Finally hearing Mahalini for the first time! Reaction and vocal analysis of the song "Sial"

[@stuffwelike7184]

My fist time hearing this, she has an amazing voice.

[@WilsonKurniawan]

l love to have conversation,,but i use only watch up,,,dont have telegram,,,,,,,how about you,,??

[@rahmatnugraha85]

You have to see this mahalini during a live performance, it's better than the recording studio version.., so powerful ❤

[@NajwaDasmaAshilla]

Up

[@eptbrofist]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4iWnqt5a7Smr6s her live performance

[@zuladika2077]

not really..on live so many flat note from her.. but overall she can improve and her vocal can be one of the best in indonesia..

[@iceelf-gs1492]

Another incredible vocalist… ❤Thank you! Yes, so many great singers, so little time…

[@zenn54321]

It's one thing when a song can deliver emotion with just the melody and singing, it's a whole other world when you understand the language. That's when you can truly connect with the message the song wants to convey.

[@mysecret3684]

I got goosebumps when Mahalini covered the song The weekend - Call out my name on the see you on wednesday channel

[@XizhuoKhiel]

UP

[@TheVocalyst]

Ooh I'll have a listen!

[@menottriwahyuningsih7454]

@@TheVocalyst kzbin.info/www/bejne/haeoqYl3ZauGZpo

[@jihadelakbar-sn9jx]

Up

[@NajwaDasmaAshilla]

Up

[@herlingmajid2254]

love your reaction Bethany 💕 Agree! Mahalini is amazingly good ✨✨

[@nafzter]

your reaction and your analysis is second to none....love it ❤

[@jufrihidayat42]

I love your review. The way you described it, it’s so legit, you know how to spell it with words. Not all people can do this as good as you, and it’s a talent I suppose. And as not an English speaker, I can understand what you are trying to explain.

[@gumsmusic8936]

This is exactyle how the expression should given, i love how she describe mahalini's vocal character, really appreciate it!

[@titinw3639]

Hi.. Im indonesian, Surprisingly you pronounced "sial" perfectly

[@NTHTVal]

Thank you for sharing this reaction Bethany 😁. Much ❤ from Indonesia

[@ilockeyou]

What an awesome and detailed review! I enjoyed it so much. Kisah Sempurna and Sisa Rasa definitely a must. I think these two songs showcase her vocal much more than this one. Looking forward to it. xoxo.

[@turfinteractionsgolf]

Jut found your channel this week, I've probably watched 20+ of your videos already! I've never come across Mahalini before either, she's got a totally fantastic voice. Personally I'd absolutely love to see your reaction to Elise Trouw, I'm a massive fan of hers and if you aren't already it won't take you long to join the fan club!!

[@glenmasdan5977]

Next 100%you have to reach the winner Indonesian idol 2023 SALMA singing JUST THE WAY YOU ARE (Bruno mars ) LOVE ME LIKE YOU DO (Ellie Goulding ) itu waspada crazy version of the song ever Bet you Will like itu so much. Trust me great musicality and crazy key changes

[@burhanblues3110]

I love your reaction😍🙏

[@suhadihadi7848]

Love the reaction , i can watch all day

[@desember-c2w]

Wow she has an amazing voice and the lyrics of the song are really sad

[@de_nars]

Love your analysis of the song.

[@magdalenaflorencia6211]

Indonesian person commenting!~ Hi! I am Magdalena and i am from Indonesia and my family always liked this song!

[@litalianabostan3811]

I think one the reasons she sings this song so beautifully is because she wrote this song.So she knows exactly how she wants to deliver and project it.

[@mika_al]

Appreciate your analysis for this song

[@hidayatullahyazid8797]

She writes this song herself, and also she has very beautiful voice...

[@freedomforlyfe2946]

no, this music is created by Andmesh kamaleng the lyrics and the note. she improvise the note on 'SIAL' so she owned this song with the way she sing this music cause she feel this music is andmesh style rather than her.

[@debbyelisaa09]

She made that song, and she really great for apply this feeling at her song..

[@jerryferreira8960]

Wow! Goosebumps material there!!!

[@shalizaalisya7293]

You should react to her other discography as well; Melawan Restu, Bohongi Hati and Kisah Sempurna..all of these songs are my favourites 😍

[@NajwaDasmaAshilla]

Up

[@diki357]

Up! “Sisa Rasa - Mahalini” with 132M viewers on youtube!

[@diki357]

Mahalini - Sisa Rasa kzbin.info/www/bejne/jZmZZ4eepd2pf5Y

[@adeniavanie]

Mahalini sangat menjiwai dalam menyanyikan lagu ini, sehingga yang melihatnya terbawa dalam kesedihan. Terima kasih atas analisanya Beth dan reaksi yang bagus! 🙌

[@marzuxyy4677]

Yang paling penting adalah penyampain dalam suara

[@donrangga1471]

Mahalini is a great singer, performer, and song writer. Her song is like a bomb in here. next, you may want to check The Indonesian Idol special season (2021) winner, Rimar Callista. She is so underrated, but got the most standing ovation in all season (indo's idol). Please analyze her performances; I'm telling you i'm not going (Jeniffer Hudson), Vision of Love (Mariah Carey), or Lovely (billie eilish)

[@NajwaDasmaAshilla]

Up

[@HarisPratama1992]

true

[@tanpanama2141]

Up

[@aripratama333]

Yeay......Rimar...🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@yotan6108]

Next reaksi Cakra cover di lagu Mahalini Siall ini please😊thanks sdh mereaksi artis cantik Mahallini... Ditunggu reaksi berikutnya👉

[@Yohaerys_Targaryen]

Sampai kesini lagunya mahalini d reac, keren keren

[@Watdehek]

Akhirnya mereaksi penyanyi Indonesia lagi😊

[@iwayanherdiana7617]

Beautifull Song, and very great review dear

[@zhaiazhary]

Love everything ur comment on her vocal, so yeah just like playin with her voice so do our feeling through the song.. love from indonesia

[@brklynbby13]

this is my first time watching video reaction without skipping

[@hendraalab10]

Golden Buzzer: Putri Ariani receives the GOLDEN BUZZER from Simon Cowell | Auditions | AGT 2023

[@hendraalab10]

Putri Ariani from INDONESIA

[@hendraalab10]

Amerika Got Talent

[@hendraalab10]

🙏🙏🙏👌👍

[@NajwaDasmaAshilla]

Mahalini penyanyi muda Indonesia 🎉🎉 next react Salma - just the way you are, Indonesian idol 2023🙏🙏🥰🥰

[@andriandri7010]

PROFESIONAL REACTION❤❤❤

[@grantos28cars]

Very cool, you need to check out Aldous Harding from New Zealand, the song.. Swell does the skull. It's the recording she done in her bathroom, she has like 3 different singing voices, this one is my favorite.

[@scoobyblue5300]

Loving all your reactions...particularly Rammstein's Mein Herz Brent! If I could reccomend the official video of David Bowie singing Wild Is The Wind...in my humble opinion one of the greatest vocal performances of modern times. Thank you.

[@Idur123]

Next Putri Ariani from Indonesia. Golden Buzzer: Putri Ariani receives the GOLDEN BUZZER from Simon Cowell | Auditions | AGT 2023

[@TheIrearmel]

Out of context but i just love the way you talk, explaining things, your voice sounds so clear

[@sakilahvn9706]

Thanks for react this video

[@beckyvashon4297]

Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge. I am learning to appreciate singers so much more because of you. I luv learning and growing. Would you review K. T. Lang singing "Crying"?

[@BUDIMULLYYANA29]

great reaction sist..

[@dhenmasipo5969]

Sister Please, Salma's reaction to the final of Indonesia Idol 2023 entitled "just the way you are" from Bruno Mars...awesome

[@aldebaran_9142]

Wow, thanks 👍🏼

[@se_sechannel]

Saya suka reaction dari anda 🤗 saya suka ekspresi anda 🤗 terimakasih banyak atas komentar baik nya 😁

[@joekiplik9108]

You can feel the msg ...

[@nandacaem]

thank you for the reaction to Indonesia's sweet heart

[@nukehatta]

Hi Bethany, love ur reaction n comment on indonesian singer like Mahalini/Chakra Khan. If u don't mind, can u also comment on Simon Cowell Golden Buzzer AGT 2023, Putri Ariani? Thx a bunch. N btw, Chakra Khan is also gonna be on AGT this year. Yep, he is in US right now. 😊

[@RamonJulian_]

Please reaction Keisya Levronka "Tak ingin usai", Anggi Marito "Tak segampang itu" and Ghea Indrawari "Jiwa yang bersedih"

[@oktavianustoddy453]

beth please watch this Putri Ariani receives the GOLDEN BUZZER 2023 you gonna like this try not emotional

[@rifarif9987]

Please check to the winner of indonesian idol 2023. Salma - Just the way you are

[@anisazannnnn]

the last verse of the song got me emotional

[@suhaidi01]

Indonesia proud of u

[@amomenttoremember1877]

Komenmu cringe bro. Plis jangan malu"in lah

[@DosBear]

Johnny Mathis/Patsy Cline/Brenda Lee/Engelbert Humperdink/Doris Day/Dean Martin/Lionel Richie/Bob Seger/Christopher Cross are a few you should consider analyzing. I enjoy your channel.

[@Strayfegaming]

have you done Morrisette Amon doing defying gravity yet? or Disney Princess Medley from Voctave? highly recommended!

[@kevinjovanoo]

13:45 that was exactly my face expression when I hear that part 😅

[@ulynalmoefidah3590]

Mahalini emang penyanyi yang berkualitas.. Salam INDONESIA

[@arieswicaksono4741]

there is a slight error in the focus of the part that needs to be reviewed. because Indonesians don't want you to review this song in any part other than the part at minute 13:29 - 13.50. precisely in that part this song went viral in Indonesia. So you spend a lot of time reacting in the unimportant parts, and the parts that make this song go viral, you don't give enough reactions

[@raka9311]

Mungkin setelah ini, anda harus liat bagaimana cara Cakra Khan bernyanyi untuk cover lagu ini 🎉

[@dessysiti]

Setuju 😊

[@ibalkarafa939]

Ow voice , Amazing ..

[@dwipras-fo4rl]

You should react mahalini live performance

[@mzm03]

one day if possible i want to hear your voice singing this song in your own way...anyway i like the way you criticize this song..good job

[@nbw0313]

Beautiful! You might want to take a look at Irina Rimes - Urbanist Session, she has like a set of 3-4 songs in live format.

[@fifidyahkl3535]

You should have to listen this song "sial" at Cakra Khan's cover. More full of "taste" 😀😁

[@brownbaschannel136]

Up

[@desawisata0409]

Kalau masalah Bakat, saya yakin indonesia gudangnya di banding negara2 lain , tapi Brending dan menegemen belum secanggih amerika, eropa, india,atau korea, semoga industri seni kita tambah maju dengan membawa identitas bangsa. Semoga ada menegement utama buat para budayawan industri atau non indurtri Andai musik indonesia ada PSSI NYA Pasti musik indonesia maju mendunia Semangat buat TIMNAS MUSIK INDONESIA!!!! Andai itu mudah sudah pasti dunia seni di kuasai indonesia. Yakin yakin yakin!!! Semoga anda salah satu promotor Dunia untuk Indonesia.,

[@lilitinggarsih2044]

Wow keren mantap 👍 thank you

[@ranuwijaya6916]

l love this vidio. You like a magic mirror that's revealed the content of the messages

[@KartuAs-lu6ex]

Mahalini mantap

[@halwakhoirunnisa358]

Thanks for reaction, next reaction rimar the winner Indonesian idol 2022

[@ibrakun89]

I like the way you react to videos, I recommended video from Banda Neira - Sampai Jadi Debu (Legend of indie/folk music in Indonesia) Or Yura Yunita - Dunia Tipu Tipu

[@samz917]

hi you should watch Mahalini ft Andmesh - Putus Atau Terus

[@segulac2]

It would be interesting to see your reaction of Klaus Nomi - Total Eclipse

[@bomi3002]

Next reaction, she from 🇮🇩 golden buzzer putri ariani receives the golden buzzer from simon cowell auditions agt 2023

[@ridwanpanakawan2280]

Next react to Putri Ariani receives the Golden Buzzer America's Got Talent 2023.. she singing and play piano to

[@irmaindri5738]

Love it❤ thanks Miss🫶 next Through the rain covered by Indonesian Singers

[@Pt14ka]

Бетани здравствуйте! Всегда приятно Вас видеть и слышать. Хочу посоветовать Вам послушать группу 'Алиса' песню ' Небо славян'

[@azidanenr]

please react to her latest single called Mencintaimu. ive got chills all over the song😭🥺❤

[@muhaiminhariyansyah152]

Pls check mahalini live(mati-matian) x factor indonesia

[@dianr5952]

Thanks .

[@marinabeana]

Please give your review of Alison Moyet! Any song!

[@12pm85]

mahalini terkenal sampe luar luar 😮

[@Super-Glad]

Please listen to another Indonesian singer Reza in her song Kepastian. The lyricist created that song dedicated only to her ❤❤❤

[@wahyujodisaputra4700]

Halo the vocalis Please reaction Putri ariani on American got talent, her receives the golden buzzer, thanks

[@harliblack]

Up

[@iwanchair2213]

Watch salma at final indonesian idol 2023 please

[@tyoprasetyo4512]

Please reaction mahalini..."mati matian" please

[@ressa6425]

Please reaction Tak ingin Usai that indonesian famous song ever

[@fendz00]

sial means good luck

[@DeezDelRey.]

if you like to hear riff n runs you should watch "peri cintaku - ziva magnolya"

[@RogerVenderer-wu1lw]

I hope you react to Niki Zefanya (Ocean & Engine), Stephanie Poetri (I love you 3000), and Anggun C Sasmi (Mimpi) they are famous Indonesian singer that know globally

[@vanyaprilia]

try "sisa rasa" by mahalini also

[@Ridth-one]

Putri ariani next, AGT golden buzzer recently from Indonesia..trust me, it's good

[@dhimasmanis9802]

Please reaction , for ziva magnolya - peri cintaku ..

[@ibuross9907]

Please check American got talent ....there are Putri Ariani from Indonesia. She got golden buzzers

[@ajiesenoputro]

hi, I'm from Indonesia. can you react to Anneth's video when she was on Indonesia Idol Junior?

[@StarGate960]

My first impression, it seems this song very personal for you.. i can see in your face, but i dont know.. maybe im wrong 🙌🏻

[@freedomforlyfe2946]

1 % komentar cara bernyanyi mahalini dan 99% terbawa perasaan lirik nya 😂

[@jasminew8835]

I'd like to see you do Tina Turner 1985 grammys performance.

[@anandarizky3361]

Please to react Salma-Just the way you are Indonesian Idol Resukt and Reunion.😊

[@nikitayudistirakiki_ompol4896]

Please react putri ariani perform in AMERICA GOT TALENT .. She's 17 years old,she song writers,and she voice like a superstar ...

[@stefanofernandes4140]

Please react: Lyodra - Sang Dewi Thank you