectively worth over Rs 5,000 cr with three Chinese companies on Monday June 15. The MoUs were signed on under the *"Magnetic Maharashtra 2.0"* hours before the violent face-off between Indian and Chinese troops'

[@haridattapanta5723]

Exactly

[@techsrif556]

O then you are poor citizen

[@riktamsarkar7684]

@@aadi2456 Why os no one talking about the cancelled tunnel tender and Indian railway cancelling tender with China. And moreover this attack was to stop India from trying to grab the opportunity from China. American, Britain, Australian, European Union etc. firm are exiting China and are planning to come to India, Vietnam and some other countries. But China's economy will collapse if companies from those country leave China and set up their production house elsewhere.

[@professionalnoobs2753]

When the ppl go against the king war at the border is common..

[@bivekdahal49]

You have wrong facts. Try to explain the real truth like Dhruv Rathee

[@nationalinfocrypto9918]

Bivek Dahal be neutral not leftist

[@neutralboi1984]

@@nationalinfocrypto9918 we are not leftist its facts

[@arjungautam6880]

Man you did all the research right expect the killing of indian citizen by nepal arm police force. Indian farmers first deny going back to india as broders between nepal and Indian is closed at this time of pandemic. Then when nepalese force pressurized them to go back but instead they throw stones and one of them try to steal the police gun toon. Then unfortunately indian farmer get shot and killed. But of you look back in time several nepali citizen has lost their life also. Less then a year back indian police had killed a nepali ctizen. #nohate

[@KhanAwaseem]

Thats how cover stories are made brother...

[@nowwhat6716]

@@KhanAwaseem u call it cover news but u believing the nonsense that nepal police intentionally kill those indian but capture one citizen . If that was intentional that old man would be dead right now✌ think logically

[@hakkhani]

India has border issues with Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal and China. And according to their logic they're a "peaceful" nation.😂😂😂

[@samrat69420]

OK,so let's clarify- 1.no we don't have any border dispute with Bangladesh 2.in the Kashmir dispute,pakistan and China were the aggressors. 3.In this dispute,You guys suddenly claimed this land,thus making you the aggressors of this dispute

[@ritrenjudhyani1547]

Ofcourse all pak Bangladesh were cut out from india..rest Tibet ke angane mein china kyaa kaam hai..rest nepali get so many job opportunities..access to iit, iims...no country helps any other country as India does...

[@sv19570]

Huge unemployed youths in India. At the same time Nepalese and Tibetans In large number working in Govt. departments of India. Central govt should take action against this practice.

[@sv19570]

L Lk India is not a problematic country. India is a peaceful country. Pakistan, China and Nepal are problematic country.

[@nowwhat6716]

@@samrat69420 it's not suddenly dumb ass you know of it today doesn't make it sudden🤷‍♂️ if u voilate only treaty that exist I.e suguali treaty then thats gonna be problem.

[@sajansingh2726]

Being a journalist you represent your country..atlest do your homework and come.it make you fool ND your country...

[@ChandishSipai]

@Madara Uchihait will be taken care of, after this issue

[@teamazay8198]

U guys haven't done enough homework

[@nimace8594]

That killing of indian citizen (may his soul rest in peace) is not related to the border issue in limpiyadhura as the border issue is in north-western side and the firing is in south-eastern side.

[@danielpearl007]

Dear admin, there is few misinformation in the video. Nepal has conducted election/census until 1962. Indian PM then requested to put its military to watch over china. Former PM IK Gujaral accepted nepalese claim over the territory and asked not to deploy nepalese forces in replace.

[@bekgurung]

These guys are the one misguiding others... And spreading hatred. And this guy don't know anything .

[@SumitSingh-iz9pw]

Because the nepalese army could have easily arrested the guy .... But instead they shot him. It is clearly that nepalese government is trying to send a message to india that you're not welcome here

[@incomparable5792]

@@SumitSingh-iz9pw that indian guy who was dead brought large amount of villagers to show off his power against police and attacked nepal armed force. to save themselves and to take matter under control. even 6 police were injured during that incident. do research properly and talk.

[@ShisherShrestha]

There is a Dhurb Rathe an Indian KZbinr video on this topic that has a very neutral explanation.

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

Don't know how can any prime minister can give such a crucial area to any country 😩. May be he don't know the importance of that area. May be because at that time china was not neighbour of India, it was Tibet. When china captured Tibet it become threat to India even till now. But historically area is used by India since after sugauli treaty to trade with Tibet and pilgrimage to mt. Kalash before and after independence of India. River is looking starting point from kalapani not limpiyadhura in map. It will be biggest blunder in the history of India if that area gone out of hand to other countries ,the whole national security will be in stake. Kalapani region, galwan valley, dokhlam and Siliguri corridor are 4 most strategic crucial posts to secure India from china .

[@lavr7196]

@नेपाली रंडी Behen India ahjao yeh duniya ki sabse badi kotha hey😂😂😂

[@madhavsadasivan6789]

dhruv rathee channel mein clear description diya hain about the issue

[@asohi47]

Bakht nahi sunte uski

[@akshitthakur6833]

@@asohi47 bhakt toh ye smjh he ni payenge English mein h na unpadhon ko kahan smjh aayega😂

[@harry_pottero]

@@asohi47 kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3vJh2B9aKx6hpI

[@vijayrawat09]

@@asohi47 abhi bhakt v sunege kyunki usne aache se bataya hai aur bola v hai wo area India ka hai.

[@jatinchauhan1880]

Even on study iq channel

[@bigenthapa5079]

This is result of low research and indian biasness. @Quint can refer BBC coverage on it.

[@nutellaaa7086]

To kya nepal ki news dekhe thapa ji

[@bigenthapa5079]

@@nutellaaa7086 nahi BBC dekho

[@trickynations1329]

Just find real source of Kali boom nepal wins

[@prakashpathak9216]

Lioulekh belongs to nepal and we have enough evidence to prove it.

[@sunilpashurai8180]

are u a nepalese citizen speaking?

[@nhk137]

Ok...what evidence....can u plz explain?

[@aaashirwaad]

@@nhk137 kzbin.info/www/bejne/qavGZX-qoMlmj8k

[@Iamkabishb]

@@nhk137 Entire border of nepal is according to sugauli treaty which is the only treaty agreed by both sides and accordingly to that treaty it is clear that limpiyadhura is the origin of kali river. People of kalapani, lipulekh hold nepali citizenship. They were part of nepali census. Now i will ask you on what basis indian government is claiming that land their own??

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

Don't know how can any prime minister can give such a crucial area to any country 😩. May be he don't know the importance of that area. May be because at that time china was not neighbour of India, it was Tibet. When china captured Tibet it become threat to India even till now. But historically area is used by India since after sugauli treaty to trade with Tibet and pilgrimage to mt. Kalash before and after independence of India. River is looking starting point from kalapani not limpiyadhura in map. It will be biggest blunder in the history of India if that area gone out of hand to other countries ,the whole national security will be in stake. Kalapani region, galwan valley, dokhlam and Siliguri corridor are 4 most strategic crucial posts to secure India from china .

[@habibuae]

When you see two fish fighting in a pond, you know that the British passed by.

[@pratik11-v7x]

Lauda british there was no dispute in time of British. It is india who is creating border disputes

[@samratxettri6776]

fabricating facts doesn't going to help indian 😒

[@twhkfk7476]

they are indian, what do you expect from them?

[@tivo3720]

Solid proof ?!!! Solid proof is that India deployed its army in that territory during war with China. And it's Nepal who is resently published a new map showing that kalapani is in Nepal. India has not published a new map. Nepal did .

[@madanepal]

I don’t want to prove Kalapani, Lipulekh and Limpiyadhura belongs to Nepal because even a lay man has access to the internet nowadays. India has changed Mahakali river map 3 times itself. All the history and proofs are there. Only Indian prime minister #PmModi ,his diplomats and policy makers might not understand the truth. Not just that much, Darjeeling, Sikkim, kumaon and Garhwal belongs to Nepal. They are indispensable territories of Nepal. Those territories has been colonized since 1816 by British and is under Indian colonizations 1947 onwards. We demand India to return back all Nepalese territories. Colonialism has ended. Several countries in the world got their independents including India. But the same colonial country, India, who fought for indipendens with British is colonizing large areas of Nepal. What does, “शत्यमेव जयते” mean? Will India even able to justify, that, it was the right time to inaugurate roadways in Kalapani? That has been clearly marked, as a disputed area between Nepal 🇳🇵 and India 🇮🇳? The whole world 🌎 is suffering from corona virus🦠. India 🇮🇳 is facing the grave danger. India is the worst nation hit by pandemic. Millions of migrant workers in India are marching back to their home, miles and miles away. 1000s are dying on the way with hunger. Economy is crumbling down in it’s lowest. What does Indian government want to show at the time of global solidarity? Indian government acts are not justifiable. Is this neighborhood first policy of mr #Modi? If, still, India want to show it’s muscles, think twice before It’s too late. What will India gain if it loose a friend like Nepal? Specially at the time, when India might be in need of a real and helpful friend, the most! India is already in war with China and Pakistan at several fronts. 20+ of Indian soldiers are killed by Chinese in Indian border. It’s not wise to add Nepal in the same list and loose more than 50,000 brave soldiers from Indian National security force, The Gorkha Regiment. If Nepalese become enemy, they will become the worst. May be much worse than India now can imagine. Indian clearly knows, Gorkhali are never afraid of death, by birth, they are a soldier. A country called Nepal is in this planet 🌎 from the time of God. All Indians knows. But the world have seen today’s India only from 1947. Stop playing #BigBrother’s role. And Leave Nepal’s colonized land as soon as possible. #backoffindia.

[@Pavan4054]

As long as you acts as puppet of china India dont give a damn about Nepal..dude this is 22 century and you are claiming Indian territories as Nepal's 😂😂..stop enchroching into Indian territories.. gorkha regiment isn't the only force in our country come out of that opinion...even every Indian will fight for the nation when it comes to our India's sovereignty..

[@lowkey4592]

they deployed the troops by taking permission bro...not by their own

[@zionNepal]

Even quint is faking news now. 😂😂

[@neutralboi1984]

@Shreyas Shenoy can't right china? So that's why indian government funded maoist to fight king and uml

[@neutralboi1984]

@Shreyas Shenoy it's all Party politics! Indian government has adminstrated many parties as national parties. It's sure one of them was supporting maoist to destabilize nepal By conducting massacre,killings,etc.

[@neutralboi1984]

@Shreyas Shenoy nepali communist are fighting for democracy and india is democracy. China has no democracy and so does the nepali monarch. China is slowly turning capitalist but authotarian

[@bigenthapa5079]

Nepal, which was never under colonial rule, has long claimed the areas of Limpiyadhura, Kalapani and Lipulekh under the 1816 Sugauli treaty with the British East India Company, although these areas have remained under the control of Indian troops since India fought a war with China in 1962. Source - Aljazeera

[@lavr7196]

Yes correct and just because india has troop there does not make it indian land. However this does not matter because 1950 indo-nepal friendship and peace treaty cancels all previous treaty signed between Nepal and India or British india. Article 8 states Article 8 So far as matters dealt with herein are concerned, this Treaty cancels all previous Treaties, agreements, and engagements entered into on behalf of India between the British Government and the Government of Nepal.

[@bigenthapa5079]

This is the greatest error. If we assume article 8 prevails and cancels 1816 sandhi than India should peacefully handover all the Nepalese land that Nepal lost to British.(From Tista to kangada). Remember how Goa was handedover to India. Nepal lost those land to British India not to "India". So India should have returned land to Nepal after British left the country. There were error and lapses so dispute occured. So 1816 treaty cannot be cancelled for the sake of India itself.

[@bigenthapa5079]

All land captured by british were returned to home country after British left. Alas Lands of Nepal were not returned. Brave gorkhalis protect your boarder and you stab them at their back, take their land and what not. Nepal was going through rough times for decades. India took full benefit of it. "The proposal has been endorsed by over 130 nations except INDIA."- Wikipedia (Nepal as peace zone). India doesnot want to see Nepal as developed nation.

[@lavr7196]

@@bigenthapa5079 Bigen Thapa bro ma ni Nepali ho what I mean is that there is already movement for greater Nepal therefore we should be talking about 1950 indo-nepal friendship and peace treaty as it does cancel Sughauli treaty therefore all the land receded to British india should be returned to Nepal and it is 100% feasible if the government of Nepal presuits it with intent and if we can raise enough awareness then British government must jntervene as it has done for Hong Kong. If you could futher elaborate on the matter of what were the error and lapses that caused dispute?

[@lavr7196]

@@bigenthapa5079 no matter what India will leave all three disputed territory, but if we do raise concerns about the land receded by British india in future than there will excuse that Nepal got what it wanted but wants more therefore we must presue the matter of Greater Nepal with the matter of Lipulekh, Limpiyadhura and Kalapani.

[@PujanGyawali]

We want greater Nepal 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵 #Backoffindia

[@NepalAffairs]

Kalapani lipulekh limpiyadhura belongs to Nepal

[@nhk137]

In ur dreams mate.....😜

[@samipbhetwal8427]

@@nhk137same to you

[@abhishekdas3121]

@L Lk yeah just cry like that....kalapani will remain under the control o india

[@lalitakhatiwada6544]

Brother first read history and come nepal & india boder was diveded by mahakali river not kali river 😁😁😁

[@techieAjay]

As many did in comments below, your bringing the death of Indian national near border is totally irrelevant, biased and incendiary, and does anything but to help to resolve the issue peacefully. That incident happened far away from disputed border, and you're coinciding the deployment of APF by Nepal and the incident in such a manner that all can see no more than an attempt to provoke people's sentiment. If you're doing any responsible journalism, you need to present the fact as is without distortion, do more research on the topic and inspire more amicable solution to the issue given the current volatile situation in the region. Truth prevails.

[@sagarlama9767]

You clearly mentioned that British then shifted the origin of the river but many don't know that even if we follow the other eastern side of the river as the boundary,the kalapani and lipulekh region comes to be part of Nepal while limpiadhula and other villages come to be in india,in any way,India has held many parts of Nepal...It is being what China is being to India..

[@rupesh9107]

what kind of historical facts does india still demand▪︎ Nepal already posses the signed treaty, Vat receipts from people of lipulekh, census document, books written about nepal by international authors during british rule in india. mismanagement of covid-19 is not the failure of govt even india doesnot have beds for patient at this time. the only fact that indian govt need is the mere acknowledgement by nepal govt that india is a powerful nation and no one shall stand against it unless you are powerful enough. indian media is the only reason behind anti india sentiments through out the world.

[@shovakhanal9232]

Why can't u say that it's Nepal's land.

[@一國兩制-o8p]

Indians want everything.

[@amritkunwar22]

The Indian citizen that was killed was not because of border issue it was because he with other people were forcibly trying to enter Nepalese territory and during their stand off with APF he was accidentally shot.

[@SaparHarai]

1st of all British india company was an aggressor within India too so it took Nepali territory doesn't mean India shoul do the same. I am neither Nepali nor Indian but i ahve seen many videos on this issue. My conclusion is it is Nepal's territor so India should restrain! 🙏

[@filmonism]

The people who have been enslaved for 1500-1600 years by the various empires they really don't know who are allies and who are the enemy. They just look all around suspiciously. Great! Keep making neighboring countries enemies. The people of Nepal don't want any kind of problems and conflict with any country. We want to create historic great relationships with all the neighboring countries. But don't force us to create a healthy relationship by sacrificing our nationality and sovereignty. We are known as "BRAVE GURKHA" and "BRAVERY" is in our blood.

[@samuelrajasekhar7911]

India doesn't seem to have good neighborly relations. Pakistan, Nepal, China.

[@darkwizard460]

Dont forget Bhutan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka as well.

[@Alex-ub6te]

Indians think that the whole of South Asia and the Indian Ocean belonged to them. They invaded Hyderabad and annexed Sikkim

[@cheelew5149]

#Article 8 of the Peace Treaty of 1950 has declared #Sugauli Treaty to be null and void which means 60,000 Sq km of Nepali land ceded to Britain must be returned to Nepal according to the international law. India on the other hand has never respected the sovereignty of her smaller neighbours and keeps on hurting the sentiments of Nepalese and the gurkhas (who are recruited from Nepal to seven different regiments of Gorkha Rifles in the Indian Army). India should never forget their past during 200 years of British Raj. India must respect the sovereignity of all her smaller neighbours. They should know the sovereignty of all the nations are equal whether they are geographically big or small. The ego of feeling of being a powerful nation will eventually destroy India if it continues hurting, provoking and torturing its closest neighbour. * Joker Firstly, we Nepalese genuinely have no problem or hatred for india citizens. the problem is only with indian modi government to be very specific which is fair enough for blockade and dominance over small country where there is roti beti sambandh.. Secondly, I have seen many comments in social media where indian citizens are saying we take islamic country like Pakistan as our genuine friend which is so incorrect. neither we have open border like with india nor we have any access to their culture or traditions. Thirdly most of the indian citizens thinks that we stay in China's lap or some other shit. but the fact is modi government created gap between our good relation with blockade, political interference, interference while drafting constitution, border capture and so on. china just fill that gap as we all know that china is pure business man. Lastly indian people will say that the blockade is not done by indian government. to them please check video on KZbin where opposition party of india themselves spoke against this blockade. I’m sorry i forgot name of that politician but you will find them. Dexter Kuaji Pure lie from indian side. They annexed territory disputed by Nepal in new map. India exposed its expansionist ideology to occupy parts of Nepal by releasing a revised map that showed Kalapani, a disputed territory, as a part of India. This move was to test Nepal's resolve and how much courage it has for its conviction that the territory belongs to Nepal. Nepal immediately objected. Kathmandu subsequently called India for settling the boundary issues on the disputed regions of Kalapani and Susta and has been urging India ever since to settle the matter. At this, the Nepal PM had also offered to send his special envoy Madhav Nepal for sorting out the issue, but India refused to meet him. The crisis deepened earlier this month, 8 May, when Defence Minister Rajnath Singh inaugurated a shorter route, which is going to be motorable, to Kailash Mansarovar for Indian pilgrims. The road connects Uttarakhand’s Pithoragarh with the Lipulekh Pass - which Nepal considers as part of its own territory - at the India-China border. After learning India's true aggresive and occupational intentions, Nepali Prime Minister Oli had no coice but to defend Nepal's sovereignty and upon thorough deliberations with security advisors, his government decided to stand up to Modi's aggressive India because appeasement does not serve an aggressor. Nepal decided to react Tit-for-Tat and officially unveiled a new political map showing Kalapani, Limpiyadhura and Lipulekh as parts of Nepal. Portions of these areas are considered by India as its territory. The Nepalese government reportedly moved a constitutional amendment bill to revise the map in their national emblem, which has since been approved by the parliament. In this way, the tiny but brave nation of Nepal has taken on an increasingly hostile aggressive India to task, which raised havoc in New Delhi - which under Modi's hindutva superiority agenda was blinded and dellusional of its make-believe power status after having been pampered by Trump's USA to contain China's rise. Chitra Dhungana I am indian and i think india should not be careless or agressive in such a sensitive matter i e land ownership. Economic blockade was our mistake and let this step should not again be reponsible in pushing nepal towards china more. That small chunk of land is not worthy than our bilateral relationship. Nepal should remain our strong ally/ friend / partner in all aspects. Grow up guys... Foids Felds What has happened to foreign policy, seems world has become an ally against India One side Nepal One side China Other side Pak Bhutan seems to join China Russia is already with China America is not coming to help against China as well European Union passed a resolution against India concerning human rights violation Arab countries stand by their relationship Is Modi just sleeping with their cabinet and what generals are going to do with China or Nepal or Pak..... Is it just bragging at media betraying nation and looting people's taxes? Mat Payne 2 hours ago, India is like a person that everybody hates... Alone with no friends Rip india Highlighted comment @no Lim-Buh 6 hours ago My dear corrupted Indian govt officials, don’t try to erase the history (but you already did sadly, and we haven’t forgotten). It’s all written in the treaties made between the then Royal Nepalese and the British East Indian Company. You can also check maps of 1960s and 1980s and you can clearly see THAT land under the kingdom Of Nepal. Clearly this current government is going to cause lots of hatred towards india and i can see it breaking apart soon. No disrespect to my indian brothers but this government, infact all is so corrupted that its sucking everything out of it Victor Chew 3 hours ago, India being colonised by the British, forced to grow poppy instead of food to enrich the British. Remember the East India Company. Still believe those countries, India need a better government, the pandemic has shown the ineptitude of their leader. Spent so much money to prop up trump's visit, while its people left to walk, cycle thousands of miles heading home many without food and water. Build relationships with your neighbours and work together for mutual benefits. Come on India, learn from mistakes and history of humiliation. Ahad One 4 hours ago (edited) India is the most corrupt country on this earth. They grabbed illegally lands from all its neighbouring countries, even didn’t spare its allies too. Juna garh, Kashmir are two most common examples. Laddakh and Nepal's border areas are other examples. These are not issuing that are impossible to solve but Indian govt always want to go by muscle and doesn’t believe in peaceful talks. That’s the reasons these conflicts have gone long and had not been solved. Indian govt does not want to listen anybody else but want to push its own point of views on others. Ask them to talk and they would say "negotiations can be done on all issues except the main root cause." That’s crazy and nonsense policy has pushed Modi'a Hindutava India ro clash all of its neighbours. You cannot show everybody muscle, sometimes you have to show wisdom and respect. Prashant Acharya that's the problem here, how pathetic & low Standard Indian media & there contain have become. India in all these year have learned only to blame neighbouring countries for their own failure. Being Bully won’t help india this type of action will only create more hatred & anti indian sentiment from Nepalese side. It is in the best interest of India to come out of colonial mindset. Remember Indian acting unilaterally and showing muscular power won’t take india anywhere... how can your country be safe when you are affecting your neighbouring countries Show less REPLY

[@subhraghimire2486]

Those are our lands 🇳🇵 ! Most of the information provided are FAKE!

[@dhanairado1360]

We’re not fighting for the land we’re fighting for the water in south Asia Kathmandu

[@gk_challenge_bd]

To overshadow political instability 😂🤣😂...Modi government is getting its own medicine...

[@parasmanirawal7455]

And i thought @The Quint is one true journalist that points out true facts based on proofs.. well i was wrong... and limpiadhura has nothing to do with killing of an indian.. i dont support violence of any sort.. but do some research on how many nepalese are killed just to protect their own land from your INNOCENT biharis. Our stronger and larger small brother India, we dont want to develop hatred of any sort with our own brother. All we ever want is our sovereignty to be respected as we respect yours. Come on Indian brothers, why are you forgetting that we are twin sons of same prachin sanatan dharma mother, who shared same sindh valley. Our heartfelt condolences to the Brave Indian souls that lost life in recent battle. We are with you brothers. But, we really want our sovereignty to be respected

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

We cannot give that crucial strategic region to any country 😩. Kalapani region, galwan valley and Siliguri corridor are 3 most important post of India to secure from china. At that time Tibet was neighbour of India not china. We value Nepal relationship and sovereignty but not on the cost of national security. We don't want to disturb relation with Nepal on that small area. India don't want to bully other countries and we never do but we don't have any option right now in such war situation😫. If we will remain secured then we with help Nepal also. There is no point of hatred between Indians and Nepali, not even Pakistani. Indian and Pakistanis are best friends in foreign countries and always helped each other in difficult situation. Even when there was earthquake in Nepal in 2015, we conduct blood donation camp for Nepalis in need. Please see this kzbin.info/www/bejne/omWseZeBraeUosU We cannot go against Nepal even Nepali is our one of official language. I hope now both the countries maintain status quo and rebuild the friendship.

[@darkwizard460]

All India medias are same. Avoid them and yes dont forget to dislike and report.

[@parasmanirawal7455]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 First of all thank you for the help during Earthquake. we understand your concern, well there can be win win situation. May be Financial lease is as option, or some other possible option that are viable for both countries. Any way, government will find a way, lets not spread hatred and those who are spread hatred, lets ignore them.. Long Live SOVEREIGN Brotherhood.

[@jeevanraut2500]

It's not a new matter A farmer from kanchanpur Nepal at indo Nepal border have full documentation of land from 2036 BSF threatened him and now they patrol in those area lots of story are hidden like that If that is roti-beti Ka rishta then what we should expect

[@vincy9394]

Dear Nepali brothers and sisters , never trust China . We can sort of issues peacefully .

[@trickynations1329]

Oi bihari backoff don't teach us

[@bottle676]

Your government dominate Nepal. Your media threaten Nepal and Nepalese people. Your UP minister backlash Nepal time to time. Your Indian army chief says Nepal did this because they are puppet of China indirectly. Indian people are bullying Nepal without knowing the true fact. Indian media already manipulate the whole facts. India media can do debate but cannot show proofs that prove that territories of India. Indian media is bullying PM of Nepal. Can they do same with Donald Trump or Modi?? It clear shows India dominates Nepal. The team to resolve this issue was made two times. But India destroyed the team. India don't even ask to Nepal to make road that goes through or near the Nepali border. It also clearly shows India dominate Nepal. Don't your media can make any news without including Pakistan and China?? Nepal has sent 37 letters and 16 mails to India since 2014. Are they are agree to talk with Nepal?? Rather than talk, they did blockaged. Now, also Nepal should be quite. Enough is enough

[@Pavan4054]

@@bottle676 India will talk when Nepal isn't the puppet of china..for now stop enchroching into Indian territories

[@bigenthapa5079]

I wonder about low literacy rate in India.

[@rojenranahochha]

I wonder about Indian citizen begging for food in nepal

[@bigenthapa5079]

@Rakesh Kumar 68% indians live under $2 and 30% indians live under $1.25 per day which is below poverty line. Its only because of your media you think you are rich country. India is a poor country.

[@bigenthapa5079]

@@rojenranahochha India reported the most number of deaths of children below five years in 2018, with 8,82,000 deaths because of malnutrition. So feed your population properly.After India, Nigeria reported the highest number of such deaths (8,66,000), followed by Pakistan (4,09,000), Democratic Republic of Congo (2,96,000), and Ethiopia (1,91,000). How inhumane is your government. Even congo feeds their children better than you.

[@tanujsharma2653]

@@bigenthapa5079 ok, how about CEOs of biggest companies like Microsoft, google, adobe are indians. How about the developments in space technology made by ISRO. And where the fuck are u getting ur stats from? Global times. Honestly, can expect something like this from a Pakistani or Chinese, but u guys are just taking it to whole different level.

[@tanujsharma2653]

@@bigenthapa5079 and about literacy rate its more than 80 percent in 2020, definitely more than nepal. I dont expect u to believe it, and couldn't care less about it honestly if you believe it or not.

[@huskieification]

@The Quint, dude you are just scratching the tip of the iceberg. Nepal was fully utilizing the territory till 1962. Nepalese administrators carried out tax collection activities and even successfully held local elections. When China India war broke out, Nehru saw there was a wide field in Kalapani that India could use to check China; but he also knew that it was west of Kali river and belonged to Nepal. So, Nehru wrote letter personally to the then king of Nepal asking for permission to ground Indian troops there. After Indian troops occupied the land, they stopped Nepalese administrators from going there and carry out any tasks. So, please do research and put full information. Anyways, it's nature of the world, that big countries encroaching smaller countries territory by force and deceivement, be it Russia in Crimea, China in Galwan, or India in Kalapani-Limluadhura.

[@sisimarusensei9497]

This video is 95% true.About the deployment of indian army,they were given permission by the then king mahendra shah of nepal to watch over the chinese military in kalapani.And about the china using nepal,there is not any proof about that.So,don't believe what the media says.We're neighbours.We help you with gurkha army to give your nation a protection and you helps us with our employment.So there shouldn't be hate between each other.

[@vijayrawat09]

Watch studyiq and Dhruv Rathee lecture i dont think whatever you said is full info.

[@abisekmndhr3620]

Study iq is part of godi social media. They give wrong and very offensive remarks of this issue. Watch BBC hindi's video regarding this issue.

[@lakpachhiringsherpa2220]

Its our territory not Indian territory..stop saying it's Indian territory....

[@freeinternet6582]

Yet again biased reporting and manipulating facts. If India had deployed troops on Nepalese land that doesn't mean that land belongs to India now, there are many countries that deploy troops to keep an eye on enemy movements, US has a whole base in Germany, does that mean US should occupy Germany now? have some common sense please. India started building roads on Nepalese land just for it's own advantage and didn't even talk with Nepal government, that's why the whole problem began. We helped you with land and strategically to fight China in the past, and now just because you are stronger now you occupy our land?

[@nowwhat6716]

Before china now you r blaming British for it enough with this blame games🤫 until 1962 Nepal conducted census, collected land revenue and issued land registration certificates in these areas. Only after indian war with china that land was taken from us .I call it backstabbing ✌

[@changamanga100]

This video clearly shows that Nepalese claim is based on historic grounds. That Nepal King did not object to British India's illegal use of land does not validate Indian claim.

[@victorstarry4273]

The Kali river which is also known as Mahakali river originates from Limpiyadhura. The river flows from the Limpiyadhura looks the real river, because it is big and wide than the 2 others rivers which flow from Lipulekh and Kalapani look small and these are only the stream. In Sugauli treaty, this is written that eastern part is Nepal and western part is India from the Mahakali river.

[@aAverageFan]

But these areas have been under British and then Indian control since the 1860s so Nepal can't claim them after more than one and a half century.

[@dragonkaanxa]

we are not claimaing that are belong to us.we gave it to the british cuz of sugauli treaty.when british moved from india they didn't return that area also sikkim,darjeeling,deharadun,kangara.

[@loveu7515]

United Nations of Momos...😆😆😆. Earlier every country is in Nepal, with Nepal...now they realised only india occupied their country.

[@HerunAdhikari]

Not India and Nepal the treaty was between Nepal and British East India company.

[@kabirshrestha]

*Does India Abide with the Sugauli Treaty?? *If "NO" India has to return all the land to Nepal before the Treaty, which Nepal is not asking. *If "Yes" as you said Treaty was done in 1816 with the boarder starting from Limpiyadhura. Can you unilaterally change the map if there was a bilateral treaty prior?? Does the second party of the treaty must accept any future changes made by first party for his good. Does a treaty work this way?? *India says we have been there for so long Nepal did not protest. If someone occupy your land by force or agreement for very long time, Does that mean occupied land is Theres?

[@sandeshsapkota2323]

you are having problem by the deploy of few Armed police to patrol. But what about 5000+ Indian Army with airforce deployed in Kalapani. Thats the attitude of typical south asian bully.

[@abhishekdas3121]

Sounds good , india air force jindabad , army jindabad......jai hind🙂👌

[@ChandishSipai]

@@abhishekdas3121 what's funny is your media having problem with a few hundreds of our APF deployed at the border, compared to the thousand of your forces deployed at the same place😆😆😆😆😆

[@ranjitjena9540]

No matter that land border was part of British India now succussed to republic of India Britishers made this conflict non of business on Indian govt

[@rajushrestha786]

We Are NEPALES Gurkhali And is Our territorry.

[@NiranjanMalakar]

India should respect to Sugauli Treaty 1816 between Nepal and British India. According to the Treaty, Nepal's western Border is Kalee River that frows from Limpiyadhura where Biggest tribut to Kalee River starts from and this tribut was called Kalee River in the MAP during the treaty signing time. India manipulated the river, Renamed the river, and rebuilt new Kalee River and new Kalee temple artificially in order to annex Nepalese Territory. India Should feel ashamed of it. Leave Nepalese territories and BACK OF INDIA. It is NOTHING to do with any other country but it is about Nepal's DIGNITY and SOVEREIGNTY. Nepal let India to use that territory during/after India- China War 1962 as a Friend. But India BETRAYED NEPAL ignoring to leave the Nepalese Territory since a long time. India ignored many time of Nepal's request. Nepal has border dispute with India, not only in Kalapani and Susta but 23 of 26 Nepalese districts that touches to India have border problem with India. SHAME ON YOU INDIA. There are two different of Nepalese who work in India. Nepalese origin Indian citizens who are from the territories when Nepal LOST to British India and Now these territories are in India. If you do not want these people, you must return all Nepalese territories that Nepal lost to British India but NOT to India because these territories have been occupied by India illegally because British India should have left these territories to Nepal but not to India. Another thing is, of course, Nepalese Citizens who work in India according to free movement between Nepal and India, there is also many INDIAN CITIZENS who works in Nepal too. India gets much more remittance money from Nepal than Nepal gets remittance money from India. It is NOT Nepal's interest to have free movement between India and Nepal because India has 1.3 Billion and Nepal has 29 millions. who will benefits most when there is free movement ??? Another thing is Nepal was NOT part of British India if you do not have any free movement between India and Bangladesh and Pakistan because you guys were parts of British India. THEN, WHY SHOULD THERE BE FREE MOVEMENT BETWEEN NEPAL AND INDIA ACCORDING TO NEPAL AND INDIA FRIENDSHIP TREATY 1950??? WE CALL IT VERY UNBALANCED TREATY THAT SHOULD BE NULLIFIED AS SOON AS POSSIBLE. SAME TREATY NULLIFIED THE SUGAULI TREATY 1816, WHY HAS INDIA BEEN KEEPING NEPALESE TERRITORIES THAT LOST TO BRITISH INDIA ??? If India does not respect to the Treaty 1816, India MUST leave all territories which Nepal LOST to British India. These territories includes Darjeeling, Kumao and Gadhawal and etc. What do you think ?

[@plantgarden669]

Please i request you to study history. In 1962 Indian troops were put out at kalapani.

[@deepak1952]

Actually that land belongs to Nepal but we are brothers politicians makes people fight so sad

[@amarnathjha8319]

Nepali land is Indian land and Nepalis are Indian citizens from ancient times: In Vedic period, India's northern border had always been the mighty HIMALAYA, not the Nepal., because Nepal did not exist. Nepal was never an independent country prior to Islamic subjugation of India. During the Ramayana period (Indian Itihas) , you find Janki's father Janak ruling one of the Janpad VIDEH. VIDEH was the region from the Himalaya to Ganga and from Kousiki to Gandaki. There was not any Nepal at that time. Janaki Mata (a historical figure and Hindu icon) was an Indian, not a Nepali. She was always addressed as Janaki or Videhi or Maithili and never as Nepali in Valmiki Ramayana. During the Mahabharat(Another Indian Itihas), Pandavs went to retire in the Himalaya, not in Nepal as it did not exist. The Mahabharata War was an Indian Civil War for the throne of Hastinapur kingdom. Kings from different parts of the Indian subcontinent participated in that Civil War as Indian kings. Yes India was ruled by small kingdoms or Janapads, but in a bigger political sense they were all interlinked internal states of BHARATA(India), not as if they were independent sovereign countries. Travel records, Trade records, expansion of Hinduism and Buddhism, ancient literature provide clear evidence of this fact. Current Kathmandu was the part of VIDEH janapada during the Ramayana period and of the Vajji during Mahabharat. Nepal was not a separate sovereign country in the long known history of India. It is a recent event, which does not make sense. Every inch of Nepali land is Indian land. There should be peaceful political realignment to re-integrate Nepal into India. You ca

[@FirstNameLastName-tu9ui]

Lmao India used to be ruled by Muslims does that mean it is property of Pakistan ?There was no India in ancient times just the culture was there ,your arguements are of borders of countries in the ancient world, hell in the modern world India was part of Britain that does not mean you're still part of Britain or a part of India is British now does it.

[@rkslim8385]

First u must know that there's only one treaty between nepal and British which is treaty of sugauli in 1816 and this treaty demarcated border as eastern parts of kali river is nepal and western parts is British India and tere is no other treaty. We all are aware that according to international border law both countries have to agree to define country borders in map. As I know that in kalapani region there was presence of India army in 1962 after Indo-China war. In that particular region it was under Nepal territory until 1961. And we have conducted elections in 1959, we have been collecting land revenue until 1960 in that region, we had conducted census in 1958 in that region and we have kept secure all this evidences. We are urging to Indian government for negotiation to resolve the issues however this issues are kept pending since very long time. Being good neighbour and being powerful nation India suppose to resolve all issues however India is publishing new political map and inaugurating road to Kailash Mansarovar. Now, we had published new political map of Nepal and Indiana media, politician, public are saying nepal is puppets of China. Let's come in the table and resolve the border issues. Indian policy makers should understand that Nepal is good neighbour country and we always stand in Indian side and keep always good relation with India than any other countries in the world.

[@NiranjanMalakar]

So, ARROGANT to tell British move border from Limpiadhuri to Lipulekh because of strategic importance of area, you do not robbed your friend's territories and Indian army moved to this territories after 1962 war with Nepal's consent or not to lend territories but we NEVER HAD ANGREEMENT SIGNED by both partners, neighter between British India and Nepal or between Nepal and India. WHEN WE DID NOT SIGNED ANY AGREEMENT ABOUT BORDER means it is border between Nepal and India is the Kali River that flows from Limpiadhuri. You must know that this is the biggest tribute to Kali River and it was called Kali River before and during Sugauli Treaty 1962. It is still called Kuti Yangti in local language that means Kali River even India renamed lipu tribute Kali River. SHAMEFUL.

[@dhanao4069]

Old rivalry in South Asia Kathmandu Nepal vs india this will never go away from Kathmandu Nepal army power settings

[@小河清水]

Beware: India's territorial ambitions are enormous! I/3 Nepal's land was annexed by India! India annexed Kingdom of Sikkim, India annexed the China's south Tibet( Illegal Arunchal Gang),....

[@Abhijeet-uk9cl]

So so sad, but you must know that all this territories are very small in comparison to the Tibet that China has annexed.

[@Arjunbas1]

Why do you only report that Nepalese security killed Indian and why don't you report how many Nepalese are killed by Indian SSB at borders. And also the Indian killed at border is an incident which is completely different with the border issues.

[@balaajumboy4763]

How poorly explained according to sugauli sandii mahakali river is the boundary between Nepal and India parbati kund is the origin of river kali which is in limpiyadhura not in kalapani where cleverley indian army made a temple of kali and made artificial pounds showing this is origin of river kali indian cleaverly occupied Nepal's teritory since india china war after india defeat the war indian army made post in kalapani

[@b.k.8625]

Not within indian boarders...it,s nepal territories.

[@ojeshpradhan7463]

Person killed in border has nothing to do with mahakali dispute. Group of People were trying to snatch a armed personnel weapons. Never post will a little facts to make it a bigger issue.

[@ramailoritulamichhane9541]

कालापानी लिपुलेख लिम्पियाधुरा पेहेला भि नेपाल का हे अभि भि नेपाल का हे

[@acesolta4045]

Shame on India for occupying land of Nepal

[@maheshpatil3964]

Nepal is a part of Hindu Religion people, it is part of Akhand Bharat, Nepal must merge in India.

[@ujwalregmi8749]

No more hindu rastra both are secular

[@ramprasadsharma1775]

kali originates at limpidhura

[@karshyoldiary3465]

Lol king mahendra already make objection before that

[@srijanlama6446]

We have disputed area in sustaa region too. We got pissed when ur government unilaterally built road in disputed region of kalapani and some of ur politician and paid media outlets without knowing the facts calling us chinese puppet.

[@sunjeeppun1]

Mr anchor, there's something called research which most journalists do. I suggest you to do more research and report it at a journalist but first liberate yourself from the mentality of what India do is right.

[@laxmanrana9699]

Are bhai, Agar ye India ka tha toh, suddenly 2019 me hi kyun map me dal diya. Pehle sehi hona tha. Apna map dekho pahleka aur bolo. Tum logo le dala. Hamne bhi dal diya.

[@Arjunbas1]

Great that you have agreed that Limpiyadhura is the origin of river kali and so according to Sugauli treaty, the territory on the east of river kali belongs to Nepal. India claims river kali originates from a kali temple below kalapani where they have created a fake kali river by collecting water in a small pond and passing that water in a canal and claims that canal is kali river. What a joke India, what a shame.

[@hemangshrivastava9561]

We still want that area because that area most crucial for India's National security. Don't know how can any prime minister can give such a crucial area to any country 😩. May be he don't know the importance of that area. May be because at that time china was not neighbour of India, it was Tibet. When china captured Tibet it become threat to India even till now. But historically area is used by India since after sugauli treaty to trade with Tibet and pilgrimage to mt. Kalash before and after independence of India. River is looking starting point from kalapani not limpiyadhura in map. It will be biggest blunder in the history of India if that area gone out of hand to other countries ,the whole national security will be in stake. Kalapani region, galwan valley, dokhlam and Siliguri corridor are 4 most strategic crucial posts to secure India from china .

[@Arjunbas1]

@@hemangshrivastava9561 We Nepalese know that part is strategically important to India but that does not mean that India can occupy it. Nepal let India stay there since 1962 without opposing much but what India did is started to claim as its own, making fake kali river and worse it did by provoking Nepal by including all of that area in its map in Nov 2019. Nepal issued several protest notes, asked for talks but India kept ignoring. The matter was worse when India inaugurated the road. For your reference about the kali river and the kalapani area look at the satellite images from google map.

[@ujwolshrestha8740]

just a typical indian speaking more than he actually understands.

[@suzalbasnet3753]

indian folks new song is out by rapper name called (ease is easy) songe name called modified it is in youtube just listen to that song with turning your captions on so that indian can understand enjoy

[@jivangurung7642]

troops were placed there with permission and not only there india placed troops inside nepal as well in 14/15 different places......nepal was helping india defeat china but instead what it got today.....all 14/15 troops post were later removed but not this one coz of key advantage point now today india bully nepal and doesnt want to move from there and claims as its own

[@mrnaba9679]

You have wrong information.

[@sanjeev9-j8y]

Now the Nepali (Gurkha army) should be brought back to India. And you have to give a job in Nepal Army. Now there is also a need to mobilize the Nepal Army in Limpiadhura. It is also relative to time. Now is the right time for the ongoing border dispute between Nepal and India. According to Indian media, India has more than 1.4 million troops and Nepal has less than one million. Smaller and less populous countries than Nepal, Singapore and Cambodia have more troops than Nepal.

[@rameshniraula4757]

By the way ,for your kind information king gave the land to india trops for camp until the war is over and do research more from nepal and india side.dont take india media as source.dont mislead people we nepalese love indians and also request to media dont mislead people plz.just search for facts

[@sanjeevsahu2951]

Nepal will not take others land. And will not give his land to other country. Nepal always been a independent country. And nepali people know this better. Nepali citizen can kill or die for it's country because our encestors dint teach us slavery... Nepal hav it's own great history.. Nepali people live for it's country. JAI NEPAL, JAI GORKHALI 🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵🇳🇵

[@Pavan4054]

😂😂😂

[@kathmandu121]

Better reporting, compared to yellow journalism practiced by most of Indian media. Indians are more aware of their media, to what level they can go for TRP. Only Issue is -- India has mentality that if it wants to do anything on border related issues, then it will go ahead, but, if Nepal has any concern, then it has to get agreement from India. Big brother attitude. These area were kept as status quo since both parties could not reach in agreement since 1990s. Then, in 2015 India and China signs treaty to do trade from this area, in June, 2019 India includes these area in its map, and now Indian government is making road over it. That is how problem started.

[@Pavan4054]

India laying the road in it's territory no need to ask Nepal and stop acting as puppet of china

[@sakeshlimbu6025]

Its not kali its mahakali when you can say another river mechi correctly why cannot you say mahakali oh you have war with china and using our high ground land to fight ccp stop blaming neutral country you cannot treat your own country men kashmiris in the name of nationalism blind followers of bjp

[@Rawalrecords]

News is fals on a person shot by nepali police its a local case not an national case plz need to be corrected

[@prakashkhadka5905]

Plz check Indian old map 1946 .there is evidence.

[@kapil4417037]

Why india keep on refusing to talk with nepal on border issue? Because india knows the fact that nepal have proof and india is scared of it.

[@su2m86sp]

If the area truely belongs to india why havent india discussed the issue with nepal even though nepal seeks diplomatic talk(not that shitty debate with loud voice and not logic)? My grandpa travelled mansarobar through the kalapani area which clearly had nepalese citizens and population census was taking place then all of a sudden war broke out between china and india. War was over but since india knew the value of such land so they snatched it hoping handing rashan card would make a strong claim in future. If all official try to solve this dispute, it will go to nepal. Indian is therefore ignoring the talk. the reason is indian official clearly knows that the area belongs to nepal and they cant win the argument. So all they do is ignoring nepal officials and pay loud tv anchors to spread propaganda... clearly india is concerned about the fact that this might weaken their legitimacy about disputed area with china and pakistan. Thats what india gets when they play imperialism..

[@trickynations1329]

Map was not based on trade it was in river

[@nagendrapoudyal8124]

India got two options follow sugauli treaty or we Nepalese should go to our previous map of greater Nepal map which includes kumau garwal parts of up Bihar darjelling and Sikkim our bottom line is clear