FLAWLESS Carlist Spain Run - Every Single Click Carlist Spain Lets Play

EVERY SINGLE CLICK VIDEOS are like a classic unedited lets play on youtube so you can play along with me. Today I unify Iberia under the carlist. Flawless strat that works every single time!
Support me on PATREON / feedbackgaming
Sub to my MAIN KZbin: ‪@FeedbackGaming‬
Sub to my FEEDBACKIRL on KZbin: ‪@FeedbackIRL‬
Sub to MEMES channel: ‪@feedbackmemes‬
Sub for SHORTS: ‪@feedbackshorts3731‬
DISCORD talk with me / discord
Follow on TWITTER: / feedbackgaming
Follow for TWITCH livestreams: / feedbackgaming
Business email: [e-mail]
Hearts of Iron IV is a grand strategy wargame developed by Paradox Development Studio and published by Paradox Interactive. Released on June 6, 2016, it is the sequel to Hearts of Iron III and part of the Hearts of Iron series of grand strategy games focusing on World War II. The player may take control of any nation in the world in either 1936 or 1939 and lead them to victory or defeat against other countries.
Feedbackgaming is known for his exploits, cheats, unlimited money videos. Is inspired by other successful influencers like the spiffing brit, isp, bokoen and tommykaylive.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Business email: [e-mail]
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
#hoi4 #carlist #spain

[@Legohunter-uv1wc]

40:00 “dios, patria y rey” means god, fatherland, king, and is also similar to the name of a monarchist song in Portuguese.

[@draxthylocalrespectorofanime]

@Orb_ its Cristo. Franco is a Catholic and its a Catholic/Christian who speaks spanish saying (Long Live Christ The King )

[@yt_tenshi]

Deus patria rei

[@tellom.8375]

"por dios por la patria y el rey our fathers fought?" we have this too in spain is a carlist thing

[@gocool_2.0]

This is the best type of videos. Hope we get more such type videos. Also I was looking for a carlist Spain guide. So it's a two in one combo.

[@wizardofloth]

It's a nice guide but by the time you get up and running you're far behind anyone and can't do any achievements.

[@some_gh0st]

I remember when you speed ran the civil war to prove it could be done. The legend

[@Prauwlet213]

thanks for this. I really want to play the Carlists and the Anarchists, but I keep forgetting about the mechanics and end up with a ton of missed bonuses and land lol

[@joesmoe6454]

I always end up making the Nationalists too strong so when I switch Carlist, they just rush me and kill me

[@jimtalbott9535]

So much of this is great advice, applicable to many HOI4 games. It would also be cool to see this sort of video for Kaiserreich>Qing>Manchu Restoration

[@jasonjohnson1824]

You were able to see this early if you are in his discord!!!!

[@enzymcs2992]

oh ok

[@cuttedarky2969]

oh ok

[@charley2714]

oh ok

[@Munin_Artthanaporn]

oh ok

[@karl5599]

Oh ok

[@joepgoudswaard4751]

I always take eastern aragon and barcelona before the war so the anarchists spawn on a random place. this way you can just walk in

[@thomasfranz6467]

"Dios, Patria y Rey" sounds a lot like "God, Fatherland and King" to me.

[@puglia5138]

Yes, the translate is the same. But Rey is the same as king

[@davidbascom5781]

There is a carlist exploit you can do that makes this even easier. If you win as the nationalists before the carlist uprising, the restrictions on your troops don't exist anymore, bc the game still sees you as tlin the civil war. So unlike at the start of the game when you can't delete or edit troops, you can cheese it like a normal civil war, and switch all your divisions to artillery

[@mertk_b]

How do you win as the nationalists before the carlist uprising without cheat

[@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692]

How would that even work, though? Your divisions like requetes, guardia civil etc don't get dissolved until the civil war is over properly. And there are no new ones created, or are there (through contact union militar espanol, maybe?), so even if it DOES allow you to edit I don't see how that works...

[@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692]

@@mertk_b Easily? Carlist uprising doesn't happen until about very late 37 or even 1938. Before I knew that you could switch to Fascism with the primo de riveira speech spam, that's how I got this achievement. I defeated the Republicans & Anarchists in very early 1937, and rushed for the focus with the France WG, but I waited for Germany to attack Poland so the UK wouldn't send them any troops. I had MONTHS inbetween having to fight the Nationalist/Fascist side and my Carlist side civil war. I also had to build two heavy tank divisions (infantry with 4 heavy tank batallions) to be able to break through, and exploit the breakthrough with a big motorized division and some cavalry. But this was ages ago, before they reworked the game with how you make tanks and the only upgrades you could do was the XP ones where you could upgrade gun, armor, engine and reliability via the + and - buttons.

[@JohnPGarrett]

Carlist Spain used to be my biggest struggle, then I did it and had so much fun! But then... NSB was released, and all of a sudden I couldn't win again. Thanks to your tutorial I've found myself able to beat it again!

[@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692]

It used to be easier before NSB. You could simply draw fall back lines on several of the important cities where you couldn't get full control with the garrison shit, and grab them that way from the get go.

[@ancaoraathasach]

Uncanny. I was just thinking today that I was hoping someone would do Carlist Spain. I need the One King, Two Crowns achievement.

[@ilikewatermelonz4959]

Thank you Dave, for showing me how to do this part of the left focus tree. Really appreciated

[@LuziFearon]

Thanks, just did 'One King, Two Cronws'! Your guide for the beginning stages of the civil war was basicly essential for me!

[@TheoHawk316]

The right-wing focus being on the left reminds me of Doc saying in Cars, "Turn right to go left!" (he was talking about drifting btw)

[@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692]

I never watched cars, but that's not how it works. Yes, a HARD countersteer before going where you wanna go helps the car turn in better. It works both for taking corners faster than you otherwise can, and it also helps whip the car around harder if you want to induce a drift. It comes from Rallying and we call it "Scandinavian flick" (technically Finnish, but whatever). So yeah, if you got a left hand corner you wanna take fast, just jerk the wheel briefly to the right and THEN turn the car in to the left. This helps with the weight transfer on the tyres, etc.

[@tonyravioli1982]

@@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692 It also helps with trailers. Coming from someone who worked in the landscaping field. Trailers just do the fucking opposite of what you do, which is really annyoing. Also fuck the youtube mods.

[@154Kilroy]

Grand battle plan probably would have been the better choice for this playthrough. It's better for infantry, and if you wait this long to attack, the planning bonuses are really good to have.

[@Stouzough]

Appreciate a lot these complete videos with each and every interaction. I'm "advanced" level in hoi4 but still we always learn something with your videos, please continue. Looking at your next challenge with France now

[@bravoxray1280]

Funny. “Advanced” is how I rate myself. I know what I’m doing. I just don’t win much.

[@Stouzough]

@@bravoxray1280 ... or you win, but could have been more efficient had you considered other options: that's what I'm looking for here

[@ben9583_]

Personally I find the best thing to do to end the civil war early as the nationalists is garrisoning your divisions on the southern cities like Sevilla and Valencia. That reduces the surrender limit of the republicans substantially. Then naval invade with AoA to Barcelona and use the war in the north focus to quickly wrap up the north. Garrisoning the south you'll have a ton of encircled troops but the AI will try and staff those frontlines and when you win the north you move all your troops south and mop things up. Usually gets things done in Jan 1937 a few months before the crackdown. I don't really care about securing carlist garrisons for the crackdown cause you start with the same amount of troops anyway and if the crackdown happens after you beat the republicans, it's a free victory no matter what, even if you just have one state cause you have so many more troops than the nationalists. One interesting exploit I've noticed is that if you end up at war with the anarchists, everyone really likes you and you can get really good "strategic interests" diplomacy boosts with everyone. It even lasts after the civil war until you reload the game, so late game you can just invite random countries like saudi arabia and brazil to your faction with tension/improve relations/spy diplo boost. Not sure if this still works in the latest version though.

[@martinguerra5152]

I'll try that last thing you said. I remember am exploit where as carlist you could get military acces with all nations. order 66 everywhere!

[@baderul1]

This is so perfect, i have strugled with teh Spanish War for so loong and every video out there is to hard to follow, but yours man. Perfect

[@F2MF2M]

did everything this guide said, failed first time because i didnt click limited conscription. second time was the charm. finished civil war and waited for germany to eat france. waited for germans to declare on soviets and declared on vichy which had a german guarantee. held my position for about 6 months and eliminated 4 italian incursions into my territory. uk divided italy into whatever the hell and started pushing. destroyed germany with only 4 generals of 24 divisions. 9 inf 1 arty supports arty air and shovels. also formed iberia (with portugal) and cored every territory (you will need the manpower if you wanna push germany+vichy+italy+all the other psychos). thanks mate. i wish you would do guides like this. every other guide was luck/too complicated

[@marados3270]

Dios, patria y rey means God, fatherland and king. It's the first verse of the Carlist anthem Marcha de Oriamendi.

[@JacekUW]

I would love to see this continued!!! PLEASE!

[@Alberld]

40:00 "God, fatherland, King"

[@maizy_th3dog]

I watched this yesterday, I think it was unlisted, but i found it in a playlist.

[@-w-6323]

I nearly got a seizure when be didn't take the Portugal fleet

[@elitetripod4188]

One tip that I found makes carlist spain a breeze: When your uprising starts make sure that you secured some territory in sevilla and cordoba for nationalist spain. That way the republicans and fascists will commit divisions down there instead of on your border and you can actually gobble up a fair amount of land at the start. My last playthrough I was basically on the door of Madrid before they manage to organise a frontline to fight back.

[@tasoslotet271]

1st try for carlist civil war (ever) with the 20 mins of your video wisdom I finished the civil war on the 1st May 1938. (15 division left) thanks for the guidance :D had a little proble when the carlist came to power. facists had a little more territory for some reason and they got too much help from germany and italy.

[@diegonayahernandez6801]

god, country and king is the name of the focus

[@amerikarhineland3185]

Ah hoi4 my beloved, really need to play it again Nice vid, i wonder what exploits are still hidden in the Clausewitz spaghetti code

[@STOPTIMMERTIME]

these videos have helped me out so much. I'm almost feeling solid enough to jump into mp games as a smaller nation now/be an air controller

[@Bluesonofman]

With Superior firepower you have to go airland even if you are not using an air force as you get that hard attack buff.

[@nojobnl]

I thought that hard attack was only useful when u go up against divisions with more hardness, and that ai doesn't make divisions with a lot of hardness and therefor useless in singleplayer. Could u explain why u should go for the hard attack instead of the more soft attack that shock & awe gives u?

[@Bluesonofman]

@@nojobnl Because I never really build tanks and I need something that can punch through tanks. The only time I build tanks is like in Red world

[@Bluesonofman]

@@nojobnl I build two units. 20 Widths to fill the Lines and 27 Widths for a few elite Units to aid in pushing. I have 20 Width Motorized for when I have wiped out enough with encirclements and can just field martial attack

[@nojobnl]

@@Bluesonofman When u go airland I think cus u dont use tanks u only get little bit more hard attack since u still get hard attack in shock in awe (with the last tech) but just a little bit less if u use for ur support compagnies and I think u should do shock and awe unless u are struggling with getting air superiority.

[@Bluesonofman]

@@nojobnl I find that Supply is more important then Air superiority. There are times where I have Air superiority but if I don’t build supply hubs I can’t push.

[@sahilhossian8212]

Lore of FLAWLESS Carlist Spain Run Momentum 100

[@Brabantian]

23:00 for some reason the fact that the top of the border with the anarchists isn’t part of the frontline is really pissing me off xD

[@mikeha]

I like these videos that show everything, that you can follow along with. It seems like once you figure out a strategy for a certain country it will work the same way every time in single player, so really HOI IV can be a game of figuring out the correct strategy that works for each country. Once you have solved one country, you can play another one and figure that one out

[@sahilhossian8212]

Hmm yes one king four crowns challenge momentum 100

[@VivBrodock]

funny thing that can be done: If Portugal goes Estado Novo and Spain goes Carlist, then after they do the union as Bourbon France you can unite with them and gain cores on Spain & it's Colonies, Portugal & it's Territories, and Brazil you can also for the EU beforehand and have cores on Italy, Germany, and the Benelux

[@fidoruh]

I love these kinds of videos. And look forward to many more of them.

[@PheonixHunter]

How convenient, I got done perfecting my SCW strategy and Dave shows me ways I can optimize it :)

[@ancaoraathasach]

Really nice video. Easy to follow along with and leaves you in a great position.

[@memazov6601]

Tips though Take Catalonia so Anarchist will rise up in the south and it would cause alot of chaos trust me

[@ZenexTheZealous]

God, Fatherland and King!

[@charlessmith9903]

Would love to see a video where you rebuild the Spanish Empire.

[@thehooligan0824]

Thank you Dave, I missed these

[@BozofOz]

I love that the popping helmets have been replaced by tiny like buttons 😁

[@tristanasbreuk8137]

There are also those videos where you have 10 episodes with an avery timespan of 1 hour per video One played the netherlands and joined the war after his 3rd 1-hour long video

[@Gharib_570]

We need you here dave . Do not be so late

[@FeedbackGaming]

I'm never late

[@simplymatt6140]

I'd like to see a guide for one of the bulkan countries where the focus trees are a bit fiddley like Yugo or Bulgaria

[@Kaiservondonau]

Bulkan 💀

[@Shadowguy456234]

How did you read my mind, that this is exactly what I've been struggling with lately.

[@GlassOfWater001]

40:01 : I am half-Spanish and: “Dios, Patria y Rey” translates to “God, Fatherland and King”. :) Edit: I see people have already answered this, sorry

[@Gamerpro-ef5ut]

40:00 God, homeland and king

[@rahmi.2934]

New lesson

[@juanespin5527]

Mucha gracias

[@frankunderbush]

GO RIGHT...I MEAN LEFT

[@danielli6400]

Iberia united looks so cool! I hope they don't lose in the World cup to their occupied territories anytime soon

[@berkbozlov5036]

For example if Portugal united with Brazil and Spain is going to annex that is Brazil going to core of Spain to and for example if this happen and we are using Alfonso and bourbon france with united Iberia it can be France get a lot of core isn't it?

[@aidenbooksmith2351]

Look up Hatless Spider's One King Four Crowns achievement. It is precisely that.

[@hadikabbout2649]

This is solid, my only suggestion is to position your original army near bilbao so you can attack it with 8/10 divisions while the modifiers are not active yet. Also i would try to steal Barcelona from the republicans with decisions, it will save you from exterminating the guerillas there and will push the anarchists further into the republican territory. Meaning more chaos in their lines. Hence a better chance for you to kill them before the anarchists die.

[@deadpan904]

Ah, my favorite Spanish general, Jose Sancho

[@V1ZI.]

I actually managed to finish on November 2nd , great video.

[@chodiloo]

"If you go hard enough left, you will find yourself turning to the right"

[@emiloster2454]

Christmas has come early!!! ☃️

[@mistertwo6113]

99.4 - .4? LOL I love your every click videos. Thank you!

[@imigi2850]

I played as Bourbon France once and single handedly won the Carlists their civil war.

[@calciumboy406]

“Always use shortcuts” dosent press enter to select a research and dosent press escape to go into national focuses

[@N1ght_Breaker]

To be fair though, even if it was live when people were watching it, you could still rewind it anyway. Watching something live doesn't prevent that, you just can't go beyond the current point if it's still live (although if the person who was live has already finished the stream then that restriction is removed)

[@TexanNative]

28:23 when you take this focus to remove state autonomy, will it remove the other autonomous states autonomy when you control them later, or only Galicias?

[@TFPSindh]

It removes all of them but you have to control the state when you do the focus for it apply. I made the mistake on my first playthrough and Catalonia and the Basque Country kept the debuff because they were held by the anarchist.

[@TexanNative]

@@TFPSindh sounds like that’s unintended by paradox, just like if a foreign nation annexes Spain, they leave those states as autonomous, even when those nations become independent, they still keep the debuff.

[@robland3253]

Should have set France to monarchist burbon?? Then you can annex them if you have Alphonso without firing a shot

[@omegawonton8749]

and then from here, you can invade the allies, join the axis, take that opportunity to eat vichy france, then backstab germany when they go for barbarossa

[@bobthebob4300]

Thanks for this guide!

[@noahcrowley2954]

this video made me realise how much i suck at this game

[@Luis_Manuel_Suarez]

39:57 GOD, HOMELAND AND KING!

[@Prauwlet213]

3:18 horseshoe theory in a nutshell

[@TheStarlightOfDawn]

God, land and king!; Dios, patria y rey!

[@joanpereveroalgeciras3618]

Dios, patria y rey. Means: God, homeland and the king. Big fan of how you pronunce Valladolid ajajaj 😁

[@C.A._Old]

*totaly awesome.*

[@g1camuschy]

"Dios, Patria y Rey!" means "God, Motherland and King".

[@Mustang-wt1se]

Picking every focus other than the research slot triggers me lol

[@wallybonejengles5595]

I finally pulled off a SCW win as the Carlists last night. Tried to go for France and got snubbed by Germany. I'm now gonna try my best to land in UK and grind enough warscore to get France, get the acheivment. And then I can go back to playing my one true love the Anarchists .

[@ravager.r.8276]

"to go right you must go left" Cosas españolas no lo entenderías ;)

[@paso_oyun]

3 minutes? I am really lucky.

[@Emel_unlegit]

One thing I wanna say, hold on to vallaladoid, it's a major supply hub, I Can see you struggling with supply in the beginning

[@danieliglesias9553]

Dios, patria y rey = God, country and king

[@iseeyou5061]

26:07 Is it so OP if you have to play Spain first to get it?

[@tonyravioli1982]

in multiplayer? Yes.

[@SoldierGeneral64]

I think you can avoid having to core if you kept state during initial pre civil war back and forth. So if one is fascist and avoids carlist uprising it works quite well.

[@AlejandroP123]

40:00 God, Fatherland (kinda) and King.

[@Corium1]

has anyone notice how a lot of countries that started with planes before BBA now don't start with them? Despite the fact they have planes already and some like Spain for example, have airanotic industries well established?

[@tutku1560]

I am not sure that I remember correctly, if you push Barcelona somehow, it breaks Anarchist spawn locations in historical game. Also, if I am correct, volunteers stay with the side who has Spain's original tag. So, if you confirm volunteers, they might stay with you.

[@dryhad9253]

I believe volunteers will be sent home when the Falangists rise up. Either way, they won't "stay" with the Falangists and in any case the Falangist AI will gladly accept Axis volunteers by itself so I don't think there's any reason not to accept them.

[@tutku1560]

@@dryhad9253 As I said, I am not sure. However, I recently saw a game that I played not much ago, volunteers first stayed with carlist spain, then after they collapsed, axis sent volunteers falangist spain.

[@kurtaerts1630]

i just did a anarchists playtrough and the soviets stayed with the comunists

[@sergioinnit]

36:54 that's what she said

[@nickmaster3886]

I want a video wholly in 1 bar speed

[@ErikaTheLeopard]

39:55 god, fatherland/motherland and king

[@supercellodude]

I have a suggestion for continuing this run: build up the navy and air force for reconquering the empire from the American sphere

[@guncolony]

I can't believe you didn't set all 3 research slots to garbage ahead of time stuff before the civil war so that the other factions never get tech.

[@youtubemodsaresnowflakelef7692]

One thing I hate about the lead up to the civil war is that the AI essentially cheats with the garrison influencing mini game. They keep spamming the decisions that cost 30 PP (like arrest primo de riveira, reassign disloyal general, concessions to the left, etc) AND they keep challenging you even where it's expensive (like when you have only one tick it's reverse expensive for them as if they challenge up north where you start with 3 ticks once you do the focus... ie where you pay 10 for one tick they pay 30 to remove that one tick). Yet they get FAR less PP from their own focus tree...

[@Lords1997]

Did someone say shortcuts!? I recommend hitting up Arumba, this guy is shortcut king lmao. Thanks for the great content as always btw

[@154Kilroy]

39:06 This is why I never play Spain with the vanilla tree. Going through all that to win the war, then having half your country de-core just sucks. It doesn't feel like something should happen when you win.

[@robbery-lu9fp]

my experience when turning carlist is that nationalist spain accept the volunteers requests

[@rosbin56]

Dios - God, Patria - Fatherland , Rey - King, i think

[@LeoSpaceman69]

Any update yet? This was so cool

[@BUHU-tl1zj]

The new DLC makes it even more annoying. You start with less divisions, you need an insane world tension to request lendleases etc...

[@slip6699]

Thank you

[@chemputer]

It might be worthwhile if you do another one like this to use a keystroke visualizer, so people can see what keys you're pressing when. Carnac is a good one, open source, free.

[@alonsolm6033]

God, our country and king. the focus.