Chilling Video Captures Ex-Kazakh Minister Beating His Wife to Death | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Chilling Video Captures Ex-Kazakh Minister Beating His Wife to Death | Vantage with Palki Sharma
The trial of a former economy minister, Kuandyk Bishimbayev, has gripped Kazakhstan, sparking conversations about domestic abuse. A brutal CCTV footage, played in the court, shows him dragging his wife, Saltanat Nukenova, and then punching and kicking her in a restaurant owned by one of his relatives last November. The trial has created a massive uproar in Kazakhstan, where about 400 women die from domestic abuse every year, according to the United Nations. This figure is believed to be higher as many cases go unreported. Will this "trial of the century" change the way Kazakhstan deals with domestic violence? Palki Sharma tells you.
---
Kazakh Minister | Wife | Murder | Death | Video | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#kazakhminister #wife #murder #death #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
​
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...

[@user-ve5eg2mv7h]

He did this in public, imagine the things he did in private and got away with before. God rest her soul.

[@KuralayAlibayeva]

She was his 3rd wife. The first one died in strange circumstances. The second one escaped with their 3 children.

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

@@KuralayAlibayeva even after knowing this why this girl married him ? 🤣

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

@@KuralayAlibayeva Then its their mistake, no one can fix girls emotional melodrama. If girls doesn't become practical & rational & remain greedy for wealth & status no one can help them.

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

@@KuralayAlibayeva why girls has this utopia to change someone what nature made them like that ? Why can't girls mind their own business & become rational ? Why is this itch ?

[@AyAReI00]

​@@KuralayAlibayevanot true, he stalked him for months sHe rejected him for months, he pretty much stalk her ...maybe he worn her down, besides he probably lied a lot

[@rogerdat37]

For you to beat someone to death with your bare hands, you have to be filled with pure evil and nothing but hatred for the person.

[@EavyMuturuh]

Exactly

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

Normal central Asian primitive men.

[@macrofrommicro6241]

Do you think politicians are good people they are power hungry pigs and most rich people get to top by doing shady stuff because if you think you can become rich by being good then you are nieve.girls who rejects poor or middle class man because they aren't that successful and say we would rather be depressed on a yacht than a hut you will pay the price of being with a evil real evil person which they are .so leave good man for more successful man and see what will happen .I know anyone with this mindset will not agree with me .

[@cohendarwin5365]

​@@surojeetchatterji9966 Religion of peace

[@blucation6060]

And hatred for himself

[@SwaggieSteve]

The fact that the women have to protest against whether or not beatings are legal is messed up..

[@tom416]

Right??? They shouldn't be out protesting. If they actually had something to say that was worth hearing they should have their man evaluate it for merit and speak for her. But we all know that wouldn't happen because they never have merit. They come close sometimes but over all, should just shut up and observe. The world would be such a better place.

[@SwaggieSteve]

@@tom416 Sorry to hear about your mental health issues.

[@mossadagent9582]

Wife beatings is legal in Islam but not to beat them to death

[@WakandaleezaRazz]

It’s a 👳🏾‍♀️✈️ country. So peaceful.

[@user-fe7mg5ot9z]

@@tom416 Clearly, you were never taught how to behave morally. Women are NOT possessions, and only a psychopath would think so.

[@noinflouencer]

I feel so sick to my stomach. He felt safe enough to beat her up in public in front of cameras. This says all about him and the country. I’m in disbelief

[@roslynnamy]

in your country abortion is legal lol

[@aakashuikey778]

This is Islamic country

[@ausra4423]

@@aakashuikey778 no, muslim country

[@noinflouencer]

@@roslynnamy yes and?

[@noinflouencer]

@@aakashuikey778 well that’s not exactly justifying it or giving a reason…

[@MDM-JinJoo]

I believe him! He didn't mean to kill her. He meant to keep beating her, torturing her, and keeping her in a state of living where he could continue to terrorize her. No, he didn't mean to get rid of his playtoy for good.

[@NaturallyAwaken]

Same is happening in Gaza by Israeli where the civilians and treated like playtoy.... That side of the story First post will never disclose! Be ashamed How one sided their only agenda to criticise one particular faith whilst the fact they themselves are the Biggest Criminals

[@antmck99]

​@@NaturallyAwaken why is this happening again? Keep crying

[@gshrdy5415]

@@antmck99 , peaceful religion is the reason.

[@Fifimon]

​@@gshrdy5415Hey👋👋👋 from which brainwashing university have you been graduated? Did YOU KNOW having brain can have brain cancer but it's OK you ARE SAFE👌👌👌 FREE PALESTINE🇵🇸 support FROM USA🇺🇸

[@ind3996]

​@@NaturallyAwaken same people of Gaza were recruited by Hamas. Have u seen the videos where semi naked dead body of a woman soaked in blood was paraded across the streets of Gaza. None of the Gazans protested it. Nobody even batted an eye. Now don't come and say that it is a propaganda video. If that's a propaganda video so are the videos of Gaza people.

[@justianiwahjudi3901]

He beats up his wife for eight hours, the ambulance arrived after 12 hours, where are the others, no one see it or hear his punches, no one reported it ? Unbelievable! The society doesn't work there ??! Come on, shame all of you Kazakh!

[@assemakqw0057]

He is one of the most powerful here, like he was economical minister , and he owns the restaurant and was beating his wife to death in the VIP-room, where no camera. Well,apparently , there were witnesses, the waiters were there, but he sent them home, and called his cousin to try cover up his murder, and told him to delete the CCTV footage. But after everything was revealed , police restored video-footage like after 2 weeks. (Sorry about my english, it's my third language)

[@ElizabethGrindon]

@@assemakqw0057 Your English is very good!

[@momchilandonov]

@@assemakqw0057why is his cousin not in prison for complicit to murder?!

[@danagul1076]

​@@momchilandonovhe is also under arrest and actually sitting with him in the court room. Also as i know he is the owner of the restaurant

[@desireeclarins5491]

@@assemakqw0057 - Powerful???? NO! He is a coward. Only cowards beat women up. And he was only the Finance Minister, big deal.

[@lasenoritacometa1977]

He was beating her like if he was fighting a man. What a coward and shame shame ..

[@eaglemgtow2789]

women = Men

[@talkingtochapri]

I bet, this male can't fight no male 🤢 that's why he was jealous and doing all these.

[@Assbeaterniggachad]

I mean men and women are equal?

[@Ellemphriem]

What is worrying in the comment section is that instead of having all people unite against such cruelty we have actual debates…. There is NOTHING to debate here.

[@talkingtochapri]

Facts 💯 but let them debate because I wanted more women see how males think about unaliving wives and how damaging marriages can be to them.

[@itsbonkerjojo9028]

What are they debating about tho ? I just see everyone hatin him collectively

[@simmods3361]

Poor woman 😢 No wonder many women are just preferring to stay single. Staying single or unmarried is better than be in abusive and suffocating marriage.

[@ineedpowers5151]

It goes mostly for Men!

[@meghanarora4136]

@@ineedpowers5151 naah marriage is heaven for men but hell for women.. at least in third world countries. not talking about western society

[@whyarepeopledumb9819]

​@@meghanarora4136 Liberal woke so called women barking in the comment section.

[@BinuIJK]

​@@meghanarora4136men suffer from marriages too

[@ananya255]

@@whyarepeopledumb9819 What is woke about this? Have you checked the domestic violence stats in third world countries?

[@patrickwilliam8060]

My wife is Kazakh, this has made the news because he is high profile. Women go through this everyday in Kazakhstan and most of the time no one is arrested.

[@noexcuses5524]

Not just in Kazakhstan. Also in russia, it is not acceptable but tolerated. I did some digging why and it has something to do with mandate military training. Some of the men were trauatize, and they want their partner to live through their trauma , is like a subconscious thing. Those people are despicable. There was a man in russia who cut off his wife hand. It gotten into news cus the dudne literally machete his wife hand. If u search more domestic abuse in russia, u will be shock. How many the statistics. Like i said it is too much that they just tolerate it. Not all men were abusive but some. Also, the sad thing is the woman will develop a trauma bond to the suspect and the abuser will put a negative affirmation into the victim mind and make them live, separate from their families and friends, also incapacitate them from earning money so the victim are dependent on the abuser so they won't run away.

[@norsidahyangyahaya6820]

Oh my god 🙄

[@zhouzen5172]

Something wrong with the men there, too much testosterone

[@PradhanmantriBruhh]

😮😮

[@PradhanmantriBruhh]

​@@noexcuses5524 Sounds like the man needs serious help😢 This is so sad.

[@anjyr3130]

I'm from Russia, and we watch here this case with high attention, as we have the same law problem. Domestic violence is decriminalized. You know, the thing that shocked me mostly is that his mother protected him in the court. She asked for understanding for her son who was forced to be violent by his wife's behavior. I can understand that there are monsters in the world, but I can't understand a woman who thinks killing other woman is OK. Mother is always mother, ok. She could support him somehow privately if she wanted. But her public speech in court was disgusting. By the way, today he got 24 years in prison for his crime. Just it.

[@Kim-vs4vb]

His mother helped make him the monster he is, she condones his behavior bcoz she most likely was is beaten by her husband and father n so it continued as if it’s normal way to live, she too needs jail time.

[@audraelynnegrimmelhaussen8808]

Disgusting mother

[@whokNews8888]

This is a damn shame! Hideous! When will men be held accountable for this behavior. Women are not property. What a cowardly act!

[@WilliamCarr-qe8sl]

Well…that man should certainly be made accountable for his cowardly barbarism against that poor woman when it’s so obvious and apparent what was on the video.

[@MansaMusa001]

First of all, how the heck do you beat someone for 8 whole hours? Like, where do you even get the energy for that. He then proceeded to call 'his fortune teller' instead of a doctor?! As if this is not weird enough, the ambulance arrived after 12 hours?! How messed up is Kazakhstan that such a guy would make it to the cabinet?! How does a nation sink to such depths of dysfunction???

[@rosebecker2242]

A psycho in the government

[@sharanya8008]

Exactly!!

[@onestate7734]

Kazakhstan is like N.Korea, its minister are like Pharaoh.

[@Seevawonderloaf]

Any place that doesn’t have fairness for women

[@eunicemwicigi8104]

Their law itself doesn't even consider domestic violence a crime.

[@dahirdubow8636]

It is extremely too horrible. He should never see sunlight

[@Dan-xx5jq]

I agree. So heartbreaking. No one helped her. She was his punching bag. So Evil.

[@Dan-xx5jq]

one would not treat a dog like that! So awful. I wish I had not seen this. It is too awful. She was gorgeous!

[@dracovirals7705]

Because she committed Adultery

[@OO9O9]

​@@dracovirals7705so?

[@Shraddha_Surfing]

​@@Dan-xx5jq why the fck would you give an example of dogs in any BAD context? Dogs are GODS. So please, stop it. 😡

[@najoy2861]

What's more horrible is that this happened in public..... Other people saw this disgusting shit happening and nobody even tried to help? What a horrible society

[@vladG30]

it was caught on security camera and published, that's why we got to know it. Otherwise, she's be another victim swept under the rug. There are powerful people in many countries who murder and never get arrested. I forgot the name of one British lord who abused and killed children all his life, like more than 70 or 80 of them and the information was only leaked out by the end of his life. It was hushed for decades. They watched him kill children for decades, but an English lord was above the law in their view. There are thousands upon thousands of women and children who died from the hand of such maniacs in upper echelons of power across the world. Not only those crimes were covered up, but in some elite circles the right of passage is to commit a heinous murder and get away with it. In fact they think the very definition of elite is not paying for crimes. When someone loses their elite position, their crimes can be prosecuted again. In this case this Kazakh minister lost his position, because Nazarbaev he was working for, got ousted and slowly his elite circle dismantled. That's why they felt free to publish this video and talk on TV about it.

[@ruthsadler2864]

He said she " just fell over"!! The women of Kazakhstan can not drop this, this shit is sickening 😤

[@ranran8934]

This is why women nowadays chose to be single rather than to be in a horrible marriages.

[@endtimeslips4660]

and you rally for palestine the very front of sex abuse practitioners. long life sharia long life feminist hypocrisy.

[@CALVIN36557]

women dont chosse to be single men nowadays ignore the\ose toxic women thus why they are single

[@zarastrausse6381]

​@@CALVIN36557 "your not single! im single!" type of argument

[@serena3673]

​@@CALVIN36557🙄🙄 you just can't accept that many women no longer see relationship as imperative anymore. Welcome to the 21st

[@nnk9305]

Nahhh,... You women actually just rather want to be with Fuckboys or Rich People who doesn'f wanna make a good effort on your love While you women left out an Average looking dude with actual good heart and soul I for one am just an Average dude with Average money, I'm just happy my wife accepts me and left out her tall-fuckboy-Ex who btw got in prison because dude beat his gf and his daughter I also had an Ex before my wife, who I've been with for more than 3 years, she actually disregarded our long-term relationship with some Foreign Fuckboy, European, Tall, White, Handsome and Rich dude, after our breakup I was frustrated and depressed and in her first month of their relationship she was happy asf with spoiled money, and then when she got pregnant with his child, the fuckboy left her and never cameback for more than years, she probably thought the child would be her ticket to paradise turns our she lived with her parents to take care of her autistic child Message to Women,... I know you know that you're dealing with a Fuckboy, but still why go out with him? Be a real Woman,...Women

[@gdonepercent]

Only cowards and bullies hit a woman. If she disrespects you, leave her. If she cheats on you, leave her. If she is an alcoholic, leave her.

[@lowlowseesee]

Abusers like control. They don't leave because that would give up their control. Read a book on it because your position is basic and uneducated

[@samspade2657]

👎

[@a6893_]

Would you disown your son/daughter as a parent?

[@romdom9406]

She drinks because of the abusive relationship.

[@ericjayfederizo3549]

True, You never ever hit a woman. a woman strength is no match to a man strength that's why the Man is design to protect his woman.

[@janinejay3423]

He beat her for 8 frikin hours straight?!!!! What a monster

[@ciro8861]

8 hours????!!!! Unfathomable. That is torture, sustained torture

[@maxstone9148]

She was forced to drink from the stress of an abusive, psychopathic husband. RIP, Saltanat

[@Noname123rr]

😂.. the assh*le could have left her or talken help of her family to convince her for rehabilitation.. pretty sure he was cheating her and doing all nonsense

[@Sk10849]

It's actually,Poor Mentality..!!!

[@ramdishali8313]

​@sanjana4713 cry more

[@brattCatt_]

​@@Noname123rr The toxicology report showed no alcohol in her system. On the other hand he was so drunk the restaurant took his keys and called his cousin twice to pick him up.

[@Noname123rr]

@@brattCatt_ exactly that is happened here.

[@calvinsuu1949]

He thinks his money and connections made him above the law

[@altmosetz_01]

It does - money, connections & the religion in his country. For a woman in a Muslim or predominantly Muslim country , the punishment would have been immediate, brutal & fatal. For him trial goes on & punishment if any will rarely ever will be as bad as his crime

[@user-pj1fh5rh8w]

Ego

[@priyankashrivastav772]

He may be because he was in jail for 10 year for bribery but left out after only 2 years. If he was in jail for that full sentence, he would have never been meet her. His family is too powerful, allegedly he and his family tried to bribe the panel.

[@yousefziadeh5808]

@altmosetz_01just another Islam hater 😂🤣All types of killing happen daily in the western chrstian world

[@marie22213]

Happens all over the world with men of all status. Many Men think in general that they own women. Not just in 3rd world or ultra religious places as the media likes to paint. In America we're still killed at high rates

[@zhaziralala]

Thank you from Kazakhstan for talking about this.

[@AzaniaJanuary]

The day I don't regret putting sleeping pills in my Husband's food I taught him a lesson he will never forget since then he never argue or raise his voice.... I will never ever let anyone hit me without defending myself never

[@roslynnamy]

you must be pro abortion

[@talkingtochapri]

Facts 💯 Women back in the days were poisoning their husbands to get rid of them 💀 Bailey sarian did a video about aqua tofana secret

[@OscarFrosty]

good for you. i hope you taught him how to treat you and i hope he listens.

[@granmabern5283]

It’s also a fact that women AND men bought poisons from “ sorcerers and witches”, which explains some of the death sentences pronounced against them.

[@kevinhoward3465]

Knowing that people actually walked by her while being held by him surely proves major changes are needed in this society. Just looking at her via video you could tell she was in distress. God bless her soul and let this be the wake up call this society needs to improve.

[@marisamartin3664]

They are partially responsible as well. There is a God, and it is not the one Mohammed made up.

[@cheycheyfriend247]

@@marisamartin3664 okay chill

[@Toxic-nx6im]

i for one will speak up when i see woman or anyone getting hurt. once i hollered at a couple while the man was beating his wife, she screamed at me and told me to f off. so you get that from some. sometimes you need to control the situation despite what the victim says. "they know not what they do"

[@Toxic-nx6im]

Islam will be the death of us all@@marisamartin3664

[@lilscenechick1995]

@@Toxic-nx6im victims of abuse will often defend their abuser, it’s called trauma bonding. They become attached to their abuser. I know you’re not blaming them or anything, but it’s a very real thing and explains that reaction. It’s horrible that anyone suffers in this way…

[@relaxchil5796]

He actually beat her in public places, this is demonic, may her soul rest in peace.

[@nt2548]

It was his own restaurant. He let the staff go and closed the restaurant

[@mboren6144]

It’s just as evil in private. But no one sees, so likely worse.

[@WilliamCarr-qe8sl]

It’s common in the culture….so sad they still live in the medieval mindset, like other cultures I could name.

[@zaraakkuly1861]

I am from Kazakhstan, and this is unfortunately, common. Misogyny and sexism is rampant.

[@knoelle1357]

They decriminalized physical abuse towards women, which is sick.

[@talkingtochapri]

​@@daulet1372this year 😲 so it was normal before. What a 💩 country

[@mossadagent9582]

​@@daulet1372 Wife beating is legal in Islam but of course you shouldn't beat her to death

[@mossadagent9582]

@@daulet1372 It's legal to beat wives in Islam...only in Islam. In civilized countries you beat a dog you go to jail.

[@SRBOMBONICA86]

​@@daulet1372no it's not ,in Orthodox Christianity it's not

[@Nutersquirrels]

​@@daulet1372nope wrong again it is not legal in all religions to beat women... you wer to honor thy mother and father and wife and neighbour in catholic religions... no real men in those countries, only men with very small weiners, or alot of closet gay men... wow a country of men that hate te female race so much.. insane..

[@KB-iz5du]

These days, being healthy n being financially independent are more important. No spouse is better than a bad spouse.

[@MaverickLee11]

People are getting k!lL3d by buses, but it don't mean everybody gonna get hit by a bus. what you supposed to do, just sit and stay at home - not leave your front door because its possible you might get hit by a bus, because you once seen it on the fear mongering NEWS? prayers and respect to the victim, but this should not stop you going out and meeting a man with the intention of starting a family - other wise the devil has LITERALLY won.

[@puneetsingh6277]

That's definitely true

[@mawutojineku]

She came from a wealthy loving family

[@Trini2dbone868]

@@mawutojinekuSMH

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

@@mawutojineku why she married a man like him in the first place ?

[@TakeTheRide]

400+ women are killed a year by their husband in that country.

[@mrvn000]

400 only?

[@iiitsnaomiii]

​@@mrvn000400 is too many regardless of comparison to other countries

[@Sk10849]

Source???

[@Autumn4464]

😮😮😮😮😮😮 for real ?

[@jadethomas6083]

​@@Sk10849it's shown in the video that u saw

[@naturelove831]

This is heartbreaking. Jusf imaging how terrified she had to be ans knowing she had no way out it absolutely insane .

[@sophieamandaleitontoomey9343]

I honestly shudder to imagine how many women there have to endure this kind of violent behavior everyday.

[@cheickfall7399]

He is not a human being let alone a leader. What a shame! What can give a right to someone to kill someone's else child? How cruel, evil. It does not matter what she did.

[@bansarimehta1204]

Not only someone else child ..even ur own child

[@bangsarster]

@@bansarimehta1204 In Islam one is allowed to beat their wife when they make mistakes. Its all to set them straight. Stop Islamophobia.

[@brattCatt_]

She didn't do anything, she didn't cheat, he did, she wasn't drunk, he was, she only wanted to leave because he was beating on her and cheating on her the whole short marriage and he beat the living shit out of her for 8 hours then left her to die while he went and had a meal with some influencer in the next room.

[@asoultress]

​@@user-84-rg9-8n2The words of d e m o n i c-m a l e s. Righteousness is Godly. Using h a r m on someone that has done nothing to you has no justifications. Wmn give birth, the fact that a book speaks abt m a l e s r u l i n g over wmn is evident enough that d i s g u s t i m g-m a l e s wrote that g i b e r r i s h you just referenced. S h a m e on you ppl.

[@cheickfall7399]

@@user-84-rg9-8n2 BS. Yeah, yeah.. Keep thinking that and doing that. That's why you are still medieval as people.. Lol

[@brucewilson1958]

I'm a 70 year old American man. Thank you for this critical issue, an issue that is Global, and totally, absolutely unacceptable. There are many men, like me, who would die to save such a victim.

[@scottiebritt3009]

PPPft. Show me what you are doing as a man.

[@brucewilson1958]

@@scottiebritt3009I cannot show you anything in this format. What are you trying to discover. Do you want a resume?

[@kidusyohannes1146]

@@brucewilson1958😂😂

[@alexandrailubs2945]

No one cares if you are 70, man or 😏

[@EmeKaGirl]

Most men beat women. Everyday I see news like this. Rape, sexual assault, catcalling, murder, physical abuse, etc. I despise men. Controlling and aggressive. Pity.

[@mickalanelson8485]

Domestic abuse, both physically and verbal mostly go unreported here in the USA. It’s UNACCEPTABLE no matter where on this evil Earth.

[@ivanastankovic275]

People cry in vain that something is unacceptable. Enough of whining. Time for acti*on. People have to uni*te all over the world. Wo*men all over the world have to act in uni*son and help one another. Me*n's vi*olence has been going on for centuries. Enough already.

[@chich2486]

They fact that other women walked passed by like its normal and not even get angered by it just shows how normal that society is. Disgusting.

[@maxh7637]

there were no other people as it was his own restaurant with no visitors

[@Lucywonderhunt]

Whole world needs to stop with dosmeric violence. 24 hours in a restaurant and no staff to help her ? What on earth ! This should shock the world

[@saivaisshnavijuttada1236]

The reason why the staff didn't help her is because the restaurant is owned by her abusive husband

[@kimking5928]

They should all be charged.

[@rocksoft1236]

No cure for evil... no matter what ... these psychopathic entitled people will do what they want to do... no law, no morality work for them... They just care not to get caught

[@sogdianababakhanova7035]

He owns the restaurant

[@mantra56]

​@@saivaisshnavijuttada1236Wow so they would just watch someone get beaten to death instead? Cowards

[@mysterious4125]

Just by the way he was kicking her, (you can tell the intensity of his hatred towards her). Imagine getting married to your future murderer. Sad😢

[@indiantravelsome]

I sympathise for her but why didnt she leave him ? Bcz after looking at the video it didnt look like he was beating him for the first time

[@Cannamom710]

It happens everyday in every country.

[@Cannamom710]

​@@indiantravelsomeYou don't get to ask that question. 😢She is DEAD! She can't answer why she never left him. I was in a volatile abusive relationship before and he threatened to kill my entire family and our son if I ever told anyone about the abuse! 😞😢Don't JUDGE OTHERS SITUATIONS!!!!!!

[@indiantravelsome]

@@Cannamom710 how did you manage to have a child with such a devil when there was no love ? I said i totally sympathise with her but I just wanna know why women continue suffering

[@poponyam]

​@@indiantravelsome why did you not shut your mouth??

[@nicres]

Domestic violence is a global problem. DO BETTER MEN!

[@HowlinWilf13]

Normal healthy men hate this too - they see their mothers, sisters, aunts, daughters, nieces, cousins, daughters-in-law and friends at risk of maltreatment, and they hate it.

[@rupshahi1819]

This is how anger destroys anybody's life so deeply

[@chewie94116]

Listening to this guy trying to explain himself and saying that killing her is not his fault is like a criminal saying-" I can not control my hands and feet because my hands and feet have their own mind and kill her. Do not blame me." This guy just have no feelings for her at all. NOT HUMAN, JUST PURE EVIL.

[@beaconlight4720]

Of course he has, otherwise, why would he kill her?

[@user-eo1zf8lp1h]

I remember a killer said "a voice in my head told me do that" (or something similar). ppl in power are not just insane

[@user-lm7og5dv8q]

Not matter if it's women or men, none has any right to physically abuse the other person. Period

[@Ramfadora]

The main issuse here is women in Kazakh being abused by their husband. This is man is sick!!

[@deloresartis8415]

It does matter because in this country an enormous number of women are killed and nothing comes out of it! The men have all the rights above the women, the women are nothing compared to the men. That's what the main issue here!

[@falkorbluckin9838]

Huh? Do you not get what this video is about

[@falkorbluckin9838]

Like seriously this is about one culture’s attitude toward abuse of women… not the fact that both sexes can abuse each other… think more

[@roslynnamy]

@@falkorbluckin9838 yeah ofc you think abuse against men is okay feminist

[@debbierowley8833]

Poor woman, guilty of nothing but being married to a monster....just horrific, don’t forget the rest of the world is watching....RIP sweet lady.

[@dianamaccow6316]

People need to stop making excuses for domestic abuse. “She was drinking a lot” I cannot stand people who put men’s behaviour acceptable

[@talkingtochapri]

And he lied about the drinking part, just like he lied about everything. There was no alcohol in her system but he was drink the entire time and was cheating on her with multiple women and she was trying to leave him. So, he unalived her. And let those incel, women beater males, grapist males, etc, bark because this will help women to see how males are and how they justify murder.

[@nicolahall27]

The fact that it was in front of other people and no one intervened, that country has a hell of a long way to go. What a disgrace.

[@vitoandolini2064]

It happened after working our in the closed restaurant of his familiar. There was nobody to stand with her.

[@vitoandolini2064]

and by the way, he graduated GWU in Washington D.C.

[@nicolahall27]

@@vitoandolini2064 with all due respect you see other people in the video, not just they 2. There were staff, people outside when he continued. WTF is what uni he graduated got to do with it? Do you think that’s some kind of explanation or reason? No it isn’t.

[@marisamartin3664]

They are awful people as a rule apparently.

[@slhkslhk2998]

@slhkslhk2998 0 seconds ago Same here, Switzerland. It's same everywhere

[@Toffeenuts]

Australia is having a big problem with violence against women as well! 25 women have died from sexual/domestic violence since the start of the year and it's always "it was their own fault".

[@alexk3604]

How many court cases decided it was the woman's fault?

[@roslynnamy]

@@alexk3604 it was their fault most probably

[@ivanastankovic275]

@@roslynnamy It is Satan's fault that you exist.

[@briangmoh5261]

To all the women out there, please learn how to fight back. It doesn't matter if you are small or physically weak, use your teeth, fingernails, elbow, knee to inflict pain in order to get away. You have nothing else to lose, so don't just lie down waiting to die.

[@kristakitchen2559]

Another example that there is no place on earth that is safe for women.....

[@taniyadutta8]

The saddest part is she might have felt very happy n at peace when she died thinking its finally over now 🥺

[@Tarnishtha]

You know parents and society never gives support।

[@MAZ732]

Sad but probably true! God rest her delicate soul 🙏

[@partheshchakraborty9077]

😢I send my heart and prayers to that poor soul 💔 Om Shanti 🙏

[@pixiestxNyomouf]

She was said to be "snoring" but her nose was broken o he sadly was probably having a heart attack . She died slowly over the course of months 😢

[@asoultress]

​@@user-84-rg9-8n2🤌🏾

[@jayjjoshi]

teach all the kids how important not to raise their hands against women ever.

[@MrSupernova111]

Men don't matter in your world?

[@Diyamondal24]

Men murder in the world​@@MrSupernova111

[@ananya255]

@@MrSupernova111 Men are physically stronger than women. Your argument doesn't stand. Most domestic violence victims are women

[@BeleniYara-ow2zq]

Teach both genders how important not to raise hands against each other

[@shwetapatil1736]

You are right, we should teach our KIDS not to raise hands on anybody. Why should only boys carry the burden?

[@funwithgames4608]

And then they say "Why Feminism exist??"

[@jashanbirsingh]

Feminism is śḥíṭ.

[@emiliamartineli1888]

He called is fortune teller? Oh lord, and yet some men have the audacity to calls women not fit for government jobs.

[@pippalewisNYC]

It's not just Kazakh society, is it. I'm so tired of men thinking they can treat women in this way. I'm so tired of men getting away with treating women in this way... ANYWHERE in this world! It stops now.

[@MaverickLee11]

not all men think this way, believe it or not the majority of men are good men - hence the world you live in which was built by men, including the house, phone and tv you use - does not mean you trust any man though.

[@tarun9542]

You are too dumb and brainwashed if you think this is only a women's problem. Cases like Amber Heard's didn't teach you much it seems or you just choose to close your eyes and remain filled with hate.

[@DonnellOkafor-pd7yn]

Pls in the US women are a protected class. It stops now? Cringe

[@Lakshaymehrachemfaculty]

@@DonnellOkafor-pd7ynIf you are from US your own country women are crying here how women don't feel safe with their own partners the problem is that men deny their their accusations easily so should women too deny that their are no exploitation with men .

[@pippalewisNYC]

@@DonnellOkafor-pd7yn you could always take your head out of the sand to know that’s not true at all. But then perhaps here is where I rest my case.‘cringe away’.

[@Vintagelife777]

This is by far the most disturbing violent crime I have seen. It took 8 hours to take someone else’s life and at no point in those eight hours did he feel it was enough. This is shocking. I Wish I had never seen this

[@teresadee9442]

It’s important that we all open our eyes to the suffering of others so that we can take that knowledge into our own lives and hearts and act accordingly. Treat people with respect, empathy, kindness..and speak of for those cannot stand up for themselves. We cannot unsee or pretend that we don’t know what happened here..our seeing is a testament to that woman’s life and despicable death at the hands of a person who should have protected her from such a violent end.

[@teresadee9442]

I agree with you though..very hard to stomach

[@ericjayfederizo3549]

Me too, why am i seeing this? it really boils my blood!

[@crischansan]

It is very painful.. and to know that it happens across the globe. A lot of them unseen and unknown, but have always been there. This being brought up to light will help not only Kazakhstan but also other parts of the world - for law to finally have more "sense".

[@dianapeek6936]

But you should see it. Don't bury your head in the sand. By doing that means you cannot face facts.

[@lordjael]

Women in America don't realize how good they have it regarding domestic violence offenses and the laws against it. Domestic violence is overlook and isn't even criminalized in many different parts of that world. Yemen, Haiti, Brazil, Russia, etc. Bless this woman's soul. 🙏🏾

[@Ortizlarson]

A disgrace. This country should be deeply ashamed of this minister . Shame shame shame.

[@mimikhan9546]

Poor lady.

[@nikhilPUD01]

😢

[@sigma_beta007]

Bulle aur kar bhi kya sakta h

[@captainprice1409]

Its your cult and it's teaching that did it, do not blame him alone, blame your cult as well because that's where he gets it from.

[@user-84-rg9-8n2]

@@captainprice1409 Hey! You can't just make assertions like that without evidence or references: *Qur'an 4:34* “Men are in charge of women by what Allah has given one over the other. So righteous women are devoutly obedient. But those from whom you fear arrogance - advise them; forsake them in bed; and *BEAT* them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand.” *Sahih Muslim 16:4152* “Allah's Messenger (May Peace Be Upon Him) said: 'It is not permissible to take the life of a Muslim, but in one of the three cases: the married adulterer, a life for life, and the deserter of his Din (Islam), abandoning the community.'” *Sahih Muslim 16:4154* “Allah's Messenger (May Peace Be Upon Him) said: 'The blood of a Muslim may be lawfully shed only in case of three persons: the one who abandons Islam, and deserts the community, and the married adulterer, and life for life.'” *Sahih al-Bukhari 9:83:17* “Allah's Apostle (Peace Be Upon Him) said, 'The blood of a Muslim cannot be shed except in three cases: In Qisas for murder, a married person who commits illegal s_____ intercourse, and the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims.'"

[@LinnRain]

The amount of bots hating on Islam is hilarious! Do you think 2.9+ billion people would've joined this "cult" if it wasn't the best thing they experienced? Especially to women. Y'all are trying to save a throne that's already vanished...

[@bernardoespartinez4048]

That man is like DEMON on earth!! How could he do such thing to a helpless women 😢🥲🥲🥲

[@zenjigaming3342]

No, he is following prophet Mohammad perfectly

[@ranran8934]

​@@zenjigaming3342Eww, no wonder why islamophobia is still rampant.

[@riscnx]

@@ranran8934 Sounds like "no wonder why pedophobia is still rampant"

[@akankshajha7250]

​@@ranran8934 we all are tired of this damn word islamophobia. Muslims invented this word just so that they could avoid accountability.

[@zenjigaming3342]

@@ranran8934 do you know what phobia means ? It means fear . And if something says kill all non muslims, make their women your sl@ves, r@pe them etc shouldn't we fear it ? I thought that's a common sense. Anyway Ayesha dad used to beat her so beating women is allowed by al-lah

[@shimmershine4079]

Teach ur girls to never tolerate any type of domestic violence.....

[@tripsmith8591]

Hes just doing this shit in public and no ones saying ANYTHING?! What the actual fuck

[@metsrus]

sickening, what kind of coward beats on a helpless woman

[@roslynnamy]

shouldn't have made him angry lol

[@seungminsforeheadyourarelysee]

@@roslynnamy what a trash mindset

[@roslynnamy]

@@seungminsforeheadyourarelysee hope you learned your lesson

[@cindyt8278]

@@roslynnamyI’m a woman and I know women aren’t innocent

[@Lakshaymehrachemfaculty]

Too many man bots working according to instructions given by andrew tate 😂

[@aprajita.makeup.film.dramaa]

Violence against women is an extremely abhorrent, recurring theme on the forefront. Sensitization of the fact the that women aren't mere commodities is almost nil. At the grassroot level, the percentage of families that seem to internalize this concept tends to be zero, let alone any government seeming to do anything about it.

[@eaglemgtow2789]

😂😂😂 Apne English writing Skills flaunt kar rahi hai kya yaha ??

[@lekevire]

@@eaglemgtow2789 What are you laughing at? Do you beat women as well?

[@eaglemgtow2789]

@@lekevire OH I LOVE IT! 😍

[@Shivakumar-dk6ph]

why u dragging gender here ? wmen domt commit crims ? are they saints ? crim has no gender..

[@Shss701]

@@lekevire don't worry this one's probably a bot

[@suegoulding1341]

This video actually made me physically sick.... poor darling girl RIP 🙏

[@Babeatrice]

She was drinking to endure the chronic pain from severe repeated injuries 😰

[@appyistic]

Yes I hope this case gets more and more international attention... so that it doesn't get swept under the rug! What a monster... once given the responsibility of making important decisions for the country!

[@kristinab1078]

That poor woman! That footage made me so angry...if only someone had seen and stepped in to help. How she must have suffered in silence living under the same roof as a narcissist and a monster. 😢

[@roslynnamy]

not like you would ever step in to help, demand a man to go be a man and risk his life for a random woman so you can feel better about your coward self

[@jenniferkenneth692]

So proud of the women that came together and said enough is enough. He beat his wife as though she were not a human being like him. Poor woman, to be beaten to death has to be horrible. The defense and their audacity! I hope he gets life imprisonment, it was full blown murder in the first degree, the way he was kicking her, unless he thought she was a ragdoll, I don't see how he didn't intend to kill her. And for those that were pushing back at the new law, God will judge you, at the end of the day we will all answer to God Almighty. May she rest peace, she was such a beautiful woman and may God give her family, the fortitude to go on, Amen

[@roslynnamy]

if a woman is not pro abortion she should never be abused

[@anjyr3130]

24 years he got today. 24 f*cking years...

[@roslynnamy]

@@anjyr3130 that's too long

[@anjyr3130]

@@roslynnamy yes, if he doesn't buy his freedom as he did after his economical crime. I hope these will be long years in prison

[@ElizabethGrindon]

Just saw this video by accident. Otherwise, I'd heard nothing about it. I'm in California, U.S.A. The whole world should know about the horrible actions of this ex-minister.

[@Wetalkdramas]

People still say why we want feminism

[@serena3673]

True but their are also men who enjoy destroying an independent woman. Domestic abuse is not isolated to specific set of women, it can happen to anyone

[@ProphetMohammed-69]

Ok, now let's Talk about how things are going on in India with women😊.

[@SelvaKumar_1992]

Yeah like feminism is the solution to everything

[@janemary8339]

Feminism? Because women can never abuse a partner? You're funny.

[@bubullibooooo9928]

​@@janemary8339 Feminism is about protecting men and women 🙄

[@neila128]

If I recall, he was actually imprisoned before meeting Saltanat for a different crime, but was let out EXTREMELY early. If the justice system did its job and kept him behind bars as they should, that monster would never have had the opportunity to approach her :/

[@lmm8960]

Well it’s Kazakhstan. They don’t have the privilege of what we in the west have.

[@amerubix185]

@@lmm8960 Same happens in the west, too.

[@maxh7637]

​@@lmm8960lmao. Are you serious? Just check European news

[@lmm8960]

@@amerubix185 yeah and we have the best judicial system in the world. We may not get em all but we at least try!

[@amerubix185]

@@lmm8960 Not so sure if we really try … respectively our judicial system.

[@mayurajagtap4403]

The girls were passing by casually while seeing this man was beating a woman. This is horrific. How come no one interven?? Does woman's life got no value in their mind??? 😢

[@gpcheng87]

he's still not sorry or embarrassed, even after being caught in a lie - disgusting. how dare they try to victim blame on top of it all.

[@wheretimehasnovalue9343]

as a man, i believe that all men should be investigated, and any crimes against woman and children should be treated as serious. any strike of a woman should be treated with a minimum of 2 years behind bars... we the men beg this law be brought into action to protect our woman and children against us

[@user-84-rg9-8n2]

NO WAY! That's racial discrimination. . . . *Sahih al-Bukhari vol 5 bk 58:236* "Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) married 'Aisha when she was a 6 year old girl, and _consummated_ that marriage when she was 9.” *Qur'an 65:1, 4* "When divorcing women, know their waiting period. For women past the age of menstruation, their waiting period is 3 months - and those who have _NOT_ menstruated yet as well." *Sahih al-Bukhari vol 7 bk 62 nr 64* “Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) married her when she was 6 years old and he _consummated_ his marriage when she was 9 years old” *Sahih al-Bukhari vol 7, book 62, nr 65* “Allah's Prophet (Peace Be Upon Him) married her when she was 6 years old and he _consummated_ his marriage when she was 9 years old.."

[@r3n736]

​@@user-84-rg9-8n2 The age of concent in the USA was 7 years during 1899 a Christian country, don't be ignorant thinking this is just islam.

[@salamander4173]

​@@r3n736 except Christians never exalted a man who married a 7 y.o. as an "example for all mankind" as is the case for islam....

[@LinnRain]

@user-84-rg9-8n2 Who's paying you? Someone's really dedicated, I could almost applaud your researches done on all of the possible islamphopic sites out there. Such hatred in your heart, must be exhausting.

[@user-use-her-vuser]

Disagree

[@user-jk6ux4gv7p]

Horrific! How do you beat someone to death; is it DEMONIC?

[@Nemowise]

Bro learned from Demonic Israel

[@lowlowseesee]

Nah thats fantasy shit that keeps people blind. The root to abuse is entitlement with a distorted sense of right and wrong

[@jayaa7152]

This is not in one country. It happens in every country. Even when there are laws to protect them. Women have to become stronger and stay united. There is no excuse to using violence

[@marasasa1995]

This is pure evil.

[@AnonymousAnonymous-dc3jm]

Kazakhstan, you mean the country that has bride kidnapping as a tradition?

[@josue_kay]

I don't believe she was a kidnapped bride.

[@mm-vg1ld]

That's their culture.

[@PanamanianMan317]

That's Kyrgyzstan

[@beach2787]

​@@mm-vg1ld Evil under the guise of culture

[@maxstone9148]

@@josue_kay Did he say that, nimwit?

[@Dan-xx5jq]

So sad. She was so gorgeous!!! EVIL MONSTER!! He should go to prison for life!!!

[@crischansan]

Rest in peace Saltanat. May her loved ones have peace as well. Your death will not be in vain. You are a beautiful soul. Thank you ❤❤❤

[@bm7493]

My whole body was going through strange feeling( like pain) while watching the video..sorry for the woman who lost her life and around the world who go under domestic violence 😢😢

[@abantimukherjee9745]

Not all men but always men. 😂

[@lekevire]

No?? Women can be abusers too... It’s common sense

[@fatemad4012]

​@@lekevirewomen don't have power to beat their husbands to death

[@briskettacos]

​@@fatemad4012Even when women kill, they do it much less often that men do.

[@lowlowseesee]

It's extremely rare but people want to live in ignorance forever

[@davecollins6122]

Percentage wise, same sex female couples have the highest rate of domestic violense in Australia, no its not always men, its always bad people.

[@kogiereddy2938]

You mean no one came to her rescue for 8 hrs

[@eloschk]

His family owns the place, the workers were afraid of him

[@selmahare]

@@eloschk Still, there's absolutely no excuse for that! If you are going to live like a coward who allows for someone to kill another person in front of you then your soul has been long condemned! If that is going to be your standard for yourself, as a human being, than you have never even been one to begin. Again, someone could have easily made an anonymous call. People are cowardly monsters.

[@abcdefghijk8925]

​@selmahare yes far too many spineless people nowadays. It's sad to think if anything happens to you, sometimes, you're all you've got.

[@aadvik_abyss2498]

​@@abcdefghijk8925😢

[@DD-sp9lu]

He ordered the stuff to leave. So there was no one in the restaurant, it was empty.

[@justreal-2023]

Put him in prison for life! Death sentence! Sickening and so sad for this poor lovely woman!

[@azadpedia2845]

Completely unacceptable

[@jjkj8421]

"Unintentionally"...these men's courage to use words. Aah aish

[@priyakanjilal7748]

One of the many defences that man has while being charged with DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, "she provoked me" and "i lost my head" or "i didnt mean to but it happened in a fit of anger".

[@sscc9290]

It's called crime of passion for a reason,women also show similar behaviour - just their outlet is different because they lack physical strength,they will throw around,destroy things,call names.This can't be eradicated.

[@surojeetchatterji9966]

In reality its true, when 2 person r in relationship they expect something from each other from that ego this happens irrespective of gender. So its better to clear all the expectations straight forward bluntly before getting into a relationship. Hidden expectations & hiding something cause the outburst in a relationships. Both gender needs to be more Frank blunt & truthful to each other before starting a relationship to avoid accidents.

[@HenriCobbs]

For 8 hrs??@@sscc9290

[@dragonfox2.058]

Not for 8 hours

[@dragonfox2.058]

@@sscc9290 Name one country where most male deaths are caused by women. I'll wait

[@FireBlade9773]

How can people demonstrate AGAINST domestic violence laws? FFS.

[@Georgia7Pap]

This happens everywhere I think. In my country (Greece) we have similar cases on the news all the time. A few weeks ago a woman was stabbed to death outside of a police station where she went to report him.

[@jazzycat312]

It does happen everywhere. I'm in US and my friends daughter was shot in the head I the parking lot because she was 7 months pregnant and he had another girlfriend he want to marry, but not the pregnant one. Even worse, he was a cop.

[@SuperGlue4321]

India too. Asian countries just hate females all together I believe. Just like the rest of the world.

[@prasannajoshi2932]

Horrible

[@user-84-rg9-8n2]

Stop being racist . . . *Qur'an 4:34* "Men are in charge of women by what Allah has given one over the other. So righteous women are devoutly obedient. But those from whom you fear arrogance - advise them; forsake them in bed; and *BEAT* them. Indeed, Allah is ever Exalted and Grand."

[@warrior9694]

Watched Rotten Mango; she covered the case in detail. This is just so horrifying. Rest in peace Saltanat. I hope her family and friends heal from this. The pain they must be going through is unimaginable. I hope that monster rots in a cell for the rest of his life.

[@Scrabbledat]

She had to die for that new law to pass. How tragic

[@Rain-xe5vr]

Such an evil world! This is what you get for turning away from God.

[@Blisscent]

I’d rather be single and alive than in a relationship and abused

[@joebidet2050]

Yes me too I've met some evil.women in my life I wouldnt to go to prison Because of them

[@Blisscent]

@@joebidet2050 ok sweetie

[@joebidet2050]

@@Blisscent I'm not your sweetie

[@k_jjunn06]

@@joebidet2050lol

[@mimikhan9546]

She doesn't fight back. Poor women.

[@victoryv116]

If she would have fight back , then people would have said ..ladki ki bhi toh galti thi , tali.do.hantho se nahin bajati ... surprisingly people would have come for his defense if she try to defend herself ignoring physical impact of injury ...

[@christiancliech299]

You know it better than most, how a muslim society works ...@mimikhan

[@phiddler1]

Shes too tired to fight obviously this was a habit for him just happens to be filmed when it went too far what a loser

[@altmosetz_01]

In a Muslim country or predominantly Muslim country, women rarely ever fight back. Men have the upper hand & any freedom n rights a woman has is dictated by men.

[@user-eg9vj1vo1w]

​@@christiancliech299 Prajwal Revanna says hi to you from Germany and Hindu bahubali rapist brijbhushan Singh say nammo namo 😂😂

[@yeah_right88]

It shows how pervasive it is in this culture. You know people saw and heard this and for 8 hours no one did a thing. Not so much as call the police. What an awful place for women to live.

[@punamahir5035]

No wonder why women choose bear over man !!

[@patwilson1257]

You couldn’t even get away with doing that to a dog in most places. It’s shameful and disgusting. How can you even do that and sleep at night? You have NO SOUL…………………………

[@simsinacafe]

Why the trial, just sent him to jail already, the evidence is clear.

[@roslynnamy]

yeah she provoked him

[@Elfieyana]

@@roslynnamyso he killed her? like who does that?

[@roslynnamy]

@@Elfieyana someone who was provoked

[@Elfieyana]

@@roslynnamy more like somebody that’s *UNHINGED*

[@Elfieyana]

@@roslynnamy thats just sick.

[@atejingldrcoach]

Im a woman, a wife and a mother. But what i dont understand is we women all have tge same parts with men aside from strength but at least we are not totally strengthless.... I am small but my husband can spank only my ass when Im unattentive despite that he is bigger than me because i dont just take what he is giving to me, hello! Fight back! You have arms and legs also plus head to think what you can grab to throw it to him it doesnt matter if you can cut him or what,. If your partner is treating you physicallly, fight back!

[@TJ-Judge]

In a public place....then he called his "fortune teller" WTF....?!