I can't expresses the happiness I felt seeing Aaron Johnson-Taylor pop up on the screen for Will. He truly is the only person I could ever imagine Will Herondale being! You're absolutely right: Douglas Booth most certainly is not Will. I also agree with your fancast for Tessa & Jem and many of the other characters :) love this!!
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Aaron truly IS Will Herondale!! (With Henry Cavill as older Will in Chain of Gold!!) Honestly he’s such a great cast for most YA stuff - he’s also my James Potter in my Marauders fan cast, as well 😭😭 I’m so so happy that you liked this video, it means so much that you liked our Jem and Tessa as well, since our picks for them weren’t popular choices. Ahhh, thank you!!
@claudiaferrier034 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction He's my James Potter fan cast too - he's honestly such a good fan cast for both!! And yesss I absolutely love your choices, they're perfect! I even started a TikTok account making fan edits for them all hahahaha
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
@@claudiaferrier03 OMG DROP THE LINK PLEASE!!!!!
@elliegaston3 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction Anaeurin Barnard as Will Herondale, look at him in The White Queen and War and Peace because he LITERALLY looks like Will and he’s Welsh so it’s a bonus, but he’s ridiculously, goddamn drop-dead gorgeous)
@denisegodman39313 жыл бұрын
Coincidentally, Daniel Sharman read the audiobook for Clockwork Princess. He also was the only narrator to give Will a Welsh accent.
@tarae65873 жыл бұрын
sam claflin and daniel sharman are two of my favourite actors of all time... i've never considered either of them for the roles of gideon and gabriel, but it's PERFECT omg (i did see someone cast daniel as will before, which i'm not entirely opposed to, but he works so well as gabriel)
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
So glad you love their casting!!
@amywinter94534 жыл бұрын
Oh my God this fancasting is literally like my dream and imagination!!
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Ahhhhh! This is ALL I want to hear!!
@anikanawal98584 жыл бұрын
I dont always agree with fancasts but this was just 💯
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Thank you SO much!! I’m so happy you liked our choices!! It took us five years but you can’t say we didn’t do our research haha
@anikanawal98584 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction i finished tid just two weeks before and i'm still in pain :')
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Trust me it’s been half a decade and I’m still recovering from THAT epilogue ?? The whole of clockwork princess was just pain I swear
@anikanawal98584 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction before starting the epilogue i was thinking ah done with their journey the herondales are happy now my wessa is sailing and jessa will also take off now but man...i wasnt ready for Will's death description. It was agony.
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
I was so sad that Jem and Tessa never got their happy ending AND THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN THEY DID!! Cassie really said screw you to a traditional love triangle hahaha
@sophia55163 жыл бұрын
I 100% agree with every casting! You guys really pinned down the reasons why some of the other fancasts don't quite fit the characters and you've obviously put so much thought into what the book says about each character. Totally agree with you about Will and the casting of Kaya Scodelario as Tessa. She fits Tessa way better than so many other fan-castings. Also Dom Gleeson as Henry I can totally see! Also, your reasoning for Jem is perfect. I feel like his beauty is really overlooked, especially seeing as Tess and Will are both described as really beautiful and they are the characters he is placed beside lots. Will is often described as 'pretty', and Sophie remarks that Jem is just as good looking as Will, and like you say, is described as angelic by Tessa and Camille, but because of his illness as well as his personality, people don't remark on it as much. I agree that Arron Bernards would play this really well and looks completely the part.
@Danielle-to8zh4 жыл бұрын
I appreciate the thought and attention to detail that went into this. I'm still fond of certain ones that have been around for years like Douglas as Will and Adelaide as Tessa and Jenna as Charlotte, but I've recently been considering others more closer to their physical descriptions. I really love Kaya as Tessa, after someone mentioned it right after I read CHOG and also watching a little of Spinning Out. I like the original cover model of Clockwork Princess for Tessa as well, but my earliest Tessa was definitely Sarah Bolger, after Cassandra Clare admitted that was who she pictured as Tessa. The perfect Henry, I never had a Henry, and Jessamine works better than I thought, Lily James has a real English rose quality to her. I also like Aaron Taylor Johnson, and for older!Will Henry Cavill like in the Enola Holmes Netflix trailer has been circulating around and I like him for TLH era. Cecily is perfect. I love Alexandra Daddario, she has a very Herondale look to her. I dislike the standard fancast for her, that girl from that old Freeform show about teen pregnancy? And Sophie is perfect! I like Anna, but I also pictured Lucy Hale hazily, mostly bc of the hazel eyes, and they have a similar intense prettiness that I imagine Sophie has. And Jem, I never had a Jem that felt right, but I'm satisfied with yours. I'm just glad people have (mostly) stopped that one guy blonde guy from Skins and various K-Pop celebrities.
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
I feel like because the books have been out for so long there are certain people that have stuck around like Douglas and Adelaide etc, but we wanted to try and match them as close to their descriptions like you said - and as for Jenna, well, there really isn't anyone else for Charlotte is there!! I didn't know about Cassie saying about Sarah Bolger that's really interesting! But yes Kaya is just perfect in my opinion for Tess! Lily James as Jessamine was rogue but I think it kinda works - especially blonde!! And honestly Henry Cavill as older Will is FLAWLESS (and I think it also works well with using Aaron Johnson as younger Will as well, they are quite similar looking) - Jem was probably one of the ones that I was most in support of, I just love Aaron Bernards and the fact that he has been used twice on covers shows that Cassie likes him as well! Also i'm so happy people have stopped using Maxie from Skins as Jem because that used to make me so confused ?? Like what on earth ? But Aaron Bernards as Jem has my heart x
@elliegaston3 жыл бұрын
Anaeurin Barnard as Will Herondale, look at him in The White Queen and War and Peace because he LITERALLY looks like Will and he’s Welsh so it’s a bonus, but he’s ridiculously, goddamn drop-dead gorgeous)
@jade7283 жыл бұрын
Omg when I read chain of iron all I could picture was henry cavill as will
@alejandrajoachin79524 жыл бұрын
I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS FAN CAST IT´S SO SUITABLE, I LOVE IT I just discover your channel and i feel I´m living the dream hahah TID, TLH, everything, thank u please please please make a fancast of THE LAST HOURS
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Omg this is the cutest message!! Thank you so much - I really appreciate it ❤️ I’ll try and do some more fan castings soon!!
@lakshmirekha91683 жыл бұрын
Your casting for Jem is perfect!
@emilycooper16024 жыл бұрын
Omfg every single one of these- PERFECT
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
COMMENTS WE LOVE TO SEE
@emilycooper16024 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction PLEASE MAKE ONE FOR TDA IM BEGGING YOU
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
@@emilycooper1602 I WANT TO BUT I DONT HAVE AN EMMA OR A JULIAN OR A MARK YET IN FACT AT THIS RATE I WOULD PROBABLY ONLY BE ABLE TO CAST ONE OF THE SHADOWMARKET VENDORS AND WHO WANTS TO SEE THAT
@emilycooper16024 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction AHAHHA ITS OKKK BUT ID WATCH ANYTHING YOU PUT OUT SO HDHSHD
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
@@emilycooper1602 HAVE YOU READ THE FIRST TWO CHAIN OF IRON CHAPTERS YET?
@zoebelle85203 жыл бұрын
Okay hear me out: Louis Partridge as Will Herondale
@palakbakshi7804 жыл бұрын
Hello! I really enjoyed your video, though a lot of you casting differs from my own. I will put mine below and explain the different reasons for this actors. Tessa Gray - Astrid Berger-Frisbey I feel like there's almost something ageless about Astrid and I actually do love her eyes and they were probably the first thing I noticed about her. Will Herondale - Jonah Hauer King This guy was a new discovery for me but I feel like he just looks a lot like Will, the only thing missing is the blue eyes. Jem Carstairs - Justin H. Min I had a lot of trouble finding a Jem and after a lot of research I just stopped on the Umbrella Academy guy. I think it might also be because of my soft spot for Ben Hargreeves but I find him quite handsome. Sophie Collins - Felicity Jones I always saw Felicity as Sophie. I find her incredibly pretty and she has this intelligence and fierceness that I find Sophie has too, and she could totally pull that scar of. Charlotte Branwell - Gemma Arterton/Jenna Coleman (I can't choose between the two) I have a hard time choosing between the pair, I think they are both brilliant actresses and could both easily pull of the role of Charlotte. Henry Branwell - Eddie Redmayne Eddie is another one that I just always saw in this role, plus I find that him playing Newt in Fantastic Beasts would kind of made my love for him grow. Jessamine Lovelace - Claire Holt I love Claire in the Originals and her character is a bit b*tchy and I feel like that fits Jessamine the only thing is that she has blue eyes instead of brown Gabriel Lightwood - Daniel Sharman Gideon Lightwood - Sam Claflin Cecily Herondale - Kaya Scodelario We seem to be in agreement with the Lightwood brothers and Cecily, so that's cool. Anyways, this was a really nice video! I would love to see your castings for TLH, TMI and TDA as well as like all the minor characters! I hope this huge comment isn't offensive or annoying. Anyways, bye!
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Hey! I LOVED seeing your choices for the TID cast! I love how everyone has different versions of the characters in their heads, it’s amazing how each reader has pictured them differently! I’m thinking about doing a TMI casting at some point, so watch out for that...
@palakbakshi7804 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction I will!
@elliegaston3 жыл бұрын
Anaeurin Barnard as Will Herondale, look at him in The White Queen and War and Peace because he LITERALLY looks like Will and he’s Welsh so it’s a bonus, but he’s ridiculously, goddamn drop-dead gorgeous)
@155qisthina284 жыл бұрын
Omg loooooovvveeeee your choice of casting. Also, I really think David Gandy would be prefect as Will in COG era. Plus, he's around the same age Will in that era.
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
Thank you so much!! Oooh I love that suggestion as well...
@elliegaston3 жыл бұрын
Anaeurin Barnard as Will Herondale, look at him in The White Queen and War and Peace because he LITERALLY looks like Will and he’s Welsh so it’s a bonus, but he’s ridiculously, goddamn drop-dead gorgeous)
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
I DIDNT KNOW WHO THIS WAS BUT I LOVE HIM THANK YOU
@elliegaston3 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction no problem hun, seriously go on Tumblr or something and look at him from those two shows especially War and Peace because he looks EXACTLY like Will
@harshchauhan65503 жыл бұрын
This was everything ❤❤❤❤
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
Thank you 🥺
@uditamishra94883 жыл бұрын
It’s like you can read my mind
@iza46873 жыл бұрын
oh my god I agree with every single one of these!!! I followed so quickly even before I watched the full video lol. Also I 100% agree with aaron johnson taylor being Will Herondale! but like imagine Henry cavill as older will from the last hours 😍😍 I really hope they do a good job with the casting for TID bc they already ruined TMI for mee😭😭
@bookishjules32153 жыл бұрын
Even more than Adalaide and Astrid, I would say Alexandra Daddario is just too mature looking for Cecily. I've always pictured her similar to Octavia but with darker hair from the 100 (season 1 specifically)
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
Oh my GOD I LOVE that casting? I had no idea who she was but I love it??
@bookishjules32153 жыл бұрын
@@MyYAFictionAddiction omg I love this reaction!! I'm so glad I could introduce you to this casting!! It's probably one of my most settled casts lol
@Jason.funderberker3 жыл бұрын
all of these were great!! personally I prefer Joshua Anthony Brand as Will though
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
Yes I love him as well!!
@Naomicheye3 жыл бұрын
I’m really the only one who loves jessamine? And i really like Lily James as jessamine :D (she was always my Dreamcast for her too) And I always imagined Eddie as Henry idk why haha. My god I love Aaron as Will!!! I can’t decide between Astrid and Adelaide for Tessa haha And I’ve never found someone who could be my perfect Jem:/ Your cast isn’t really mine but I like it too:)❤️
@MyYAFictionAddiction3 жыл бұрын
I think I prefer Jessamine as a ghost lmaoo - but Aaron as Will is just *chef’s kiss*, so glad you enjoyed!!
@perlarios38113 жыл бұрын
I think Henry lau is perfect for Jem!!! 🥰 I honestly can't picture anyone else
@julielegrix72584 жыл бұрын
No for me Tessa as Astrid and Will is douglas haha 😭😂
@MyYAFictionAddiction4 жыл бұрын
I swear everyone has such different ideas for this cast!! HOW ARE THEY GONNA PICK THE REAL ACTORS FOR THE SHOW I HAVE NO IDEA