The study doesn't say that they couldn't tell the two parts. It's saying that professionals can't distinguish which is Strad, and which is new, and audience and professionals 60% prefer the sound of newer violins (while can't identify them).
@jasminewu59284 жыл бұрын
@@dustintsai1839 ganna want to tell you something funny , if there's a violinist like Paganini ,I mean any of perfect violinist, they can play a very beautiful sound even you use a $100USD violin. So the only problem isn't about violin but who play it😏
其實已經把這些古琴當成古董、名畫收藏品了!音色根本沒有特別特別的好,玩古董和名畫收藏的人都知道,說穿了都是吹捧,把這些古琴當期貨炒,滿可笑的!影片後段,也通過多種科學手段、測試與實驗,證明了新琴音質比古琴來的更好、更棒!所以..........最後結論就是,一般普羅大眾,還是乖乖的去買類似yamaha v20或是suzuki No.550等級的小提琴足以,這兩把已經是該品牌裡的高檔價位琴,換算台幣也不過8萬~12萬之間!超過這個價位的琴,又是不知名作坊的小提琴,真不值得購入,除非它得到小提琴公認組織的認可和發證,不然它就是一把純粹自娛娛人在家自己玩耍的琴,將來若是想變賣,可能當初100萬購入,出手時連2萬都賣不到。 奉勸家裡有學音樂、學小提琴的小朋友的家長們,千萬不要落入小提琴老師的陷阱,打著為小朋友好的名堂要你升級小提琴,實際上就是無良的想賺一大筆中間差價!家長若真要買高品質琴,又要有保障!那就買大眾品牌的樂器,如yamaha、suzuki,其他一堆鬼品牌就不要考慮了,更不要相信小提琴老師的建議,家長們直接到京東直營店下單購買yamaha v20的琴(在yamaha官網的最列表裡,它已是最高級的小提琴"Exceptional Quality and Value"),全套也才86000,花個運費也就88000元,不到10萬台幣!
@si168co56 жыл бұрын
真不知道這裡多少批評的人分得出來violin 跟viola的差別~
@YenchihZass5 жыл бұрын
於閑 一支比較大,一支比較小
@jasonwong78655 жыл бұрын
什麼是viola (壞笑
@bosco_c64315 жыл бұрын
黃業竣 中提琴
@bosco_c64315 жыл бұрын
黃業竣 用alto clef(中音譜號)
@bosco_c64315 жыл бұрын
黃業竣 就是比高音譜號低一點
@user-qk1ci1cf6v5 жыл бұрын
如果不久前的國中生摔的是這把琴的話.....
@user-xc4mk4nh1l5 жыл бұрын
可能要貝多芬才聽的出吧?
@francoislamarche27955 жыл бұрын
葉辰子 你开玩笑吧 贝多芬听得见吗?
@user-zy8wk5yy5q5 жыл бұрын
我猜他故意的...
@bluehuang20035 жыл бұрын
...... 請閉眼仔細的聽,真的是不一樣的...
@user-lt9ft8vx7x5 жыл бұрын
但是又怎樣原製琴者也去世 拿最多的是轉賣者
@user-fx6py2nd4z5 жыл бұрын
我不會解釋但真的有差!
@dustintsai18394 жыл бұрын
But which is Strad? You're misunderstanding the study
@user-fx6py2nd4z4 жыл бұрын
@@dustintsai1839 抱歉我不懂小提琴 可以的話可以解釋下這實驗的意義嗎?
@dustintsai18394 жыл бұрын
@@user-fx6py2nd4z The double-blinded study is where both the violinists and audience all do not know and cannot see the violins they're playing (so cannot tell which are old Stradivarius and which are new violins). This study was repeated many times where many Strads were compared to newly made professional violins. The results were than both the professional violinists and audience all could not tell which were the Strads and which were the new violins; rather, when asked to which violin sounds did they prefer, 60% of the people, including the professional musicians, preferred the new violins over the old Strads. But if they can see they're playing the Strads, then they'll say Strads are better, of course...