Frugal Fridayz | Best & Worst Drugstore Makeup Removers

[@carolineg.4455]

Thank you so much for being a Porcelain Goddess. Although there is nothing wrong with going tanning or fake tanning, you don't know how much I appreciate seeing a woman like me. I've not always felt to confident about my skin color, and I've even tried everything to change it. Just watching your videos inspire me to embrace my Scottish heritage! Much love Zabrena! ❤️

[@YoutubeInes]

It's super sad to read that. Just embrace who you are, no matter what society wants to put in your mind :)

[@fabianledger1666]

I guess Im randomly asking but does any of you know of a method to get back into an instagram account..? I somehow lost my login password. I love any help you can give me

[@Blackandwhitepolkadots2828]

I've really been impressed by the new Garnier micellar water too! There's a formula for waterproof makeup and it's amazing! 🙂

[@janedoe7187]

Please do the video about only cleansing oils!

[@meagankominczak8050]

holding the makeup removing wipes next to my eyes like you mentioned has worked so well for me! I had thought about it before but since I hadn't really heard of anyone else doing it that way I didn't really think about it again so I'm so glad you mentioned it! It's such a good tip because it not only breaks the makeup down it reduces the rubbing near your eyes too which is always great! Thank you for the tip! :)

[@chempanda6388]

the green simple bottle one seems pretty good for the price point and its quite natural. i may look into that one when i finally use up all of my other makeup cleansing solutions

[@LindseyZal]

Interesting that you thought Neutrogena was one of the worst. I've always used that makeup remover, and thought it was one of the best, I guess I need to keep looking to find something better! Thanks again for the great review, as usual, Zebrena!

[@livin4jc3]

The new Garnier micellar water with the blue cap for waterproof works super well and doesn't leave that blurry oily feel. I went through many bottles of the Boots Brightening remover before, but I think I'll use the Garnier from now on since it's a bigger bottle. :)

[@BathingTime]

I can't stop listening to you speak! You annunciate so well and so clearly! I love it. Thanks for the amazing video

[@Zabrena]

+Sara Dirani Thank you, Sara! Props go to Dad for that, he'll be very happy to hear that!

[@ivanna1019]

I love that, too, but then get startled when Zabrena randomly yells something out, hahahha. Sorry! Not gonna stop watching ever, so it's fine.

[@BathingTime]

Papa raised you well!! The you speak very fluidly. Amazing!

[@Hannahkaykayable]

This was perfect!!! People always tell me how amazing neutrogena makeup remover is and I have never loved it because of the residue! I just bought the maybelline and now I know I need to return it. Thank you! Please continue to do videos like this! We need this!

[@erinhigginson1090]

your hair! love it you look so classy & beautiful! ☺😘

[@Zabrena]

+Erin Higginson Thank you so much, Erin! :)

[@TheMKEWERBY]

+Zabrena I think I would go with the Garnier, myself, as it is the brand of those I have the most experience with. Nice eyes, too. are they contacts? hope not!

[@Zabrena]

+Michael Werbovetz (81GMC2500) thank you! No, not contacts :)

[@TheMKEWERBY]

Didn't think so! Personally if I had to judge them for what I need my glasses for & from a religious standpoint I'd say contacts are blasphemy. do you wear anything other than sunglasses?

[@fierceANM]

+Michael Werbovetz (81GMC2500) contacts are blasphemy? Thats a new perspective ._.

[@chiklitz]

All of Simple's products are amazing! I have the most hyper sensitive skin and I love how my skin feels with their stuff

[@mayrar.4776]

I LOVE how you have the picture of your cat framed on the table! He does not look happy but still looks precious! LOL i would love if you did a video on cleansing oils :) Neutrogena and Burts Bees each released on in the past few months, cleansing oils are for sure my favorite way to remove heavy makeup

[@karenmccreary4538]

Eye makeup remover is meant to be used first, then cleanse your entire face, there is NOTHING left after that ! I had same Neutrogena experience ; was going to go back to L'Oréal (Lancôme) until I saw that Garnier Cleansing Oil. WOW!! did that ever do the job. I was a makeup artist/rep years ago and really learned a lot, got to try a lot and taking off your eye products first was repeated over and over. I wish I didn't know so much sometimes ! I also wish I didn't have about another week's worth of Neutrogena stuff to use ! Thanks for all your work, it is top drawer.

[@melaniefarrow7152]

You are so naturally pretty. Without makeup you look like you popped out of a classic painting.

[@Riche1094]

I love this series, keep up the great work. Maybe you can do a battle between all the brow mascaras that there are. Theres Maybelline, Milani, Nyx, Loreal, Ulta, ect and its so hard to choose.

[@bizzybmama]

I love the garnier oil especially if you have dry skin in the winter. I use the simple too! Both are fantastic! I use the neutrogena ones just for my eye make up. Great video! I love these type because it introduces me to new items to look for.

[@lisac1385]

Your look in this video is absolutely stunning!! Do you have a video showing the eye look??

[@elichan7919]

Love your new look Zabrena! More sophisticated and exquisite

[@bethknapp5838]

I use Systane lid cleanser wipes, I have very sensitive eye lids and the lid wipes remove all of the eye makeup and keep my eyelids from getting irritated. Then I use Simple micelar cleanser to remove my face makeup before washing my face. They are both keeping my skin in very good shape so far after 3 weeks, love this combo.

[@christopherm6805]

First time I've seen the deeper red hair. I love it! And the style. Classy.

[@denisefincher15]

I have used Mary Kay's makeup remover for many years and I love it. I will continue to purchase it but I also love the Simple Micellar water, and Boscia's Makeup Breakup oil.

[@PriyaTilkar]

Wow...you really did an awesome job...you have put in so much effort in it...great... Love it

[@dianariv9761]

I lovvveee how high quality your videos are! There isn't a lot of editing like other KZbin videos that I watch, others are very choppy and tbh difficult to watch it can get annoying. You're personality and just the way you present yourself is so fun and I just really enjoy all of your videos:)

[@Lora-Lynn]

I purchased the Garnier skin active micellar cleansing water with the blue cap... works great, no burning of my sensitive skin. Great hair cut btw!

[@monacoia8294]

You got my favorite the Garnier facial oil! I also use it on my beauty blender to break up some of those stubborn stains of makeup.

[@peggyroher6157]

Thanks for including the color of your polish....I was going to ask. I'm a polish junkie and love your choices! Great video....I'm going to try the cleansing oil! 😉

[@kickchick5683]

Love you zabrena!! Could you do a best & worst of the simple brand??

[@alisa1727]

i was soo nervous to hear about your review on the simple brand micellar water! Im on my third bottle and i just love it! So happy that you reviewed all of these, because i wanna try so many more!

[@ladyflimflam]

The Loreal green clean artiste is the same formula, or nearly so, as the Lancôme Bi-facile remover that is widely reputed to be the bee's knees.

[@SarahBelenO]

that lipstick matches you PERFECTLY, specially with your hair and pale skin. you look gorgeous!

[@jennag7650]

I use baby oil only on the eyes and follow up with the oil free Almay wipes to remove any excess oil. It erases every single trace of eye makeup down to the smallest molecule. I prefer just to use a warm wet wash cloth and a gentle cleanser for the face.

[@yloshaw]

I've been using the Garnier oil for months. Their moisturizers are pretty good as well! Love your channel!

[@CarlaRoberts102956]

I love the simple brand. have used it for a while but I also love the Neutrogena remover wipes. Have also used them for years and they do a great job of removing makeup.

[@chasingautumns]

I've started using those Makeup Eraser cloths - they work! And less crap in our landfills!

[@bflower8830]

Loved this video!!!!!! Can you do a Best & Worst of cleansing oils ...Then micellar waters?

[@TheSarahLindy]

I just found the Garnier Micellar water at Walgreens in my area! They have one that is just the cleansing water (with a pink lid) and one that has the dual-suspension (with a blue lid). I never wear waterproof makeup, so the one with the pink cap is the one I purchased, and its great! Glad to see this formula finally making it to the states, because i love it! Better value for money because there are more fl oz than the Simple, and works just as well!

[@hannahshmulsky7119]

Super helpful! I've been using the Neutrogena for ages and not been that happy with it; I use a 50/50 mix of jojoba and olive oil to remove my mascara, what a pain in the butt. I don't always want to deal with oils and oily residue...so nice to know my options, thank you!!

[@StephanieElayne]

I love the neutrogena ultra light cleansing oil, very similar to that garnier one

[@laurencedeno5473]

Zabrena, the best makeup remover I've ever used is actually a creamy facial cleanser from Lush called Ultrabland! You massage it on your face and then remove with a warm wash cloth and it works perfectly! I would love if you reviewed Lush products too!

[@raniat4343]

I would love to see a cleansing oil compare/review. I picked up the berts bees cleansing oil today. I'm stuggling with super dry skin right now and hoping it helps. Thanks for all you do!

[@yayallewellyn9997]

i've been using the Garnier cleansing oil for a year now and i LOVE LOVE LOVE it!! the main secret of using it is to rinse it off a little at a time. but yeah ya definitely do not have to wash your face again after it.:-D love ya Zabrena!! thanks for all you're doing for us!! much appreciated :-D

[@debbiem6406]

P.S. Tried the L’Oreal Clean Artiste and absolutely love it. Thank you!! The best remover especially for long-wearing eye makeup that I’ve ever tried (and I mean over decades). Wow! It works fast. Your trick to hold the pad on the eye for a few seconds is great. And, how it doesn’t leave any oily feel is truly a mystery. Now I need to find really good disposable remover rounds or pads.

[@denisef3228]

Hi Zabrena. My experience with Micellar waters, so far, has been that it is pretty good at cleaning off most of my makeup but just doesn't work well on waterproof mascara. I end up using my long time fave, the Mary Kay makeup remover.

[@Bkillaa]

I love your videos as well as how organized & detailed you are about the products! You get yourself a new subscriber! ❤️

[@kimberlyplayer]

I don't wear falsies but I do stand by my Pond's cold cream. I may try something else one day but I like the way it smells, the way it gets all the gunk off and how it feels on my skin. It's smells just like the Hello Hydration face cream so I don't have a bunch of different scents giving me a headache. I love it!

[@heathergirtz2750]

I love using the Simple wipes to remove my makeup and then in the morning I use the Simple micellar water to clean my face instead of doing a full cleanse like I do at night. I really love the micellar water because it doesn't dry out my face and leaves my skin feeling refreshed. I personally don't think it takes of my makeup that well but I'm glad it worked for you!

[@justStardust940]

all of your videos are super enjoyable and helpful! my fav beauty guru by far!

[@kathybrou1340]

I watched this when it came out. Bought three of your recommendations. Loved them . You have saved me tons. I use to use Clinique's. It was expensive and I wasn't that happy with it. Loreal, Lumene, and Studio 35. Loved Loreal best.

[@ElleIsForLiving]

The hair! Love these videos! I love oils for removing make up. ♥ Elle

[@OpheliaXo]

I get so excited seeing a drugstore video every Friday!

[@Zabrena]

+OpheliaXo Whoo hoooo!!!

[@sandratati13]

Can you do a best and worst cotton pads??

[@education461]

Cotton pads are all bad for you and the environment! Use simply a make up sponge and wash it with soap. It is the most gentle thing you can use to clean your face and you can use it so many times if you wash it.

[@nicolepostier4534]

Zabrena, I was hoping you might do an updated version of makeup removers please?!

[@LYDISANC21]

Thank you!! I have been looking for a comparison video on the make up removers. I love using Dermalogica PreCleanse! It is similar to the last one that you used and it takes EVERYTHING off in one application. I bought it last year at Ulta. Hands down my go to, but I have to now get my hands on that Simple one so I can switch off.

[@boredpeanutable]

I use that Garnier cleansing oil and have done so most of 2015. I rarely re-purchase skincare, but that I'll keep buying. I sometimes follow it with Garnier's new micellar water or use the water only when traveling. I find it more effective than Simple's version and it is also a better value. Finally I'm a brand new subbie and I love your vids!

[@Withloveariaxo]

I'm gonna try the Garnier cleansing oil! I'm having so much trouble removing the last traces of my HG covergirl supersizer waterproof mascara!

[@kimberlyherring9784]

Thank you! this video was so helpful. I wonder if you're going to post a video in the future on facial cleansers/exfoliaters 😊

[@Starofthecity12Blogspot]

Love your makeup in this video Z! Your skin looks flawless too.

[@jiannabenedetti9752]

Love this review of removers! Also, thank you for placing the name of each remover on the screen while it was under review & we watched you using it. Thant is so helpful!😃

[@adaywithaleks6556]

I love your frugal Friday videos, they are my favorite! Thank you for taking the time to film this and testing out all the products I as well as I think allot of your subscribers greatly appreciate it Zabrena!..I heard good things about the Simple brand makeup removing water and I also want to try the Loreal one..and yes the Garnier cleansing oil is amazing I have been using it to remove my very tough revlon colorstay and it works the best at removing long wearing makeup..Although, I don't know why mine needs to be completely removed with cleanser..maybe I am sing it wrong? I was surprised to here yours just comes off with water! Still love it though! :)

[@cindyyu9626]

You are so well-spoken!! Ugh, I envy your speech skills. This was a very detailed and helpful review. Thank you for this!

[@marybethhofbauer2683]

I love Neutrogena light cleansing oil. Now that you've reviewed Garnier, I need to try it too. I really love the cleansing oils. I feel they're much kinder to my skin.

[@MaRyJoYo23]

I love the Simple Micellar Water, I've even used as a toner as well. I definitely think you should try cleansing oils, my favorite at the moment that I couldn't recommend enough is the Clinique Take The Day Off cleansing oil!

[@samg_prickles]

I love your frugal Fridays. you do the best comparison videos that I've found.

[@lifeismakeup]

yas girl the loreal clean artiste is my favorite!!

[@replicapierry1389]

I am using Barnier's micellar makeup remover. It does a great job. No stinging or burning sensation on the eyes. It's inexpensive. I used to use Lancome, but it's gets to be too expensive for a small amount that finishes too quickly. I can happily say Garnier is the best of them all.

[@polishmomma7936]

I love watching these videos. I am almost done with my Garnier cleansing oil and thought about trying their micellar water. I also used up all my Studio 35 eye makeup remover and need to buy another one. Good to know I made the right choice the first time, lol.

[@DRmakeupgirl]

Love the hair! I keep backups of the Loreal one! I used Mary Kay's makeup remover for years at $15 a pop & I compared the Loreal to it so I switched & not looked back! Saved myself a bookoo of money! I'd like to try the Simple brand & the Garnier. I'm thinking maybe the oil would work well for mature skin.

[@annlinton7804]

I do love the Garnier cleansing oil and their makeup remover lotion cleanser although I always follow the lotion with my regular cleanser.

[@qfusarah]

I like the clinique one. it's on the expensive side so I can't wait to try the garnier cleanser for a budget alternative. Thanks for these video's...I love the detailed information.

[@KosmetixWithKate94]

First off, I LOVE the hair. Also, I now feel so justified in my dislike of the Neutrogena makeup remover! So many KZbinrs rave about it, but I found it fairly ineffective! I am glad that I'm not the only one. I will be picking up the cleansing oil! It scared me because as an oily gal, putting oil on my skin seemed like a bad idea. But we have pretty similar skin types, so now I'm curious. Thank you, as always, for another supremely concise and informative video!

[@thedailywithkaylee2363]

Thank you so much Z! I have really been looking into trying micellar water, but now I think I want to try that garnier oil! Another make up remover I think you should try is the Mary Kay oil free makeup remover, it is my holy grail I'm sure that you will love it! Thanks for all your helpful posts, your skin is looking flawless girl!

[@lorellrogers1216]

The Almay Eye Makeup Remover Liquid is my favorite, and you can use it all over the face in addition to the eye area. I always go for the oil free one.

[@bushrasheikh7761]

Thank you very much for testing and giving your opinion on Simple Micellar water!!

[@sabahaq6503]

Z you are looking fabulous and soo is your background and try the garnier micellar water xxx

[@maxinemm1607]

Love the cleansing oils! Been using them for a while but I have found that the neutorgena cleansing oil is so much better than the garnier cleansing oil.

[@bunnyday1473]

I'd love if you did a cleansing oil video! My skin has been getting super dry and I've wondered if oil cleansers would help :)

[@jenniferthompson6500]

You look even more gorgeous!!! Love the hair - couldn't stop admiring it!

[@elainer4642]

Thank you for the video. I love how you try out products for us and show us how they perform. I use Avon eye makeup remover lotion. It works really well and gets everything off.

[@aracelitorres7171]

Thanks for this video. I have tried so many drugstore makeup removers and have not found one that I liked. I always end up going back to the one from Clinique which I love but it is more expensive. I will try some of those that worked for you. I have already tried the Loreal but I tried the regular one, I think I want to try the waterproof.

[@josephinegarcia6883]

I like the rite aid brand of the nuetrogena one. I usually wash my face after I take off my makeup though. I love using the simple micellar for days where I cant fully wash my face and I need something to clean it or after I wash it to make sure all the residue from makeup is off my face.

[@littlecap1]

Love the Simple Micellar water. And be sure and try the Eclos cleansing oil. Its delightful. Rinses clean away with water.

[@TheBchbunnie4]

I love the Eclos one!! It's my favorite!

[@PutYourMakeUpOn]

love these types of videos...super informative...what do you do with the ones you didn't like? return them?..use em for removing hand swatches?

[@Zabrena]

+PutYourMakeUpOn Yeah, they'll be used for taking off swatches in the future :) I won't be running out of makeup remover any time soon! Haha!

[@rachelm_curlysue]

Oh My gosh your hair! I love it! I've been doing red lately too and love it. I'd love to see a video on how you maintain your beautiful color! I'm going to try out that cleansing oil. I've just bought some pure beauty oils to use on my face since I'm so dry, and a cleansing oil might be really great for my skin as well. Thanks for trying all these for us!

[@1990christmas]

Kudos for timing how long it takes to remove. Love how detailed you are. Thanks for the recommendations. I'm going to try the one for sensitive eyes. I used Ponds cold cream for years and years but suddenly had a reaction and can no longer use it. They tell me they haven't changed the formula but I've used it for over 20 years with no problems and now I have issues with it and I've tried several different jars purchased at different stores.

[@leahmichelle5164]

I use plain old coconut oil and love it! A big jar at Walmart or Aldi $4-$5, it starts as a solid but immediately melts to a liquid on my finger tips. I haven't tried it on a makeup pad so not sure how it performs that way. I just rub it on thoroughly to loosen up all my eye makeup before washing my face. Reminded me a lot like the cleansing oil you used and liked. I can say, I have to go in with a wet q-tip after washing my face to get the skin between my lower lashes fully clean when I use waterproof mascara {which is every time} :) I like that it's a 100% pure and natural product that also conditions my lashes and the skin around my eyes.

[@AlexandraMoraru92]

I'm using the Garnier micellar water and I'm pretty pleased with it!

[@tcshy1903]

I saw someone that loves the Garnier Micellar Water too. I am going to get some of the Garnier cleansing oil!

[@finnicking]

your background and hair look so beautiful in this video! (you're always gorgeous, but this hair is SO flattering on you!) amazing video as usual xx

[@ericafolange6457]

I've used Rimmel ' s makeup remover and liked it, but I'm totally getting the Garnier cleansing oil next!

[@BrynneC]

The Nivea Express eye makeup remover is my FAVOURITE!

[@debbiem6406]

Wow, this is comprehensive, concise, and thorough. Very much appreciated! The other things I look for are products without parabens, and 100% cruelty-free. Thank you for testing these out so I don’t have to. 😍

[@MichelleRauKlimas739501]

Is there any Updated videos on waterproof makeup removers? Great video BTW💖💖 Tyvm

[@q4734]

You should try pond's cold cream!!! It's amazing for taking all your makeup off and makes your skin feel great!

[@annacarnell1626]

Hi Zabrena, I have Ponds deep cleanser and makeup remover in the jar (w/ no scent). I love it. I use it as a makeup remover because it's one of the only products I can find that doesn't hurt my eyes. It's a cream so I remove it with a warm rag. Takes less than a minute for me. It removes my waterproof makeup, too. Would like to hear your thoughts on BioDerma and if it's worth the hype on removing makeup.

[@sammiels12]

i absolutely love the neutrogena ultra light cleansing oil. i always feel fresh and clean after

[@sammiels12]

i also put a little bit of it on a q-tip to get in close to my lashline. works really great.

[@becca3115]

Garnier also makes a makeup remover lotion in a squeeze tube that I absolutely love! I have the cleansing oil as a backup, so now I'm excited to try it! Loved this style of video. Very helpful! ;)

[@tracyedwards-ouellette7796]

One you could try is the liquid eye makeup remover by Annabelle that has a pump. It removes even waterproof makeup.

[@verogb]

taking a quick moment to mention congrats to you almost there at 200 000 followers. Just love watching your videos, one of my fav moments of the day. Wishing you happy holidays from Montréal-Canada

[@lilysifu]

Love your drugstore videos. I really like lumene but I don't use false lashes so that works for me. Can't wait to see your next video!!

[@nadiah1991]

thanks zabrena for keeping up with frugal fridays. love this series the best! hope you will continue doing them :-)