FAKE PLAYING? Why Korean Bands Can't Play Live Performance on TV? (QWER, CNBLUE, DAY6, FT ISLAND)

[@elentiya2853]

This got me so emotional. As a villain (XH fan) I am so deeply thankful for these bands for paving the way for the industry to accommodate bands. Because if there weren't any improvements to how korean bands promote themselves, and the system (I know it's still shit and there's still a lot to do) but I wouldn't probably have stumbled upon xdinary heroes. And they are my ray of sunshine these days. So, I am sending the warmest hugs to all k-bands and their fans

[@faizazza3552]

Same girl i cant imagine not having xdinary heroes content and them🥺💛

[@venyykiwi5238]

JYPE way of promoting is quite clever despite I-fans criticizing it for not promoting on music shows enough blah2. Day6 really stabilize their image as a band through basking and live performances in their early days which makes them acceptable within Indie rock world. And I am so happy for their success after so many years of hard work and dedication ❤🎉

[@CaptainQuirky]

This is so informative and a great collection of clips showcasing the artists while explaining different bands' perspectives and some history surrounding the issue! I also love how you ended it with that inspiring quote. I love the language used recognizing the effort of these artists and how we should unify and prop one another up rather than pretentiously make distinctions and tear each other down. I love bands and love that Korean bands are getting more mainstream appreciation and renumeration (which they more than deserve), though it's also comforting to know there will always be fans who support this kind of music however popular they are

[@BAND_CODED]

Thank you so much for your thoughtful comment! I'm really glad you found the video informative and enjoyed the way I highlighted different perspectives. It’s so important to appreciate the effort these artists put into their craft and to support them as a community, rather than divide. I completely agree-whether mainstream or not, these bands deserve recognition, and it's amazing to see fans like you who will support them no matter what.

[@ShuaJohn-gd8kr]

Compared to the idol bands up to 'day6' in the video, 'qwer' is in a completely different position. The idol bands up to 'day6' debuted after years of practice, and 'qwer' debuted as soon as KZbinrs first encountered playing musical instruments. So an idol band up to 'day6' will feel unfair. However, 'qwer' doesn't have to feel that way.

[@모닝스타-y1b]

음방에선 어쩔수 없이 핸드싱크를 하는거죠;; 공연장에선 그냥 연주하는거보다 핸드싱크하기가 더 힘듬 ㅎ 그걸 핸드싱크라고 한다면 귀가 썩은겁니다~ 아님 공연장을 한번도 안가봤다는 증거

[@으먀-v4v]

한국 방송에서 밴드가 라이브를 하려면 3000만원 이상의 비용이 든다고 해요. 그래서 대부분의 밴드가 방송에서 라이브 하는 게 힘들다고 하더라구요. 그래서 아직까지 QWER이 방송에 나가지 않는 이유도 있다고 하네요.

[@ieeteei]

밴드라 비싼게 아니고 그냥 다 비싸.. 립싱크하는 아이돌도 음악방송 나올려면 몇천 꺠진다고 중소 기획사는 돈없어서 못나간다잖아..

[@악플퇴치위원회]

​​@@ieeteei아이돌 그룹 무대설치비 및 무대의상,헤메비용 까지 다 소속사 에서 비용부담 하고 아이돌멤버 들에게는 5만원 내외 의 출연료 지급이 다임니다 더군다나 밴드 같은 경우는 무대설치비+악기 및 음향장비 세트 설치비용 임 그러니 라이브 로 무대한번 하려면 수천만원 이 지출 되는데 음방 에서 라이브 를 하면 수천만원 이 적자인데 어느 밴드 가 라이브 를 할까요?

[@harmonyfuntime1082]

Now I understand why JYP did not bring day6 to music shows at their early times (even tho I wanted them to be promoted so badly) but now that I see why I actually appreciate what JYP did 🤧 that way Day6 would be able to stabilize themselves as an actual band and they proved themselves lots of times which is why they are so successful today 😆 their music is also amazing so how could anyone not like day6🥹🫶

[@newworldhello]

Korea TV stations should have a permanent stage which is set up for band performance only.

[@ZairaKurbanalieva]

Xdinary heroes and Day6 These guys are very talented ❤

[@yongkim5826]

Be the King! 왕이 되라. 아웅다웅하고 싸워봤자 방송국에서는 핸드싱크밖에 할 수 없다. 방송국에서 기본적으로 밴드연주할 수 있도록 세팅해 놔야 됩니다. KBS 수신료는 받으면서 왜 그런건 해주지 않는 거야? 국방방송도 해주는데.

[@화려한사춘기]

대부분 걍 아이돌 판이라 ㅋㅋㅋ 걍 댄스음악에 춤추면 알아서 덕질해주니 ㅋㅋ 솔까 락밴드도 대부분 걍 아이돌밴드지 ㅋㅋ 진짜 락밴드인지도 모르겠음 ㅋㅋ

[@jin_p1ng]

@@화려한사춘기비난하는건 아닌데 시대가 바뀌면서 장르에 대한 작곡방식도 바껴가는건 어쩔 수 없다 생각함 언제까지 가죽자켓 입고 그로울링 할 수 없잖슴..

[@화려한사춘기]

@@jin_p1ng 맞습니다.... ㅠㅠ 저도 그냥 한쪽으로 너무 치우쳐지는 음악이 아쉬워서 글 써봤어요 ㅜㅜ 무튼 한국에서 다양한 색과 음악이 나왔으면 좋겠어요 ㅠㅠ 한국 음악 사랑하고 늘 응원합니다! 제이팝 화이팅!!♡

[@MrSunzg]

앞으로도 누가 공중파 음방을 볼까요? 이미 한물 가고있는 중 같은데.

[@pierz510]

if you guys watch QWER different live performances, you'll notice a slightly different sound & tone from Hina's guitar & Magenta's bass. Well, it's because their stage amp provided are different for each live. Marshall will not sound like Mesa Boogie, Mesa Boogie will not sound like Bogner and so on. That showcase how real they're playing their instrument.

[@jin_p1ng]

I think they are playing on AR on stage

[@nopal1045]

​@@jin_p1ngno

[@superrookie-1]

Honestly they seem fake to me, i play guitar and what the guitarist plays on stage doesn't match the sound she is producing

[@mgmmj6664]

​@superrookie-1 I don't trust a random on the Internet to be a guitar player either lmao

[@thedog_pt]

QWER live performances are really good, they know they’re good and they will piss haters forever haha

[@yeontanemil]

being an idol and band by itself is hard enough, being an idol band is even harder. that's not mentioning this weird gatekeep culture in the indie side as well. the fans of indie band often won't like it if their band promote even just slightly like an idol and just want indie/underground band to stay underground & unknown. it's like there's no place for those who are in between. let band be idols too! let them be in the middle of the spectrum peacefully :(

[@BAND_CODED]

I totally agree! It’s tough for idol bands to find a place when they don’t fit neatly into one category or the other. The gatekeeping from some indie fans can be disheartening, especially when a band just wants to grow and share their music

[@ShuaJohn-gd8kr]

Compared to the idol bands up to 'day6' in the video, 'qwer' is in a completely different position. The idol bands up to 'day6' debuted after years of practice, and 'qwer' debuted as soon as KZbinrs first encountered playing musical instruments. So an idol band up to 'day6' will feel unfair. However, 'qwer' doesn't have to feel that way.

[@Ofra8191-]

I saw it really well in the survival show that was on around 2 years ago where bands competed against each other. ONEWE was the only "idol band" amongst them, and even though ONEWE went through everything the other bands did (they're self formed, not formed by a company, they write, compose, arrange and produce all of their own songs, and they came up busking and playing small gigs until a few YEARS into being a group they got signed by a company), they were still looked down on by all the other groups just for being idols and handsome. they were kicked off the show for, and I kid you not, being too good at playing live and performing.

[@사랑혀-m6e]

한국만??? 아닐걸요? 보랩에서 퀸도 방송국에서 핸드싱크 요구 받아서 반발하는 장면 나오잖아요 실제로 해외음방에서도 다 핸드싱크하는 걸로 알아요

[@wonhojang1213]

세상에는 좋은 밴드가 너무 많다. 그런데 더 많았으면 좋겠고, 좋은 밴드들을 모두 응원합니다. 밴드음악을 너무너무 좋아합니다.

[@saras.5619]

Thank you for this very informative video. As a Day6 fan since early 2016 I know all the struggles my fave band went thru. Such a pity for korean bands who's talent and skills can't be acknowledged due to the lack of space and opportunities. So frustrating at how all these wonderful musicians are not taken seriously. Hopefully it's time for a change..

[@BAND_CODED]

Thank you for your comment! It’s frustrating when such talented musicians aren’t fully recognized, but hopefully, increased awareness and support will lead to positive changes. Here’s to hoping for a brighter future for all bands

[@worldwidespring]

I watched QWER's performance a few days ago. It was such an exciting live performance. If they had seen their performance in person, they would never be able to bring up such foolish things as hand-syncing. Moreover, they proved their live performance at the Pentaport Rock Festival, the biggest rock festival in Korea. Their new album is coming out on 9/23. Listen, everyone!

[@WeNeedU9]

I remember that Day6 Jae Fancam showing his guitar is not even connected in a speaker I assume? A lot of people criticized him while not even knowing they are not also happy to do that. They were forced to do that

[@rhythmpointless9885]

true i was traumatized seeing locals and bandistas criticizing him on sns 😭😭

[@_Cjlvre]

As a Villain (xh fanbase) i bacame a fan like a few months ago. I always listen to the mvs and other KPOP then I started watching the Channel stations version, I noticed that the instruments weren't plug. It somewhat bothered me cuz like the lead guitarist of XH doesn't even sing. So I was "that's it?? what's the pointing he just standing pretending to play" then I read somewhere that the KPOP artist do pre recording.. I was somewhat discontented

[@KrissieS]

JYP have done the same thing with Xdinary Heroes they've done lots of outdoor festivals in many different towns and countries :) they always sing live on shows but rarely play live you just have to look at the size of Gun-ils drum kit to know if they're playing live lol and obviously the wires and paddles all over the floor

[@amuroanakin3246]

The sound engineering of Korean broadcasting stations has been poor since long ago. Most of the engineers at broadcasting stations are not people who studied sound, but rather people who majored in electrical engineering, and they value academic background more than skills. Their understanding of band sound and engineering are also very poor, and they take up a lot of time, so they themselves refuse to broadcast live. I envy the live sound level of Japanese broadcasting stations

[@anistardi]

Indonesia have college to study audio engineering. Audio engineering must know about music, basic of electronics, and basic of acoustic. I'm an electronic engineer and design audio product.

[@Ofra8191-]

@@anistardi Than maybe we need to send those sound engineers to Indonesia....

[@Macobartcreation]

As a Idol Band stan (I stan almost all the bands showed in this vid), and a musician myself, I can completely understand the situation and see how unfair it is for bands to be forced to play with hand-sync. I've seen the broadcasts, and itswpretty obvious that its not live, but since I started hearing Kbands, I never judged them for that bc I've seen their concerts on YT and their live performances, acoustics, MTV (In Cnblue and Ftisland case) and in this cases we can see their experience and skills playing and singing live. Lately Day6, XH and Lucy have uploaded live performances to their YT and we can clearly see their live, so, we should keep supporting thid amazing bands, bc the companies are not giving them the attention they deserve, each band have a different color and it's unfair that companies just decide to givw them less attention bc costs more 😢😢 I love bands, and so should do every Kpop stan, bc they are pillars in the Idol industry.

[@BAND_CODED]

It’s so true that idol bands are incredibly talented, and it's unfair they’re often forced into handsync situations on broadcasts. It’s frustrating that companies sometimes overlook these amazing bands just because it's more expensive to support them fully. Bands really do play a huge role in the K-Pop industry, and they deserve all the recognition

[@BLue3547-o7v]

What's sad is how a freaking military base can provide the facilities for band to play live while these so called music show wont.i still cant understand why setting live instrument for these music show can cost more than renting a month of whole 5 floor building.

[@Macobartcreation]

@@BLue3547-o7v OMG yeah you are so right, I didn't remebered that. It's so unfair. Happened a lot to Onewe, when they where in the military service T-T

[@basaraki]

음방에서 무대 꾸미는 비용이 중소에서 천만원에서 2천만원 정도선. 대기업은 3천 정도선. 거기에 밴드같은 경우 악기로 라이브 세팅까지 가져가야 한다면 최소로 잡아도 5백에서 천 정도... 그러니 그냥 라이브 세팅 포기하고 악기만 들고 가서 비용 절약.

[@jin_p1ng]

보통 핸드싱크까진 아니더라도 ar위에 연주하는 팀이 많죠

[@oneusonewelover245]

Wow, thank you for this eye opening video 🥺 im actually just a new kband fan, although i used to listen to day 6 songs, I don't really watch their performances, but now that im head over heels for Onewe, i did notice how hard being an idol band is. I didn't know they had to pay a lot just to promote in music shows but here i am wishing they perform more 😭😭

[@Pass1ngbyebyeby]

QWER is actually playing their instruments They saying it a lot of times And..people don't believe it because Their first thought, first impression never change.(and that thougt is a mistake out of misunderstanding and prejudice)

[@kpop.mp4]

This is such a great video! Thank you for posting this! Even as a k-band stan, I learned a lot!

[@BAND_CODED]

I’m glad you enjoyed the video and found it informative ✨

[@useranon613]

"The world created by Seo Taiji who faced a 'blindly no' from the critics." (7:50) I think it was a very strong statement. We all have seen it since FTI & CNB era, and I've thought many things have changed since then. Nowadays I no longer watch mainstream music shows cause they provide nothing more than chances for big companies to flaunt their money. So I did not realize that this hand-sync situation is still very prevalent now. But then, seeing how the public reception still choose to one sided-ly blame the talents is very disheartening. I think Korean bands have a unique and distinct style but because of this strong prejudice, their growth are often stunted from the early days. Anyway, thanks for the great video, it summed up the situation nicely and very easy to understand. Great job as always ^^b

[@BAND_CODED]

It's sad but true that despite the progress made since the FTI & CNB era, the handsync issue remains prevalent, and it’s often the artists who get blamed rather than the system. It’s frustrating to see how this limits the growth of incredibly talented bands who deserve more recognition. Hopefully, with the rise of band popularity in Korea right now, things will change over time

[@optimumpr1de]

I could tell if a band is doing handsync by listening to the sound and their hand movement. But i can easily recognize a band doing handsync by just watching their expressions. They look so much passionate when doing live music

[@beniirama4076]

i took my hat off for kim egg. aside from his eccentric behaviour, all his move about qwer are actually very well calculated. in this era of social media, you need to fully utilized it for the benefit. thats why he intentionally choose social media personalities are the member. gave them enough training and some fitting songs, and use the member follower as promotion tools. and guess what? it worked. a thing thatbactually just another of his youtube gig became a hit. they even manage to reach top spot on music chart. and they done it with zero tv promotion (with the reason as stated above; expensive). in today k-music industries that already overfilled with rappin-dancin-bling bling, the existence of music band like qwer or day6 gave a new breath of air. no wonder both of them peak the chart head to head. looking forward for another k music band 😎

[@lingth]

Kim Gyeran said because ppl keep saying they are finger syncing.. he put a Go Pro camera on the guitar to film it to prove it

[@beniirama4076]

but haters always have somethin to spit on them.. that's why they release fake idol, to spit back on those haters 😂

[@dithadithia]

Day6 and The Rose are my favorite band 🍀🌹

[@BAND_CODED]

They have a great way of consistently delivering high-quality music ✨

[@ryunekoyashiki]

QWER doesn't go to music shows coz it will cost them a lot....QWER still growing and i freakin proud of em 🥰

[@miylo21]

and because QWER was born from the ridiculous ambition of an egg, it makes me proud too 🤣

[@ryunekoyashiki]

@@miylo21 more precisely a muscle egg 😂

[@cheonsa2k18]

exactly. the cost is huge and they can't afford it yet plus they need to setup.

[@xmhcix5310]

thank you for making this video! very insightful~

[@syafiqaszamin6411]

QWER has made it clear from day 1 that they are a growing idol band. I'm proud how far they have come.

[@xh_75]

thank you for this great information!

[@BAND_CODED]

My pleasure

[@bosenngantor9160]

very very informative, I've been a fan of many korean (idol) band for quite long now, Day6, N.Flying, and now I'm also a big fan of qwer, and no one can't deny the existence of qwer is really makes us as international fans excited, they bring "new experience" of music format, they make band format feels more "pop", more trendy among korean fans, I really don't understand why some k-netz are often seeing lots of things so negative, never really gave "benefit of the doubt" they just keep saying "no no" to something they don't like while spreading lots of fake news, or fake allegations, it's frustrated me how dense and ignorance some of those knetz. I do hope lots of other bands like qwer would be born in the future, also we can see that Day6 receive a huge success just recently after almost a decade in the business, I feel like "wth knetz where've you been after so many years"...Day6 swept the charts it gaves me goosebumps, and qwer staying so long on charts too, the obstacle is a lot, but I see a future for (idol) bands, a bright future I think, tho again we may find many difficult times thanks to those stupid knetz. Anyway, very good video from you 🔥

[@BAND_CODED]

I completely agree, it’s amazing to see bands like QWER bringing a fresh, modern take to the K-Band scene. It’s frustrating how some negativity overshadows their achievements, but it's inspiring to see how Day6, N.Flying, and now QWER continue to gain recognition and success despite the challenges. International fans like you are such an important part of their journey, and I also hope that more innovative bands will emerge in the future. Thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts

[@vipkonic8693]

As a VIPiKONIC I saw the stereotypes that TOP, GD & Bobby had to overcome as an idol group with gaining respect from the HipHop/rap community (even though some were from underground HH scene) As a baby MyDay & learning Day6 had the same struggles in the Indie scene to then overcome up through their hard work & continuous improvement makes me so happy for then.

[@cutie-fw3ix]

Day6!! Thank you for this informative video

[@BAND_CODED]

Glad you enjoy the video 😊

[@Erik-kim-8964]

Nirvana also played hand sync on BBC broadcast.

[@kimnamho100]

셋팅비용 하나더 세팅시간때문에 생방위주로 하는 음방에서는 핸드싱크 할수밖에 없는 사정이 있음..

[@kiirolicht]

Oh so that's why Lee Seungyoon was talking about QWER during his appearance in Bibim-Pop.... I think he's right tho, because of bands like QWER that doesn't sound like your traditional band, band music became more well-known. Also isn't band music the "pop" in western music? (before the incoming of electronic music tho). It's great seeing the k-band scene flourishing these days, I hope they all walk in flower road...

[@BAND_CODED]

QWER are definitely helping to bring more attention to the K-Band scene and make band music more recognizable. I’ve read many Korean comments noting that while some 'rock enthusiasts' may dislike or underestimate idol bands, it's true that many people were first introduced to band music through these idol bands and then went on to explore and discover more bands, including indie ones. I’m glad to see the K-Band scene flourishing too and hope they continue to thrive and get the recognition they deserve

[@angiee1603]

The "pop" in Western music stands for popular and bands have not dominated popular music recently.

[@mgmmj6664]

​@@angiee1603 "recently" it was different in the past

[@angiee1603]

@mgmmj6664 What are you correcting? I said bands have not dominated popular music recently.

[@Lupita311]

That is why ftisland doesn't go to music shows to promote their songs, the drawback no views on their videos, no reactions. They are fantastic in concerts. There is no singer like Lee Hong Ki and no musicians like Jaejin and Minhwan period.

[@min1min]

콘서트에서 라이브하면 되죠 뭐 음악방송에 3000천만원 깨지면서 까지 할 필요는 없을거 같네요

[@ieeteei]

악기 세팅하는데 시간이 오래걸려서 음악방송에서 라이브 하기 힘든거지 그냥 립싱크하는 아이돌도 한번 출연하는데 몇천 깨짐 무대세팅비용, 의상, 헤어,메이크업 이런거 때문에..

[@Ofra8191-]

I'm a fan of ONEWE, and they've talked a few times about not being able to play their instruments live on shows. Luckily for them, they weren't created by a company, they were self formed and played together for some years before signing up to an idol company (RBW), so they have years of playing small gigs and busking and such to prove that they very much ARE very capable of playing live, and even over 5 years after re-debuting as a so-called idol band, they still do busking and small live outdoor gigs, they even invent entire songs on the spot, so there's no way to say it's handsynced... that's one of the reasons why they often guest on radio shows meant for bands, they can play live on them....

[@busybody5381]

From what I see, it's hard to be an idol rock band, they dont fit anywhere. They lack the popularity they deserves just like other idols from the same company, but they are too "maintenance" to be an indie. Their music always get criticized from both even though they charted well; "too loud", "too obscure", "too pop", "too pretty". One of the reason I know K-rock was through N.Flying and CNBlue and from then on, I keep on watching both Idols and K-rock. It's pretty sad since idol rock bands, at least in my view, are what makes k-rock go international especially in K-wave era, yet they aren't appreciated enough by both sides.

[@눈을감자-e6q]

썸네일 ×같이 만들었네 QWER 축제나 공연 영상 하나만 찾아봐도 핸드싱크 아닌거 뻔히 들리는데 뭐 이렇게 만들었냐?

[@Lululaa00]

음악방송은 앰프연결하고 라이브 할 수 있는 여건이 안돼요..

[@aina6992]

They will keep saying it is handsync as if their idols dont lipsync all the time

[@lydinspear1121]

Performing live band on any music show on TV is actually much more expensive and hassle than performing live singing

[@BAND_CODED]

You're absolutely right! Performing live as a band requires a lot more equipment, set-up time, and technical support than live singing. It involves setting up and mic'ing multiple instruments, balancing sound levels, and making sure everything works smoothly, which adds to the complexity and cost. Unfortunately, that’s why many TV shows opt for handsync or playback to save time and resources. It's a tough reality, but hopefully, more shows will find ways to support live band performances in the future

[@anistardi]

​@@BAND_CODEDIt is a pity that South Korea do not have professional sound engineer. Indonesia have college that study sound engineering. We have professional level and amateur level. Even we design audio amplifier with high power for live music. It is DIY (Do It Yourself).

[@milk__teee]

Learning about how music shows will charge you a bunch to play live was pretty eye opening. It’s crazy that so many groups who did go on music shows and didn’t pay would then be criticized if they didn’t actually play because music show never said anything about this stupid fee. Makes sense that groups that play instruments rarely go on music shows, since it’s almost a lose lose. You lose a bunch of money if you do play live, if you don’t play live you get criticized if you are shown to be fake playing. Too much risk for a stupid music show that most bands won’t win since bands aren’t as popular as idols.

[@jse.sd.1972]

My expectation for all band appearances on music shows is that they’re like MVs but w/ live singing. After YoungK’s interview w/ Eric Nam talking about the expensive logistical nightmare of playing live, I can understand why. Not ideal or preferred, but it’s something they need to do to promote their music. TBH, Kpop groups dance but typically lip sync on these shows, right? Why aren’t they called out for not really singing?

[@BAND_CODED]

I think a lot KPop idols also get called out for Lipsync, that's why KPop idols aren't really considered as singer in korea

[@anistardi]

​@@BAND_CODEDSome kpop group sing live in their concert and they used backtrack vocal mix with live vocal. You never go to the concert and never watch their video. Your opinion only base on assumption. 😂😂😂

[@BAND_CODED]

No, you misunderstood my comments... I'm not saying that all idols are lipsync. Of course they also sing live on their concert most of the time I just want to point out op saying "why aren't they (idols) called out for not really singing" which is not true because multiple groups are getting call out for doing lipsync actually and people often make fun of these idols for doing lipsync without even knowing the reason why they do that Most music show don't really have good sounds system, that's why these days most idols are lipsync on music show, even when they're really good at signing like Taeyeon or aespa In Korean there's only a few idols that are actually being recognised as "singer" but most of the time they just see idols as idols not a "singer' Just like how most Korean don't really consider idols as "dancer" or "rapper" or "actor" or "musicians"

[@angiee1603]

Idols have definitely been called out for not singing live on music shows although it is more accepted for them to lipsync. It seems like a lot of people look at idols as performers and not singers so they expect good dancing and stage presence more than they expect live singing.There has been more backlash against idols for poor performances when they do sing live. Famously, Jimin of BTS performed an encore stage after he won on a music show and did not sound good. He received a lot of criticism for it. From what I heard it may have just been a technical problem where he couldn't properly hear himself when he was singing.

[@xxemaxxs]

CNBLUE FOREVER

[@JHlee-xj4lw]

결국 핸드싱크네 뭐네 욕하는 놈들은 그냥 듣는것도 못하는 머저리들이라는걸 입증해버림과 동시에, 지금 밴드들이 처한 현실에 대해서 알게 됬고, 마지막 멘트에 정말로 공감합니다. 그냥 패배자 멧돼지 페미들 말고, 진짜 락 들으시는 분들..그래서, 꼰대질 해서 얻은게 뭡니까? 응원해줍시다. 락음악 한다면 그게 아이돌이건 뭐건간에 말입니다.

[@주스트로]

밴드 데이식스가 차트 지금 씹어먹고 있는데 엑스디너즈 히어로즈도 락밴드 하는데

[@silentgas]

As a drummer and a part of a band myself this is just sad. As if being in a band and having a band isn't hard enough and then this another level kind of fckery is happening to them, bro that's tough.

[@BAND_CODED]

Being a part of a band already comes with its own set of challenges, and dealing with issues like hand-syncing just adds another layer of difficulty. It’s tough to see talented musicians facing these obstacles

[@k22nikki]

Ah.. now I know why no K-band after verry long-long time, imagine the industry wanna makes lot of money but doesnt whant spare more for paying band equipment etc. For them a band like giving more money, more difficulty and more headache, I guess rhythm-work just an excuse..

[@chcc3934]

great video

[@BAND_CODED]

Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed the video!

[@zeldroid]

Let the band PLAY!! Please don't treat band group the same as idol group

[@mostrack5627]

Even on German TV, you can often see hand-synched bands without any connecting cables. This is due to the limitations of the broadcast environment, not because they cannot play.......

[@BAND_CODED]

I think Hand-syncing isn't exclusive to Korean TV it’s a common practice in many countries due to the constraints of live broadcast environments

[@emazhatt6561]

Boice❤where are you guys?❤ CNBLUE 💙 💙 💙

[@junographystudio]

ar말고 mr정도는 라이브로 쳐줘야한다. 부족한 악기나 사운드를 보충해주는 점에서 오히려 관객들은 좀 더 완성된 곡을 들을 수 있어서 이득이지.

[@drag_611]

qwer might not be the best at their instruments but if you actually watch their performances from day 1 literally their first ever performance on entview_live it is so obvious that their instruments are live. really scary that people who can't even tell handsync to live can sit there with confidence and say that they're handsyncing.

[@BAND_CODED]

Thanks for your comment! It's frustrating that some people jump to conclusions about handsyncing without really watching closely. Hopefully, more people will recognize their growth and live skills as they continue performing

[@beniirama4076]

that's why they release fake idol song, a blunt move to spit back on those haters 🤞😀

[@shiraisimai]

It doesnt matter if u dont like qwer. But u shouldnt tell lie about qwer

[@BAND_CODED]

I'm not telling lie nor do i hate them, have you watch the whole video? 😭 There're part when qwer explain that they never do handsync and the reason the never appear on music show it because they don't want to do handsync and it Is very expensive to perform with live performance on music show This whole video is about how korean bands often have no choice but to do handsync because music show didnt provide them to perform with live instruments But somehow they would still get critisized for doing handsync even tho it's not even their fauts

[@shiraisimai]

@@BAND_CODED ah my bad, please support them then 🙏😂

[@jiedragonhub]

​@@BAND_CODEDyou can't really blame him/her for this comment. This is the result of clickbaity thumbnails.

[@neobongzzz]

Justice for kbands

[@gazzaga]

우리나라는 공연을 할수있는 전용콘서트장도 없음 매번 스포츠경기장 빌려서하고 잔디 손상간다고 욕먹고 규모도 소규모라 돈도 안됨 문화가 잘나간다고 떠들어봤자 일본에비하면 하늘과 땅차이임 다른거 일본에 지는거 싫어하며서 공연문화 이런데 투자하는 정권이나 정치인들은 못봤음 유명 외국 아티스트들이 한국은 공연장이없어 안간다고 일본만 가는거 정말 속상하고 억울할일임

[@anistardi]

Indonesia have a concert hall. I have some friends who worked as acoustic engineer for building. I though South Korea is more advance from Indonesia, but it is not 😂😂😂

[@disastermoon69]

Qwer 특히 기타파트는 줄 씹히는 소리 개많이 나는데 뭔 핸드싱크임? 연주실력 부족으로 깔라믄 까지.

[@김민송-v7t]

근데 애초에 mr에 악기사운드가 포함되있어서 어쩔 수 없는거 아닙니까?

[@Fenitra_Fenitra]

Music broadcast doesn't allowed artist to show their talent either kpop idols nor K-band. They want to edit a clean perfect show like a mv, 'cause all music broadcast systems are like a commercial plate-forme. But for K-band it' s crucial for them to perform not handsyncing😢

[@BAND_CODED]

Music broadcasts often prioritize a polished, MV-like presentation over showcasing live talent, which affects both Kpop idols and Kbands. For K-bands, being able to perform live is crucial to demonstrate their musicianship, but the constraints of TV shows can make it challenging. It’s a tough situation, and hopefully, there will be more opportunities for bands to perform live and get the recognition they deserve

[@Fenitra_Fenitra]

@@BAND_CODED that's why I like watching radio show more than music show station

[@4thwall826]

imagine singing live then they just put pre record audio over it and put it online… now everyone watching it just think they are lip syncing

[@bloomingivy]

They also need to pay more for live performance 😔

[@samhue4194]

QWER worked so hard to be able to perform live

[@beniirama4076]

thats why they never want to play on tv station music show. they have to pay the tv station for promotion, they have to setup all the sound system and the instrument by themselves, and that will cost stupidly high. even kim egg said during jang sungkyu interview that the cost of 1 time tv promotion is more expensive than their building monthly rent 😂

[@gragalakaisel1477]

when day6 back then is so rarely getting opportunity to perform on TV. they did it with their instruments not plugged in and they look dead LMAO.

[@user-jh5dh4oz1s]

Qwer은 핸드싱크는 아닌데 실력이 다른프로에 비해 부족한거지 열심히 연습해서 점차 늘고있긴하지만 몇년후에는 프로라불려도 손색없을정도로 실력쌓으면됨

[@wdxp28]

못해서 핸드싱크를 하는게 아님

[@ggammbu]

핸드싱크타령족은 듣는 귀가 없다는 애기네..ㅎㅎ 연주하다 틀린 부분도 있덴다..ㅎㅎ.. 핸드싱크타령족 잡으러 가야지...ㅎㅎ

[@ShuaJohn-gd8kr]

Compared to the idol bands up to 'day6' in the video, 'qwer' is in a completely different position. The idol bands up to 'day6' debuted after years of practice, and 'qwer' debuted as soon as KZbinrs first encountered playing musical instruments. So an idol band up to 'day6' will feel unfair. However, 'qwer' doesn't have to feel that way.

[@drag_611]

yes they do? first of all their drummer is a music major and has played the drum since she was a child. also, the other members have been playing for months before their debut, since then they have improved a lot and do play live on every performance. why is it not unfair to be labelled hand-syncers when they play albeit not as well as the other listed idol bands?

[@주스트로]

이제는 데이식스 세상이지 멜론 탑 5 에 4곡이 데이식스 인데 이건 어떤 탑 1군남돌 1군 여돌도 못하는거임

[@토마토_TOMATO_asmr]

Lucy!

[@BAND_CODED]

I love them ❤️

[@Xynic48]

As a guitar player, it's quite obvious hina is fake playing, well her guitar is plugged, but the guitar backing track is too loud to even hear her play. But I kinda just forgave it because she was basically a beginner when she joined the band. You need to have at least a year or two of guitar practice to be live performance ready. It's not that she cant play, mistakes are just inevitable in her current level. From what I've noticed, occasionally they make her play live in some easier songs. This is a step forward at least. Magenta play the bass live maybe 80% of the time, chodan always plays live since she was a drum major. Si Yeon sings live (0 to very low backing track) maybe like 20% of the time when they were starting, now, she's singing 100% live more often. They need to make Si Yeon sing live more. She can sing well without backing track, koreans are just too obsessed with perfectionism.

[@cap0038]

Hina was not fake playing. As she explained, they really do use backtrack and she plays the lead line at the same time so she admits that there are times that it really can't be heard very well.. Fake playing and Playing instruments where she can't be heard because of the back track is a different thing..

[@Xynic48]

@cap0038 I know fake playing when I see it, like the vibrato, bends etc doesnt match what she is doing. She maybe pressing on the correct note, but there's more to a guitar than putting your finger on the fret board. Yes they use backing track but the guitar backing track is so loud, you cant even hear her guitar. What's the point if she is really playing when you only her the backing track. That is essentially fake playing, because if her guitar is completely audible, you will be able to hear her make mistakes every 5 notes because it takes at least a year or two to be decent in playing guitar. Right now, maybe because of the negative comments, they lowered the volume of the backing track although her guitar is still barely audible. This is obviously so when she makes mistakes it's not as jarring. But at least I can kinda hear her play now which is an improvement.

[@newworldhello]

You're probably wrong. Did you watch their documentary? It's highly possible that she did play. She trained for around 6 hours per day. At this rate, she could indeed master guitar really quickly. They have music instructors teaching them, this is helping them to reach advanced levels quicker. And she already knew how to play the keyboard, that means she already knew music theory and she could understand guitar quicker.

[@Xynic48]

@newworldhello I know she practiced, but obviously it was not enough because the guitar backing track is too loud. That was on purpose to hide her guitar playing. Well now, she is decent enough that in certain songs they let us hear her play to a certain extent, although it is still obvious she's still in the beginner level or slightly above beginner which is understandable because she hasnt been playing for that long. Again, I know this because I have been playing the guitar for years, it is very easy to spot someone who is playing live or not because it either sounds too perfect or the sounds doesnt match the slides, vibrattos or bends which is present in many of their songs.

[@Xynic48]

@newworldhello And 6 hours of practice a day is not by any means abnormal. That is well within range of practice every serious musician does.

[@PaipilUlum-hx7bk]

Humans standard hahaha 2024 to be idealist?

[@jin-m7795]

QWER I LOVE YOU❤❤❤❤❤

[@BAND_CODED]

❤️❤️

[@galerights8983]

Also why does it costs so much to perform live? Not only the equipment, what other factors boost its expensiveness?

[@ky9999]

You need time for rehearsals, and audio mixing by a pro audio engineer to eliminate noise and feedback issues, which is more difficult compared to MR. Wireless systems, TONS of mics (one mic for each drum kit piece, that’s 10+ mics for drums alone). But it’s mostly time, because time=money

[@newworldhello]

​@@ky9999this should be pinned.

[@12aki20]

0:13 что это за песня?

[@BAND_CODED]

LUCY - Fill it Up

[@12aki20]

@@BAND_CODED Спасибо!

[@jinwoolim6881]

핸드싱크니 뭐니 하는 이슈도 QWER이 있으니까 생긴거지 존재 자체도 관심없는 밴드들이 핸드싱크를 하던 말던 사실 대부분 관심이 없음 그리고 QWER은 성장 해가는걸 지켜 보는 아재들의 매의 눈이 있기에 항상 오늘보다 내일을 증명해야 하는 숙명을 타고남

[@bosenngantor9160]

watch the video, you clearly didn't watched it...why all CNBlue cried if haters didn't complained about it, and CNBLue case was already years ago

[@주스트로]

어자피 시간 지나면 관심 없어짐 처음 이니 신선 해서 그런거지 이번 신곡 가짜 아이돌 망했더만

[@아프니깐닝겐]

@@주스트로 야 너 따위가 뭐냐????가짜아이돌이 망해????별 개잡소리는....망해가는 니 인생따위나 잘 쳐 사라....

[@user-jh5dh4oz1s]

이건 너무억빠인데 qwer이 밴드붐에 일조한건맞는데 락씬도 최근몇년간 신예발굴많이해서 파이커지고있는데 무슨 ㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-js2pg6dz8c]

루시팬인가 보네? 근데 느그 멤버 큐떱 맞팔이던데 이런 영상 보여주면 존나 좋아하겄다잉?

[@bbada1756]

자막이 영어라서 해석이 정확하게 되는건 아니지만 썸네일은 어그로성이고 내용은 핸드싱크 할 수밖에 없는 한국 현실 뭐 이런거같아요 후반부쪽에 QWER이 핸드싱크 아니라고 해명하는 내용도 있는거보면요ㅎㅎ

[@groemilchstrae6287]

my fellow bawige, this is harmless video and this isn't only talking about QWER, the whole idol band scene and why they aren't attending music show. This is very informative for international listeners. There's nothing to do if this account Lucy fans or not, this account on X app been promoting k band even before qwer existed. Look, English comments are all positive.

[@개두목-l5o]

Qweŕ 핸드싱크임???

[@JamesDuffne]

무슨소리 하는거임

[@개두목-l5o]

@@JamesDuffne 썸네일에 핸드싱크인거처럼 해놧길래

[@돈많은백수-w6x]

@@개두목-l5o 영상도 안보고 쎔네일만 보고 댓글다는건 뭔 생각임

[@개두목-l5o]

@@돈많은백수-w6x 그럼 왜 썸네일에 핸드싱크인거처럼 해놔

[@돈많은백수-w6x]

@@개두목-l5o 유튜브 어그로 하루이틀 보남

[@galerights8983]

I only follow Day6, so are their instrument playing in music shows actually hand-synced and not actually live?

[@ky9999]

Yes, it’s hand sync

[@mymelody3732]

For some music shows they do hand sync but as for their comeback stage in MCountdown its actually live and intruments are plugged in...

[@mymelody3732]

i think only Mnet allowed day6 to play live during comeback stages..they played Melt down, WTTS and Sweet chaos live in Mcountdown... I hope they will also allow other boybands to play live

[@bosenngantor9160]

@@galerights8983 on music shows? Sadly yes, they forced to do so.

[@CandyCane23049]

Jype pays for Day6 and Xdinary Heroes to play live at least once for their comeback. It's usually Mcountdown that let's them play live.

[@주스트로]

Qwer 이 원제 부터 밴드신을 꽉잡았는지 호들갑은 이번 가짜아이돌곡 망했는데

[@아프니깐닝겐]

햐....머이런 방구석 개 찐다ㅣㄴ가????QWER은 벤드씬에대해 단 한마디도 않했어....호들갑 떤 적도없고.... 가짜아이돌곡이 망했다고???야 니 인생이나 잘 쳐 사라....월 400은 버냐????세전????

[@주스트로]

@@아프니깐닝겐 400도 못벌면 사람 이냐

[@jsfgrs5772zghykbzzuj]

​@@주스트로400못벌면 사람 아니면 뭐냐?? 천박한 마인드네. 이게 사람이하 인증이지.

[@hyosikson8393]

타이틀아닌 선공개곡인 가짜아이돌 뮤비가 유튜브 700만뷰 8일걸림

[@MrLikewind]

언제부터 활동곡도 아니고 선공개곡으로 망했니 흥했니 하게됐냐 선공개곡은 그냥 수록곡인데

[@c4wk4w4ii]

Oh thank you for this video it really shed a light on why they're forced to play MR instead of live. I've already known about the fact that performers have to pay themselves if they want to promote in music shows but it's more insane to know that its MORE expensive if they wish to play live which is really unfair for bands promoting 😮‍💨 Also thank you for sharing day6's early days. People think that the group had it easy and have the privileges just cuz they're under a big 3 company. The recognition and appreciation theyre getting now are thanks to their own hard work alone as well as mydays 🥲