Trump Vows to End Birthright Citizenship. How will it Impact Indians? | Vantage with Palki Sharma

[@జైతెలుగు]

Yes dont give citizenship for any one besides native americans

[@brownadam999]

Lol

[@danpoole5721]

Facts

[@minxiyer]

Firstpost gets it wrong. President elect Trump said - abolishing birthright citizenship for illegal immigrants; not legal immigrants. He could further propose at least one of the parents need to be a green card holder or a US citizen for the child to have birthright citizenship, which is absolutely fair.

[@Mr.Whonow]

Thats right!! Applies to illegals

[@brianburgess3231]

then your lost on the law and the logic .. you just contradicted yourself

[@timothylee2772]

I think that's fair. It promotes law and order. Because the status quo with birthright citizenship is just abusing the law and the immigration system.

[@revivalarchives5667]

You got it bro

[@DennistheMenace2011]

.......and shut down the birth tourism industry. Or better yet, send them to Canada.

[@rosyralte168]

He should… Atleast one parent should be citizen.. i think this is what many EU countries also follows

[@Serge-cm5my]

Citizen or have a permanent resident permit.

[@abbaemmanuel3450]

Yes that is what he said at least one parent has to be citizens, he disagrees with the procedures where anyone born here without either parent being citizen to become citizens by birth

[@జైతెలుగు]

One parent must be native american*

[@Ramarao02]

@@జైతెలుగు sandhu dorikannapudu alla iragodutunnav sivaji 🔥🔥

[@timelyferry]

High time americans put themselves first.

[@sahilprasai9869]

More like a descendant of colonizers

[@petem9994]

What a cheap shot Palki. Using trump father in this video. You're no good! Ending Birthright Citizen is critical for America to maintain it's identity. Too many unregulated and illegal persons WHO ARE INCAPABLE OF ASSIMILATION within the US culture, Laws, and customs wants to be here just so they can bilk the system FINANCIALLY and claiming all sorts of reasons such as wanting a better life...Bullshit!

[@peeyar2000]

All legal immigrants should get birth right citizenship. Not illegals.

[@mohamedcamara8785]

You talking about Native Americans…

[@Dabeachguy]

@@mohamedcamara8785😂😂😂

[@Ladykiesh]

Vivek pushing for it more then Trump

[@rajeshx1983]

Only indians know the pulse😂😂😂

[@rashius]

October 7, 1885.. Then shows a plane taking off. You know the first plane ever flew in 1903 right?

[@mohamedcamara8785]

He came on the boat illegally…

[@revivalarchives5667]

This got me 😂 like seriously. Like we are all fools?

[@Mmvrvin]

The children are innocent

[@Diagonal3375]

If all the citizens of other countries work with the intention of making their countries better I dont think thisnwill be an issue

[@DxvidGolixth]

Its Native-Americans right? Not like people from New Delhi right?

[@paulafranciscac2787]

It is a VERY different story. They came to work hard, not to demand financial help and to take advantage of the US welfare system at the expense of taxpayers.

[@skratta]

being born in the USA during 1885 for birthright citizenship is not the same as being born in 2024 for birthright citizenship

[@user-fl5fn7ev4q]

Why is that?

[@ArterifikCollective]

😂😂 how is it different?

[@jimmyl8332]

Only legal migrant should have birthright citizenship!

[@Vann20F]

Or people that have connections like Melania and her parents 😂😂

[@RajMohan-g9o]

Iam living in Saudi Arabia 35 years. Ibrougt many of my friends and relatives here for work they all well settled. Why you want citizen ship.Earn and back to to your Home Land.

[@okislife80]

Because Indians believe in full power.

[@felixthecat2786]

My grandmother's parents were born in Italy. I guess my 99 year old grandmother is not going to be a United States citizen anymore.

[@ghostbansurvivor6229]

Trump's mother was born in Scotland, his paternal grandfather was born in Germany, all but one of his children were born to foreign born mothers.

[@vijayjayaraman5990]

Even India requires at least one parent to be an Indian citizen for the child to get Indian citizenship. India stopped giving citizenship by birth back in the 80s or 90s.

[@chandra_has]

Ya people waiting in line to get one 😂

[@vijayjayaraman5990]

@chandra_has That's not the point. Very few countries offer unconditional birthright citizenship. Even India has removed it. Why wouldn't the US remove it?

[@vijayrangarajanramakrishna318]

​​@@vijayjayaraman5990US is the land of worldwide immigrants unlike India

[@vinaypenta4391]

@@vijayjayaraman5990 you can keep calm Vijay just let it flow you are not the one to point out

[@X.A.V.l.E.R.]

Same in Europe... You don't get citizenship by birth in EU

[@jeffreypaul734]

It would be cool not to worry about borders, End war, and take care of insurance executives in the streets

[@AguiarMelwyn]

Why is Firstpost acting like the stupid woke media by not representing facts correctly. Trump spoke about this and it was to do with illegal immigration not legal immigration. This is stupid Firstpost.

[@Tube-You357]

Only birthright citizenship should be kept for legal immigrants

[@mohamedcamara8785]

For native Americans

[@KingSargon96]

Yeah free the native americans 🇺🇸

[@truth9415]

what if 1 parent is legal? Does the child become 50% half-citizen? Or will the child be deported, despite being born in the country like You.

[@Cvr1963]

Right of citizenship by birth of children of legal immigrants cannot be done in any way.

[@DannyLucas-tb7lr]

He can change it

[@rajeshx1983]

India retains brain drain ans make super power in bharat 😂😂😂

[@dedollarizer]

The fact that this is being discussed by an Indian news channel shows how much this thing gets misused.

[@leviacekrman5246]

The law is pretty clear! "Born on US Soil -> Citizen", if you don't wanna that to happen, protect your borders and stop whining about it!

[@RaymondTorres.49ers]

You have to legalized in America are an American born here for people to have legal citizens ship. So if I get a illegal immigrant pregnant my children because of me being an American is a legal citizens. Now two illegal citizens who have a child in America so that child is an illegal citizens still. Why because they are trying to use the law about not breaking families up to gain legal citizens ship. If that was the case then everyone who come to America and have children so they can't get deported. There has to be a law that prevents this from happening so Those that are coming to America and filing the right paperwork to be an American will have the opportunity. I'm for a law that will prevent people coming to America and having kids so they can stay. I'm American Mexican and I believe people from Mexico should by filling out the right paperwork to become American citizens not illegal.

[@inquisitorkrieger8171]

He can but he won't. He's all talk. I remember this windbags first term.

[@obajuluwaoluwatomisin3883]

Its a well known tactic in Nigeria. If you hv money, visit America few times, time your pregnancy such that you are in America during childbirth and boom, you hv a child thats American citizen. That means full American rights for the child and easy access to America for the parents of the "American" citizen.

[@adamx284]

Naija pipo and cho cho cho. No be everything u must cast🙄

[@adamx284]

Na everything tin wuna must talk?

[@giftfolique464]

Bro delete this comment and stop tagging ur country in a bad light. Every country does this. If you want your children to have dual citizenship or a different nationally from you, you can give birth to them abroad. Not just a Nigerian thing

[@Awesome_Wonders]

Olodo....eranko....omo ale ni e. Ogidi omo ale Yoruba ni e pelu!!!! Naija o ti se to awon Indians, Chinese, Mexicans, Philippines, Pakistanis, etc. Mi o ro pe eni kankan ti lo si ilu oyinbo ri ninu family yin!! Baba nla wereyyy....

[@obajuluwaoluwatomisin3883]

Lmao. Yall asking believing I'm wrong is one of the reasons why Nigeria is run down. Yall believe in cutting corners and exploiting all means if it benefits you regardless if it harms others. If it was truly a good or honourable thing, then why hide it? You say don't tarnish the image of your country, I say the truth is the truth and I'll never be afraid of saying it.

[@stephenh3293]

If you think homeless people is a big crises in America now then just wait for this new law which will make homeless crises even bigger.

[@user-fl5fn7ev4q]

We need to go a lot further than that. If both parents and grandparents were not born in the US then you should not have citizenship.

[@ghostbansurvivor6229]

In that case Trump can't be a citizen since his mother is Scottish, his paternal Grandfather was German, his 1st and 3rd wives were Czech and Slovenian respectively.

[@AngieWaltersTorus]

1492, illegal immigrants, undocumented, anchor babies landing in the Americas, Africa, Asia, Australia Back to Europe.

[@Alexbhar274]

American and there delusional culture 😂

[@davidh4374]

why not parents, grandparents, great-grandparents, great-great-grandparents, great-great-great-grandparents, and great-great-great-great-grandparents? And why not go further? Anyone who's ancestors arrived after the first wave of migration from Siberia (not even the 2nd or third migrations)?

[@truth9415]

Hopefully that will Remove Trump out of office.

[@navyalexmagezi1497]

But how did Americans choose to vote such a guy?

[@HalifaxComputersRepair]

i highly doubt it he will get that even to happen , his grandson is ready to kick the bucket lol

[@luisdepina2258]

About time…

[@gastronomistmd5078]

H1B birth right citizenship last 20th years .. JAI HO

[@chrisdavis6264]

Good

[@MichaelMorse-q2f]

Birth right is not in the constitution

[@Ladykiesh]

It is

[@gameplayer8998]

Did you not watch the video or are you missing a brain?

[@greghight954]

Go Trump!!

[@RitaDoss-qx4lz]

Thanks 👍 Mr Donald Trump ❤️🇺🇲

[@alpark3024]

claim executive order to end birthright citizenship

[@ajkulac9895]

Constitution > executive order

[@brianjohnston4207]

Not on his own, but he can work with congress to get it done.

[@HwnDragon1]

What does it mean for Hawaii residents that were born when our islands were still a territory?

[@primal1233]

I don't think this is going to be able to get through. A lot of politicians are going to oppose this

[@xbxtbe]

Is that how America became America?

[@krishnaraju3165]

Put a condition - “ eligible for tax payer of atleast 5 years” !

[@e.t.2230]

I support this

[@johnnypham2850]

This is disappointing FirstPost. This was AI worthy. Trump is initiating a Law which would allow those who enter the country through legal means to continue as per usual. As for unidentified lawbreakers that would not be the case.

[@nirjharrajawat2222]

Doesn’t matter he end or he keeps it world to be a total different ball game in next 10 years.

[@patrickodonnell9388]

He can because if people would just read the constitution it never said what people where told its implying that you are if your not subject to other political jurisdiction i.e not under other governments rule if so then you are a citizen if born here if your parents are not a citizen first from other country's or state.

[@believersday]

I don't care if US gives my child citizenship or not.. but i am only worried how will my child come back to home country without passport from any of the countries? Child cannot have indian passport if born in the US and US won't give citizenship. So would there be any other document?

[@tipsjameel]

women who have less than 2 months until giving birth travel to America to give birth because of the citizenship benefits. Perhaps this practice should be addressed.

[@tonychessma229]

The report disnt say a word about the foundation of US consitution. Its not just simply words. The founding father recognized that in order for the constitution work, there must be some condition. The moral fiber of the society. If the society turns into corrupt in general then no words in the world can save the society as we have seen thru history without execption. Its true this proposal might have a uphill battle becasue of the plain words in constitution. But it is not without justificstiin cuz many have taken adavatage of this law. Not to.mwntion the governement has deliberally allowed tens of millions illegal into country .

[@jacksonuche7428]

They are reporting it this way because it won't favour them and meanwhile, they don't practice in their own country 😂😂😂😂

[@Punch8721]

As explained birthright citizenship is on the constitution. President has no authority to change the constitution with an executive order

[@andis9076]

Exactly. Executive order is to execute constitution, not against constitution.

[@irvingberlin8489]

Did Palki choose the video of an airplane landing in 1885?

[@Ramberna08912]

Justice for Atul Subhash

[@riaanbotes3509]

hightime

[@riaanbotes3509]

i am from africa some africans go on holiday in usa get a baby who are now a citizen and dont want too leave

[@DrSchmerz]

One parent has to be legal in order for the child to be legal. That is all He is saying so do not twist it please.

[@AB_NYC]

How far is he going back?

[@aguntoroti5318]

This will affect so many living in the state calling themselves Arab United States

[@andrewt35]

Hi Palki- you have this completely wrong and lack any and all context. I am American- no one (Trump included) is discussing removing birthright citizenship for anyone other than those born to illegal (undocumented) immigrants. This is because birthright citizenship allows people who illegally cross the border to give birth just so that child will be a citizen. No one is talking about removing Indian Americans’ or other legal immigrants’ citizenship. This is absurd fear-mongering.

[@RidoBd-be3mv]

So he him self would of to leave dwl

[@takeshih3909]

looks like CAA act following modi ji foot print in AMERICA hmm

[@onidoremc9490]

Trump only suggest modiji caa He did it first in 2016..

[@Vijay-wr2bv]

Your reporting is out of context - he is referring to birthright citizenship rules relating to Illegal immigrants. Anything illegal is illegal - just a simple common sense.

[@Jaaaa832]

I doubt he can do anything about it.

[@essiadzima6549]

No he can not 😂

[@okislife80]

Potty Sharma why are Indian worried about US Citizenship. Modi should worry about Indian not Trump.

[@eirvingdiaz7185]

If we're chaning the constitution, then you may want to add "universal health care"

[@brianburgess3231]

or end voting .. like Dictators Xi, Mussolini, Hitler, etc did

[@gabrielhatter4795]

Isn't his son an anchor baby?

[@HibruNeagleshadow]

This the white man country and I fully support it.

[@cryp4life509]

Lol this country wouldnt be shid without fba's (Foundational Black Americans). You would be square dancing to fiddle music and watching Hockey, Baseball, and old reruns of black and white sitcoms on tv. Fba's gave the US it's charisma, style, and popularity. Without Blacks which the majority of have a longer history in the US than the majority of Whites, this country would be like Ireland without the money. My family has been here for centuries. Yours most likely got here within the past 100 years at MOST! Slow your roll bro...this is OUR country.

[@RaymondTorres.49ers]

This is not a white man's country I'm an American Mexican and I do believe some law has to be put in place to support those who are coming to America the right way and not illegally.

[@HibruNeagleshadow]

@RaymondTorres.49ers fool you have your own country its called Mexico. You have your own continent it's called south America. Go fix it! I'm black me and my people have nothing and we built this country for 400 years. Oh but my bad this your country you were the Indians right? Shutup and think before you speak.

[@DirkWillem-c2q]

No comment as you dont know history

[@HibruNeagleshadow]

@King_Dong_Bundy yes I know this I can see you are all quite mediocre and slow I'm implying that the white man took this country through sheer force and that this is their country now. I fully support when a stronger power conquers a weak one it is the balance of nature itself. Even in the wild.

[@Cvr1963]

In French Constitution, there is no provision for Right to Citizenship by Birth. It is only based on "Consanguinity" which means that the children of a French mala citizen shall become citizens of France automatically, in whichever country they are born. However, this right is not available to children of French women citizens. This France is the champion of human rights and women empowerment.

[@brianburgess3231]

It doesn't matter what happens in France

[@keerthichrist]

It is a great move

[@joannwilliams9973]

He can do it🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@cybeast0076]

Great

[@cuteangelsongs2.w1113zuch]

🤣🤣4 - у нас ваще бусы в канате 🤷🤣

[@cuteangelsongs2.w1113zuch]

🤣 дон а кто тебе паспарт та дал в юсэй-амэурика? 🤣