FAIR ISLE KNITTING: A Benjamin Burton Short Doc

[@chrisb1682]

Lovely film... would’ve preferred without the music during the interviews as competing with the people speaking. Gorgeous filming. Thank you for sharing 🌿

[@winniemortier5634]

I agree competely

[@kathosim501]

I agree too - it’s a bit too loud during the bird interviews especially. But a better film than I could make!

[@Terrestriellie]

So glad the wool needles hands podcast led me here, what a lovely piece of film

[@57sduffy]

Me, too!

[@conniedunfield7601]

Thanks Benjamin I loved your film because I love to knit and learning the history & background of different methods of knitting makes knitting mean so much more to me than just a hobby or craft. And yes, we all need to "Wise Up" Thanks

[@marlenejensen8881]

This popped up in my knitting feed. Watched it and 100% enjoyed it. Keep up the good work....now I’m off to watch your other videos.

[@jenniferlopez7205]

Loved this so much! As a knitter, I am always thankful to find true explorations of the art and process of knitting. Thank you for shining a light on such a beautiful knitting tradition.

[@flourchylde]

I LOVE this video. It was so entertaining and instructive and introduced us to a part of the world few of us will ever see. As an avid knitter, a lover of Shetland wool and semi-skilled at Fair Isle knitting, I was enthralled throughout the entire video. My only comment would be to lower the volume of the music (or delete it entirely) during the interviews. It made it difficult to understand the heavy Scottish accents. Thanks for sharing your talents with us.

[@wildrose7546]

Superb video. Very professional and well done for making the journey there. I'm from the UK and very few of us even get to The Shetlands, let alone the Fair Isles 👏

[@drrd4127]

Shetland is in the UK, it is part of the Scottish islands AKA the Kingdom of Scotland that makes up the UNITED Kingdom

[@russellburton3288]

Dude I can't even begin to say how proud I am of you this is you added to your first semester and now you're producing it is the end of your last semester and it is unbelievably Dynamic active dude there's so many ways that I want to describe and analyze that but you did such a good job man your mother would be proud I am so proud of what you've done Beyond I don't know what else to say man I love you

[@scotttenenbaum27]

Really great job. For reasons I don’t understand I recently became fascinated with Fair Isle. I was thrilled to find your piece. It was perfect. thank you.

[@kevenwalters5632]

I loved this. Thank you. Great job. I especially loved the woman whom the island adopted, and she adopted its ways

[@lavieestduresansconfiture3912]

Had no problems with the sound. Thanks for this little masterpiece. And the clicking was amazing.

[@freiwm]

Beautiful film. Thanks for doing it and sharing I am an old granny knitter and found the background music and sounds made the interviews difficult to hear. Using subtitles was distracting because of so many wrong words. Fair Isle was always printed as feral. But lovely and informative film.

[@catherinerosengren3122]

Thx for stopping it I loved the film I fair island knit

[@sylviajensen2412]

This is wonderful. I love fair isle knits. I can’t believe you actually went. So cool. I looked into how to get there at one point too but you did it. Really lovely video. Enjoyed it so much. Keep going!

[@lisawilliams-mccallum6961]

BEN!! It’s Desmond’s mom! I totally just found your channel by accident as I am learning how to knit and want to learn Fair Isle knitting. You go kid!!

[@thebenburton]

Thanks so much Lisa it means a lot! Good luck learning fair isle patterns, I still haven't lol it's tough but you've got it!

[@heatherz4631]

Beautiful! I love your film style. I love stranded knitting of all types.

[@Ms.Murchison]

Benjamin, one bearcat to another, brilliant film! I put it on to watch while knitting, but couldn't knit because it was too interesting. :) I hope all's well with you!

[@thebenburton]

First off SCO BEARCATS!! Thanks so much, I'm glad that you liked it! I'm good and working on some new doc projects, hope you're doing good too!

[@pambrown8697]

This is complicated knitting, I have yet to try it! It has been proven that knitting improves your brain...especially this kind. It is very mathematical.

[@bubbechutzpah]

Hi from PDX. Was watching "the repair shop". They mentioned in a spinning wheel segment about fair Isle,that wheels parts would be made from wood washed up from the sea, since there's no trees there.

[@Mindfulnessification]

Wow! I am going to visit!!!❤❤❤

[@jackroberts8336]

Thanks so much for posting this. Was knitting while watching it.

[@thebenburton]

That’s the best way to watch anything! Thanks for the support

[@bheinatz1]

Go Bearcats! Willamette '09 alum!

[@janekellett304]

The music is really maddening!!! I almost stopped watching because of it.

[@nicolefields5917]

Thank you for this sweet tour of a place that I have on my list of destinations for my upcoming sabbatical! I so enjoyed meeting the people and seeing the place-so beautiful!

[@anngreen9918]

Thank you

[@susanfortner2630]

I lived in Salem for several years, and wished I’d known that Willamette Uni’s cafeteria was open to the public then! Willamette Uni had been the site of the Nwrsa yearly conference, this Uni is an excellent site for any kind of conference! Ben you did an excellent job on your video! Ne last thing REAL MEN KNIT!

[@thebenburton]

REAL MEN DO KNIT!!! Thanks so much for the support and kind words, we love Willamette!

[@susanfortner2630]

@@thebenburton what a nice surprise! Keep on knitting! When my dad was in med school, he had a college who had anxiety so bad he would pass out. Dad said he would walk into the Dr’s lounge and this guy would be in there knitting to relieve the stress. I have found that my BP goes down when I knit or spin! I’m one of those weirdos who spin wool also! I like to say that I spin my wheels and actually get somewhere!😜 What yarn shops are in Salem now?

[@gaillawson3011]

Beautiful! Thank you!

[@grumpynanny7402]

My grandmother was a Fair Isle knitter. Beautiful knitter. She also knitted lace and crochet as well. I knit too so did my mum. Maybe in our Scottish blood.

[@wanderingheartknits]

I’m so glad this popped up in my feed! Thank you for sharing!

[@YarnDragonsCreations]

Such a wonderful video. It reinforces the reasons the area is on my wish list is places to visit.

[@wellwoman4685]

Fabulous. We need more of you

[@j_filippo]

Just amazing. You did a great job. I want to go visit (but I have been dreaming of that for a year now) Thanks for your film.

[@lydiarowe491]

Knitting simple pieces..it makes me appreciate the jumpers made here in Fair Isle..thanks for this one..a hard to get to place but worth it.. it seems..as they say civilised.. 🧶 .. ❤.. 🧶

[@deborahcresswell1616]

Thank you for making and sharing. Beautifully done and beautiful content. Someday I hope to visit there also.

[@thebenburton]

Thanks for yoru comments. You should visit! The isle and the people on it are amazing, it's unlike any other place I've been.

[@jeannedelaforet6441]

Too bad this movie wasn’t edited for sound. The background music and other weird clicking sounds overpowered the beautiful people’s voices. Please try again and dial down all the background noises.

[@thebenburton]

I agree I wish that I would’ve chosen better music, I made this 3 years ago and I’ve learned a lot since

[@jeannedelaforet6441]

@@thebenburton I’m watching it again Muted and using Closed Captioning. I really loved everything else about your video.

[@jenniferaustin8750]

Thank you. This was delightful to watch while knitting today. Great work!

[@cmaur811]

So special..

[@annchenweidemann5694]

Fabulous!! Thank you.

[@mariabergmann9084]

AWESOME TRIP!

[@kathosim501]

This came across my feed as I get interested in stranded knitting - imagine my surprise to find out it’s a WU student! Go Bearcats! (JD 2008) Thanks for the video!

[@ellieduncan]

Just watching with closed captioning and found the auto translation of Fair Isle into feral knitting very amusing. From now on I'll be feral knitting! I didn't catch a mention of the actual island yet though and am quite a way in.

[@rosesmith1108]

Awesome

[@utekosslitz3536]

Nice video, wished you show more fair isle knitting.

[@sierrabird2460]

This deserves way more views! loved it.

[@thebenburton]

That means so much more than you know, thank you ❤️

[@cristinacerqueira3468]

Thank you!

[@inMuro]

i've been to fair isle a few times, it's really worth a visit. and not at all so difficult to do as you might expect. if you're an artist, you might like to do a residency at fair isle studio.

[@josiahedwin5276]

This was such a beautiful documentary. I absolutely love your camera work and the whole atmosphere you created. Looking forward to discovering more of your channel.

[@dykepansy8643]

This is really gorgeous, my partner and I are hoping to go after the pandemic and this has made me so excited!

[@ContinentalTitleSvcs]

So inspirational!

[@colleenstafford5029]

Well done and soul nourishing. Thank you!

[@MultiKnitter]

Well done Benjamin! Thoroughly enjoyed your doc. film.

[@karenbochinski]

Beautiful filiming. I love fair isle. Without music would be better.

[@meemahmcdoogle]

Knitter here too. Time for you to travel to Peru. Chullo hats!

[@thebenburton]

Haha I’d love to make a documentary about knitting all over the world también siempre había querido viajar a Peru I might have to!

[@pstcali7152]

Why do people think that you need music in their videos. But, anyway, just keep watching.🤔

[@itsirkeel]

Love this!!

[@evermateo6166]

lol chevrolegs! So cool thanks for the journey!

[@susanfoster8637]

Fabulous!

[@PatlLawson]

Encore 👏👏👏

[@anitajohannadrost]

👍😁👋🇳🇱 Thank you!

[@anneoc231]

Benjamin I have to stop watching the music prevents me from hearing the people speak. Beautiful idea and people.

[@millsgirl2]

The noise over interviews was distracting bordering on disrespectful. But otherwise it was a great piece of film.

[@glendabathgate4036]

Interesting thanks

[@rootbeef]

This was beautiful to watch, great cinematography and the sound design was really creative! You really evoked that feeling of going somewhere special and the sweetness of leaving with the joy of having experienced something wonderful. Thank you for sharing your trip and for making this lovely documentary :)

[@piccalillipit9211]

BRILLIANT - I really want a Fair Isle sweater that is knitted ON the island, but out of my price range I am sorry to say...

[@Ynnsie]

Thanks for posting this - I enjoyed it very much. You needed to have shown yourself knitting, Benjamin, in order to show you've got knitting chops! Or at least show *someone* doing some hand knitting (even if it's you!). And what kind of sheep are we looking at there? Very enjoyable. Did you make a career out of this documentary-making business??

[@DreamWeavr]

Hopefully, you can adjust the background music level, this is a wonderful film. Thank you.

[@countesscable]

The music completely drowned out the interviews

[@elena7834]

Appreciate you putting this out there! Means I dont have to take the long trek myself ;P Sub'd and looking forward to seeing more of your content

[@thebenburton]

Thanks so much for the positive feedback, I wish I could go back and do it again to give everyone another angle of the island. If you ever get the chance there really is nothing like visiting the actual place!

[@elena7834]

@@thebenburton yeah, maybe one day! Nothing like staying home in the PNW though. I wonder if the cascade region will ever develop its own knitting styles.

[@bunnyechoes]

It looks really interesting but it's hard to watch because the background music is too distracting, and as an EFL speaker I need more clarity to actually understand what the people are saying.

[@katiejewel6703]

I'm a grad student in Eugene, OR. I'm an amateur knitter. Small world. I would love to go see this place someday.

[@thebenburton]

If you ever have the opportunity to go you really should it’s an amazing place! If you’re ever at Willamette come say hi!

[@anepictree]

Hi Benjamin, I think your choice of music is perfect and adds a great deal to the story telling you do.

[@jan2sugars378]

good apart from the cacophonic music spoiling the interviews

[@michelecraig9658]

I loved the film as far as I watched, up to the sea bird part. To hear the people talking I had to have the sound up too loud and the music was physically making my ears hurt. I have moderate hearing loss, so it probably isn't the same for everyone.

[@lucillecooper3600]

Love Fair Ilse knitting and have been in e mail contact with Mati Ventrillon 's partner...would love to own a Fair Ilse garment!

[@thebenburton]

Haha me too, maybe if this gets enough views she'll send me that free jumper!

[@monicapassey5957]

Knitter in Shropshire. Thankyou

[@claireryan8074]

Mistake to add the clicking and musical background. It really spoils it for me. Sorry. At least I can mute it and read the captions.

[@brendahamblin4559]

Lovely film, but terrible discordant noise around the 10 min mark. And the clacking noise throughout sounds like a pepper grinder.

[@rosemarynewman8716]

Poor sound, good film!

[@susannebaverstrand1057]

Why the background sound?? Very disturbing, couldn´t watch it to the end. I would like to watch it again, when the back ground noice is gone.

[@tinafletcher1145]

lovely video but disappointed that you didn't show any actual knitting being done

[@MichelleLewis-nc8zv]

Disappointing that the sweaters are not knitted by hand ☹️

[@catherinefox7832]

What’s the clicking sound in background ?

[@cmaur811]

I think its the knitting machines

[@nancycampbell7959]

LOVED the film. Brilliant! But what in the hell is that beyond annoying clicking sound going on?

[@miniaturehome]

Needles clicking.

[@susanneanna2421]

I am not a native speaker and the music over the interviews makes it nearly impossible for me to follow :-(

[@lorrainenielsen6304]

Terrible noise in background

[@jackwardrop4994]

Music underneath anyone who is talking tells the audience what they are saying is unimportant. It’s more performance than educational.

[@olive5890]

Interesting, but couldn't finish watching it due to the annoying clicking in the background music

[@marichristian1072]

I'd like to see the woman knitting.

[@marny7760]

With its lovely content, this could have been a fascinating documentary, but unfortunately the incidental music was too loud and busy--it detracted from the interviews in an unprofessional, even disrespectful way, as if you didn't actually want your interviewees' voices and words to be heard. I don't believe you intended this, and now I see farther down in comments that you're aware of the problem and wish you could do a do-over. Three years later, I imagine your skills have greatly improved! I wish you the best.

[@elizabethfox8004]

Too much music and clicking while people talking , veery distracting. I had to turn off half way through.

[@tkarz]

No need for music when people are talking; it doesn't maximise the impact, just detracts

[@catherinerosengren3122]

What is that background clacking noise? Its very distracting had to mute

[@faithwalker5196]

Background clicking is distracting

[@friedasorber1653]

Such a pity you have machinery running and music throughtout interviews. Plus panning over the knitting, the in and out of focus is annoying. The pace and general content very nice.

[@Pinguinpullover]

this would have been a nice film, but it turned out an acoustic overload, thanks to random notes being forced upon the viewer who is desperately trying to make out what the featured people are saying. i am sure, t would have been most interesting. but, alas, one cannot hear it. this is not a documentary. it is a lecture on how not to do a soundtrack.

[@milabulic]

I had to stop watching this due to the annoying music/noises that made it virtually impossible to understand what the interviewees were saying. Too bad because it appeared to be otherwise well produced.

[@meletcl]

Interesting vignette of Fair Isle - a place that has fascinated me and which I would love to visit. As that is unlikely thank you so much for this short doc. I did find some of the audio difficult to hear and while the music is atmospheric, overlaying it over speech was distracting. I so wanted to hear all that was being said. A lovely and much appreciated visit to Fair Isle.

[@thebenburton]

Thank you so much for the nice comments and valid critiques, there’s so much that I would change if I could do it again. This was my first time taking on a project of this size and I’d love to go back and try to tell the story in a better way!

[@meletcl]

@@thebenburton You did a stellar job for a first time project longer that was more involved than any previous endeavors. I am sure you are benefiting from this experience and are growing more adept at fashioning your vision for other projects. I did enjoy it as I was able to travel to Fair Isle without spending a penny or embarking on a series of plane trips! Thank you again.

[@jeannedelaforet6441]

I agree. This video could have been top notch had it not been for the sound issues. So disappointed. I muted it and watched.

[@gonnermleggies4813]

I adore seeing men amongst the knitting community.

[@patbelowsky8210]

Such a beautiful film. You are an amazing young man! I’ve been a knitter my entire life, fascinated with Fair Isle. I want to live there!! Keep up the great work and always follow your dreams 🧶

[@thebenburton]

Thank you so much, your words mean so much to me ❤️ It would truly be a wonderful and unique place to live, you should do it!

[@DisneyIsHardcore]

Fantastic video, but I’m really struggling to understand the words especially with the music around the 10 minute mark. It would be better if the music was a bit quieter against the voices, or if there was subtitles :) but I am really loving this The jumpers are absolutely beautiful!