FDNY 3/22/24 Brooklyn: 4 Alarm Fire 413 East 3rd Street, Fire in a 2 story private dwelling

Brooklyn 4 Alarm Fire Box 3780
413 East 3rd St. Fire in a 2 story private dwelling with extension to exposure 2 and 2A

[@edotoole6604]

Another superb failure. Don’t hit the obvious spreading external fire. Concentrate on the internal fire whilst the external fire spreads around and bypasses the internal fire fight. Rinse and repeat for next exposure.

[@Greylocks]

Those buildings are so close it leads to disaster quickly. I wonder why the spaces between the buildings was not protected first? Were the spaces too thin to reach the back where a lot of visible flames were spreading? Were there things in the way to prevent access to an engine? Was sufficient water access available? I see further into the video that passing a line into the back was very difficult to do. What a difficult mess for the personnel.

[@gusbailey68]

Old codes. Not permissible today.

[@beckytwister01]

Good training video on how it's not done.

[@virgilhilts3924]

@JB91710 is notorious for babbling even though he has never been a firefighter and obviously knows nothing about firefighting

[@TheHonarable1]

jb91710 is def one of the biggest trolls out there who seems to only critique paid departments??

[@joerosado86]

This firefighters act like they are the last Coca Cola in the desert, is like the old saying goes. How many firefighters do you need to change a Lightbulb? (6) One to grab the lightbub, the other (5) to turn him around

[@virgilhilts3924]

@@joerosado86 Oh look another Boo-Boo jealous because he couldn't become a firefighter and instead has to work some boring, lame, meaningless job 😆😅😂🤣

[@JB91710]

@@virgilhilts3924 Are you Ever going to Grow Up? I know a lot of people as ignorant and childish as you will give your comments a thumbs up but to anyone with an IQ above 20 sees how pathetic you all are, and You are at the top of the list.

[@emerydavis5682]

Great video as is the norm from NYRRT. A small piece of advice to those critical of the efforts to extinguish this fire. UNLESS you are a firefighter with years of experience, please keep your criticisms of the FDNY to yourself. Watching fire videos and having no relevant training and/or experience does not qualify you to pass judgment on the FDNY. BTW, Brooklyn is 1 of the most different & challenging locations in the country to fight fires. Houses too close together, streets packed with cars, etc A lot of houses built extensively with wood. You name it, Brooklyn's got it. If you think you can do a better job, become a firefighter then rise in rank to command a Battalion. THEN & only then will your comments carry weight.

[@JB91710]

Well at least we know why you couldn't critique their performance.

[@baruchben-david4196]

Agree. Any idiot can sit and criticize what was done; and many did.

[@JB91710]

@baruchben-david4196 I see you don't have anything to offer at all. So, do you use your comment as your go-to excuse?

[@johnweber6612]

what about the right to free speech?

[@JB91710]

@@johnweber6612 Many, many people say what he did, but they are trying to make the commenters stop evaluating fire department performance because they are incapable of doing it themselves.

[@TodManning-wh6ce]

Saving the foundation in FDNY

[@turtlebarnessr0248]

The members were confronted with numerous problems with this particular incident. Balloon construction, space separation of the structures, high winds, and a water supply problem on initial arrival. Having a rescue to attend to slowed the initial attack. I don’t usually comment on fire operations but I do have to at this point. To me it appears that the Batt chief had tunnel vision and lost sight of the big picture.🇺🇸🚒🐄

[@JB91710]

This could have been extinguished from the exterior using tank water in a few minutes. You were saying?

[@pauljames5914]

Why didnt they put a line on the exp 2 side. The same thing happened in Milwaukee a couple years ago. 4 houses totally lost. A woman and her baby died. Cities should NEVER had been permitted to build wpoden houses 3 feet apart. Recipe for disaster. The Milwaukee fire was caused by a grill on a rear wooden porch.

[@baruchben-david4196]

Reading the comments, it's a shame no one was there to show them how it's done...

[@richardjensen8351]

3 houses involved and the best they can do is 1 line

[@sherribrawn3757]

I'm curious... If your house caught fire then set your neighbors on fire would your insurance cover it?

[@azul8811]

Do you think that only one line is stretched at a 4 Alarm fire?

[@craigsewell752]

Very good coverage 👍

[@johnpratt9429]

Excellent video work!

[@NYRRT]

Thank you very much!

[@100aceswid]

Fight it from the outside.

[@gusbailey68]

I get that codes were different, but this speaks volumes to separation of combustible exposures. Which structure was original fire building?

[@jz1340]

Great capture....

[@sherribrawn3757]

Precisely the reason I chose my two story single family dwelling that's at least 100 feet from another home. I'm curious though.. If a fire in your home set your neighbors house on fire would your insurance cover it as well???

[@glenbearh9109]

Wow the guts it takes to enter the building!

[@TodManning-wh6ce]

😂😂😂😂 I did it it's not that big of a deal😂😂😂😂😂

[@earllutz2663]

I have done it also. It's just what you do when you are a fire fighter.

[@glenbearh9109]

@@earllutz2663 Actually I did save a life in a fire at the state hospital I worked for. A patient set another's room on fire and the other patient ran to the window which is barred and I carried him out. my lower pant leg caught fire but no injuries!

[@azul8811]

@@TodManning-wh6ce What IAFF local did you belong to?

[@moemcgovern7345]

I Pray there was no injuries.

[@JB91710]

The FDNY is notorious for ignoring Visible Burning Material to "Go Inside" to get Off while Playing the Hero. In most FDNY KZbin video you will see them go inside to only be driven out by the fire they walked by outside which has now gotten so big, they can't survive inside. How do you think the victims are managing in their street or night cloths? Do you see that fire at 3:00? Why is no one out there eliminating it by this time? The camera person was able to get there after spending a lot of time out front. They let the flames go out the alley windows and attack the house next door, and now, it's heading to the third house all because they are trying to extinguish this from the inside. Your heroes in action. The guys that, "Go inside rather than fighting the fire from the outside." Outside where they actually have a clear and safe access to the burning rooms through those windows. What they SHOULD have done from the beginning, they reluctantly did at the end. 7:20 What does he think he is going to accomplish going inside that room with no hose to stop combustion? 7:40 DO YOU SEE WHAT THEY ARE DOING? They are standing there watching while they ALLOW the fire to consume the THIRD house when it should have been stopped at the first house. These are not Firefighters! If this doesn't prove it to you, I have a massive file that proves their incompetence. There is NO REASON to LET that fire damage the third house and yet they do. Why isn't water still being pumped through the attic window? 8:20 Does this not look insane to you? Not one person there, cares. Putting water in the alley at the end when it should have happened from the front at the beginning with an assault to the rear.

[@williamlogullo8452]

Let me just say you’re an idiot!

[@mfcjr1]

Maybe you should show them how it is done. I have never seen you with a positive post.

[@ALee8456]

🐔💩🤡 🤏🍆

[@JB91710]

@@mfcjr1 When 95% of departments in the USA have no clue what the job is let alone how to do it, combined with my ability to THINK rather than FOLLOW, what other comments should you expect to see? UL and ISFSI are 95% correct in their teaching and yet, those 95% of departments ignore them for much less effective and much more dangerous and irresponsible tactics. What does That tell you? Notice your 5 thumbs Up people had nothing to say at all. You people are nothing but Followers!

[@mfcjr1]

@@JB91710 Your hate for the USA shows.

[@Lovejoyrat2]

Oooof those exposures were so close together. I don’t think I’d buy something that’s close like that. Balloon structures?

[@joerosado86]

Am sure am going to get slammed for saying this, but what I don't understand is, they have a in the back with a little fire starting on the 3rd house, why don't they throw a little water for the time being before it turns out into a third major fire on that 3rd residence, nope, can't do that yet, we need to let the dam house fire to get bigger before they move their culito... we don't see this kind incompetent here in Chicago, only in NYC & And New Jersey

[@Dan-O40]

I am not a firefighter but if I was I would be embarrassed to say I was part of this terrible work.

[@asbestosfiber]

Yeah, You had me until you started in with "Chicago's great" BS. every FD has issues.

[@joerosado86]

@@asbestosfiber Yeap, only with the ones that have too many Prima Donna's

[@JB91710]

You see this performance in every USA big city and the FDNY is one of the worst. This was Typical, not the exception.

[@JB91710]

@@asbestosfiber You have a name that would send chills up anyone's spine!

[@piercedriver1]

Defensive attack from rear outside, then aggressive interior attack.water curtain between exposure side 2 & 4. I’m not critiquing or armchair quarterbacking, that’s just what I would have done. With 33 years as asst chief in a city department. Every incident is different and I’m not privy to all information. I’m certain they did their best at the time.

[@azul8811]

What “city” was that?

[@williamlogullo8452]

@@azul8811the city you don’t want to be in lol

[@JB91710]

You stop it with the common sense and logic! Who do you think you are? The FDNY? ;-)

[@azul8811]

@@JB91710 See if you can persuade your comrade to tell us what “city” he was an Assistant Chief in for 33 years…and if Assistant Chiefs drive Pierce Engines and Trucks in that city Department.

[@JB91710]

@@azul8811 It doesn't matter what city anyone fought a fire in or how long they did it. All that matters is their performance from a strong and responsibly work ethic based on common sense, logic and grade school science. The FDNY is one of the worst departments in the country if not the world so how do those letters impress you?

[@Battalion31]

Tough job, limited access, good job, assume balloon frame construction too

[@JB91710]

Yeah, blame everything on balloon framing. They are incompetent and that's all there is to it.

[@deborahsoucy2884]

Excellent video --- Debbie & Tiffany

[@grabasandwich]

2:57 looks strangely washed out. What kind of camera?

[@negansstuntdouble1777]

Anytime some o u clowns commenting wanna come help out in parts of Brooklyn Queens Bronx n Harlem come on in, I guarantee u will have fun in as little as 24 hrs, make sure u bring diapers

[@jz1340]

Working fire experts on their keyboards in their mother's basement.

[@negansstuntdouble1777]

True- They have no idea@@jz1340

[@mgratk]

Why didn't they use the quadruple deck gun that draws moisture directly from the air???!

[@negansstuntdouble1777]

Waited for rain?@@mgratk

[@mikeggg1979]

FDNY best of the best 💪🏻🥃

[@skeptical2649]

Gimme a radio. I want to talk too!

[@ronfreniere8769]

Hopefully there were no injuries to anyone related to this incident, and wow the back of those buildings were really cooking. Thank you to all firefighters everywhere for protecting the citizens of your coverage area.

[@philipdecatanzaro1822]

When I saw/heard this on another video yesterday there was a 10-45 Code 2 in the radio traffic. Not sure of the outcome of that person.

[@ronfreniere8769]

@@philipdecatanzaro1822 well if there were any injuries Hopefully there were minor. Thanks for letting me know.

[@csalerno7472]

In FDNY codes a 10-45 Code 2 means critical injury unfortunately.

[@ronfreniere8769]

@@csalerno7472 that's to bad, hoping & praying for them

[@NYRRT]

@@philipdecatanzaro1822 Person just passed away 😥

[@udizzy1969]

Good work David, Stay Safe Dizzy.

[@glyn1]

Building to CLOSE man how many are they going to lose

[@stillbobrb9]

Ask the builder, if you can locate his grave. These homes were grandfathered in…

[@williamlogullo8452]

I love these comments lmao 🤣 bye the way hell of a job. FDNY!

[@beverlyboys73]

Very sad😢

[@JB91710]

That's the FDNY! Anybody see anything wrong with this picture? This is what happens when you fight fires from the inside out. Even when the fire is on the outside. It looks more heroic that way. I wonder what excuses they will use.

[@loganMcMorrow232]

can you repeat that i think the last thing they want to be doing is standing outside spraying the fire

[@user-ci5zp3vk4f]

Shakin in my gloves😭 0:22

[@abcxyz-io7wt]

A lot of trash talk here, are any of you firefighters

[@JB91710]

Obviously you aren't.

[@gerryjamieson1861]

Well that didn't go well!! . To not put a couple of lines in between the houses (1 line in front and 1 line in back) to protect the exposures on both sides of the fire building makes no sense. You can see how much the fire is allowed to grow. And to let the fire at the back between houses 2 and 3 is ridiculous. You don't need to be a professional firefighter for decades to see the need to protect the exposures and thus help control the spread of fire from house to house. If I were the homeowner of the third house I'd be pretty pissed off.

[@bigboyhotstuff]

That’s literally exactly what’s going on the rear. There was about 4 lines alone that were protecting the exposures. The only reason why a 3rd and 4th exposure wasn’t involved, was because of the exterior lines

[@bigboyhotstuff]

I think you also may be confused because the video is showing different angles at similar time stamps.

[@JB91710]

@@bigboyhotstuff What video are you commenting on? Did you see how long it took them to extinguish this Tiny fire?

[@bigboyhotstuff]

@@JB91710 mental health awareness brotha. Go get checked

[@FradetotheLIMIT]

1928 why is he carrying a can inside? please im not trying to be a D im really asking

[@JB91710]

They can be of great use on small fires in a room. It doesn't hurt if you have nothing else to do.

[@TodManning-wh6ce]

We had a fire on the 87 floor and the Chicago fire department showed up and brought a can to put out fire and the room flashed over when they open the door they almost killed 6 firefighters and none of them had scba on

[@JB91710]

@@TodManning-wh6ce Well, it sounds like they did a few things wrong!

[@williammora7077]

A Wind- Driven Fire.

[@williamlogullo8452]

These comments are hilarious, again another great job by the FDNY

[@mikeymcmikeface5599]

lol

[@JB91710]

That's what all the Hero Worshippers say no matter how they do.

[@gailbarrett5525]

What caused this fire?

[@joshastana849]

Mice with matches

[@cm-ek4ci]

Russian with a careless cigarette 😊

[@timweis3265]

Solar panels and the battery system

[@kevinjones1993]

Wow very sad , all the guys they have on scene nothing get done , why did it take them so long to put out the fire on expos 3 I don’t understand why there weren’t able to get that fire put out sooner with a aggressive attack 😮

[@williamlogullo8452]

lol 😂

[@JB91710]

This is typical of the FDNY. Look for it in all their videos.

[@JB91710]

@@williamlogullo8452 That was really mature. Obviously, you have no clue how to fight fires.

[@williamlogullo8452]

@@JB91710 lol

[@bobandvirginiaravera4775]

Excellent video! FDNY did its usual aggressive attack but this was a dangerous fire!

[@mikeymcmikeface5599]

Lies.

[@JB91710]

What video were you, oh it's you. I should have known.

[@transilvanischervampir666]

🧐

[@mikeggg1979]

Why living in this dump city sucks. Houses are literally on top of each other. Brooklyn is definitely the worst of all the boroughs, most blocks the houses are connected and if there detached the guy next doors house is 5 feet or less

[@eriksand9262]

So...every major cities housing plan?? 🤣🤣

[@craighanson-rc1md]

imagine being in an apartment & it catching fire.... Then it's not just one family or two but you have logs of people & traffic with the building possible to fall apart of whatever.

[@HerbertWilder-pd8qm]

I never did like to. Live to build the clothes like that👉🔥🔥🔥🔥🏚🏚 hell naw The bad problem is just standing there. Why did it burn? Why not put some water on it now? You got 2 fires now As though you all wanted to burn , you get more money for how well it burns You had to water holes.All you had to do is put it on the other house 😅😢😇😂🤣💦💦💦🤦🏿

[@stillbobrb9]

Why don’t you become a firefighter? Ask the family that will bury their love one the firefighter? These men put their lives on the line daily yet some computer junkie dares to criticize why!