Farming Simulator 19 vs Farming Simulator 17 | Toast 🚚

Join our server on Discord! / discord
Subscribe for more videos ▶ / @toastcz
#FS19 #FS17 #Toast
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Do you have some offer? Tell me more.
[e-mail]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Recorded with Shadowplay
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Czech Republic
🚚 Thanks for watching 🚚

[@Rutisija]

I think FS17 graphics are more smooth and easy for the eye... and from far camera angle it looks better. FS19 is amazing improvement in many parts, the lightning is just 100 better, but with some tv's and screens it can look bad. I think FS17 was great product and it was game changer. FS19 will of course include patches to make more improvements in the future

[@bradiator6465]

I've been playing FS 13 for 5 years now, i just updated to FS 19 yesterday and here are the changes i have found so far- it is a lot more realistic now, The graphics are a lot better, the interior of vehicles now look a lot like in real life rather than just blurriness, you can now change the color of your vehicles and equipment, you can no longer mow grass wherever you feel like, you can now only mow grass on land that you own, you can now dump your grain trailer wherever you want. TBH I have only played FS 17 a couple times on xbox 1 and i gotta say it was my favorite. overall i think FS 17 is the best.

[@garryturner3203]

bradiator646 fs19 is better ( my opinion)

[@sadeyau773]

Jesus you must be poor lol

[@riphezo]

@@sadeyau773 lmao, you must be an asshole to make assumptions like that

[@masonwoodhouse6589]

Sade Yau some people like older games it doesn’t mean there poor for all you know he could be a wealthy businessman

[@wadimka_pubg_6185]

I have bad computer and play fs 17

[@snowy6592]

FS19 Needs more updates. The graphics can be way better. There should be way more things to do and more details

[@thisguy9042]

I agree!

[@kristianlorenc7404]

w8 for fs21

[@farmingbest9721]

Snowy yes there should be more details on farming sim 19 and updates

[@snowy6592]

@@kristianlorenc7404 ye wait till it looks like shit again

[@Steven-hi3pk]

I don't think there will be a fs21 but I could be wrong

[@lordoftherims436]

Fs19 has way too many blemishes i get that they are including shadows and bright spots better but its excecuted poorly. Also the crops are too thin and transparent when they are standing

[@junkiexl86]

The shadows need work, but at least the game isn't as flat and lifeless as 17 felt. The lighting quality is much improved for 19 as well as the vegetation.

[@korbinwilliam1675]

3:32 well, thats one way to park your pickup

[@guildrich]

I know, right? That "pickup" just became a f--kup! 😂

[@garryturner3203]

guildrich 😂😂😂😂

[@charmosthecereal637]

I like fs17 because the mods and the graphics and the lighting and more tractors

[@dogeboi3239]

CharmOs The cereal nah fs19 is better

[@ilikegames5796]

they need to take more time for the next farm sim. i believe if you give them 4 years. it can be awesome. 2 years is just to less to create a good game.

[@blake1995]

ILikeGames it seems like they rushed fs19. Some things are just glitchy. They did a really good job on the graphics and textures but I wish they would have made the physics more realistic

[@ericthompson3253]

ILikeGames oh no I can’t play this shit for another 4 years :/ going back to fs17...

[@snowy6592]

Actually 1 yr cuz they make for phones too like fs16 and more

[@doner4908]

4 years are too long but 3 years are ok

[@ericthompson3253]

The Snowy Guy omg don’t even say mobile. It’s another devolopment team I think not sure

[@thelion9588]

19: washed out colors sometimes plastic looking not much realistic atmosphere is created blown out boring skies better physics more details like weed and flowers 17: more even colors paper looking amazing skies and atmosphere sometimes not so many graphic details but overall gives you a more realistic dreamy feeling that will bring nostalgia years later

[@antzero4609]

FS17 has 2009 graphics

[@sunsetrecords2548]

I think fs 19 is way to bright and hard on the eyes but fs17 looks good the lighting looks better and much more enjoyable so Ill fs 17 more than fs 19

[@RichTexas82513]

I agree but to give the devs some credit the darker theme is "primitive" as some critics says so they had to adapt for ratings, besides that fs17 is better

[@garryturner3203]

Sunset records fs19 is better ( my own opinion)

[@dolboeb123]

+

[@Azmythometre]

Turn your screen brightness down, or put it on night mode.

[@justinc2633]

@@Azmythometre theres literally a brightness option in fs 19 settings, some people are hopeless lol

[@NortOfficial]

The only thing i would like for 19 to change in a hurry... is the Krone Mower at 6:23, it needs a working trailer attachment asap in 19, but alot in 19 tells my already that multiplayer will be a think you have to at some point to advance in your farmlife, you cannot simply solo it to glory, and that's a shame.

[@jrchickenbone]

so basically a graphics overhaul, new bugs, and all that for a brand new price tag. Ill stick to fs17 for now

[@sadeyau773]

ruktuMonsu the attitude of a poor man lol

[@midnightrunner6691]

@@sadeyau773 the attitude of an ass licker capitalist

[@progamingofficialpenguin2601]

@@midnightrunner6691 Better than communist

[@midnightrunner6691]

@@progamingofficialpenguin2601 they're both the same shit

[@progamingofficialpenguin2601]

@@midnightrunner6691 I am fascisto-liberal so idc but I think you are anarchist

[@humphreycustoms]

I still love FS17. The only issue I see with FS19 is the crop looks a little spread out which I kinda don’t like it.

[@mikeaust1698]

I have all versions of Farming Simulator except FS19. I prefer FS17 and still run FS15 for some favouite maps. AS a pensioner I cannot justify the cost of FS19, for as I see it, very small benefits.

[@pictlandpickers1171]

Your a pensioner, treat yourself to 2019, just pretend you forgot the grandkids birthdays

[@darthtool8131]

not quite a fair comparison, you haven't loaded any of the basic Giants modules that were released for FS17 (ground response/mud tires etc) for a start, the lighting in FS19 is like looking directly at the sun, its far too over the top. the aforementioned modules became standard for the game and make up the base of fs19.. hence its more fair to compare fs17 with those modules activated. FS17 with even a half dozen decent mods is far better, might not have the graphical flare but it plays many times better.

[@travisjohnson8240]

It is a fair comparison on your first argument as they both have no more and it is base game

[@thelion9588]

The sky is much better in fs17. In 19 is always washed out.

[@dolboeb123]

Lol +

[@guildrich]

I prefer FS17. Just something about the colors that I can't quite put my hands on...

[@Nukedi_]

Me too.

[@mwnciboo]

Over-saturation, with light effects gives it an ethereal feel.

[@RabbitConfirmed]

I know exactly what you mean. FS19 feels "Unreal Engine'ish" What do I mean by that? Unreal engine always has this very uncomfortably dark and tacky look. Everything looks a bit like plastic. Most games developed on UE have over used lighting and shadows which makes them even worse to look at. They look nice at first sight or for "non gamers" because they have many "movie effects". But a gamer needs kind of "clear vision". Best way to describe it for me is this: FS17 looks like Source Engine (Portal, HL) FS19 looks a bit more like Unreal Engine (Just look up some UE games)

[@laszlolowescher8377]

Same

[@ericthompson3253]

Just because the game is brighter and flashier doesn’t mean it looks better

[@junkiexl86]

Then you pause at 9:46

[@mantrafiscus]

I don't find the difference enough to make it worth sacrificing all my saved games in FS17. I don't like the washed out colours in FS19 either.

[@tyelillybell7602]

19 looks to cartoon like 🤔

[@eoinb2135]

didnt know there was that much of a difference😂

[@qkohe155]

4:05 The best music from ls13 trailer!

[@thelaxx8923]

Sorry. You mean FS13??

[@qkohe155]

@@thelaxx8923 ls/fs is the same but translation

[@Azmythometre]

@@thelaxx8923 LS13 means Landwirtschafts Simulator 2013 which is german for Farming Simulator 2013. (All the Farming simulator games are made by Giants software, who are based in germany, so that's why it's sometimes called Landwirtschafts Simulator).

[@northstarstatepolitics1652]

17 is more complete at launch, 19 is better overall but needs updates now! So in my opinion FS17 is better because the mods are better, and it feels more complete. This is coming from a Farm Sim Veretan who has been playing since FS2011

[@tyelillybell7602]

Wow well it looks like I'm staying with 17 lol 19 just looks odd it has a few upgrades but just doesn't look right 🤔

[@ARtheman516]

im sticking with fs 17 too

[@booldawg]

I put 800+ hours into FS17 but just cant find the love for 19. It seems more of a mod than any real 'next version'. The grind is too much to build up decent money. I spent around 3 hours harvesting a big ass field of potatoes as a contract and got about 24k for it. Just the tractor and cultivator I want to buy is over £600,000! I chose to the option to have no farm but start with £1,250,000. All I have to show for that is one field and enough to do a harvest - this is with only one tractor to run the cultivator, seeding machine and transport harvest to store. Hate the way that if you pause the game your vehicle will still move if you havent stopped it previously, had vehicles end up in rivers and all sorts! I'll battle away with it, maybe its a case of owning every field in 17 along with 400 cows and always above £10m in the bank and then having to start from scratch.

[@aivarsurva4864]

My oppinion is that 17 is real graphics and 19 is over realistic.

[@uncle7162]

I’ll tell giants something if you spend four years on the next farming Simulator and get your graphics to a Red Dead Redemtion 2 level you’ll get so many more player... from a fs player of half a decade

[@TusharGupta-nb7dd]

RDR2 was a AAA title game with a whole player base of GTA fans. FS series is targeted to a niche audience and it is not an AAA billion dollar budget game.

[@henkhenksen1699]

if u would compare one version versus one four years later you would notice such a difference, but it just takes time to get there

[@elpatrico2562]

I think they should rather make it an actual simulator. I don't really care about the graphics, I'm kind of satisfied, some stuff just does not really make sense (like a powercultivator does not make any differnce compared to a regular one) or there are just ton of features that should be added (a gearbox or more realistic mud for example), and it also needs a physics overhaul, it just feels like toy tractors for me, but maybe I played too much Spintires and I'm kinda used to feeling a vehicle's mass. There are some titles that got the physics and graphics right, but they are too much overshadowed by FS, so developement is pretty slow on them.

[@bene3816]

After three weeks I got back on the FS17 because the graphics are too bright for me and just a lot of mistakes small-minded things are.

[@abhisheksahu664]

If landscaping was in fs17 , i wouldn't have got to fs19

[@TheRlswrestler]

Ome of the best KZbin video I've watched in a while. Great comparison I play fs17 was interested in fs 19. But I might wait until some updates come out to fix the bugs and a price drop cause its basically looks similar. But I have hure fs19 doesn't run as smooth yet. But I wonder what it would play like on the xbox one x. What system was this played on by chance?

[@cobravenomX1]

same here

[@RVJimD]

Thanks for the side-by-side! I didn't buy 19, it just doesn't look right to me, like the contrast is too high? On the baler shot there is no dust in the 19 clip, but then on the corn head clip there is?

[@OliverLee390]

4:03 does anyone else recognise this music from the FS13 launch trailer?

[@garryturner3203]

Wrangler yes oh the nostalgia still play it sometimes tho

[@User-en4jm]

Nun ich persönlich finde den Ls 19 schon nicht schlecht, aber der Ls 17 ist einfach allein von der grafik viel schöner. Ich habe beim Ls 19 nie so recht lange Lust auf einer karte zu spielen, wie im Ls 17

[@frozehnal]

Je hezký se podívat jak se ta grafika posunula :) Hezké video

[@agri.j728]

19 was released too early. Needs better graphics, better game engine, ai traffic needs fixing, console item limit needs to be done away with

[@easyrider8887]

Genau so ist es👍

[@blackbolt0253]

You cant get ride of slots as if you did it could crash the console

[@MultiTurbospeed]

@@blackbolt0253 if they did fs19 would only be on pc

[@haydenbenninghofen]

Better graphics?!? It looks amazing!

[@AntonsFilms]

I’ll keep FS17 for the time being as the difference is very small. Hopefully Giants release FS21 with a new graphics engine.

[@Azmythometre]

I disagree with a lot of the comments here, I think fs19 looks MUCH better than fs17.

[@killianfritz5840]

I can't hardly watch this😂 it hurts watching anything to do with 17, the graphics are so much better now

[@valleyboy2099]

No not really!!!

[@FreshGage]

​@@valleyboy2099 There is literally no denying that they have improved alot

[@jayextarys8616]

Thanks I was wondering if it was worth buying. Money is tight... but it only got 2 maps and miss some game mechanics like weather... But I think I'll jump in and encourage them so the next is even more awesome.

[@heysupguys30]

I agrees lol

[@heysupguys30]

It looks way better than 17. 17 don’t look alive and wash out like fade color and the physical don’t move at all compare to 19

[@jamesbell2902]

19 is better looking, but so far that's all it has on 17. Just adding a couple JD tractors doesn't justify leaving out a lot of good equipment that was in 17. Also the way the American map was made compared to the euro was just insulting. Too many negatives in 19s corner. Hopefully time & some updates will help. Till then I'd have to say 17 is by far the superior game.

[@Axo_Gaming]

Great comparison also great job, nearly at 10k, very much deserved 👍.

[@TheDigitalHorizon]

Aaaand npc villagers' walk in FS 19 is still animated in a way that makes them look as if they have a long pole shoved up their poop shoot. Nice improvement, Giants. (sarcasm) Also, where are the clouds in FS 19, what's up with that nonsense?

[@ARtheman516]

the sun makes it unrealistically bright. and plus does anyone else think the lizard pickup truck model looks better in fs17. sticking with fs17 Edit:lol I just noticed you can take as long as you want on contracts and the best part is that you can have a helper do it for you lol

[@aziza7660]

On the contracts and having a helper, are you referring to FS17 or FS19 when you say you can take as long as you want?

[@ARtheman516]

@@aziza7660 fs19

[@aziza7660]

@@ARtheman516 I'm just getting in FS but I have yet to buy any game in the series. Since I am looking to buy into it, which one would you strongly recommend and why? Honestly. Thank you.

[@ARtheman516]

@@aziza7660 with fs 17 the vehicle models are much nicer and the contracts are timed and they have stories to them and you CANNOT hire a helper. fs 19 also has quests but the quests are not timed and they have no story and to me its weird that you can hire a helper to do a contract for you. but they also have contracts asking you to deliver stuff UNLIKE fs17. fs 19 has a few ugly pickup truck models. the pickup truck models look 2 or 3 times better in fs17 but they have horses in fs 19 that you can also ride. and the chickens are different because in fs 19 the eggs automatically get sorted into pallets for you to sell. but in fs17 you have to manually pick up the eggs. the graphics of fs17 has some really nice lighting. but with fs19 the lighting is sometimes way too bright.but all the other features i can think of are the same. i would go for fs 17. but if you want to play multiplayer a lot (like me) you may want to pick fs 19 because its way faster for a player to load in on fs19 its takes about 10 secs to a min. but in fs 17 it takes about 1 min to 5 mins. or you may even wanna pick fs19 because of some of the features. tbh i usually do logging and its the same in both games but i have noticed you can put way more logs in the back of a pickup truck in fs19. in fs17 if you put too much logs the front tires come off the ground XD. they might also be working on fs 21 if you wanna wait. but i dont know for a fact if they are making fs 21 yet. but thats all i know so far. And this is what i think of this game so i hope this helped you :D

[@VauxhaIIOpel]

i feel like 17 has lower graphics settings

[@cobravenomX1]

17 has a 4k setting and i use it and it looks great

[@luka985-s4c]

I feel like 17 has pale graphics

[@archie598]

if there was one thing i could change about fs19 it would be so ai can go round a field (even if its round) a few times and then up and down

[@marcelo8355]

Woah, amazing comparison!

[@cobravenomX1]

how about being able to go in houses and stores and talk to people.

[@MrMiike83]

Not being able to connect multiple semi trailers to make a road train is annoying..needs fixing..

[@user-ix2eh3xv3k]

I dont really care about the graphics fs17 is better Also fs17 is more colorful and that's why I like I think fs17 is a little dull though

[@henriqueroque3701]

The sounds have also been improved

[@user-ix2eh3xv3k]

Oh ok I know I don't really care about the sounds tho

[@henriqueroque3701]

@@user-ix2eh3xv3k Whatever dude but is big a diffrence

[@user-ix2eh3xv3k]

@@henriqueroque3701 it's just my opinion

[@henriqueroque3701]

@@user-ix2eh3xv3k Sure, I respect that

[@blackkaro9072]

fs19 just has better grapichs thats it but fs17 has better feeling to it and better mechanics (seasons mod)

[@giuh_]

It's a community made modification, that means it's not from the base game. Therefore it's stupid to call a game better because of a mod. And yes, this modification is being done for FS19 and will be released soon.

[@blackkaro9072]

Giuh okay i'm excited

[@стасмухтарович]

dirt????MORE REALISTIC + GEAR BOX + FOR REAL MODULE??weight of trailers and trucks and tractors??physics????the graphics engine is not all

[@levin4212]

im looking back at it now, 17 was just the best

Now You can clearly see the differece!

[@lordbrunswick6144]

I WAS NOT READY

[@TjRoss2012]

This is like a Walmart and dollar tree comparison. FS17 being Walmart 😂. Looks like there’s no reason to buy FS19 yet 🤷🏽‍♂️...

[@FinnleyShoveller]

Some thing about 15 and 17 that make it more realistic than fs19 and fs22 (same game engine) with fs 25 coming out in about a year they should look back on fs 15 and 17 and make a game based on mud runner graphics that would be the DREAM.

[@jameshughey5747]

I want better AI that will haul goods to where ever you tell it to

[@ilikegames5796]

James Hughey download courseplay

[@20RM02]

Well...they have that in fs 18(mobile) lol

[@Martamania26]

Fs19 looks way better visually. There are some sounds in fs17 that I prefer but overall I think fs19 is far and away the superior game mainly because of the amount of content in it.

[@MagnumLoadedTractor]

Isn't most content in fs19 ported from fs17?

[@bowen0378]

Is it just me or is fs17 more smooth than fs19. But fs19 has better graphics while fs17 doesn’t but fs19 feels like it was rushed while the other wasn’t it’s just my opinion though

[@SkyBlissyt]

Farming simulator platinum gameplay edition

[@HEROFOREVER]

9:30 for both of these time periods, it’s awful graphics. The 2019 fsgraphics aren’t even good compared to games from 2017.

[@TimmyTheSnail]

And now they’re releasing FS22 with graphics that look the same as 19, if not a little bit worse 😂

[@Adrian-kr4xz]

00:54 spójrzcie na pług po prawej stronie w farmingu 17, on źle ora to pole

[@anoxer3947]

Ja to kozak

[@spud76]

I still think FS17 looks pretty. I can't pinpoint what i don't like in FS19, but to me the graphic is more ugly and feel rushed in some way. In some way i have regretted that i have bought FS19 insted of FS17.

[@Ki_t997]

Same right here i want my money back!

[@kubabooba548]

@@Ki_t997 I just refunded FS19 for FS17. Reason being that the shadows in FS19 seem to flicker around and look like water effects from Tomb Raider PS1. The shadows would do my head in.

[@someguy1865]

I'll stick to FS17...and buy dlc and download mods for it

[@notjustfarming9486]

The chainsaw sound got fucked up on fs19

[@therealheroxx]

Great!!! Big Farming Simulator 19 Community Event incomming? 😍😉

[@justinwhittinghill4474]

I love that on farming simulator 19 on Xbox one

[@chrisandrews5174]

I play both fs 17 and fs 19 they are equally both good in there own way.

[@mariussnyman3882]

I think giants should hire all the poeple that works on the graphics on the snowrunner game.snowrunners graphics is exelent. Brilliant! !!!!!!!!

[@pondabyss]

You can just easily mod FS17 with realistic mods.... like crop destruction and better steering and all the other great mods it supports.

[@kolejbobkucz3476]

I have FS19 but I like more FS17

[@tankslayer7208]

I feel like im about to buy the fs 17 lol

[@henry9538]

Do you think it will work on HP notebook 15

[@Ethan-ck6iz]

FS17 yes, but FS19 no, I think.

[@TheWitex]

I am waiting for explanations and comments of people who call fs19 with a fried cutlet with new machines. This movie shows the post between fs17 and 19

[@lepaul26]

Yes graphics are better but straw bales are still behaving as cardboard boxes, AI still doing weird things, cars are stronger than tractors, etc etc ... this game is more than 10 years old and still has the same problems ... of course the graphics are better ... if they wouldn't have been better, why make another game ??

[@lepaul26]

Oh yes: patatoes and sugar beet are still a graphic ribbon going though the machine. Not worthy of a 2019 game The grass is even more realistic in 17 than 19 The soil after seeding corn or wheat looks the same ...

[@Nurburgring00]

Farming sim 19 has a new engine.

[@adriaanboshoff7242]

FS19 or FS17??

[@charmosthecereal637]

Adriaan Boshoff fs15

[@Pocokcic]

Who did notice the car/truck upside down?

[@PAXDOFICIAL]

They can put airplanes in farming sim 20

[@someguy1865]

Crop dusters yes

[@cnd_ion]

Farming Simulator 19 its the same 17 but also with some physics and a Graphic,not to special! FS 19 a lot of bugs not solved

[@hunterwilliams4890]

Then don't buy it and don't complain, this game has plenty more features such as already having sugarcane in it and John Deere, the game will get better just wait

[@dorianvolpe]

Suis-je le seul à préféret le 17 au 19 ? Sauf à : 6:28. Lol 😂

[@elpepeneto]

Great video man, thanks!!!

[@luka985-s4c]

In my opinion 19 is better it have better mods in modhub and other and it have better graphics and tractors

[@jaskycomendajja9433]

IF Farming simulator 19 has a little easier driving system i could play it... Remember this is my option!!

[@Xeno-yy8dz]

Whats the outro song?

[@spidergaming4664]

love the fs 19 for me best fs in history

[@RuralRyan420]

Lizard pickup rodeo > Lizard pickup 1978

[@AnkaPutra]

what is the name of the last music playing?

[@tutomukimuraisw11k]

music? check description.

[@ballomba]

PC????

[@udhamkhera3604]

We need mud mode in farming simulator 17 for ps4

[@-_-Montana-_-]

On 17 the vehicles sound better

[@archie598]

ive been playing since fs11 came out when i was 3

[@christopherandersson8109]

I hate The sound from The tractors in fs 19.

[@blake1995]

That’s one thing I like about 17 is they sound a lot better. And the vehicles actually take off faster in 17, 19 literally takes forever to get up to 40 mph

[@sethnield7821]

They weren't even the same tractors 😂 diff models on first one

[@archie598]

Seth seth crocombe?

[@sethnield7821]

Archie Da best what?

[@david110kommander9]

3:30 the car fs 17

[@esmeraldaperez3744]

Fs19 like

[@DTD2212]

FS19 is good but I prefer FS17 just because I got so used to it I guess I can't play anything else

[@Steven-hi3pk]

Does anyone think that logging is easier in fs17

[@bonkerek119]

First song?

[@rewardunkind4541]

I prefer farm 17 because I can control vehicles better

[@moslem8656]

fs19 color not my fav idk but they look so much white Giant they should fix the color "contrast" its look awesome better than 17 but i still prefer the last one hope they do gr8 in the nex FS game.

[@Sunbag4401]

I think 17 looks better and sounds better and dose anyone remember the dirt crunching sounds from 17 they are not in 19 same with gold nuggets and the starting out maps are better in 17

[@unclefestersworld3180]

gold nuggets are for people who don't want to do the work to earn accomplishments, just have everything handed to them in a tidy clean package. You know, for the lazy people.

[@kubabooba548]

​@@unclefestersworld3180 Lol. For the lazy people...Dude you play a farming simulator game.....It's not real.

[@charmosthecereal637]

Remember my old comment well I play 19 the most now that was a prank comment.

[@giannistlmz6229]

Nice work bro 👍

[@chriswizard4930]

IFF IT JUST THE GRAFIC ITS WASTE OFF MONEY. THE CAN UPGRADE THE TEXTURES AND SOUND. SO NO NEED TO BY FS 19