FULL: Carpio vs. Roque on China and West Philippine Sea | GMA Digital Specials

Sa gitna ng mainit na debate kaugnay ng China at West Philippine Sea, tinanong namin sina Justice Antonio Carpio at Presidential Spokesperson Harry Roque tungkol sa iba't ibang issue na nakakabit sa usaping ito. Paano nga ba mareresolba ang territorial dispute na ito?
Narito ang kabuuan ng special series ng 24 Oras tungkol sa West Philippine Sea kasama sina Justice Carpio at Secretary Roque. Panoorin natin ito.
News updates on COVID-19 (coronavirus disease 2019) and the COVID-19 vaccine: www.gmanetwork...
Breaking news and stories from the Philippines and abroad:
GMA News and Public Affairs Portal: www.gmanews.tv
Facebook: / gmanews
Twitter: / gmanews
Instagram: / gmanews
GMA Network Kapuso programs on GMA Pinoy TV: www.gmanetwork...

[@leticiabalitaan5924]

A big applause for you ,ho respectable, Justice Carpio.

[@erwinayubansr8551]

I salute justice carpio 4 depending our terretories in west phil sea, sharing hia knowledge/wisdom to us is highly commendable,

[@danielbertubin2579]

Justice Antonio Carpio you're absolutely correct,malamang nakasangla na iyan.

[@lrtjratec1209]

This politician can only talk but he's not expert when it comes to this specific topic.

[@nixjun242]

That right on the head . Argumentum ad Ignorantiam has visited young Lawer's mind. It's a defeatist postion for the Argument to presuppose that we lose what is ours in a legally contested issue in a proper forum . The Court International Court' Decision as the bulwark and engine of universal Justice has clearly and resoundingly spoken it's Conscience thus , said Decision must be universakky respected by respectable civilized Member states . There was clear bullying . Some erudite induviduals who failed to see it , must be morally blind.

[@dreambynata3561]

Atty. Carpio, you seemed so confident that the other countries when invited, will join the Philippines in its fight for the territory, how can you be so sure of that? History tells that after the withdrawal of our ship from Scarborough Shoal while the Chinese vessel stayed inspite of the so-called agreement brokered by the US, not even the US raised a concern over it.

[@hernandobonecile8524]

Natumbok mo!

[@bpike-]

Tapos marameng uma angkas sa idea.. Tutulungan tayo ng US, e-enforce nyo yan.. Colonial mentality 😔

[@Sabalas]

Kakampi daw kasi tayo ng UN... 😑 Nakalimutan ata nila na kasama yung China sa permanent security council ng UN. Sila mismo nagdidikta kung paano gumalaw ang UN. Yun nga ang dahilan kaya hindi kinikilalang bansa ang Taiwan eh.

[@ireneavitualla6187]

Maybe the U S and China sabotage the Filipinos , they think that we are too small and idiots. They think we are slaves can follow what they want , call the things

[@digitalian99]

@@ireneavitualla6187 U.S. sure ako, since may precedent nagbentahan ang U.S. at Spain, at ang bansang Pilipinas ang ibinenta tinuturo yan sa skwela, pero maraming pinoy slave mentality pa rin sa mga amerikano

[@ericolimpiada2917]

Kailangan malaman sino nagtraydor ng maparusahan at di na maulit ang ginawa, dahil kundi baka malaman mo na lang isang araw na wala na din pala Pilipinas sa mga Pilipino! Madali lang sabihin gusto ng war sa mga taong kayang lumipad lang at manirahan sa ibang bansa kapag ginera ang Pilipinas, sino magdudusa kung ganun? Push pa more sa claim ngayon, bakit hindi noon? keep safe everyone🙏✌️

[@weareheretochange7361]

Report all interent trolls Let end this Some account already under surveillance for public Misleading and pubic assault

[@lermacalubing7484]

Kaya nga po

[@litoceleste4262]

Lahat ng maka China at ayaw ipagtanggol and mahal nating Pilipinas lumipat na kayo sa China at doon na kayo manirahan mabuti pa!

[@jnlolimberio7122]

Sino bng maka-China? Pinanood mo ba ung debate? Mukang 'di mo naiintindihan ung nangyayari eh.

[@litoceleste4262]

@@jnlolimberio7122 mukha lang na wala ako na intindihin sa tingin mo pero ikaw wala tlga alam!

[@jnlolimberio7122]

@@litoceleste4262 Nge? 😂

[@missinglink8585]

sa issue ka kasi mag focus. bawat isa mag research wag maging prejudice.

[@luzhernan120]

O sige punta ka sa wps, dala ka baril lusubin mo china,

[@ismail1521]

EH BAKIT NOONG PANAHON MO BILANG ASSO JUSTICE NG SUPREME COURT WALA KANG GINAWA?????

[@charoyoshimoto9993]

Di naman trabaho ni Judge Carpio yan before. Di rin siya presidente para mag- decide. Ngayon lang siya pwede magsalita dahil retired justice na siya.

[@charoyoshimoto9993]

Pinanalo na nga ni Pres. Pinoy ang pag- aari ng Pinas sa West Phil. Sea. Tuta lang talaga si Duterte ng China from the very start of his presidential campaign 2016.

[@Carla-lj4ik]

Yes.. umiiwas nga sa "kung sino Ang nag utos Ng pag atras Ng navy natin sa standoff".. eh mukhang dun sa instance na Yun nah umpisang lumakas Ng pag sakup Ng intsik sa area na Yan.. Isa pa, Nung nagsampa Ng reklamo Ang Pinas sa unclos ay dito pa kumuha Ng panambak na lupa Ang intsik sa Zambales at pinayagan din Ng gobernong noynoy a kinabibilangan ni kinabibilangan ni Carpio.. edi natural pagtatawanan talaga Tayo Ng intsik. Ano ba Yung pagsampa Ng reklamo sa UNCLOS palabas lang ba? Nagpoprotesta habang nakikipag tulungan sa pag gawa Ng krimen?

[@3jprintingservices504]

Pareho po kayo matalino pagsamahin nyo nalang para makabuo ng isang matatag na paninindigan laban sa mga sakim at mapanglamang sa kapwa God Bless po

[@wilbertdiaz6546]

Oo nga sana kaso yung isa ginagamit ang katalinuhan lbn sa byan..bnabyaran ata ng china cila spokeperson ng china..sbgay si roque last presidential election di nman c duterte sinoporyahan nya tinawag nya png murderer iba talaga ngawa ng pera at kapngyarihan ngbabago ang panininfigan

[@rven14ify]

oo nga, pilipino kasi mahilig mag pagalingan.. hindi nalang pag isahin ang ideolohiya kung ano ang mas mabuti

[@junjuncimafranca7823]

I believe carpio is politicizing coz if he is sincere it could have been done during his time. Why now? Ph lost during their time and now he is loud. its deceitful!! I get your point but are you doing it for the people or you have personal reasons!!!!

[@charoyoshimoto9993]

Paano naman gagalaw si Judge Carpio before e di naman siya presidente before at sa Supreme Court siya nakatalaga??. Ngayong retired na siya, ngayon lang siya pwede magsalita.

[@mariafeagustin5001]

Bakit hindi mo ginawa noong nakaupo ka pa sa pwesto mo as jestice at noong panahon ni pinoy

[@wizards8882000]

aba good opinion to ah....

[@lumiesarabosing9141]

Traditional fishing grounds are area outside the EEZ. In the international water.

[@pamelasayson75]

Bakit sabi ng boss mo wps ay ss chins ma

[@jomariecallueng9220]

@@pamelasayson75 nyare sayo

[@lumiesarabosing9141]

@@pamelasayson75 What is SS chins ma?

[@roelsison6530]

Sa loob ng EEZ natin brod tinataboy ng china mangingisda natin may vidio yan hindi lang pinansin nila duterte hinaing ng mnga mangingisda natin kaya nabutasan ni carpio, dapat pinascortan nia manlang mnga kawawang mangingisda natin

[@bernardalvarez6233]

@@roelsison6530 spratly un sir kc nga na take over na nila un😅 un ung pinabayaan n nonoy kunin ng china.. na ngpautoh ang pinas sa sab ng America😅kng 220 cnasabi n carpio bkt hnd nila ginawa yan sa administration n nonoy bkt now lng xa ngpuputak? 🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@kuyagelo8396]

panay kayu galit sa china order ng order naman kayu sa shooppe at lazada

[@daled.a2034]

Different story. Taasan mo konte IQ mo.

[@arkcliref]

@@daled.a2034 he's talking about hypocrisy. If you don't accept being called a hypocrite, then prove that you're not.

[@leandromasanque6620]

Mr. Cardio bkit nong ikaw ay s nsa Preston pa ay di mo gnwa

[@jenjoven8870]

Cnong Cardio😂😂

[@paulorivera1569]

meron nga.. sa tingin mo bat umabot sa UN????

[@redensalig3497]

Carpio kong gusto mo nang GIRA sumolong ka doon mag isa!!!

[@akolang2580]

Saan kaya mag ttago si carpio pag nag ka gera baka mag tago sa u.s

[@lumiesarabosing9141]

Ikaw saan kayo tatago? Sa sarowal ni Duterte?

[@Banok_2014]

Pag nag ka gera? Eh sabi ng DDS walang laban ang pinas sa china. Kung hindi tutulong ang U.S sa gera, Ehh? Saan ka tatago?😂😂

[@akolang2580]

Ohh bakt kau umiiyak?? Hahaha saan ako mag ttago edi maki pag patayan rin ano pa ba magagawa ehh kau ?? Iiyak nalang? Aasa kau sa u.s?

[@romeosuarez3499]

Ang tanong nga bakit na posses ng China ang portion ng wps at Scarborough shoal? Nasaan si d Del ROSARIO? at Napaka ironic Kung sino ang nag file ng arbitrary ay sya pang Isa sa mga salarin?

[@me_sensei]

di lng ironic yan, hindik balahibo pah.... dapat sisihin China, ksi sila may pakana ng 9-line in 1st place eh... imbento lng pla... sabi tribunal.

[@jessecuenca2425]

Ang paliwanag ni Justice Carpio ay maliawanag at nasa batas tuloy lang bakit ang “MAPILINDO” Po ba ay wala na humongous tayo ng tulong sa mga powerful na bansa kahit ano🤩👌✅

[@neliaesperanzate5899]

Dapat imbistigahan ng Senado yang WPS,nagbubulagbulagan yung mga Senatong.

[@tengteng4076]

Impeach n lang tatay digong mo sa pagiging pambansang traydor ng pilipinas

[@jenjoven8870]

@@tengteng4076 Tama ka ISANG Traydor yang Si Digong kita nyo hindi nya mamura yang CHINA...pero Yung DIYOS namura nya....😴

[@lucianoeufronioalvia7187]

@@jenjoven8870 tama ang walang modong presidente ng Filipinas

[@delfinjrlor1953]

Eh dapat di nyu hinayaan sir carpio untill almost 5 year hinayaan nyu mawala. Wala kayung imik . Lol.

[@charliedomingo759]

tama pero dapat ngayon na napa labas na ang issue all force na kasi kong mapataagal pa to ang mga kagayang mga walang utak na maka duerte e maka hanap naman ng dahilan para ma balin ang issue katolad ng trabaho, covid, at iba pa tanungin parin natin si carpo bakit pero wag ninyo ipasalin na walang kasalanan rin si pres. dahil ang sabi ay wag na kayo gagalaw

[@juanthegreat3954]

Kasalanan pa ni Justice Carpio? Diba dapat yung presidente yung responsable sa pagtangol ng ating territoryo? Oo nga pala, tuta pala ng Tsina si Digong.😂

[@ArchAngeLDeux]

Carpio, di ba member ka ng Philippine Arbitrary panel nung time na un? Bakit di ninyo na-push para magkaroon ng resolution? Bakit NGAYON kayo yumayawyaw?

[@masid1863]

Kase mag eleksyon na. Nag aambisyon maging senador or presidente

[@carljohnzyntronolo1661]

Up! 😂

[@intengbotikol3600]

Election na. Wala pa sila iba maisip na panlaban ng administration

[@lumiesarabosing9141]

The international tribunal court is not responsible for resolution. They only deliver decisions. The same thing happened in Guam, Diego Garcia and islands in Indian Ocean. Those people won the case. They are now allowed back to those islands. But they have to do it themselves. UN cannot force the invaders/defendant to compensate the Islanders.

[@cipCrack]

pakatalino po tayo sa next election parang awa nyo na.

[@joelfavorito6442]

Dpat wla ng ibotong demonyong dilawan.

[@quchi7232]

@@joelfavorito6442 true, kaso isa sa mga founder sa PDP-Laban (Duterte’s Party) ay si Ninoy Aquino :(

[@conradodia1977]

Tama kapag ba mangingisda kaba ay may gera ba bakit ba pinagbabawalan ang ating mangingisda

[@michaelraro2598]

Edi try mo don mangisda sa teritoryong pinagaagawan para alam mo kung ano mangyayare sayo. Napakahina mo magisip ano ka grade 2? Haha

[@KorayMeARiver-if5qd]

@@michaelraro2598 pang elementary nga magisip itong c conrado. Kala mo pinas nagbabawal sa mangingisda nating mangisda. Pinasasamahan na nga ng mga CG mangingisda eh. Tsk3

[@roelsison6530]

@@michaelraro2598 illegal ang pagpapaalis ng china sa mangingisda natin sakop ng EEZ natin ang pinangingisdaan ng kababayan natin

[@ronniebonganay5004]

Tingin2 kman sa balita dati tinataboy ang mangingisda ngaun hindi na naniwala kman sa balita sa abias abs cbn puro yan fake news ngbabayad ng tao para maninira utak mo dilaw hahaha

[@bernardalvarez6233]

@@ronniebonganay5004 tama kau jan sir.. sa PTv at mata ng agila news iba cnasabi ng mangingisda don.. kabaliktaran sa abs at gma. Sa admin nga n nonoy tinataboy mangingisda. Now hnd na..

[@annjumamil7529]

Kung Alam ninyo ang history sa Pilipinas lalo na sa West Philippines Sea huwag idaan sa gulo at pamolitiko. Ilang taon ng lumilipas bakit ngayon lang kayo nagsasalita . Kailangang magkaisa ang Pilipino. This WPS issue ay hindi pang-pangtalinohan kundi Unity sa mabuting pamaraan.

[@simonjames9481]

Malapit na kasi election kaya nag start na nila siraan ang Duterte admin.

[@adriangatuz7377]

I agree with Justice Tony! Stick with the issue, roque!

[@bluebalagao2557]

Carpio pumapapel ka naman ano ba talaga gusto mo dati hindi mo ginawa iyan noon naka upo ka? ngayon ka nag iingay.

[@georgeoms8713]

Dapat i bartolina itung si Duterte at Roque, sila pa nag aabugado sa China laban sa Pilipino. Mga taksil sa nayan.

[@remegiobalanon274]

THUMBS UP AKO KAY SEC. ROQUE REGARDING HIS LINE OF THINKING AND OR REASONING ABOUT THE DISPUTED WPS AND EEZ.

[@cieloditching7609]

Justice Carpio is right about WPS territory issues

[@markarnega2342]

he is right BUT missing points. CRITICAL points.

[@josephanunciado2119]

Kong si carpio ang maging Presidente, sigurado durog tayo, benham rise is different from WPS, benham rise is in the Pacific ocean.

[@daled.a2034]

Philippines let China conduct scientific studies on benham rise instead of funding filipino researchers. Super dumb move.

[@noelbalmes1450]

West ph sea is also a part of the Pacific Ocean.

[@charliedomingo759]

sinu nag sabi bobotohin natin yan ang tanung lang ay may kababayaan ba ang adminestrasyon ngayon sa issue

[@warrengabales1231]

Bopol

[@jonaldmalagayo2706]

There's so much opportunity to learn listening to what FSCJ Carpio has to say and Roque's turn was just my moment to absorb everything he said. I cannot even compare them because the magnitude of the amount of intelligence and honor is miles and miles away from each other. Roque should be feeling like in a high place being compared to Carpio and not anymore to the creatures of the sea.

[@trulyblessed5236]

Correct nagpka humble na si Justice Carpio pra patulan si roque for the sake of the Philippines' right in the West Philippine Sea.

[@romualdobarloso9623]

Triplihin ang budget ng AFP.

[@digitalian99]

pag ginawa yan, may bagong narrative ang oposisyon "may pandemic, pero uunahin nyo budget nang AFP - tapos biglang sabi oust-duterte"

[@cesariavintusa6896]

Mukang Hindi Rin effective Yung strategy Ng duterte admin na makipag kaibigan sa china, Hindi napakiusapan paalisin Ang china even through friendship. Anu pang other option na pwedeng gawin? I like Yung idea ni carpio na to invite other countries sa issue .

[@fernandocruz4877]

Sna nun p nla gnwa🤣 kya lng ganyan c carpa nmumulitika1😂

[@edwinabrantes8997]

ano solusyon?di pla effective ang duterte admin.

[@azonegarlan5963]

latag ka nga ng solusyon at ng mapag usapan,baka ikaw na ang kasagutan sa pangyayaring yan..hala latag muna now na

[@cesariavintusa6896]

@@azonegarlan5963 bukas na Lang ako maglalatag, inaantok pako .😂😂

[@allankeyflores7118]

Anu gusto mo effective?

[@gatsdonarber6623]

Tanong ko lang: ang sinasabi ba ni roque , bilang spokeperson ng presidente, ay totoo o joke only?

[@cloweduran6035]

Boang

[@markarnega2342]

nice one. 🤣

[@BorjEndymione]

Ang lesson jn wag tau umasa sa ibang bansa plakasin ang pwersa ntin palayasin ang komonista at oligarch n hawak ng banyaga

[@salbinosamson7777]

Timing ang tamang Descarte

[@Joiceamazing]

Ewan ko sayo Carpio. Di mo naman alam pinagsasabe mo.

[@michaelguapz9525]

Kahit saang banda Carpio hinding hindi mo ako matatalo sa basketbol

[@rolandoorqueza3386]

sec roque is really intelligent than carpio. how is carpio going to implement the ruling on wps?

[@analizatenio8103]

Carpio timang timang ka tlga😫😫😫

[@mhercalauad6301]

Yes, it should be exclusive for filipino people not for china. AJ Carpio was very very true. Come on AJ Carpio fight for our right.

[@bertirabon8585]

Sa akin pananaw parang kinakampihan pa natin ang singkit naka pasok na sila economic zone noon tinataboy yung ating mangingisda pinabayaan lang natin

[@dpathpatrimonio8435]

The other countries fishing in our territory ....bat ganon?? walang magawa ang nka upo....

[@janesaguid1797]

Bkit nhayon lng ngingay c carpo noon tahimik ka sna noon ginawa nyo

[@irnenriuseumague5367]

Is he the former associate justice?..

[@pacitaignacio8809]

Ating Ang Phillipine west Phillipinesea Bless lord Pilipinas

[@masid1863]

Carpio naman😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jagrandom641]

Tulog ka parin?! 🤣🤣

[@roniebanquiao3227]

Ung mga tao gusto giyera na may mga green card yan , pag magkagulo na lalayas yan doon na sila sa ibang bansa ang kawawa ung mahihirap

[@kirkbelcher9863]

anong gyera sinunog nga sa Indonesia ang mga barko nang mga chinese nahuli sa kanila. Si Duterte lang ang nagsabi nang gyera para ma ipagtanggol niya ang China. Ang kapwa Pilipino pa ang minumura niya pero sa China Thank you.

[@sergiocerezo7229]

Si Carpio mayroong vested interest dahil sya ang lawyer ng company nina Salim,Manny Pangilinan at Del Rosario na may interest na mag-extract ng oil sa makukuhang oil sa ating EEZ sa West Phil Sea.Isa pa bakit ba inuuna ni Carpio ang matagal ng guli dyan sa West Phil Sea samantalang dapat ang pagtuunan natin ng pansin ay ang Covid pandemic ,nasaan ang mga priorities mo Carpio

[@bpike-]

Tumpak. Iyan ang pinaka ugat kung bakit kumakahol si Carpio ngayon. Dapat pinapakita ng mainstream media ang kaugnayan ni Carpio sa mga Oligarchs.

[@rab1058]

Hanggang ngayun naniniwala padin silang tutulong sa atin ang America? History po, paulit ulit n history ang dapat pagbatayan.

[@denzilsegunto9918]

Us wont even help taiwan, if china invades taiwan.

[@joshguzma9234]

History ng ww2? Dahil sa 2 atom bombs ng US, isinurender ng Japan ang lahat ng war victories nito na halos kalahati ng China, buong korea at Taiwan.

[@sunshinesea607]

@@joshguzma9234 right? It took 3 years before bumalik si mcarthur..Thank you USA for letting us suffer from DEATH MARCH, RAPE, and SLAVERY for 3 years from the Japanese :)

[@lonelymoon8452]

Vip

[@Banok_2014]

@@denzilsegunto9918 US help Taiwan if china invades Taiwan. May U.S citizen dyan sa taiwan HOY!.😅🤭

[@christinetomelden4337]

Communist China will never agree to leave those Islands regardless, China is aggressive, diplomatic relations with China is questionable! You can keep on talking with China, they will just insist on what they like, so, this problem will remain! Fishing rights should be respected by all countries! Why cant you ALL countries CO-EXIST!

[@danilojaucian2770]

Bakit ba laging naninisi. Ang problema en un ngaun.anong mangyayari kung magsisihan ng nakaraan...

[@simonjames9481]

Ano din mangyayari kung isisisi sa kasalukuyan ang kasalanan ng nakaraan?

[@shirlsstrangethings]

At Bakit ngayon putak ng putak tong si Carpio? Wala naman siya sa gobyerno... Nung nakaupo siya di ninya iginiit kay Panot na lumaban ka sa China!!! Ngayon ngawngaw ng ngawngaw??? Wala kayong point Kaya Mas Maganda wag kayong pukol ng pukol sa kasalukuyang administration. Pag binalik sa inyo pukol sasabihin ninyong Walang sisihan!!! Wag kayong dumada. Para wag kayong sagutin ng ayaw ninyo!!! Gets ninyo ba?

[@danilojaucian2770]

May mangyayari kung kikilos at gumawa ng paraan d ung wala pang ginagawa ibinibigay na sa china na may pananakot pa sa mga tao.cya ang naka puwesto ngaun so,may magagawa kung gusto. D ako dilawan o dds sarilin kong opinyon lng...

[@MamertoCostuna]

We can not consider west Phil. sea as domestic problem. See China insist the whole of the sea as their own. A rough & greed move.😅😅😅

[@deevoizeify]

In SUMMARY & To LEARN something out of the AGREE or DISAGREE … I urge to set aside political admiration and to look into following considerations: FACTS; 1_ That the arbitral RULING, in spite China given the chance to present their defense to rebut, states that NINE-DASH-LINE claimed by China has NO justification and erroneous and has no title to any claim portion in WPS. China disregards this RULING. 2_That WPS/EEZ belongs to Philippine’s sovereignty as per UNCLOS, signed and agreed by China. 3_ That China is currently occupying a reclaimed artificial portion of WPS within Philippine EEZ. THEREFORE, China occupation by virtue of force, threat and territorial intrusion is considered unlawful and invasive to PI EEZ and FON by International Law. It’s impossible that the world can be run by a mob, gang or by a TAIPAN Boss. CONCLUSION what do we do… Between us and China alone, 1_ We can treat China as our guest in our EEZ under Philippines House Laws and Rules within a specified period of TIME. 2_ We can charge RENT / LEASE for a specified period of TIME under a balance of debt payment program. 3. We protect our sovereignty by all means. Between International and China, 1_ If they don’t abide by any of above, then we have no choice but to abide by International ally’s proposal as to how we should resolve, to evict China out and maintain FON, peacefully and in civilized manner … Feel free to rebut… u have my permission ADMIN to pin this on top.

[@mizuelourdesmori1483]

Ayaw banggitin ni AC na nag umpisa ang problema sa panahon ni Pinoy....ipinipilit niya na dapat ay ayusin ni PRDD ang problemang minana....maganda at malinaw mga paliwanag ni Roque pero si AC ay parang isang Batang Sutil na ipinipilit ang gusto kahit di tama 😱

[@bpike-]

The Aquino Administration invented 'West Philippine Sea' on September 5 2012 to portray that it could be disentangled from the South China Sea. It has created an impression among Filipinos that the country can pursue its rights and duties under UNCLOS without cooperating and coordinating with the coastal States of the South China Sea I.e Vietnam and China, and worse, that the Philippines could pursue a policy that would exclude other coastal States. Article 123 of UNCLOS obliges States bordering a semi-enclosed sea, such as the South China Sea, to "cooperate with each other in the exercise of their rights and in the performance of their duties under the Convention" Further, it obliges States to "endeavour.. to coordinate the management, conservation, exploration, and exploitation of the living resources of the sea; to coordinate the implementation of their rights and duties with respect to the protection and preservation of the marine environment; to coordinate their scientific research policies and undertake where appropriate joint programmes of scientific research in the area...

[@bpike-]

Look at your Point Number 2. You're commiting the same mistake as Antonio Carpio. You said: " the WPS/EEZ belongs to Philippines's Sovereignty as per UNCLOS" signed and agreed by China. 👈 how did you come up with this? Sovereignty o Soberenya = Full and Absolute control. From baseline to 12 Nautical Miles (BAHAY HANGANG BAKOD). Sovereign Rights OR EEZ = 12 - 200 NM Pls understand the difference 🙏🏼 According to the Report on Preliminary Examination Activities of the ICC (2019), the communication Carpio et al sent alleged that the crimes he mentioned in his communication "were...committed by Chinese nationals in the territory of the Philippines" Yup, he used "territory" to refer to EEZ. The ICC lectured then our beloved Supreme Court Justice that "maritime zones beyond the territorial sea, such as the EEZ and continental shelf, are not considered to comprise part of a State's territory under international law".

[@deevoizeify]

@@bpike- PART 1 … First of all, let me tell u that people are listening on d other side of the pond. I want to erase the grin on their faces at us arguing over semantics of terms, but rather make them hold their breath and sweat instead, a strategic tactics way of saying don’t be hasty...😉. I outlined 3 main points in my comments that is related as ONE to each other as cause-and-effect reactions to the case and top it with a proposed resolution. However, you seem to delve urself in cherry picking an aspect separately from the other. Look, we could have an endless debate over the semantics and terms use that winds up to end on the same meaning. My focus was China NINE-DASH-LINE as d culprit of all our hardships first, a hoax, long before any rebut to ur arguments. So, pls, not worth our time. I have more on d China/NINE-DASH-LINE issues, if time and space would permit. Something that would enlighten reasons and how to correct such a big mistake by China relative to Philippines.

[@deevoizeify]

@@bpike- PART 2 … We are all wise and bright Filipinos and I respect both gentlemen i.e., Carpio / Roque. Though Carpio’s points reach as far as Hauge tribunal that I find it more credible. My points are combined summary collected from both, rather than figure whose right or wrong. ANYWAY, regardless of how our past politicians did it, nothing binds us with China until all resolution is made into Law by all chambers of government. So, we’re still stuck…obviously, we’re not progressing by ur perception…😊 … Now, pls share me ur idea on how we should resolve? 😊…

[@joelbaun9224]

Sa tingin mo ba Carpio merong investor na magkakaroon ng interes na mag invest dyan sa WPS na alam naman nilang may problema? madaling sabihin yan Carpio pero mahirap gawin.

[@walbabynosabella2674]

Magsama silang 2 ni Trililing. Puro Kulelat, isama na dyan Leni Lugaw.

[@ecxalabang1841]

Unrealistic answer by carpio, parang fantasy ang sagot. Parang batang gusting pumunta sa neverland

[@heavenabove579]

Roque is a fool. He is saying something else now diff from UNCLOS.

[@dendipudge238]

Bubu dapat sa panahon pa ni carpa ginawa yan wala nga isla nakuha sa panahon ni prd sa panahon Nila ilan bubu?

[@jeancapiato170]

Tama bakit Hindi tutukan Kung paano malulutas Ang problema at Hindi Yong nagtuturoan,magsisisihan,ngayon Ang mahalaga Hindi Yong pagaawayan Kung Sino may kasalanan at lkung Sino at Sino pa.mahalaga pagisipan mabuti Kung paano na ba Ang PWS?

[@michellevblanco6126]

BRAVOOOOH..!!! BRILLIANT JO SIR SPOKE PERSON HARRY ROQUE. I LOVE TO HEARING YOUR POSITIVE ENTHUSIASTIC COMMENTS ABOUT EVERYTHING SPECIFICALLY THIS WEST PHILIPPINES SEA. GREAT JOB SIR ROQUE. KEEP UP A BRILLIANT JOB AND YOU'RE WAY TO GOOOO..!!!

[@weareheretochange7361]

Report all interent trolls Let end this Some account already under surveillance for public Misleading and pubic assault

[@ruthtubadeza1819]

Agree! Spox Harry Roque is much better and not reading

[@weareheretochange7361]

@@ruthtubadeza1819 Nope Idiots

[@jhonmarc8208]

Dont entertain them pls...mga kulang lang sa pansin yang mga politiko na yan..hahay

[@jaymie8239]

Carpio if you are seeking for war, mauna ka na dalhin mo ang mga kasama mo isangbayad

[@craigcayetano4480]

Lumilihis si Tony sa issue sa panatag shoal. Alam na dis.

[@tolpabili9616]

Pinangakuan na kyo,gusto nyo pa tuparin.🤑🌚🙈🙈🙈

[@MrGrey-im4qd]

Nabasa kona to Wala ng dating ngayon

[@JP-nf9lk]

😁😁😁

[@robbynatividad6857]

Maybe carpio in the of it’s plan he will run for president. The reason he sounds vocal right now.

[@francissalva9732]

D nman po cguro masama,Kung sya tatakbo,

[@EvendimataE]

COVID KUNIN MO NA ANG MGA TAKSIL SA BANSA NAMING PILIPINAS....IKAW NA BAHALA PUMILI KUNG SINO YUNG MGA HINAYUPAK NA TAKSIL

[@veteranstalon7382]

sana now na.. PLEASE PLEASE COVID. PRAYING NGAYON NA.

[@bannyfide7657]

Trill at panot plsss

[@ayukiisheon6678]

Unahin mo na co ivid itongdalawang tuliisan natrililing atfuck yaw

[@charlitocatapang5285]

Dina tatablanin covid may pan laban

[@coryfaustino8021]

Charlito Catapang yah, masamang damo kasi!

[@jessie_8301]

Theres always a trace of leaning towards in favor of China if you notice the way Roque talks. But he is aware of the overwhelming outcry of the filipino people (including some intelligent DDS) so he is restraining himself.

[@forevergamer9931]

KAILAN MAN AY DI AKO NATAKOT SA MGA MANANAKOP,DAHIL MAS NKAKATAKOT PA ANG MGA MANGMANG KONG KABABAYAN KAGAYA MO. BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@francissalva9732]

Listo nga sinabi ni roqueee,e bkt nakalusot ang china lalo sa pagpapatayo Ng Kung ano ano dyan SA WPS.

[@renesiborboro9757]

@@francissalva9732 kelan ba napatayo yung mga ano ano sa wps?

[@babyluzfrance7860]

Bago pa naging president si tatay digong issue n yan dahil natalo kayo lahat ng sisi itinambak nyo s kanya

[@jessie_8301]

@@babyluzfrance7860 FYI binoto ko si PRRD.

[@samuellerosales1486]

Kung buhay lang sana si carlos p. romulo, hindi sana nangyayari ang ganitong dispute. Remember the insult thrown to us by the russian diplomat Andrei Vishinsky that Romulo is just a little guy from a little country? Romulo countered by saying that it is our duty as "little david" to fling the pebbles of truth in the eyes of the blustering Goliath and force them to behave. The russian diplomat of course has nothing to reply. China should behave in the face of the world... if romulo were still here.😔

[@idangnasagac7983]

Very well said kabayan 👏😔

[@nenitavelasquez5208]

Agree simple pero may dating ang statement.

[@mangteban3640]

kwentong barber shop

[@Maestraako]

@@mangteban3640 kawawa ka naman. Broaden your knowledge so you won’t stick to a barber shop talk. I am not disparaging barber shops I’m just responding to a comment

[@montieladriankid]

ano magagawa ni romulo kapag nag war na.hahawak ba cya na baril? walang magagawa ang puro salita.

[@trulyblessed5236]

Tama namn si Justice Carpio, dapat magkaisa ang lahat ng Pilipino sa usapin about West Philippine sea against china, Hindi ung Filipino vs Filipino, natutuwa lng china sa nangyayari, tayo tayo nag-tatalo. Wla nman ksi tlga dapat na pagtalunan sa totoo LNG. Dapat kumilos nlng, wag na magturuan. Ang mahala ung ngayon, anu pba mga pwedeng magawa. Malinaw nman na lahat ayaw ng Gera. Kaya wag na ipanakot ang Gera...

[@marudelossantos1858]

Asan ba ang ating navy at coast guard?bkit di nla mabantayan ang ating coastal areas?bkit cla nasa edsa at binabantayan ang mrt???ang lalaki ng sweldo!!!gawin nla ang tunay na trabaho nla!!!to secure & protect our coastal areas against foreign aggressors like CHINA!!!

[@diojan7590]

Nasa west PH sea ang ating 2 barko at di aalis yun katulad ng ginawa sa panahon PNOY at Del Rosario nung 2012.

[@roylowedideles11]

Clarung-claru sabi ni Carpio, nakikita mo pala noon pa eh bakit sinisisi mo ang si PRRD?, ngayun? sa mga mali nyo? buti pa c PRRD dahan dahan na inaayus ang problema dyn kahit my pandemia pa nagaganat sa Philippines ngayun.

[@clarkcasa8067]

PRRD said during the campaign he will protect the Local Fishermen but he said it was just a CAMPAIGN JOKE. Well hes entire presidency is just a joke to be honest. Abay Run Duterte Run pala ang Tagline niya.

[@jenjoven8870]

Pangulong walang paninindigan mag hhamon nung pinatulan atras mag sasalita on national TV tapos sasabihin joke lng yun lahat nalang joke gawain ba ng matinong presidente yan..dapat nag comedy bar ka Hindi presidente Susme😔

[@daled.a2034]

Aso si PRRD eh. Aso ng CCP

[@andregacasan3062]

Bakit hindi moyan ginawa carpio noon bakit!!! Ang dami mng sat2 tandang carpio!🙄

[@angelatayag1958]

Hahaha nasa Judiciary yan noon , trabaho ng executive ang hinaanap nyo meron separation of power ang manga yan hindi sila pede sumawsaw basta sa ibang jurisdiction

[@dendipudge238]

@@angelatayag1958 bakit ngayon ngawa ng ngawa yan

[@kimgonzales220]

@@dendipudge238 halatang hindi ka nagbabasa

[@dendipudge238]

@@kimgonzales220 we mukha mo lips kayo ni carpa

[@divinevienes4317]

ang kinukuha natin ay un atin di un sa kanila. karapatan nating mga pilipino na angkinin natin ang para sa pilipino.

[@montieladriankid]

mam hahawak kba ng baril kapag nag war na?

[@inyourdreamsbaguhin9983]

Bakit inangkin naman natin kaso inangkin lang sa kunin natin punta tayo at paalisin ang mga taga china kong anong mangyayari sa atin

[@winefredogerms7064]

Itong c Roque ay wala ring pakialam sa karapatan ng Pilipinas MAYAMAN kasi at madaling makapag abroad

[@richardflorin7007]

@@winefredogerms7064 Naligaw ka ata.... !!!

[@hernandobonecile8524]

Sabi ng lolo ko,pg ang isang taong kausap mo ay hndi mkatingin s mata mo hbang kausap,ito dw ay isang traydor, wla b kaung nappansin ky aj carpio??

[@jiancarlotv3977]

Hahaha tama k boss 👊

[@rosavillarosit4277]

Tama..

[@abayarijosemari648]

Sabi ng lolo mong patay na?

[@RonaldTradio-kb8if]

sino kaya sa.inyo ni j carpio ang traidor?. c carpio na pinaglaban ang pinas? o baka ikaw nakampi ng mga singkit.

[@leticiabalitaan5924]

Roque, pls … make our claim stronger, by using your talent in protecting our country, PHILIPPINES…. PLEASE…..

[@amduras6258]

Ang pagtatayo ba ng artificial island at pagsira ng kalikasan hindi ba DAHAS yan?..nagtatanong lang po?

[@aerich5538]

nag salita ang malinis kala mo hindi gumagamit ng plastic

[@aerich5538]

Di yan dahas dahil dinaman nakita o hindi napansin

[@christianjaynazareno6534]

Part of the globalization nayan te ang sirain ang kalikasan HAHAHAHA

[@avabril9008]

pero kung naging chief justice yan c carpio bago nagretire, tahimik sana yan ngayon...

[@rodignacio453]

HINDI NAMAN PANGINGISDA GINAGAMIT MO LANG ANG MGA MANGINGISDA CARPIO. ANG TUNAY DIYAN YUNG MGA CLIENTE MO NA OLIGARCHS NA GUSTONG MAG MINA NG LANGIS DIYAN . YUN ANG TUNAY NA HISTORY NIYAN

[@machristinapaulamontebon5761]

😱😱😱😱

[@catalinoruben2665]

TutA KA NG CHINA UMALIS KA DITO SA PILIPINAS.

[@richbc517]

si tatang di maka tingin sa camera ..halatang halata na nagbabasa ...

[@daled.a2034]

Lol gusto mo mkakita ng nag babasa? Dun ka kay tay digs at bong go. Halatang halata yun.

[@lumgarcia]

Ha ha ha, totoo ka.

[@manuelnacu1086]

ano kayo klaseng pilipino ? pinagtatanggol ang atin karapatan natin at magiging lahi natin.malaking kataksilan iyan ginawa ni digong at iyan taksil na si roque mo.

[@manuelnacu1086]

Mabuting usapan ang laging dahilan ni digong at roque.BUYING TIME ANG GINAGAWA NG CHINA.HANGGANG WALA NA MAGAWA ANG PILIPINAS.

[@dendipudge238]

@@manuelnacu1086 hahaha sa panahon ni prd may isla ba na nakaw sa panahon Nila panot ilan Ang isla na nakaw bubu?

[@DUROTTVOfficial]

Benta nyo pa lupa sa bundok ng zambales para sa artificial island ng China.. very nice,, Tapos makipag agawan kayo ng teritoryo,’

[@rosedror8620]

May mga solution pla si carpio dapat ginawa nla nuon pa .

[@johnmarkserrano7031]

lumabas yung desisyon nung nakaupo na si Pduts

[@michaeljoshuadomingo5704]

@@johnmarkserrano7031 Kahit na 2012 pa yan eh

[@veteranstalon7382]

@@michaeljoshuadomingo5704 Philippines filed an arbitration case against China over the West Philippine Sea on January 22, 2013 and it was won by philippines last july 2016 during dutae's time

[@rudyllanora849]

Read first

[@LailaHorvina]

2016 .. naghain ng protests dahil tumakbong Presidente si Digong 😁 .. joke Din itong mga DiLAwan , so Kung si Roxas nanalo walang protest ? 😔🤦🤦🤧😜

[@christinam8552]

Me la ban ka ba roqueta. Panay. Daldal ka. Ng walang kawawaan ikaw nga d mi maintindihan cnasabi mo

[@Cosmo_creations7393]

pulpol carpio

[@heartylee2828]

KAWAWA NAMAN SI CARPIO, HANGGANG PANGARAP LANG WALANG MAGAWA!

[@markpenado3103]

NAG IINGAY C CARPIO PARA DAGDAG POINTS SA GRUPO NYANG SCAMBAYAN HHAHHA

[@cabiloganlion9031]

Hindi po pweding sabihin na wala kang pakiaalam kung sino ang nag order ng withdrawal dahil dito nag mula ang problema.

[@bpike-]

Correct.

[@markarnega2342]

sinabi mo pa.

[@marianodojino3724]

Spox Roque... nag Mamarunong iyan lamang siya. Mahalaga ang Investigation sa Senado at Lahat ng mga Involved... Treason iyang Case nila at Dapat ang Death Penalty ay ma Approved na! MARCOS/DUTERTE sa 2022, Bangon Pilipinas naming Mahal...!!!

[@delacruzgr1]

Plunderer and killer

[@jerome7873]

Ayaw sagutin nI Carpio bakit umalis ang Pinas during stand off?

[@erickj.j.7437]

So GMA sa inyo nang galing: US intervention walang nangyari . Binewala ng China . Pilipinas pa ang natalo. Kaya hindi kailangan ng 3rd party country para resovle ang issue. STOP letting the Phillipines be a lame duck. LET THE PHILIPPINES SOLVE ITS OWN.

[@idangnasagac7983]

Koreeeeek, koreeeeek, koreeeeek 😡😡😡

[@jimmybudoy8290]

Kung ang namumuno ay si Digong nyo ay di mareresolba ang kaso at gagawin pa tayong province of china..youtube title..Paano Dinapurak ni Duterte ang Pilipinas..at saka mo sabihing kaya nating iresolba ng walang tulong ang America

[@shadowheart2337]

@@jimmybudoy8290 ikaw lang ang nagsasabi ng magiging province tyo ng China, yan kadalasan ang sinasabi ng mga anti govt. tapos sabay sabihin na nag dapat maresulba ang issue sa WPS. Ito dapat ilagay mo sa isip mo ang Scarborough shoal ay hindi na natin makukuha yan dahil China na ang may kontrol dyan kahit nga si Carpio d masagot kung sino ba dapat ang sisihin kung bakit nwala ang atin ang Scarborough nagdahilan nalng at sinabi na "wala ako pakialam dyan". Ito ang dinatnan ni duterte ng naging presidente cya 1. wala na sa ating kontrol ang scarborough shoal, hindi na ibibigay ng china yan dahil nagpatayo na sila ng military base. 2. hindi mapakinabangan ang panalo natin sa Hague dahil d naman kinikila ng China ang result at walang UN force na mag empose ng panalo natin. 3. D only possible solution para mapa alis ang china is gumamit tyo ng dahas which is wrong at wala tyo pwersa para gawin un 4. the only option na meron tyo ay makipag usap which is ang best possible result na makukuha natin is joint exploration sa resources. Bago ka mag salita tungkol sa resulbahin ang issue, ano nga ba ang acceptable result ang gusto mo mangyari.

[@me_sensei]

“LET THE PHILIPPINES SOLVE ITS OWN”, DE PUEDE, ksi lalong sasama resulta… world nga eh inignore, Pilipinas pah. DAPAT, Pilipinas MEDIATE lng, let the concerned worlds takes its course…sitting pretty lang dapat Pinas and watch China collide with world over their Nine-Dash-Line. Edi bida pah Pinas…ksi referee eh… 😊 ... (post k rin pla to, prang maganda eh...)

[@Mike-cd3yd]

Tama yan Sec Roque deplomasya parin ang magandang paraan sa WPS.

[@faithclarete8823]

Mr. Carpio during the time that you were in charge on WPS transaction when Pnoy was the President bakit hindi mu po ginawa yan suggestions mo now why are acting like mas marunong ka pa while nung ikaw yung ikaw yung incharge jan before you haven't proof anything to talk to china and di what saying now. You are just acting like akala mo may nagawa ka talaga. Pero what happened after 6 years of service ni Pnoy same situation naman din wala kang nagawa. Sorry to say. It's a fact.🙄

[@AhBasta]

Parang ngayon , mag six years na rin pero kung di nabatikos na matindi eh wala nman balak ng ipagtanggol ang teritoryo nya,,at least yung nakaraan inihain yan sa unclos at international law,,problema nga lng ang china na isa sa mga mataas na opisyal ng unclos ang syang ayaw sumunod sa batas nito,,na senigundahan pa ni pres duterte

[@Sabalas]

@@AhBasta 2012 - Inalis ang Navy sa WPS, China hindi umalis 2013-2016 - Hindi binalik ang Navy kahit hindi sumunod ang China Walang rin kwenta yang papel na lagi niyong pinagsasabi. Akala niyo naman kapag sinabing hindi sa China ibig sabihin sa Pilipinas na agad? "Hague ruling: Filipinos, Chinese may fish in Scarborough" The UN-backed tribunal recognizes the 'traditional fishing rights' of small-scale Filipino and Chinese fishermen in the shoal, effectively declaring it as a common fishing ground The tribunal junked China's claims that Scarborough is an island and favored the Philippine position that is only a "rock." *But the tribunal did not declare the Scarborough Shoal as part of the Philippine EEZ* even when it is located within 100 nautical miles off the country's baseline. Rocks like Scarborough Shoal have territorial seas and are thus sovereign territories that are excluded from the EEZ of countries, the tribunal said. *The tribunal stressed that it does not have jurisdiction to rule on sovereignty issues.* "We asked the tribunal to rule that the territorial sea of Scarborough Shoal be declared traditional fishing ground of Filipino fishermen. *We did not ask that the territorial sea of Scarborough Shoal be declared part of our EEZ because legally it could not be,"* explained a senior member of the government team that handled the Philippine case. The tribunal stressed that *"traditional fishing rights" are private rights of individuals,* which must be protected. The ruling on Mischief Reef, Second Thomas Shoal, and Reed Bank is different. They are not rocks but "low tide features" that form part of the Philippines' EEZ, the tribunal said *How the Philippines can recover Mischief Reef, which has been reclaimed by China, is another matter.* But the ruling is seen to deter China from continuing its aggressive actions in Second Thomas Shoal and Reed Bank, two flashpoint areas between Manila and Beijing. (...) These 11 maritime features are the following: Gaven Reef (North), reclaimed by China McKennan Reef, reclaimed by China Johnson Reef, reclaimed by China Cuarteron Reef, reclaimed by China Fiery Cross Reef, reclaimed by China to host an airstrip Itu Aba, occupied by Taiwan Thitu (Pag-Asa), occupied by about a hundred Filipino civilians West York Island (Likas), occupied by the Philippines Spratly Island, occupied by Vietnam North-East Cay (Parola), occupied by the Philippines South West Cay, occupied by Vietnam Like the Scarborough Shoal, *the tribunal cannot rule on the sovereignty of these 11 maritime features.* Carmela Fonbuena, "Hague ruling: Filipinos, Chinese may fish in Scarborough", Rappler, July 13, 2016.

[@AhBasta]

@@Sabalas so wala po pala kwenta yung papeles na yan,,so ano plano ng pamahalaan para ipagtanggol ang teritoryo natin?isisi na lng sa past admin?

[@Khiven_]

@@AhBasta mag-usap ang china at Philippines malamang president to president para mas maintindihan nila ang isat isa

[@ronswanson7177]

@@Khiven_ that’s what the CCP wants, a bilateral agreement, ayaw nila na kasama lahat ng may territorial claims sa discussion.

[@conradodia1977]

Kung kaibigan Yang mga chino bakit nag declare sila ng band na bawal mangisda

[@francisasenjo8377]

thats called , strategic tactics but merun pa tayung magagawa dyan kase kaibigan naten ang china.,., china well listen us .,.,

[@paidtrollwheresmymoney5421]

Bakit may mosiko ba doon? Fiesta?

[@KorayMeARiver-if5qd]

Nagdeclare ba na bawal mangisda? Pinambayad nila ung donation ng sinovac

[@giniafami1089]

I think this interview not a debate* making the people worries kung sno ang mangyayari sa Pilipinas just incase magkaroon ng hindi pagkakasundo sa WPS with China I think GMA not helping regarding this interview halata2 nman meron sila favoritism

[@weareheretochange7361]

Report all interent trolls Let end this Some account already under surveillance for public Misleading and pubic assault

[@paulorivera1569]

Roque is twisting the presidents statements.. and assuming Carpio's stand..

[@enriquemariano7947]

Minsan kung matino kayo dapat simula palang wala kahit ano diyan.

[@ericmedina8999]

Nako bayas talaga kayo GMA

[@buboygallego2099]

Carpio kng totoong mgaling k bkt nuon hnd m gnawa ngayon mg magaling k

[@thepedronix5318]

dahil sa tayo ang nanalo dapat yun na yon enforce nlng by all means umubos ng maraming laway at higit sa lahat wag makipag kaibigan sa china and di ko maintindihan rokz ginagago na tayo bakit pa tayo mkipag kaiabigan sa isang bully parang nung highsch lang yan pag my bully pag isipan panu makakaganti sa bully !

[@moviestowatch7184]

Pano ma enforce kung di kinikilala na china ang pagkapanalo natin. May kakayahan ba tayo? Sino ang magpapatupad. Kahit anong plano gawin ng gobyerno, wlang magagawa kung di sila aalis.

[@moviestowatch7184]

Lalo tayong wlang makukuha kung kakalabanin natin sila. Sabihin mo nga pano natin kukuhin yon na kaaway natin sila. Walng makikipag away sa atin na bansa ng wla silang mapapala.

[@florenciaben1787]

Sa totoo lang di ba ang magkaibigan eh kung minsan nag uutuan

[@theobserver1]

Dak dak ng Dak dak tong si Roque, Gawin nyo Trabaho nyo! Gusto ng Sambayanang Pilipino Paalisin sa EZZ ng Pilipinas ang China yun lang! Kahit Itak lang dalhin nyo Basta Pa alisin nyo.

[@virgiliogalaura6134]

Why you withdraw?, if that is the bigger picture

[@gwapoko2077]

mas clear magsalita si Roque

[@gwapoko2077]

@Ferzus felicio diercho punto explanaciones.

[@jorriestuiza718]

carpio halatang press release lang

[@nicandroonipa4334]

Hoy Carpio tumigil kana wala ka rin magagawa😈😈😈

[@sorn2866]

Andaming troll fake accounts sa comments ang bilis na iisa halos ang script

[@extremewaters51]

napansin mo din un sir.... bayaran ng pcoo yan..

[@sorn2866]

@@extremewaters51 kase kung pupunta ka sa ibang video same lines same persons copy pasta Tatanungin mo sasagot ng maliwanagan daw tao Lol

[@extremewaters51]

kay k percy lapid lagi ako nkikinig.. dun nliwanagan tlaga ako... nbuo ang paninindigan ko dun.. search mo sir..