Whatifalthist's Civil War Predictions and the Incel Rebellion

[@FreddaYT]

Play War Thunder now with my link, and get a massive, free bonus pack including vehicles, boosters and more: playwt.link/fredda

[@No.1_ZIL-130_Fan]

No thanks

[@Schmoogie]

Fuck sponsors

[@ThunderTheBlackShadowKitty]

Bad game, scam, do not play, do not give them money

[@hely_2405]

@@ThunderTheBlackShadowKitty As a player with over 3000 hours, I can confirm this statement while continuously flooding the snail's throat with my money

[@zhcultivator]

Please upload a full reaction to the Incel Revolution video

[@Pompeius_Strabo]

I just want to point out that Whatifalthist is wrong, Stand on Zanzibar did not predict a black American president named Obomi. Obomi was the president of the book's version of Nigeria, so it predicted a black president in Africa (very unexpected). Sounds to me like Whatifalthist didn't read the book.

[@liquidityoforange440]

I think he has been using the same slide about Zanzibar's predictions for several years. There are a lot of copy and paste parts of his videos if you've seen enough.

[@geo8rge]

Zadkiel F. Obomi, President of Beninia en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand_on_Zanzibar

[@hedgehog3180]

@@geo8rge I knew the name was familiar, turns out this is just a generally well regarded, if slightly obscure, science-fiction book and it's very obviously in the Cyberpunk genre.

[@senlim8461]

probably just saw "president" and assumed it was of the US

[@JohanKylander]

​@@geo8rgeThose characters are something else. A Puerto Rican baby farmer, Rival popes, President of Beninia, a yonderboy(?), a 91 year old cyborg, and "watches TV", lol.

[@CallMeThing]

A historian critiquing Whatifalthist, is like an architect critiquing a child's sand castle.

[@YoutubeAccount-om6sj]

@user-kbascd4o24🤨

[@Karlswebb]

@lewakar Ratio'd lmao

[@peachypet808]

​@lewakarAnd?

[@peachypet808]

@lewakar Historians might disagree on that stance. Any sources findable online that aren't from highly right wing political sides (or Chinese influence) seem to refer to him as. Samurai if not one that came to be the standard way

[@peachypet808]

@lewakar Yeah, Cleopatra was of Greek descent. That is well known. And if you can show me the Japanese people that are outraged when all sources online that aren't heavily politically biased point towards Yasuke being a Samurai that would be great. You know. Evidence for outraged people that aren't just racist

[@Stoneworks]

We're HURDLING towards a civil war, my left-hand leftist Islamic crystal ball showed me

[@omeganichtdieuhrsondernder6906]

Didn't expect you of all the Fish.

[@Stoneworks]

🐠 glrp

[@jojoohyeah4761]

@@Stoneworksstoneworks here? Based. Love the Minecraft world building series btw, make more and more and more (pls ofc)

[@JM57-99]

Bardonia is surrounding me on all directions, now that's a war I'm worried about 😅

[@bennelong8451]

Ukrainian flag pfp being leftist and Islamic. I’m overloaded by the irony

[@brandonprendergast7806]

The incel rebellion sounds like a hoi4 event

[@Lex_Araden]

I never thought I would hear of a more silly rebellion than the Grunt Rebellion in Halo 2. The world is vast.

[@behindyou666]

the dream of hoi4 players

[@Lex_Araden]

@@behindyou666 I wonder what the Mean Time To Happen for it is.

[@Bridget4President]

esoteric incelism...

[@thatrandomguyontheinternet2477]

'Today news has come from all over the United States. From the cities of the midwest to the golden beaches of the south, from the golden arches in the west to the great port of New York an uprising has ignited and the Holy Pure Empire of Waifus has been declared. Current fighting in major cities has shown an uncertain result to the conflict with Atlanta being declared a capital by the movement as their first major captured city. The government has started conscription, the army reving up for war, the navy has already shown signs of mutiny and infighting while major airbases have been raided by the HPEW'

[@Johntology]

Everyone is talking about WhatIfAltHist but no one is asking HowIsAltHist? No seriously even by WhatIfAltHist standards I don't think posting 40 minute long video essays fantasizing about Incel Civil Wars every single week is a sign that someone is doing too well.

[@weiserwolf580]

he forgot to take his meds... again

[@spagootest2185]

It actually is concerning. A couple years ago I used to watch a tiny streamer that became a lolcow, and after a while he committed suicide.

[@naldormight6420]

True, but I find it hard muster empathy for the self-declared empath. We can't all be as aware and gifted with foresight. 😂

[@dragonslair951167]

Yeah, this kinda leads to a downward spiral fast. The radical right is a deeply unhappy place. They have no community, no emotional connection, no sense of purpose. All they can do is keep fantasizing that their day will come, a story you could get from a $5 palm reading.

[@JoshSweetvale]

He's making money.

[@badhammy865]

I was not emotionally prepared to hear Whatifalthist unironically call himself an empath. I just bluescreened on my couch. 😭

[@badhammy865]

@@g.v4848 Obviously this is anecdotal, but it seems like my friends in their 20s are, on average, more in touch with their emotions than their parents. Which allows them to empathize with others more easily. But then again they're mostly queer women, I just don't know a lot of male shut-ins like Whatifalthist's target audience.

[@AL-lh2ht]

@@g.v4848whatifalthis is very obviously autistic. Like, extremely autistic.

[@Trench216]

It is a Hell of a leap for someone like him who broadcasts antisemitic conspiracy theories about white replacement.

[@bombocrusty4251]

My favorite part is him being like "I know it might be cringe because the worst people in the world say this." As if the fact that he is aware it's cringe as hell means that he can't possibly be cringe himself because he's so self aware. But like no dude, you are not the one chosen guy who is some empathic wiseman sage able to predict the future, and just because you are semi self aware about how you come across like a jackass crank doesn't actually make you any less of a jack ass crank. It's so funny too because like, I *was* this guy when I was like 14. But unlike him I grew out of my main character syndrome

[@4marra]

@@badhammy865 most people like whatifalthist have no actual empathy except for their inner circle of fellow basement dwelling incels😭the capacity for empathy among my friends is pretty high and they’re all straight men, it is likely a mix of the generational differences and societal shifts + the inherent conditions we face as people which impact our perspectives

[@Beelzeboogie]

Regarding that bit about loneliness, I remember the part that alarmed me rather than the lack of people having sex, was the number of people who say they have no close friends. Every youtuber providing commentary online seemingly jumped on the lack of sex part. Whereas I'm sat there thinking "Who are you supposed to have sex with, and how are you going to meet people to have sex with, if you have no friends?" Like there's this fuckwit idea that seems to be going around that getting laid will address someone's loneliness whereas it seems more like people aren’t getting laid BECAUSE they're lonely.

[@LondonMoneyCashEnterprise]

I think it depends, cause some people have friendships which lack intimacy, they dont have/enjoy intimate friendships so they crave romantic/sexual intimacy

[@neoqwerty]

@@LondonMoneyCashEnterprise The problem is that most of the people who think getting a PRETTY GF will fix their loneliness. Last I checked someone's physical attractiveness doesn't mean you're gonna get along with them personality-wise, in which case, you're basically a dumb pigeon eating white bread that you can't even digest nutrients from because you're hungry: the end result is starving to death on a stomach full of junk you weren't supposed to eat.

[@stormysoup1083]

It's more common than a lot of people think, I've straight up never had a close irl friendship in my life and as an adult, there aren't a lot of ways to make friends or meet new people, especially irl

[@Madonnalitta1]

Bingo.

[@Beelzeboogie]

@stormysoup1083 Oh I agree, my close friends are all people I met in school or university, or people I met THROUGH those people. I wouldn't have a clue how to do it as an adult. There's a distance between me and the friends I've made as an adult through work or something.

[@joshb6132]

"Maoism with Chinese characteristics" is the funniest shit I've heard in a while.

[@shinsenshogun900]

Marxism with German characteristics moments

[@pufffincrazy5275]

Incelism with loser characteristics

[@ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45]

"Maoism" "With Chinese characteristics?' "Yes... That's what... Maoism is."

[@kazaddum2448]

@@ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45 Not exactly: Maoism (full term Marxism-Leninism-Maoism) was synthesized by Chairman Gonzalo in Peru after Maos death. It claims the universality of Maos teachings. China practices Mao Zedong Thought, which is Marxism-Leninism as applied to China by Mao and other chinese theoreticians and leaders. In effect called "Socialism with chinese characteristics" edit: Gonzalo did his tihng in Peru, not Chile. I messed up T_T

[@thunderspark1536]

@@kazaddum2448 "Hm yes the Chinese philosophy is made out of Chinese philosophy"

[@kaisertyranny]

"The vibes are worse than any other point in my life." - man who was not alive during 9/11

[@pablo_giustiniani]

ACHTUALLY 🤓 he was alive during 9/11. He was not even a year old, but he was in fact, alive back then.

[@MarinaInChains]

​@@pablo_giustiniani he was at most 2 months old, fair shot he wasn't

[@Stoneworks]

WhatIfAltHist can make these videos in 2 days because he: 1. Doesn't do any research 2. Recycles material 3. Doesn't thoughtfully edit, structure, or reorganize his points 4. Edits the visuals as a slideshow of google images, like I did when I started 5 years ago.

[@error5202]

Pure stream of consciousness

[@CrabRangoonSortaGuy]

​@karaqakkzlwait is that a diss at masaman? I've watched his vids for a while and always wondered if I'm getting baited by another whatifalthist type. He says things that are just slightly "off" sometimes idk.

[@Trench216]

Hey, Mark Felton uses Google maps!!! 😂😂😂

[@Emery_Pallas]

He doesnt “not do research” he just makes assumptions based on first principles and words he likes in books.

[@IgN5P]

@@Trench216 Mark Felton has been caught stealing content from Reddit, and plagiarizing other serious scholars. Just saying.

[@thiscommentsdeleted]

"Hilter was larping" ~ Whatifalthist

[@Callzter]

In all fairness, Hitler sometimes claimed that he was possessed by an ancient Aryan spirit. If that’s not deeply unserious larping in its purest form, then what is?

[@grutsthefoodman3645]

To be fair, shitler was larping up a storm

[@vidzorko4492]

@@Callzter Obviously the claim was that he was larping as a natzi. Not whatever garbage you brought up. If it looks like it, acts like it, claims to believe it, and preaches it, than it IS it.

[@thiscommentsdeleted]

Nah bro, hitler was just role playing as a murderous insane dictator on speed.

[@error5202]

It was just a prank bro

[@In_Our_Timeline]

In a live stream, he declared war on the internet and issued challenges to debate Nick Fuentes, Vaush, Sneako, Destiny, and Hasan in that order. It's funny because it appears that Jreg is moderating.

[@808FUCKEM]

nightmare blunt rotation

[@atomicexistentialism8428]

I would pay to see Hasan do that. I don't like Hasan, he's an arrogant bastard, but he's funny, and perfect as a weapon we can unleash when needed

[@jesusimpersonator1648]

vaush and Jreg in a room

[@IngiR08]

Bro no shot that is happening, all the people in that debate despise Hasan LMAO

[@JaneFleesTexas]

Is this true? lol

[@starhalv2427]

Bruh, WhatIfAltHist predicted that Russia would defeat Ukraine in a week while also fighting NATO, and then conquer all of Baltics and half of Poland in another week. He has no right to claim he "predicted war in Ukraine".

[@grayghost7216]

Well in September 2021 I wrote that Russia would invade Ukraine during the last week of February 2022. Although in December 2022 I also said I expected Russia to win by the end of May 2023.

[@starhalv2427]

@@grayghost7216 Bruh, it was obvious after a month (when they started falling back, failing to conquer any major city except Kherson, and Mariupol which was besieged) that they wouldn't win

[@grayghost7216]

@@starhalv2427 Russia won this war before it began.

[@starhalv2427]

@@grayghost7216 Tell that to people in Kursk :) Or to families of dead soldiers

[@grayghost7216]

@@starhalv2427 You're sort of like the guy who would have said on December 8 1941 America lost to Japan because of Pearl Harbor.

[@Snailman3516]

US Generals are well known for frequently attending West Point, a highly prestigious military college. When you throw as much money at the military as the US does, educating commanders and specialists is a pretty reliable way to increase military effectiveness. An artilleryman that knows physics and trigonometry will be more accurate than a conscript with a basic high school education.

[@Knights_Oath]

There are several senior level education courses for senior officers starting at 0-5. For 0-7 and above they have additional schools and even diplomatic training as 3 stars and above can be assigned to NATO commands.

[@HeadsFullOfEyeballs]

Also, if we're goint to RETVRN TO TRADITION, the officer class is traditionally recruited from the aristocracy, who all received a comprehensive formal education.

[@Suiseisexy]

lol legacy thinking, anything can be procedureized and performed by someone with no education. You will at some point write procedure for your own uneducated replacement. Oh, and your uneducated replacement lacks the monetary means to defend himself in court, so I prefer him in every way to you.

[@naldormight6420]

Even if his assessment was right... how would uneducated, armed and violent men be a good substitute for "elite ivory tower diplomates"? 🤡

[@alexalbuquerquerodriguesal108]

Oh, are you saying that modern militaries relies on scientific knowledge? Crazy, next time you're about to say that a lot of military R&D depends on MIT experts or something. Completely nuts.

[@xionkuriyama5697]

"I'm a 22 year old with no credentials" Yeah we can tell

[@ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45]

I'm 22 and I probably have more credentials as a historian than this sentient boulder.

[@levirognejensen1745]

He got a D in history, but knows real history, which is memorizing the specs of WW2 tanks, especially the German ones.

[@IJustAnimateThatsTheJist]

That and he depends on outdated >1960’s books. No wonder he doesn’t have a clue about geopolitics and history in general lmao

[@teeveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee]

@@levirognejensen1745 Never ask a man his salary, a woman her age, or history fans about their obsession with germany during ww2.

[@Scornfull]

Why does credentials matter?

[@gurugru5958]

"My friends who are body language experts say that a civil war is imminent."

[@daanstrik4293]

If I read this in a parody book I would discard it for being too stupid

[@akkarides]

I wonder if Obami is the plural of Obama

[@MoonshineH]

Actually it’s Obamna

[@10Tabris01]

It should be Obamae, considering Obama is first declension

[@MoonshineH]

@@10Tabris01 Wait, I thought Obamae was the dative case….. maybe I’m confusing it with the declensions in Russian (обамей)

[@DebatingWombat]

@@MoonshineH Aha! So he’s not only a Kenyan and a secret Muslim, but a Russkie and probably ancommie as well! It all makes sense now! /s

[@error5202]

Obamna!

[@void-creature]

He literally feels like a Disco Elysium character, like he somehow escaped out of the game.

[@metetural9140]

I can literally see Harry having a conversation with him about all this conspiracy bullshit while Kim is just facepalming

[@chingoputoh7969]

I can see how you'd get that impression. Rudyard's mannerisms almost seem like a parody of online pseudointellectuals.

[@fredfuckstone914]

He's definitely basing his beliefs on video games.

[@monaambient]

he's literally Gary the Cryptofascist brought to life

[@void-creature]

@@monaambient beads and all!

[@CH4R10T_TV]

"Hitler was LARPing" alright everyone welcome back to our favorite game, "Whatifalthist video or Disco Elysium dialogue?"

[@thelastchannelonyoutube]

"I've stopped going to major cities because the vibes are just too bad" Bro that's the car pollution making you sick Edit: A lot of people seem to think I'm saying that cities don't have problems. I'm not, I'm making fun of Whatifalthist for bragging about his "uncanny empath abilities"

[@nerag7459]

too many black people

[@robert9016]

Pretty sure he is just afraid of black people.

[@pro_154]

I just want you to know I lived in quite a few of the major cities up and down the east coast and I've actually seen the decline in the quality of living. Shill or bot comments like yours just made me believe in his whole speech so much more. Also whatever they're paying you to Gaslight other people like yourself isn't going to be worth it and your great-grandsons life. The wages of sin are death and the sins of the father are passed from who to who

[@winterbliss4459]

@@pro_154Schizophrenia

[@4marra]

@@pro_154actually delusional person

[@dummyxaverie6381]

"The incel revolution" Me suddenly rallying the White Army, and the Freikorps

[@pvknight4014]

"""""revolution"""""

[@andreamarino6010]

Uhm sure ehm kamerade... we are all based right wing here. No communist here

[@brandonmoreland4392]

You just sound soft asf

[@briantarigan7685]

the fact that there are people willing to die because they can't get some coochie is always so funny to me

[@esbenm6544]

@@brandonmoreland4392 👶🍼

[@johnadams3368]

I can't stop laughing at the parts where he started ranting about 'men vs women brains' and the self-aggrandizing of his obvious 'empath' abilities.

[@DMHR100]

was he wrong?

[@AzureDragon158]

@@DMHR100 Yes, Yes, he was very obviously wrong.

[@tuxtitan780]

​@DMHR100 there are some differences between male and female brains. However, they're not super crazy differences, and if you've ever actually interacted with a wide range of people of both genders, you'd realize the differences are pretty subtle. Atleast, they're subtle if they're true. The idea that there's any difference at all between the two has come under scrutiny and been debated for a long time now. One of the critiques and challenges to the idea is that long standing different culture norms/ expectations for the two genders have shaped these differences. Men have always been expected to be better at things like math, and for a long time, women were outright prevented from divulging in advanced mathematics. Meanwhile, women have always been expected to be nicer and more sociable, considering the home keeper and mother role which they have historically been designated, even if they didn't want those roles. So in conclusion, there's a division in academia over whether the idea is actually true or not. However, most research has shown that there are **some** differences in male and female brains structure, and that's likely the cause for the subtle behavioral differences between men and women.

[@user-lt4ty5ij6z]

OH MY SCIENCE FELLOW DINGLEBERRIES DID YOU KNOW THAT WHEN THE EMACIATED SOCIOPATH CHARLATAN BABBLED OUT THIS BRAINLESS WORD SALAD, HE WAS BABBLING THIS?

[@zacheryeckard3051]

​@@DMHR100Demonstrably so, yes.

[@d_trich]

18:30 "I am an empath" The calling card for people who are anything BUT an empath.

[@tbotalpha8133]

It's much like telling people that you're "intelligent", or "the king". If you have to say it out loud for people to know it, then it probably isn't true.

[@Trench216]

Don't mistake empathy for something it's not. The ability to feel another's emotions is not an excuse to accommodate people who hurt others.

[@weiserwolf580]

we call these specimens, psychopaths

[@btarczy5067]

@@tbotalpha8133Now I‘m picturing Joffrey screaming „I am AN EMPATH!“

[@scottduncan92]

Whatifalthist might be autistic, much like Elon Musk, and we all know how empathetic Elon is...

[@mogscugg2639]

He challenged vaush to a second debate after getting owned so hard he manifested a 9 pm doctors appointment as an excuse to dip

[@PlatinumAltaria]

Imagine losing a debate to vaush, that's like losing to Joe Biden.

[@grahamskippy]

​@@PlatinumAltaria Hey wait a minute, I know someone who lost to Biden

[@Kingedwardiii2003]

When did this happen, recently? I saw his idiotic post about it but did he cower out?

[@mogscugg2639]

@@Kingedwardiii2003 oh the post about it is still up, but apparently Fuentes backed out because he wants to handpick a mod

[@justinbeath5169]

​@@Kingedwardiii2003 The debate did happen. Whatifalthist showed up 15 minutes late. He attempted to gish gallup his way through it, but Vaush kept calling him out. About thirty minutes after he got on the call he claimed that he needed to leave in ten minutes to go to a doctor's appointment

[@rikstan15]

Kind of a gigachad move from whatifalthist to just NOT HAVE A CONCLUSION AND JUST END THE VIDEO RANDOMLY

[@danksheev66]

Hearing "have you heard of crypto" immediately lmao

[@joshb6132]

Terrifying jumpscare.

[@johnnydeals]

I mean if I time jump with a cut and skip would make whatever is said sound funny too.😅

[@arpandey698]

Whatifalthist has gone off the rails in recent weeks. He literally made an incoherent manifesto that was more akin to vague platitudes and mystic nonsense than anything concrete. If I were to take a guess, I would assume that a girl broke up with him and now he is making being an incel his primary political philosophy.

[@JaneFleesTexas]

I would guess this happened awhile ago, poor little dude. He’s gotta learn to take breakups a bit easier!

[@ryllo2886]

How's that different than before?

[@Pantherenjoyer]

😂

[@fredjohnson9833]

His manifesto was fucking hilarious.

[@jed_5124]

Everything is about sex with y’all huh

[@PC42190]

“The incel rebellion”, love it. It’s basically astrology for all the incels in Reddit

[@jeffersonclippership2588]

Astrology but it does the kind of tangible harm incels say astrology does

[@briantarigan7685]

the fact that there are people willing to die because they can't get some coochie is always so funny to me

[@President_NotSure]

we're coming out of the basement

[@stripeytawney822]

​@@President_NotSure not before noon... Waiting on mom to get my laundry done.

[@vidzorko4492]

If you think "reddit" is the site with the these problems, you don't know much about incels at all

[@Jon.A.Scholt]

Whatifalthist: Women are sooooo emotional Whatifalthist: His entire view on any political issue is based on emotion instead of empiricism.

[@xibalbalon8668]

He probably thinks all women are into astrology and silly then does this "left hand path magick left-brained = leftist politics" mystical nonsense. I really don't get this nerd

[@miguelpadeiro762]

This is while the whole "culture war" shit in the US is so pathetic, ppl like Ben Shapiro going "ummm actually facts dont care about your feelings I only care about facts and logic" and then proceed to get absolutely triggered when someone doesn't conform to their ultraconservative values like a child

[@balinthehater8205]

​@karaqakkzl I'm going to be honest buddy, I have no idea what you are trying to say, might want to clear that comment up.

[@owenelliott5742]

@karaqakkzl i liked jar jar

[@dftp]

​@karaqakkzlCan you repeat that in English please?

[@walterreeves3679]

The fact that he's 22 explains a lot. Video calls were predicted as long ago as the 1930s. Not much of an intuitive leap considering television was invented in 1927. Likewise, as pointed out, anyone who lived through the 1960s could have predicted continuing racial tension and the eventual legalization of weed. The ultimate acceptance of same sex marriage was implicit in both the movements for Women's liberation and Gay liberation as well. That he is so impressed by such predictions just emphasizes his profound ignorance of the historical context in which they arose.

[@picahudsoniaunflocked5426]

Didn't one of the early or mid-century Worlds Fairs even have a working televisual-phone in a pavilion?

[@Poctyk]

Not to mention "electric cars" (#12) existed for 1/2 of century at that point, before basic economics and technological inperfection screwed them. Predicting that "yeah with better batteries they might come back" isn't that much of a leap. >Fall of USSR Looking at the wiki article about predictions of the Soviet collpse, it was fairly popular in the 60s, and ironically not that popular in the 80s. >China replacing USSR as the main US antagonist Gee, if we remove the prime Communist power, what kind of opponent is left?

[@thunderspark1536]

@@Poctyk Funnily enough China actually learned well from the USSR, that selling stuff to the US instead of fighting them as much works out well.

[@hedgehog3180]

@@picahudsoniaunflocked5426 The New York's World Fair from like the 50s had a working video calling phone.

[@MatecaCorp]

@@Poctyk electric cars in fact existed BEFORE internal combustion cars. Man’s off his trolley. (Or car I suppose)

[@jeffthebovine4158]

‘A great failing of our society is that we need a spreadsheet or scientific study to say what’s obvious to anyone…’ is such a strange Way to say ‘I can’t prove the stuff I say’

[@snood4743]

And he also calls the left unscientific in the same video.

[@yaboye3791]

Lead and CO poisoning are doing a number on that man's brain

[@Utilizador-gs3lx]

this is the most normal ceasar fan

[@Trench216]

@@snood4743 He's never directly said it (I think) but he probably supports COVID denial given the company he keeps.

[@Gyati]

“It’s common sense! It’s common sense!!”

[@mycodingchannel9690]

14th March 1883 - Karl Marx died. WHATIFALTHIST was born on June 23, 2001. Welcome back, Karl Marx. I*cel revolution will feed families, unlike co*munism.

[@zerq4558]

I wonder what he was doing during 9/11

[@mycodingchannel9690]

Damn I feel bad for typing this comment because I'm a Marxist

[@aproxy7263]

ah, coomunism

[@Faehen]

everywhere I go I see r/ultraleft

[@kazaddum2448]

@@zerq4558 Someone had to do it.

[@Hugh-Jassoul]

I honestly, unironically hope that someone close to Whatifalthist finds out what’s going on with him and gets him the help he needs.

[@ThePaleKing47]

You're all overreacting.....

[@DeathToCapitalists]

@@ThePaleKing47I’m not so sure. We all know how the last “incel revolution” guy ended up. He’s clearly very mentally ill and lost in his delusions.

[@albert_obey3151]

@@ThePaleKing47Fr

[@ThePaleKing47]

@AK-Roy-vp6ex Yep

[@hedgehog3180]

@AK-Roy-vp6ex You guys are quick to start fatasizing about being oppressed.

[@Supaawesomeification]

“When I interact with women” I really don’t believe you there bud

[@rahulterwade]

This comment really shows your intellectual capabilities.

[@JoshSweetvale]

I mean he doesn't even buy groceries.

[@madeline6951]

whatifalthist: body language shows there's going to be a civil war me: crouched over like a goblin eating cold noodles

[@HF7-AD]

GOBLINS RISE UP

[@jorvool12527]

Holy shit. Goblin invasion confirmed?

[@falloutjustcause]

The whole no college eduction military thing is insane. broke my head on that one lmao. Most people above 0-2 have master degrees in public admin lmao

[@ianbelanger7459]

The impact of education and experience on battlefield success has actually been tested on a few occasions. The 77th Infantry Division during WW II was an explicit experiment that demonstrated the superior performance of experienced (life in general and not service) and educated soldiers. There was also a post war analysis of the survivability of Second Lieutenants during firefights in Vietnam. Despite the same training, college educated junior officers survived longer.

[@falloutjustcause]

@@ianbelanger7459 I didn’t know that thanks for the info i’ll have to research that more. I mean it just points out the historical revision of reactionaries. Throughout history most professional armies were comprised of well off/ middle class people and they traditionally are just more educated. I think people get stuck on the armies being made of poor people with no options when the data shows us that’s a misconception as well

[@ianbelanger7459]

@@falloutjustcause the sticking point will definitely be the definition of professional soldier/army. I would tend to agree that professional soldiers have generally been well educated, but, depending on the exact historical period or type of conflict, the percentage of professional soldiers compared to the total number of people fighting could be quite small. For example, before WW I, England had an aristocratic officer corps resulting in low quality officers, poorly trained troops and inefficient bureaucracy. During WW II, a lot of soldiers were conscripted. After WWII, most countries transitioned to a professional and volunteer military because the costs of a standing army were outweighed by the advantage of professional soldiers.

[@zeitgeistx5239]

That's what you get from a young white supremacist incel keyboard warrior. The classic I'm a kid and anything outside of my personal worldview and experience simply doesn't exist. Anything I haven't learned about or experienced simply does not exist. Anyone who doesnt look like me or share my culture is just inferior. Classic child like logic.

[@Sky-pg8jm]

West Point isn't real it's a woke conspiracy

[@SemiIocon]

Btw, Whatifalthist doesn't read books more recent than the 60s because according to him, that's when academia was overtaken by postmodernists.

[@Man-of-Steel674]

Imagine if some guy in STEM field said that.

[@thunderspark1536]

@karaqakkzl I'm sorry but the way you phrased it as "history and academia" maybe having a leftist bias makes it sound like the entirety of history, like all of human history, has a liberal bias. Which isn't too off the mark since the world is constantly moving forward one way or another. Staying the same (conserving the present) means you get left behind.

[@bingwen469]

Because they're educated ​@karaqakkzl

[@jaideepshekhar4621]

There was a "study" that cornflakes are better for you than meat.

[@unyu-cyberstorm64]

And even then there’s still a lot of excellent material he simply ignores, if not discredits, that were written before that.

[@RagnellAvalon]

"I have two friends who are professional experts in body language" I nearly choked on my coffee

[@pufffincrazy5275]

His two friends are “me” and “myself”

[@IJustAnimateThatsTheJist]

Considering the fact that “body language” (especially of the human variant) is usually considered pseudoscience, I say it goes great with the rest of his video lol

[@RagnellAvalon]

@@IJustAnimateThatsTheJist yeah that's what drew the reaction out of me lmao

[@paulsmart4672]

How nuts do you gotta be for that comment to just skate by, huh?

[@maciejbala477]

@@pufffincrazy5275 left hand and right hand. They only speak in body language, and they're his hands, and he's an expert, so that makes them both experts on body language. I don't get how you didn't understand that.

[@jmmip202]

Crazy how this guy's got an expert friend in every conceivable field of study just waiting to disclose their valuable insight to him. Half of the evidence he cites is "I have a friend who is an expert in underwater basket-weaving and another who has a PhD in cryptozoology and they both explained to me in no uncertain terms that aliens will make first contact with Earth in the year 2031." Sounds like just some guys in a discord server who have read 500 wikipedia articles about the topic at hand.

[@submersed8434]

He pulled the “at least 70% of 21 year old men are virgins” thing completely out of his ass. No reputable source says that. He’s definitely projecting/compensating

[@maciejbala477]

well if 7 of the grand total of 10 men he's ever interacted with are virgins, then that's clearly an official statistic

[@daanstrik4293]

If that were even remotely true then 3/10 men have either a harem or woman are equally lonely. Neither of those fit his worldview

[@theirs7351]

In an earlier video he brought up a study that showed that 31% of men are not sexually active, then he went "This is clearly understated!" and said that the real numbers were more like 50%, I guess he did the same thing in this video.

[@ZorroVulpes]

I like how he thinks a group of people whose only thing they have in common is inaction due to fear of negative consequences is going to start a war.

[@xibalbalon8668]

The people known for not leaving their rooms or exercising are going to take over the country

[@joeschmo4646]

Clearly not all incels are inactive bro.

[@pugasaurusrex8253]

@@joeschmo4646 Just most of them

[@danskkr]

Funniest thing I've read all week Like I'm too scared to either talk to a girl or make a relationship work. So yeh, I'm obviously well suited to organising a revolution.

[@dustina69]

@@danskkrhe said the incels will be recruited by the “chads”

[@MarcTelang]

"I declare war on the internet. I challenge Nick Fuentes, Vaush, Sneako, Destiny and Hasan to debate. Debates will not exceed an hour, be live and moderated. Jreg has offered to moderate. Anyone who backs down is a coward" "If the Gallic chieftain Brennus was alive today, would you support him for president?" "Favorite mass murderer? Here are the top 5 ranked" -Whatifalthist in the past week

[@priestofronaldalt]

The debate is more about letting Jreg know that he's coming for the title of most insane political KZbinr

[@chewchewtrain]

@@priestofronaldaltNot even Jreg stands a chance in that contest, unfortunately.

[@sophiaerren8253]

@@priestofronaldalt except jreg is whole point is that he says absurd stuff without relieving any genuine political position(last few vids have been more genuine tho,like the irony poisoning one)so for jreg to attend a debate of weird people,even such delusional ones as whatifalthist is pretty normal

[@notme8232]

@@priestofronaldalt Thing is, Jreg is usually right, the topics he chooses to be right about just happen to be totally post-ironically insane.

[@ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45]

"$1,000,000, or the chance to wait on this table?" _The table is all of these people_ "I'll take the $1,000,000 please."

[@nerd7834]

Sometimes brain damage is fun to watch sometimes it’s painful.

[@wumbojet]

First KZbinr to get CTE from making videos

[@maciejbala477]

Both? Both. We want both.

[@Agentsmiskatonic]

Out of everything he has said, him saying he has 2 friends is the most unbelievable.

[@timv9223]

As hominem

[@scyobiempire4450]

him saying he has friends*

[@Agentsmiskatonic]

@@scyobiempire4450 I commented before the 3rd friend was mentioned. I can't believe he can claim he has at least 3 friends without cracking

[@HelmsmenL]

​@@timv9223 why are you not taking one of the least respectable human beings alive seriously?

[@timv9223]

@@HelmsmenL because what he has to say is interesting

[@andrewkent6402]

"The population needs a Civil War to prevent them from killing themselves" WHAT?! WHAT THE FUCK DOES HE THINK HAPPENS IN WAR?!

[@kristofferhaugstad7616]

He is referring to killing itself spiritually

[@MatecaCorp]

@@kristofferhaugstad7616 war of course has famously positive impact on the spirits of people

[@mkvenner2]

Probably that other people die and he reaps the benefits. When in reality he the odds of him surviving is in the single digits.

[@legitplayin6977]

Omg, I’ve been having a very shitty depressive episode lately and holy shit, “Obomi” has taken me right out of it. Thank you whatifalthist, you cured my depression

[@OhioMan1854]

Whatifalthists make the cringe, Freddas critique the cringe, we are in perfect balance. But seriously glad you got that depression fought back for the time being. Clinically depressed myself, feeling ok today for the first time in days.

[@legitplayin6977]

@@OhioMan1854 Yeah I wouldn’t I’m feeling “ok” but “Obomi” does provide a welcome distraction by giving me a laughter attack whenever I think about it. Also glad you’re doing better

[@stripeytawney822]

​@@OhioMan1854 sunlight gentlemen, it helps my depression. Mostly.

[@tbotalpha8133]

@@stripeytawney822 I find exercise helps, too. Not arguing that it's a cure-all, mind you. Most things that help with depression have to be done alongside other helpful things, to have the desired effect.

[@stripeytawney822]

@@tbotalpha8133 agreed. Getting myself moving to exercise is a bit of a trick unto itself though. A good laugh, a little exercise, some sunlight.

[@UrsusUrsa]

"I can play the emotions of the crowd like a musician." - Neckbeard basement-dweller

[@paulsmart4672]

Ah, but have you considered... perhaps he is simply conducting a symphony of scorn and disgust?

[@Haispawner]

That is the most 2015 r/atheism ass quote my god

[@daneater957]

The analogy about the woman begging her boyfriend to beat her is unhinged for two main reasons. 1. It pretty much displays Whatifalthist's disbelief of and disdain for women. 2. Even IF the girlfriend was literally asking her boyfriend to beat her, that doesn't make it legal for him to do so...

[@TheGahta]

2. Ist that exactly what makes it legal? (assuming it can be proven afterwards ofc) Otherwise you pretty much invalidate all forms of competetive combat sports and some other run off effects

[@daneater957]

@@TheGahta No. There is a contextual difference between combative sports (I.E. Boxing) and a woman literally asking her boyfriend to beat her. That is, combative sports involve contractual agreements that specify the possibility (and probability) of physical injury and the latter situation does not.

[@TheGahta]

@@daneater957 the contractual thing is a red herring, they exist for comercial purposes Explain the distinction between A women ask Partner to hit her B a Person askd for another to hit them (sparring matches for example) You cant draw on intention since that cant be shown unless there is a difference in how both (intentional an unintentional) act on the victim

[@daneater957]

@@TheGahta Sparring matches are a socially agreed upon norm that actually occur on a regular basis in the world. A woman asking a partner to hit her, at least to the extent that it gets to the level of abuse, doesn't. There is kink that involves physicality, but there is usually stipulations that come alongside that. The hypothetical you're creating doesn't have any such stipulations. Debate bros are the worst.

[@naldormight6420]

My (limited) understanding is that it is about consent and "actual harm". But yeah. Women should stay clear of the guy for their own savety. Also funny how th incels feel the need to so agressively selfreport.

[@kayleighlehrman9566]

WIAH has Classical Greek Historian understanding of history, historiography, and sociology; "it was revealed to me in a dream"

[@orangmawas3858]

That's unfair, historians like Thucydides had a way better method of researching than this guy.

[@terrifictomato262]

“Seize the means of reproduction!”

[@seangambogi7901]

from each according to her attractiveness, to each according to his horniness

[@maciejbala477]

i lol'ed, that's a genius line, thanks for sharing lmfao

[@jangamecuber]

@@seangambogi7901 4channers of the world unite

[@eyesofthecervino3366]

GET OUT!

[@ninyaninjabrifsanovichthes45]

@@eyesofthecervino3366 It's not the Miyagi-Do way

[@tomasjakovac7950]

We must keep up the fight to promote Obomi Thought with Female Characteristics

[@senlim8461]

i have been WAITING for an incel revolution video response, that video was so terrible i had to watch it over multiple sessions to take it all in, literally turned off my phone when he started talking about how women only want bad boys

[@3p1Kf41L]

Why do goooood girls waaaant baaad guyss??

[@FreddaYT]

This isn't a detailed response to that one specifically, I think I could make another WIAH video in a bit based on some of the recent stuff he's done though.

[@renlevy411]

​@@FreddaYTBased

[@JaneFleesTexas]

@@FreddaYTOh please do! Your criticisms make his videos hilarious and educational…😊 I tried watching some just on their own and it’s too infuriating.

[@Pantherenjoyer]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@TwizzTBD]

i get the feeling that whatifalthist wants a civil war because it happened in his hoi4 millenium dawn game and he thought "huh this is cool" and is now trying to cope it into existence

[@niftyrobo]

He wants it because he thinks it'll get him laid

[@CaesarGhost2030]

its inevitable if we cant cope anymore

[@this_isnt_patrick]

“Hitler was LARPing conquering Eastern Europe.” It’s off to a fucking fantastic start

[@iBullyDemons]

It was just a LARP bro

[@BudewFan_]

I’m convinced whatifalthist’s only real source is a pipe loaded with some WILD strain of devil’s lettuce

[@JoshSweetvale]

Nah, it's a puree of pseudofascist agitprop he's regurgitating like a grass cow.

[@zakselbert6890]

Bros definitely way too dorky to be smoking weed he seems like the type to snitch on kids he sees doing it tho😂

[@Akapaco2]

He was definitely the kid that reminded the teacher that we had homework!!

[@Xenomorthian]

​@@Akapaco2I can't hold the guilt in anymore I was the kid who did that /srs

[@4mazIngxXGamEr]

What's so funny about 8:53 is that battlefield commissions existed but now they don't. If you are a noncommissioned officer seeking a promotion into commissioned status you need to finish a bachelor degree. Not a single one of the joint chiefs of staff in our recent history was able to become a general or such a high ranking officer without a bachelor's degree or training at a naval academy or at a military academy. "Right prefers non-college educated military" is such a moronic statement that either whatifalthist doesn't know about high ranking military officials or know anything about the American political elite from both sides of the aisle... they both are college educated. 99 and 94% of our legislature is college educated.

[@thefluffymunchkin5430]

Hearing him say "yeah women don't need proof of them being abused anymore" then following it up with "a bunch of my friends have been accused of abuse and I didn't believe any of the accusations" is SO FUCKING TELLING about this guy's mentality.

[@scooble_]

I can't wait to see what crime against academia he made this time

[@kormagogthedestroyer]

“As I explain in this text wall” is an absolutely wild wing to say in a video essay. Like my man cannot even bother to edit an extra minute into his 30 minute slideshow to explain his points

[@taiwanisacountry]

As a sinologist I can tell you that, the Chinese emperor was often very much aware of the revolutions and invasions, even the invasion of the northern Song dynasty by the mongols. That was an invasion that was only 100km long. That is practically nothing on horse back. But the army generals and the emperor knew it, but there were still nothing he could do, because the Northern Song was purely focused on culture, science, legal studies and trade, they barely had a military. So they could not do anything. That is 1000 years ago.

[@DinggisKhaaniMagtaal]

Based username, and awesome summary. Took two courses in Bronze Age Chinese archaeology and I miss every minute of it

[@chriss780]

Chinese History is Rich varied, fascinating and covers a period of thousands of years and anytime you hear an american start talking about it you know you are going to here some of the dumbest shit imaginable

[@jackthorton10]

Bronze Age Chinese Archaeological…. wow 😮

[@kazaddum2448]

@@DinggisKhaaniMagtaal Based unsername? Taiwan is not a country. It's an island and part of China. The selfproclaimed (it is no longer the recongized government fo China by almost all nations on earth) country thereon is the Republic of China, which is in a state of cold civil war with the peoples Republic of China over who is the correct government of China. Neither considers "Taiwan" a country. The user name is wrong on the level of the Whatifalthist dude. Maybe don't ignore modern chinese history over ancient one.

[@thunderspark1536]

@@kazaddum2448 Taiwan is the name of the island, so it's shorthand for the ROC.

[@Sam_Markley]

Wishing all of Freddacord a very pleasant Certified Proletarian Classic

[@peoplesrepublicofliberland5606]

Incel Revolution: "Virgins of the world, Unite"

[@aaroncruz9181]

Pov : when the price of living is death itself :

[@g.lucchio5660]

"We are gonna have a Civil War!! At any moment! Any moment. Any moment... In 3, 2... 1.5? [Awkward silence] 1.25?"

[@eternalcanadiandevyt]

Whatifalthist has been getting progressivley crazier over time and im totally here for it.

[@naldormight6420]

Wanna bet on when and for what he is gonna get arrested?

[@asdf-sr1ny]

@@naldormight6420 I feel like it’s going to be something that will leave everyone dumbstruck given how bat-shit insane he is. His “Logic” makes sense only to him.

[@hedgehog3180]

@@naldormight6420 drunk driving.

[@aproxy7263]

Abandon ideology, embrace larpism

[@thegreatcollector4548]

Alt’s resources are vibes and backs up his sources with “I am the center of the world and everything flows around me so Im always right”

[@priestofronaldalt]

Until his channel crashes his God complex only stands to grow.

[@Johntology]

WIAH's sources consist of the eNotes readings of 'the Decline of the West' by Oswald Spengler and a crackpipe

[@xibalbalon8668]

It really shows off the conservative mindset in the perfect way. He's a white Christian conservative 22 year old, so he can easily not think about how black people didn't have equal rights in this country and scoff at all the crazy leftists talking about racism, but men his age not having sex is a BIG deal to him that WILL have dire consequences

[@Suiseisexy]

Actually that that his views and situation are alarmingly common seems salient enough. The left can't conduct a conversation about topics it can't engage with, one is anti-natalism, it can't disengage denials of racist theorycraft from genuine questioning if environmentalists have walked into some kind of Malthusian trap, which really isn't a paranoid question in the slightest with anti-human "green" styles well in place on the left. Pseudoholy how-dare-you-even-ask handwaves aren't going to hold back suspicions from increasingly extreme humanist atheists upon increasingly extreme environmentalist atheists. Look at it like this: delete all identarian elements from the equation and leave just money, assume the various identities work it out and we get back to the moment of Occupy Wallstreet was at before the SJW false flag arrived. It becomes a conflict about wealth, childbirth and the future of Earth that absolutely nobody is ready for and there's his Final Conflict, freed from his youth and his neurosis.

[@naldormight6420]

Litteraly: "I know a dude who told me!" 😂🤡

[@seb-fluffysnowcap9530]

The lack of sex can be easily explained by saying the economy is fucked and the young don't have enough time, money and energy. Which can all be shown by young people abandoning pubs due to cost.

[@orangmawas3858]

Also socio-political polarization between the sexes.

[@seb-fluffysnowcap9530]

@@orangmawas3858 I was intentionally avoiding anything that could be connected to the culture, and focusing on material conditions.

[@vanillabatcave5677]

there's a general decrease of human connections, and friends in general, like, who are you gonna bang if you know no one?

[@hedgehog3180]

Pretty sure that it's also more just of a trend towards people having their sexual debut at a later age which is probably more likely to be a result of better sex education leading people to make more informed choices about having sex. Usually the very early sexual debuts (before the age of 15) are something that people regret and are usually a result of a lack of proper education about sex. Also as a culture we have started to lift much of the many stigmas around sex so younger people probably just feel more secure in valueing their own comfort and won't rush to have sex just to be able to say they're no longer a virgin. Also of course asexuality is slowly becoming more and more accepted so there's tons of people who now feel comfortable completely opting out of sexual relations.

[@somedipshtinthecomments2507]

"The vibes are worse than they have been in any other time in my life" YOU'RE FUCKING 22!!!

[@cabnbeeschurgr]

"I remember the very bad vibes when I was several months old after 9/11..."

[@eedeneel]

It's actually kind of sad. He is just spiralling, getting more and more extreme and higher and higher on his own supply, that now he won't go to big cities because "the vibes are just too bad". Bro it's YOU that has the bad vibes. Get some help. Start therapy

[@jacobnoelle8428]

Therapy wouldn't help because therapy only work if the person WANT to change

[@SamuelAnderson-vz7fe]

8:57 he hates higher education because he is simple and dumb, I hate higher education because I’m broke and didn’t like school. We are not the same

[@Man-of-Steel674]

😂😂

[@coolman6139]

Based.

[@rugops6549]

Most of the comments in this video are just petty and particularly mean insults towards him. You guys don’t realize you sound more insecure then he does.

[@MatecaCorp]

@@rugops6549 calling people insecure because they call someone else insecure gives off strong insecure vibes ngl

[@Eltipoquevisteayer]

How can someone regress so much intellectualy and spiritually? He sounds... broken

[@error5202]

Was he ever there in the first place though?

[@Eltipoquevisteayer]

@@error5202 He was just a nerdy dork before, now he is teetering on the line of unhinged and/or lolcow

[@notrod5341]

​@Eltipoquevisteayer Check his comments. Dude's audience is making him think he's a genius and not some guy just saying stuff on the Internet.

[@lucasmatiasdelaguilamacdon7798]

He’s a victim of the internet to some degree. Anyone can be a lolcow at a young age. I once was. Then I went to college, started an actual major in history, started actually getting challenged and questioned harshly on my similar very vague assumptions. He’s surrounded by yes-men, and people who I can’t shake the feeling are trolls wanting him to get more unhinged fir their amusement. I believe a huge portion of his audience are just throwing coal into the fire for enjoyment, the guy is young and impressionable, and it seems he’s been made into a lolcow by his own audience. This is something you’d see back in the day in the Somethingawful forums.

[@xibalbalon8668]

I feel like a lot of people were like him once, including me. Pretentious teenage history nerds who fantasize about being some renowned intellectuals. Most people grow out of it once they realize they don't know everything, but WhatIf built an online personality off it that rewards him for staying like this.

[@digitaldevilshitposts6731]

"I'm a 22 year old with no credentials" Holy shit, he's a year younger than me

[@DestructorN7]

2 years younger than me, surprising given the amount of confidence he has in his insanity

[@jacobnoelle8428]

Me too. What the fuck.

[@thechin9241]

I dont think a niche internet group of creepers is capable of being effective foot soldiers for any insurgency

[@epikbearcz7962]

15% of the world population

[@segasaturndude8945]

The alt rightists on 4chan can hardly walk a kilometer

[@Firebringer121]

@ 21:30 I remember having a "let them eat cake" moment happen to me when I was talking about having a root canal and not being able to afford to go to the dentist. A friend told me straight up "You should go anyways, your health is important." No shit man, its not that I don't want to go to the dentist, I can't go to the dentist because I can't pay for it.

[@agreatmanlookingtotheright]

The question is would you rather not afford the treatment now or not afford the consequences from a lack of treatment later.

[@hedgehog3180]

@@agreatmanlookingtotheright Do you understand how money works?

[@jacobnoelle8428]

Ah the "shoes" problem en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boots_theory

[@jtojagicc]

the sad thing about whatifalthistory isn't that he's dumb, it's that 600k people think he's smart

[@ctnke]

are you sure all of the 600k people isn’t subscribed because they think his videos are the funniest shit they have ever seen? He unironically says the most funny stuff

[@jacobnoelle8428]

He might have also paid for bots.

[@mitchellskene8176]

Prime example of why he should have stuck to alternate history.

[@bamboozled9127]

"I often hear stories of the Chinese Emperors..." had me deceased

[@RedTRM]

About halfway through the video, and one thing I'll say that's kinda funny is that Fredda sounds much happier and more animated in this one than the last time, but Whatifalthist sounds EXTRA depressed this time Edit: I would like an analysis of the Incel Revolution video, and thanks for making this video!

[@Ganzier]

About ha-ACK!!!!

[@timv9223]

Irrelevant to your comment, but gender doesn’t exist and only sex does. You are the sex you were born as and nothing can change that

[@0Kubus0]

Fredda breaking Whatifalthist news! He just got mental breakdown!

[@alexbattaglia8297]

whoa bro predicted China turning to Maoism? What is he over 100 years old?

[@Sam-hd7iy]

my btich mother: "go outside and play" me: "NO MOM THE VIBES ARE OFF"

[@noradrenalin8062]

Have you seen his manifesto, that has an ad segment in it. He calls it his most important work and that he is one of maybe five people world wide who can influence the American right. And then he cuts to an ad. I can't even...

[@hewhomustnotbenamed5912]

I love the idea of saying that the Soviets were "larping" revolution. They killed the old leaders, fought an extremely violent civil war against counterrevolutionaries who were received both foreign weapons and troops for aid, and they industrialized an agricultural nation in just 9 years (the first 2 5-year plans). It seems to me that they actually did do a revolution, regardless of how a person calling it "larping" feels about that revolution. If they're referring to the Bolshevik party "larping" before the actual revolution started, that also seems silly. They were outlaws who robbed banks and distributed works advocating revolution. What more could they have done before the rest of the people joined them?

[@thunderspark1536]

Soviets: We did a little too much trolling

[@hedgehog3180]

Tbf there is definitely many chapters in the history of Russian socialism that can be described as LARPing, like the Going To The People.

[@hewhomustnotbenamed5912]

@@hedgehog3180 they distributed a large amount of farmland from their former owners to the actual farmers working them. Many factories were placed under the management of worker coops, thus giving workers immediate control over their own lives as well as income proportional to their productivity. A large proportion of government positions were taken by working people who were nominated by a coop or representative council, etc. They did start repealing some of these later after the 2nd World War. That's why there isn't a USSR. Cuba performed better in this regard. Once their democratic institutions were sufficiently developed, Cuba got rid of their Communist Party's government functions and the party's ability to nominate candidates for office. Recall that the USSR existed for 69 years. So there's plenty of time for the intentions of the party to change. But in the pre 2nd World War period, they were undoubtedly invested in giving the people more power. They did so in undeniable economic ways, and the political ways they did it were undoubtedly more serious than anything that's happened under Capitalism, even if one reasonably argues that too much political power was left to the party.

[@siluda9255]

If he is a empath i am a psyker from 40k

[@richardvlasek2445]

into the throne with you

[@siluda9255]

@@richardvlasek2445 t-this seem tô be a m-mistake, when i filled form tô volunteer my body and soul to the emperor i thought i would join the astra-militarum

[@thedoruk6324]

@@siluda9255 my dude you are assuredly gonna have so much fun and wholesome moments with the sisters of silence and the black ship fleet ! Unless you born some unknown lost human colony planet

[@vitaliitomas8121]

@@siluda9255 if you refuse to serve in the throne, you will serve in firing line!

[@maciejbala477]

yeah bruh he clearly has no clue what it means whatsoever... if anything he is the opposite, or he is what he thinks an empath is, which is some kind of psychic attuned to society trends or some telepathic shit. Much like the communism video, source is crack pipe

[@Aryasvitkona]

0:06 Well you ALMOST won your bet, though it wasn't the deep state lmao

[@cabnbeeschurgr]

I mean the fbi yoinked the body and burned it so I wouldn't discount it

[@wilson1889]

Whatifalthist actually went off the deep end after this one huh

[@paulsmart4672]

"A great failing of our society is that the data contradicts my feelings."

[@RJKilroy]

I wouldn’t be surprised if he actually said that

[@paulsmart4672]

@@RJKilroy Not in exactly those words, but he did kinda say it.

[@martyr_lightsilver1833]

That's completely fair. You can always change things that will, in turn, change the data.

[@ZloyIfrit]

“My friend are experts in face mimics and posturing. They predict civil war” OMG, he is serious on this

[@gjeggi6760]

I'll be honest. I have watched most of his videos, and i got something of value from them. Introducing me to the historical cycles for one. Him comparing the 21st century with the 17th century. I have watched all of your videos on Whatifalthist, to see what other people thought of him or what he was criticized for. Something in the back of my mind has always felt like something was missing, and your videos answered them. I believe your criticism of him are valid. So, thanks!

[@Piratewaffle43]

I exhibit civil war body language 24/7.

[@soquality9405]

Whats up gamers

[@suspicioususer]

His sources are unironically "It was revealed to me in a dream"

[@hansvalen]

Women are more emotional than men, but I won’t go to major cities because of the vibes 🤔

[@connorgventer6489]

@FreddaYT So the US ARMY is traditionally divided into Enlisted and Officer ranks as follows. E1‐Private E2-Private second class E3-Private first class E4-Specialist/Corporal E5-Sergeant E6-Staff Sergeant E7-Sergeant first class E8-Master Sergeant/ First Sergeant E9-Sergeant Major O1-Second Lieutenant O2-First Lieutenant O3-Captain O4-Major O5-Lieutenant Colonel O6-Colonel O7-Brigadier General O8-Major General O9-Lieutenant General O10-General of the ARMY (This is not the literal head of the ARMY) Theoretically you can do all of enlisted ranks without college, however higher education makes you a better prospect for promotion so it's not uncommon uncommmon even as low as E4.

[@connorgventer6489]

Addendum there are also Warrant officers WO1 - WO5, these are different from Officers in the traditional sense in they don’t hold commissions but "Warrants" instead but this population is also highly educated like both the commissioned and non-commissioned officer classes. Financial assistance for education is major draw for enlistment and pursuit of higher education is professionally incentivised in the US Military, whatifalthist is on crack if he thinks the armed forces are full of the uneducated.

[@hedgehog3180]

Imagine looking at the military that operates nuclear powered carriers with electromagnetic catapults operating wings of stealth fighters and saying that it is uneducated. My guy do you know what a nuclear reactor is?

[@spamfilter32]

I find it interesring that Whatifalthist listes a Strength of the Left that the vast majority of the richest countries are Left. I mean, if that were true, shouldn't that tell him something about the Right and economics?

[@danielhanna19]

It's like he's trying to prove himself wrong

[@polygonvvitch]

I'm larping watching this youtube video.

[@red..ridding..h00d]

😭😭

[@princekyle4132]

Love your pfp. I too like Owl House :3

[@danielhanna19]

I'm only larping replying to you

[@warlordofbritannia]

He's getting worse. I didn't know it was possible. He's rapidly degenerating into mysticism and Splengerism. Edit: Omg, he's actually talking about "cycles of civilizations"

[@kazaddum2448]

And he's just 21!

[@warlordofbritannia]

@karaqakkzl In my professional opinion, Spengler was bunk. His view of history was inherently bad and the only way you should bring up Spengler is in a historiographical sense (ie, the history of studying history).

[@weiserwolf580]

@@kazaddum2448 basically he is the answer to Q: "why don't we let children vote?" A: "because you get this sort of mentality!"

[@warlordofbritannia]

@karaqakkzl That’s way too reductive, inaccurate, and kinda racist…all synonyms for Spengler, come to think of it

[@pufffincrazy5275]

He’ll be singing the praises of Hyberborea soon enough

[@dv8me666]

Man, whatifalthis has so many unnamed friends in highly specialized fields that all have been studying and also perfectly agree with his hyper niche politics. They should meet my girlfriend from Canada. They'd get along so well!

[@Ryzard]

There wont be a civil war or revolution because everyone is too comfortable. That's the main inciting factor - everyone being uncomfortable and angry. Being angry and confortable just makes people rant over the news.