Investigating The Ghost Lady of Bluewater Marsh - Red Dead Redemption 2

The story of the mysterious ghost lady of Bluewater Marsh. A complete investigation & theory.
COMMUNITY DISCORD: / discord
Channel merch:
shop.spreadshir...
Join (Curse) Union for Gamers: www.unionforga...
My second channel: • Video
Support me on Patreon: / fishyyarpster
Snapchat: cabbagefishd3
Follow me on Twitter: / ejwoodgates
Woof: / doggoofhappines
Like my Facebook page: / fishyyarpster
Thanks for watching!
Please:
Like
Subscribe
Share
Comment
TELL YOUR FRIENDS ABOUT ME (please?)
NO SELF ADVERTISING WHETHER IT BE OF PRODUCTS OR CHANNELS (if you want me to notice your videos/products then be sure to privately message me)
I hope you enjoy the video!
Music from Epidemic Sound: www.epidemicsou...
#RedDeadRedemption #RDR2 #RockstarGames

[@ItsAv3rageGamer]

"I gave you everything I had" interesting how she repeats Arthur's last words.

[@llamakicker7299]

Sam Harrison Mine was Damn us Both :/

[@Cognitoman]

Wait...Aruthr actually said he had a baby and wife that died...

[@bizio760]

@@Cognitoman she didn't hang herself though... She and her son were killed by bandits

[@friendlycrusader2394]

It’s Gavin

[@angrymp4815]

Stalin and Gavin are connected

[@unfathomable3434]

John Marston: paranormal investigator

[@VampEngr]

John Marston; paranormal investigator, gunslinger, rancher, family man

[@unfathomable3434]

@@VampEngr thanks for catching my sentence

[@thelonecourier3439]

@@VampEngr and zombie killer

[@bajenbilly]

@@thelonecourier3439 and he sucks at swimming

[@albertomiranda3719]

And bounty hunter

[@andytekno]

The voice acting for this ghost is awesome.

[@thepoet9253]

It is. It's pretty creepy actually how authentic it sounds. When they put such work into a ghost that you may never even find or see in game, you know that it's a good game.

[@jackoblllllllll]

haunting...

[@cameronb7161]

Someone poured their heart out into voicing this event. Something most players may never stumble across. I've tried multiple times but have NEVER come across this ghost.

[@deeznutz8320]

Indeed watching this late at night gives me the creeps

[@0Satanael]

@@cameronb7161 I mostly hear/see her appearing on foggy nights around 12-4am. She also only seems to appear once every two days, so once you see her you have to wait two days before she shows up again. It's also the top of the swamp area that she seems to reside in by the shack near the river. That's the best chance I can give you at seeing her based on my experience

[@hamsters7760]

The gang: rapidly falling apart from within and without Arthur: spends a month in the swamp stalking a ghost

[@Kova-ow2en]

Imagine vanishing without a trace and coming back two weeks later and having to explain why you were gone so long

[@JohnMcdonald2004]

Imagine John explaining to Abigail why he's going out to the the lemoyne swamp's for this

[@danielnikitin2020]

*Abigail don't be worried I am Ghost hunting in the swamps and see a hanging girl that just Confessed to me. Have a good one!*

[@sadieadler3065]

Listen, Abigail, I’m stalking a lady in the swamps at night who appears to have been taken advantage of in the past. It’s been 26 nights since I first saw her and she’s poured her life story to me and now she dead :)

[@shotq8070]

Abigail I know you love me but I've got to go out to the marsh so I can stalk this ghost woman and find her handing corpse

[@rgw7345]

@@sadieadler3065 "What CHOICE do I have Abigail?"

[@BammerHammer627]

I think it's funny knowing that John most likely spent close to 3-5 weeks within the game camping out in the swamp.

[@drizzt_tvold4109]

I have played enough witcher to know that swamps should be avoided

[@mrnuggetman7720]

300th like thank you

[@charlesterras3717]

And ghosts!

[@fearmyshadow4685]

why? the battle theme there is AMAZING!

[@theArab__]

@@fearmyshadow4685 LELELELELELELELELELELELELELELELELE

[@liamleonard9120]

You need to burn what ties her spirit to that place. Then meditate, apply specter oil to your silver sword, equip the yrden sign, do about a dozen combat rolls and kill her

[@kimberlyh.7797]

"You look just like him.“ Personally I think she might have had a child with this man and spoke to him and not to us

[@ralcogaming7674]

Also if it is Agnes then I have a theory. She fell in love with a slave. That house and all the out buildings scream plantation. I can't imagine her falling in love with too many people her parents wouldn't approve of. But at the time a black man oh yeah they'd shoot him. The thing I can't sort are all the different surnames in the graveyard. If her parents did this she'd have killed then too. Yet no other dowd there's 2 charlesworths in the graveyard though

[@rgw7345]

@@ralcogaming7674 Her parents called him white trash, so no.

[@austinmasoni3750]

maury:you are the father

[@sunnex474]

Katie Adler the man is gavin and that made him go missing

[@nickcurrant2254]

That's what I thought. My first interpretation was that she was describing her child, and the player is meant to experience her sorrowful experience.

[@josephl5405]

This guy is like the non click bait version of MrbossFTW

[@TheYouTubeCommentPoster]

That's an insult to Fizhy.

[@notaraider7115]

eMPhish *no*

[@NordicSoldier]

haha my thoughts excactly!

[@ulises.-.5455]

@@eMPhish N O

[@eMPhish]

Uli. ?

[@james5076]

imagine the entire van der lin gang just camping out in the swamps and listening to this. itd be hilarious

[@erikallen3804]

I think what you’re trying to say is what if the Van Der Linde Gang was camping out at Bluewater Marsh and not Shady Belle.

[@SpazzyTaco-mz5cy]

And if Sean was still alive, just imagine his Irish as fuck reaction to a creepy ass ghost lady "Oh fUcK ofF yOu sPectRal trAnsLuCent oL' BItCh, 'Fore I fill ya wit lead"

[@sadieadler3065]

John: Wait why are we here? Arthur: MARSTON SHUT UP IM TRYNA LISTEN FOR CHRISSAKES! Dutch: Have some faith Arthur! Hosea: Dutch! You’ll scare her off. Sean: FECKIN GHOSTS DON’T SCARE ME ~runs toward the ghost~ Lenny: Uhm this feels wrong guys should we be here? Kieran: ~Ran off at first sign of the ghost~ Uncle: ~Piss drunk and passed out~ Reverend: I tOlD yOu Charles: Oh I’ve heard stories about this, here let me tell you... Javier: WHAT THE FUCK IS THAT Micah: You’re all dreaming this ain’t real I’m the only unexplainable force here Bill: Heh?

[@Kanal7Indonesia]

Well the gang did camp at the creepy Lakay Lagras

[@sunnex474]

Micah: WAY TO GO BLACK LUNG

[@riptidemonzarc3103]

"He looks just like you" and "I gave everything to you" and "nobody will have me now" are very strong evidence that the woman got pregnant and had a son; other quotes imply that the girl was betrothed and broke it off for a dalliance with the hillbilly, who then rejected her after she slept with him. She then couldn't find a 'suitable' husband, since she was 'ruined' by losing her virginity and having a child out of wedlock.

[@Floridian_Kole]

Bro I thought the same thing. Literally looked for a comment of someone explaining it before I wasted my time repeating it. Very well put💯

[@AbaddonAlmighty]

I thought the same. Also thought maybe she had twins, a boy and a girl, but killed them before killing herself. That would explain the "and others".Family probably wouldn't want to specify that she killed her bastard children to prevent more shame.

[@realtundragaming]

I thought so to so idk how he got all that wrong in the video cause I’m like dude you got it wrong she was pregnant and he left her 😂

[@radu19d]

Same here 😁

[@seanowens6888]

@@Floridian_Kole same

[@hugonusselder4782]

I was actually looking for her and just when I looked at my phone for a moment she appeared right behind me saying 'I always loved you'. Scared the shit out of me

[@PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven]

Same happened to me I dropped my Molotov and got killed by dickheads cousin

[@marlenebellic449]

@@PrimarisBlackTemplaDraven cousin💀

[@rokkfel4999]

Black Templar Knight Draven ahh...I got killed by assholes nephew(the damned snakes)

[@ihatemylife6126]

Dickheads cousin by marriage

[@marcusadowning]

There is also a random camp event where you can hear Swanson yelling to Tilly about seeing ghosts in the swamp, claiming it was a young woman. Tilly dismisses him as crazy, but it turns out he probably saw the ghost of this woman.

[@archer9819]

Bro I saw that at camp right after that blue water marsh ghost and I was SO scared

[@ZarakiKempachi]

15:45

[@benformation8123]

Something else: I set up camp rather far away from where the ghost appears, I went to sleep for about 18 hours leading me into the next night, but when I woke up, I was spawned by the tree where the ghost hanged herself....creepy business.

[@datsimplenope]

No fucking way

[@robinchwan]

that final "I love you"... i don't think it means in a romantic sense but thanking you for releasing her suffering and moving on

[@thepoet9253]

I thought so too. Makes sense that she'd thank the player for helping her exact the revenge necessary to free herself

[@CMRT420]

I'm Arthur Morgan, and you're watching Ghost Hunters with Morgan & MA FREEEEENDs!

[@jonathonboelter8792]

Not to burst ur bubble but hes playin as john

[@nightraven5710]

That's really funny!!

[@ellis4091]

@@jonathonboelter8792 Arthur is the host,John is the reporter

[@LubyLifts]

killshot q I love this response

[@el_dante616]

“Ghost Hunters with the Van Der Linde Gang”

[@b4nd1t9]

2:32 probably the most insightful, meaningful, and eye opening part of the video

[@erikallen3804]

“Oh don’t worry Abigail, I’ll back back in probably 2 weeks because there’s a ghost near Saint Denis.”

[@bigthink954]

So it looks like reverend Swanson was right when he saw a ghost

[@14DiamonD47]

i wonder if there's different reply to him talking about this ghost after you saw her

[@erikallen3804]

Having people in camp talk about this stuff is basically Rockstar’s way of telling you to get your lazy butt out of camp and go exploring.

[@aidenmccleary8464]

@@erikallen3804 Like Sunny and bill but after u meet sunny Bleh

[@N1sjsjsj]

no shit sherlock

[@joaogomes9405]

@@erikallen3804 No thanks, I'll skip on night time delvings in the swamp. Crocodiles, night folk, rapists and fucking ghosts? A shotgun to the face will only stop 3 out of those 4 and personally I'm not ok with those odds.

[@atomicdreamz6035]

The idea that the ghost passes on after you hear her tale and see her fate is... Uplifting. It sounds awful to relive those moments forever. It's good that she finds peace

[@blobbertmcblob4888]

The swamp is beautiful during the day, terrifying at night and as someone who grew up down south US, I can tell you that Rockstar did a really good job of capturing how swamps are in real life.

[@Kova-ow2en]

Even though im also a southerner, more around Appalachian mountains, I had the fortune to visit some of these swamps back when the game came out and got to say it honestly was quite beautiful. The smell is definitely something I can’t forget

[@lisaashby1547]

I think it's strange how she died in September 1883, the same time that the Pleasance villagers were all killed. Maybe Agnes went on a mad rampage in that town before killing herself later. It's possible that's where her lover was from, or his new girl, and she took her revenge on the whole town before killing herself in remorse.

[@twistedyogert]

Seems pretty hard to kill an entire town without help.

[@editating_2614]

@@twistedyogert poison the water supply

[@SomeCrusader]

@@editating_2614 And that's why there are warnings of plague around the town... Well, I ain't sleeping tonight.

[@editating_2614]

@@SomeCrusader goodnight

[@issyd2366]

You can find Agnes' grave at the Shady Belle estate. She and her family were the ones who originally lived there. She fell in love with a young man and became pregnant with his child, but the relation went downwards as the man got cold feet when he became a father just except for what Agnes' parents thought about the whole story. Agnes' father and her boyfriend murdered each other when the father searched him up for claiming vengeance on him for having seduced her and then abandoning her and tried to kill him despite the fact that Agnes had forgiven him herself. Her father was killed himself and then she commited suicide due to the grief and remorse. The tombstone even says that she caused a lot of people's death.

[@lupev8437]

Logan Paul go there right away thinking : *Content, Yes!*

[@doky7174]

lmao

[@frend1220]

FOUND GHOST IN AMERICAN SUICIDE SWAMP (no clickbait)

[@pugachevskobra5636]

Lmfao

[@MissKittieMo]

The fact that you didn't take "He looks just like you" as the obvious YOUR SON LOOKS JUST LIKE YOU, is mind boggling. She clearly said she's been ruined, no one else will have her. Why wouldn't anyone else have a 19 yr old woman in that time? BECAUSE SHE'S NO LONGER A VIRGIN AND SHE'S SHOWING IT! Girls in that time (and of that status) could get away with sexual acts and claim virginity to the man they married, were they lucky. What they COULDN'T do is hide an obvious pregnancy. The hillbilly got her pregnant, her parents were likely pissed at the fact that he was not only poor, but was stepping out on his responsibilities to her and their unborn or born child. Not to mention, if the man expressed distaste for the child (clearly, since he was skipping out on the responsibility), then her obsessive love for him would have caused her to abandon or kill the baby FOR HIM, "I left him for you". Which would then explain the markings on her tombstone about how she took her life AND others. She wasn't talking to us until that last night.

[@javiercamacho4575]

I saw a comment suggesting that her “I love you” line was basically a thank you to John (the player) for letting her emotions out and moving on

[@madamebkrt]

YEP, this is the most accurate analysis thus far.

[@PhotriusPyrelus]

This is the correct interpretation. I was flabbergasted when he didn't put those obvious things together ("He looks just like you" and "I gave you everything I had ... no one will have me now."). Also, I think the "I love you" wasn't directed at the player at all, it was her last words in life. Listen to the voice, that's not relief or pleasure, that's anguish and distress. It's a completely different tenor to the immediately preceding lines when she addresses the player.

[@Kova-ow2en]

Nobody cares about virginity anymore 😂

[@papikika]

The ghost lady wasnt important. The toad being blown off with a sawed off shotgun is more important 2:30

[@madamebkrt]

Correction, Dickhead killing John is *the most* important.

[@coathanger2579]

Exactly

[@nemidoonam6963]

Thats connected to gavin im 100% sure

[@davesworld7688]

ADPhG Gamer Any info?

[@alexfergus7603]

She is Gavin

[@snaggiz]

Gavin was her lover lmao

[@53197654321]

Her lover was Curtis baines from the abandoned town of pleasance on his tomb stone says his love was taken away from him by hated

[@jackoblllllllll]

@@53197654321 doesnt much as if the seducer was in love with her, though the people who buried him may have thought so

[@devinmorris4330]

6:07 my wisdom tells me she talking to the alligator

[@0ofabrain575]

Saw that to

[@RandomMadnessChannel]

6:15 the lady is actually a 3 star American Alligator. Mystery solved.

[@calmate9417]

The gost's voice actress is amazing

[@Fabian6980]

I gotta get her to suck me off

[@howdymista2299]

@@Fabian6980 ahh a virgin

[@samueljay8519]

@@howdymista2299 Most likely a bitter incel as well but that's just speculation.

[@kreeping8308]

anyone notice that they misspelled ghost

[@ryanb01]

@@Fabian6980 wtf

[@Duckkis]

I actually saw the ghost just minutes ago, for the first time after hearing her voice on multiple occasions. Really creepy. The voice actor did a brilliant job.

[@Syndixal]

Im so happy that the qaulity of you're content keeps getting better fizhy

[@FuckdasketsHOPassass]

Up the RA

[@ethaneberly5511]

I think she had a kid with the guy and that’s why she said “he looks just like you” and “nobody else will take me now “

[@Kova-ow2en]

Oh, there was definitely enough white knights who would take her

[@MediumDSpeaks]

On my first playthrough of the game I steered clear of the Bayou like crazy at night because I knew of the ghost. One time I got caught out there at night and while wandering I started hearing her talking, while it was sometime in the mid-morning with everyone in my home asleep and my lights all off and have never moved so fast to gtfo of anywhere in my entire life. This may be fictional, but it is absolutely horrifying and I want NOTHING do to with it.

[@SomeCrusader]

It's definitely unnerving. Hearing my older bro walking around upstairs while I was watching this video made me paranoid as Hell.

[@Overpowered4500]

Herd a guy scream after the dad pulled the trigger

[@ggamez8371]

Underpowered Gaming. same I did 2

[@alexhazell8898]

At 8:20 you can hear a loud scream too, creeped me out

[@Kamesuko]

Yeah, at 4:59

[@bradcantrill6773]

heard not herd

[@UniverseGOD2525]

Those are fucking animals

[@muhammad7687]

me and the boahs lookin for ghosts at 3 am:

[@LilRipper76]

Dutch: Arthur, just have some god damn faith! she will appear put of nowhere Arthur and I have a plan to catch her!

[@samh3805]

I think the developers left the lady slipper orchid as a final nail in the coffin, just to confirm what happened to her, as it’s very common in Japan for people to take their shoes off and put a suicide note in them before ending their life.Thus, that’s why it’s a *Lady Slipper* Orchid.

[@AngryIcecube]

more likely, it's related to that fact that it is common for people who hang themselves to screw it up and rather than snapping their neck, instead manage to just dangle there, kicking and thrashing until they (finally) die, losing their shoes in the process. Seeing as how this game does not take place anywhere NEAR Japan, nor was it developed by a Japanese developer.

[@Uhhhhhhhhhhh309]

Dumb theory but maybe it’s because she wasn’t ready to do it yet but she slipped and she was a lady so it was called a lady slipper

[@twistedyogert]

@@AngryIcecube The opposite can be just as horrific. Sometimes if the drop is from too high the victim is decapitated.

[@Ash-gtr32]

​@@Uhhhhhhhhhhh309it's not dumb, people can have different interpretations.

[@GoldenNorway1]

The "she took her own life, and others" is probably not meant litterally. I guess she "took" other lives by comitting suicide. It fits with the movie show at Valentine Theatre as well.

[@ellbent]

All because she loved someone who didn’t love her

[@mrcaesar3123]

She could’ve been pregnant

[@KestralKuthule]

@@mrcaesar3123 I think she'd already given birth. "He looks just like you" sounds like something you'd say when describing a baby to their Dad. Other context clues give me the idea she got pregnant outside of marriage.

[@Kova-ow2en]

@@ellbent typically how life goes

[@Kova-ow2en]

@@KestralKuthule doesn’t most people? Oh time period was different

[@terminallumbago6465]

This voice actress did such an amazing job. I felt genuine sympathy and sorrow listening to the ghost’s story.

[@starroe30]

By that tree, near the river, you find like someone was buried there without a marker.

[@gagenelson4735]

I have never really felt bad for a video game character, but idk why this hit me so hard. Imagine getting fucked so hard your ghost haunts a swamp where basically no one will know. And no one will know your story.

[@saitojharry]

Damn September 1883 sure was bloody. Thought the"And Others" from Agnes Dowd's headstone meant the dead people from Pleasance. But when i watched the video again, she died on the 4th and the people of Pleasance were massacred on the 17th (based on some of the headstones).

[@chronovac]

I wish the bayou's in Louisiana were actually this interesting, all we got is mud, and snakes, and mud

[@DixieWhiskey]

But our bayous are also where you'll find a guy that quacks and throws marshmallows at the gators.

[@Neon-lt5jl]

You must not go out there at night

[@BeexDubb]

Reality is often dissapointing, this is rockstar giving in to all the san andreas mystery theories lul

[@dinolandra]

You got some delicious nutria too

[@badussy]

You should look for night crawlers

[@dragonorbminecraft]

Anyone kinda feel like on her final few encounters she actually seem to always be watching you? Like her head turns to you and not staring off in the distance

[@MongyBongy]

I want to talk about the gravestone from 1864 that says "he loved all men equally" I think we have a union veteran which is interesting

[@jamesanthony8438]

"You said... You said all those things..." - Ghost Lady in the swamp "That's just what we call Pillow Talk, baby." - Bruce Campbell, "Army of Darkness"

[@ConnorNotyerbidness]

HA wish i was clever enough to think of this comment

[@-austintacious-2400]

“He looks just like you” is referring to a child they had together

[@calluxr3242]

I think i heard a man screaming around 4:57 or 5:00 and another scream in 8:18

[@ggamez8371]

Same

[@Scoffslaphead72]

Nightfolk most likely

[@alexhernandez6305]

@@Scoffslaphead72 nightfolk dont make noises.

[@bajenbilly]

@@alexhernandez6305 nah but the people they kill probably do

[@RealWhore]

its 4:59 exactly. its probably someone getting clapped bu nighfolk. or the nightfolk as they do scream occasionally

[@papabray4703]

The most upsetting thing here is the betrayal of Dickhead

[@augustnoir2004]

The strategy guide confirms that she's Agnes Dowd

[@macawlover8251]

Here's my interpretation of events: Agnes fell in love with a man from a nearby rural town (Pleasance, Lagras, or possibly even Lakay, based on location). They had probably been seeing each other for a little while when Agnes' parents found out. They obviously disapproved of their daughter being involved with someone of significantly lower wealth than they were, and fought with Agnes to leave him. Agnes' mother is implied to have called him "Hillbilly white trash" (or something like that), Which you can hear Agnes say in one of her encounters. Despite their disapproval, the two continued to meet in secret under the tree that Agnes hung herself from (whether they had met there from the beginning, or only after Agnes' parents found out I don't know). The lovers continued to become more and more intimate until Agnes became pregnant. Agnes told the man this news one night during one of their secret meetings, and sensing he was in danger from the wrath of Agnes' father, or just not wanting to care a child, he broke up with her on the spot. Agnes' started to yell at him, filled with anger and sadness, saying things like "I gave everything to you", "You ruined me", and "Nobody else will have me now", implying that because she was very obviously not a virgin and still young, nobody else would want to date her. After an unknown amount of time she eventually forgave him, and would call out for him at their tree, which matches up with her dialogue at the beginning of the video. Either before or after she forgave him, Agnes gave birth to their son. After several nights of her lover not returning to their tree, Agnes either abandoned, or killed her newborn and set off to her lover's house. When she got there she told him about their son ("he looks just like you") and told him what she had done and that she forgave him ("I have always loved you"), only to find out that he was now involved with another woman. She their either out of anger, or an attempt to convince him to leave her, told him that the new woman never truly loved him like she did. At some point during this Agnes' father showed up, likely having followed Agnes. He was angry that this man had ruined his daughter for anyone else, and now their son (the only thing that would have been a positive from their relationship) was now gone. Agnes tried to calm her father down by telling him to put the gun down for his little girl. Her attempts were unsuccessful and her father shot her ex lover before dragging her back to Shady Belle. Then on September 4th, 1883 (could have been the same night as the previous events) Agnes broke down and murdered her parents before hanging herself from the meeting tree. She was likely talking to her ex lover's spirit before she committed suicide, her last words being "I love you" before she died. Her spirit was probably then trapped in a sort of purgatory until the player comes along, due to all of the unsorted emotions preventing it from fully 'passing on'. She likely notices the player whenever you encounter her, but doesn't acknowledge you until you see her for the last time. I'm not completely sure about how much sense this makes, but she was probably able to sort out her feelings by having someone whiteness her story (Kind of like ghost therapy I guess?). In the final encounter with her, she speaks to the player for the first time, letting us know she knew we were there the whole time, and in a way thanking us for listening by inviting us to watch her peacefully pass on, poetically repeating the words she said right before she died.

[@-Beidou-]

When she says "He looks just like you, I left him behind for you!" she's talking about a child. She was having an affair with married man and had a child by him. He promised to leave his wife, but ended up not. That's why she says "I gave you everything! No one will have me now!" That's because she can't be married with that kind of scandal. Otherwise I think her final statement she is talking to us.

[@benshapirosgreatuncle4060]

6:16 nothing like letting your feelings out with a carnivorous man eating reptile

[@xdraptor5296]

This is one of the reasons why I don't go through the swamp at night

[@mitchell1976]

When there's something strange and it don't look good who ya gonna call? Fizhy! I also like your theory!

[@laky934]

ghost busters

[@DogOfWar64]

Really good voice actor for the ghost. She sounds genuinely distressed and full of anguish.

[@chainos2519]

*John Marston Spends an entire month away in a swamp* Abigail: "John Marston, where have you been?" John: "I've been seeing another woman"

[@AverageAlien]

Literally no other game has such deep hidden details. An entire bloody story out of some hard to find, random Easter egg. Insane.

[@James-vm2cl]

Spooky ghost stuff then out of nowhere “if you shoot a toad with a shotgun it will explode” I love this channel

[@whitewolf152]

Whats really pathetic is…I watched this video, and then later on in the game I stubbled upon this on accident…and I still got scared.

[@krzi-o5619]

I love watching videos of RDR2 even still today , you never know what you might find that someone from other channels didn’t post. This isn’t one of them but still very interesting. It’s just awesome to think the people that put this game together just had a very deep imagination and seems like they put anything and everything in this game that crossed their minds. Anyway , even after one year this game is still awesome to me. Not sure what everyone else thinks about it but to me I still love playing the story mode.

[@keeva2007]

At 6:17 I just want to imagine shes talking to that gator.... Its obvious why her relation went south now

[@ottovonbismarck8460]

keeva2007 no pun intended? 😂

[@juno_the8774]

8:18 I love how you can hear Kieran getting tortured as you’re watching the ghost

[@brosb4hoes696969]

kinda disappointing cos your videos are so good and you don't reach at least 100k views. your stuff is underrated as hell man... defs got my subscription.

[@thepoet9253]

I feel as if perhaps instead her father had attempted to kill her lover finally and she had killed her father and mother in the spur of the moment in defense of her lover. Upon telling her lover, he revealed himself as a monster and left her, so she committed suicide. Possible also that she may have been pregnant and abandoned the child with her parent's corpses to start anew and finally feel that she was separate from their lineage.

[@wh1tehoes]

That “I know you’ve been watching me stranger” part caught me off guard and scared the shit out of me

[@colonialbred2219]

i love how at 6:24 the alligator is just chillin next to the ghost like this is completely normal

[@lsswappedcessna]

"In other news I learned if you shoot a toad with a sawnoff shotgun it'll explode." Yeah. I wonder why?

[@totalcreativegaming6681]

That truly is unsettling when the Ghost acknowledges the player. I’m not gonna lie, when you were walking up to her for the last time when she invites John or Arthur over… a part of me was expecting some type of jump scare where her ghost attacks you and kills John or Arthur in a single hit. But I’m glad that didn’t happen. But seeing a ghost reliving their suicide is both creepy and heartbreaking.

[@sorridusnakerru]

Fizhy, no wonder little kids love you. You put soooo much effort in your videos. And you always have free candy

[@universal_wisdom3416]

I really liked all the gravestone writs in RDR. The cemeteries from the west of the map are basically remastered but it’s rare to find new graves with unique writing on them.

[@cappademon7387]

I'm late to the video but when she says "for your own little girl" a man screams off in the distance.

[@erikallen3804]

Humorous timing. But I do believe it is NightFolk torturing someone.

[@Xehanort10]

John: Abigail I saw a ghost. Abigail: Arthur was right John. Those wolves did eat your brain.

[@jmc3971]

You've been making some great videos on RDRD2. Appreciate all the work!

[@xeno1632]

Red Dead Redemption Dead 2?

[@zombywoof864]

I think the weeping swamp lady is the night folk using the legend of this ghost to lure people in.

[@LeonardsParka]

Oddly enough I found the Shady Bell graves about a week ago but instead of running to camp interactions I actually walked over to read them. I had no idea about the ghost girl but still, the name Agnes Dowd stayed in my head. I don’t know why but something about her tombstone resonated with me. So, yeah, I was thinking about it her name the whole time before you brought her up.

[@elainejoavenido7235]

There was so much effort put into this video and it made me feel the proper chills! Kudos! The editing was topnotch as well!

[@trickymicky7177]

The piggyback guide states that the ghost is the ghost of Agnes Dowd

[@jake_does_nothing9231]

"But dickhead betrayed me so i moved away from dickhead'' Thats so funny that he named him dickhead cause that's what gators are in red dead redemption 2

[@Sploooks]

I remember when investigating this myself that I thoroughly shit myself during the last encounter

[@GR100K-x]

12:55 bro you're soo brave😨😨😨😱

[@ReSpark141]

john marston: Ghost Stalker

[@aapjeaaron]

13:30 it is absolutely worth mentioning as lady slipper orchids are typically only found in west Elizabeth. As it says in the description "This type of orchid can be seen growing in the grounds of the forests, meadows and woodland areas like the Big Valley and Tall Trees area of West Elizabeth." They don't grow in the swamp.

[@Maniax7517]

"in other news I learned if you shoot a toad with a sawn off shot gun it will explode" 😂😂😂

[@jackoblllllllll]

toad :D

[@erikallen3804]

Same thing happens in RDR1 if you try to kill a rabbit with a shotgun.

[@blockhustler214]

Love the channel ,started watching recently... the way you tell the stories but let the game speak for itself... got me playing red dead along with the videos so I can experience these things I never knew about first hand

[@georgewilkes02]

Also… she took her life… AND OTHERS… IN September 1883 just so happens to be the year that all the graves at Pleasance have the date of the PLEASANCE MASSACRE IN SEPTEMBER 1883

[@DHCNetwork06]

7:27 man that literary scared the hell of me.

[@thatlocalnerd8455]

I have personally seen her and got that creepie "come closer" dialogue on my second encounter it may be because I made her disappear a few times a little off topic I saw a ghost heron by the abandon swamp house behind shady belle hideout I wasn't seeing things I know for sure because it was glowing white and that reflected off the water as it flew away.

[@patrick17_6]

7:26 I shook in my chair ffs

[@allninelivez7631]

I thought I heard something when I passed through that area on my first playthrough. I went to investigate but no one was there. I assumed she got eaten by a crocodile. Knowing it was a ghost now. 😳 Trippy. Lol

[@peregrinplants]

She’s a weeping woman. Women who kill their children and then themselves. My guess is the lover got her pregnant, further making her parents disapprove. Then the lover abandoned them, making her go mad and kill her child ‘he looks just like you.’ And then herself

[@Firefox1189]

This gives me La Llarona vibes.

[@erikallen3804]

10:50 There’s actually an encounter where she is seen hanging from a tree. If you go close but not too close, she’ll say something along the lines of “Hello stranger, I know you’ve been watching me.”

[@thepoet9253]

I do believe this exact encounter is literally in the video.

[@erikallen3804]

Yes it is, I’m blind.

[@thepoet9253]

@@erikallen3804 Yes you are XD. It's all good man.

[@Theadam-1030]

Great video and wow that was honestly terrifying

[@Kova-ow2en]

When I played the last night clip, if that makes sense. I now think she was actually reading her suicide note, and not talking to the player. She was saying things like “come to **Our** Tree” instead of “Come to **The** tree). “Come meet me in the swamps by our tree.” Which sounds like she’s talking to someone who wasn’t in the swamp at the time. If she was talking to us, the player, why would she say that? We are already in the swamp and by said tree. Then in her last breath or sentence. She tells her boyfriend “I love you”. I think she was trying to make her “boyfriend” or whoever this guy was to go to the tree and see her hanging from it. Perhaps to make him suffer or see how much pain and misery she went through because of him. Her love drove her mad and made her take her life. I don’t know if this makes sense, but I’ve read another comment which at first I didn’t believe about this being a suicide letter, but looking back at what she says it makes sense. The “stranger” isn’t us, it’s the guy she thought she knew and loved. Someone who she became estranged and jaded to. If anyone reads this and wants to say something or understands what I’m even saying I’m interested in your interpretation

[@adnanrivera7795]

She was Gavin

[@ChuckyCheeses]

Plot twist: we are Gavin

[@akeneo1169]

Chucky Gaming plot twist: the plot twist is Gavin

[@jiggityjack8113]

Iplayvideogames Plot twist: Gavin is a godly figure

[@bigmuscleman4205]

Plot: gavin is the plot

[@YORK13LAD332]

GAAAAAAVVVIIIINNNNNN

[@erikallen3804]

When you list the night at the beginnings, it brings back FNaF flashbacks.

[@napoleonbonaparteempereurd4676]

Yup

[@skeletor4436]

Should have named the alligator gavin

[@damianmackie7612]

I think Agnes killed the town of pleasance and then hung herself because if you look at the pleasance graves the dates are September 1883

[@leonv.3810]

4:58 That scream confirms it to me that her boyfriend died.

[@lillygarrett7470]

when i did this i was Arthur, i had been gone for around 20-30 days. at like the 20ish day the gang sent out Javier to come looking for me and he said that dutch and the people of the camp were worried. i didn't expect it and thought it was a really nice touch. Also the reason it took so long (it was probably gone longer than 30 days) was because night folk and other things kept happening and she never appeared or spoke

[@TheDreamManifester]

Don’t even play this game, but this was a cool watch!

[@boolosboi7503]

TheDreamManifester I'd recommend it.

[@TheDreamManifester]

I bet! I’m willing to try it once it’s released on PC! Rockstar usually delays PC releases 6-12 months later.

[@TheDreamManifester]

Fizhy - The original was! So was GTAV, like half a year after it’s initial release. I would assume they would. 👀

[@Lentoron]

same

[@FeelFree2RateMyENG]

@@Fizhy *OOF!*

[@Ghoulstille]

You can get a better Angle on looking at her from across the river over the wooden bridge. She will still appear if she senses you from that side and you don't have to worry about alligators from there. And when she disappears she'll spook your horse , Same as the Ghost Train so be prepared.