Fnirsi LCR P1 Transistor Tester | New LCR Meter Components Tester Review

[@Tech-Relief]

It tested the LCR-P1 and it is really bad. It seems similar to the TC1 component tester but it is no way near as good. It cannot recognize Schottky Diodes it thinks they are resistors. It can't recognize Thyristors, dual diodes in to220 packages. And the capacitance and ESR is also inaccurate. And it is much slower than my TC1. I emailed FNIRSI several times but they won't respond. Stay away from it.

[@cesitli5615]

Hi sir Can you suggest me another measuring device?

[@Tech-Relief]

@@cesitli5615 If you can afford it get an Atlas DCA75 Pro but it only does semi-conductors otherwise the old TC1 Component tester is better. I just ordered a TC3 Component Tester and will do a video on it on my channel when I receive it.

[@jarokowalski3355]

Dzięki Stary !

[@brouwereric644]

For general component identification and testing at a 3600MW, 6 generator power station and it's electronic modules, this device is great for fault finding on 1975-era Siemens, Brown Bovery, Alsthom, Measuretronic, Ultrakust, Semicron, Hartman & Brown, GE, Multilin, ASEA, BBT, ABB, Credfield etc. cards. Yes, it is not the best, but beats the crap out of most other test instruments. This unit should be seen as a helpful tool, instead of a high-accuracy, calibrated highly expensive test rig like the PinPoint Sigma or similar test units.

[@ДмитрийДемидов-м2у]

Could you install a diode or zener diode with a cathode from the right. Will the polarity of the electronic component on the screen correctly display? Also with transistors.

[@ivolol]

What method are you using to verify that the measurements are accurate?

[@WAElectronics]

@ivolol if component damaged like short or open, this device not show you it's parameters.

[@Rafa-xl4uf]

@@WAElectronics So how do you know that the device is precise and perfect?

[@marcocaprino1032]

Try to put a resistence series cap and check if calcolate right ESR

[@scottfoulk7480]

How about a price range and proof of accuracy? It's just like a "Gee, this sure is swell" advertisement. It makes me think this was compensated for by the manufacturer.

[@modomaker852]

​@@Rafa-xl4ufsi no obtienes lecturas entonces el componente está fallado, es así de simple! No hay más. Así funciona cualquier probador de componentes. No esperes que te diga la falla porque eso no existe.

[@ManOleg38]

Is it based on m5stack module?

[@abelzavala1303]

Good tester I think…how will be that price?

[@ADHIRAJEDM]

have you tested rds of mosfet does it shows perfect or it has some bugs in software like fnirsi dso tc3. i had 1 dso tc3 rds on according to datasheet is 2.4 ohms and dso tc3 shows 0.4 ohms to 0.5 ohms this meter also had same problem.

[@Yesid_jrh]

Can you measure ESR of Tantalum capacitors?

[@olegi.4681]

А что за подставку вы используете? И хотелось бы увидеть внутренности прибора :)

[@radekb9479]

A jak sobie ta "maszyna" radzi z odczytem tranzystorów IGBT? Bo wiem że w pierwszych urządzeniach tego typu jest problem i nie potrafią ich poprawnie odczytać.

[@les12001]

What Is ir-decoding?

[@heinztimmer5453]

Ir - decoding is finding out which codes/pattern an ir-remote e.g. for your TV produces when pressing a button.

[@stephenlafferty7327]

I really enjoy watching all your videos, is there somewhere I can buy the circuit boards and components all in a kit ready to solder together

[@WAElectronics]

@@stephenlafferty7327 in which project you are interested..

[@stephenlafferty7327]

@@WAElectronics is being a few interesting projects that I've seen on KZbin, and I just wondered if you get them in like Kit form where you can buy the printed circuit and all the components as one

[@treadmillrepair754]

Hi, someone knows if these meters can test IGBT's transistors? Thanks in Advance.

[@SokeElektronikKartTamiri]

[@savvy6826]

IGBT?

[@treadmillrepair754]

I want to know the same.

[@EasyOne]

nice

[@WAElectronics]

Thanks

[@sarcomakaposi2054]

I don't think so. This is not how you test a TESTER. You have to test against leaky and faulty components. No one needs a device that states the obvious. Unless you are blind and can not find this information yourself. I've been wanting a device that can actually run diagnostics on a component using simulated workload and use its datasheet to compare parameters to give me an actual result. This thing is a toy, no serious technician would use professionally. That blue led diode is 3 volts, 20mA that reading was wrong.

[@modomaker852]

Pero el título dice claramente "revisión" y no "prueba". La revisión es justamente lo que hizo, mostrar como viene empaquetado, que accesorios trae, como se ve de aspecto en cuanto al peso dimensiones y demás. Estás confundido, el vídeo cumplió con su propósito, tu estás buscando otro tipo de video.

[@studioborosoft3973]

Good looking product, but the functionality of the whole device is not good. During the tests, I discovered errors in the firmware and although I have asked the company several times to fix the firmware, so far without success. The product does not measure very well and has no setting menu. For example, when measuring diodes, he is unable to correctly mark the cathode and anode. And that's just a small detail. I do not recommend the product, you will be disappointed.

[@hirnspender]

no ESR reading?

[@WAElectronics]

Sure in Next Video

[@uni-byte]

You can clearly see the ESR results on teh screen as he tests capacitors. At least I can, and I'm legally blind in one eye.

[@PeterMüller-s4s]

@@uni-byte Guess why

[@jbravovideos]

Why playing music with your video????

[@rafalg.6901]

Most important question - Is it any way better, than previous model TC-1, which failed to test IGBTs, because voltage was too small to open the gates ? To be honest it is a biggest concern for me, I am looking for tester able to do this, and I hope, that Fnirsi had made some research this time and improved faulty functions of previous model, plus added some new abilities. I hope, that they cooperated with a team of electronics to make this time a really good product, and that they didn't just paid a designer to put 5$ worth old circuit into a nice, new enclosure. Otherwise this thing is a total waste of money and i am definitely NOT going to buy it, especialy when they threw out oscilloscope from it and when i have seen how shitty is the new Geiger counter made by Fnirsi! Seriously - I liked old stuff, but now i am close of starting to hate this company for they new politics!!

[@AndreyAkTis]

FNIRSI DSO TS3 and TS2 do not measure ESR correctly or do not know how to measure it at all! Fnirsi LCR P1 - Does it know how to measure ESR and does it measure correctly?

[@KKOOEERR]

新玩具

[@LawpickingLocksmith]

Pity for the horrible music and p l e a s e NO more unboxing time wasting!

[@uni-byte]

Maybe you should have sent him your favorite music pieces to choose from before hand? It's strange, but for most technical content creators unboxing and mailbag videos are amongst their most popular. It seems you might be in the minority, so of course he should listen to you. One other observation if I may. It seems he has acquired 20 times as many subs as you in half as many videos. Maybe you could do yourself a favour and take some lessons from what he is doing rather than criticize someone with obviously better video making skills. Just a thought.

[@LawpickingLocksmith]

@@uni-byte of course, just make AI unbxing UR Christiano sh*t as there are way too many clean fans...

[@uni-byte]

@@LawpickingLocksmith Well, that was unhinged. Care to translate? BTW I'm atheist, so don't where the religious reference comes in - unless it's to your own pitiful gospel videos.

[@robertfrancisgomes7031]

Not a complete review

[@Schraubfreak]

This tool is absolutely garbage. It looks nice, but that's it. At first you have to compare with the cheap testing tools for not even the half of price from it.