Vigil held for woman burned to death on NYC subway

[@kennethrosario6706]

Doesn’t matter if she was homeless! Nobody deserves this

[@Jim-q6w]

Exactly. Alot of sick people out there.

[@notmebutyou8350]

You're absolutely right. That was demonic what he did to her.

[@CatMowpurr]

@@notmebutyou8350 what? just light a cigarette near her? wasn't his fault she went up in flames, she should have worn something less flammable and not sat in alcohol pools

[@shamithemisunderstoodpussy6681]

​@@CatMowpurr lol you actually believe his defense? Lmfao

[@apv5774]

It kinda should. How many Americans are bashing on the homeless, and even now, they are complaining that homeless are getting help only to suddenly grow wings and are now sad over this victim

[@jeanellreynolds7291]

This case brought me to tears. She was already suffering, she was homeless. 😢

[@derekjeter3654]

How do you know she was homeless?

[@maddscientist3170]

@@derekjeter3654because they said she was

[@jeanellreynolds7291]

@ I live in NY and the news just said she was homeless. They still haven’t released her identity though.

[@zoeking95]

This city is soulless

[@jeanellreynolds7291]

@ exactly 🫤

[@vivianaknight3750]

All while the idiot governor was boasting about “subway safety”… 🤡🤦🏻‍♀️

[@JeanetteFaith]

She and DA Bragg are disgusting!!!

[@BarbKramer-d7f]

They lie. Here in Denver/Aurora the governor and mayor denied we have a gang problem. Within the past 2 months about 15 gang members have been arrested for murder, kidnapping and torture, smash grab burglary and sexual assault on a minor. The newspaper suppressed it all for at least a month.

[@KevinSun242]

While she has a security detail of several armed state troopers after signing legislation that bars any other citizen from carrying onboard public transit.

[@jason-s8c]

@@vivianaknight3750 yo u got a boyfriend?

[@toadfrench7801]

I bet her armed security detail was with her the entire time.

[@allthingsharbor]

I am grateful someone has taken the time to publicly pray for her and acknowledge the horror she endured.

[@senaitgebru2310]

❤🙏🏽

[@georgeplagianos6487]

There's a media grabbers if they announce this prayer 1000s will come. I'm out here trying to help 3 homeless who sleeping in the subways on 86th Street 4th avenue the R train in Brooklyn. One woman named Loida tells us she's been raped last Friday. These people homeless or not who doze off for sleeping are so vulnerable and our clergy just been down and pray. God put hands and feet in a brain in our. Nothing just pray but to do good for other people help the homeless not become vulnerable or taking them in your churches. The way they were taught to do back in the eighties and nineties but the partnership for the homeless I volunteered in the 80 and 90s and the situation is worse now than before. Crazy people with their documentary or not are threatening the poor. I know I have that happening to me now. The churches have to wake up. Take these poor people into your churches like I have taken him into my home 6 during the pandemic. Now I've been made permanently crippled by one of of their friends that I've took in. Got no help from our politicians. Here in Bay Ridge not by Justin Brandon's staff or Andrew Gounadis office. They don't care about the homeless they're all over Bay Ridge. I try to a few but I can't keep doing it alone with our any help.. please get involved in your community help them . TY

[@yapandasoftware]

NOT ONE PERSON STOPPED TO HELP HER. NOW THEY WANT TO HONOR HER? THIS IS PATHETIC.

[@annalewis3356]

@@yapandasoftware There was a subway picture of a NYPD policeman walking pass her this needs attention because he needs to be charged! am so angry.

[@franktoledo6342]

NYC except illegals being a santuary city is also to blame. The White House policies never helped.

[@LovieBrown-hy7dq]

The agonizing pain that poor poor woman suffered. My heart hurts so bad for her.😢😢 That dam evil monster!! 😡😡

[@barbaramelville337]

😢😢😢😢😢😢😢so 😢 I pray 🙏🙏 this is horrific 😢😢😢😢

[@فيالفي-ج2ش]

😞

[@Christobanistan]

Dude claims he was drunk and doesn't even remember doing it. Liar. Hope he enjoys life in prison w/o parole.

[@wendyadams3557]

He is probably telling the truth, drinking is evil

[@evoz4489]

There is a video floating around of him taking a vid of himself just moments before he committed the crime, complaining that he will do whatever he wants with his alcohol and f*** everyone who has a problem with him being here. He's obviously drunk in it. Of course people have a problem with him being here...he's ILLEGAL, mooching off our country living in a men's substance abuse shelter and has absolutely no direction in life. He chose the most defenseless person he could find. I know this would never happen in the US, but maybe people wouldn't do this crap if the consequence was the same thing they did to the other person.

[@_invinciScribe_24]

Fr 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@jameshill8493]

@@wendyadams3557nah bro. You dont just get drunk and light someone on fire and watch them burn, unless you already had that darkness in you

[@rogeramezquita5685]

he was drunk there is video of him messed up drunk

[@PaulMason-b9f]

This was a planned attacked. This dude knew exactly what he was doing, he is not stupid, he knows that we are stupid enough to believe his drunk story. He is a terrorist and that was terrorism. There's no telling how many people this man has killed in this country.

[@CatMowpurr]

It wasn't an attack at all. She wore flammable clothing and sat in alcohol. He was lighting a cigarette. She accidentally got caught on fire. That's why he can't remember such a mundane thing. Normal people don't just burn. Did he throw fuel on her? No. So he should be acquitted. No intent to cause harm.

[@waterhorse-r6p]

​@@CatMowpurr trolling used to be believable

[@shvsing-tb9ym]

@@CatMowpurr Is this the truth, did you see something!

[@Andreya_C]

@@CatMowpurr you’re sick!

[@briantbmoth6472]

Exactly. He’s a psychopath.

[@somemorre]

If they can't identify her then why don't release a picture of her face so the public can identify her? I'm sure a subway camera somewhere has her face on it.

[@RodneyMunch117]

Because they can’t admit that the victim was black. Gonna be a real mess when it comes out. Especially after the Penny trial.

[@krishjaya-mx1od]

They are trying to bury this

[@chrisramos1525]

There is a picture of her on social media , she is a white woman .

[@pikespeak8669]

Maybe her face was burned too😢😢😢😢 Nobody stepped in to safe her? They ould have removed jacket's,🧥 place over her😢😢😢😢 Thx joe and 🐫 😮

[@TropicoDreams]

​@@pikespeak8669Dental records identified her like 2 days ago.

[@briantbmoth6472]

No one deserves to die like this. I’m glad there was a memorial acknowledgment of her. I just wonder whom she was. Tragic. RIP lady.

[@kennethrosario6706]

Amelia Carter was her name

[@jamilahana1728]

Rest in peace Amelia Carter.🙏😣💔 You are known.❤ Prayers from Marrakech, Morocco. 🤲🙏💖

[@jasonheilinger8437]

​@@kennethrosario6706that hasn't been confirmed

[@TeacherMan-h1e]

I don't care if she was homeless or home more what he did to that poor woman was brutal they should have a law that gave him the same punishment that he did to her

[@Kawabba]

This is a divine law most people hate except true Muslims. Eye for eye, tooth for tooth

[@SusanChristopher-k9y]

Well,ya know I have never believed in the death penalty I do now. Rest in Peace dear lady

[@IRGhost0]

So all the other horrific crimes, you didn’t care that much, but something about this triggered you to appreciate the death penalty? Is it because you’re a woman and you now understand that this can easily happen to you or someone you know, like it happened to the victim?

[@IamDoogy]

It's an offense to humanity to let the perpetrator live.

[@jvanek8512]

I understand your emotions, but your comment actually proves why it shouldn't exist. It can't be based on vengeance. You can't have a system that gives it to some people and not others who commit the same crime. For example people don't think that Luigi guy should get it despite the fact he committed the same crime as this guy.

[@toadfrench7801]

@@jvanek8512 you do realize that being burned alive is one of the worst and painful ways to die right?

[@safeandeffectivelol]

@@jvanek8512 People are given different sentences for similar crimes all the time. Does that mean nobody should be punished for rape or murder?

[@truth815]

Not one person help her..sad times we live in....

[@garyhoff3260]

If they did DA would have charged them with something.

[@Smarty2able]

How when she is in flames and don't have any tools to make the fire disappear. If they fan her it would get worse. They don't have water or anything what were they supposed to do then catch the guy who did it? You know there's lawsuits in NY charge when you try to help people?

[@kellysanchez2629]

If criminas weren't protected so much im sure someone would have helped

[@Cecille_the_one]

@@garyhoff3260💯💯💯

[@joburch7583]

What exactly would you have done to help her?

[@rmkofmd1398]

With all the cameras on the subway system, you'd think they would release some clear photos of her before she boarded to help get her identified.

[@Annie-t7m9w]

Yep

[@renna912]

They have it. I hear she was a black woman. That's why they don't care. All this new technology they have.They can find out who that woman is, they don't want to because she's black.

[@truther001]

They are supposed to notify family first rather than see it on the news.

[@gabepizza]

in the winter especially the homeless, really cover up. Probably had her hood on, scarf, very hard to tell

[@georgewolfiii1170]

They already know the name of the woman. But there is some strange reason why they don't want to divulge her name.

[@ksaljulimaiajuli5687]

Instead of helping everyone pull out their phone to record. What an evil world we live in

[@doloresparlato]

Agreed, easier to just observe life than actually live it; what each person did who recorded this and did nothing, is actually how they do life, picking the low hanging fruit so to speak, just living on the edge of life, never fully engaging the one life they've been given, and they never fully develop on a deep level, and they try to hold on to their precious perception of being safe. They stay small inside, like shrunken beings. They could have done something significant that day by saving, or even just trying, to save that dying woman, but they chose instead to hide. Pitiful. They didn't move towards another with compassion. Death looks many ways, not just like a woman on fire. It also looks like people paralyzed with indifference. Someone could have been a hero that day, but they opted out. Easier to die small, die forgotten.

[@dingoledingus9039]

​@@doloresparlato They all have to live with themselves and the fact that they did nothing while someone died. That's going to be a long, hard lesson for all of them and I don't envy it. I live my life in that I'll always try something if someone needs help because I can wake up everyday knowing I at least tried. I can't imagine seeing something this horrifying and doing absolutely nothing.

[@everlastinglife5978]

I wish someone would have tried to help at least. But it's easy to type a comment online about doing something it's a lot harder to actually do it when the time comes. Those people are regular people just like you.

[@angelesblancosincofficial4756]

Cold evil world ..Lord have Mercy of humanity.

[@nay6727]

Death penalty....This craziness need to stop.

[@ljBloomington]

“Snuck back in” Probably walked right back over the border more likely. This should not have happened.

[@echecs9]

Would not have happened if Trump was President.

[@Jaykay033]

@@echecs9he came to the United States Illegally in 2018. That was during trumps administration. So save the bs….

[@IYeleven]

@@Jaykay033 And trump sent him back but this guy returned under bidens so do some research before making a conclusion

[@shippo4ever101]

@@Jaykay033 He wasn’t allowed to govern like he wanted to. He was gonna make a wall but both countries rallied against it with full force. If his plan was enacted like he wanted, yes this guy wouldn’t be here

[@5014chizuka]

I was just saying the same thing!!

[@RoughRaiders13]

It's kind of ironic to have a bunch of people standing around mourning the death of a woman whose life could have been saved if people weren't standing around watching her burn to death, and instead took off their winter coats and actually tried to tackle her and smother the flames. And the transit cops that kept telling people to get back and also just stood there and watched her burn to death should all be fired. There's at least two cell phone videos that exists of this incident and that woman was standing there in complete shock but very alive for quite a while and easily could have been saved. But instead everyone just stood there and watched her die. Absolutely pathetic

[@BrianChristian-up7tk]

Mr Penny tried to help someone and almost went to prison for life. When a system only caters to criminals and punishes the law abiding working class.. everybody is scared to do the right thing.

[@LanceABoyle]

Cops won't help unless they get OT.

[@Geechee_Chick]

How are people supposed to put out flames that large without fire extinguishing equipment?? They would've gotten burned as well.

[@michelleruffin6903]

⁠Oh stop with poor excuse for lack of humanity. These were two totally different incidents!@@BrianChristian-up7tk

[@BarbKramer-d7f]

Best answer and bringing up Penny isn't relevant.

[@ghostbusterslimer3457]

That poor lady so heartbreaking! No one deserved that NO ONE. That makes me so mad and angry! The governor and mayor adams are at fault. They caused this. The fact this happened to a homeless person just trying to sleep makes me even MORE MAD and everyone should be mad.

[@RobynHood1021]

Government seems to care more about luigi who killed the be of the elite of society

[@malin7919]

The result of electing woke pols.

[@dianadundidit5343]

BLAME BIDEN/HARRIS/HOCHUL/ADAMS AND EVERY SINGLE DEMOCRAT!!

[@monicavidal850]

Please 🙏 people vote out democrats governor and mayor next year/ to save your city.

[@lilamayoral1031]

​@@RobynHood1021 the Media cares about Luigi .... He's the Left sex symbol now ..

[@IamDoogy]

The people who watched her burn and did nothing… Shameful. Inhuman.

[@NouraZahle]

Because when men do intervene they get arrested like Daniel Penny.

[@catgirl6803]

What were people supposed to do? Burn themselves? From the video it sounded like people didn’t even realize a person was burning.

[@WarlockX4]

Blue states have set a precedent that if you play "good samaritan" the DA will come after you with the full extent of the law. It's not worth it.

[@hoehoe360]

@@catgirl6803 ofcourse a catgirl would say thiss

[@YoureNotThatGuy-777]

​@catgirl6803 I'm sure there are people watching when the guy first lights that fire. It seems that people in New York don't get involved whenever strangers needs help.

[@LoveMyPeople04]

While this poor woman suffered and slept out in the cold on the streets of New York, her hometown, her own government betrayed her and offered five star hotel accommodation to illegal migrants like this murder. Food stamps was provider as well as every day spending money. This murder received help while she suffered…I’m pissed as hell… smfh

[@ronnie6696]

she could be illegal

[@ForeverYoung20092]

Poor lady. That’s not even an act you do to your worse enemy.

[@warrenbuyer]

some foreign cultures don't mix

[@DamarisWilliams-k8g]

That is true, but this simply comes down to a lack of border control and no consequences for coming here illegally.​@warrenbuyer

[@scm4you599]

actually no, people have done a lot worse things to their worst enemy in history.

[@WULDInc]

@@warrenbuyer I don't think everyone from Guatemala believes in sadistic torture. It's like saying Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, or Charles Manson represents American culture.

[@raaspider]

@@warrenbuyer you are exaggerating buddy

[@pedrofernandez8729]

"We are calling on this and calling on that but we're still voting for the same people who let this happen"

[@dixonmopar2129]

JOETATO ! Pardoning his son , for 180 years in the senate !!

[@terryhoagland6009]

The next time vote Republican!!!

[@Kaye321]

EXACTLY, NYC still keeps voting Blue EXCEPT me.

[@divinedianec3170]

This is why Donald trump is doing mass deportations.

[@zoeking95]

To many woke liberal idiots in this city who always vote democrats

[@tysonrolls9713]

Imagine seeing ur child burning to death and seeing cops just walking away

[@zoeking95]

In NYC you can’t really expect the police to help. They r pathetic.

[@Kurt-83]

​@zoeking95 And on top of that you anyone do something they would be charged themselves.

[@thirzajohanna6020]

How do you help someone engulfed in flames ?! Without risking your own life. Make it make sense ! It’s unfortunate but not an easy task. There are no fire extinguishers on platforms or in trains.

[@Kurt-83]

@@thirzajohanna6020 Ever heard of a fire extinguisher or a fire blanket? They are not on the subway's? No one ever thought hey what if a fire break out?

[@dingoledingus9039]

​@@thirzajohanna6020water, soda, any container of no flammable liquid you have on your person. I would not risk smothering because she was probably burned to the point of her skin sloughing off. You wouldn't be getting super close to her to douse and she was standing by the opened door so you wouldn't have to worry about smoke inhalation. There was a lot that could have been done, but hindsight is 20/20 and clearly every one present at the scene did not make very good decisions in dire moment.

[@sidewindersid4180]

I don't care the race/religion or gender of the perpetrator or the victim...how dare another person do that to a fellow human being.

[@Dguallpa98]

I can’t believe that in a modern city like NYC where millions commute, there isn’t a fire extinguisher readily available.

[@zekemedia1310]

The MTA keeps them locked up because when they weren't fools were throwing them out the windows of trains and hitting people and also teens were using them to spray each other and bystanders.

[@SF-my4uq]

lol. You realize it would be stolen within a nano second, right????

[@yungblade7]

​@@zekemedia1310 you realize that's why they are supposed to be sealed in a breakable glass so you can break it open during emergency

[@derekjeter3654]

And where do you think the fire extinguisher will be put?

[@garlicgirl3149]

@@zekemedia1310 Sigh!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@youwish378]

They know they have a picture of her on the subway before this happened they could be showing everyone who she was !!! WHERE'S THE PICTURE OF HER 😡

[@hughbetcha436]

She might be a POC

[@kasun1752]

That is crazy that noone is claiming her …

[@BarbKramer-d7f]

If she was dressed in warm clothing and blankets her face was probably never visible.

[@Fendogs.]

Maybe they don't want the family to find out like that

[@Ccdddttt]

it was a white women

[@mstly4lg]

I'm relieved to hear that these community leaders held a vigil. More people should have been present. The world should be outraged. There should be more vigils

[@Xosia88]

Me too😢

[@franklin8618]

Totally agree....especially people who ride the subways that feel unsafe and voice their anger to the Mayor and Govenor Hogul about their nonsense statistics that it's safe to ride the subway.

[@KPate-y5z]

The British press and media haven't even covered it which is shocking given how unsafe out borders are due to out of control illegal migration into this country.

[@frank-xp6pj]

Why isn’t this country outraged that we allow illegals into this country without any screening whatsoever ? Do you remember NewYork held rallies years ago demanding they wanted illegals ? It’s on KZbin look it up….smh

[@Maxigirl5523]

They would have been outraged had the illegal been the victim. The warped thinking of those on the left. 😢

[@commentandlikedistributor]

he’s just been here six years chilling

[@lamujermaslinda]

This isn't the first time someone was burned alive at the nyc subway station. I think in the early nineties a transit employee was also set on fire and died. They need to put in measures to ensure something like this never happens again.

[@roselynholloway7863]

Oh wow

[@edge2991]

Dude got a psych evaluation, legal aid, translator all at tax payer expense by NYCers with a .00001 % attention span , all of you voted for these laws and the system

[@edgargee408]

Don’t bring me in to this ask your mommah foo

[@randominternetuser2888]

👆 Ragebait 🐂💩 American justice system works that way 🤷 start taking away those protections and see what happens to American citizens who aren't wealthy or politically connected 🤔

[@margielopez9741]

This administration is quickly out the door....'THEY" created this mess.

[@edmendez4049]

Those cops running back and forth while that lady burned and did nothing should be held accountable

[@dixonmopar2129]

I say give JOETATO another 180 years ! Bound to get it right some decade , correct ?

[@elsierodgers4874]

For what?

[@rmkofmd1398]

@@elsierodgers4874 Police have a duty to render aid. They could have forced her down and tried to smother the flames with a jacket or something.

[@suncat991]

@@elsierodgers4874for not upholding their duty to protect and to serve. They were cowards.

[@michaelsmith6318]

​@@elsierodgers4874 for not trying to put the fire out?...

[@dianadundidit5343]

This is absolutely horrible!! They have to have a picture of her before this maniac killed her!!

[@yungblade7]

They have footage all over that subway

[@littleredhen2894]

​@@yungblade7That's what I thought...surely there's footage of her when she was coming in, and before the m*rder? Poor woman...

[@Xosia88]

They're trying to dehumanize her. That's why all they're telling us is that she's homeless... They definitely got pictures of her before this happened! WTF!?😡

[@MaiMai-ys4yg]

I agree! Literally nyc cameras everywhere

[@Giuseppe_1994]

Can we get an image of her walking on the subway so the public can help identify? Why hasn’t this been released?

[@satwoods4]

People pulled out their phones, one cop walked pass, no fire extinguishers no where? This world crazy..

[@scm4you599]

no just this ghetto city.

[@cyberbron2024]

You think people got GTA inventories or something.

[@nethandelwampa116]

Saw the video of it, not one person stepped in to save her. Police officer standing there. What universe is this? I was horrified. How far have we fallen as humans where we can’t help each other?

[@scm4you599]

in america, it is every man for himself.

[@garlicgirl3149]

A Fallen universe.

[@WULDInc]

I guess the question is, what could people have done in that circumstance when she was already severely burned? If you've ever researched burn victims and burn wounds, you'd know that the suffering doesn't stop after the flames are put out. The only thing you could is at the very beginning, when she was first put on fire, by extinguishing it immediately. And if you wanted to be extra merciful, they could have ____ her, but then ended up with a murder charge.

[@lisanealy1703]

"What universe is this?" It's New York-- explains everything.

[@steveshap6219]

In a liberal-run city like NY, if you help her, then you'll be put on trial. Blame the dim-wit dems.

[@CynicalDelightxXx]

There's videos you never want to watch twice. I just couldn't believe what I was seeing. Terrifying. Haunting.

[@littleredhen2894]

I saw a few seconds by accident when it popped up on my screen and can't unsee it now...poor lady... nobody deserves this 😢

[@cyberbron2024]

Fr it actually haunted me, that’s the most evil sh*t I’ve ever seen. The fact that someone could do that to another person is crazy to me. Whoever did that needs to stay in jail forever.

[@Theinspirationalrogue]

Those cops who were nearby on their phone should be held accountable!!

[@lisov4575]

Because this whole thing is only the cops fault, right?

[@zoeking95]

If you learned anything these past 4 years the police do not give AF about the public

[@JeanetteFaith]

why didn't the people filming it help her???? You use your coats to smother the flame when you have no water of fire extinguisher. Stop-drop-and Roll.

[@Ccubed92]

​@@JeanetteFaith it's not that easy. You never had experience in putting a fire out and without training you would end up burned and she was fully engolved in fire so the damage in her lungs and skin would have killed her at that point.

[@Skrittles-f4m]

@@lisov4575 thise cops should have a class in how to put fires out. but they can carry a gun ?? all you have to do is smother the fire with your jacket. we learned this in school. its not hard.

[@ducksternlight6463]

if they do not know who she is, then how do they know she is homeless???????

[@expat-k8d]

They're saying that to deflect from the politicians. They don't want anyone to know she's a young student.

[@VoxDeiUniversity]

​@@expat-k8dShe's not a young student that's a lie. There is no Amelia Carter.That's a made up lie with the fake image.

[@VoxDeiUniversity]

That's why they believe she was homeless because they cannot I d her and nobody has said they're looking for her.

[@amywamala]

Also because they said she was wearing lots of clothing layered up and a couple of blankets!!😢

[@timothybronson6973]

I believe she was someone who was on the list. Because it does not take this long to find out who she is they are hiding it hoping we all move on from this story.

[@TheDweeb002]

Now suddenly people are concerned about the homeless…

[@xircc]

Now the media is gonna keep saying she’s homeless (even though there’s 0 proof of this and it shouldn’t matter even if it’s true) so they can bury this story while any little thing that happens with Luigi will be “breaking” and they talk about it all week

[@youwish378]

They know they have a picture of her on the subway before this happened They could be showing EVERYONE who she is 🙏🏼

[@malachibenyisrael4621]

Good thing they are not showing her face. Everyone thinks she's a white woman, if she were anything else most ppl wouldn't care.

[@xircc]

@@youwish378 The picture that was circulating around that was supposedly her is not her. That was a random woman that’s alive I don’t trust the NYPD saying she was homeless. One of them literally just walked by while she was on fire

[@OpeningsOpenings]

@@youwish378exactly They know they have footage of her getting on the train and falling asleep and could probably trace her coming into the station she got in at and getting down the street to that station before that They were able to get VOLUMES of video footage as evidence for the Luigi Mangione case - so why not for this woman?

[@zaq1337]

@@youwish378 Yup they have cameras EVERYWHERE

[@PoppyParker-ef4le]

Media tried to ask AOC about this poor burned to death victim and she ignored the question. House him with her.

[@JeanetteFaith]

AOC wants them here in the USA.

[@margielopez9741]

THAT WOMAN IS DISGUSTING...THAT'S WHY SHE LOST. AOC...YOU'RE FIRED AND DESERVE TO BE!!!!!

[@lanaofficiel4042]

AOC is disgusting.

[@Smileasyoumasturbate]

​@@JeanetteFaith yes in the jew sa

[@toadfrench7801]

and AOC keeps getting reelected.

[@AB-by8xu]

that is what he wanted , free housing and food , he will get it with life in prison

[@divinedianec3170]

This is why Donald trump is doing mass deportations.

[@es4242]

I wouldn’t want those accommodations. Life won’t be good for him in prison.

[@KRW3321]

That was my first thought regarding his motive.

[@margielopez9741]

Thanks to 4 years of this administration about to exit.

[@Jaykay033]

@@margielopez9741 he came to the United States Illegally in 2018. That was during trumps administration. So save the bs…

[@RumpelFourSkin]

That cop should be charged for walking on by, not helping at all

[@stevenaleshire7941]

Enough... Totally preventable if the law was followed. This "Gentleman " so used to be given a free pass even after deported returned... Living in a shelter ? Enough.

[@sbar3546]

I would never visit NYC now.

[@sharpasacueball]

Unless your job pays for your stay, it's not worth it

[@StevenSeagull1984]

​@@sharpasacueballno job or amount of money is worth going to NY...

[@PredatorGoose]

everything i hear about new york is how garbage it is

[@Professor_Kaos]

Same, those people are robots apparently.

[@angelanabozny83]

I agree I'm never going to New York again

[@Viral_videos_95]

Stop saying he enter illegally when y'all let them in y'all gave them buses y'all gave them money. The media always trying to narrate things to brainwash people

[@rubysteincoppage4225]

Say that

[@angeldelgado7120]

He is illegal though, how does anything you said change that?

[@theoriginalkrabbypatty]

He’s illegal! He would have done this to someone in Texas, Florida, or California.

[@elwingw4321]

They flew them in. And drove them in. Just so they could destroy America. They knew they were criminals and gang members. Police ordered to stand down when they looted . This was the plan. To steal kill and destroy. Where is the mayor talking about the safety of his city like he did for mangione. Nowhere. Whatever benefits him politically.

[@elwingw4321]

@@angeldelgado7120 no border security for this reason. Bring them in to cause chaos and destruction . If he is illegal how did he get shelter and money for booze. How is he being supported here being illegal. They made no one illegal.any criminal has freedom here.

[@VimyScout]

It's beyond comprehension to think of the pain that poor woman suffered. Hard to believe that some one deranged enough could even evoke such an act. I hope she is with God now.

[@scm4you599]

u hope but there is one problem. god isn't real. so how do u hope? LOL

[@leoleal8053]

Where is the outrage of the people?

[@bigburrearp7609]

How do you like your sanctuary city now?

[@dawnburkinshaw]

Horrific can’t believe anyone could do this. It’s against everything

[@terryhoagland6009]

He's not only mean but looks mean!!

[@anjanashyam9333]

That thing looks like a demon

[@Claudialupperocd]

Not against whatever pagan witchcraft they practice in his pais. They are not just sweet people iso a better life. Big lie

[@Vale0x3]

I can believe it, remember live leaks. Everyone was complaining that it made South Americans look bad. This is what they do in their own country. It's not even safe to travel there yet they are let in freely here.

[@walkinbeauty7273]

​@@terryhoagland6009he looks possessed

[@BigRayHernandez]

Praying for a victim who’s already dead… The MTA didn’t have a fire extinguisher ANYWHERE???? The “Governor” SHOULD BE FIRED!

[@lamujermaslinda]

yes praying for her soul so that she can crossover. It's highly encouraged to pray for the souls that have passed on especially for those who died in horrible circumstances like this poor lady.

[@jessicapurdum5084]

I think it’s nice that people took time to gather, pay respects, mourn her soul. Guess you’d be happier if no one did anything to pay respects besides comment online. Just like no one helped her in person, just recorded on their phones.

[@garlicgirl3149]

I was wondering if she got that wrong.

[@Kurt-83]

​@@jessicapurdum5084Well, people have been saying why do people come here get all the help while our people suffer?

[@wallstreet_au]

you dont understand Christianity. keep quiet else you'll look like a bigger fool.

[@captainbeyond4350]

This killer illegal wants to be in jail in America. His country is worse . He will have three meals a day, cable tv , air conditioning, heating, and health care and dental.

[@rhonddavincent2803]

What a horrible world we live in. The poor lady. ❤️

[@509livin8]

People are scared to help people because they can be arrested instead of the criminal. There has been many examples in the past few years

[@scm4you599]

in america they would arrest batman for attacking joker...LOL

[@Yamahaaaaaaa]

Maybe the New York subway system needs to be shut down for a few weeks. Since they can’t act right under ground. That’s crazy.

[@evoz4489]

I agree. To the people just standing there doing nothing. You should be "grounded" for a week. You ruined it for everyone else. Maybe everyone will stop and think about how much they take their ride to work in the morning for granted. As a matter of fact, the whole damn subway system should shut down for a week. That includes getting the homeless people out of there. I'm sure people will complain how "inconvenient" it will be, but just look at how inconvenient it was for this woman who was doing nothing but minding her own business and no one did CRAP to tackle that guy to the ground and suffocate those flames. There is something psychologically wrong with people that feel the need to stand there and film someone suffering to get views and likes. And a COP! It's called lack of empathy and it's disgusting.

[@vincentbarney3091]

They can't act right above ground

[@lisov4575]

How are people supposed to get to work? This damn city cant function without the subway.

[@AbbyJones-pi8gt]

They going to give people free Lyfts?

[@markcatcash4688]

Call on Biden and Harris for allowing this..Joe is probably asking if he can pardon him

[@dixonmopar2129]

Mr .Magoo probably has no idea what year it is ....

[@LanceABoyle]

​Trump Uber Alles.

[@gammer4life-oc5nh]

when stuff like this keeps happening after biden is gone you going to blame trump then right?

[@sonvapritch1]

What an idiotic thing to say. People commit horrible atrocities like this under all sitting presidents. Grow a brain.

[@betsyp500]

STOP BLAMING ALL OF THIS WRONG DOINGS ON BIDEN, HE WASN'T THERE AND HE DIDN'T DO IT, SO BLAME YOURSELF FOR MAKING IGNORANT COMMENTS!!!

[@stephanefotso]

the horrific crime is the careless act from the people and officers standing and just watching someone dying...

[@janetprice85]

They have fire extinguishers on thst subway?

[@everlastinglife5978]

I would assume there is a fire extinguisher on every train. If I was there I pray I would have been able to act fast enough to help.

[@melbacruz703]

Justice for this woman!!!

[@Kaye321]

This is why it's the city that never sleeps, everyone is afraid to close their eyes.

[@-ULTRA-Games]

Do something about subway crime but not homelessness in New York? This woman would have been safe if she wasn’t forced to sleep in the train

[@sherienichol1580]

Exactly, while they give free housing to people who do not belong in this Country! This is just so sad!

[@kimleone5496]

I don't disagree that homelessness is a problem but this guy would have killed somebody else. He should have never been allowed into the US

[@lisov4575]

No one "forced" her to sleep in the train. Stop saying that.

[@margielopez9741]

RAOOM AND BOARD FOR MIGRANTS, YET OUR OWN HOMELESS PEOPLE HAVE TO SLEEP AND DI=E ON THE TRAIN.

[@BarbKramer-d7f]

Shelters don't take you if you're drunk. But the illegal perp was getting treatment for it!!

[@DonatelloRogers]

He dont care if he got charged

[@crystalmaze3646]

Never ever fall asleep on public spaces never safe

[@lashayj4965]

I'm glad people are standing up for her. God bless you all!!!!

[@JamesMackenzie-sx2bu]

What?! The coward cop should have stood up for her when she was still alive. You utter useless tool

[@BlairK-k3p]

Where is the governor?

[@MrTtaakk]

And the Mayor.

[@ulikepoi]

Smoking pot

[@joshuajohnson7519]

Posting on social media about how subways are safe.

[@KevinSun242]

@@joshuajohnson7519 While hiding behind her armed state police detail

[@JG-ll5pg]

Taking money under the table from the hasids.

[@witcheswarlocksworldwide2244]

Homeless? Why wasn't she put up in the Roosevelt hotel? Doesn't make any sense at all. All the New York City housing authority apartment buildings are in inhabitable conditions and many homeless people and veterans sleeping in the streets and they don't get a hotel stay. Very sick

[@stevenaleshire7941]

Maybe because she was a citizen. Roosevelt Hotel and all the rest just for illegals... Americans go to the street in NYC. Never forget Adams profiteering as he lies.

[@Kurt-83]

Oh nooo, black people we not entitled to any of that, no just the people who come here illegally.

[@rayharvey1330]

Remember all the people who showed up to block the subway after the Daniel Penny incident? Where are they now???🤔

[@Jade-fu7oy]

What happened to the cop/security guard that just walked right by her flames and did nothing??

[@donjon123]

1:50 arent these the same animals that tried to put daniel penny in jail

[@beckinfidelis3916]

For real, talk about mixed messaging! My guess? They want you to act to protect black victims, but don't protect anyone from black perpetrators! They can't just say it directly, it would make people angry. So, we get mixed messages without explanation. Not that I want the loudest voices to decide when people should act when it's all based on their own prejudices and personal opinions.

[@XJ9sodypop]

all lives matter

[@Treemonieee]

Who are the animals?? I don’t see any white maggots on the screen..

[@markhunt575]

Ask Alvin Bragg what happens when you try to help people if you a little on the pale side.

[@nurim.4439]

If somebody try to help that woman like Peny, that person will be in jail right now and the killer as the poor victim.

[@yungblade7]

Helping someone not burn to death vs intervening in an assault is two totally different things genius.

[@ManChan-w5p]

Sleep with one eye open especially in the subway.

[@HomemakingandHomeschoolMama]

Don't sleep at all on a subway

[@bbygrlpt2]

You cant sleep in the subway thats insane

[@RamseyThomoson]

Homeless stop using that ok doesn't matter she was a human being no one deserves this 🙏🏾

[@evetteboss4085]

Biden nor Harris have said anything about this incident. Where are they?!

[@margielopez9741]

STILL PARTYING FOR THE HOLIDAYS. BIDEN TAKING NAPS.

[@musterseeds1778]

After the Daneld Penny case, no one want to help....thank to AG...

[@pedrofernandez8729]

Don't forget BLM, they deserve credit as well.

[@dixonmopar2129]

Simply another day in a BLUE UTOPIA !

[@Peaceman1.]

Hitler Benjamin natanyahu going to jail ICC

[@Peaceman1.]

Daneld Penny help Palestine children and Palestine women and Palestine babies

[@KristineMarieTxSPI]

​@@Peaceman1. ???

[@ethancastro2359]

The system and the people just watching failed her!

[@everlastinglife5978]

Knowing how hard her life on earth was, I hope she's happy in her afterlife. Rest in peace.

[@highlovevibration]

I was just thinking that 😢🙏

[@ThumperX9]

He's got a permanent ticket punched to live in the US now...

[@barbiejimenezmojica40]

I couldn’t understand how people could not take off their jackets help put out the the fire 🔥 so sad she is with God Now he will take care of her forever ❤🙏🏽

[@JoyceRodriguez-p1w]

They should be held accountable

[@JayP-vh9wc]

You gonna buy people a new jacket?

[@lisanealy1703]

​@JayP-vh9wc You gonna crawl back under your rock?

[@GiovannaCatanzarite]

So is Alvin Bragg going to go after this guy instead of going after innocent people like Daniel Penny??

[@Claudialupperocd]

Nope. Doesn't fit the anti whyt narrative. This guy will probably get off on a bogus mental health defense and chill out at taxpayer expense the rest of his life, which was his plan anyway since he is illegal. POS.

[@nicoletrulyyours]

He’s in Jail charged with first degree murder smh

[@irenewheatley8669]

Poors and underprivileged people are always guilty they are irrelevant in the eyes of laws . Very sad mentality.

[@PremierComputerFairs]

Bragg is eating Kentucky Buckets!

[@samuraidough5377]

No compassion for others. Sad, nobody helped this woman just sad . Somebody mother,sister daughter, and even grandmother. We as a country got to do better.

[@JJ-fu4by]

Sickening how many people just recorded and did nothing. Pathetic.

[@expat-k8d]

Hochul, Schumer, Adams, Cuomo, DeBlasio All responsible

[@doublebreasted1422]

How?! Were the ones with the matches/lighter??

[@cathleenmore4656]

Don't forget by done and Kamala and myorkas

[@rhodium69]

Lets not forget Alvin Bragg and Jerry Nadler as well as the city council and James

[@tubecontributor3206]

Don't forget the DEI infested City Council and leadership in the Senate and House in Albany who pushed for bail reform.

[@madison-Roccoa-Mason-drake]

Don't forget trump let him in 2018.

[@robertsontirado4478]

All these tough folks covered in tattoos acting like gangsters but are really cowards.

[@Cocoabrown25]

Exactly

[@sportgoofy1975]

​@@Cocoabrown25you mean the subway goers who witnessed this or the two police officers who did nothing? New York. City of the cowardly.

[@JeanetteFaith]

This is BEYOND SAD!!! It makes me cry. The people of NYC need to get rid of Governor Hochul, the Mayor, and definitely DA Bragg!!!! He charged Daniel Penny and now no one will get involved and help. Horrible! President Biden and his Homeland Security man should also be held accountable for allowing all these unvetted people to cross our southern border illegally!!! May God Bless this woman's soul.

[@margielopez9741]

NO, THEY LOVE OPEN BORDERS!

[@AuntieAlexandra]

He walked back in to the country in 2018. Remind me who was president then?

[@JeanetteFaith]

@@AuntieAlexandra No. He was first deported in 2018. No one knows when he came back because he is not listed...he's one of the million plus 'got aways'. But you got the year...just not the facts.

[@tetraquark2402]

What an evil thing to do.

[@grettalemabouchou6779]

PRAY FOR HER MOM AND DAD FAMLY AND FRIENDS.😢

[@rodellwilliams871]

RIP 🙏🏽 so sorry to hear

[@virginiaconnor8350]

Aren't there sprinklers and video cameras in the cars? If none, there should be. Let's not just find out who this lady was, but also his motive for doing this to her? Why did he single her out to set on fire?

[@RooRoove]

I didn't think there are sprinklers in the actual train cars, but I could be wrong.

[@yungblade7]

PSY-OP to induce fear

[@emilypatrizia7419]

Because he's a deranged, drunk, illegal pos. Probably pissed off at Americans because he gets deported and has to live his life sneaking around.

[@Jess_Tropical_jungle]

Good luck with that, last time yall had a good Samaritans step in to prevent potential lost lives you put him on trial and demanded his life for stepping up.

[@DuckyBhoy]

Yup 100%

[@justinperez2441]

Mayor and governor always saying subway crime is down is BS !!!

[@scm4you599]

they mean crime is now down underground...

[@drewhill1291]

I have never seen this same kind of depravity that we see in these blue cities on a daily and sometimes an hourly basis. Just ABSOLUTELY DESPICABLE

[@SalAvenueNJ]

"Everyone Just Stood By" that's a load of crap !! 2 cops from the mezzanine got down there as soon as they smelled smoke. And an MTA worker with a fire extinguisher put the fire out right after it happened. The guy was in custody in a matter of hours.

[@yungblade7]

They stood there pacing back and forth like a bunch of NPC's for at least 5-10 minutes. You call that asap??

[@JeanetteFaith]

People won't help after DA Bragg dragged Daniel Penny through the court system when he helped on a train. This is just so sad.

[@nicoletrulyyours]

@@JeanetteFaith I don’t know why people keep comparing the two different situations. When people are asking why didn’t anyone help her. They’re not talking about choking the assailant or holding him until the police came. No one tried to take off jackets or clothes to help contain the fire. They sat and watched her die.

[@JeanetteFaith]

@@nicoletrulyyours They are two different events on the NYC subway, but when DA Bragg tried to convict Daniel Penny after the people on the train thanked him, it causes people to not want to help. I do agree that people standing there should have used their coats and done the Stop-drop-and-roll. I would have if I had been there. DA Bragg seems more interested in prosecuting Americans who do step in to help. I feel so sad for this woman.

[@Cynical-kl3wy]

@@JeanetteFaithStop using one isolated incident as an excuse for people’s bullshit. A lot of people haven’t even heard of Daniel Penny’s case. It’s an excuse, plain and simple.

[@oldman9606]

They know who she is. They have a reason for not saying.

[@C12341]

Exactly. They don't like the optics. She probably is similar to the woman whose face was slashed. YOU DO NOT do young men of color a service by telling them, when they're capable of greatness, that they are the eternal victim and Karen is oppressing them. It seems okay to hate ww right now both by white people and black people and we need to address that. Also Daniel Penny. I'll just stop but I bet you get it.

[@roselynholloway7863]

Why

[@bobbyash33p66]

Police literally didnt help her just stood by and wven told a guy who was trying to fan her to stop and walked off...why didnt they help her

[@MISSLOVELY_REE]

Nobody helped this poor woman 😡😞 nobody not even the officer 😔

[@logicking3765]

“How come no one helped?” Last time someone tried, he was sued by the DA.

[@dannyjamison8337]

Any word from the police officer who stood there and did nothing to help her? Any word from Governor Kathy Hochul? How about mayor Eric Adams.. does he still insist that New York should be a sanctuary city? Hey New York.. you voted for this!

[@deescott8312]

What kind of monster does this

[@gizmonovack]

Democrats supports sanctuary

[@richardanderson4757]

It shouldn’t never had happened, someone on that subway, could have stopped him, or help put the fire , that’s on the Biden administration right there,

[@JanetProtasiewicz-vu9fl]

Wonderful people having a vigil and praying for this poor woman's soul. I am sure she is in God's arms and at peace. How do they know she was homeless if they haven't identified her yet?

[@Kurt-83]

You get what you vote for, the people in charge doesn't care about anyone but themselves.

[@JesusRincón-x6y]

5 stars hoteles for illegal migrants and the curb to the homeless Americans. WTF ?