Fan Request Scramble | Commander VS | Damia vs Mayael vs Rubinia vs Old One Eye

Enjoy a new take on fan requests! What happens when the CMDR crew plays decks meant for each other?
Commander VS 399 | Season 37 Episode 7
Submit your decks using this form forms.gle/Fdr6... for a chance to see it played on Commander VS!
#magicthegathering #mtgcommander #CommanderVS
Check out the latest TCG news and info!
Get the latest SCGCON updates here! scgcon.starcit...
Save big with this week’s sale: starcitygames....
Get the latest MTG cards: starcitygames....
Get MTG news, strategy, and deals delivered to your inbox: starcitygames....
More Magic: The Gathering Videos!
- Commander VS: bit.ly/3rSsT5b
- Upgrades: bit.ly/3vOJxUt
Like us on Facebook: / starcitygames
Follow us on Twitter: / starcitygames
Follow us on Instagram: / starcitygames
Always buying singles/sealed products and store inventories at starcitygames....
For business inquiries, email [e-mail]
Star City Games is the world's premier TCG retailer & event organizer.

[@SCGCommander]

DECKLISTS!! articles.starcitygames.com/magic-the-gathering/commander-vs-399-fan-requests-with-a-twist/

[@BluePatrone]

Where is the assasins creed commander vs???? I wanna see y'all play with the new assasins creed cards lol I bet it would be a funny match

[@avatarofpapermagic]

Can I be honest, haven't watched a video in a while due to Magic product fatigue. Shocked to come back and see Stephen has lost so much weight! Proud of you mate, that's the good endorphins I needed for this week!

[@anthonyotlang1872]

I checked back even a year ago because this comment and yeah, its awesome!

[@daleway5429]

Thanks Stephen for playing my deck. Great games as usual.

[@SCGCommander]

Congrats, you made a great one!

[@Nerveroxis]

Take a shot everytime Jon says he will respond then does nothing, getting drunk speedrun edition

[@Synced_OW]

As a note Gisela, Blade of Goldnight says prevent the damage rounded up. So if a 1/1 would attempt to deal damage it would be reduced to 0 damage. So at 58:58 Jeremy would have only taken 10 damage. The 7/7s would only deal 3, toski would be 0 and the bears deal 2 each.

[@timothybrown1020]

The way that card reads is weird. I can understand the confusion they had lol

[@jasonmolisani1864]

This is also relevant with how Ram Through works and the fact that "lethal" damage is assigned to the creature before considering what Gisela will do to modify the damage. With Old One Eye in play, it is impossible for Gisela to be killed with Ram Through since it will always try to assign just the missing damage and Gisela will reduce that, eventually reducing 1 to 0. The first Ram Through should have assigned 5 (reduced to 2) to Gisela and 2 (reduced to 1) to Jeremy. The second should have assigned 3 (reduced to 1) to Gisela and 4 (reduced to 2) to Jeremy. They didn't happen, but: The third would have assigned 2 (reduced to 1) to Gisela and 5 (reduced to 2) to Jeremy. The fourth (and any past that) would have assigned 1 (reduced to 0) to Gisela and 6 (reduced to 3) to Jeremy.

[@ShroudedBlade]

This is also one of many times in the history of this show where they do not get the ruling of Gisella's abilities right. Many times in the early days of CMDVS, someone died when they shouldn't have with her on the battlefield.

[@shelkofsky1]

Whats a tyrannid to a godsire is an amazing quote

[@1023orphen]

The more I watch these the more I realize Corey is just playing with 3 friends that need a 4th. Kinda meh when he is the target for the most part, props to him for keeping it light I would of lost it by now lol.

[@HadesElderSage]

Pretty much been that way for a long time. It is very annoying to see over and over again and most of the time it is Green initiating it and the outer two watching it happen.

[@papaflowers5726]

He cracked the code though. He isn't stupid, he just is chipper as all get out, getting paid to play the game. Dying just means you can go home to family or get to the next game. I used to not like the guy honestly but now I just admire him.

[@AgonalRhythm]

Jeremy definitely gets stomped on more than Corey. These guys all know each other and have for years, he's on the cast for a reason. I feel like it's pretty weird to read into the show gameplay to see the inner workings of the play group. Going back to previous iterations, Stephen and Justin would be at each other's throats all game.

[@shade580]

stephen cheated jeremy said enchantments off auster command and he didnt put the enchantment off his land into the gy

[@MaximilianoEmanuel.]

Is a good day when someone see this oldies make real work!

[@matthewbeard7841]

Shared Fate is a beautiful mess of a Magic card. I remember having a game end where I had a Shared Fate in play and every player in the game had an empty library but no one could lose because the replacement effect of Shared Fate stops you from actually drawing. No one had any creatures left and no one had any way to remove Shared Fate. Game should have been a stalemate, but everyone else conceded before they came to that realization so I 'technically' won. Definately one of my more memorable games of Magic!

[@Belena711]

It feels awesome to get some classics. 👍😎

[@RPGFanboy14]

I don't doubt Steven could have probably answered the Archon and Gisela with the insane amount of cards he was drawing, but the misplay at the end should have stuck imo. Jeremy did clarify that it would die several times. Either way, very fun game with some very funny decks. Stevens reaction when he realized the deck Corey stole was golden, totally worth losing the point lol

[@yorkazord319]

At 57:00, not sure why Jeremy just doesn’t take everything and deal 20 damage to Steven’s face. Then he would kill both Steven and John on the crack back. (Blocking any creatures that make sense)

[@WayneyMTG]

Favourite bit of this game has to be trying to guess Corey's theme, hilarious 😂

[@lookslikeajob4]

Man, that Damia deck was awesome. It's a shame it never made it to at least one upkeep. The power level of cards nowadays is so fun sapping. All rules text, no flavor. Makes me appreciate the simple things.

[@RobotButlerJ]

Phew, what a game! Great to see the guys playing to have fun! It seems that the last couple of videos were made to promote MH3

[@brutalkingofdoom2]

Requesting Corey B. Play Edward Kenway when the assassin's creed decks get played.

[@michelwerner3276]

Corey chose the wrong art for mystic remora though. It should have been the one from dominaria remastered.

[@ToobzMD]

I saw that and wondered if anyone else at the table was going to call him out on it 😂.

[@jakeb.2708]

Could you make a cPDH episode? Probably a two for one unless everyone's playing blue 🙏 SEO in case someone uses ctrl + f: request requesting deck decklist reqest requst reqeust ruqeest rekwest

[@nickjoseph77]

Unless Jon had a sideboard, why was death wish in the deck? Omg that deck is so great!

[@ToobzMD]

Hey, that's my deck!

[@SCGCommander]

Congrats! Which one??

[@ToobzMD]

@@SCGCommander The scroll deck! 😉

[@SCGCommander]

Ha that was a good one!

[@kandjar]

That deck was just awesome 👍

[@clintonschultz2750]

Austere command should have blown up Utopia sprawl and the blue enchantment from LOTR should have tempted Corey with the ring I think. Just so ya know ;)

[@LewisMarshalll]

Actually I don’t think the ring thing would tempt Corey here The ability had a target that became illegal, so would be countered on resolution due to no longer having a legal target

[@theaamanable]

@@LewisMarshalllyou don’t have to have a legal target for the ring to tempt you

[@ipsyop]

@@theaamanable The saga effect would fizzle, no ring tempting as it is a part of the resolution of taking control of the artifact.

[@LewisMarshalll]

@@theaamanable no but you do need the ability to resolve, which in this case it wouldn’t

[@Ricardo-zo1ti]

"Put something into play" and "play" is not the same thing. You don't trigger "when you play a land" effects while ramping

[@theaamanable]

What card does not trigger from ramping

[@Ricardo-zo1ti]

@@theaamanable Horn of greed, for example

[@thadrin]

That music sounds very Elder Dragon Hijinks... did Corey lose a bet with Eilidh in Amsterdam?

[@trevorpeters4976]

Like, comment, share, subscribe, binge, and ring someone else's bell

[@dragonmaster1601]

Are they playing edhijinks music?

[@Gunnarr123abc]

Why don't they ever intervene to save another player? Doesnt it give another point for saving someone? I never see it happen though.

[@allein8er]

I've seen it. It happens like once or twice a season. But there was one season like 3 seasons ago where it happened like 5 games in a row i think.

[@quack929]

Clearly it’s just to maximize spite lol, Steven has infected everyone with his mindset

[@kandjar]

Is it me or the end of the game got cut off???

[@allanstaite7908]

My also got cut off the end of the game . Who won ?

[@KarenSummers-k7g]

Davis Sharon Thompson Paul White Cynthia

[@noahsummers1883]

do you do any guest games? I live around an hour away from roanoke and I would love to be a guest if available.

[@dustyfox6511]

Where's the scroll on Mystic Remora?

[@ToobzMD]

Corey used the wrong art. The borderless one from Dominaria Remastered has one! 😂

[@LaurieArnold-b6d]

Anderson Patricia Hernandez Kevin Gonzalez Elizabeth

[@Dark-Pikachu1]

37:23 miss trigger

[@BridgesElva-v1v]

Wilson Deborah Thompson Brian Taylor Paul

[@FoilMythicRare]

You guys should do Alphabet Soup again. Just like in season 7. Just make sure there is a “v” and not a “y” 😂.

[@MaisaKhatun-i3d]

Robinson Mark Lopez Brenda Hernandez Kenneth

[@dereksekingsman2591]

Walker Eric Davis Sandra Young Joseph

[@DollyLaurel-j6l]

Wilson Elizabeth Hall Dorothy White Michael

[@jacobyspurnger8488]

Was the fan request that Jeremy be in the red chair?

[@jacobyspurnger8488]

Because that would be mine, honestly. Can Jeremy just stay in the read chair the whole season?

[@ClassicFloats-f3q]

Robinson Thomas Davis Jason Thompson Steven

[@SbnrDd-z6e]

Martinez Melissa Thompson Lisa Davis Richard

[@SomebodySadhanDurbanEleven]

Wilson Susan Davis Eric Miller Brian

[@graysathorndike9955]

Robinson Margaret Miller Brian Lewis Frank

[@NoelDuroe]

Perez Donna Wilson Angela Rodriguez Sharon

[@SamanthaLee-i9i]

Young Kimberly Lopez Shirley Jones Daniel

[@BusterMayers]

Thomas Jeffrey Davis Donald Thompson Jason

[@CommandersSanctum]

Missed bleep at 34:53 😂

[@SCGCommander]

😳

[@l6ogan9]

Just don't tell the guys lol

[@GaryGarcia-h1c]

Martin Steven Johnson Ronald Thomas Kenneth

[@BridgesElva-v1v]

Martinez Linda Williams Matthew Wilson Matthew

[@Jidayun]

So my understanding is Stephen was asked multiple times about the death trigger, said yes, then as it was gonna happen, he realized he would lose the game, so only then invoked a takeback? That seems like cheating at that point. Just gross, really.

[@brianlips8346]

Yeah

[@lukeroden3593]

Oh definitely but then this is a friendly group of players who take back quite a lot.

[@billhoward5551]

Maybe in a tournament. I'll untap all my stuff when you play a land. Because its a game with friends. Relax adolf...

[@Jidayun]

Bruh adolf? Take backs are for like "I tapped wrong" or "I meant to do this in another order, can I do it that way?" Not for "oh an effect is resolving that is losing me the game, I'll rewind to not block". I do not understand commander players, I guess, but adolf is a disgusting thing to say to someone with Jewish heritage.

[@shlaxxn1923]

@@Jidayunmost people in a casual format, are fine with you taking back actions that you didn’t know gave advantage to another player as it is seen as something you wouldn’t want to do and therefore in all fairness you can undo it, also how on earth would he know you have Jewish heritage, you are literally some random guy on YT comments.

[@joelderesaustin9946]

Martin Paul Hall Christopher Davis Karen

[@SomebodySadhanDurbanEleven]

Martin Jeffrey Brown Maria Moore Frank

[@LikeGreeceButWithaP]

Firsties!

[@nathanmarines1907]

First

[@Aiko-f8q]

Who is the GENIUS that thought slapping interview-like edits between the games to explain a deck we are watching being played.. was an idea worth implementing? Dudes, you are better than "game knights" (or whatever that dull channel is called)!

[@uandubh5087]

Calm down, it's just them telling us what the idea behind the decks is. They used to do this right before they start the game but now do it a couple turns in, it's a stylistic choice I guess. But it's nothing like the Game Knights commentary inserts (which I think are totally fine, it's just a different type of gameplay presentation).

[@papaflowers5726]

Its one time only each episode, and this is like the 5th season they've done it. Tell me you don't watch the show without saying you don't watch it.

[@marvinrose6273]

Ur so low that u have to attack last place and not attack first hey stephen do me a favor a quit because u bring this show down

[@craigrivet3889]

False

[@marvinrose6273]

Maybe kiled one eye instead of focusing cory

[@brandonoliver447]

Hernandez Kimberly Jones Michael Hernandez Larry

[@BostonFreedom-r1d]

Thompson Christopher Taylor Joseph Anderson Jennifer

[@EueySarah-p2k]

Young Richard Brown Jessica Wilson Donna

[@dondedestephen4857]

Young James Johnson Jessica Wilson George