Fishing Lines 1: A Critical Link in Getting Fish to Bite.

[@CookingandFishing]

You, sir, are adding impressive *original content* to the vast, overstuffed bass fishing online library. Bravo! And please keep it up!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Cooking and Fishing.

[@les121476]

Cooking and Fishing Well said sir

[@0017Bulldog]

Paul, you are a true hidden gem of fishing expertise. I'm as guilty as the rest of us...we love to watch the vids of catching fish. But, to truly understand what is going on beneath the surface is what makes the difference. Thank you so much for doing what you do.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Bulldog. I like the catching vids too. Fun to visit with other fishers and see what they're up to. But, in the end I'm just too curious about the deeper stuff. Glad you can go there too.

[@utubeaccess7]

0017Bulldog couldn't agree more😃

[@PhantomMemory0]

It took me a long time to find the type of fishing video that incorporated fish biology/behavior in the way I was hoping for. You did it! Thanks :)

[@chrisfoley3320]

Your dedication to making the most informative videos on the planet is something all bass fisherman should be thankful for. Thanks for all your work!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Chris. Thanks. Share with friends. Cheers, Paul

[@richierich8678]

I had to pause the video to tell you that the information you are bringing to the table is more helpful then anything I’ve ever heard. It’s always about selling some sort of magical lure, but you sir are actually extremely helpful. Thank you for taking the time to make this video.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Richie. Perfect! I was always frustrated with most fishing talk too; Except maybe back in the day when Fishing Facts and then In-Fisherman showed up to set a new path. I had got tired of reading, and hearing, "...depends on conditions", followed by a pause and... a shrug. "What conditions??!!" I actually began to shout. I realize that fishing is a complicated subject, when trying to explain what's going on down there, and even tougher to take a crack at the "why's". So... undaunted, (OK, it's been a long haul), I went after it, through a number of venues. Turns out, conditions are only half of the story. Sometimes, you've just got to do things yourself. :) Thanks for the great comment! Paul

[@ronlewis2448]

SUPER educational video! Understanding fish behavior is more important than all the gear you can spend your money on. One piece of feedback, less hands... I’m off to watch more of your videos!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Ron. Yes, understanding fish behavior is where the game really begins. As to the hands, you are not the first to mention that. Unfortunately, hands are wired close to the speech center in the brain. For some people, that connection is pretty tight. Will work on it. Cheers, Paul.

[@Trevlee74]

A level of nerdom rarely seen in fishing videos. I love it!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Trevor. :)) There's actually plenty of nerds and wonks out there; Tends to follow obsession. Most are focused on lures and tackle, boats, electronics, ..., though . I want to know what the heck is going on down there. Paul

[@Charlie-lh4xb]

You sir are someone I can listen to instead of "bubba" over there leaving his beer can in the weeds. You are teaching me & I'm verifying some things I've learned. Even at 49 I haven't mastered all. Thank you

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hey, Charlie. Thanks. It's helpful for me to hear back from other anglers. If what we experience jives, that suggests we are on the right track. Easy to go astray in this business. Thanks, again. All the best, Paul

[@darrylshisler2636]

I look forward to your upcoming documentaries. Myself, I do not lose the desire for information and have no problem waiting between videos. I value your studies and as always appreciate the time and generosity in which you share.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Darryl.

[@mudpro200]

Thanks for all your work. I have been fishing over 30 years and you have shed new light on things for me and I'm sure many others. I hope you continue to share your knowledge with us as we will pass this to our future angles as well.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Motoholic. Thanks. Be sure to share my channel with friends. Cheers, Paul

[@clubpresident9147]

Great stuff. Based on the number of dislikes, there are 8 individuals who have duplicated the studies referenced here and with solid scientific precision have completed their valid studies with valid, repeatable results which differ from the ones opined here. OR, this video is beyond their comprehension and they're lacking in mental acuity.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, CB. Well, I knew it wouldn't be for everyone. And I do want to be inclusive. However, my latest like/dislike ratio was 105.5%. I don't know how YT came up with that number, but... great! :) Cheers, Paul

[@UDsawyer]

Wow, was expecting a quick “buy this line video”. Great video- thanks for the knowledge drop!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Shannon. I don’t want to waste either your time or mine. Plenty of infomercials out there. They have their place. All the best, Paul

[@Tackle2thePeople]

Could you please share your source at 3:55?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi T2. Wish I could. A while back I double checked where I’d got that and could not find it. I then wrote in the description noting that, while I looked further. I thought I’d re-located it so I deleted the note. But, when those pieces arrived they involved lines down .010” and did not involve a food reward. I’m at a loss at this point. I’ll put the note back into the description. The take-home of the video, though, does not rely on whether bass can see line; They do not know what line is or means. What alarms them is the disturbances a length of line can make. This regardless of a lines diameter in some conditions. By some comments, I’m not sure this successfully got across in the video. I’ve been planning a follow up video to clarify that. And to address the fact that I cannot find the research that backs up that statement that bass can physically see lines of all diameters. What’s been done on bass visual acuity suggests that bass may not be able to discern an object of very fine diameter. However, the overall point is that a length of even fine line can represent a large or unexpected object too close for comfort for spooky fish. Thus, fishing lines can be a major fish spooker, even fine diameter lines. Hope this helps. Paul

[@jdcisz7980]

You are a Fish Mensa! I appreciate the science you apply to fishing in a way I haven't heard before. I often felt fish could learn, or react based on what worked one year vs another and your content adds more understanding and depth to my impressions. Well done. Thank you.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Jd C. Thanks. Yeah, there's a bit more to fish than most people realize. Shouldn't be too surprising, since they live in complex environs, and go through a whole lot of changes from tiny fry to adulthood. Cheers, Paul.

[@austinshull1600]

I just stumbled across these videos. They are by far the most informative videos I’ve ever seen. The amount of work and time put into each one is top notch. You have me ‘ hooked’. 😄

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Austin. Great to hear, esp considering how much work and time I put into them! :) Glad it shows. Cheers, Paul

[@magglespaffygaming]

You're awesome dude. This is the perfect content for serious fishermen. Understanding how fish behave is paramount in catching fish.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, MSG. Yes, it is content mostly for serious fishers. I tried to give the upshot, and then get into the nitty gritty. Don't want to spook anyone. :) Cheers, Paul.

[@FNG_Star]

I have been looking for informative fishing videos that break down the science of fishing and fish behavior and how they relate to one another for a bit now. This video series has my nerd senses tingling. Love it.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, gmzd. Me too! Sometimes you've just gotta do stuff yourself! :)) Nice to have another nerd along. Apparently there are a few of us out there. I put out the spawn documentary as a trial balloon. Guess I'll keep with YT for a while and see how it goes. Glad to have you along. Cheers, Paul.

[@FNG_Star]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 Absolutely. Thanks for taking your time to make such videos. I am sure a lot of time and effort went into them. Your passion is clear. Thanks again.

[@handicapitation3250]

Holy crap, my mind is blown right now! The art of fishing explained on a scientific level. New sub here sir!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, h. Yeah, this is the kind of content I always wanted to find. Sometimes you just have to do stuff yourself! :)) Glad to have you along. Cheers, Paul.

[@jackjr1]

I really enjoy your scientific approach to fishing!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

jackjr1 Thanks, Jack. Me too. Sure is cool stuff.

[@rex2837]

Good stuff, you have the right mind for this undertaking, and that is successful fishing. Because there’s so many elements. Even in lines, my decision tree, for bass tournaments, fluorocarbon b/c it’s clear and sinks. Braid for landing a bass in heavy heavy cover. Think 5 LBs of hydrilla and a Lilly pad with a bass inside of it. But everything you said was spot on.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, rex!

[@reybuSWAG]

This is incredible. So different than most of the fishing videos on youtube. I do like watching people catch fish but this deep, analytical and informative content on fishing strategy is awesome.Thank you!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, RbKnox. Good! It may not be for everyone, but it's the kind of info I always wanted. Sometimes you just gotta do stuff yourself. :) Cheers, Paul

[@reybuSWAG]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 Let me ask you a question. I know your content is geared mostly for Bass but do you think crappie are easily spooked by line? I try to use 4lb fluoro and find I get my best results with that but many people use 8lb hi vis mono in neon yellow and seems to do just as well at times. Do you think Crappie may not be as sensitive to line thickness because they often do a negative bite and maybe won't interact with the line as much?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

I don't think line color matters much to the fish. Fish really simply don't know what line is. Unless it moves too much water, and/or the fish are able to be aware, or are esp spooky, as in really high vis conditions, and then it might be an issue, if it's course and moving too much. Most of the time, the fish have no idea what alarmed them. And, there are many places and conditions where line is less a factor, period. Use as heavy a line as you can get away with, or, as light as you need, depending on conditions. Active aggressive fish helps too, bc there attention may simply be so focused on the "food" that they don't notice the line. I'm not advocating light lines; Use as heavy, or as light, a line as you can get away with or need, depending on the conditions and circumstances. As to your crappie... There are times any fish can become "negative" or, less than enthused to chase prey. Crappie are known for it, I'm guessing bc there can be a lot of mouths to feed in a crappie school, they hunt when the hunting's good. True for all fish, but maybe crappie more than others? You may not be able to control this, but, as far as things you can do, I'd pay attention to lighting/visibility for the fish, which can make them relaxed (dim) or spooky (bright). Line could be a factor under different conditions. If you have good to high visibility conditions on given days, you, and the other guys, might do better with lighter line. This has not been an uncommon scenario for me: When I show up with 4lb and my buddies come with 8lb. They catch far fewer fish, until they drop to 4lb, and then they are in business. But... again, this really depends on lighting (sky, water, depth) conditions, fish aggression (attention), and the fish's experience with fishing. I've also had circumstances when I show up with 4lb and my buddy with 8lb, and all we need to do is up-size his jig weight. I'm good with 1/16oz jigs on the 4lb, but he needs a 1/8oz. jig on his 8lb. Then we catch fish side by side. There, the issue isn't spookiness, but basic depth and speed control. Hope this helps. Paul. Oh... also, you might want to see my video "Bluebird Blues", VFJ4, in my Video Fishing Journal playlist. It's about dealing with high vis, vs low vis, conditions, and describes how fish commonly respond to each.

[@reybuSWAG]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 Wow great insights! I never put that much thought about conditions in my fishing, I always approached it as "put a minnow on the hook and they're either there or they aren't" but now I am very intrigued about learning more about "conditions and circumstances" as you say and adapting accordingly. I will definitely watch that video and thank you for your replies and knowledge!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

A lot of the time, C&C run the show out there.

[@DonnyJ_CountryLife]

Who the bloody hell disliked this video? Great stuff here!!!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Donny. Thanks. I think some people just want things to be simple. I guess they've come to the wrong channel. Easy fix. Cheers, Paul.

[@righteous7788]

Once again the video you have put out is of amazing quality and I feel as if I am attending a college level class in terms of how much I am actually learning from each one of your videos. Amazing work and thank you!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, R. Thanks. Glad you too appreciate the details of what goes on down there. Best, Paul

[@sonofafisherman743]

Wow I’m blown away all I can say is that I’m subscribing and won’t miss any of your videos and no other angler finds this channel but me 👍

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Soaf. Thanks. Do share, though, so I can actually keep this stuff on YT. Cheers, Paul

[@sonofafisherman743]

The Nature of Fishing I will defenetly share thanks

[@SquatchT4R]

Another GREAT video!! A real service to the sport, sir. I am certain that you will shatter many commonly held beliefs as well as myths concerning fishing line. I can’t say enough for your research. Salute to you!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Charlie!

[@Oper8or]

You have made me take a step back and look at my methods in a different way. Thank you very much for making such wonderful videos. I REALLY enjoy the way you present the information. Fantastic work!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Oper8or. Really pleased you, and others, can sit through such detailed explanations. There's real stuff going on down there; It's just not easy to get at, and understand. Lucky for us there are a lot of curious people out there in many fields doing just amazing work. Makes for an even more fascinating world.

[@mg_customs8531]

THANK YOU FOR THIS AMAZING CHANNEL! I TELL ALL MY FISHING CO WORKERS AND BUDDIES ABOUT YOU, KEEP IT UP MAN WE LOVE YA

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Mitch. Thanks. Very encouraging. Wish I had more time to put to it. WAY too much time passes before I can get to it. :( All the best, Paul

[@jdcisz7980]

FISH MENSA!! Paul, thank you. I am not sure which is a more appropriate title to describe your expertise - "FISH MENSA", or "KUNG FU FISH SENSIE" You masterfully blend science and "the presentation" of fishing together better than any video I watched to date. Well done! "Making the appropriate move." Love it! Trained verse untrained bass? Love the additional insight. You sir, have made me reevaluate what I do when trying to entice a fish to bite. Thank you. If you ever come to the La Crosse area and want to fish the Mississippi, I hope you would consider looking me up. I would love to fish with you.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jd C. Glad you like to go deep, too. Thanks for the invite. Cheers, Paul.

[@christopherpettersen2359]

Great discussion on the topic of lines. Look forward to future discussions like this, as well as your documentaries. Your previous documentary was very informative and was waiting patiently for follow ups. I appreciate the quality over quantity approach standard you set forth. Keep up the good work.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Christopher. Hoping YT can support quality over quantity; At least at the pace I can muster at this point.

[@paulmerritt7540]

I had forgotten about this important trick! Thanks for helping me re-learn the fundamentals.

[@HowieDewitt7575]

Your content has a lot of love and dedication in it, best ive ever seen! Great Job!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Michael. Yes. One tends to beget the other. It's why I hate , most of us hate, getting exercise on a treadmill. There are much more fun ways. :) Have a great holiday. Paul

[@danomite359]

I've not noticed a lot of difference in fish biting better on different size line, but then I generally fish water with less than 2-3 ft clarity. I'd like to see video of bass actually avoiding line! A bigger deciding factor on line size to me is in casting distance, sensitivity, strength and floatation of the line. I do enjoy the discussion.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi DM. Thanks for the comment. Things do get uglier as visibility increases. To the point that it can seem nearly impossible at times. As I said in the video, I’ve not experienced bass “hearing” line movement like I have with carp. But I’ve had line diameter affect catch rates pretty drastically, in not entirely clear water either, but this has been most often in the finesse presentations. In heavy cover it’s not been such a… painfully noticeable issue. :)) See my video fishing journal called “Bluebird Blue”, the “Blue-pers” at the very end to see some of that kind of trouble. All this said, I can’t say I’ve done the opposite and tried heavier line to see if I could still catch fish in various conditions. I’m sure it’s possible at times. Thanks for the comment. Best, Paul

[@edgroves233]

Paul, this was simply a brilliant take on line. I am anxious to see the followup videos.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Ed. Working on it right now. Gotta get it off my plate so I can move on to even cooler things.

[@bobdashiell6714]

Hey Paul, I stumbled across your channel by happenstance a couple of days ago and I want to say thank you for what you do. I doubt that there is a more informative channel on KZbin. This is great information that has taught me more in 2 hours than I've learned in all of my years of fishing. (I won't say how many.) Awesome videos, great work. Keep up the great work. Tight lines, Bob

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Bob. Thanks, very much. Can't really do it any other way. I've been hooked a long time. :) Cheers, Paul

[@les121476]

Wow!! I just came across your channel. I can not express how much I appreciate your indepth knowledge and footage. Simply amazing footage. Thank you sir. We can patiently wait for content that is as detailed and wonderful to watch such as this. I can watch people catching fish for hours. But I can watch your videos all day on how to be a better angler. I thank you sir My wife thanks you My son thanks you Hell, even my dog thanks you We all love to eat fish.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Mour Nukes. Wow! Thanks, X4! Please share with like-minded friends. Cheers, Paul

[@jondoeherty8451]

So informative! That's why Bill Dance was my favorite fisherman. He really explained everything in great detail! Really great channel! My new favorite!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jon. Great to hear. Yeah, the devil's in the details. Busy world out there! Cheers, Paul

[@ericburger6482]

I love your straight forward and science based explanations! 👍👍

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Eric. Thanks so much. Me too! :) Best, Paul

[@sporkcrx]

Fantastic! Can’t wait for more on line, as I debate what to use constantly. Small diameter braid, vs smooth clear flouro or mono. The underwater shots look amazing

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, sporkcrx. As you know I've been trying to get this topic covered before I move on. Worked hard to get this one out before heading out if town for my 30th(!) university reunion. Next one will will go into specifics on line types. Short story is... They're all good. We're blessed nowadays. Don't sweat it. Of course there are details worth knowing that help us chip away at the odds. That's what we'll hit in the next segment on line.

[@PanhandlePrepping]

This is brilliant work, Paul. You’re a natural teacher, and I appreciate the way you have approached and presented this topic. Sorry that I’m just now finding your channel, but I’m subscribed now. As a high school science teacher with a background in microbial ecology research, I really enjoy the scientific aspects of fishing - fish biology and behavior, fisheries ecology, the physics of lures and gear, and how they all interact. I’m looking forward to your new videos and your documentary. Keep up the great work!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, T L. Thanks! Microbial ecology is... probably where it all happens! VERY cool. Really happy to have you along. More to come; Just finishing up my next doc, and that's been a couple years in the making. After that, I can get back to regular pieces. Channel's growing but, I'm not going to be able to chase the YT algorithm. Cheers, Paul

[@benhunter4041]

Can’t wait for the development video, the teaser footage looks great. Keep up the good work. I studied fisheries in school and enjoy your approach very much. BH

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, BH. I can't wait either! Yes, the fisheries science perspective is a fascinating one, but not terribly accessible for a lot of fishers.

[@xemagaldon]

Man... once again, this is awesome! I'm desperately waiting for your next vid!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, xemagaldon. I'm dying to get them out, believe me. The way I'm doing things takes a lot of time. It's suggested of course that I break things up more. But the real explanations, the why's underneath, require more than sound bites. If I had my way, was independently wealthy and had the time on my hands, I'd have put all the documentaries in me out first. But, I guess we'll just all have to be patient. Tough one for me since I've been going tooth and nail trying to understand what the heck is going on out there for a long time now. Glad you are as rapt as I am.

[@CJBagley]

Hey Paul, As a!ways you offer a great and informative piece. I've never been the sort to fuss overly much about line type, and until recently was strictly a mono gal. (Ande Tournament Green exclusively) Line size was always the lightest I could reasonably use based on reel requirements more so than lure size/weight. The old theory was the lighter the line the more action you could illicit from any given lure; more action somehow equates to more strikes/hookups. With the newer rods, reels and high tech lures I'll be really interested to see your next segment in hopes that I can glean a better understanding of the science behind the line/leader choices we make. There are so many choices now, and for those of us who came up through the days of limited brands, and a handful of line sizes (10# test works for everything mentality) it can be a bit daunting to decipher the what, when and why. This is not a subject that seems to get a lot of press in major industry magazines, the ones that are filled with "tips from the pros" . They have lots to say about all other aspects of their gear it seems, but never the intricacies of the line used; with maybe an exception for color or sinking/floating ability. Am going to watch this one again and take notes in my trusty fishing journal while eagerly awaiting your next segment. Even after 50+ years of swinging a rod it is an exciting prospect to anticipate learning even one new thing that will enhance our ability to be the best angler we can be. P.S.: In my most humble opinion, you should never apologize in anyway for the amount of time between videos. I personally would rather wait and have consistent quality than a bevy of mediocre offerings. Just my two cents. Ladimopar (@ BR)

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, CJ. Thanks. Mono is a good way to go. I still use it quite often. It's just been my standard for so long. While braid and FC have some advantages too, I've spooked plenty of fish with 10lb braid. This piece was more about what's going on rather than what to do about it. That's another discussion. And we only have so much control over that. But as you mention, tech advances and is chipping away at the challenges.

[@mr.fatbasstard648]

CJ Bagley great comment CJ. I'd like to add my two cents..lol..of agreement to your post script.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, MFB, and CJ. I'm working hard on the next documentary. Got some great additional shots this summer and think/mebbe I have enough to put it together. At this point, there's enough in there for more than one doc. Will see what is best to get it all out. I'm also continuing to collect adult hunting/feeding behavior shots, which will be a doc in itself. I've got some amazing stuff there. One thing that is becoming more and more obvious, is how difficult it is to capture prey. They are as amazing a challenge for the bass, as the bass are for the prey. Thanks for your patience. I know it's not needed. However, the YT model requires regular posting and I'm wrestling with how to do that. Not quite sure what that'll look like at this point. Also steeped in working, taking care of my family (parenting a teenager, even an upstanding wonderful one like we have, is... more labor intensive than I expected! :o :) ), and our house and property (lotsa fire mitigation work to keep up with, and the decks have needed attention). Now that I'm officially "Partnered" through YT, I am putting together a Patreon page, but don't want to fire that up until I have the next doc up and have some shorter pieces ready to release. Thanks for checking in. :)

[@mr.fatbasstard648]

The Nature of Fishing outstanding Paul, always looking forward to any fishing subject you care to share. I'm a huge fan of your Channel but I am a minority in KZbin's criteria, they probably think I'm the most boring person in the world lol. Somehow I must be a bit baffling to them, the commercial interruptions that I get while watching fishing videos are ads for hairspray and makeup while my gender and age demographic ad targeting for their clients wanting to sell me something should be Erectile Dysfunction, Alzheimer's and Life Alert products :-) Really looking forward to predator-prey and who's eating who. Given the bass's reputation of a fierce Predator and an eating machine most assume it's easy for them. On contraire Pierre, the competition is fierce and the prey is well-equipped each in their own given way. What a great subject which is rarely addressed. As a youngster I was taught how to jig fish using handmade crawdad imitators buy an old-timer who is now in the fishing Hall of Fame. He dropped me off on a small secluded island in the California Delta. He handed me an empty 1 gallon paint can and told me to go catch crawdads and fill up the paint can with them. When he finally came back 2 hours later and got me I had a full can. I handed him the can and he put a lid on it, I thought we were going to use it for bait but he said they were for supper :-(... then he handed me a rig with one of the handmade artificial Craw jigs tied on. When I basically asked him how to fish the Jig he said "you tell me you're the expert on finding and catching crawdads...." I have something I've been curious about for years Paul. And it might fit into your Prey/Predator thoughts. Every year I catch spawned out females nothing particularly unusual except there are times that I catch them looking terrible all the way into late July and early August ??? What is happening to these poor girls. Some of them are in obvious 10lb frames and barely weigh 6 soaking wet! I'll see if I can send you a photo of a recent one. As always thanks again for your time and effort Paul. I totally understand that you have a life :-) and it makes it that much easier to appreciate what you're doing for us.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, MFB. Those skinny post-spawners... Dunno exactly. My first thought is, and since it's only some individuals, they are sick fish that may or may not rebound. Could also be senescence, you know... Erectile Dysfunction, Alzheimer's and Life Alert kind of stuff lol. One of the most generally effective lures I devised was a crayfish jig, for stream trout and smallmouths. I also turned it into a trout fly that is also deadly. I published that fly in a feature article on crayfish in Fly, Rod & Reel a while back now. I've since made a big largemouth version, but have yet to find time to put it to work. Maybe someday...

[@AFishBicycle]

Best bass info content out there.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, AFB. Thanks! Paul

[@srs.bassin1124]

You deserve more subs your documentaries are great any bass angler or bass enthusiasts should be watching. sick footage and research 👍🤙🏻

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Shaun. Can't wait to release the next one.

[@wabassin11t30]

Very good stuff. If only I had professors in college that could hold my attention and cause me to think critically about a subject! I know I'll be watching this video a few times to catch all the details.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Ha! Yes! I never understood teachers who weren't all that interested in the subject matter, teaching or, for some, their students. Yes, there are a lot of details. I've really struggled, over the years, to understand the relevant fields, and develop the language, so that I can get this stuff across. Terms often have whole bodies of work behind them, so information is nested. That's why I'm using the documentary, and largely scripted formats; The language matters. And I'm proceeding in a certain order. What I've come to realize, is how quickly a 20 or 30min video fills up! It's not a whole lot of time for a conversation, especially when I have to pre-suppose the questions. Anyway, glad my efforts are not in vain. Much appreciated, wabassin!

[@nativewildman9335]

I use 6lb fireline for pan fish and sometimes big channel cat (16lb my pb). I have never had any problems with it I even throw flys with on spinning gear. Great job on the line information. This is my first time seeing your channel and I'm going to watch more. Almost forgot I chose the line because of it's low diameter

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Shawn. Thanks for sharing. Hey, a 16lb channel cat is quite a beast. And on 6lb... that's quite a project! I've come to call them "cinderblocks with fins". When I hook a big one from my float tube, I just kick to shore and fight them from there. It's awful tough pulling a cinderblock up from under the boat!

[@nativewildman9335]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 it was a nice fight on my Ugly Stik ultra light I thought it would never stop taking drag

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Yeah! They are mighty strong fish. And they can be fast too.

[@wilfredocasillas678]

Great presentation! I love the"why" behind why things work/don't work. Time to retool some gear!!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Wilfredo. Great to hear. Cheers, Paul

[@keithbuckner5086]

I love the info., Great videos, I'm looking forward to each new one you put out. I watch allot of KZbin fishing videos, but I honestly learn something new every time I watch. Thank you for all the hard work and for sharing your passion and knowledge.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Keith. Thanks. Believe me, I look forward to each one I put out. Wish it could be more often. Working on that. My next, and what's holding me up, (besides being sick for a week, and counting), is my next documentary. It's on the development of behavior in LMB, from egg to adult. It's where the stage gets set for the making of a Super-Predator. Hoping to release this spring.

[@superimpala4791]

Ive tried tons of different lines, lure, presentation, lakes and conditions cant hardly catch a fish. I bank fish and am new to the state just trying to see what the fish here like, seems like they only want what I dont have. Helpful video I'll try it out

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, SI. The bass in each state are pretty much the same animals. But bass are tough to catch consistently. It's the waters and conditions that vary. This is why I highlight C&C (conditions & circumstances) in my fishing videos (my Video Fishing Journals and Tackle Know-How vids). My documentaries are focused on behavior, the observable link between the fish and the environment. Eventually, it should all fit together, but it'll take me some time to get it all together. Working on it. As to your fishing... It's interesting. Info is great, but then your body literally has to incorporate it, and apply it. It takes time to figure things out for yourself. Once your body is involved, it'll get easier. It helps to fish with others, bc we often learn their stuff easier, or quicker, than we can figure stuff out for ourselves. Here's the way bass fishing has gone for me, and friends: We discover something that works, and that's our first "GoTo". Then it fails. But, we discover something else. That becomes a GoTo. Over time, we pick up things that work in different C&C, and become versatile enough to be able to catch in a variety of times and places. Being shorebound, try to find some small waters to fish if you can. Fish may be unreachable on many big lakes, esp in summer and winter. On small waters, the fish are right in front of you, more or less, and you then have to find biters, or figure out how to make them bite. Often, making them bite has a lot to do with not alarming them first. Hope this helps. If you haven't, see my Video Fishing Journals. I view them as us fishing together, and I try to give the relevant background info on each outing. Hopefully this will help you ask better questions as you fish on your own waters.

[@donovanb9020]

You are 100% on drag in fly fishing. We have "mends" we can do to the line but, even that technique has an incredible amount of nuance to it so as not to disturb the water too much in our effort to reduce drag and better present the fly.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Donovan. Yes, FF is such an intricate game! Detaching the fly from the line is the fundamental challenge there, around which our tackle, approach, casts, and mends are all focused. As we spend more time at it, we begin to realize that we are having to detach the fly from the last inches of tippet -what I call micro-drag- for as long as possible, or at least at the very last moments! Talk about nuanced, maddening, and oh so satisfying when we accomplish it. I find it so mesmerizing that I think I got good at it, and began to understand it, bc I found good presentations, good drifts, as rewarding as the fish caught each day. In my mind, effective presentations -in any given spot- are the goal. And, that’s when the catching begins. Yeah, talk about satisfying. FF, esp on moving water, has it in spades. Hey, you'd made a comment on the Development of Behavior doc, but it doesn't show up anywhere that I find I can respond to it. Maybe you deleted it and it's still stuck in my notifications? Curious where it could be hiding is all. Cheers, Paul

[@xCrIscoDisCOx]

Hello, I've just stumbled across your videos while watching video after video itching for spring to get here. (I live off Lake Erie so I have a few more months atleast still to wait) :/ ... fully enjoy the facts, how everything's all methodically broken down so any level angler can understand what they are being shown and put what they learn into action on the water! So thought you deserved a little more recognition and approval than just clicking a thumbs up and stuff... so, I'm glad I discovered your channel so I can subscribe and can't wait to see what else you will post in the future.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Chris. My wife is originally from Erie. Presque Isle is a pretty wonderful place. I'm originally from upstate NY, and yeah, the waiting can be tough. I was a steelheader, and ice-fisher, though too, which helped some. Tough around the East ends of the big lakes though bc of the snow cover. Hang in there! Sounds like you are making good use of your off-the-water time. I'd like to do some OTW videos, but I'm having to do one thing at a time here. Next up is my next documentary, on the development of behavior in LMB. It's s big project, but I'm nearing the home stretch here. :) Glad you are able to follow my rather in-depth, sometimes dense, videos. A chunk of my time is taking that much info and making it understandable. Glad they're working for you. I'm getting better at it as I go. Thanks for the comment. Really means a lot. I want to know how I'm doing, so comments help. Cheers, Paul

[@phillyphilly1076]

You have out don’t yourself again Mr. Paul! Awesome information. Again I can’t wait to go again!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Philly!

[@mariodepiero]

great content! If you dont watch these vids you are missing out on some great info! Thank you for these videos.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Mario. Still not sure they're entertaining enough for the wider fishing world. I'm pretty much content focused. Thanks, again.

[@douglynch9012]

As someone that fishes very clear water for Smallmouth and Brown Trout I learned the importance of line diameter years ago. Fishing with a flyrod as well as gear fishing I learned that the diameter of leader material for flyfishing was a much smaller diameter than monofilament for gear fishing in the same weight rating. For example the diameter for a popular brand of mono at a 10 lb test rating is .011 while my 15 lb flyfishing leader material is also is .011. Since I use a braid to mono or flouro leader combo for most of my gear fishing I have used flyfishing leader material for many years now. It does make a difference.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Doug. Thanks. I've been aware of the ratings, and possible quality, differences between mono's sold as leader materials and filler spools. Since I, too, use short lengths of mono with braid, leader material is an option. I'll have to look into whether the difference is real, and great enough, to warrant the expense. Thanks for the head's up. Paul

[@douglynch9012]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 ... the comparison I noted was taken directly off the labels from 15 lb Rio leader material and 10 lb Trilene XL mono which I use as backing before spooling my braid.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

@@douglynch9012 Thanks, Doug. I'll check it out. Paul

[@dankjankings7339]

Sir, I have probably watched more content on fishing than most. A lot of info is just things repeated over time.....not really based on other people’s circumstances.....YOU DESERVE SO MANY MORE SUBS......I SHARE YOUR CHANNEL WHENEVER I CAN.......THE WORK YOU PUT INTO THESE AND YOUR KNOWLEDGE IS MIND NUMBING COMPARED TO OTHERS, THANK YOU, I CTCH MORE FISH FTER EVER VIDEO

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Dank. Thanks so much. Glad you like to "look under the hood" some. Important to know how to fish. But, I was always left with the "why's". Just what is actually going on for those fish. Not easy to get at. But there are a lot of people with the same curiosity, in the sciences, offering wider lenses to look at things through. These videos are my take on what's going on down there, and how I conduct my fishing. Can't really do it another way in my mind. I'm hooked! GREAT to hear you are able to put some of this put it to ground. It ain't easy to do on a consistent basis. It's big wide and wild world out there. Enjoy it! All the best to you. Paul

[@dankjankings7339]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 To you as well sir, thank you.

[@melgozakoki85]

Thank you for all this info now I know why... Lol Makes a lot of sense. I get more fish on my light gear. 10lb 8lb test with a very slow retrieve at least at the lake I go to the most. Conroe tx. Thanks again for sharing your knowledge. I'll buy you a beer any day.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jorge. "Now I know why." That's what I always wanted to know! :) Happy to hear you are a why kinda guy too. Paul

[@mattnash5159]

Quality is right! Your video's are very intriguing as well as educational. Look forward to seeing as many more that you have time to make👌

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Matt. I'm in the throes of finishing up my next documentary, on the development of behavior, from egg to adult, in LMB. Then... I can get back to covering some more fishing related subjects.

[@mattnash5159]

The Nature of Fishing nice thanks for the info. Even with the gaps in between the quality of your vids let's us all know that when you do drop a video it's going to be a real treat👌 Needless to say can't wait for the next one!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Matt, the gaps have been WAY longer than I ever expected. :( I've been thinking about putting out some shorter pieces, so that subscribers and followers will know I'm still kicking. Right now, I've got a doc to finish. Some pros have suggested I go elsewhere than YT for such productions, but I'm giving it a shot. Thanks for your patience, and encouragement. -Paul

[@mattnash5159]

The Nature of Fishing you dont have to do that brother were not going anywhere👌

[@jasonphillips1342]

I'm not sure who wrote the book on fishing but I bet this guy taught them everything they know

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jason. Thanks. But... no one's written that book. If someone finds it, it'll be written in stone by an immortal hand and have come from a mountaintop, or the bottom of the sea. :) But thanks for the compliment. Soon I'll be a legend in my own... mind. Or, a rebel... without a shoe. :)) Thanks, Jason. Cheers, Paul.

[@greatsoutherntrendkill79]

I am so grateful and thankful for the time you have spent making these videos. I have learned so much from your videos. Thank you.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Gstk. I can’t wait to be up and running again. Cheers, Paul

[@gregc7314]

The question I have is are fish more sensitive to the diameter of line or the visibility of the line. For example, would they react more negatively to 30 lb braid or 15 lb mono? 30 lb braid is thinner than 10 lb mono and should have a lot less presence in the water than 15 lb mono.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Gregory. I believe it's the diameter -it’s “presence”, as you aptly put it- more than “visibility”. Even though lines are thin -measured in thousandths- they are also very long, so they can disturb a lot of water. It’s the “disturbance” that matters, however it is that happens. This is more important than the line itself being seen by the fish, and then recognized as some unnatural part of the lure. They don’t see the two as related, unless perhaps too course a line moves with the lure, making the two look like something larger than intended. Imagine 15lb mono on a tiny jig. Heavy lines can also affect the action of a lure, or the line’s presence can simply be too large an object too close for comfort. This is pretty much the gist of the video. Braids, I feel, are generally less obtrusive than mono’s, bc of their thin diameter, their suppleness, and their low mass: They land very softly on the water. Paul

[@dennisederer3594]

Absolutely incredible presentation. I appreciate the a academic study and association with the nature of a bass. Perhaps I will achieve better success due to better of understanding.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Dennis. Thanks. Glad you liked it. Good luck with your time on the water. Cheers, Paul

[@Dss-bm3rz]

Wow, why haven't I found your videos until just now. This is just the info I'm craving

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, DS. Thanks. It was the kind of info I was always craving too. Sometimes ya just gotta do stuff yourself. :) I'm getting found, but slowly. Share with your like-minded friends. My channel probably won't be for everyone. Cheers, Paul

[@michaellohman5260]

Can't wait to see the next documentary, the last one was fantastic.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Michael. Me too!

[@ishankabartholomeusz1023]

Which colour braid would you recommend for topwater poppers and minnow lures?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Ishanka. I don't think it matters. It's the movement of line, esp when it disturbs the water, revealing a "large unidentified object" close to the fish that I believe counts most. I use green for most of my fishing. Some people like white for visibility against the water. I think this is a good idea. I know someone, who catches a LOT of bass, who experimented by fishing fluorescent yellow braid, tied direct to his lures, for a year. And he found no difference in catch rate compared to running a "less visible" leader. I don't think fish know what line is. Hope this helps. Best, Paul

[@dragon-fishon2670]

appreciate your efforts. I'll take the quality over the quantity all day.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi Drag On - Fish On. We used to say, "Fish on, good day". Lol. Thanks. Glad you can go deep. I've been known for long posts on forums, and some people would respond: "My head hurts!" I guess I've been at this so long now, it just doesn't hurt anymore. Lol. I was concerned how something like this would fly in video format, esp with the YT model that favors content quantity. Still trying to find my way here. Thanks for the affirmative comment.

[@neutzz2008]

Great content. I really enjoyed your format and delivery

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Andrew. Thanks. Glad you enjoy my videos, especially my "format and delivery" I've felt I really need feedback on that. Work in progress, as most things are. Cheers, Paul

[@H8er-Maker]

Informative video Paul, that's an interesting to know that a bass can associate a line to an angler. I've always assumed they forget everything every 15 mins.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Bruce. LM's have been found to have memories for lures (as "not food") for as much as 3 months, as long as was tested. I don't think they associate line with anglers, as much as the line can put them off or alarm them by it's presence. Not sure they even identify what it is even. At least I haven't seen anything that would have me believe that. But, I suppose it's possible.

[@peteh7966]

This is a great approach, a lot of us (me), give little thought to this more scientific approach to our fishing, I'm primarily fishing for Australian Black Bream which are super spooky, so I'm hoping to glean some helpful info from your series of videos - thanks.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, CNF. Really pleased to have an Aussie angler aboard. I've spent some time living in SE Asia, and even though I had very limited fishing time there, I developed an interest in S Pacific inshore species that would take casted artificials: Mangrove Jacks and Black Bream in particular. Loved watching the Australian fishers at work. Both species reminded me of the bass fishing here. Hope my videos are of help. Cheers, Paul

[@peteh7966]

@@thenatureoffishing7591 Hi Paul, I have found the three part series on line very thought provoking. Summer at the moment here with very bright days and I'm finding the biggest bream are very easily spooked by seeing the braid when cast, no matter how careful I am. I've even toying with running Vanish Ultra2 7lb/0,222mm fluorocarbon (my normal leader) straight through. Do you will think this will help or is it probably just the shadow they would be picking up? Pete.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi Pete. OK… I'm loving this comment. :) It's summer there and you are actually fishing! I'm right there with ya buddy, esp since we're still iced over here. And… I feel your pain. I know what you're up against; Or, it's at least very familiar. So, a few thoughts :)) on a very cool and challenging subject: First, I have a video on fishing "bluebird blue" conditions, in fact it's called "Bluebird Blue..." in my video fishing journal playlist: VFJ1. If you do watch, be sure to watch all the way through, or just skip to the end, for the day's "Blue-Pers". They are... funny, at a safe distance now :)) You'll at least get to see that Black Bream and Largemouth Bass appear to share similar risks. I believe that piscivorous birds have a big part in that. A quick look up on Black Bream describes a very eclectic (capable!), but primarily benthic, forager. Main predators... Birds! No surprise there. My thoughts… more than you asked for. But, I really do share this challenging issue and find it fascinating, and even worth the pain, in acceptable doses. As I'd said in Line 1, bass can physically "see" lines of essentially all diameters. (The comparative capabilities of your BB are not likely known.) In my experience, fish perceiving fishing lines has most to do with the line’s motion. It can be darn tough to hide a line from sharp-eyed fish in high vis sky and water conditions. There was a Blue-Per clip I didn't include in the video (bc the camera didn't pick up the bass) that was especially... illustrative, and frightening in terms of a fisherman's ego. :) It was a bass I watched calmly swim beneath my .007 (.19) braid, lying serenely on the surface. I scarcely moved the rod tip, and the line tensed. Tensed! Wrinkled the surface film! That was all!! Boom! Gone! "What do I have to do??!!" Well, apparently a lot LESS than I just did lol. Frightening. Maybe, you are experiencing this too? OK, so let’s break this down. (Love this stuff; I’m so glad you are in the thick of it, and sharing it). Primary spookers IME are: -Angler, rod, line, motions while in line of sight of the fish. You’re already on this. But I’m writing this for others, as well, and… it can be darn surprising how visible, or how much we are actually moving, when we think we’re being stealthy. Video cameras trained on ourselves can be embarrassingly revealing. :o -Line flash in the air. Big fish spooker. This is the reason I use braids (and tinted mono’s) for such high vis fishing. This said, the lure in the air is often the much larger culprit. -Lines landing on the water. This is why I use braids. Mono’s are just too heavy. They disturb the water too much. I don’t know Bream, but, I suspect that FC’s are not likely to help in this regard. I am not sold on the idea that FC’s are “invisible UW”. Again, it’s not the “line” per say, it’s its movement. Fish don’t have to “know” what spooked them, as it happened, or even afterwards. They are not in bird’s gullet, and that’s what really counts. IME, hiding monos is a lot tougher than hiding braids, at least at the surface. -Lines moving underwater, might be a somewhat different story. Sunken lines are less an issue with bass, it seems, than with some other species, as I mentioned in the Line1 video; Unless, the line is pretty thick in diameter, really visible, and/or disturbing water. I’ve actually watched this, with steelhead, the big ‘bows just moving aside as a glowing rope affixed to a tasty bait, or fly, swings through; Otherwise… well presented. FC’s density could be a plus, for its ability to tuck under the surface film, which may take away a big part of what spooks fish -those surface disturbances. That is, if you can cast out ahead of your fish so they don’t see it crash onto the water, or get tugged -even”wrinkled”- through the surface film. The easiest way out is to do what many other predators do, rely on -take advantage of- C&C (conditions & circumstances). VFJ’s 5 and 6 (back to back days meant to be seen together, hit this (Colorado weather here is very helpful in this regard). Some of the most common gifts from the gods are, of course: Morning/evening, clouds, surface chop, turbidity, proximity to cover, competition, and… other distractions. I’ve had some cool experiences, where I’d managed to figure something out, in creative ways. Some were pretty revealing. Like… “are those super spooky fish even willing to strike a lure??” Turns out, yes, if you can get the darn lure anywhere near them! Under such conditions, that’s what it takes just to get into the ballpark! -Boat/Angler Positioning? Get a lure out ahead of direction of travel? Wait em out? Angle from the sun to reduce visibility? Super high, super long, casts, so fish can’t see the lure in the air? This has panned out for me with bass. Hmmmm… Best I can do from, gee, 8000 miles away, this time! Hey, Pete, really glad you found me. Pleasure having an angler aboard, whose sharing something both fish and fisherman share, the world over. I'm really diggin' that. :) Please do let me know if you figure something out. Or, if you don’t. Can be just as valuable, at least on the ego. And there is something to be said for that. Cheers, -Paul

[@azhang929]

very very original. thank you for a new light. subbed.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Addison. Glad you liked it. More to come; Just takes time. All the best, Paul

[@CMDAVISs]

This guy is very informative and interesting ! Thank you. What about braid in stained water and so on.... How does this affect the fish. We never spoke on water clarity as a factor. Please do

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Cody. I see water clarity as pretty much the same as visibility, for the fish. We can get away with more under reduced visibility. But, the issue is, once again, not that the fish can see fishing line, they don't know what it is, but instead whether its presence registers with the fish, the biggest issue being when it disturbs water near them. One of braids biggest advantages is its softness and low mass, meaning it disturbs water the least of all the lines. As to its visibility to fish, again, they don't know what line is. I, and others, have fished straight braid, no leader, even bright yellow lines, without the fish seeming to care. Right now I'm working on a series of videos on Conditions & Circumstances, what I call the C&C. I'll be putting them in a new playlist, called Fundamentals, that will hit underlying foundational topics that I don't have time to cover say in my video fishing journals. I'll be hitting water clarity in C&C#3, under the heading, Lighting. C&C#1 will be out this week. Hope this helps. Cheers, Paul

[@r.barefoot8386]

This video really challenged me to consider how fishing line is perceived by fish. In particular, I think your theory about displacement of fishing line spooking fish rather than line visibility, especially with the huge marketing push towards fluorocarbon. I've recently been putting this idea to the test in a couple of nearby public waters that are known for being difficult to fish due to high water clarity and high pressure. I had been flat out told by a few locals that the fish there would never touch anything attached to braided line. I had some luck with smaller finesse presentations, but still had a hard time getting a bite with lighter fluorocarbon or mono (8-10) lb. I thought about you displacement theory and decided to try a smaller diameter braid. It was like night and day. I'm still trying this out on other similar waters, but I've had better results with smaller diameter braided lines than with larger diameter fluorocarbon...in high pressure, high water clarity conditions at least. I always look forward to your videos! We definitely need a more scientific approach in the fishing community

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, BB. Thanks for the comment. Great to hear other's experiences. Displacement, moving water, has appeared to me to be the main fish spooker. "Displacement" is a good general term for it. Such feedback is exactly what I'd hoped for this channel, positive or negative, as we're all here to learn. It's a big world out there. Thank, again. More to come. I'm currently just finishing up my next documentary, and made the decision to get that released before I take anything else on. It's pretty much finished. I'm putting together a Patreon page to release at the same time. Wish me luck. Cheers, Paul

[@corywalker6245]

You have just put me with a whole different perspective on my fishing standpoint.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Cory. Great! Hope it helps. Don't spook em! The rest is puzzle enough. :) Cheers, Paul

[@grippinglipsfishing5671]

First! I have been missing your videos sir! Good luck with the documentary!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, GLP. Yeah, I wish I could get more out. Lol, that was quick!

[@rvfishingyet]

Extremely helpful discussion on presentation, and my take away matching line diameter to lure size and hook size. Please attach charts to your details section. Those are solid work. Thank you!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, RV. Great to hear. And a good idea. All the best, Paul

[@yuureihaiku]

Great videos!! Please keep making them! The information in these vids has really helped me with getting back into fishing. Thanks!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, TAH. Thanks. Glad you can wade through such details with me. And, welcome back to fishing. Paul

[@manifestgtr]

I had a perfectly illustrated experience with this earlier this week. I was on top of an enormous hatch with about a dozen trout just hangin out in this large pool in front of me. They were so keyed in on feeding, they would swim right up to within ten feet of me to grab a nymph...but they wouldn’t take my little nymph pattern...rejected every time. At first, I thought I would just swap out colors but let’s be honest, color shade is a pretty secondary factor when there’s a major frenzy happening. Then it hit me like a bolt from the blue...my tippet is too large, they’re seeing my line. Swapped from a 5x to a 6x tippet and BAM. It was like someone flipped a switch and I took one on the first cast. That was a really important lesson. The margins can be really small sometimes but let’s face it. Trout and bass have survived millions of years worth of evolution by understanding “this is food, this is not food”. That’s what we’re chasing here...it’s not “I can see the line, how dumb does this idiot think I am?” Its “hmmm, that’s not food”. That’s the line of thinking that gets you where you wanna be.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hey, manifestgtr. It can take a lot of years to see things... like a fish. And it helps to know what to look for. Here, it's how the line affects what the fish perceives. What can be really weird is how a truly effective fly pattern may not look in hand anything like what "the insect" looks like in hand. But beyond that, even the perfect imitation is dead in the water if presented poorly, even slightly at times. I had this driven home years ago fishing live stonefly nymphs to "unsophisticated" brookies. Those "flies" were the real thing, dislodged from the current and heading right down the pipe toward pods of hungry brookies. Doesn't get much better... until the current caught an errant loop in the tippet causing micro-drag; "Not Food." "Come on!" I'd practically shout. "You silly fish! You don't know food when you see it??" :)) They wouldn't spook, I was being darn stealthy and they relatively un-fished, but... they'd just let those wriggling nymphs, trying to get back down to the substrate, pass by. "Not Food". But get a good drift and "Bam!"

[@JasonC1981]

Nice video! Love the info and footage in the beginning! So cool!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jason. Thanks. And, yeah, there's a lot of cool stuff going on down there. Lotsa hours of video to reveal those gems though. And it helps to know where and when to place the cameras. Still, I'm often surprised at what transpires in front of those cameras.

[@SalDesignMan]

Man you are so informative love watching your videos. A true work of art!!!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, SDM. Thanks. Great! I wish I could put more of them out. Cheers, Paul

[@cadeyates2786]

I wonder if a form electro magnetism would be able to do something like "get rid of fishing line" the only issue is your lure would have to be connected to the rod possibly via wifi connection

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Cade. :)) There's an idea to run by Elon Musk! That would be great... I think. :) You'd need a pretty strong wi-fi- connection. And...my biggest concern about "getting rid of the fishing line" would be having no connection with the fish at all! I've enjoyed my time spent with nets and electro-fishing gear, but... it's just not the same. :) Fun comment. Cheers, Paul

[@Dsmuyt]

would you say that trout are like bass in that they are alike in all fish that we try to catch in our waters ?...C and C ?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi Daniel. Great question. The answer is, a flat out Yes. Absolutely. All fish share similar challenges. Specifics vary, but the basic premise is the same. The reason I focus on behavior is bc it is the link between a fish's physiology (the "machine") and the environment it has to make a living in. C&C pretty much run things. However, the fish's physiology (and of the other players in the system) has a lot to say about how to respond/"behave". If you go through the fields of study, a lot of people have been looking at this stuff for a long time. We're a curious bunch. I'm just bringing it to fishing here. We could be focussing on any creature though. I've done an awful lot of trout fishing in my day, but chose bass to start with, for several reasons. I want to do trout though! I could do trout really really well. This is not a brag, but excitement. I want to do trout so bad. I hope I live long to do them justice. :) Last year I was killing some time by a small local trout stream, so I dropped in a camera just for the heck of it. What I happened to drop in on was amazing. A roughly 10" brown was on station, when a little 4"er dropped down, and immediately bolted back upstream, obscured by a large boulder. The bigger brown followed. After 20sec or so, the bigger dropped back down in front of the camera, with the tail of the little brown sticking out of his mouth. This is not only a rare and cool shot, but it illustrates how some trout get BIG, and others don't. This is especially true of browns. Anyway... someday. Paul

[@jakesoriedem4747]

Great Video, I subscribed @ the 3 second mark. You are the Bill Nye of the fish world. Thank You

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Jake. Great! Welcome. LOL, you're not the first to call me that. :) My favorite, and maybe most accurate, was "the Bob Ross of the fishing world". :)) Cheers, Paul.

[@YKW-YouKnowWhat]

Great work. I love underwater filming.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Nemo. Thanks.

[@SirPraiseSun]

WOW those baby bass feeding on little creatures and bugs is crazy footage!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Raffael. Yeah, I was surprised how much they were doing when I finally got up close and personal with them. Took some doing though. To see more, see my Documentaries playlist. Cheers, Paul

[@tedchu8888]

Great discussion. What do you think of those hig-tech nano lines that are extremely thin?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

I like them. I started with Nanofil, using the .001 for nymphing for trout in our turbulent canyon streams. .001 is about as close as one can get to "doing away with that pesky string of molecules"! But, it lacks abrasion resistance, shredding way too easily. I used .004 Gliss this winter, with a FC leader. Nice! I kinda lump them in with braids, bc all are stronger than the rods we use them with. I'll be talking about them in the next line video. Pros and cons to all.

[@nmbass]

best bass fishing pieces of information aound! good job!! keep it up

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Nicholas!

[@stevegercone7837]

As always Paul great job and eye opening!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Steve.

[@dandolan3168]

Any thoughts on small gaug nylon line ...

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Dan. I use it too, usually for shallower water. I'm apt to use FC in deeper water though, to keep baits down and potentially detect bites a bit better since it sinks. Paul

[@SVMSICE]

Excellent video, great study, great information. You explain things very clearly. I just subscribed. I loved the videography of the crow and under the water, can't wait to see the documentary you are making.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, SVM. Thank you. Very much appreciated. Yeah, that was a cool shot. I can't wait to see the next doc either! Getting close. Took a break to get some prespawn, binge feed, fishing in. Editing that now, then... back to the doc. Stay tuned. Cheers, Paul.

[@TR4SHMUFN]

Is there any type of expected completion date for the documentary cause I'd love to watch it!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, YT. Looking at a late spring/early summer release. Wish me... godspeed. Cheers, Paul.

[@fishingwithvin]

This makes a lot of sense and it confirms what my suspicions are about my last weekend. I used a 12lb florocarbon with a a variety of spinners for trout this last Saturday and didn't catch a thing but another guy using the same spinners with 2lb line caught his limit in an hour. I even dropped down to 6lb line and a tiny spinner but still nothing while others were getting bites left and right or catching them. I'm going to try again this Saturday and in going with my 4lb mono line on smaller rods I have to see if that helps.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, NTF. I've had similar experiences. The difference in surface area between 12lb (.012) and 4lb (.008) is immense, in practice. Good luck with your next outing. Paul

[@chonhzilla]

Great video! Looking forward to the next one! Very informative. 👍🏻👍🏻

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Choh.

[@dougrussell1926]

psychoanalysis for bass.. loving this

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Doug. Great, 'cause it's going to get even deeper. I'm in the throes of editing my next documentary, on the development of behavior in LMB. And I have to address their cognitive development... bc fish actually make decisions -they "think". I'm working my way toward a big question: Not only why fish bite, but, more often, why they don't. There's more to it than, they're "inactive". No, it's not going to get weird lol. But it's not going to be your usual fishing video, either. Cheers, Paul

[@thomasleebrown3136]

I personally haven't given line diameter any thought. Thank You for the education.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Thomas. Yeah, I think it’s the most useful way to look at fishing lines. Cheers, Paul

[@mattfields2033]

Absolutely love your videos

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Matt. Thanks. Don't forget to share with friends. Cheers, Paul

[@mr.fatbasstard648]

Conditions and Circumstance, I fish a lot of primarily clear deep water reservoirs. On Windswept days or days with high recreational boat activity the shoreline can get quite turbid with suspended matter and straight braid is fine. But a clear protected cove is a whole different story. Paul, are any of the upcoming videos going to deal with sound and bass hearing. I still personally believe that bass use site, lateral line detection and taste while nearly being deaf. No one seems to want to study hearing much but manufacturers promote so many lures based on sound. I've noticed in the past 10 years lure manufacturers are changing lure descriptions to vibration and rattling while previous sale promotions were highly based on sound. I've written letters to some manufacturers regarding the auditory attraction of their lures. Some respond with ridiculous babble others will send me a handful of lures :-) asking me to try them out and let them know what I think. Personally I still think it's the amount of molecular disturbance that causes a response. I'm just grateful that hungry and angry territorial bass will occasionally make a mistake and that I won't be here when the next generation is using remote control lures once they figure out how to drive a fish back to the operator/angler once you catch it lol.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

I agree with you that sight and water movement detection are primary. Bass are not deaf, but are known to have a surprisingly limited range of hearing. I'll do something on bass hearing sometime. It's interesting and surprising. Although all the facts are almost assuredly not in, its not what lure marketers would like to hear. Water movement is a big factor that that plays a huge role in final triggering or "sealing the deal". Experienced fishers all tend to gravitate to this idea over time. It's surely why Rick Clunn designed cranks have textured bodies that, supposedly, add to the wake they throw. "Grateful that hungry and territorial bass will occasionally make a mistake..." Now that is a statement only someone whose been around the bend a few times is in a position to admit. That's fishing in a nutshell. Knowing how many fish are down there NOT biting is mighty rough on the ego. Glad to have you aboard, MFB. :)

[@xCrIscoDisCOx]

It really is outrageous how the lure manufacturers have conditioned anglers to make their purchases based upon what is typically unrealistic to real life every day fishing conditions and results with whatever lure they claim to be the next big thing. Lol. But I do think that when they refer to the sound of a lure it translates to the amount of vibration it'll create in the water which in theory causes sound waves to travel thru the water and hopefully be detected by a fish...

[@bassnazi4713]

It really does basically translate over to the same, although they try to make it sound like different things. The lateral line, our ears, vibration, hearing, all equates to the same things really. The sound is basically a vibration in our ears the brain picks up and interprets just like a splash sends vibrations through the water the fish pick up through lateral line translation. I'm sure it's other sensing going on as well, same as we can feel some sounds throughout our body. I think the loud knocking some promote is more a fisherman thing, since sound carries better below the surface in many ways. Just like most would never want to be near a military sub pinging lol.

[@caryjapp9149]

Another great video, learned a great deal, I was curious on how line type plays a role in the factors in the video, specifically braided. Thanks

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Cary. See the other Line videos in the series, 2 and 3. My channel is organized in playlists: Documentaries, Tackle Know-How, Fundamentals, and Video Fishing Journals. They, the VFJ's esp, are meant to be archivable, to be re-referred to every yaer, as things come round again each year, but with the new twists each year brings. Hope this helps. Happy to answer any specific questions. Cheers, Paul

[@escalade8759]

Great Stuff! Just never new there was so much to this hobby of fishing.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, Escalade. Yeah, it's a big world down there. And, we can't see most of what's going on. Luckily, there have been a lot of curious people before us. Paul

[@theoriginalcatdaddy]

Dynamite doesn't have fishing line. Just kidding I love watching your videos keep up the good work. I hope you get to do some videos here in central florida.

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, toby. Yeah, same amount of fight too I suppose. :) Central FL looks awesome. Someday perhaps. Cheers, Paul

[@empyreanb9444]

Such a great teacher. Thank you for sharing your knowledge. If you don't mind me asking, what region or state is your field footage shot in?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Thanks, EB. I'm in Colorado. Everything is shot in the wild in public waters.

[@robjones7410]

I always thought that between .011 and .013 was the best up to a 12 lb line was the "sweet spot"...was I told wrong?

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, Rob. In my experience, a "sweet spot" is... as a sweet spot does. :) In other words, where I fish, there's a place for line's from 4lb (.008) to 20lb (.017) in bass fishing. Line diameter needed depends on the weight of the lure, the wire gauge of the hook, the cover present in that water at that time, and how spooky the fish may be. Even in one small pond, I may use from 4lb to 20lb+ over the course of the year. Paul

[@Maru-ge6jn]

I love this video on so many levels!

[@thenatureoffishing7591]

Hi, John. Great to hear. It's my take on what I think is going on with those fish when we put fishing lines near them. Hope it gives you stuff to think about. All the best, Paul